Management Accounting I
Management Accounting I
ACCOUNTING I
George Gitari
Course Content:
Nature, Purpose and scope of Management Accounting;
Decision Making environments and techniques;
Cost Behavior; Cost Estimation;
Variable and absorption costing
Relevant costing;
Cost-Volume- Profit Analysis;
Master Budget and Responsibility Accounting
Expected Learning outcomes of the course
By the end of the course unit the learners should be
able to:-
i) Explain the importance of management accounting
in the management of organizations
ii) Apply management accounting techniques to solve
various management dilemmas
iii) Explain the importance of budgeting and
responsibility accounting in management of
organizations
Course Assessment
Continuous assessment tests and assignments (CAT)
20%
Assignments 10%
End of Semester Examination
70%
Total 100%
References
Core Text books:
i) Horngren C.T and Foster, G: (2009), Cost Accounting: A
Managerial Emphasis, (11th Edition)
ii) Hansen (2008); Management Accounting; Cengage Learning
( Thompson )
Recommended Text Books:
i) Horngren C.T Sundrem G L and Stratton W. O; (2007), An
introduction to Management Accounting, (10th International
Edition), Prentice Hall International Inc
NATURE AND PURPOSE OF
MANAGEMENT ACCOUNTING
Accounting system provides accounting information to interested
users and since users have different types or forms of accounting.
Accounting is the process of identifying, measuring and
communicating economic information to permit informed
judgments and decisions by the users of information.
alternatives.
The first five stages represent the decision-making of
the planning process. Planning involves making
choices between alternatives and is primarily a
decision-making activity. The final two stages
represent the control process, which is the process of
measuring and correcting actual performance to
ensure that the alternatives that are chosen and the
plans for implementing them are carried out. Let us
now consider each of the elements of the decision-
making and control process.
i) Identifying Objectives
Before good decisions can be made there must be some
guiding aim or direction that will enable the decision-
makers to assess the desirability of favouring one
II)THE SEARCH FOR ALTERNATIVE COURSES OF
ACTION
The second stage of the decision-making model is a
search for a range of possible courses of action (or
strategies) that might enable the objectives to be
achieved. If the management of a company
concentrates entirely on its present product range and
markets, and market shares and cash flows are
allowed to decline, there is a danger that the company
will be unable to generate sufficient cash flows to
survive in the future. To maximize future cash flows, it
is essential that management identifies potential
opportunities and threats in its current environment
and takes any developments which may occur in the
future. In particular, the company should consider one
or more of the following courses of action:
1. Developing new products for sale in existing
The search for alternative courses of action involves the
acquisition of information concerning future opportunities and
environments. It is the most difficult and important stage of the
decision-making process. Ideally, firms should consider all
alternative courses of action, but, firms will in practice consider
only a few alternatives, with the search process being localised
initially.
III) GATHER DATA ABOUT ALTERNATIVES
When potential areas of activity are identified, management
should assess the potential growth rate of the activities, the
ability of the company to establish adequate market shares, and
the cash flows for each alternative activity for various states of
nature. Because decision problems exist in an uncertain
environment, it is necessary to consider certain factors that are
outside the decision-maker's control, which may occur for each
alternative course of action. These uncontrollable factors are
called states of nature. Some examples of possible states of
nature are economic boom, high inflation, recession, the
The course of action selected by a firm using the information
presented above will commit its resources for a lengthy period
of time, and the overall place of the firm will be affected within
its environment—that is, the products it makes, the markets it
operates in and its ability to meet future changes. These
decisions are normally referred to as long-run possibilities and
hence the type of decisions it can make in the future. These
decisions are normally referred to as long-run or strategic
decisions. Strategic decisions have a profound effect on the
firm's future position, and it is therefore essential that adequate
data is gathered about the firm's capabilities and the
environment in which it operates. Because of their importance,
strategic decisions should be the concern of top management.
Besides strategic or long-term decisions, management must also
make decisions that do not commit the firm's resources for a
lengthy period of time. Such decisions are known as short-term
or operating decisions and are normally the concern of lower-
level managers. Short-term decisions are based on the
environment of today, the physical, human and financial
Cont……
Examples of short-term decisions include the
following:
1. What selling prices should be set for the firm's
products?
2. How many units should be produced of each
product?
3. What media shall we use for advertising the
firm's product?
4. What level of service shall we offer customers
in terms of the number of days required to deliver an
order and the after-sales service?
Data must also be gathered for short-term decisions;
for example, data on the selling prices of
competitor's products, estimated demand at
IV) SELECT APPROPRIATE ALTERNATIVE COURSES
OF ACTION
In practice, decision-making involves choosing between
competing alternative courses of action and selecting the
alternative that best satisfies the objectives of an
organisation. Assuming that our objective is to maximise
future net cash inflows, the alternative selected should be
based on a comparison of the differences between the
cash flows. Consequently, an incremental analysis of the
net cash benefits for each alternative should be applied.
The alternatives are ranked in terms of net cash benefits,
and those showing the greatest benefits are chosen
subject to taking into account any qualitative factors. We
shall discuss how incremental cash flows are measured for
short-term and long-term decisions and the impact of
qualitative factors.
IMPLEMENTATION OF THE DECISIONS
Once alternative courses of action have been selected,
they should be implemented as part of the budgeting
process. The budget is a financial plan for implementing
the various decisions that management has made. The
budgets for all the various decisions are expressed in
terms of cash inflows and outflows, and sales revenues and
expenses. The budgets are merged together into a single
unifying statement of the organisation's expectations for
future periods. The statement is known as a master
budget. The master budget consists of a budgeted profit
and loss account, cash flow statement and balance sheet.
The budgeting process communicates to everyone in the
organisation the part they are expected to play in
implementing management's decisions.
VI) COMPARING ACTUAL AND PLANNED OUTCOMES
The final stages in the process of comparing actual and planned
outcomes and responding to divergences from plan represent
the firm's control process.
To monitor performance, the accountant produces performance
reports and presents them to the appropriate managers who are
responsible for implementing the various decisions.
Performance reports consisting of a comparison of actual
outcomes (actual costs and revenues) and planned outcomes
(budgeted costs and revenues) should be issued at regular
intervals. Performance reports provide feedback information by
comparing planned and actual outcomes. Such reports should
highlight those activities that do not conform to plans, so that
managers can devote their scarce time to focusing on these
items.
VII) RESPONDING TO DIVERGENCES FROM PLAN
This process represents the application of management by
exception. Effective control requires that corrective action
is taken so that actual outcomes conform to planned
outcomes.
The managerial function of control consists of the
measurement, reporting and subsequent correction of
performance in an attempt to ensure that the firm's
objectives and plans are achieved. In other words, the
objective of the control process is to ensure that the work
is done so as to fulfil the original intentions.
Decision Making Environment
There a four main environment within which decisions can be
made. These are:
Certainty
Risk
Fundamental uncertainty
Competition
Certainty environment
In this environment complete information is available as to
which states of nature will occur. The decision making
process just involves picking the best alternative.
RISK
Risk involves situations or events which may or may not
occur but whose probability of occurrence can be predicted
from past records. In this environment, the states of nature
are not certain but probability distribution can be assigned.
Fundamental Uncertainty
Uncertain events are those whose outcome
cannot be predicted with statistical confidence.
In this environment the states of nature are
not known nor are their probability
distribution. The decision making process
depends on the risk attitude of the decision
maker.
Competition
In this environment the decisions made by the
firm are affected by decisions made by other
firms with opposing interests.
DECISION MAKING UNDER RISK AND UNCERTAINTY
Before looking at the various methods of making decisions under risk,
we shall look at the three main risk attitudes that distinguish different
decision makers. These are:
1 RISK SEEKING
A risk seeker is a decision maker who is interested in the best possible
outcome no matter how small the chance that they may occur i.e. he
takes high risks in anticipation of high profitability. For such a
decision maker, the marginal utility for wealth is positive and
increasing.
2. Risk neutral
A decision maker is risk neutral if he is concerned with what will be the
most likely outcome i.e. he is indifferent to risk. For such a decision
maker the marginal utility of wealth is positive and constant.
3. Risk Averse
A decision maker is risk averse, if he acts on the assumption that the
worst possible outcome will occur, and chooses the decision with the
least risk possible.
Measure of Risk
Std deviation (δ)
This is the square root of the variance, where the
variance is the summation of the difference between
the outcome and the mean squared.
Coefficient of variation.
It is a relative measure of risk and it is used to compare
alternatives of different magnitudes based on their
risk return consideration.
C V = δ___
EMV
EMV = ε MVt Pt
Methods of Decision Making Under Uncertainty
DECISION MAKING CRITERIA
Maximax decision rule
This decision rule looks at the best possible result and it chooses the
maximum payoff for each alternative and then the maximum of this
maximum
Maximin decision rule
Under this criterion, the decision maker looks at the worst possible
outcome of each decision alternative and then chooses the
alternative that offers the least unattractive (worst) outcome i.e. He
chooses the alternative that maximises the minimum profit.
LAPLACE CRITERION OF RATIONALITY
This criterion holds that if decision makers do not know the
probabilities of the various states of nature and have no reason to
think otherwise, then the states of nature should be considered to
be equally likely. On the basis of this assumption, the expected
monetary value for each alternative is calculated and the
alternative with the highest expected monetary value is chosen.
Minimax Regret Criterion
This method seeks to minimize the maximum regret that would occur
from choosing a particular strategy or alternative. The regret is
the opportunity loss that occurs from taking one decision given
that a certain contingency occurs.
ILLUSTRATION 1
Assume that ABC Ltd is trying to set the selling price for one of its
products and three prices are under consideration. These are
Sh.4, Sh.4.30 & Sh.4.40
The following information on the units to be sold is also provided
Alternatives
Conditions Sh.4.00 Sh.4.30 Sh.4.40
Best possible 16,000 14,000 12,500
Most likely 14,000 12,500 12,000
Worst possible 10,000 8,000 6,000
Fixed costs = Sh. 20,000
variable cost per unit = Sh. 2
METHODS OF DECISION MAKING UNDER RISK
In this environment, it is possible to attach probabilities to
the various states of nature. The decision criteria would
either be:
The expected monetary value
The expected opportunity loss
The two criteria are similar since the choice that
maximises the expected monetary value also minimises
the expected opportunity loss (EOL)
ILLUSTRATION 2
Assume in the ABC pricing decision (illustration 1) that
the probability of the best possible outcome is 0.2, most
likely outcome is 0.6 and the worst possible outcome is
0.2.
Perfect and Imperfect Information
The uncertainty about the future outcome from taking a
decision can be reduced by obtaining more
information fast about what is likely to occur.
That information can be obtained from various sources
e.g.
Market surveys
Conducting a pilot test
Building a prototype model
Hire consultants
Information can be categorised depending upon how
reliable it is likely to be for predicting what would
happen in the future and for helping managers to
make better decisions.
Perfect information (PI) is information that can be
Both perfect and imperfect information is costly and its value
must be determined.
Value of perfect information (Pi) = EMV with PI – EMV
without PI.
ILLUSTRATION
Consider the ABC pricing decision (Illustration 1) and assume
that it is possible to obtain ideal information at a cost of
Sh.500
REQUIRED
Advice the company on whether to acquire the perfect
information
EMV with PI = 0.2(12200) + 0.6 (8800) + 0.2(0) = 7720
Value of perfect information = 7720 –7370 = Sh.350
The decision is not to acquire perfect information since it
EXERCISE
A distributor buys perishable articles for £2 per
item and sells them at £5. Demand per day is
uncertain and the items unsold at the end of the
day represents a write off because of perishability.
If he under stocks he losses profit he could have
made.
A 300 day record of the past activity as follows:
A Daily demand (units) No of days
10 30
11 60
12 120
13 90
What level of stock should be held from day to day
EXERCISE 2
Cement Co is a company specialising in the manufacture of cement, a product used
in the building industry. The company has found that when weather conditions
are good, the demand for cement increases since more building work is able to
take place. Cement Co is now trying to work out the level of cement production
for the coming year in order to maximise profits. The company has received the
following estimates about the probable weather conditions and corresponding
demand levels for the coming year:
Weather Probability Demand
Good 25% 350,000 bags
Average 45% 280,000 bags
Poor 30% 200,000 bags
Each bag of cement sells for frw9 and costs frw4 to make. If cement is unsold at the
end of the year, it has to be disposed of at a cost of frw0·50 per bag. Cement Co
has decided to produce at one of the three levels of production to match forecast
demand. It now has to decide which level of cement production to select.
Required:
(i) Construct a pay-off table to show all the possible profit outcomes.
(ii) Determine the level of cement production the company should choose, based on
the decision rule of maximin, Minimax Regret Criterion and Expected Monetary
Value. Show your calculations clearly and justify your decision.
(iii) Determine the value for perfect information
COSTS, AND COST
CLASSIFICATION
Cost
Cost is the monetary measure of resources sacrificed or forgone to achieve
a specific objective e.g acquiring of a good or service. The resources
usually given up are generally in terms of money or, if not in terms of
money, they are always expressed in monetary terms.
Cost can also be defined as the amount of expenditure incurred on or
attributable to a specific thing or item.
When a cost is incurred, it could be in the form of deferred cost (asset) or
expired cost (expense). Deferred costs are unexpired costs, capitalized
costs, which provide benefits in future periods and known as assets and
hence appear in the balance sheet. An Expense is an expired cost which has
given benefit to the organization and no longer has any service potential of
providing more benefits to the organization. Loss is a lost cost. It represents
the cost that has expired (incurred) but has not yielded any benefit to the
organization. In financial accounting, it is used to denote a situation where
the expenses exceed revenues for the accounting period.
Cost Unit
Cost unit is defined as a unit of quantity of a product,
service or time in relation to which cost may be
ascertained or expressed. The cost unit will differ
from organization to organization.
Cost unit is considered as a unit of measurement of
cost or a quantification for which costs are expressed
e.g. litre, kilogramme/tonne, kilometer etc.
Thus a cost unit is any convenient measure of activity
giving a feeling of what the firm is producing.
Responsibility Centre
This represents an individual part of the business whose manager has a
personal responsibility for its performance.
Many organizations are structured into a hierarchy of responsibility centres
which include: cost centres, revenue centres, profit centres and investment
centres.
Cost centre
Cost centre may be defined as any particular part of the enterprise. A cost
centre may be a particular department, function or item of equipment for
which costs may be ascertained and related to cost unit for control purposes.
Cost centres are basically organization segment or area of activity
considered to accumulate costs.
Revenue centre
This is a segment of the organization which is primarily responsible for
generating sales revenue. A revenue centre manager does not posses control
over cost, investment in assets, but usually has control over some of the
expenses of the marketing department. The performance of a revenue centre
is evaluated by comparing the actual revenue with the budgeted revenue.
Profit centre
This is that cost centre which not only incurs cost but also
yield revenue. This is part of the organization for which both
the revenue and the costs incurred and revenue earned are
identified.
The performance of the profit centre is assessed in terms of
whether the centre has achieved its budget profit
Investment centre
This is a segment of the organization which has the
responsibility for capital investment and possibly for
financing and whose performance is measured in terms of
return on investment or return on capital employed.
Definition
Cost classification is the process of
grouping costs according to their
common characteristics.
A suitable classification of costs is of vital
importance in order to identify the cost
with cost centres or cost units.
Cost may be classified accounting to
their nature, i.e., material, labor and
expenses and a number of other
characteristics.
The same cost figures are classified
according to different ways of costing
depending upon the purpose to be
Purpose of cost classification
1) Preparation of budget: classification of cost helps in preparation of
the budget of the organization. For preparing the budget of an
organization one must know how and where exactly the expenses have
been incurred in relation to manufacturing the product. On the basis of
this classification of the cost an organization accordingly prepares its
budget.
2) Helps in measuring efficiency: classification of cost helps in
measuring the efficiency of the organization. On the basis of the places
where the costs have been incurred and the amount of cost that has
been incurred the efficiency of the organization can be judged.
3) Controlling cost:
Labour cost: classification of cost help organization to control its labour cost . If labour
complete their task in time and with efficiency then the organization would be able to
reduce its labour cost.
Material cost: material cost can be controlled if material wastage is avoided and proper
standardization of materials is used.
Overhead cost: overhead comprises indirect expenditure incurred in manufacturing. By
knowing the amount that has been incurred under various heads an organization can
device ways to reduce cost.
4) Expansion of the organization: Once an organization is able to
control its cost then it can concentrate on its expansion. Thus with the
help of classification of cost an organization is able to device ways for
its expansion.
METHODS OF COST CLASSIFIICATION
MANUFACTURING COSTS
Manufacturing costs are those costs that are directly involved in
manufacturing of products and services. Examples of manufacturing
costs include raw materials costs and salary of labor workers.
Manufacturing cost is divided into three broad categories by most
companies.
Direct materials cost
Direct labor cost
Manufacturing overhead cost - includes all costs of manufacturing
except direct material and direct labor. Examples of manufacturing
overhead include items such as indirect material, indirect labor,
maintenance and repairs on production equipment and heat and light,
property taxes, depreciation, and insurance on manufacturing facilities.
Indirect materials are minor items such as solder and glue in
manufacturing industries.
Required;-
Determine the cost equation using account classification method and determine the cost of producing
1,400 units
EXERCISE
In the year 2020 VIP incurred the following expenses to
maintain 1500 lecturers.
Sh
Administration expenses (40% variable) 4,000,000
Lecturing pay (60% variable) 8,000,000
Airtime allowance (fixed) 1,000,000
Sundry expenses (50% fixed) 500,000
Soda allowance (variable) 300,000
Required;-
a Using accounts analysis method, express an equation in form y
= a +bx
b Using the equation expressed above, estimate the total cost of
2000 lecturers incurred to be employed in 2021.
Exercise: Accounts Analysis Method
ABC Ltd produces a single product which is meant for the local
market only. The
monthly demand for this product varies from one month to
the other.
During the month of November 2013, 1000 units were produced
incurring the following expenses.
$(Thousands)
Direct Materials 30
Direct Labour 40
Rent (Fixed) 25
Electricity (40% fixed) 27
Property Taxes and Rates (80%
variable) 50
Technical Support (fixed) 28
Total 20
Required:
a) Using accounts analysis method, formulate a predictor equation
in the form of
y=bx + a
b) During the month of December 2013, ABC Ltd estimates to
HIGH –LOW (OR RANGE)METHOD.
In this method the highest and lowest activity together with
their corresponding costs is identified. The two points i.e. the
lowest and the highest are used to derive a cost function in the
form of
y = a + bx
This method is based on an analysis of historical information of
costs at different activity levels. The high-low method finds the
equation of the straight line joining the two points
corresponding to the highest and lowest activity levels.
What we need to do is to separately identify the fixed and
variable cost elements so that each can be predicted for
anticipated future activity levels.
The variable cost is estimated by calculating the average unit
cost between the highest and lowest volumes and the fixed and
total cost function can then be derived.
Example
Based on performance, you have been provided with
the following information regarding ABC Ltd for the
year ended 31 December 2022 :
Labour hours Service cost
(Shs)
Highest activity level 800 200,000
Lowest activity level 300 150,000
Required
Develop a total cost function based on the above data
using the high-low method.
Illustration 2
The production manager of XYZ Company, is concerned abut the apparent
fluctuation in efficiency and wants to determine how labour costs (in
Sh.) are related to volume. The following data presents results of the 12
most recent weeks.
Week No. Units Produced(X) Labour Costs(Y)
1 34 340
2 44 346
3 24 287
4 36 262
5 30 220
6 49 416
7 39 337
8 21 180
9 41 376
10 47 295
11 34 215
12 24 275
Required: Estimate the cost function using high low method and
determine cost for producing 45 units
THE SCATTER GRAPH METHOD
For this method a scatter diagram is constructed which is used to visually i.e. by inspection
deduce a relationship from observed pattern if there is any. By obtaining any two points on
constructed graph, we can fit a straight line if the pattern suggests a linear relationship.
x x xx
xx x x
Non-linearrelationship
x • Quadratic since has one turningpoint
xxx x xx
x x x
x xx
X
THE SCATTER GRAPH METHOD
Advantages of visual fit method
1. It takes into account all the observations unlike the high low
method.
2. It is easy to apply.
Disadvantages of visual –fit method
1. It cannot be used for two or more independent variables
2. We cannot measure the size of probable error.
3. It is subjective to some extent.
ORDINARY LEAST SQUARES
REGRESSION METHOD
Regression analysis is a technique that uses a statistical model to measure the amount of
change in one variable (dependent variable) that is associated with changes in amounts of
one or more variables.
This method is used to determine the equation of the line of best fit by minimizing the
sum of the squares of the vertical
When it has been established that a causal relationship exists in the data and that a linear
function is appropriate the statistical technique known as least squares is frequently used
to establish values for the coefficients a and b (representing fixed and variable cost
respectively) in the linear cost function.
y = a + bx
where y is total cost – the dependent variable
2. xy = a ( x) + b ( x2)
a= Y - b x
n n
Looking at illustration 2, then we first compute the sum of X, Y, XY, X 2
Illustration 2
EXERCISE 1
Virunga Designers produces men’s suits for all age groups and has provided the
following cost and production data for the month of May, 2022.
Number of suits Total cost (Frw‘000’)
250 21,420
270 22,930
310 25,951
340 28,217
350 28,972
420 34,258
1,940 161,748
Due to the increased demand for Virunga Designers’ suits, management intends to
increase its production from 1,940 suits in May to 2,400 suits in June, 2022.
REQUIRED:
Using regression analysis, forecast the total cost for the month of June, 2022.
Disadvantages of marginal costing
1. The separation of costs into fixed and variable is difficult and sometimes gives misleading
results.
2. Normal costing systems also apply overhead under normal operating volume and this shows
that no advantage is gained by marginal costing.
3. Under marginal costing, stocks and work in progress are understated. The exclusion of fixed
costs from inventories affect profit, and true and fair view of financial affairs of an
organization may not be clearly transparent.
4. Volume variance in standard costing also discloses the effect of fluctuating output on fixed
overhead. Marginal cost data becomes unrealistic in case of highly fluctuating levels of
production, e.g., in case of seasonal factories.
5. Application of fixed overhead depends on estimates and not on the actuals and as such there
may be under or over absorption of the same.
6. Control affected by means of budgetary control is also accepted by many. In order to know
the net profit, we should not be satisfied with contribution and hence, fixed overhead is also a
valuable item. A system which ignores fixed costs is less effective since a major portion of
fixed cost is not taken care of under marginal costing.
7. In practice, sales price, fixed cost and variable cost per unit may vary. Thus, the assumptions
underlying the theory of marginal costing sometimes becomes unrealistic. For long term
profit planning, absorption costing is the only answer.
EXERCISE 2
Kirezi Beauty Cosmetics (KBC) imports and supplies body perfumes to residents in
Gisagara province. These perfumes are sold in standard size of 300 ml per bottle.
KBC sells each body perfume at Frw 12,500 after incorporating a markup of 20%.
The weekly sales demand and relevant costs for the month of May 2019 are
provided as below:
Week Sales (bottles) Total cost (Frw ‘000’)
1 120 1,390
2 200 2,150
3 140 1,580
4 240 2,530
700 7,650
KBC has resolved to increase its selling price per bottle of the body perfume by 4%
in June 2019 owing to the ever increasing demand for its perfumes. The expected
sales for June 2019 were projected at 840 bottles.
REQUIRED:
(a) (i) Using regression analysis, determine KBC’s profit in the month of June 2019.
(ii) Using computations, show the effect on KBC’s profit if selling price and
variable cost per unit reduced by 4% and 5% respectively?
ICPAR-Q3b –August 2021
Imena Milk Industries Limited deals in production of milk. Over the past two years, it
realised its sales were unstable, something that triggered the management to put more
efforts in advertising its products on different media platforms whilst expecting
increase in sales.
Below are the cost of advertisement and associated sales unit for the past six months:
Month Advertisement cost (Frw) Sales units
January 800,000 4000
February 500,000 3000
March 350,000 1000
April 1,000,000 6000
May 850,000 5000
June 1,300,000 7000
July 1,100,000 6000
August 1,600,000 8000
i) Using the High Low method, estimate the total cost function and calculate unit
variable cost and unit fixed cost. (4 Marks)
ii) Estimate the total cost function using linear regression analysis and calculate
how much cost will be incurred when sales units are 1000. (4 Marks)
ICPAR-Q7b –November 2023
(b) REG Ltd deals with the construction of houses in Kigali. It has had a
good performancefrom September 2022. REG Ltd is currently reviewing its
performance so as to ascertain its costs for May 2023 for planning
purposes. Total costs and output for the last seven months are presented in
theParticulars
table below: Number of houses Total costs
constructed
units Frw
September, 2022 8,500 4,475,000
October, 2022 5,000 3,150,000
November, 2022 6,500 3,850,000
December, 2022 7,500 3,750,000
January, 2023 9,500 4,825,000
February, 2023 5,500 3,260,000
March, 2023 6,000 3,540,000
REQUIRED: Using regression analysis method of cost estimation, calculate
the following
i) variable cost per unit
ii) Fixed cost of constructing the houses
iii) Formulate the total cost equation
MARGINAL AND ABSORPTION COSTING
Marginal Costing, also known as Variable Costing, is a costing method whereby decisions
can be taken regarding the ascertainment of total cost or the determination of fixed and
variable cost in order to find out the best process and product for production etc.
It identifies the Marginal Cost of production and shows its impact on profit for the
change in the output units. Marginal cost refers to the movement in the total cost, due to
the production of an additional unit of output.
In marginal costing all the variable costs are regarded as product related costs while fixed
costs are assumed as period costs. Therefore, fixed cost of production is posted to the
Profit & Loss Account. Fixed cost is also not given relevance while determining the
selling price of the product or at the time of valuation of closing stock.
Absorption Costing is a method for inventory valuation whereby all the manufacturing
expenses are allocated to the cost centers to recognize the total cost of production. These
manufacturing expenses include all fixed as well as variable costs. It is the traditional
method for cost ascertainment, also known by the name Full Absorption Costing.
In an absorption costing system, both the fixed and variable costs are regarded as product
related cost. Fixed costs are assumed as product costs. In this method the objective behind
the assignment of the total cost to cost center is to recover it from the selling price of the
product.
DISTINCTION BETWEEN MARGINAL AND ABSORPTION COSTING
Basis for
Comparison Marginal Costing Absorption Costing
A decision making technique for Apportionment of total costs to the cost center in
Meaning ascertaining the total cost of production is order to determine the total cost of production is
known as Marginal Costing. known as Absorption Costing.
Cost Recognition The variable cost is considered as product Both fixed and variable cost is considered as product
cost while fixed cost is considered as cost.
period costs.
Classification of Fixed and Variable Production, Administration and Selling &
Overheads Distribution
Profitability Profitability is measured by Profit Volume Due to the inclusion of fixed cost, profitability gets
Ratio. affected.
Variances in the opening and closing stock Variances in the opening and closing stock affects
Cost per unit does not influence the cost per unit of the cost per unit.
output.
Highlights Contribution per unit Net Profit per unit
Marginal Costing
Profit and Loss Statement
Sales xxx
Less: Cost of sales xxx
Opening stock
Add: production cost xxx
Direct Material xxx
Direct Labour xxx
Variable Production O/H Xxx
(xxx)
Less: Closing stock (xxx)
Gross contribution Xxx
Less: Other variable costs
( xxx)
Net Contribution
xxx
Less: Fixed costs
Xxx
Production
xxx
Administration xxx
Selling and distr. (xxx)
N. Profit Xxx
Absorption costing
Profit and loss statement
Sales Xxx
Less: Cost of sales xxx
Opening stock
Gross Profit
Additional information
1.During the month of March 2011, production was 10,000 units as planned but the sales made were 8,000units
2.The standard fixed production overhead absorption rate was based on a budgeted activity of 10,00units
3.There was no opening stock at the beginning of the month
4.All units were sold at the standard selling price
5.Other costs incurred during the month were as follows:
Variable Fixed (Sh.)
Selling and distribution 20% of sale 600,000
Administration 1,000,000
Required: Income statement for the month of March 2011 using Absorption costing and Marginal costing
Example 2
Mr Jones has set up in business making a renewable energy product. He has
provided you with the following budgeted sales and production information per
unit:-
£
Sales price 1,200
Direct materials 400
Direct labour 250
Variable production overhead 120
Fixed production overhead 200
Fixed administration & general overhead 150
Mr Jones has projected his activity levels as follows:-
Sales (units) Production (units)
July 300 500
August 600 750
September 600 1,000
Fixed overhead costs have been projected on the basis of annual activity of 9,000
units and will be incurred constantly over the year. There is no opening stock.
Requirement:-(a) Prepare a budgeted statement of profit for each month using:
i. absorption costing
ii. marginal costing
88
(b) Briefly explain the differences between the reported profits for each month.
Advantages of marginal costing
1. Marginal costing is simple to understand.
2. By not charging fixed overhead to cost of production, the effect of varying charges per
unit is avoided.
3. It prevents the illogical carry forward in stock valuation of some proportion of current
year’s fixed overhead.
4. The effects of alternative sales or production policies can be more readily available and
assessed, and decisions taken would yield the maximum return to business.
5. It eliminates large balances left in overhead control accounts which indicate the
difficulty of ascertaining an accurate overhead recovery rate.
6. Practical cost control is greatly facilitated. By avoiding arbitrary allocation of fixed
overhead, efforts can be concentrated on maintaining a uniform and consistent marginal
cost. It is useful to various levels of management.
7. It helps in short-term profit planning by breakeven and profitability analysis, both in
terms of quantity and graphs. Comparative profitability and performance between two
or more products and divisions can easily be assessed and brought to the notice of
management for decision making.
Disadvantages of marginal costing
1. The separation of costs into fixed and variable is difficult and sometimes gives misleading results.
2. Normal costing systems also apply overhead under normal operating volume and this shows that
no advantage is gained by marginal costing.
3. Under marginal costing, stocks and work in progress are understated. The exclusion of fixed costs
from inventories affect profit, and true and fair view of financial affairs of an organization may
not be clearly transparent.
4. Volume variance in standard costing also discloses the effect of fluctuating output on fixed
overhead. Marginal cost data becomes unrealistic in case of highly fluctuating levels of
production, e.g., in case of seasonal factories.
5. Application of fixed overhead depends on estimates and not on the actuals and as such there may
be under or over absorption of the same.
6. Control affected by means of budgetary control is also accepted by many. In order to know the
net profit, we should not be satisfied with contribution and hence, fixed overhead is also a
valuable item. A system which ignores fixed costs is less effective since a major portion of fixed
cost is not taken care of under marginal costing.
7. In practice, sales price, fixed cost and variable cost per unit may vary. Thus, the assumptions
underlying the theory of marginal costing sometimes becomes unrealistic. For long term profit
planning, absorption costing is the only answer.
Advantages of absorption costing
i) Fixed costs are substantial and increasing proportion of costs in modern
industry. It thus forms a significant part of costs of production so it should
be included. Marginal costing divorces fixed costs from production.
ii)It is used preferably where stock building is a necessary part of operations
e.g. wine making. Otherwise fictitious losses will be shown in earlier
periods to be offset eventually by excessive profits when goods are sold.
iii)Relying on marginal costs could lead to management setting prices at
below total costs but making slight contribution. This is avoided in
absorption costing.
iv)International Financial Reporting Standards suggest that costs and
revenues must be matched in the period when revenues arise not when
costs are incurred. It also recommends that stock valuation must include
production overheads incurred in the normal course of business even if
such overheads are time related.
Exercise
Langata is a manufacturing company which produces a single product. The following standard
unit costs relate to the product.
Cost Sh.
Variable manufacturing 90
Fixed manufacturing 70
Variable selling and 16
administration
Fixed selling and administration 60
236
Fixed manufacturing costs per unit are based on a predetermined absorption rate established at a normal activity
level of 45,000 production unit per period. Fixed selling and administration costs are absorbed into the cost of sales
at 20% of selling price. Under/over absorbed overheads are transferred to the profit and loss account at the end of the
period
The following informationSales
is available
– units
for two consecutive periods. Period
42,500
1 Period 2
45,000
Sales – value (Sh.) 12,750,000 13,500,000
Production units 40,000 46,000
Variable manufacturing costs (Sh.) 3,600,000 4,140,000
Variable selling and administration 3,200,000 3,150,000
costs (Sh.)
Fixed selling and administration costs 680,000 720,000
(Sh.)
2,700,000 2,700,000
Required
a) Income statements for each of the two periods under the absorption costing basis
b) Income statements for each of the two periods under the marginal costing basis
c) Reconciliation of the profits under the absorption costing and the marginal costing basis for
each of the periods.
APPLICATION OF MARGINAL COSTING
Marginal costing is applied internally by management
in decision making such as:
i)Cost volume profit analysis(CVP)
ii)Planning
iii)Decision making(non-routine)
iv)Cost control
v)measurement of efficiency
vi)Evaluation of profitability
Cost Volume and Profit
Analysis (CVP)
CVP
Cost volume profit (CVP) analysis is the study of the effects on future profit of
changes in fixed cost, variable costs, sales price quantity and mix.
The purpose of the C.V.P analysis is to understand the relationship amongst the
aforesaid variables to forecast profits, determine the volumes to be achieved to meet
target profit, and such other short term decisions. The CVP analysis is based on the
premise of marginal costing.
The marginal costing technique recognizes variable cost as the product costs and
fixed costs as period costs. The principle is that only variable costs will change with
a change in volume of production and sales, but the fixed costs will remain the same.
Cost volume profit (CVP) analysis is a systematic approach of examining the
relationship between changes in volume and changes in total sales, expenses and net
profit. The underlying objective of CVP is to know the effect of fluctuation in the
activity volume on financial results. The following is a typical cost volume profit
diagram that depicts how sales revenue, fixed costs and variable costs respond to
changes in the volume of sales and production. The volume of production and sales
is measured by the X-axis and revenue, costs and profit (loss) are measured by –axis
in the CVP chart.
Break-even analysis
Traditionally cost volume profit analysis is
called break-even analysis. Break-even is the
volume of sales at which the business just
“breaks even” so that it makes neither a loss
nor a profit.
Break-even point is the point at which the
volume of sales is equal to the total cost
therefore the profit is ZERO.
Calculating break-even can be useful to
management because it shows what is the
minimum volume of sales must be to avoid
making a loss in the period.
Margin of safety
This is the amount by which firm’s actual sales revenue exceeds its
break-even sales. This is the amount of sales revenue that could be lost
before the company profit would be reduced to zero.
This is the difference between the actual/budgeted sales volume and
breakeven sales volume. It is simply a measurement of how far sales
can fall short of budget before the business makes a loss.
A large margin of safety indicates a low risk of making a loss, whereas
a small margin of safety indicates a fairly high risk of a loss. It
therefore indicates the vulnerability of a business to a fall in demand.
It is usually expressed as a percentage of budgeted sales.
= Fixed Costs x 1
C/S ratio
d ) Level of sales to result in target profit (in units) = Fixed Costs + Targetprofit
Contribution/unit
a) Level of sales to result in target profit after tax (inunits)
Research and Development Cost Budget
Development cost is the cost of using scientific
or technical knowledge in order to produce new
or substantially improved materials, devices,
products, processes systems or services prior to
the commencement of commercial production.
Capital expenditure Budget
It represents the expenditure on all fixed assets
during the budget period. Addition intended to
benefit future accounting periods, or
expenditure which increases the production
capacity, efficiency lifespan or economy of an
existing fixed assets are also incorporated.
Cash budget
It records the cash inflows and outflows, which
are expected to take place in respect of each
functional budget. It may be prepared for a
period span of one week, month or quarter of
the budget period.
It has the following benefits/advantages:
It ensures that sufficient cash is available when
required.
It shows whether capital expenditure projects
can be financed internally.
It indicates the cash needed for current
operating activities.
It indicates the effect the position of each
seasonal requirements, large stocks, unusual
receipts and laxity in collecting account
receivable.
It indicates the availability of cash for taking
advantage of discounts.
It reveals the availability of excess cash so that
short-term investments may be considered.
It serves as a basis for evaluating the actual
cash management performance of responsible
managers
Venus plc produces two products Niks and Args. The budget for the next year to 31st 2023 is to be
prepared. Expectations for the forthcoming year includes the following:
Venus PLC
BALANCE SHEET ASAT 1APRIL 2022
Creditors 6,800
180,765
Financed by
180,765
(b) Finished Products NIKS ARGS
The Sales Director has estimated the
following:
(i) Demand for the Co’s products 4,500 4,000 units
units
(ii) Expected S.P per unit Rwf 32 Rwf 44
(iii) Closing stock @ 31 March 2023 is 400 units 1200 units
required to be
(iv) Opening stocks at 01 April 2022 900 units 200 units
(v) Unit cost of this opening stock will be Rwf 20 Rwf 28
(vi) The amount of plant capacity required
for each 15min 24min
product is: Machining
Assembling 12min 18min
(vii) The raw material content per unit is
Material A 1.5 kg 0.5 kg
39,500 18,650
Depreciation is taken at 5% straight-line on
plant and machinery equipment. A machine
costing the company Rwf20,000 is due to be
installed on 1 October 2022 in the
machining department which already has
machinery installed to the value of
Rwf100,000 at cost and Rwf87000 at cost to
Assembly.
Sellingand distributionexpenses Rwf
Sales commission and salaries 14,300
Travelingdistribution 3,500
Officesalaries 10,100
General administration expenses 2,500
30,400
(g) There is no opening or closing work in progress and
inflation should be ignored.
Required
Prepare the following budgets for the year ended 31
March 2023 for Venus PLC.
Sales budget
Production budget (units)
Plant utilization budget
Direct materials utilization budget
Direct labour budget
Factory overhead budget
Direct materials purchases budget
Cost of goods sold budget
Budgeted profit and loss account
Exercise
GG plans to incorporate a company to be known as GG holdings Ltd, for the
distribution of locally made spare parts. He intends to contribute an initial capital of
frw 450,000 in cash. After approaching His bank manager for financial support he
was asked to submit projected statement of profit and cashflow of the business for
the next four month commencing 1st July 2018. After a careful analysis GG gathered
the following information relating to the business operation for the six months to
December 31st 2018.
i. At the beginning of July operating furniture and equipment will be acquired for
cash at a total cost of frw 880,000. In addition stocks costing frw 500,000 will be
acquired out of which half will be paid for in cash and the balance in the following
month.
ii. Stock levels will be maintained at a level that is sufficient to satisfy sales for the
next month. The company intends to earn a gross margin of 50% on the sales.
Credit terms from suppliers require payment after 1 month from date of purchase.
iii. Sales are expected to average frw 600,000 per month for the next one year. It is
expected that 75% of the customers will pay in cash and 25% will take credit. All
iv. The following monthly expenses are incurred:
Rent frw 100,000
Miscellaneous frw 25,000
Salaries frw 60,000
Depreciation frw 50,000
All the expenses will be paid for in the month they are incurred except
rent, which is payable quarterly in advance.
i. The proprietor expects to withdraw frw 50,000 from the business every
month for personal use.
Required:
Prepare a cash budget for each of the month of July, August, September
and October 2018