Background: There is a negative relationship between education and religiosity and a positive relationship between education and acceptance of evolution, but how this manifests in college students who differ in degree of religiosity and...
moreBackground: There is a negative relationship between education and religiosity and a positive relationship
between education and acceptance of evolution, but how this manifests in college students who differ in degree
of religiosity and prior educational experiences is unclear. We focused our study on the relative importance of
education and religion on evolution understanding for college students at a large, public university in the Deep
South.
Methods: We used a structural equation model incorporating both acceptance and knowledge of evolution to
evaluate the relative influence of religion and education on evolution understanding of 2,999 surveyed students.
We further focused on acceptance of evolution and academic level, college major, high school experience, religion,
and religiosity. We conducted pre and post course evaluations in three biology classes, and finally we tested the
relationships between the quality of K-12 state science standards and states’ religiosity and educational attainment.
Results: We found that the degree of religiosity mattered significantly more than education when predicting
students’ understanding of evolution. When we focused on acceptance of evolution only, students taught
evolution or neither evolution nor creationism in high school had significantly higher acceptance than those taught
both evolution and creationism or just creationism. Science majors always outscored non-science majors, and not
religious students significantly outperformed religious students. Highly religious students were more likely to reject
evolution even though they understood that the scientific community accepted the theory of evolution. Overall,
students in two of three biology classes increased their acceptance of evolution, but only those students that
seldom/never attended religious services improved. K-12 state science standard grades were significantly and
negatively correlated with measures of state religiosity and significantly and positively correlated with measures of
state educational attainment.
Conclusions: Religiosity, rather than education, best explains views on evolution. In areas of the country where the
vast majority of residents believe in God and the literal truth of the Bible, students may be hampered as they enter
and progress through college. These same states tend to have lower state science standards and lower levels of
educational attainment