AQC1 2012 Basic Compressor Analysis
AQC1 2012 Basic Compressor Analysis
Analysis
AQC1
• Scrubber sizing
• Bottle & pipe sizing
• Plugged screens
• Instrumentation defects
• Leaking by-pass and recycle
valves
• Excessive vibration / support
deficiencies
Detectable Malfunctions
• Overloading - 28%
• Liquid/foreign object ingestion - 18%
• Lubrication - (lack of rod reversal) - 12%
• Fatigue/excessive stress - 10%
• Freeze damage - 7%
• Other causes/undetermined causes - 25%
Purpose of Compressor Analysis
• Evaluate performance
• Maximize Compressor Efficiency
• Maximize Valve Life
• Maximize Throughput to Horsepower
Ratio
• Research and Development
• Economic Evaluation
• Evaluate mechanical condition
• On-Condition Maintenance
• Insure Reliability and Safety
• Evaluate PM program
• Reduction of Maintenance Costs
• Less Downtime and Lost Production
• Attempt to “Warrant” no Catastrophic
Breakdown Between Analysis
The Reciprocating Machinery
Flywheel
Connecting Rod
Crosshead assembly
Wiper packing
Piston rod
Pressure packing
Piston
The Reciprocating Machinery
Crosshead shoe
Distance Piece
Valve cap S/D
Suction cavity
Cylinder head
The Reciprocating Machinery
17 3 11 13
21 19 16 4
12 14 18 9
2 20 10 1
15 7 22
8 5 6
Component Identification
Large 4-Stroke Multi-Stage Integral
Separable Engine-Compressor
The Analyst
The analyst is the most significant component in a successful predictive
maintenance program. Much of the actual data interpretation and analysis
is performed in the human mind. The analyst converts data into
information. Some key characteristics include:
Piston or
Crosshead
25
20
15
displ(inch)/vel(ips)
10
5
DISP
0
VELOCITY
-5 0 45 90 135 180 225 270 315 360
-10
-15
-20
-25
degrees
Mechanical Specifications and
Dimensions (Compressor)
• Number of Compressor Cylinders
• Number of valves for each compressor
cylinder end
• Rated Horsepower and Speed
• Atmospheric Pressure
• Standard Pressure
• Cylinder Phase (TDC)
• Cylinder Bore Size
• Stroke
• Connecting Rod Length
• Piston Rod Diameter
• Rod Load Limits (Compression and Tension)
• Mass of Reciprocating Weights
• Accurate Gas Analysis
• Load Step Clearance Information
Pressure Sensor Points
(Compressor)
• DC Pressure Sensor
• Head end Pressure
• Crank end Pressure
• Suction Nozzle
• Discharge Nozzle
• Suction Pulsation Bottle
• Discharge Pulsation
Bottle
• Suction Valve Cavity
• Discharge Valve Cavity
Pressure Sensor Points
(Compressor)
• Head end and Crank end
Indicator Valves
• Pulsation Bottle Indicator
Valves
• Vibration
• High Frequency
Vibration
• Head end
• Unloaders (optional)
• Crosshead
• Valve caps (optional)
• Raw Vibration
• Head end
• Crosshead
Compressor Vibration Sensor Points
Compressor Ultrasonic Sensor Points
Ultrasonic
probe
• Ultrasonic
• Cylinder Head end (optional)
• Cylinder Crank end (optional)
• Cylinder Side (optional)
• Suction Valves & Unloaders
• Discharge Valves &
Unloaders
• Gas Packing Area (optional)
Compressor Ultrasonic Sensor Points
Ultrasonic
probe
Frame Crank-angle Vibration Points
• Raw vibration
• Main bearings
• Accessories
• High frequency vibration
• Main bearings
Main Bearing Test Points
• Locate a good
vibration path
from the mains
to the outside of
the unit
or
• Crank-angle
related or FFT
Route Based FFT Accessories
• Oil pump
• Water pump
• Hydraulic pump
• Frame
• Cylinders
• Piping
• Horizontal
• Vertical
• Axial
Machine Software Setup Review
Reciprocating Compressor Design,
Theory and Sequence of Events
Typical Balanced-opposed Compressor
• Block valves
• Pressure control
valves
• Scrubbers
• Volume/pulsation
bottles
• Screens
Discharge System
• Pulsation/volume
bottles
• Gas cooler
• Recycle lines
• Relief valves
• Check valves
Compressor Components
• BDC Crankshaft
– Fixed Design
• P1*v1 = p2*v2
160.0
140.0
120.0
100.0
psia
80.0
60.0
40.0
20.0
0.0
0 5 10 15
volume
P1 V1 = P2 V2
1000.0
100.0
log psia
10.0
1.0
1 10 100
log volume
Compressor Temperature
• When the volume of gas remains the same and the absolute
temperature of the gas increases, the pressure increases
proportionately.
• P1/p2 = t1/t2
• 100 psia pressure raised from 100 deg F to 200 deg F will
cause the pressure to raise to 118 psia.
P1/P2 = T1/T2
40.00
35.00
30.00
psia
25.00
20.00
15.00
10.00
500 700 900 1100 1300
absolute temp
Charles’ Law
• If the absolute pressure remains constant, the
volume of a gas increases proportionately
with any increase in the absolute temperature.
• V1/v2 = t1/t2
24.00
22.00
20.00
volume
18.00
16.00
14.00
12.00
10.00
500 700 900 1100 1300
absolute temp
Ideal or Basic Gas Law
• (P1*v1)/ t1 = (p2*v2)/ t2
• P = absolute pressure
• V = volume
• T = absolute temperature
Displaced Volume – The volume the piston displaces as it move from Top
Dead Center (TDC) to Bottom Dead Center (BDC) of the cylinder.
Power = Work/Time
Friction Horsepower
Ring/Liner friction
Wrist pin/Bushing friction
Connecting rod bearing/ crankshaft friction
Compressor Indicated Horsepower
• The horsepower measured at the compressor
piston face with an indicating device (eg: 100 IHP).
Crankangle Plots
Used for Performance Information
and Mechanical Condition
Crank-angle Sweep
TDC
TDC BDC
Compressor (Press Vs Crank-Angle)
Crank-end
Discharge Head-end
toe pressure Discharge
toe pressure
Crank-end
Discharge Head-end
toe pressure Discharge
toe pressure
As the piston moves toward the crank end, the gas in the
crank end cylinder volume is being compressed (1).
Immediately after compression begins, the suction valves
close because the pressure in the crank end is now slightly
higher than the pressure in the suction line. Simultaneously,
the gas in the head end is beginning to expand (2).
Compressor (PV Diagram)
When the pressure in the head end drops below the pressure in
the suction line (1), the differential pressure causes the suction
valve to open, filling the head end with gas at suction pressure.
In the crank end, the pressure has increased. When the
pressure reaches a point slightly above discharge pressure (2),
the discharge valves open and the gas is discharged.
Compressor (PV Diagram)
At this time, the piston has passed through TDC and his moving
back toward the head-end. The piston reaches the end of its
stroke compressing the gas in the head end to discharge
pressure (2),and expanding the gas in the crank end to suction
pressure (1).
Compressor
(Head End PV Diagram)
A – Expansion B – Suction
C – Compression D – Discharge
Compressor
(Crank End PV Diagram)
A – Expansion B – Suction
C – Compression D – Discharge
Compressor Volumetric Efficiencies
• Suction Volumetric Efficiency (VEs) is the
percent of the cylinder end's displacement
that the piston passes through after the
internal cylinder pressure drops to suction
pressure as measured at the end of the
stroke.
• T2 = ((T1+460) * R^((K-1)/K))-460
T2 = Theoretical discharge temperature
T1 = Beginning temperature degrees F.
R = Absolute compression ratio
(absolute disch pr / absolute suct pr)
K = Ratio of specific heats
Theoretical Temperature Example
T1 = 60 deg F
R = 200 psia / 100 psia = 2
K = 1.28
T2 = ((T1+460)*R^((K-1)/K))-460
T2 = ((60+460)*2^((1.28-1)/1.28))-460
T2 = (520*2^(.28/1.28))-460
T2 = (520*2^(.21875))-460
T2 = (520*1.1637)-460
T2 = (605.124)-460
T2 = 145 deg F
Capacity
Crank-end
Discharge Head-end
toe pressure Discharge
toe pressure
HE
3D 1D
2D
5S
4S 6S
HE
3D 1D
2D
1S 2S
HE
4D 3D
Compressor CE Valve Leakage Patterns
CE
3D 1D
2D
5S
4S 6S
CE
3D 1D
2D
1S 2S
CE
4D 3D
Before the Analysis
• Research the maintenance history of the unit.
• Review previous analysis reports.
• Talk to people closely associated with the unit
about potential problems.
• Verify TDC reference accuracy.
• Inspect indicator valves and passages.
• Verify pressure transducer performance.
Initial Site Inspection
Crank-angle Encoder
• Mechanical or
friction drive
• No slippage
• Shaft properly
aligned
• Solid on floor
• Avoid excessive
tension
• Angular velocity
issues
Analyzer Equipment Setup
(Once Per Turn/n-turn)
Magnetic Pickup
• Magnetic or
optical pickup
• Not tracking
crankshaft by
degree
• Works better
on electric
driven
compressors
• No angular
velocity data
(TDC Identification and Synchronization)
TDC Marks
(accuracy rules!) • Reference mark
on flywheel lined
up with reference
mark on frame
• Couplings can
cause
synchronization
errors on
separable
machines
• Second stationary
mark on frame
eliminates
parallax errors
TDC Accuracy
• Compressor Performance
• Manual Panel, Temperature/IR
• Economic
• Set-up Data
• Prioritized Deficiency List
Compressor Performance Report
These items are used in the flow calculation at suction conditions. All 3 can be
affected by the mechanical condition of the cylinder. Even in a healthy cylinder,
the values could be wrong. The temperature at the cylinder valve port is difficult to
obtain. The pressure and volumetric efficiency accuracy can be affected by
channel resonance. The pressure can be affected by the sensor zero and
linearity.
Compressor Performance Report
Absolute
compression ratio
These items are used in the flow calculation at discharge conditions. All 3 can be
affected by the mechanical condition of the cylinder. Even in a healthy cylinder,
the values could be wrong. The temperature at the cylinder valve port is difficult to
obtain. The pressure and volumetric efficiency accuracy can be affected by
channel resonance. The pressure can be affected by the sensor zero and
linearity.
Compressor Performance Report
calculated Measured
difference (from page 1)
The Theoretical
discharge temperature
is calculated from the
The delta temperature will
measured suction
elevate as the cylinder leakage
temperature, the
rates increase.
compression ratio of the
toes and the K-value of
the gas.
Compressor Performance Report
In a healthy cyl
end, the SWR
calculation will
normally agree
closely with the
set clearance if
the set
calculated clearance is an
accurate value.
difference
The Set value is used in These are the calculated clearances using
the creation of the the GPSA method. The actual clearance is
theoretical PV models, not needed to make this calculation. The
the log/log plots, and avg value should be used as the set
the polytropic values clearance for good diagnostic plots of
(n). It must represent theoreticals. In a healthy cylinder, with an
the actual clearances in accurate TDC, the Suc and Dis
the individual cylinders calculations will be close together.
ends.
Compressor Performance Report
• A Destroyed
discharge valve
• B Discharge valve in
suction port
• C Suction valve in
discharge port
• D Indicator passage
drilled into
discharge cavity
• B Wrong reported
clearance
• C Excessive
suction valve
leakage
• D Rings leaking in
one direction
• E None of the
above
Double-Acting Cylinder with 4 Valves per End
• A Excessive
discharge valve
leakage
• B Excessive
suction valve
leakage
• C Excessive ring
leakage
• E None of the
above
Double-Acting Cylinder with 4 Valves per End
• A Discharge
valve leakage
in both ends
• B Suction valve
leakage in
both ends
• C Suction
leakage in
head end &
discharge
leakage
in crank end
• D Ring leakage
• E None of the
above
Double-Acting Cylinder with 4 Valves per End
• A Head end
discharge
valve leakage
• B Crank end
suction valve
leakage
• C Moderate ring
leakage
• D Excessive
power losses
• E None of the
above
Double-Acting Cylinder with 4 Valves per End
• A Head end
discharge
valve flutter
• B Crank end
suction valve
flutter
• C Indicator
passage
channel
resonance
• D Ring leakage
• F None of the
above
Double-Acting Cylinder with 4 Valves per End
• A Head end
discharge valve
flutter
• B Crank end
suction valve
leakage
• C Indicator
passage
channel
resonance
• D Ring leakage
• F None of the
above
Double-Acting Cylinder with 4 Valves per End
• A Head end
suction valve
leakage
• B Crank end
suction valve
leakage
• C Ring leakage
• D None of the
above
Double-Acting Cylinder with 4 Valves per End
• A Slight crank
end suction
valve leakage
• B Slight crank
end discharge
valve leakage
• C Slight head
end discharge
valve leakage
• D Ring leakage
• E None of the
above
Double-Acting Cylinder • A Suction and
with 4 Valves per End discharge
valve leakage
• B Set clearance
volume is
smaller than
actual
• C Set clearance
volume is
larger than
actual
• D Ring leakage
• E None of the
above
• A Head end suction
Double-Acting Cylinder valve leakage
with 6 Valves per End
• B Head end
discharge valve
leakage
• C Crank end
suction
valve leakage
• D Crank end
discharge valve
leakage
• E Ring leakage
• F None of the
above
Double-Acting Cylinder
• A Top valve
with 6 Valves per End indicates
leakage
• B Bottom valve
indicates
insufficient lift
• C Middle valve
indicates
restriction
• D Bottom valve
indicates
spring damage
• E Both A and D
• F Both A and C
• A Top valve is a
Double-Acting Cylinder leaking
with 2 Valves per End suction valve
• B Top valve is
a leaking
discharge
valve
• C Top valve is
a suction
valve with a
sticking
component
• D Both A and C
• E None of the
above
• A Cylinder has
Double-Acting Cylinder slight discharge
valve leakage
with 6 Valves per End
• B Cylinder has
moderate
discharge valve
leakage
• C Cylinder has
moderate suction
valve leakage
• D Cylinder has
slight suction
valve leakage
• F Both C and E
Unloaded Head End Cylinder
• A Loose piston
on rod
• B Piston hitting
crank end
head
• C Piston hitting
head end
head
• D None of the
above
Atmospheric Pressure
Methane ______
Nitrogen ______
Packing Leakage
Shifting the pressure trace to the right will result in ? Check all
that apply.
Bore ______
Stroke ______
Rod length ______
K-value ______
Compressibility ______
Measured RPM ______
Transducer 0 offset ______
Transducer linearity ______
Flow Measurement
Which of the following have an effect on the calculated
flow rate? Check all that apply.
Bore ______
Stroke ______
Rod length ______
K-value ______
Compressibility ______
Measured RPM ______
Transducer 0 offset ______
Transducer linearity ______