How To Write - Legal Writing Guide
How To Write - Legal Writing Guide
com
Legal Writing
Guide
by
Copyright
This document is subject to copyright. You are not allowed to distribute this document electronically, email it, load it on your
website, or circulate it. You may not alter or edit it in any way, nor may you claim it as your own work or charge for it.
Liability disclaimer
The material contained in this document is general and is not intended as advice on any particular matter, whether it be
business, academic, or legal. The author expressly disclaims all and any liability to any persons whatsoever in respect of
anything done by any such person in reliance, whether in whole or in part, on this publication. Please take appropriate advice
before acting on any information in this document.
Writing Rules
"Writing in plain language is just writing in clear, straightforward language. There are
no hard-and-fast rules. There are no international standards or infallible tests. The
main thing to remember is that if what you have written could be unclear or confusing
for your reader, you should rewrite it so that it becomes clear and unambiguous".
Avoid legal jargon – those archaic words and expressions for which modern English words
can be substituted or which can be left out altogether; for example, "hereinafter","hereunto".
Use terms of art, however, which are short accurate expressions of complex legal ideas like
"tenants-in-common", "fee simple", "consideration".
Avoid foreign words like "sui juris". We have an alternative – "with legal capacity".
Use a single word rather that a circumlocutory phrase. Use "under" rather than "under the
provisions of".
If a word that has no substantive meaning can be left out entirely, do so.
Use words in the order in which they would be used in everyday speech:
Avoid Use
the lender so far as it has the power so the lender, so far as it has the power
to do [to do so]
without the consent in writing of the without first obtaining the written
lender first had and obtained consent of the lender
State matters positively as positive statements are easier to understand than negative ones:
Avoid Use
the Secretary may not register shares the Secretary may only register
without the consent of the Director shares with the consent of the
Director
regulations not consistent with the Act regulations inconsistent with the Act
Avoid Use
A and B hold as joint tenants and not A and B hold as joint tenants
as tenants in common
Avoid Use
"In-house asset" shall have the "In-house asset" has the meaning
meaning given to it in Regulation 16A given to it in Regulation 16A of the
of the Superannuation Regulations Superannuation Regulations
Use the present tense where you are providing for an existing situation and for the
consequences of some future event:
Avoid Use
Use active rather than passive voice as it is easier to read, simpler and more concise. It is
also precise because it makes clear who does what. If you use passive voice, you can have
a grammatical sentence but one which does not impose an obligation on anyone.
Avoid Use
shares may be issued by the directors the directors may issue shares
if the obligations under clause 12 are if the seller does not perform his
not performed on or by the Completion obligations under clause 12 on or by
Date the completion Date
Do not use false provisos. The formulae "Provided", "Provided that" or "Provided always" are
generally wrongly used to state an exception or qualification, to introduce the several stages
of consecutive operation or to introduce an inconsistency.
Instead:
Avoid use
the Lender may demand payment of the Lender may demand payment of
the loan PROVIDED THAT it may not the loan but it may not do so unless
do so unless the Borrower has failed to the Borrower has failed to make an
make an interest payment interest payment
(b) use a full stop and start a new sentence omitting the proviso:
Avoid Use
all such monies, costs, expenses, all such money, costs, expenses,
outgoings and liabilities shall be added outgoings and liabilities which shall be
to and form part of the principal sum limited to reasonable amounts
and be repayable accordingly reasonably incurred by the
PROVIDED THAT such moneys, Mortgagee, shall form part of the
costs, expenses, outgoings and principal sum and be repayable
liabilities shall be limited to reasonable accordingly.
amounts reasonably incurred by the
Mortgagee.
(d) use "and" instead of the proviso if the ideas being expressed are conjunctive.
(e) if the ideas being expressed are alternatives, divide them into separate clauses or
paragraphs joined by "or" or "and" simply subdivide the text into separate clauses
without any connectives:
Avoid Use
the Trustee may distribute funds the Trustee may distribute funds if:
PROVIDED THAT it has a surplus of
(a) it has a surplus of funds; and
funds and PROVIDED THAT the
(b) the beneficiaries are over 21;
beneficiaries are over 21 and
and
FURTHER PROVIDED THAT no loans
(c) no loans to beneficiaries are
to beneficiaries are outstanding
outstanding
Be precise in your choice of words and do not rely on context to resolve ambiguities:
Avoid Use
Choose words which have only one meaning or if words have more than one meaning make it
clear which meaning you intend:
Do not use "he", "she", "him", "her", "his", "hers", "its", "they", "their", "it" unless there is no
confusion about which party is being referred to:
Avoid Use
the Tenant and the Landlord agree that The Tenant and the Landlord agree
he will make all structural repairs that the Tenant will make all structural
repairs
"This" is ambiguous. It can refer to an idea or thing, one word or a whole sentence. Make
sure the reader always knows what "this" means. If in doubt, add the appropriate noun: "this
clause", "this document", "this reasoning".
Avoid general references such as to the appointment of a director "under this Deed" if there is
more than one mechanism for appointment.
Avoid Use
the defendant refused to service the with good reason the defendant
belonging to the man who had insulted refused to service the car belonging
him with good reason to the man who had insulted him
Use tabulation where there are a number of references to which a qualification could relate:
Avoid Use
Use precise transitions such as "if … then" but make sure they are complete.
Use the same word or expression for the same concept throughout the document. The reader
will know immediately that you mean the same thing. If you refer to "the contract", do not later
refer to it as "the document", "the agreement" or "the instrument"; if you refer to "a proposal",
do not later refer to it as "a suggestion".
Use "must" or "must not" (rather than "shall" and "shall not") to impose a positive or negative
obligation. Use "may" or "may not" when conferring or limiting a right, power or privilege.
Legislation traditionally treats "shall" as establishing a requirement. However, in other
contexts "shall" is read as meaning either "must" or "may" and is therefore ambiguous.
Avoid Use
Notice of appeal shall be lodged within the party may appeal by lodging
14 days notice of appeal within 14 days
There words are rarely seen outside legal documents; they can either be replaced by more
usual words like "the", "that" or "those", or left out entirely.
Use these words sparingly. Reserve them for emphasis only. In most cases, the words "a" or
"an" can be substituted for "any" and "each":
Avoid Use
if the tenant commits any breach of the If the tenant commits a breach of the
Lease Lease
The word "all" can in most cases be deleted without changing the meaning:
avoid use
Where it is necessary to use the future tense, use "will" not "shall" unless the documents
speaks in the first person:
Avoid Use
the Developer agrees that it shall the Developer agrees that it will
convene monthly meetings of the convene monthly meetings of the
Development Control Group Development Control Group
"either X or Y or both"
"either X or Y but not both"
"any one of"
"any combination of"
"both of"
"all of"
(b) tabulation:
where the seller terminates the where the seller terminates the
contract, the seller may forfeit the contract, the seller may forfeit
deposit and keep all the instalments the deposit and:
paid or sue for damages (a) keep all the instalments paid; or
(b) sue for damages
Never use "and/or" as it is ambiguous. It forces the reader to consider all the alternative
meanings and to guess which one was intended. It is also difficult to read and can lead to
absurdity.
avoid use
the Bank may require the Company the Bank may require the Company or
and/or the shareholders to provide it the shareholders or both to provide it
with security with security
the vendor may sell and/or retain the the vendor may sell the property or
property the vendor may retain the property
Use a singular legal subject whenever possible to avoid both ambiguity and the inadvertent
creation of joint rights or obligations:
Avoid Use
the parties may terminate this a party may terminate this agreement
agreement by 3 weeks’ notice in by giving to the other 3 weeks’ notice
writing in writing
the directors must disclose their a director must disclose any interest
interests in shares, debentures and in shares, debentures and contracts
contracts
the directors may delegate their the directors may delegate any of
powers to committees consisting of their powers to a committee or
such of their number as they think fit committees consisting of such of their
number as they think fit
If you use the plural, make it clear whether the obligations imposed are joint or several or both:
Avoid Use
A and B agree with C that they will on A and B jointly and severally agree
1 April 1993 pay to C the sum of $5 with C that they or one of them will on
Our language does not cope very well with the fact that both men and women participate in
society; our language does not make it easy to refer to both male and female genders
together.
To avoid using the alternative form "his or her", try these methods to be gender-neutral in
your writing:
Avoid Use
the Trustee may pay the amount at his the Trustee may pay the amount at
or her discretion the Trustee's discretion
Avoid Use
Avoid Use
draftsman drafter
authoress author
poetess poet
Avoid Use
the applicant should fill in the applicants should fill in the document
document using his or her own using their own handwriting
handwriting
Avoid Use
the applicant should fill in the you should fill in the document using
document using his or her own
21. Spelling
Use the Macquarie Dictionary to check any spellings of which you are unsure.
You must renew your driving licence annually; you will then be licensed to
driven a car.
You must renew your practising certificate annually; you will then be entitled to
practise as a solicitor in private practice.
(d) effect (noun or verb) with affect (noun or verb). Effect used as a noun means a result
or consequence:
Affect used as a noun means a feeling or emotion; used as a verb it means either to
influence, act on or produce a change in:
Avoid Use
Take particular care with the spelling of clients' and parties' names.
Use short sentences (preferably no longer than 3 lines) and tabulation to aid clarity. Break
up long sentences into separate clauses and tabulate into paragraphs within clauses.
Clauses and sub-clauses are whole sentences; paragraphs and sub-paragraphs are items
in a list within a sentence. Begin a new clause when you want to cover a new topic. Use
tabulation to help the reader see immediately the structure of a list.
The statement 'If either trustee is at any time unable to act by reason of death,
disability or absence from the country, the other shall act alone' would be
construed as excluding the resignation of a trustee.
If it is necessary to enumerate particulars, use the expressions 'including but not limited to' or
'including without limitation':
General words which follow specific words will be construed in accordance with ejusdem
generis rule to be limited to the same class or category as those preceding specific words:
or
another [general word] whether of the same kind as those previously listed or
not.
Be careful with associated words. Where two words or expressions are placed together, one
normally including the other, the general is then presumed not to include the particular:
If reference is first made to 'land and buildings' and then to 'land' the word
'land' by itself does not include buildings.
Conversely, if two ideas are associated in a way that indicates the first is included in
the second a further reference to the second will by implication include the first:
If reference is first made to 'gold and other minerals' and then to 'minerals' the
word 'minerals' includes gold.
Use the following system of numbering and lettering except where there is a reason to depart
from it:
(b) paragraph.
3. Heading
3.2 Sub-clause:
(a) paragraph;
(b) paragraph; or
(c) paragraph:
(i) sub-paragraph:
(A) sub-sub-paragraph; or
(ii) sub-paragraph;
Example:
The introductory words of a clause or sub-clause, before a series of paragraphs, end with a
colon(:).
24.3 Paragraphs
Each paragraph starts with a lower case letter and ends with a semicolon(;).
An 'and' or 'or' appears at the end of the second last paragraph in a list depending on whether
the paragraphs are cumulative or alternatives.
Words in each paragraph must be consistent with the introductory and resuming words of the
clause or sub-clause.
25. Cross-References
Make any cross-references as specific as possible. If clause 10 can only affect clauses 30
and 31, make clauses 30 and 31 'subject to' clause 10 or rewrite clause 10 to refer to
clauses 30 and 31. However, in some cases, you may want or need to use 'blanket'
provisions such as 'subject to this deed' or 'despite any other provision to the contrary'. Use
these carefully as they may allow unintended interpretations of the document. You may find
it an aid to clarity to put references to clauses and schedules in bold type (which can be
removed in the final version).
Avoid Use
if the landlord serves a notice under if the landlord serves a notice under
sub-paragraph (iv) of paragraph (c) of clause 23.1(c)(iv)
sub-clause 1 of clause 23
26. Headings
Use headings to indicate the content of each clause. Headings should be short and should
describe but not summarise the provisions to which they relate. State in the interpretation
clause that headings are for reference only and do not form an integral part of the document.
27. Punctuation
Use punctuation consistently and correctly to make the document easier to read. However,
the meaning should be clear even if the test is unpunctuated.
A full stop is used to mark the end of a sentence that is a statement or command, or after a
sentence containing an indirect question:
In acronyms and abbreviated names of widely known organisations full stops may be omitted:
AMA MDU
Three spaced stops are used to show that words have been omitted from a quoted passage:
'every juror … must before being empanelled … make and subscribe … an oath
of allegiance'.
If the ellipsis comes at the end of a sentence, it should be followed by the punctuation
normally required.
Will you please sign the contract where indicated and return it to us.
Commas separate clauses, phrases and words in sentences, in order to direct the reader to
their correct relationship. They indicate necessary pauses for breath and control the fall of
emphasis in the sentence. The modern tendency is to use no more commas than is essential
for clarity.
Use a comma to separate long coordinate clauses joined by 'and', 'but', 'for', 'or', 'nor' or 'yet':
They feel more and more the heavy burden of steadily advancing years, and
would like to find a smaller house.
I haven't looked into the matter and I don't intend to. Your firm may act for such
clients but ours would not.
When enumerating items in a sentence, use commas to separate all but the last:
A comma is needed to separate introductory clauses or phrases from the main clause in the
sentence:
As it is so long since you visited us, I think you should stay overnight.
A comma is not needed when the introductory phrase is very short and no misreading is
possible:
Within seconds you will have the remainder of the documents by facsimile.
Adverbial clauses following the main clauses are not normally set off by a comma:
Compare: Having said that I will not refer to the matter again.
Compare: The communists say the coalition parties are likely to win the next
election.
The communists, say the coalition parties, are likely to win the next
election.
Commas should be used to mark off direct quotations and to separate clauses or phrases that
come between the subject and the verb, or to make expressions that function as 'asides':
Mary Smith, the well-known writer, was also included in the New Years Honours
List.
The semicolon separates parts of a sentence that require a stronger break than that marked
by the comma but are too closely related to be broken into separate sentences:
The company will not fail; it will continue regardless of the bankruptcy of two of
its directors.
Judgment has been given in the negative; thus, we shall have to reform our
habitual practice in the matter.
Your survey confirms the need for rented computer services; we disagree,
however, that our client lacks the flexibility to provide such service.
A semicolon is used to separate more clearly phrases that are already punctuated with
commas:
A semicolon is used to separate parallel clauses where the connecting conjunction is omitted:
To be poor and not complain is difficult; to be rich and not complain is easy.
Use single quotation marks (' ') to enclose the exact words of a writer or speaker, whether or
not these form a complete sentence. Double quotation marks (" ") are only used for a
quotation within a quotation:
I refer you to what the biographer of Mme Curie calls 'this entrancing story of
her strange experience in Poland under Russian Tsar, "born in servitude and
chained in our cradles"; of gay dancing days and sleigh rides; of secret society
Our client's message read, 'Please ignore the wording "No correspondence will
be entered into" in the terms and conditions of the Beauty Contest.'
However, quotation marks may be used to distinguish one or more words to show that
they are given exactly as in the source:
The 1924 Act provides that is the 'duty' of every elector to record his vote at
each election.
Use single quotation marks to set off colloquial words, words use facetiously, nicknames,
slang, coined expressions and technical words when you wish to draw attention to their
technical usage:
Enclose in quotation marks the titles of articles, essays, chapters and sections of books.
(Titles of whole books and separately published monographs should be in italics):
At the end of a quotation, put comma or stop inside the quotation mark, a semicolon or colon
outside the quotation mark and an exclamation point or question mark inside or outside,
depending on whether it is your punctuation (outside) or part of the original passage quote
(inside):
When I say 'We know,' that is how I understand the evidence; you may view it
differently.
When a quotation is broken by 'he said' or a similar expression, the interruption is normally
preceded and followed by a comma. The punctuation should always, however, be kept as
close as possible to the original. If the original contained a colon, semicolon or a dash at the
break point, that punctuation is retained within the quotation mark; but where the original had
a full stop it is replaced with a comma and the full stop moved to the end of the interruption. A
capital letter then follows after the next quotation mark:
'The Governor shall appoint a Board of three persons,' reads the Scotish Act,
'the Registrar of Companies or his deputy to be the Registrar of the Board.'
If the matter is quoted, it should be reproduced exactly even if it contains errors. Insert 'sic'
or editorial comments within square brackets:
'The child's essay began: 'My family lives in London but we used to live in
Milton Kaynes [sic] which is much smaller.'
The colon marks a pause or degree of separation somewhat shorter than that marked by a
full stop.
A colon directs attention to the statement that follows it. It is a strong mark of punctuation and
signals that everything that follows is an amplification, elaboration or itemisation of the
statement that goes before:
Our client stocks all sizes: small, medium, large and extra large.
This is the company's plan: to open a new factory in Alice Springs and save
the cost of transporting goods to the outback.
its belong to it
yours belonging to you
theirs belonging to them
whose belonging to whom
ours belonging to us
hers belonging to her
it's it is
you're you are
If a word is already plural – e.g. men, children – the apostrophe precedes the final 's': e.g.
men's shoes, children's playground; but if the word already ends in 's the apostrophe follows:
e.g. employees' pensions, boys' gymnasium, the Smith' departure for Europe.
Words in the singular, including names, that end in 's' should normally be written with an
apostrophe 's' in the possessive case:
St Mark's Church
Miss Simple's curriculum vitae
In the case of certain ancient classical names and of names ending in 'ses', 'sus', the final 's'
is commonly omitted. Thus:
Where the sense of the noun is adjectival rather than possessive (i.e. where the
expression might be replaced by a 'for' phrase) no punctuation is required:
a boys high school; the Teachers Training College; visitors book; National
Aborigines Week; owners manual.
There is an increasing use of the apostrophe for names of cities and countries and
institutions:
Hyphens have a variety of uses in joining words or parts of speech to form compound
expressions.
As a general rule, compounds should only be hyphenated when the combination alters
the meaning of any part. If in doubt, consult the dictionary.
son-in-law; Vice-captain
When these expressions are reversed and no noun follows, the hyphen usually disappears:
Avoid the 'suspension hyphen' unless it is impossible to express the idea in any other way:
Hyphenate compound numbers from twenty-one to ninety-nine and all fractions. No more
than one hyphen should be used in expressing a fraction.
forty-six participants
four twenty-fifths
three hundred and twenty-four dollars
ninety-nine hundredths
twenty-four sixty-eights
A dash, like a colon, is a strong mark of punctuation. It may signal several different intentions
and should therefore be used sparingly in legal writing, but it can be used to add colour and
emphasis.
What we meant was – buy why rake over old coals? – that you should have
insured against fire.
The Land Rovers – I am reluctant to admit that there were three of them – all
came round the bend on the wrong side.
For emphasis or clarity, use dashes instead of commas to set off explanatory phrases,
summary statements and rhetorical repetitions; especially when the summary is introduced by
all of these:
The strike will have serious effects for everyone – effects upon transport
workers, upon service employees, upon employment in related trades.
New products, new markets, new jobs, increased leisure – these acts are the
promises of the electronic revolution.
Curved brackets may be used in the same places as dashes. They give the expressions
within them the effect of 'asides' or how-voiced explanations. Punctuation marks follow them
just as they would have followed in the sentence without the parentheses:
There was no book of account (except the stock journal, to which I will refer
presently) showing the quantity or value of the cotton in the mill at any one
time.
They can improve the quality of our existing services (this statement is
especially true for smaller banks).
39. Brackets [ ]
Square brackets are used by a writer to enclose his own corrections or explanatory remarks in
a quoted passage:
Said Mr Griswold, 'They [the Banks] just don't have enough work to keep their
machines busy 24 hours a day'.
They may also contain an omitted word or the correct spelling of a misspelt word.
They are also used in the citation of cases where the year indicates the volume.
They should be used with [sic] indicating an error in a quotation not the responsibility of the
transcriber.
40. Definitions
(b) ambiguity caused by using different words or expressions throughout the document
for the same person or thing.
Do not define words or expressions that are used with their ordinary meaning and do not
define terms that occur only once or infrequently in a document.
In a long document you should begin the definitions clause by stating that 'In this
Agreement/Deed unless otherwise indicated by the context:'
Avoid Use
Avoid Use
41. Capitals
Use capital letters sparingly. Do not capitalise common words such as bill, departmental,
judgment, solicitor, seller, lender, statutory, ministerial, government, parliament, federal, law,
regulation, by-law, clause, paragraph, section, page.
(f) Days of the week, months of the year, ceremonies and historical periods:
Monday, March, Easter, Anzac Day, the Vietnam War;
Major headings should be set entirely in capitals. For other headings, capitalise the first
letter of the word and then only the words which would be capitalised in the text:
Avoid Use
(2) A particular document is being specifically referred to: 'Please sign both
copies of the Lease where indicated and return the copies to us.'
(b) Parties unless they have been defined: the company, the seller, purchase, vendor,
the vendor's solicitor.
42. Abbreviations
Use abbreviations sparingly but correctly. Abbreviations are more frequently used in
catalogues, business forms and technical writing than in ordinary business correspondence
and reports. For the correct form of an abbreviation, consult your dictionary.
Other, less common abbreviations may be used provided they are known to the reader or are
initially defined for him:
Avoid Use
2
10 square metres/sqm 10m
Avoid Use
Use figures when you are referring to a part of a document which is itself identified by a
number:
Avoid Use
Clause five Clause 5
43.7 Fractions
Avoid Use
1/4 0.25
14 3/4 14.75
43.8 Years and spans of years
Avoid Use
1980-88; 1980-8 1980-1988
The 80's; eighties The 1980s
The 18th century The eighteenth century
43.9 Dates
The matter was set down for hearing on 1 April 1993 but was settled on the
14th.
The borrower must pay the mortgage on the tenth day of each month.