Chapter 1 Introduction
Chapter 1 Introduction
INTRODUCTION
The European Union defined CSR as ―The voluntary integration of companies’ social
and ecological concerns into their business activities and their relationships with their
stakeholders. Being socially responsible means not only fully satisfying the applicable
legal obligations but also going beyond and investing more’ in human capital, the
environment, and stakeholder relations.
1
account the expectations of stakeholders; complies with current laws and is consistent
with international standards of behavior; and is integrated throughout the organization
and implemented in its relations.‖
Philip Kotler and Nancy Lee (2005) define CSR as ―a commitment to improve
community well being through discretionary business practices and contributions of
corporate resources‖ whereas Mallen Baker refers to CSR as ―a way companies manage
the business processes to produce an overall positive impact on society.‖
Archie Carroll in 1991 describes CSR as a multi layered concept that can be
differentiated into four interrelated aspects – economic, legal, ethical and philanthropic
responsibilities (Carroll, A. B., 1991). Carroll presents these different responsibilities as
consecutive layers within a pyramid, such that ―true‖ social responsibility requires the
meeting of all four levels consecutively. The model probably is the most accepted and
established.
Howard Bowen, often regarded as the father of CSR, has defined corporate social
responsibility as the obligations of businessmen to pursue those policies, to make those
decisions, or to follow those lines of action which are desirable in terms of the objectives
and values of our society (Bowen, 1953). Bowen is one of the earliest writers to have
defined CSR.
2
The term was coined first in 1953. In his publication named Social Responsibilities of the
Businessman, American economist Howard Bowen coined the term and he is often
referred as the father of CSR (Chatterjee, A., & Mitra, N., 2018) .
In India, there are sufficient anecdotal facts available giving us sense about how corporate
groups were engaged in building universities, hospitals etc. During the freedom struggle,
they have played a crucial role in funding the freedom movement. Mahatma Gandhi,
father of the nation was closely associated with several businessmen cum philanthropists.
But, most of the donations were going through religious institutions with the purpose of
helping the dispossessed. On the international front, philanthropic activities by
industrialists can be traced back to the Industrial Revolution. By the mid-to-late 1800s,
there were growing concerns regarding workers’ wellbeing. Many reformers were raising
the issues of the emerging factory system, working conditions and condition of labourers.
Whether connected or not but this was the time when the rise of philanthropy can also be
traced. One industrialist named Andrew Carnegie donated large portions of his wealth to
causes related to education and scientific research. He had made most of his fortune in
the steel industry. Many other industrialists followed his footsteps. Like John D.
Rockefeller, who is widely considered the wealthiest American of all time, and the richest
person in modern history, donated more than half a billion dollars to religious,
educational, and scientific purposes. He had made his fortune in the oil industry.
But it was all informal. It was American economist Howard Bowen who gave it a clear
identity. However, a question remains unanswered: how does the term get accepted in the
whole world? After the effort of Howard Bowen, there was a sort of lull period for the
next few decades. But in1990s, many other economists focused on it. In 1991, University
of Pittsburgh professor Donna J. Wood published Corporate Social Performance
Revisited. He expanded and improved on early CSR models by providing a framework
for assessing the impacts and outcomes of CSR programs.
In the same year, another professor at the University of Georgia Archie B. Carroll
published an article named The Pyramid of Corporate Social Responsibility. Since then,
the term CSR has become an essential strategy for many organizations. India moved
3
ahead and brought a legal framework to ensure big corporates don’t forget their social
responsibilities.
• The net worth of the company should be Rupees 500 crores or more
• The annual turnover of the company should be Rupees 1000 crores or more
If the company meets any one of the three fiscal conditions as stated above, they are
required to create a committee to enforce its CSR mandate, with at least 3 directors, one
of whom should be an independent director.
• The committee will allocate and audit the money for different CSR purposes.
• The committee will issue an annual report on the various CSR activities
undertaken.
4
• CSR policies should be placed on the company‘s official website, in the form
and format approved by the committee.
• The board of directors is bound to accept and follow any CSR related
suggestion put up by the aforementioned committee.
• The aforementioned committee must regularly assess the net profits earned by
the company and ensure that at least 2 percent of the same is spent on CSR
related activities.
• The committee must ensure that local issues and regions are looked into first
as part of CSR activities.
• The CSR rules came into force on 1st April 2014 and will include subsidiary
companies, holdings and other foreign corporate organizations which are
involved in business activities in India.
• CSR has been defined in a rather broad manner in Schedule VII of Companies
Act, 2013. The definition is exhaustive as it includes those specific CSR
activities listed in Schedule VII and other social programmes not listed in
schedule VII, whose inclusion as a CSR activity is left to the company’s
discretion.
5
• To provide research, training, practice, capacity building, standard setting,
advocacy, rating, monitoring, recognition and related support in the field of
CSR.
• To facilitate any other assistance directly or indirectly for activities which seek
to promote CSR practices.
• To establish and deepen links with the organisations in various parts of the
world which promote CSR practices for exchange of ideas and for collaborative
actions and programmes.
• To create CSR fund with contribution of Government PSUs and private sector
companies and channelize the CSR fund for optimum utilisation through a
sustainable mechanism.
6
o Promotion of an ecosystem for enhancement of cognitive growth of Pre-
Anganwadi children o Contributions of funds to the technology
incubators located within Gujarat o Such other activities relating to CSR as may
1.6.1. ITC
ITC has been doing impactful CSR activities in India for years now. ITC has
educated about 2,52,329 children through its 2,334 Supplementary Learning
Centres. They have also supported empowered about 15378 women members
through 1183 self – help groups.
1.6.3. Infosys
Infosys is one of the early adopters of Corporate Social Responsibility. They
have take up projects like the restoration of water bodies in Karnataka and
metro station construction in partnership with Bangalore Metro Rail
Corporation Limited. Also, they are making a contribution in Sports through
7
their GoSports Foundation. Their CSR initiative also includes a relief fund for
Tamil Nadu, Karnataka and Kerala.
1.6.4. Reliance
Reliance has taken up the initiative of securing the life of villagers of Balangir
district. They have a life insurance programme for them. The ―Education for
All‖ initiative was launched to provide access to quality education in India to
everybody. They work to protect the right to education of underprivileged
children, girl-child and differently-abled. They also contribute to disaster
relief funds.
1.6.6. AMUL
Over the years, Amul has contributed to rural health and development through
Tribhuvandas Foundation. They have also established Swarnjayanti Gram
Swarozgar Yojana, a holistic self-employment programme in Kheda district.
They also successfully run tree plantation drives, blood donation camps and
rural sanitation programmes. They also provide scholarships through their
Amul Scholar schemes.
8
empower differently-abled people. Their biggest CSR initiative is the SVGH
Vocational Training College in Chikmagalur, Karnataka.
1.6.8. P&G
―Shiksha – Padhega India, Badhega India‖ is a crucial part of Procter &
Gamble‘s CSR. THE Shiksha initiative has, till date, helped about 280,000
underprivileged children to get access to their right to education. They have
also built & supported over 140 schools across India.
1.6.9. Wipro
Wipro makes its contribution to education and upliftment through Wipro
Care. Not just education, Wipro addresses disaster relief and rehabilitation
and health and wellness programmes for the needy as well through Wipro
Care. They have also launched Wipro Eye that promotes ecological
sustainability in its operations.
1.6.10. DLF
DLF is India‘s largest real estate company. Initiated in the interest of
educating children of construction workers, Swapana Sarthak Informal School
was established. They have also set up employable vocational training centres
under the banner of DLF LIFE.They‘ve also set up DLF Inspire to improve
the quality of life of underprivileged children.
9
without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their needs.
The concept of sustainability is composed of three pillars: economic,
environmental, and social—also known informally as profits, planet, and
people. Increasingly, companies are making public commitments to
sustainability through actions like reducing waste, investing in renewable
energy, and supporting organizations that work toward a more sustainable
future. (Grant, 2020)
1.7.3. Transparency: Transparency means winning the trust and loyalty of your
customers. In order to do that these days, your company needs to show up as
authentic, transparent, and purposeful. Just like any other market condition,
the ground has shifted underneath companies when it comes to corporate
giving.Consumers and investors are simply expecting more and better
information out of companies with regard to their CSR and corporate giving
programs.
10
Companies can likewise witness increased foot traffic if they're committed to
supporting the local community. For example, banks that dispense loans to
low-income households are apt to see an uptick in business as a direct result.
11
Community-oriented companies often enjoy a leg up on their competition as
well, thanks to superior brand imaging. For example, Tesla Inc. (TESLA)
CEO Elon Musk has successfully attracted environmentally-minded
consumers with his line of cutting-edge electric cars and green automotive
products.
1.8.6. Corporate Social Responsibility goes a Long Way in Creating a Good Brand
Image
Doing something for your society, stake holders, customers would not only
take your business to a higher level but also ensure long term growth and
success. Corporate social responsibility plays a crucial role in making your
brand popular not only among your competitors but also media, other
organizations and most importantly people who are your direct customers.
12
People develop a positive feeling for a brand which takes the initiative of
educating poor children, planting more trees for a greener environment,
bringing electricity to a village, providing employment to people and so on.
You really do not have to invest much in corporate social responsibility
activities. Do not undertake CSR activities only to gain publicity but because
you believe in the cause. There are many organizations which tap remote
villages, some of which are even unheard as an initiative of corporate social
responsibility
.
Brand image is the overall impression in consumers’ mind that is formed from all
sources. Consumers develop various associations with the brand. Based on these
associations, they form brand image. An image is formed about the brand on the basis of
subjective perceptions of association bundle that the consumers have about the brand.
Volvo is associated with safety. Toyota is associated with reliability.
The idea behind brand image is that the consumer is not purchasing just the
product/service but also the image associated with that product/service. Brand images
should be positive, unique and instant. Brand images can be strengthened using brand
communications like advertising, packaging, word of mouth publicity, other promotional
tools, etc. Businesses spend a lot of time curating a brand personality, voice, and brand
positioning in the marketplace. It goes beyond visible elements such as having an
identifying symbol, mark, logo etc. that companies can use to distinguish themselves
13
from rivals. All these elements of a brand contribute to the way a customer interacts with
and perceives your brand, which culminates in brand image.
This is particularly true in the post-pandemic world: 61% of people said that how a brand
responded to the crisis would have a large impact on whether they‘d keep their
relationships with them afterwards.It’s not just how businesses care for others, either –
it‘s about how they care directly for customers. We found in our Global Consumer
Trends Report 2022 that more than 60% of consumers feel that businesses need to care
more about them and that they‘d actually buy more if they felt that care.
14
responsibility program, which is demonstrated through various relevant actions. These
actions will then establish the company’s presence in the minds of the consumers and the
general public, as a whole.
If you look at the brand management strategies of various companies, one thing is
constant: they advertise. They spend on their marketing campaigns. They put out
promotional materials and perform promotional activities to put their name out there.
They tap into various distribution channels in order to increase their visibility. The more
effort they put into it, the higher their brand equity becomes.
Showing that they have a strong social responsibility policy in place has been seen as a
very effective way of generating positive press for companies. The media pays more
attention to them and they become instrumental in letting a wider audience know about
the company’s ―good works‖. It is, for all intents and purposes, a way to advertise the
company.
Loyalty and trust of customers are what businesses are most after for their brands to be
successful and enduring. Indeed, customers tend to be loyal to brands that stick to them
for all the right and positive reasons.
15
Stanford found that MBA graduates would sacrifice up to $14,000 on their annual salary
just to work for a more socially responsible company.
In other words, the people with the best skills simply want to feel as though they’re
making a difference in the world. That‘s particularly true for millennials. Around 80% of
13-25-year-olds would prefer to work for companies that care about their impact on
society.
However, you can lose out on brand affinity if your customers feel as though you’re only
engaging in CSR efforts to improve sales. This simply means that you’ll need to make
sure that the programs you implement are as authentic as possible.
A company with a CSR definition stands for something bigger than itself, and because of
this, it stands out too. With a solid corporate responsibility campaign, you can outshine
your competitors, and make your target audience take notice.
16
The role of business in society has undergone several changes. Awareness of the impact
of business on society and environment has grown along with the increasing socio-
regulatory pressures. It is no longer simple enough to employ people, make profits and
pay taxes. Companies are now expected to be responsible, accountable and benefit the
society as a whole (Brown, 2001). Business cannot escape from society and society
cannot exist without business (Davis and Frederick, 1985). Thus, there is a two way
relationship between business and society, Cannon (1994) holds the view that business is
expected to create wealth, supply market, generate employment, innovate and produce a
sufficient surplus to sustain its activities and improve its competitiveness while
contributing to the maintenance of community in which it operates.
Consumers consider switching to another company's products and services, speak out
against the company to family/friends, refuse to invest in that company's stock, refuse to
work at the company and boycott the company's products and services in case of negative
corporate citizenship behaviours (Edenkamp, 2002).The modern consumer understands
CSR that much more intimately. The future of marketing is full of CSR (Harish Bijoor,
2008).
CSR has an important role to play especially in building up trust in the minds of the
consumers. In an emerging market where consumers are looking for functional products
which last longer and accelerated obsolescence is not a problem like in developed
markets, the consumer perception about the company brand assumes significance. A
company which builds the image of producing quality products that last longer though
they may not be on the cutting edge of technology will actually be able to gain strategic
advantage in emerging economies. Firms all over the world are beginning to grasp the
importance of intangible assets, be it brand name or employee morale. Only firms that
have gained the goodwill of the general public and are ideal corporate citizens will be to
develop these intangible assets into strategic advantages (Edenkamp, 2002). CSR
practically has the same effects as advertisements, because it sheds a positive light on a
brand or product. That is why CSR can also be seen as an expression of marketing. By
including the brand name in social responsible campaigns, brand awareness and brand
recognition are raised. It's clear that the concepts of value and values are rapidly merging
17
in the minds of consumers. People want to be engaged with companies that share their
values (Scott Beaudoin, 2009).
On 29th August 2013, the Companies Act, 2013 replaced the Companies Act of 1956.
The new Act introduced far-reaching changes that affect company formation,
administration, and governance, incorporating an additional section—Section 135, which
mandates Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) obligations for companies listed in
India (The Companies Act, 2013). This clause outlines the essential prerequisites for
execution, fund allocation, and reporting, ensuring the successful implementation of CSR
projects (The Companies Act, 2013, Section 135).
India became the first country to legislate the need to undertake CSR activities and
mandatorily report CSR initiatives under the new Companies Act 2013. This is the
beginning of a new era for CSR in India.
The enactment of the Companies Act, 2013 by the Ministry of Corporate Affairs,
Government of India was one of the world's largest experiments in introducing CSR as a
mandatory provision, imposing a statutory obligation on companies to undertake CSR
projects for social welfare activities (Ministry of Corporate Affairs, 2013). This has made
India the only country to regulate and mandate CSR for select categories of companies
registered under the Act. This CSR initiative aims to push the nation toward achieving
sustainable development goals (SDGs) and fostering public-private partnerships in India's
transformation (Ministry of Corporate Affairs, 2013).
18
Tata Consultancy Services have the highest number of CSR activities in India. There are
over more than 16000 companies in India that do CSR activities. CSR activities are
expected to be done by medium scale and large scale companies, especially ones which
have their production in activities that are harmful to the environment or society. CSR is
a successful program in India. It has been observed that companies are taking efforts in
fulfilling their CSR duties and contributing more than the required target in CSR
activities. The CSR initiatives by various companies have achieved a number of
milestones and have been working actively for the well-being and betterment of society
(Singh & Sharma, 2016). However, on the other hand, companies are gaining just as
much, or even more, from their CSR efforts (Choudhury & Das, 2017). Taking up
corporate social responsibility ensures that the company is committed to ethical values
and works on ensuring environmental health, even in their private projects (Gupta,
2018). These projects help them gain publicity and attract a number of stakeholders due
to their trustworthy status (Bhat & Kumar, 2019). Furthermore, CSR efforts contribute to
employee satisfaction and improve brand loyalty, which ultimately leads to increased
profitability (Sharma & Kapoor, 2015). Companies that integrate CSR into their
business model often see an improvement in their reputation and long-term
sustainability (Malhotra & Sood, 2017). CSR initiatives also help companies mitigate
risks associated with environmental and social challenges (Kumar & Jain, 2016).
Reliance Industries Limited has been the top CSR spender in the country for the last
several years. The Company spent ₹1186 crores on its CSR initiatives in FY202122,
19
higher than what it was obligated to spend as per the Companies Act ( ₹ 1112
crores).
V. Infosys Limited
In India, Infosys Limited was a pioneer in the CSR movement. The majority of its
CSR projects have been carried out through the Infosys Foundation, which was
founded in 1996—long before CSR was legislated in the country. In FY 2021-22,
the company spent Rs. 344.91 crores for its CSR programmes. It was, however,
obligated to spend Rs. 396.70 crores as per the company‘s latest annual report.
20
was prescribed to spend Rs. 184.43 crores on its CSR. However, it spent Rs. 157.58
crores on it.
21
Among these top ten companies we have picked up to companies for our study. These are
Reliance Industries Limited and TATA Group of Industries. These companies always
shine in the list of top CSR companies and have a good corporate reputation.
1.19.1. Introduction
Ratan Tata is one of India‘s most influential and respected business leaders.
Born on December 28, 1937, he is the former chairman of Tata Sons and the
Tata Group, one of India‘s largest and most diversified conglomerates.
Known for his visionary leadership, ethical business practices, and deep
commitment to social welfare, Ratan Tata has played a crucial role in
shaping modern India‘s corporate landscape. His contributions extend
beyond business, making a profound impact on society through numerous
philanthropic initiatives. Even after stepping down from active leadership,
his influence continues to inspire generations of entrepreneurs and social
leaders worldwide.
22
experience in the industry. Over the years, he worked across various Tata
companies, understanding the intricacies of the business.
I. Contributions to Healthcare
Ratan Tata has made substantial contributions to the healthcare sector. He
played a crucial role in funding cancer research and treatment facilities,
including the Tata Memorial Hospital, which provides affordable cancer
care to thousands of patients. During the COVID-19 pandemic, Tata
Trusts donated substantial funds to provide medical equipment, testing
kits, and relief support to affected communities. His contributions to
medical research, particularly in biotechnology and artificial intelligence
for healthcare, have helped revolutionize treatment methodologies.
23
Harvard, Cornell, and MIT. He has also supported research institutions
and universities in India, including the Indian Institute of Science (IISc)
and the Tata Institute of Social Sciences (TISS). His initiatives in skill
development programs have empowered thousands of young individuals
by providing vocational training and employment opportunities.
24
1.19.6. Conclusion
Ratan Tata is more than just a business tycoon; he is a visionary leader,
philanthropist, and humanitarian. His life journey reflects resilience,
innovation, and a deep sense of responsibility towards society. His legacy
continues to influence not only the corporate world but also millions of
individuals who aspire to make a difference. Through his philanthropic
initiatives, he has touched countless lives, proving that true leadership is not
just about financial success but about making the world a better place for
everyone.
Furthermore, this study helps explore the impact of CSR on financial performance,
investor confidence, and long-term business sustainability. Consumers today prefer
brands that demonstrate social responsibility, and companies that align their CSR efforts
with their brand values often enjoy higher trust and engagement. By comparing Tata and
Reliance, this research can reveal whether a strong CSR strategy leads to increased
profitability and competitive advantage. Additionally, the findings can guide other
corporations in structuring effective CSR programs that not only benefit society but also
enhance corporate reputation. This study also has implications for policymakers, helping
25
them understand the significance of CSR in corporate governance and sustainable
development.
26