ENGLE205F Module Three
ENGLE205F Module Three
Module 3
Production
ETPU Publishing Team
Copyright acknowledgements
The following copyright materials (HCP070274OU) have been copied in
accordance with the terms of the licence issued by The Hong Kong
Reprographic Rights Licensing Society Limited. You are not permitted to
make any further copy of the materials, or to sell, or make them available
to others.
Figure on p. 8.
Introduction 1
Reading intensively 23
Scanning 23
Strategies for understanding the meanings of unfamiliar words 25
Identifying possible synonyms for key words and phrases 30
Unpacking complex sentences 32
Identifying examples 34
Conclusion 49
Module 3 1
Introduction
This module aims to give you practice in a variety of skills and strategies
for dealing with academic texts. As in Modules 1 and 2, the activities in
this module do not relate directly to IELTS test questions but instead
focus on developing your ability to comprehend a range of academic
reading texts. In Module 7, you will be asked to apply this ability to
reading passages similar to those that might be used in the IELTS reading
test.
Activity 3.1
Think about the following kinds of texts and what your main reading
purpose might be as you approach each of them:
5 a journal article that reports on research into the hole in the ozone
layer.
Once you have determined your reason or purpose for reading a text, you
can then decide how to read it – for example, whether you need to focus
on key points, specific details or the writer’s opinion.
Module 3 3
Activity 3.2
Imagine that you are doing some research for an essay you have to write
for a university course. You have found 15 journal articles that relate
broadly to your essay topic, some of which may be worth using and some
not. You have two hours to review them to decide if they are worth
reading more closely. Each journal article has 15–20 pages, so you have
about 200–300 pages to cover in two hours! How would you approach
these articles to determine whether or not they are worth reading in more
detail? What reading skills or strategies might you use in the two hours
you have available?
Your task in the above activity was to think about skills and strategies
you could use to quickly review each article and determine whether or not
its main ideas were useful for your essay. Once you know the main points
of an article, you are in a better position to decide if you should read it
more intensively. Let’s look more closely at skills/strategies for reading
for main points or ideas.
4 ENGLE205F Preparing for IELTS
Look for a minute at the following passage which tells users of the
OUHK’s Online Learning Environment (OLE) how to save OLE email
messages to their hard disks. What do you think would be your main
purpose when reading this?
Reading passage 1
3 Click Save as from the ‘File’ menu. Select the folder that you have
created to store your downloaded message.
In the ‘File name’ box, rename the message by deleting the long file
number and retyping a name for the file.
Module 3 5
In the ‘Save as type’ box, select ‘Web Page HTML only (*.htm, *.html)’
and then click the Save button. The message will then be saved in the
folder you created in your hard disk.
Note: If the email message has an attachment, the attachment will not be
saved in the hard disk. You will need to open the attachment and use the
Save option to save your attachment separately.
4 Once you have saved the email message on your hard disk, you
should delete the email message from your email folder in order
to clear the email space.
• Would you agree that this passage has features that are common to a
set of instructions? If so, what structure, layout and language
features are generally distinctive to instructional texts like this?
• What verb form is mostly used in this kind of text? Is this verb form
commonly used in instructional texts? Why?
Activity 3.3
Look again at the types of texts you came across in Activity 3.1, and
think about the kinds of structures, layouts, content and language they
might have. In each case, consider whether the text is likely to include
graphics, bullets or numbers; how headings and paragraphs might be
organized; whether the language will be persuasive or factual; and what
sorts of grammatical forms (e.g. different kinds of verb tenses) are likely
to be used. Think also about some of the vocabulary that might be used
for each topic:
4 a journal article that reports on research into the hole in the ozone
layer.
List different features and predict some possible language for each
passage.
1 Look at the title. What key words does it include? What does it
suggest about the passage?
2 Look at the text’s layout and structure. Are there numbered parts?
Are there sub-headings? Are there boxed pieces of information? Are
these labelled? How do sub-headings and any boxed pieces of
information relate to the main title? Can you see any progression of
ideas?
4 Read the first and last paragraphs quickly. These often contain the
main ideas.
5 Read quickly the topic sentences (usually the first sentence) of the
other paragraphs. These sentences usually contain the main idea of a
paragraph.
Before you begin the activity, take a moment to orient yourself to the text
and think about the following questions:
Activity 3.4
Set yourself a maximum time limit of two minutes for reading, and skim
the review, using the suggestions above. After you have skimmed the
book review, answer the questions that follow.
Reading passage 2
3 What most readers will not know and what is explained most clearly
is the theory behind acupuncture. Some very beautiful old diagrams
of the body help readers follow the explanation. The health of the
body depends on a balance between the forces of yin and yang,
Module 3 9
between the cold, slow and passive and the warm, fast and active.
When the balance is disturbed the flow of qi, vital energy, along the
twenty energy channels of the body, is blocked. The acupuncturist
analyses the situation carefully and selects some of the two thousand
acupuncture points on the body and by use of the needles unblocks
the channels, gets the qi flowing again and slowly but surely
restores the patient to health.
A painless painkiller
7 It was at that point that alarm bells started going off for this reader.
How and why are these needles doing so much good and achieving
such wonderful results? Yes, the writer has explained about the
channels and qi, but we know a lot about the human body and there
are no energy channels running through it, nor are yin and yang
scientific concepts.
Alternative views
1 What do the picture, the sub-headings and the layout tell us in this
book review?
2 What does the title tell us? Do you think it’s a helpful title for
describing the main ideas in the review? Why/why not?
3 Having read the first and last paragraphs, what is the reviewer’s
general view of the book?
Now try practising the skimming skills you have learned with another
reading text.
5 Read quickly the topic sentences (usually the first sentence) of the
other paragraphs.
Activity 3.5
Module 3 11
Reading passage 3
6 Well, surely, then, this is a ‘new kid’ we can warmly embrace, but
nothing is always that simple and there are, as ever, nay-sayers.
Let’s address their worries calmly and see if they can possibly
outbalance all these benefits. The problem began in 1986, when
nanotechnology had hardly been born, with a book called ‘The
Engines of Creation’ in which the author argued that self-replicating
robots would take over the world, with disastrous reactions turning
the whole planet into a grey jelly. So far it has not happened.
7 What are the other fears? Nano-particles can accumulate in the bodies
of animals and do damage. Carbon nano-particles do not set off
immune reactions but can actually enter cells; they might therefore
be used by bacteria to infect humans. Neutral nano-products might
be hijacked and used maliciously by our natural enemies. As the
nano-scale makes materials behave differently, we must not assume
that the changes are benign; normally useful and harmless
substances may become toxic. Nano-materials are not natural to our
world. We are creating something new and releasing it in increasing
quantities into the environment without knowing the long-term
effects.
the air will be polluted. And we do not know what the impact of all
that water vapour will be.’ Well, yes, the coal burning had its
downside, yet would anyone, apart from a few dreamers, want to
return to a pre-industrial world. There were losses, but surely the
gains were greater?
9 Nanotechnology will not be all plain-sailing, but its benefits will far
outweigh its drawbacks. You can be confident about that.
We saw in Module 1 that the topic sentence gives the main idea of a
paragraph, and is usually the first sentence in a paragraph. The topic
sentences in the nanotechnology text are easy to identify because they are
all at the beginning of the paragraphs. Some of them are actually
questions which are answered by the rest of the information in the
paragraph.
14 ENGLE205F Preparing for IELTS
Activity 3.6
Look at the key ideas in each of the topic sentences in the
nanotechnology passage. Then match each of the paragraph summaries in
the left column below with the paragraph that it describes. One answer
has already been given as an example.
f Definition of nanotechnology
Activity 3.7
Now, go back to Reading passage 2 (the book review ‘Does it really
work: The History of Acupuncture’) and skim the topic sentences of the
paragraphs. Try to make a skeleton or outline of the text by completing
the table below. Use just a few words or a short sentence to describe the
main point in each paragraph.
10
11
16 ENGLE205F Preparing for IELTS
• gave a definition;
• provided some background history;
• outlined current uses of nanotechnology;
• suggested possible future uses;
• discussed potential problems or concerns;
• mentioned potential solutions for these concerns; and
• recapped the main idea.
Reading passage 3
6 Well, surely, then, this is a ‘new kid’ we can warmly embrace, but
nothing is always that simple and there are, as ever, nay-sayers.
Let’s address their worries calmly and see if they can possibly
outbalance all these benefits. The problem began in 1986, when
nanotechnology had hardly been born, with a book called The
‘Engines of Creation’ in which the author argued that self-
replicating robots would take over the world, with disastrous
reactions turning the whole planet into a grey jelly. So far it has not
happened.
7 What are the other fears? Nano-particles can accumulate in the bodies
of animals and do damage. Carbon nano-particles do not set off
immune reactions but can actually enter cells; they might therefore
be used by bacteria to infect humans. Neutral nano-products might
be hijacked and used maliciously by our natural enemies. As the
nano-scale makes materials behave differently, we must not assume
that the changes are benign; normally useful and harmless
substances may become toxic. Nano-materials are not natural to our
world. We are creating something new and releasing it in increasing
quantities into the environment without knowing the long-term
effects.
9 Nanotechnology will not be all plain-sailing, but its benefits will far
outweigh its drawbacks. You can be confident about that.
Activity 3.8
The paragraphs in the boxes below have been jumbled and are not in the
correct sequence. Look at the paragraphs and then try to put them into the
correct order.
The topic sentences of each paragraph provide some clues for ordering
the paragraphs, but focus also on reference words such as ‘these’ and ‘it’
and the cohesive links they create.
Think about what these words refer to. Remember also that general points
usually come before specific details or examples, and more serious
problems often come after less serious ones. This exercise is intended to
help you focus on the structure of the passage and on how the writer uses
some of the conventions described above to order the passage logically.
As you sequence the paragraphs, try to remember the reasons for your
choices.
b With all these doubts about these drugs and their side-effects – as
well as the manic episodes mentioned, such as nausea,
sleeplessness and loss of appetite – why are they used so widely?
Discourse markers
In Module 1, we saw how academic writing uses discourse markers to organize ideas and
demonstrate relationships between them. Discourse markers can signal examples, a
sequence, a cause and an effect, or a similarity or contrast. For example, words such as
‘however’, ‘on the other hand’ and ‘though’ may be used between two sentences to show
that one idea is in contrast to another. Notice how in the introduction to the book review
in Reading passage 2 the word ‘though’ is used to indicate a criticism:
This is an elegant, well-illustrated book, printed on glossy paper. The title, though, is
rather a misnomer as after the first chapter the author concentrates on the practice of
acupuncture and seeks to promote its use among readers.
Module 3 21
Activity 3.9
Look now at paragraph 8 in Reading passage 3 (on nanotechnology).
Notice the discourse markers that are used in this paragraph to signal
ideas that are contradictory, and then complete the following table. An
example has been included for you.
It would be good to
debate the safety
concerns of
nanotechnology before
deciding whether to use
it or not
To sum up what we have learned in this section, you can identify the
main points of a reading passage by:
• Using clues like the title, sub-headings and graphics to get a clear
picture of the main topic. Start to generate expectations, and recall
what you know about the topic.
Reading intensively
Having used a number of strategies to grasp the main points of a text, we
now look at how to read more intensively. Reading intensively also
involves a number of particular skills, which include:
Scanning
Scanning involves identifying specific information quickly. This
information might be numbers, measurements, a person’s name, a place,
or a technical word or phrase. Scanning is the technique you often use
when looking up a name in the telephone book or a word in the
dictionary. In most cases, you know what words you are looking for, and
so you can concentrate on finding particular information, rather than on
trying to get the general meaning of a paragraph. Generally, scanning is a
technique that is helpful when you are looking for the answer to a known
question. Here are some strategies for scanning efficiently:
2 If you have skimmed a passage, use your knowledge of its main ideas
to guide your scanning.
3 To scan a reading text, you should start at the top of the page and then
move your eyes quickly towards the bottom.
The following activity asks you to scan for specific information in part of
the nanotechnology text.
24 ENGLE205F Preparing for IELTS
Activity 3.10
Scan the excerpt below from Reading passage 3 for the information that
answers these questions:
2 How wide is a strand of DNA? (Hint: Note that you are looking for a
number or measurement, which will be located close to the words
‘strand’ and ‘DNA’, or their synonyms.)
3 Who was the first scientist to pioneer nanotechnology? (Hint: You are
looking for a name with capital letters.)
Reading passage 3
Next let’s practise our skills to work out the meaning of some less
common words in a longer passage.
Activity 3.11
Refer to Reading passage 4 ‘America and drugs’ below. Scan for the
following words, then find clues to understand what each word means by
looking at the context of each word:
By paragraph:
1 minimal
2 sedated
3 hyperactive, conform, dosage
4 alienate, lavish, advocates
6 nausea
Reading passage 4
26 ENGLE205F Preparing for IELTS
4 Or does it? One difficulty with such lucrative drugs as these is that
there are powerful vested interests in favour of them and reluctance
to hear any criticism. Advertising from drug companies was worth
over three billion dollars in 2003 and continues to increase. Unless
an editor has overwhelming reason to think there is a real problem,
s/he is not going to do anything to alienate such lavish advertisers.
An example of this came a couple of years ago. After reviewing the
evidence, the British government concluded that some of the SSRIs
caused young people to suffer restlessness and sudden outbursts of
mania that might lead to suicide. Their prescription to under-18s
was forbidden. The American press did not make a big issue of this,
and it took the American authorities quite some time to agree that
the drugs might cause an increased risk of suicide attempts, even if
not of actual suicides. A warning was accordingly put on the drugs.
To be fair, their advocates pointed out that the drugs were only
given to rather disturbed individuals and that overall since the
introduction of SSRIs, the suicide rate among the young, related or
unrelated to that event, had fallen.
6 With all these doubts about these drugs and their side-effects – as
well as the manic episodes mentioned are nausea, sleeplessness and
loss of appetite – why are the drugs used so widely?
mis + nom + er
The root (or main part of the word) is ‘nom’. Can you think of other
words that use this root? (We thought of ‘nominal’ and ‘nomination’.)
This root comes from Latin and means ‘name’.
The prefix mis- comes from French and is used in many English words
(e.g. ‘mistake’, ‘mispronounce’, ‘misconception’). Based on your
knowledge of the root and the prefix of the word ‘misnomer’, do you
think a title which is a ‘misnomer’ is appropriate or inaccurate?
Activity 3.12
30 ENGLE205F Preparing for IELTS
Try to work out the meaning of these words from their roots, prefixes and
suffixes:
1 anarchy
2 autobiography
3 luminescent
4 foolproof
5 psychotherapy
6 deformation
7 megalomania
8 chronometer
9 misogynist
10 monologue
11 antipathy
12 disqualification
13 hydrological
14 psychokinetic
15 hypothermia
For example, imagine that you were reading the following paragraph
from the ‘America and drugs’ text in order to answer the following
comprehension question:
Activity 3.13
The paragraph below discusses computer viruses. Find words and phrases
in the paragraph that mean the same as the ten synonyms in the left
column below. The answers should be in the same order as they appear in
the text.
1 joined
2 continuous
3 unpleasant
4 difference
5 forms
6 frequently used
7 careful
8 harmful
1 odd
0
32 ENGLE205F Preparing for IELTS
Computer viruses
Any computer connected to the Internet is under constant attack. This is
a grim fact of cyberlife. Viruses and worms (the distinction is almost
lost now) arrive in various guises and can cause serious damage.
Messages about email that cannot be delivered and prizes we have won
are common ways to get themselves on a computer. The wary know
never to open them and to delete at once. Trojan horses are an ever-
present danger allowing your machine to be remotely controlled from
afar. Spyware is as nasty as it sounds along with its slightly less noxious
cousin adware. Downloading free software is a risky business nowadays
as often some malware gets in at the same time. These programmes slow
down your computer, make your web browser behave in peculiar ways
and generally degrade the performance of your machine.
Academic reading often involves being able to cope with long and
complex sentences. We now discuss some strategies that can help you
unpack or simplify complex sentences.
Although there has been a great deal of research, a vaccine has not
yet been found.
Being able to ‘unpack’ complex sentences and identify their main clauses
is a key skill in reading intensively, as it helps you to determine the main
ideas and establish a writer’s main arguments.
Recognizing concession
In academic arguments, writers often acknowledge (or ‘concede’) that
there is more than one point of view. To signal differences in opinion,
writers often express two points of view by combining two contrasting
clauses in one complex sentence. They also often signal to the reader that
one point of view has more importance than the other by placing the less
important view first in the sentence – often preceded by a preposition that
indicates some concession to a different or opposing argument.
Module 3 33
Although tests have not been completed, permission has been given
for the wider use of the new drugs.
Activity 3.14
Examine the following complex sentences and, in your own words,
paraphrase the main opinion or argument.
1 Regardless of the fact that severe piracy laws have been enforced,
pirated CDs and DVDs are widely available in shops and markets.
2 Although it is certainly not impossible, the theory may not strike one
as especially plausible.
Identifying examples
In addition to recognizing a writer’s concession to an opposing fact or
argument, it is also important to be able to recognize how writers use
examples to support their opinions.
For example,
For instance,
This is indicated by …
This is shown by …
Activity 3.15
In the paragraph below (which also discusses the use of anti-depressants
in America):
To sum up what we have learned in this section, you can read intensively
and locate specific information in the following ways:
• Unpack complex sentences to identify their key ideas. Look for words
or phrases that signal concessions or conflicting facts and arguments.
For example, look at how the negative and emotive underlined words in
the passage below connote the author’s belief that viruses are dangerous
and a serious problem.
Computer viruses
Any computer connected to the Internet is under constant attack. This is
a grim fact of cyberlife. Viruses and worms (the distinction is almost
lost now) arrive in various guises and can cause serious damage.
Messages about email that cannot be delivered and prizes we have won
are common ways to get themselves on a computer. The wary know
never to open them and to delete at once. Trojan horses are an ever-
present danger allowing your machine to be remotely controlled from
afar. Spyware is as nasty as it sounds along with its slightly less noxious
cousin adware. Downloading free software is a risky business nowadays
as often some malware gets in at the same time. These programmes slow
down your computer, make your web browser behave in peculiar ways
and generally degrade the performance of your machine.
Computer viruses
Any computer connected to the Internet may be affected by a virus.
Viruses and worms come in different forms and can alter a computer’s
operation. Trojan horses are viruses that allow a computer to be
remotely controlled. Spyware and adware are other kinds of viruses.
These programmes can reduce the operating speed of your computer,
and make the web browser behave in unusual ways.
Undoubtedly, …
Clearly, …
Without question, …
Activity 3.16
The paragraph below discusses whether life exists on other planets. What
is the author’s attitude to this issue? Underline any words that help you to
determine the writer’s attitude to the question of life on other planets.
How certain is the author of his/her opinions?
Astrobiology
In the history of humankind’s thinking about itself, one thing is very
clear. We began by assuming we were unique and we have gradually
realised this is an illusion. Earth is not the centre of the Solar System.
We are not unrelated to other animals. We are not the only animals that
use tools and have ways of communicating. Our Sun is not an especially
impressive star. There are inconceivably many more galaxies than ours.
Many stars have planets. It is highly likely that our belief that life is
unique to Earth is also going to be proved wrong. The signs are already
there.
38 ENGLE205F Preparing for IELTS
Activity 3.17
Now read the passage that the above paragraph was taken from (Reading
passage 5 below) and note the degree of certainty in the other paragraphs.
Mark the following statements as ‘very sure’ or ‘not completely sure’
according to the passage. Remember to look for words that express doubt
– for example, ‘maybe’, ‘possibly’, ‘could’, ‘might’ and ‘seem’ – or
certainty, such as ‘definitely’, ‘it is clear that’, ‘obviously’ and ‘fact’.
Reading passage 5
Astrobiology
2 A few years ago one of the principal arguments supporting the idea
that life might be an extremely rare phenomenon was its fragility.
The list of requisites was deemed to rule out most places: liquid
water, a narrow temperature range, protection from harmful rays
and even ultra-violet light that breaks up organic molecules, and
freedom from bombardment from space debris. Finding such a place
was likely to be very difficult. A view of our own neighbours
underlined the problem. Mercury suffers terrible extremes of heat
Module 3 39
and cold and any liquid must have long been boiled off by the Sun.
Venus is a hydrocarbon furnace. Mars appears to be cold and dead.
The planets beyond that are gas giants with incredible pressures and
temperatures close to absolute zero.
4 Now that they can look at Mars in more detail many astrobiologists
expect us sooner or later to find life on the planet. We have
discovered there is water on or just below the surface and that once
there was lot of surface water there. Ages ago, Mars was warm and
wet. Life may well have appeared and hung on in hidden niches
below the surface. Subterranean bacteria could explain the rather
puzzling presence of methane in the Martian atmosphere. Some
even believe a meteorite from Mars found in 1996 already contains
evidence of bacterial activity on the red planet. Certainly the
presence of magnetite crystals is puzzling.
5 According to some scientists, Earth was seeded with life from outer
space. It could have been a rock from Mars or a comet. On the
whole, objects falling from the sky are more likely to have on
occasions stopped life in its tracks or driven organisms to extinction,
and the conditions they undergo when falling through the
atmosphere are likely to tax even the most extreme bacteria, but it is
true that red giants produce organic molecules and that amino acids
have been found on meteorites. The theory may not strike one as
especially plausible, but it is certainly not impossible.
Other factors – such as the audience’s age, sex, race, education level,
profession and so on – also influence the use of academic language. For
example, a textbook for Secondary 3 students will obviously be written
(and illustrated) in a very different way from a report written for PhD
candidates or senior professionals.
Module 3 41
Activity 3.18
Look again at Reading passage 5. Who do you think is the intended
audience for this passage? How do you know?
1 Do you think the writer has written this passage for a specialist or a
general audience?
• What audience do you think this passage was written for? How do
you know? Remember to think about the level of assumed
knowledge, the extent to which specialist language is used, and the
degree to which the writer explains or defines uncommon or technical
words.
Reading passage 6
One of the most controversial of modern technological breakthroughs has been that of genetic engineering,
especially the ability to splice the genes of one organism into those of another so producing a new, ‘improved’
variety all the more capable of meeting human needs. Humans had long modified crops and animals by means
of selective breeding, but now far faster and more dramatic alterations to organisms have become possible. This
has ignited a fierce debate.
II
The first thing any supporter of the genetic modification of crops will do is list some of the products of this
engineering. We have rice that yields more, produces Vitamin A, can grow in a salty environment, can
withstand stress and resist the ill-effects of chemicals sprayed to kill weeds, insect pests and harmful bacteria.
We have potatoes with more protein, which bruise less and can withstand insect and viral attack. We have
soybeans that are less allergenic, contain more oil, can withstand the cold, grow in soil with metallic content
and survive spraying for weeds and insects. There are
42 ENGLE205F Preparing for IELTS
tomatoes which resist viral and fungal attacks, have a longer shelf-life and contain more anti-oxidants
(thought to reduce the risks of cancer). New peppers have more flavour and resistance to viruses, and there
are strawberries that can be grown in colder places, fight fungal infection and last longer (an important
factor in getting soft fruit to market). These modifications and others are helpful to farmers, businesses and
consumers (see Table 1).
Table 1
• Plants that can be sprayed with pesticide without Produce with: Produce with
ill-effect • altered oil content increased:
• Plants naturally resistant to: insects, bacteria, • increased shelf-life • flavour
viruses, fungal infection • vitamins
• less bruising
• Plants that can withstand: cold, stress, salty • anti-oxidants
conditions, metals, drought
• protein.
• Plants with improved nitrogen fixation
• Plants with increased yields Produce less likely
to trigger allergies
There have also been modifications to farm animals with, for example, cows that produce milk ideal for
cheese, pigs with less fat in their meat, and faster growing salmon.
In the face of all these benefits, the pro-GM camp cannot understand why anyone should not be delighted.
They take the general view that new advances are, like accused people, deserving of the benefit of the doubt
and should be regarded as innocent until proved guilty. Until and unless there is a problem, which they are
confident we would soon be able to fix, they see no reason for hesitation. The Industrial and Digital
Revolutions can now be joined by the Biotech Revolution and bring profits to all. In any case, they point
out, GM foodstuffs and crops are widely used in the United States, Canada, Australia, Argentina, India and
China, all major agricultural producers. There have been no problems of a significant nature.
Many writers defending GM crops claim that the technology is the key to reducing world hunger and
malnutrition (these are not quite the same: many people have food in sufficient quantity but do not have a
healthy balanced diet). Plants can be designed that will flourish in poor soil, survive in harsh conditions and
supply the right nutrients to people. To miss this opportunity would be an unconscionable shame.
III
Genetically modified crops have not, however, been welcomed by all. In 1999 Europeans suddenly became
aware of what was happening and reacted, in many cases, with great hostility. Probably as a result of a
number of scares attached to modern farming methods (notably the BSE disaster in the United Kingdom),
Europeans showed no willingness to trust the assurances of experts that all this engineering activity was
safe, especially when there were some who were saying the exact opposite. It became politically impossible
for governments not to act and a number of restrictions were placed on the use of GM plants. Products
containing GM ingredients have to be clearly labelled and are practically impossible to sell in the European
market. The Japanese consumer has also proved to be reluctant to try the new crops. This has had a strong
knock-on effect on farmers who hope to export to these markets. They know that GM foodstuffs are
unacceptable to consumers and hence avoid them. American farming interests suspect that the European
aversion to GM crops is part of a protectionist plot. Certainly the EU is guilty of protecting its farmers, but
the strength of feeling on the part of the public was genuine whether or not it was justified. What caused it is
our next question.
Module 3 43
There are a number of points made in opposition to genetic engineering of the sort being discussed.
First, it is seen as ‘unnatural’. The food produced as a result was named ‘Frankenfood’ with all its
associations of horror. The argument is a little vague, but reflects a public fear that scientists have
got too used to playing God and are venturing on forbidden and very dangerous ground without
even taking any precautions. The mind-set of these concerned people is very unlike that of the pro-
GM thinkers; they are very nervous of the genie being let out of the bottle. Until it has been proved
that genetically altering organisms is harmless they want no part of it.
A stronger argument than the fear that GM foodstuffs might turn out to be toxic, is the fear of
genetic pollution. The manufacturers of GM crops assured people that new genes would not
spread, but research has shown that seeds travel further than expected and accidental and
unforeseen mixing is quite probable. This raises the question of the emergence of ‘superweeds’
which cannot be killed by spraying. In the case of specialized plants that produce, for example,
pharmaceutical drugs, one would not want their qualities spreading to ordinary edible plants. It is
also reasonable to point out that one cannot really beat nature for long. If plants show resistance to
various viruses and insects, natural selection will swiftly produce new ones capable of overcoming
their defences.
Another line of argument involves the companies themselves. People are not happy with the idea
of plants and genes being patented. They fear that rather than helping the poor the new crops will
earn huge profits for the biotechnology corporations. Farmers will be dependent on them and the
companies will gain a form of monopoly. At first, this seemed to have been confirmed by the use
of ‘terminator’ tactics that ensured the seed produced each year would be infertile. Ironically, this
would help to solve the contamination problem that also concerned critics, but it still enraged them.
It certainly needs to be conceded that some of the possible benefits to the developing world
trumpeted by GM companies are unlikely to emerge from profit-driven companies whose interest
in the poor is always minimal for obvious commercial reasons.
IV
It seems unlikely that any consensus on this vexed topic will appear soon. The argument goes
beyond facts to basic attitudes and philosophies.
Activity 3.19
Answer the following questions about Reading passage 6:
1 How would you describe the author’s attitude to the topic of GE?
Does he/she take a particular position or side in the debate?
6 What does the writer mean by saying ‘people are very nervous of the
genie being let out of the bottle’ (section III, paragraph 2)?
44 ENGLE205F Preparing for IELTS
7 Why would one not want the qualities mentioned in the passage
spreading in the way described (section III, paragraph 3)?
8 How will natural selection produce the effect described in section III,
paragraph 3?
First, practise orienting yourself to the text. Then try to quickly skim the
text, noting the main arguments in the introduction and conclusion and
the key ideas in topic sentences. Pay attention to discourse markers and
the structure and logic of the passage. Then read the passage more
carefully and try to guess the meaning of unfamiliar words. Also, look for
any positive or negative words that suggest the author’s attitude, and
think also about the intended audience of the passage.
Reading passage 7
Plastic beauty
1 In the developed world, plastic, or cosmetic surgery as it is
increasingly known, is booming. More and more clinics are being
opened, advertisements seem to be everywhere and more and more
of one’s friends are disappearing for a short time and then
reemerging looking different. It isn’t even only the old who are
turning to the knife to improve their looks; more and more
adolescents are having adjustments made to their appearance.
2 Among the most common operations are work on the breasts (often
enhancement but also reduction for women) and on the eyes (in
Asia to make the eyes more Western-looking and among the older
to remove bags and wrinkling). Liposuction removes fat from the
thighs or any other places with unsightly bulges; face-lifts smooth
out the effects of aging; rhinoplasty improves the shape of the nose
(males are particularly drawn to this operation; and otoplasty (often
resorted to by teenagers) sorts out large or prominent ears.
3 In some cases the surgery is carried out for medical reasons. Large
breasts can, for example, cause back problems, but in most cases the
motive is beauty. People want to look more attractive, and who can
gainsay them? Research has time and time again shown that
physically attractive people get better jobs, earn more, are more
likely to be helped and generally have a better time. Even very
young babies will look more frequently at people who are regarded
as good-looking than at others. Making your features more regular
makes sense.
7 Arguments from nature rarely work. The term is too vague. There is
nothing new to humans altering their appearance with various types
of piercing and tattooing. Societies in which implants are put into
lips, necks are elongated, feet are made artificially small and wigs
are worn are easy to think of. If such behaviour is so old and so
wide-spread, how can we say it is unnatural to the human species?
All that has happened is that it can now be done far more effectively
and safely.
9 There is some irony in the fact that just as women made such
breakthroughs in developed societies and rejected the image of sex
object or baby-bearing machine, cosmetic surgery came along and
made many women seek to enhance their sexual attractiveness to
men by means of its procedures. It is, then, understandable that
feminists are no fans of cosmetic surgery carried out for such
reasons, but, again, these are issues for individuals to think about.
Activity 3.20
Answer these questions by scanning the text very quickly for specific
information.
Activity 3.21
Scan the passage to find which paragraph mentions each of the ideas
listed in the left-hand column of the table below.
48 ENGLE205F Preparing for IELTS
Ideas Paragraph #
Activity 3.22
Answer the following questions.
d thought to be (2 words)
Conclusion
This module has introduced you to three main sets of skills and strategies
for reading academic texts.
• using clues like the title, sub-headings and graphics to get a clear
picture of the main topic;
• thinking about the logic of the passage and about how relationships
between ideas and paragraphs are ordered and organized; and