Topic 21. Problem Solving
Topic 21. Problem Solving
PROBLEM SOLVING
PROBLEM SOLVING. DIFFERENT CLASSES AND METHODS OF SOLUTION.
PLANNING, RESOURCE MANAGEMENT, REPRESENTATION, INTERPRETATION AND
EVALUATION OF THE RESULTS. EDUCATIONAL INTERVENTION STRATEGIES
INTRODUCTION:
The area of mathematics has a formative value aimed at the development of
skills and instrumental abilities that enhance and increase the
possibilities of knowledge, such as mental calculation, language, geometry, the
problem solving... These skills are acquired with the full development of the
mathematical competence, which is the ability to use and relate numbers,
its basic operations, the symbols and the forms of expression and reasoning
mathematician, both to produce and interpret different types of information, as
to broaden the understanding of quantitative and spatial aspects of reality, and
to solve problems related to everyday life, thus favoring the
effective participation in social life.
1. PROBLEM SOLVING
2
1.2. Historical view on problem solving
Since ancient times, guidelines have been attempted for teaching
resolution of any type of problem. Thus, the appearance of clay tablets,
documents and papyri of the main civilizations (Egyptian, Babylonian, etc.) us
and Clara knew that, at that time, they were trained in problem-solving.
On the other hand, we are aware of the emergence of schools, especially those of the great philosophers.
Athenians, where they were taught, among many other things, in problem-solving.
mathematicians.
In the 3rd century BC, Euclid of Alexandria recorded almost all knowledge.
mathematician of the time through propositions and demonstrations where it becomes evident
heuristic methods and techniques (deductive reasoning methods, inductive
reduction to absurdity...)
In the Middle Ages and in India, between the 5th and 7th centuries, a language develops.
symbolic. In the Middle Ages as well, in Europe, universities emerged where
They work on manuals already written in previous times in pursuit of resolution
practical problems.
In the Modern era, and especially during the Renaissance, thought resurges strongly
mathematical activity thanks to capitalism and the universalization of the system of
Hindu-Arabic numbering. The philosopher Descartes (16th century) believes he has discovered a
general method for solving any geometric problem and seeks to generalize
achieving all mathematical knowledge by seeking and dictating rules that allow for solving
and prove almost any problem or proposition.
Inspired by the ideas of Polya and Hadamard, psychologists such as Shalon or Kantowski,
among others, they will be developing and clarifying modern models and techniques
problem-solving heuristics.
3
1.3. Relevance and necessity of problem solving in the
Primary Education
Some authors have highlighted the role of problem-solving in the field of
mathematics in the following way:
In the last point, educational intervention, we will see how the resolution is addressed.
of problems in the E.P. curriculum. Finally, to say that problem solving
It is the learning of a process that is not studied for its application in the
mathematics, if not for its application in life, to learn strategies of
problem solving in real life.
They are a great tool for the development and assessment of key competencies.
4
2. DIFFERENT CLASSES AND METHODS OF RESOLUTION.
There are different types of problems in mathematics, just like different types of
reasoning to confront them. Among the most common types of problems in
primary we highlight:
5
. Reason or rate: There is a simple and direct proportion between the
quantities (A building has 3 floors, on each floor live 6
people. How many people live in the building?
. Multiplicative comparison: Two collections in which the greater
they have an exact number of times to the least. (I have 12 cards
and my brother has twice as many as I do. How many cards does he have?
Problems related to games and hobbies (with or without verbal statement). In its
development brings problems and mental exercises that favor the
application of mathematical knowledge, the search for strategies, stimulate
imagination and develop intelligence.
Individual or group games (cards, target shooting, skill, Bingos,
Board games, etc.
Logical-mathematical hobbies: cryptograms, magic squares,
enigmas, soups, etc.
6
2.1.2. Classification criteria for problems
7
2.2. Problem-solving models
For a substantial improvement in problem-solving, this activity must be
sequenced through a series of phases that mark the very diverse models of
resolution of existing problems.
J. Hadamard established more concise and revealing phases about the process that
It should continue to solve a problem. In summary, they are:
Schoenfeld Model: Analysis and understanding of the problem; Design and planning
the solution; Explore solutions; Verify the solutions.
Muller Model: Orientation; Preparation; Execution; Evaluation
Mason, Burton, and Stacey Method: It consists of three phases: Problem approach,
Attack (conjectures and justification) and Review of the above.
Polya's Model (in the next point we will explain it in depth)
They share many common characteristics in what we could call the phases.
general (problem introduction phase; exploratory phase; resolution phase of the
problem; and phase of problem review and conclusion.)
8
We must provide them with situations so they can practice in the
mental processes involved in problem solving.
2.4. Heuristics
Currently, 'heuristic' refers to the collection of mental operations that
we carry out when trying to solve a problem. Not exclusively operations
mathematics if not to all the convoluted ideas that circulate in the brain
when one wants to try to resolve a problematic situation. For example:
They are a collection of logical and mathematical techniques in which one of them may
to approach the solution or to get closer to a known algorithm. The knowledge of
heuristic techniques will expand the range of problems solved.
9
2.5. Difficulties in problem-solving. Heuristic guidelines.
in Polya's model.
In the realization model of a problem, conflicts and difficulties are created. It is
It is important that, when they appear, we can have a series of heuristic guidelines.
to be able to resolve them.
Heuristic techniques:
c. Start by solving a similar, easier problem
d. State the problem in a simpler way
e. Distinguish in the statement the data that are known, the data that are not.
but they are necessary and the values that will be the solution
f. Make diagrams, tables, drawings
g. Carry out experiments and examples of what is requested
h. Find the relationships between the data and solutions of the problem
i. Use an appropriate method of expression: verbal, algebraic, graphical...
j. Provide easier examples
If there are several ways to solve the problem, look for which one is the most
simple
10
1. Break down the problem into smaller problems (simplify)
m. Start from the end (consider the problem resolved)
11
2.6. Some classes and heuristic methods for solving
problems
Knowing and adding new techniques to those learned will provide the students with more.
possibilities for problem solving while increasing security and
self-esteem and stimulate the taste for mathematics. There are three groups of
fairly broad and well-defined heuristics that we can define as follows:
12
i. By trial and error by chance, when there is no clear idea of
where we can find the solution and it is tested at random
until I find her.
ii. By systematic trial and error, when our choice is limited to
the possible cases that can occur.
iii. By trial and error, when our choice always takes
consider the possible cases and the previous elections of such
so we are narrowing down and maximizing the possibility of
find the solution.
b. Analysis of possibilities, through which all possibilities are explored
open meeting of the solution based on the conditions of the
problem.
Other modes: Start the exercise from the end (reasoning the operations to the
opposite of how we would do it if we went from the beginning to the end - subtract in
sum place, for example-); look for a similar or easier problem; divide the
problem into sub-problems (this strategy will only succeed if the sub-
The problems we pose are simple and affordable for us.
13
3. PLANNING, MANAGEMENTDE THE RESOURCES
REPRESENTATION, INTERPRETATION AND VALUATION OF THE
RESULTS
Four aspects are associated with the development of problem-solving.
complementary. planning, resource management, representation and
interpretation and evaluation of the results. The four are related to each other,
with resolution methods and common heuristic techniques. We must
teach to work with these four guidelines as they define the process, which is
more important than the result.
3.1. Planning
Set of abilities associated with the understanding of the situation presented for
organize, outline a plan, seek strategies and make decisions. It can be broken down into
four blocks:
1) Analysis of the available information: need, relevance, superfluous data,
important, are there missing data?, partial reasoning about the data. We can
distinguish here two parts:
Reflections on the possibilities of available information: how does it
Can they be combined? What relationships are there between them? Operations.
possible?, with meaning?, etc.
Reflections on the relationships between data and questions (analysis)
means-ends): how can we respond to what the problem asks with the
Information that we know?
2) Organization of available information: schemes and diagrams with data and
unknowns (what is known – what is not known).
3) Exploration (Schoenfeld techniques): capabilities associated with examining cases
particulars, examine equivalent problems, modify the problem.
4) Conceive and structure a resolution plan: reason with part of the data or
with all the information, anticipate possible outcomes, test strategies or
heuristics (auxiliary problems, analogous problems, backwards problems, etc.).
3.3. Representation
The skills and abilities related to representation are:
1) In the understanding phase: comprehensive reading, represent through
diagrams, words, symbols, etc.
2) In the planning phase: schemes, diagrams, drawings, steps to follow,
organize and code (notation, language, figures, models, etc.).
3) In the execution phase: perform and write calculations and relationships and structure
steps and results.
4) In the evaluation phase: repeat the steps considering the solutions
found, reflect through a scheme of the process followed, use
other data and check if there are more results.
1) Verification of the response and the coherence of the entire process: is it logical the
complete history? Is the result compatible with the statement?
comparison of initial–final situation, substitute the result in the statement: is it
Is the story coherent? Etc.
2) Analysis of alternative procedures and results: Could it have been solved
In another way? Are there more solutions? etc.
3) Analysis of difficulties: Have there been blockages?, inconveniences and
solutions?
15
4. EDUCATIONAL INTERVENTION STRATEGIES
16
Let's now move on to the evaluation criteria and the learning standards.
We will always see each other together since the seconds stem from the firsts. The
we have in the following table
17
4.3. Intervention proposals
Motivate.
Work interchangeably on various models.
Reach the automation of the model. With analogical reasoning, not
through the continuous repetition of the model.
Through Res. Problems, they will be able to experience the potential and usefulness of
mathematics.
It constitutes one of the main axes and the main support of the activity.
mathematics in Primary.
In the Problems Resolution, many of the basic abilities are used: reading
comprehensive, reflection, work plan and possible modification, verification of
the solution and communication of the results.
Being a good problem solver will provide great benefits in the
daily life and at work.
The heuristics that should have the most weight in daily work with students
primary in the pursuit of problem-solving, are those previously mentioned, although
should be adapted to these ages in the following way:
18
systematizations in the search for regularities, the collection of data and the
reasoned downpour of conjectures about a problematic situation based on
experiments with known, simple, and concrete objects of life
daily and of the environment.
In the strategy of particularization, the method of testing must be worked on.
with concrete examples and the assimilation of the trial-and-error technique where the
students end up valuing the guided practice of it more than the
fortuitous.
In the analogy strategy, experimentation will be sought at all times.
of students with physical and graphic models in the early ages that will go
handing over the baton, as the students internalize them, to the models
more typical of formal logical reasoning. They will be given
physical experiences of the concepts of number and their main operations,
geometric figures in two and three dimensions with their characteristics
regularities and differences...
1st and 2nd year In this cycle, the differences between the courses are more tangible.
that in other cycles, during the first one, children are starting in the
development of reading comprehension skills through written texts.
In the second course, the level of development of these skills is very
advanced, which will allow for a greater variety of resolution types
problems. Students will be introduced to solving simple problems
of logical reasoning, insisting on the understanding of the statement,
solving them through small representations, games or experiences
simple. The work
3rd and 4th grade: We start from abilities that are already in the process of
acquisition, greater reading competence, more autonomy, development of
calculation skills, etc., thus the teaching will focus more on practice and
internalization of the problem-solving process emphasizing the
planning, asking the student to express in writing or orally, each
one of the steps that is being carried out, in a simple way.
5th and 6th grade: It means the end of the stage and gradually the students will have
internalized problem solving and will have to apply it to other situations,
being able to express mathematical reasoning, constructing their
own judgment, and evaluating the results obtained at the end of the process.
19
4.3.4. Role of the teaching staff in problem-solving
Group Zero (1984) determined the traits that characterize good problems.
(the problems that teach and with which heuristics techniques can be worked on).
These traits are:
It should be an optional aid in the event of possible blocks or consistent difficulties. It does not
must resolve issues or blockages that implicitly provide final guidelines in the
resolution of the problem, but rather must be limited to reflecting with them through
questions, similar problematic situations, about what they are
carrying out.
20
In summary, it is about providing you with a varied sample of problems.
with some solutions that indicate the way to go. Fundamentally, it is about
to put the student in a good disposition, to enjoy working on this
mathematics, which always puts all its attention on waiting for the unexpected, that
accustomed to working systematically, to organize their thoughts and them
speak and write, doubt even the obvious, question and verify
hypothesis, that verifies solutions, that generalizes results, that is proposed
new problems arising from those already solved.
CONCLUSION
Problem solving should not only be considered as procedural content,
but also how the context in which concepts and skills can be
learned, developing confidence in one's own abilities, helping to value
the usefulness of mathematical knowledge in real life.
But ultimately, the important thing about problem-solving is the process more than
the result, the ability to put a plan into practice and develop it more than the
management of concrete operations, and without a doubt, the ability to carry out these methods,
these processes to real life to solve the problems of everyday situations.
It is essentially to provide our students with the opportunity to adopt habits.
of appropriate thinking for the resolution of mathematical problems and not
mathematicians.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Legislation:
21
Authors:
- COLL, C. Psychology and curriculum. Laia. Barcelona, 1987 and Pedagogy Notebooks
GONZÁLEZ MARÍA, J.L. (2010). Resources for the mathematics classroom. Seville:
Alberque Group.
22