1

(SINGLE BENCH)
MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL : NAGPUR BENCH : NAGPUR
BEFORE THE HON’BLE SHRI JUSTICE M.G.GIRATKAR : VICE-CHAIRMAN

(“COURT HALL A” ) (TIME – AFTER DIVISION BENCH MATTERS OVER) (DATE- 06.03.2025)

ORDER MATTERS
1 O.A.698/22 Dr. R.R.Meshram State & 4 Ors. Recovery For Reply to R/1 &
P.O.for R/1 & 2 & 5 2
Adv. G.G. Bade, Adv. S.C. Deshmukh
P.P. Khaparde for R/3 & 4
2 O.A.235/23 A.P. Meshram State & 2 Ors. Deficiency of the For Reply
P.O. Service & Pensionary Objection :
Adv.G.G. Bade,
Benefits Page No. 16 & 17
P.P. Khaparde
are not legible
3 O.A.249/23 M.S. Manwar State & 2 Ors. Recovery For Reply
P.O. for R/1 & 2
Adv. N.R. & Mrs. K.N. Adv. N.M. Kolhe for
Saboo R/3
4 O.A.645/23 M.D. Maskar State & 2 Ors. Time Bound For Reply
Adv.P.J. Mehta P.O. Promotion

5 O.A.1056/23 Dr.A.R. Tarale State & 2 Ors. Time Bound For Reply
P.O. Promotion, Arrears of
Adv. N.R. Saboo
salary & Interest on
delayed payment
6 O.A.1226/23 S.V. Ambekar State & 2 Ors. Posting/ Transfer For Reply to R/1 &
P.O. for R/1 & 2 2
Adv. S.R. Charpe, P.S.
Dhenge Adv. A.S. Ambatkar,
P.J. Mehta for R/3
7 O.A.115/24 W.U. Ramteke State & 2 Ors. Interest on delayed For Reply
P.O. Payment
Adv. S.M. Khan
8 O.A.122/24 P.R. Shende State & 3 Ors. Challenging For Reply
P.O. for R/1 & 2 Appointment of R/3 &
Adv. K.J. Topale, Sau. S.P. Pakhale, 4 for Police Patil
Sanket Walde R/3
S.A. Chavan, R/4
9 O.A.195/24 S.U. Dhurve State & 2 Ors. Family Pension & For Reply
P.O. Retirement benefits
Adv. S.I. & S.M. Khan,
R.R. Evnate, D.R.
Anandani

10 O.A. 233/24 G.V. Shinde State & 3 Ors. Transfer For Reply
P.O. Objection :
With Adv. M.Y. & Miss. Page No. 21 is not
E.M. Wadodkar legible
11 O.A. 236/24 K.A. Fuse State & 3 Ors. Transfer For Reply
Adv. M.Y. & Miss. P.O.
E.M. Wadodkar
12 O.A. 270/24 D.A. Mante State & 2 Ors. Relieve For Reply
Adv. S.S. Shingane P.O. for R/1 & 2
Z.P. Buldana, R/3
 2

13 O.A.295/24 A.K. Kubde State & 2 Ors. Time Bound For Reply
P.O. Promotion Objection :
Adv. P.V. Thakre
Point of limitation
In view of proper
clause ‘B’ O.A.
Appear to be
barred by
limitation
14 C.A.425/24 in V.G. Wankhede State & 3 Ors. Disqualified for the For Cond. of delay
P.O. for R/1 to 3 post of police patil For Reply in C.A.
O.A.St. 2179/24 Adv. Mrs. A.M. Raut- Adv. J.S. Wankhede
Narwade Objection:
for R/4
Page No. 20 is not
legible
15. O.A. 418/24 (C) P.S. Uike State & 2 Ors. Appointment on For Reply
P.O. Compassionate
Adv. R.L. Alone
Ground
16 O.A.437/24 S.T. Waghode State & 2 Ors. Suspension Period For Reply
P.O. treat as duty period
Adv. S.M. Khan
17 O.A.446/24 A.P. Bhelonde State & 3 Ors. Deemed date of For Reply
P.O. Promotion
Adv. S.N. Gaikwad
18 O.A.698/24 S.G. Chandikapure State & 2 Ors. Transfer For Reply to R/1 &
P.O. for R/1 & 2 2
Adv. P.S. & K.P.
Wathore, A.A. Adv. D.M. Kakani,
Wankhade G.K. Bhusari, for
R/3
19 O.A.743/24 P.S. Singh State & 2 Ors. Refund the Recovery For Reply
With P.O. amount with interest
Adv. S.U. Bhuyar
20 O.A.744/24 A.D. Yadav State & 2 Ors. Refund the Recovery For Reply
P.O amount with interest
Adv. S.U. Bhuyar
21 O.A. 801/24 (C) A.J. Kamble State & 2 Ors. Posting/ Attachment For Reply
P.O.
Adv. S.V.Sirpurkar,
Dr. R.S. Sirpurkar
22 O.A.1051/24 B.S. Charhate State & Ano. Transfer For Reply
Adv. Tejas P.O. Objection :
Deshpande, Alpesh Not make T.C. to
Deshmukh, S.S. Documents
Nagrase
23 O.A. 1111/24 V.E. Wankhade State & Ano. Appointment on For Reply
P.O. compassionate ground Objection :
Adv. V.B.Bhise,
A.Motlag Page No. 37 is not
legible

24 O.A.1201/24 A.B. Deshmukh State & 2 Ors. Pensionery benefits For Reply
Adv. S.M. Vaishnav P.O. for R/1 & 2
Adv. U.A. & K.A.
Patil,
A.S.Deshpande for
R/3
 3

25 M.C.A.02/25 in V.S. Marbhate State & 3 Ors. Deemed date of For Extension of
P.O.for R/1 & 2 Promotion Time
O.A.434/22 (C) Adv.A.B. Tikle,
Adv.T.M. Zaheer for (Filed by R/3 & 4 )
with N.S. Autkar
R/3 & 4
26 M.C.A.03/25 in B.B. Kudkelwar State & 3 Ors. Deemed date of For Extension of
P.O. R/1 & 2 Promotion Time
O.A.435/22 Adv.A.B. Tikle,
Adv.T.M. Zaheer for
with N.S. Autkar
R/3 & 4
27 M.C.A.04/25 in Y.R. Khade State & 3 Ors. Deemed date of For Extension of
P.O. R/1 & 2 Promotion Time
O.A.436/22 Adv.A.B. Tikle,
Adv.T.M. Zaheer for
N.S. Autkar
R/3 & 4
28 M.C.A. 06/25 in V.L. Fating State & 4 Ors. Recovery For Speaking to
P.O. Minutes
O.A.747/22 (C) Adv. R.K. & V.R.
Borkar
ADMISSION MATTERS
1. O.A.139/25 (C) S.G. Chavan State & 3 Ors. Time Bound New O.A.
P.O. Promotion Objection :
Adv. D.S. Sawarkar
1.Page No. 33 is
not legible
2.Margin Index,
Synopsis Page No.
11 & 38
3.Not Make T.C. to
Documents in
Annexure A-5
2. O.A.245/25 (C) R.M. Patil State & 2 Ors. Suspension New O.A.
Adv. N.R.Saboo P.O.

HEARING PARTY MATTERS

1 O.A.03/25 Dr. S. M. Bhise State & 3 Ors. Voluntary Retirement High on Board
Adv. N.D. & T.N. P.O. Objection :
Thombre Page No. 44, 45 are
not legible
2. O.A.812/16 V.J.Raut State & 3 Ors. Deemed date of
Adv.S.N.Gaikwad P.O. promotion &
Challenging
promotion of R/4
3. O.A.686/17 M.S. Bochare ( Patil) State & 2 Ors. Challenging Recovery
P.O. of Excess Payment
Adv. D.M. Kakani,
G.K. Bhusari
4. O.A.1022/19 (C) H.N.Abhyankar State & 3 Ors. Refund the amount
P.O. with interest and Pay
Adv.Bharat
fixation
Chandrakapure,
P.Ramteke,
P.Chandrakapure
5. O.A.252/20 (C) P.V.Dingolia State & 3 Ors. Punishment stoppage
Adv.G.G.Bade, P.O. of increment and
suspension
P.P. Khaparde
 4

6. O.A.913/20 T.B.Deshmukh State & 2 Ors. Posting Objection :

P.O. Page No. 23 to 25,
Adv.A.P.Kalmegh
29, 30 & 32 are not
legible
7. O.A.1113/21 (C) Dr. D.V. Dhopey State & 3 Ors. Continuation of
P.O. for R/1 to 3 service, pension ,
Adv. S.P. Palshikar
Adv. K.S. Malokar Pensionary Benefits &
V.D. Kohande,
for R/4 Suspension period
Mrunal V. Kohale,
treat as duty period
R.S. Suryawanshi,
8. O.A.128/22 M.C. Rathod State & 3 Ors. Release the gratuity
P.O. for R/1, 2 & 4 amount with interest
Adv. A.M.Tirukh
Adv.M.I. Dhatrak, and Revise pension as
S.A. Sahu for R/3 per 7th Pay
Commission
9. O.A.964/22 R.M. Borkar State & 2 Ors. Transfer
Adv.N.R. &Mrs.K.N. P.O.
Saboo, A.P.Barahate,
S. Katkar
10 O.A.996/22 S.G.Aloni State & 4 Ors. Time Bound
P.O. Promotion & Pay Scale
Adv. A.
Ananthakrishnan
11 O.A.816/23 S.D. Bhagat State & 3 Ors. Time Bound Objection :
P.O. Promotion Page No.
Adv. N.S. Warulkar,
24,25,49, 86,94 &
S.K. Bhattacharya
113 are not
legible
12 O.A.845/23 (C) S.A.Binzani State & 2 Ors. Grant medical
Adv.A.W.Paunikar P.O. leave/Commuted
leave
13 O.A.1161/23 Dr. D.P.Chokhandre State & 3 Ors. Stoppage of increment
Adv. N.D.Thombre, P.O.
T.N.Thombre
14 O.A.1219/23 D.D. Diwate State & 2 Ors. Release the arrears of
P.O. Revised pay difference
Adv. D.M.Kakani,
G.K.Bhusari
15 O.A.1337/23 H.U. Rawat & 42 Ors. State & 7 Ors. Pay Fixation
Adv. S.U. Bhuyar P.O.

16 O.A.664/24 G.U.Sonaskar State & 2 Ors. Recovery Objection :

Adv. Sagar Katkar P.O. Page No. 13 is not
legible
17 O.A.1009/19 (C) W.P.Kawade State & 4 Ors. Recovery from
P.O. pension
Adv.P.D.Meghe &
P.Rathi,Arti Singh,
Nitin Thamke, K.Roy

18 O.A.1116/23 R.G. Mandal & 23 State & 2 Ors. Declare final order of
Ors. P.O. the Recruitment
Process of Police Patil
Adv.V.N. Morande
P. Mehta
 5

19 O.A.1232/23 (C) K.R. Bala & 13 Ors. State & 2 Ors. Police patil/
P.O. challenging
Adv. V.N. Morande,
Pratik Mehta Re-examination of
Police patil
Recruitment
20 O.A. 907/21 P.N. Thegne State & 4 Ors. Recovery from
P.O. Pension
Adv. R.K. & V.R.
Borkar
21 O.A. 35/22 P.M. Nimgade State & 4 Ors. Recovery from
P.O. Pension
Adv. R.K. & V.R.
Borkar
22 O.A.625/22 N.G. Dube State & 4 Ors. Recovery from
P.O. pension
Adv.R.K.& V.R.
Borkar
23 O.A.24/22 M.H. Kuchankar State & 4 Ors. Recovery from
P.O. pension
Adv. R.K. & V.R.
Borkar

kds Deputy Registrar,

Checked by:- Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal,
Nagpur
 6

(DIVISION BENCH)

MAHARASHTRA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL : NAGPUR BENCH : NAGPUR

BEFORE THE HON’BLE SHRI JUSTICE M.G.GIRATKAR: VICE-CHAIRMAN
AND HON’BLE SHRI NITIN GADRE : MEMBER (A)

(“COURT HALL A”) (TIME – 11:00 A.M.) (DATE – 06.03.2025)

ORDER MATTER
1. C.A.102/25 in A.R. Dhanvijay State & 2 Ors. C.P. For Dispensing
C.P.11/25 in P.O. with the office
O.A.342/23 (C) Adv. I.G. Meshram,
objection
U.I. Dhawade
Objection :
Legal notice not
served to
Respondents by
Name
New C.P.
ADMISSION MATTERS
1. C.P.14/25 in Y.R. Khade State & 4 Ors. C.P. New C.P.
O.A.436/22 (C) Adv. A.B. Tikle, Y.R. P.O. Objection :
Kinkhede, A.V. Not make T.C. to
Borekar Documents

2. C.P.15/25 in B.B. Kudkelwar State & 4 Ors. C.P. New C.P.

O.A.435/22 (C) Adv. A.B. Tikle, Y.R. P.O. Objection :
Kinkhede, A.V. Not make T.C. to
Borekar Documents

3. C.P.16/25 in V.S. Marbate State & 4 Ors. C.P. New C.P.

O.A.434/22 (C) Adv. A.B. Tikle, Y.R. P.O. Objection :
Kinkhede, A.V. 1.Page No. 40 is
Borekar not legible
2.Not make T.C. to
Documents
3.Page No. 59 not
tagged in 2nd set
4. C.P.25/25 in S.G. Tiwari State & 2 Ors. C.P. New C.P.
O.A.564/19 (C) Adv. D.R. P.O. Objection :
Rupnarayan Legal notice not
sent to
Respondent No. 1
& 2 by name

5. C.P.28/25 in S.J. Zine State & 2 Ors. C.P. New C.P.

O.A.1059/21 (C) Adv. V.B. Gawali, S.V. P.O. Objection :
Lanje Page No. 19 is not
legible

6. C.P.29/25 in Dr. A.V. Shambarkar State & Ano. C.P. New C.P.
O.A. 1087/22 (C) Adv. S.C. Deshmukh P.O. Objection :
List of Annex not
sign in 1st set
 7

7. O.A.175/25 (C) Dr. P.R. Singh State & 2 Ors. Career Advancement New O.A.
P.O. Scheme Objection :
Adv. R.K.
Maheshwari Page No. 14 to 21
not proper Margin

8. R.A.16/24 in M.S. Tangade State & 3 Ors. R.A.

P.O.
O.A.581/23 Adv. R.R.Deo,
Madhur Deo

kds Deputy Registrar,

Checked by:- Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal,
Nagpur