EPEE3111: INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS
TRADE UNION IN MALAYSIA
6/12/2013
Prepared by: Dr. Parwazalam Abdul Rauf
Main Actors in Industrial Relations Systems
WORKERS and their ORGANIZATIONS Rules and legislations
GOVERNMENT and their AGENCIES
EMPLOYERS and their ORGANIZATIONS
2
UNDERSTANDING TRADE UNION
TRADE UNIONS is . . A voluntary association of wage earners organised for further or maintain their rights and interests through collective bargaining with the employer, especially for improving wages, hours and conditions of employment.
(Websters New Collegiate Dictionary, 1956:901)
All union must be recognized and have resources available at the workplace to act as the representative of its members.
The trade union recognition is the process by which management formally accepts one or more trade unions as the representative(s) of all, or a group, of its employees for the purpose of jointly determining terms and conditions of employment on a collective basis.
In Malaysia, a Trade Union includes: An associations / trade union registered under the T.U Act, 1959.
4
However, the following group of employees are not allowed to join a trade union: Managerial capacity Executive capacity Confidential capacity Security capacity.
RIGHTS OF WORKMEN AND EMPLOYERS:
Industrial Relations Act, 1967 (Part II, 4): No person shall interfere with, restrain or coerce a workman or an employer in the exercise of his rights to form and assist in the formation of and join a trade union and to participate in its lawful activities.
UNFAIR EMPLOYER LABOR PRACTICES (U.S.)
The Wagner Act deemed statutory wrongs (but not crimes) five unfair labor practices used by employers:
1. It is unfair for employers to interfere with, restrain, or coerce employees in exercising their legally sanctioned right of self-organization. 2. Companies are prohibited from discriminating in any way against employees for their legal union activities.
7
3. It is an unfair practice for company representatives to dominate or interfere with either the formation or the administration of labor unions. Among other management actions found to be unfair under practices 1 and 2 are bribing employees, using company spy systems, moving a business to avoid unionization, and blacklisting union sympathizers.
4. Employers are forbidden to discharge or discriminate against employees simply because the latter file unfair practice charges against the company. 5. Finally, it is an unfair labor practice for employers to refuse to bargain collectively with their employees duly chosen representatives.
6/12/2013 Prepared by: Dr. Parwazalam Abdul Rauf 8
UNFAIR UNION LABOR PRACTICES
The Taft-Hartly Act enumerated several labor practices that unions were prohibited from engaging in: 1. Unions were banned from restraining or coercing employees from exercising their guaranteed bargaining rights. For example, some specific union actions the courts have held illegal under this provision include stating to an antiunion employee that he or she will lose his or her job once the union gains recognition; issuing patently false statements during union organizing campaigns; and making threats of reprisal against employees subpoenaed to testify against the union at NLRB hearings.
Prepared by: Dr. Parwazalam Abdul Rauf 9
6/12/2013
2. It is also unfair labor practice for a union to cause an employer to discriminate in any way against an employee in order to encourage or discourage his or her membership in a union. There is one exception to this. Where a closed or union shop prevails (and union membership is therefore a prerequisite to employment), the union may demand discharge for a worker who fails to pay his or her initiation fees and dues.
3. It is an unfair labor practice for a union to refuse to bargain in good faith with the employer about wages, hours, and other employment conditions.
4. It is an unfair labor practice for a union to engage in featherbedding.
6/12/2013 Prepared by: Dr. Parwazalam Abdul Rauf 10
APPLICATION FOR REGISTRATION:
Every application for registration shall be made to DGTU in the prescribed form: Signed by at least 7 members of the union (any of whom may be officers thereof), Accompanied by such fees as may be prescribed, A printed copy of the rules of the trade union signed by the members with the following particulars:
The names, occupations, address of the members making application, The name and address of the trade union, The titles, names, addresses and occupations of the officers
6/12/2013 Prepared by: Dr. Parwazalam Abdul Rauf 11
The DGTU may refuse to register if:
There is in existence a trade union representing workers in that particular establishment (it is not in the interest of the workers concerned). Likely to be used for unlawful purposes or for purposes contrary to or inconsistent with its objectives and rules. Not satisfied that the trade union has complied with the Act and of the regulations. The objectives, rules, and constitution of the trade union conflict with any of the provisions of the Act. The name which the trade union is to registered is:
Identical/nearly resembles to that of any other existing trade union. Undesirable, unless the trade union alters its name to one acceptable to the DGTU.
6/12/2013 Prepared by: Dr. Parwazalam Abdul Rauf 12
WHY DO WORKERS ORGANIZE?
. . The urge to unionize often boils down to the belief that it is only through unity that the workers can get their fair share of the pie and also protect themselves from the arbitrary whims of management.
6/12/2013
Prepared by: Dr. Parwazalam Abdul Rauf
13
WHY EMPLOYEES UNIONIZE ?
Studies on successful unionization activities identifies 4 categories of reasons why employees organize. Reasons include: 1. ECONOMIC NEEDS
Dissatisfaction with wages, benefits, and working conditions appear to provide the strongest reasons for joining a union. When employees believe that their economic need is greater than they can fill in individual negotiations, then chances for successful unionization are enhanced.
6/12/2013 Prepared by: Dr. Parwazalam Abdul Rauf 14
2. SOCIAL AND STATUS CONCERNS
Employees whose needs for status and recognition may join unions as means for satisfying these needs. The union becomes a conduit for fraternization and sharing feelings about the job in a safe environment. It also provides the basis for developing off-work friendships based on shared interests. Further, union service can provide opportunities to use leadership talents.
6/12/2013
Prepared by: Dr. Parwazalam Abdul Rauf
15
3. DISSATISFACTION WITH MANAGEMENT
Employees cited favoritism shown by managers as major reason for joining unions. Employees may seek unionization when they perceive that managerial practices regarding promotion, transfer, shift assignment, or other job-related policies are administered in an unfair or biased manner.
4. GROUP DIFFERENCES TOWARD UNIONIZATION
In certain cases, certain groups are more unionized than the others. (i.e. trend of unionization among certain races, minorities group, locality, industries, etc.)
6/12/2013 Prepared by: Dr. Parwazalam Abdul Rauf 16
Specifically, Trade Unions are organized with the following main objectives: 1. To secure the complete organization: to promote the industrial, social and intellectual interests of its members. 2. To regulate the relationship between employees and their employers, member and member, and members and other workers. 3. To promote the material, social and educational welfare. 4. To provide legal assistance to members. 5. To provide victimization pay and dispute pay. 6. To promote legislation affecting the interest of 6/12/2013 Prepared by: 17 the members. Dr. Parwazalam Abdul Rauf
7. Conduct collective bargaining with the employees with the view to concluding collective agreement. 8. To represent the employees in trade disputes with employer. 9. To represent the employees in Industrial and Labour Court. 10. To undertake such other activities as to promote social, recreational and cultural activities among its members. 11. To promote or organize any legitimate industrial action: strikes, picket, etc. subject to provision of the Trade Union Act, 1959.
6/12/2013 Prepared by: Dr. Parwazalam Abdul Rauf 18
Workforce in Malaysia
1998 = 8.881 million: 8.597 employed = 96.8% employed
2000 = 9.194 million: 8.920 employed = 97.0% employed 7.72 mil. = private sector 0.98 mil = public sector Plus 1.14 mil. = legal foreign workers (Estimated 1 mil. = work illegally)
6/12/2013 Prepared by: Dr. Parwazalam Abdul Rauf 19
Trade Union Density in Malaysia
In 1998: 720,000 workers belong to Trade Unions. Private sector = 400,000 (55.5%) Public sector = 320,00 (44.5%)
Union density = 720,00/8.881 mil = 8.1%
6/12/2013
Prepared by: Dr. Parwazalam Abdul Rauf
20
Unionism: - An International Comparison
Singapore = 15% Philippines = 25% Japan = 35% Hong Kong = 22% Sri Lanka = 35% India = 28% Korea = 19.7% New Zealand = 31%
6/12/2013
Australia = 55% Canada = 35% Great Britain = 51% USA = 28% Sweden 82% Denmark = 65% Norway = 61%
Prepared by: Dr. Parwazalam Abdul Rauf
21
Number of Employees Union, 1965 to 1998
1965 = 286 1990 = 468 1970 = 237 1992 = 479 1975 = 252 1994 = 501 1980 = 369 1996 = 516 1985 = 369 1998 = 533
Distribution of Trade Union by Sector
Sector Private sector Civil service Statutory bodies
6/12/2013
1993 276 = 56% 132 = 26% 088 = 18%
Prepared by: Dr. Parwazalam Abdul Rauf
1998 314 = 59% 133 = 25% 086 = 16%
22
The Density of Union Membership by Sectors, 1998
Sector Agriculture Mining No. of workers 1,401,000 42,000 Union members 55,000 1,000 % Unionized 3.9% 6.4%
Manufacturing
Construction Public sector
2,279,000
808,000 3,190,000
145,000
4,000 195,000
5.9%
0.5% 6.1%
Private sector
All sectors
6/12/2013
877,000
8,597,000
320,000
720,000
36.5%
8.2%
23
Prepared by: Dr. Parwazalam Abdul Rauf
The largest unions by membership 1995, 1998
Name of Union National Union of the Teaching Profession 1998 76,311 1995 28,546
National Union of Plantation Workers
National Union of Bank Employees Electrical Industry Workers Union Amalgamated NU of Local Authority Employee Malay Teachers Union, Pen. Malaysia Telekom Bhd. Employees Union National Union of College Trained Teachers Metal Industry Employees Union Non metallic Mineral Prod. Mfg. Employees Union Transport Workers Union
6/12/2013 Prepared by: Dr. Parwazalam Abdul Rauf
39,420
27,622 27,015 19,322 16,935 15,847 12,307 11,474 10,976 10,469
100,052
12,922 18,025 14,217 15,531 8,537
10,447
24
New Trend: - Union-free Environment
1. Employers who adhere to certain union-free strategies and tactics can remain or become union free organization.
2. Some managers believe that the presence of a union is evidence of managements failure to treat employees fairly.
6/12/2013 Prepared by: Dr. Parwazalam Abdul Rauf 25
Many factors significantly reduce the chances of unionizing, notably:
1. A conviction by employees that the boss is not taking advantage of them.
2. Employees who have pride in their work. 3. Good performance records kept by the company. Employees feel more secure on their jobs when they know their efforts are recognized and appreciated.
6/12/2013 Prepared by: Dr. Parwazalam Abdul Rauf 26
4. No claims of high-handed treatment. Employees respect firm but fair discipline. 5. No claim of favoritism thats not earned through work performance.
6. Supervisors who have good relationships with subordinates.
6/12/2013
Prepared by: Dr. Parwazalam Abdul Rauf
27
Some Evidence from Research Findings:
Certain similar characteristics help organizations remain union free: 1. Competitive pay and strong benefits. 2. A team environment. 3. Open communication. 4. A pleasant work environment. 5. The avoidance of layoffs.
Organization should also establish its strategy long before a union organizing attempts begin.
6/12/2013 Prepared by: Dr. Parwazalam Abdul Rauf 28
Organization must borrow some of unions philosophy:
1. Management must be able and willing to offer workers equal and better conditions than workers could expect with a union.
2. Weakness in any critical area may be an open invitation to a union. 3. All aspects of an organizations operation are involved in maintaining its union-free status.
6/12/2013 Prepared by: Dr. Parwazalam Abdul Rauf 29
Factors Involved in Maintaining a UnionFree Status Organization
Effective first-line supervisors Effective compensation programs Effective employee & labor relation
6/12/2013
Union-free policy Effective communication
Remaining Union-free
Trust and openness
Dr. Parwazalam Abdul Rauf
A healthy and safe work environment Prepared by:
Government influence
30
