Statcom
Statcom
1 Introduction ....................................................................................................................................................... 3
5 Conclusions ...................................................................................................................................................... 39
Only the case of shunt compensation will be considered here, where the injected voltage is
connected to the system via a coupling inductance, which is usually the leakage reactance of the
coupling transformer. The connection is usually made at approximately the midpoint of the
transmission line but connection near the load is also possible. The converter used to generate
the voltage is a self-regulated inverter, where the dc bus voltage is controlled by introducing a
slight phase shift between the output voltage and the voltage at the point of common coupling
(PCC). This is most commonly referred to as a static compensator (STATCOM).
Iq
Vc
compensator
Iq
capacitive inductive
V V
1 1 2 2
V
q
Ic
compensator
V
q
inductive
Ic
capacitive
In the case of a STATCOM, the line reactance is typically the leakage reactance of the coupling
transformer and the load on the dc side is typically absent. The injected voltage is usually in
phase with the source voltage and the amount of reactive power injected or absorbed in
controlled by varying the magnitude of the voltage. In order to account for losses in the switches
and the transformer, a small phase shift is introduced in order to regulate the dc voltage. The
STATCOM topology and the associated phasor diagram can be used to understand the basis for
the control of the reactive current, iq (Fig. 1.3).
(a)
X
I1
Vs VI1
(b)
I1
VS
jX I1
VI1
(c)
Ih
hX
VIh
(d)
Fig. 1.2. Operation of a self commutated synchronous rectifier. (a) Schematic diagram
(b) Equivalent circuit for fundamental frequency operation. (c) Phasor diagram for
fundamental frequency operation. Leading power factor. (d) Equivalent circuit for
switching frequency components. Line reactance and synchronous reactance are
lumped.
(a)
I
Vs jXI
Vi
Leading var
Vs
I Vi jXI
Lagging var
(b) var
Fig. 1.3. Static compensator (STATCOM) based on the principle of synchronous voltage
sources. (a) Power circuit configuration based on a voltage source converter. (b)
Operation with leading and lagging var injection.
The steady-state operation of the STATCOM can be represented by the reactive injections as a
function of the reference voltage at the PCC. Each of the lines have a small slope, known as the
droop characteristic, whereby the reference voltage is slightly less at maximum leading reactive
current and slightly greater at maximum lagging reactive current. Typically, the variation in the
reference voltage is 3%.
Inverter
Icomp
In Imax
Capacitive Inductive
Slope
setting
Reference
Voltage + + + Converter
+ Error
Regulator gating
amplifier
- - + generator
Instant.
Positive Phase
reactive
sequence locked
current
calculator loop
calculator
Auxiliary control signals may be added along with the positive sequence component of the
voltage such as the deviation of the system frequency, Δf or the change in the power flow along
the line, ΔP, which can be used to help provide power oscillation damping [1],[4]. However, the
basic control scheme remains unchanged and the primary goal of voltage regulation already
These characteristics are inherently linked, resulting from the fast-acting nature of the
STATCOM and its ability to inject rated current even at deep voltage sags (unlike SVCs, whose
iq limits depend very strongly upon the voltage at the PCC). The goals of this study are to first
represent a three-level inverter based STATCOM in EMTP-RV and secondly, to demonstrate the
desirable characteristics that the STATCOM possesses by performing various systems studies.
The following sections present the design and representation of the STATCOM followed by
some simulation results which illustrate how the STATCOM can be used to aid in system
performance.
a
b
c
+
Fig. 2.2 EMTP-RV representation of the insulated gate bipolar transistor (a) IGBT model
(snubber 10 Ω, 0.1µF) (b) current limiting inductance connection to dc bus (resistance in
parallel with inductance).
a
b
neutral c
neg
Fig. 2.3 EMTP-RV model of a three phase, three-level voltage source inverter
Table 2.1: Switching logic and output voltages for a three level converter
SU1 SU2 SL1 SL2 Vout
0 0 1 1 -Vd/2
0 1 1 0 0
1 1 0 0 Vd/2
The PWM signals are produced using two triangular signals: starting from a conventional
triangular carrier, two different offsets of opposite sign are added to the triangular waveform to
give the required carriers. Then, the two new carrier signals are compared with the reference
voltage waveform and the output as well as its inverse are used for the various gating signals. In
order to deduce which outputs correspond to which gating signals one simply refers to Table 2.1.
The figures of the reference voltage, the triangular carrier and the desired output voltages are
given below (Fig. 2.4).
-0.5
-1
0.82 0.825 0.83 0.835 0.84 0.845 0.85 0.855
(a)
0.5
Van / Vdc
-0.5
0.82 0.825 0.83 0.835 0.84 0.845 0.85 0.855
(b)
1
0.5
Vab / Vdc
-0.5
-1
0.82 0.825 0.83 0.835 0.84 0.845 0.85 0.855
(c)
time (s)
Fig. 2.4 (a) Reference voltage with triangular carriers (b) three level output line to ground
voltage and (c) line to line voltage
The theory of the three level PWM generation is then reproduced in EMTP-RV using various
blocks from the control library. First the triangular signal is produced to which the various
offsets are added. Since EMTP does not possess a triangular waveform block one was created
using the desired switching frequency, fs, and combinations of various control blocks (Fig. 2.5).
The first f [u] block performs a simple calculation in order to extract the decimal component of fs
* t which is then limited between the range 0 and 1. In order to understand the idea, consider the
simple example of a switching frequency of 2 kHz and t = 17 ms. The output of the first f[u]
block becomes:
The output of the first block is then evaluated by the two f[u] blocks which follow, which are
simply linear functions as shown. The final component of the waveform generation is the
comparator signal which selects the linear waveform corresponding to the solid line in the figure.
In this way, a triangular waveform is synthesized which can be used for various types of
modulation used in the control of power electronics, including SPWM, dc chopper circuits, and
In order to utilize the triangular waveform for three phase modulation, offsets of 0.5 and -0.5 are
added to produce the two required modulating signals. Following the comparison of the new
triangular signals with the reference voltage, the gating signals are selected from the various
inputs. The entire representation of the three level modulation for one inverter leg is shown in
Fig. 2.6. Note that this block alone does not complete the modulation of the three level inverter
since it does not take into account the neutral point balancing problem.
0
su1
+ + 2 Compare
+ 1
0.5 Vtri
sl1
-0.5
c 0.5
su2
- 1 Compare
+ + 2
sl2
0
Vref
to -1
input
1
-
Fig. 2.6 Generation of three level PWM signals
There exist various algorithms for neutral point balancing including control of neutral point
connection [19], space-vector modulation techniques [18], and control of the negative sequence
power for higher level converters [11]. In this case, the neutral point connection time is
controlled since the PWM scheme is easily modified and the concept is relatively
straightforward. In order to understand the principle let us consider the case of how the neutral
Fig. 2.7 Neutral point connection and resulting change in capacitor voltages
In order counteract a neutral point potential unbalance, the neutral point connection of the phase
which will contribute further to the imbalance is omitted. This is done by utilizing traditional
two-level modulation for that phase only. Since neutral point unbalance does not occur with
large frequency for a 1% tolerance band and due to the fact that only one phase is modulated
using two level PWM, there is not a significant reduction in the effective switching frequency.
To summarize, the redefined modulation scheme, taking into account neutral point balancing
consists of the following:
(i) Identify whether neutral point unbalance exist by comparing the upper and lower
capacitor voltages,
(ii) If not, modulate according to three level theory presented above
(iii) If unbalance exists, first identify the phase current which will contribute further to the
unbalance
(iv) Modulate that phase using two-level modulation, the other two are modulated using
the three level theory.
This is method is realized continuously, therefore if the unbalance is eliminated or if the phase
current which contributes to the unbalance changes, the control responds accordingly. The
implementation of the balancing algorithm is shown in Fig. 2.8.
1
Vmid vdc
1
Compare Vmax_high
2 Has the upper or low
neutral point potential
c
0.01 -1 1
Compare Vmin_low been exceeded
2
detect 1% unbalance
ia 3
ib 2 MIN iph_charge Determine which phases
ic 1
are the neutral point
3
charging and discharging
2 MAX currents
1 iph_discharge
1
1
f(u)
iph_charge 2 +
Vmin_low + +
1
f(u)
2
iph_discharge Vmax_high 1
1
f(u)
+ sel1
iph_charge 2
Vmin_low sel2
1
+ + sel3 mid_select
f(u)
2
iph_discharge Vmax_high
1
1
f(u)
iph_charge 2 +
Vmin_low + +
1
f(u)
iph_discharge 2
Vmax_high
The STATCOM is controlled using measurements of the voltage on the high side of the
transformer and the line currents between the converter output and the transformer. In addition,
measurement of the voltages across the capacitors is required for neutral point balancing and dc
voltage regulation. The details of the control, the principles of which have been outlined in the
introduction, will be presented in the following section.
Sa
Sb
pos
Sc
+
#two_C#
v(t)
BUS1
a i(t)
a
neutral b
b
2
c
c
13.2/500
+
#two_C#
neg
+
0.02
+
20uH
Fig. 2.9 STATCOM representation in EMTP-RV with three level converter, control, dc
capacitors and coupling transformer.
i cos
cos 2
cos 2 i
i
2 3 3
a
3.1.4 Filtering
Each of the phase signals is filtered to extract the fundamental frequency component using a
band-pass filter which is tuned to fundamental frequency, 60Hz. The filter is a second-order
filter with the following transfer function:
The frequency response of the filter is plotted in order to illustrate the gain with frequency (Fig.
3.4). Modification of the response is possible, if desired, following filter design techniques as
outlined in various signal processing references, such as [23].
-5
Magnitude (dB)
-10
-15
-20
-25
w = 377 rad/s
-30
1 2 3 4
10 10 10 10
Frequency (rad/sec)
Fig. 3.3 Frequency response of bandpass filter used for filtering of fundamental
frequency component
I1 X
VPCC Vst
Then, assuming the angle, δ, between the two voltages is small allows us to re-write (3.3) and
(3.4) as follows:
V PCCVst
P (3.5)
X
One can then see how the reactive current can be controlled by simply adjusting the relative
voltage of the fundamental component of the Vst. In addition, this has shown that introducing a
phase shift between the two voltages allows real power to flow and thus can be used to regulate
the dc bus voltage (discussed later). Derivation of the state space model of the real and reactive
components of the current can then be used to determine the controller gains.
Where, R is the lumped losses, L is the leakage inductance, and ωo is the nominal system
frequency. Here the subscripts d and q denote the components in phase with and quadrature to
the VPCC space vector, respectively. Consequently, there is no quadrature component
Table 3.1 Parameters used in state space model and determination of transfer
function
R (pu) L (pu) ω0 (rad/s) VPCC (kV) Sbase (MVA)
0.675% 15% 377 13.2 425
Bode Diagram
Gm = -28.202 dB (at 0 rad/sec), Pm = -178.45 deg (at 1952.4 rad/sec)
60
40
Magnitude (dB)
20
-20
-40
180
135
Phase (deg)
90
45
0 2 3 4
10 10 10
Frequency (rad/sec)
Fig. 3.5 Bode plots of iq (s) / Vst,d (s)
K
G PI ( s) K p 1 I (3.7)
KPs
KI
a 1 (3.8)
K Pc
Typically a in (3.8) is chosen to be 0.1 or less. Following testing of the system, slight retuning of
the controllers or redefinition of the gain and phase margin may be required, to account for
model inaccuracies due to model uncertainties. The complete current control representation in
EMTP-RV is shown below in Fig. 3.6.
Vdc ( s) 3m 2 o LVdco
2 3 (3.9)
( s) CL s 2 RLCs 2 ( o 2 L2 C R 2 C 3m 2 L) s 3m 2 R
Where m is the modulation index (0.8), Vdco = 2.2 pu, is the nominal dc voltage, R is the lumped
losses, ωo is the nominal system frequency, and the remainder of the parameters are as presented
previously. The Bode plots can then be obtained for the open-loop system (Fig. 3.7). Similar
control techniques as presented in the previous section can be performed in order to obtain the
controller parameters.
Bode Diagram
Gm = -111.95 dB (at 800.57 rad/sec), Pm = -89.888 deg (at 17406 rad/sec)
150
Magnitude (dB)
100
50
-50
0
-45
Phase (deg)
-90
-135
-180
-225
-270 0 1 2 3 4 5
10 10 10 10 10 10
Frequency (rad/sec)
Fig. 3.7 Bode plots of ΔVdc (s) / Δδ(s)
1.03 pu
1.0 pu
0.97 pu
Icomp
Iqmax
Capacitive Inductive
Fig. 3.8 Droop characteristic for a set-point voltage of 1.0 pu and 3% slope
The line current is plotted for the same operating conditions along with the modulating voltage
(Fig. 4.2). As can be noted in the figure, the modulation index varies between approximately 0.6
and 0.9. This is desirable because the converter operates within the linear range and the
modulation index does not drop below 0.5 and therefore, the harmonic content is acceptable over
the entire range of operation.
0.5
iq, iqref (pu)
-0.5
-1
-1.5
0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2
time (s)
Fig. 4.1 Response of the reactive current iq to step changes in the reference current
1
ia (pu)
-1
-2
0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2
time (s)
1
vmod phase a (pu)
0.5
-0.5
-1
0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2
time (s)
Fig. 4.2 Line current and modulating voltage for the step changes in reactive current
(0.6<ma< 0.9)
1.1
1.05
Vdc (pu)
0.95
0.9
0.5 1 1.5
time (s)
0.04
0.03
Vn (pu)
0.02
0.01
-0.01
0 0.005 0.01 0.015 0.02 0.025 0.03 0.035 0.04 0.045 0.05
time (s)
Fig. 4.3 Step change in dc bus voltage, neutral point potential kept within bounds of 1%,
Vn set to 5% initially
The STATCOM is subjected to a 7.5% change in the dc voltage reference. The control responds
nicely and adjusts the voltage accordingly and returns the voltage to its nominal value following
removal of the offset. Also, it can be noted that the neutral point balancing algorithm
successfully returns the neutral point potential of 5% to within ±1% of the dc voltage and it
remains within the limits thereafter.
40%
l1 l3
40%
l2 l4
The voltage regulation ability of the STATCOM is demonstrated in the following studies and
thus is not presented separately here.
No Statcom
1.04
Delta f only
1.02 Voltage
regulation
only
|V| (pu)
1
Both
0.98
0.96
0.94
1.6 1.8 2 2.2 2.4 2.6 2.8 3
time (s)
Fig. 4.5 Demonstration of power oscillation damping
1
|V| (pu)
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.9 1 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5
time (s)
150
load angle (deg)
100
50
0
0.9 1 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5
time (s)
Fig. 4.6 Voltage and load angle response resulting from a 12 cycle three phase fault
without STATCOM
1
|V| (pu)
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
1 1.5 2 2.5 3
time (s)
80
load angle (deg)
60
40
20
0
1 1.5 2 2.5 3
time (s)
Fig. 4.7 Voltage and load angle response resulting from a 12 cycle three phase fault with
STATCOM rated at 0.5 Sbase
1.1
With STATCOM
1
0.9
0.8
|V| (pu)
Without STATCOM
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.9 1 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5
time (s)
Fig. 4.8 Magnitude of voltage with and without STATCOM
Within the rules section various parameters which are passed into the STATCOM subcircuit are
calculated using the STATCOM ratings. As well, the control parameters are defined within.
Normally they should be left unchanged but the user may want to make changes in certain cases.
droop_percent=droop/100
Vref_max=1+droop_percent
Vref_min=1-droop_percent
It is noticed that the changes to the transformer data are automatically transmitted to the transformer
appearing at the first subcircuit level of the STATCOM. The transformer has an Exported Mask. The
connection between the STATCOM mask and the transformer mask is achieved in the Rules section
through the function “set_converter_transfo”. The transformer is located using its specific name
“Converter_Transfo”. The user can modify the rules by adding other options, such as changing
transformer scope requests or transformer saturation data. Transformer data can be also changed
manually by first eliminating the call to “set_converter_transfo” (last line in the Rules section), then
clicking OK on the transformer device mask and subsequently canceling the Exported Mask status.
The user must remember that subcircuit content changes are automatically transmitted to all other
subcircuits of the same type unless the modified subcircuit is first made unique using the menu
Options>Part Type>Make Unique Type.
It is noticed that the last line in the Initial values section of this device is the function call:
make_me_unique();
This statement makes the top level subcircuit of the STATCOM unique as if the Make Unique Type
command has been applied manually. After clicking OK on the STATCOM mask the user can modify the
top level subcircuit contents, without affecting data for other SVC devices in the given design.
The make_me_unique function has two optional arguments:
do_mychildren: set to true if the Make Unique Type command must be applied all subcircuit
levels of this subcircuit. Default is false.
my_action_message: set to false to turn off the echo message in the Console window. Default is
true.
Control Parameters
For all PI control blocks the parameters are defined referring to the compensator structure:
K
G PI ( s) K p 1 I
KPs
Dc voltage regulator
Ki_dc =15;
Kp_dc =1;
K_dc =0.25;
Iq control parameters
Ki_iq=180;
Kp_iq=1;
K_iq=0.03162;
Ac voltage regulator
Ki_ac=10;
Kp_ac=1;
K_ac=3;
Δω damping constant
K_damp=0.01