Real Estate Price Statistics in
Oman
International Workshop on Short-term Statistics
18-20 May 2015
Beijing, China.
Hilal Al Harthi
                                                  1
         Outline
Real Estate Index Overview
Land Price Index
Construction Input Price Index
Results
Challenges
Conclusion
                                 2
Real Estate Price Index Overview
   A Proxy index combining of two separate indices:
   A. Land Price Index
      Measures the average price change of land plots
      in the country.
   B.    Construction Inputs Price Index
         Measures the change in average overall costs
         involved in construction
        Not follow the purchase prices for complete real
        estate units.
        Nor is it based on the re-sale of real estate units.
Real Estate Price Index Overview
      REPI measures the total costs involved in the
      developing residential real estate.
      This is probably still the most typical way of
      getting family housing in Oman.
      Each citizen has a right to own at least one
      residential plot.
A) Land Price Index
Concepts and scope
 Quarterly Indicator measures the average price
 changes of land plot around the country
 Actual selling prices on a sample of blocks
 or prices estimated by local real estate companies
 (in case of no transaction has been made during the
 month)
Sample & Data Source
 Oman divided into 10 regions       oo o
                                        oo
                                          o
 Al Wasta & Musandam were                oo o       ا
 excluded from the sample.                 o    ح
 1st stage: Selection of wilayat.
 2nd stage: selection of blocks
 (Blocks as Ministry of Housing
 definition)
                  SALALAHo
Sample & Data Source
                                         oo o
                                             oo
                                               o
Sample of 20 wilayats using (PPS)                        ا
                                              oo o
sampling     Transaction value                  o    ح
The frame     Ministry of Housing real
estate register
 Sample of 175 blocks using (PPS)
 sampling     No. of transaction
 The frame     Ministry of Housing
 real estate register
 100 estate agencies
A) Land Price Index weights
  The Index weighted based on total value transactions
  Figure 1. LPI Weights Structure
                                            Weight
                 Muscat
                Dhofar
   Ash- Sharqiyah North
  Ash- Sharqiyah South
          Ad-Dakhliyah
            Al Buraymi
       Al - BatinahNorth
      Al - Batinah South
         Adh - Dhahirah
                           0%   10%   20%       30%   40%   50%   60%   70%
LPI Questionnaire
The data collected during (Feb. , May, Aug. ,
Nov. ) and includes:
  Actual average price of actual selling transactions
  Estimated price based on knowledge of market
  prices
  Plot area in square meter
  Is the plot empty or built-on
  Number of transaction
                                                        9
B) Construction Input Price Index
    Concepts and scope
 o Quarterly Indicator measures the average
 price changes of construction sector inputs;
 materials, labor, plant & other costs.
 o This inputs is measured for different
 construction types; residential, non residential &
 infrastructure.
                                                      10
B) Construction Input Price Index
   Construction types
        1st satge was to determine the projects or the
        construction types:
        Using tender board data, building permits data ,
        discussion with construction companies and others
        sources
         Residential buildings
             Villas   low cost – medium cost - high cost
             Apartment buildings
         Non-residential buildings
             Commercial
             Non-commercial
         Other construction
             Transport infrastructure
             Networks                                       11
  Over-all structure
      The weight structure is identified individually for
      different types
      The CIPI is compiled separately for the two main
      types of construction (Building & Infrastructure)
Figure 2. CIPI overall Structure
                                                            12
Inputs structure and weights
    2nd stage: Building type level weights:
    Source: Sample of actual project BoQs from tender
    board analyzed by quantity surveyors:
o   Quantity surveyors task:
      Defined the inputs
      Highly detailed cost structure for all inputs
      Cost shares within each construction type
      Cost share matrix (Construction type, cost element)
       NCSI staffs defined the basket items by asking the
       building materials companies and other sources for
       the fast moving items
Construction inputs
Figure 3. CIPI Inputs
                        14
  Cost share matrix (Construction type, cost element)
  Figure 4. Cost share matrix (Weights)
                                                                     Commer     Combin                       Wareho                      Health   Health
                                           Low-    Medium Apart-                          Commer                       Govern- Educati
                                                                     cial       ed res ./                    us e &                      building building Mos qu
                                           cos t   cos t    ment                          -cial    Hotels              ment     on
                                                                     retail /   comm.                        indus tri                                     es
                                           villa   villa    building                      office                       office   building
                                                                     wholes a   building                     al                          (Hos pit (Health
                                             12.1%    33.4%   15.2%      3.9%       5.9%      5.9%    2.0%       2.0%      6.9%    6.9%     2.0%     2.0%     2.0%
Mate rials                                  56.9%    60.1%    58.9%    61.2%     60.9%    62.1%    62.9%      57.7%    63.6%    56.4%    64.0%    58.4%    61.0%
          1   Concrete and aggregates        12.5     12.8    10.5      4.7        9.1      7.1      7.3        9.9      8.4     14.1      7.7      8.6     10.3
          2   Precast Concrete Blocks         2.9      2.9     1.6      0.6        1.4      0.8      1.5        0.8      1.5      3.6      1.6      1.5      1.3
          3   Steel                          11.0      8.9    11.1     23.1       11.0      8.3      4.7       26.4      9.5      9.5      5.6      6.8     10.0
          4   Waterproofing                   6.8      4.1     2.0      0.6        1.1      1.3      0.7        1.9      1.3      3.0      2.2      2.6      6.4
          5   Timber                          3.0      5.7     6.2      2.0        7.1      3.1     10.6        1.7      4.0      5.9      3.2      7.7      5.1
          6   Doors and windows               5.7      4.0     3.3      1.4        5.5      6.3      2.3        3.1      4.3      2.4      1.3      2.2      0.8
          7   Finishes                        6.6      8.8    10.0      2.1        8.1      5.4      6.4        1.6      9.4      7.1      5.2      4.5      9.9
          8   Conveying system                 -        -       -       1.0        1.6      2.2      1.5         -       2.1       -       1.4       -        -
          9   Mechanical installations        3.1      3.0     4.5      2.8        4.9      2.8      3.7        2.1      1.7      1.6      6.9      4.7      0.9
         10   Sanitaryware                    0.4      0.6     1.0      0.2        0.8      0.7      3.1        0.0      0.8      0.6      1.1      2.6      0.1
         11   Building management system       -        -       -       1.1         -       0.4       -          -        -        -       1.7       -        -
         12   Air conditioning                0.8      6.7     3.5      8.3        5.0      8.8     10.5        4.7     10.1      2.4     10.9      7.1     12.1
         13   Electrical installations        3.9      2.7     5.4     13.5        5.4     14.8     10.5        5.4     10.6      6.3     15.1     10.2      4.0
Labor                                       25.2%    23.4%    24.4%    20.1%     22.2%    18.4%    20.7%      19.3%    20.5%    22.9%    20.1%    23.0%    22.7%
         1 Skilled                           20.8     19.1    20.0     17.0       18.7     14.9     16.9       15.8     16.8     18.3     16.6     18.6     18.5
         2 Semi Skilled                       0.3      0.5     0.6      0.6        0.4      0.6      1.0        0.6      0.5      0.6      0.5      0.9      0.3
         3 Unskilled                          4.1      3.8     3.7      2.6        3.1      2.9      2.8        2.8      3.1      4.1      3.0      3.4      3.9
Pla nt                                       6.7%     6.3%     6.1%     6.1%      6.4%     5.6%     5.1%      10.7%     5.1%     9.4%     4.7%     8.1%     6.0%
P1            Excavating & Earth Moving Equipments
                                              1.7       1.3      0.9     0.6        0.4      0.9      0.1        4.5      0.4      3.5      0.4      2.6      1.3
P2            Compacting Equipments           0.7       0.5      0.5     0.4        0.3      0.4      0.2        1.4      0.3      1.3      0.3      0.8      0.6
P3            Mixing Equipments               0.5       0.4      0.3     0.0        0.3      0.1      0.2        0.1      0.2      0.4      0.2      0.2      0.3
P4            Transporting Equipments         -         -        -       -          -        -        -          -        -        -        -        -        -
P5            Hoisting Equipments             2.3       2.4      2.2     2.9        2.7      2.8      2.3        3.1      2.7      2.4      2.3      2.5      1.8
P6            Other Equipments                1.5       1.6      2.2     2.1        2.7      1.3      2.3        1.7      1.6      1.8      1.5      2.0      2.1
Overheads a nd profits                      10.0%    10.0%    10.0%    10.0%     10.0%    10.0%    10.0%      10.0%    10.0%    10.0%    10.0%    10.0%    10.0%
O1            Construction costs             0.04     0.04    0.04     0.04       0.04     0.04     0.04       0.04     0.04     0.04     0.04     0.04     0.04
O2            Support                        0.05     0.05    0.05     0.05       0.05     0.05     0.05       0.05     0.05     0.05     0.05     0.05     0.05
O3            Miscellaneous                  0.01     0.01    0.01     0.01       0.01     0.01     0.01       0.01     0.01     0.01     0.01     0.01     0.01
                                                                                                                                                                     15
Cost share matrix (Construction type, cost element)
Figure 5. Cost share matrix (Weights)
                                                      16
Data Sources
    Building material
       Building materials wholesalers & retailers
    Wage and salary
       Construction companies
    Plant costs
       Rentals of vehicles and machinery
    Other measures
       Proxy measures for some parts of the index
o   125 items from 156 Outlets
o   Around 1500 price each quarter + labor data
o   Coverage: Whole Sultanate, Muscat the largest
    source with over 50% of sources
Dissemination
   LPI   Regional indices (The Sultanate, Muscat,
   Dhofar, …)
   CIPI   The Sultanate index by building types and
   Cost elements.
    Currently, they are presented within the NCSI only.
   Will be released in the monthly statistical bulletin.
   A quarterly real estate bulletin will provide more
   detailed data.
   NCSI website
RESULTS
          19
Figure 6. LPI for the Sultanate
                       Land Price Index _ The Sultanate
120.0
110.0
100.0
 90.0
 80.0
 70.0
 60.0
 50.0
 40.0
        Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4
           2008        2009        2010        2011        2012        2013        2014
                       (     را     () ب      ا   وا     د)ا   ا       ت ا ء#$د       % ا(ر' م ا
 Figure 7.             CIPI for Total Construction(Buildings&Infrastructure) by Cost Elements
      GEN ERAL CON STRU CTION
Cost Element                       W eight     Q2 2009 Q2 2010 Q2 2011 Q2 2012 Q2 2013 Q1 2014 Q2 2014 Q3 2014 Q4 2014
      Material                       54.1         98.4    101.4   103.27    98.76    96.93    95.86    95.72    94.35    93.79
M1    Concrete and aggregates        10.0         99.2     93.0    87.07   100.62   100.64   100.42   100.82   100.58   100.99
M2    Precast Concrete Blocks         2.5         99.7     87.6    85.73    99.26   100.73   100.74    99.80   100.05   100.55
M3    Steel                           7.8         97.7    124.8   132.38    99.71    88.20    83.29    81.76    77.75    76.20
M4    W aterproofing                  2.2         99.3    114.0   106.62    99.76    99.85   106.78   105.05   104.33   103.93
M5    Timber                          3.5         95.7     90.1    95.90   101.37   100.27   101.34    99.53   100.52   100.08
M6    Doors and windows               2.5        100.4    101.4    97.61    95.72    95.52    95.98    92.06    91.90    91.17
M7    Finishes                        4.9        100.4    101.1   105.11    98.33    99.04   103.73   103.41    99.69    99.57
M8    Conveying system                0.3        100.0    106.0   107.78   100.17   100.17   100.57   104.23   102.71   102.71
M9    Mechanical installations        2.7         90.5     88.0    91.58    92.71    91.83    92.49    92.75    91.83    89.42
M10   Sanitaryware                    0.4         99.0     98.1    98.48   101.01   100.00   104.41   101.08   101.00   100.69
M11   Building management system      0.1         98.3    104.0   112.05      -        -        -        -        -        -
M12   Air conditioning                3.4        100.0    105.3   104.51   102.27    98.56    94.15   101.80    93.32    93.05
M13   Electrical installations        4.9         96.2    106.4   115.57    93.74    92.12    89.60    86.30    85.87    87.65
M14   Infrastructure materials        8.9         99.7     95.6    99.76    99.31   100.58    96.42    98.08    99.09    96.83
      PLAN T                         14.1         99.2     95.8   108.00   100.01    96.93   103.34   104.05   105.05   100.51
      LABOU R                        19.9         99.9    101.3   110.17    98.99   100.79   123.22   123.22   124.50   124.50
      OVERH EAD                      11.9        100.0    101.7   104.65    99.14    87.95    87.86    88.31    88.42    88.49
      TOTAL IN DEX                     100.0      99.0    100.6   105.48    99.03    96.63   101.40   101.48   101.14   100.21
                                                                                                                                 21
Figure 8.   CIPI for Total Construction(Buildings&Infrastructure) by Cost Elements
                                                                                     22
                                         را      ب         ا    ت ا ء#$د      % ا(ر' م ا
                       Figure 9.         CIPI for Infrastructure by Cost Elements
       IN FRASTRU CT U RE
Cost Element                        W eight         Q2 2009 Q2 2010 Q2 2011 Q2 2012 Q2 2013 Q1 2014 Q2 2014 Q3 2014 Q4 2014
       M aterial                         45.1          98.8     98.1   101.10    98.92    98.79    96.55    97.17    97.23    96.22
M1     Concrete and aggregates                8.4      99.6     94.4    88.39      -        -        -        -        -        -
M2     Precast Concrete Blocks                3.0      97.1     81.8    80.27    98.87   100.78   102.70   101.33   101.33   102.70
M3     Steel                                  3.6      98.3    126.0   133.74    90.96    80.47    76.22    74.77    70.27    69.02
M4     W aterproofing                         0.4      99.9     96.4    96.92    89.66    89.15    88.10    88.10    88.11    87.96
M5     Timber                                 1.2      96.5     94.1    98.20   101.28    98.66   101.55    99.02   100.31   100.46
M6     Doors and windows                 0.00          0.00     0.00      -        -        -        -        -        -        -
M7     Finishes                               0.3      97.2     92.7    95.49   101.74    96.18   100.11    99.69   100.73   100.80
M8     Conveying system                  0.00          0.00     0.00      -        -        -        -        -        -        -
M9     Mechanical installations               1.9      97.7     98.2   105.55    99.61   103.68   102.81   103.76   102.28   101.05
M10    Sanitaryware                       -            -        -         -        -        -        -        -        -        -
M11    Building management system         -            -        -         -        -        -        -        -        -        -
M12    Air conditioning                   -            -        -         -        -        -        -        -        -        -
M13    Electrical installations               3.2      93.6    111.5   126.38    99.80    98.57    95.04    92.77    93.09    93.93
M 14   Infrastructure materials          23.1          99.7     95.6    99.76    99.31   100.58    96.42    98.08    99.09    96.83
       PLAN T                            25.8          99.6     95.8   109.73   100.27    96.88   102.55   103.31   105.90   101.96
       LABOU R                           14.1          99.9    100.7   110.37    98.96   101.08   124.60   124.60   124.75   124.75
       OVERH EAD                         15.0         100.0    101.5   104.22    99.18    88.77    88.71    89.10    89.20    89.27
       TOTAL IN DEX                     100.0          99.3     98.4   105.10    99.31    97.12   100.88   101.41   102.14   100.68
                                                                                                                                      23
Figure 10. CIPI for Infrastructure by Cost Elements
                                                      24
Challenges
o   LPI:
     - Some times we have few available prices
    estimated prices based on agent knowledge
     - large differences in prices within a block due to plot
    location (corner, near the main road, …), other factors
    we ask for a typical type of plot
o   CIPI :
     - Labor data (response rate, …)
                                                                25
Conclusion
The real estate Index is an experimental indicator that
combines the two indices (LPI & CIPI)
The aim is to summarize the two different sources of
inflation in real estate, the asset (LPI) & physical
construction cost (CIPI)
Our Plan: other indices:
   for new houses (in practice normally dwellings)
   for existing constructions (re-sale price for existing
   dwellings)
                                                            26
Thank you
            27