Roshan Black Book
Roshan Black Book
ST.WILFRED’S COLLEGE OF
ARTS COMMERCE AND SCIENCE
ACKNOWLWDGMWNT
To list who all have helped me is difficult because they are so numerous
and the depth is so enormous.
I would like to acknowledge the following as being idealistic channels
and fresh dimensions in the completion of this project.
I take this opportunity to thank the University of Mumbai for giving
me chance to do this project
I would like to thank my Principal Mrs. Sayma Natekar for providing
the necessary facilities required for completion of this project
I would also like to express my sincere gratitude towards my project
guide Mrs. Anuja Patil whose guidance and care made the project
successful
I would like to thank College Library for having provided various
reference books and magazines related to my project
Lastly I would like to thank each and every person who directly and
indirectly helped me in the completion of the project especially my
parents and peers who supported me throughout my project
Made with Xodo PDF Reader and Editor
3
CERTIFICATE
Date Of Submission :-
(project guide)
Made with Xodo PDF Reader and Editor
4
TABLE OF CONTENTS
S.N CONTENTS OF THE RESEARCH PAGE NUMBERS
O PROJECT
A ACKNOWLEDGEMENT 2,3
CERTIFICATE
1 Topic of the research 5
2 SHORT DISCLAIMER 5
3 INTRODUCTION OF THE TOPIC 6,7,8,9
4 OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY 10
5 DATA COLLECTION METHODS 11
6 SAMPLE SELECTION/RESPONSES 12 to 69
COLLECTED AND PERFORMANCE
APPRAISAL SYSTEM IN IT
COMPANIES
7 REVIEW OF LITERATURE 70,71,72,73,74,75,76,77
8 HYPOTHESES STATEMENT 78,79,80,81,82
9 DATA ANALYSIS 82,83
10 REPORT ON FINDINGS OF STUDY 84
11 SUGGESTIONS/ADDITIONAL 85
SOLUTIONS
12 CONCLUSION 86
13 ANNEXURES 87,88
14 REFERENCES 89,90
Made with Xodo PDF Reader and Editor
DISCLAIMER:-
1:- INTRODUCTION
The performance management is the system that shows how employees are doing
their work. In an Organisation there are a lots of employees who do their work,
how they are working, what is their Performance, Some Employees do good work
Some Employees do bad work, Some Employees works more and some Employees
work less. Every year or two years, the company increases the Salary of the
Employees or increases their profits. But all the things that Increase or decrease are
on their Performance. So first of all, the company should have a system that let us
know about that how many people are working in our Organization, how they are
doing their work, and how well they are doing.
7
employees. If there is an increase in productivity of employees, then productivity
of organization will also increase.
The thing that happens in organization is that the company create a system to know
how much work is being done in the organization so that employees know that
whatever work I am doing is being seen and monitored. And when it will be
monitored, a result will come, that there is a group of 10 people, these 2 people out
of those 10 did a great job, then their appraisal, their salary and their behavior will
also be good. Then the employees will realize their efforts and hard work, then
they will do their work in a better way so that they can have their benefit in the
future. So the basic meaning of performance management is that the company
should know the employees of their organization, how much work is done.Who is
Made with Xodo PDF Reader and Editor
8
working so hard. And the last thing is that how's the employees handle the situation
and Faced the problems.
It is the process to obtain, analyse and record the information about the relative
worth of an employee to the organisation.Performance appraisal is done
periodically, but on a continuous basis.
9
● Motivation
HYPOTHESES STATEMENT
10
● Promotion
● clarity of roles
● Feedback
11
Employees who are subordinate to such employees feel unhappy and can leave the
organization. Such attrition may ultimately affect the organization’s performance.
To obtain the objective of the study primary data has been collected through well
designed questionnaire, the secondary data has also been used where it was
necessary.
12
Sampling method plays an important role in any research design. The basis
attention will be sampling. To make generalization and to draw calculations, it is
necessary to know who or what is described by the dates. Respondents from all the
units of the population are more reliable in this study.
1. CHI-SQUARE ANALYSIS
The main of the analysis is to determine the Performance appraisal causes feeling
unvalued. The Statistical tools are of Chi-Square Test.
Made with Xodo PDF Reader and Editor
13
CHI-SQUARE TEST:-
It includes:-
A.QUESTIONNAIRE FORMED:-
A questionnaire is a research instrument consisting of a series of questions and
other prompts for the purpose of gathering information from respondents.
Although they are often designed for statistical analysis of the responses.
https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSf5Vq04ECUut
Q9b_QRBCFeDjbJZWTa9c8vyMdLSfdlDrpQAiA/viewfor
m
Made with Xodo PDF Reader and Editor
14
RESEARCH PLAN
B.RESPONSES COLLECTED:-
EXPERIMENT/STATISTICAL TECHNIQUES:-
15
16
Made with Xodo PDF Reader and Editor
17
Ques.2:- Your Gender
FEMALE 18 58.1%
TOTAL 31 100%
Table1. Shows that 13 individuals who represent 41.9% of the total respondents
were Males. The other 58.1% were females and they were 31 in number.
Made with Xodo PDF Reader and Editor
18
Ques.3:- DEPARTMENT
SALES 4 13.8%
HR 8 27.6%
MARKETING 7 24.1%
TOTAL 29 100%
Made with Xodo PDF Reader and Editor
19
Table2. Shows that 10 persons representing 34.5% of the total Respondents were
from the accounts department. 4 persons representing 13.8% of the total
Respondents were from the sales department. 8 persons representing 27.6% of the
total Respondents were from Marketing department. And 8 persons representing
24.1% of the total Respondents were from HR department.
20
25-35 1 3.2%
25-36 10 32.3%
36-45 2 6.5%
MORE THAN 45 0 0%
TOTAL 31 100%
Table3 Shows that 18 persons who represent 58.1% of the total Respondents were
18-25 of age. 3.2% of the total Respondents who was 1 in number was 25-35 years
old. 32.3% of the total Respondents were 25-36 years old and we're 10 in number 2
individuals who represents 6.5% of the total Respondents were 36-45 years old.
And No one is abouve or more than 45 in the total Respondents.
Made with Xodo PDF Reader and Editor
21
22
MBA 9 29.03%
GRADUATED 8 25.80%
BBA 2 6.45%
B.COM 4 12.90%
B.Ed 1 3.2%
BE 1 3.2%
BSC 2 6.45%
M.COM 2 6.45%
ITI 1 3.2%
TOTAL 31 100%
Made with Xodo PDF Reader and Editor
23
Table 4. Shows that 1 person representing 3.2% of the total Respondents has Post
Graduated with MASTERS IN ARTS. 9 persons representing 29.03% of the total
Respondents had post graduated with MASTERS IN BUSINESS
ADMINISTRATION. 8 Persons representing 25.80% of the total Respondents are
Graduated. 2 person representing 6.45%% of the total Respondents has completed
BBA. 4 persons representing 12.90% of the total Respondents are pursuing
B.COM. 1 person representing 3.2% of the total Respondents had Completed B.Ed.
1 person representing 3.2% of the total Respondents had completed BE. 2 Persons
representing 6.45% of the total Respondents had completed BSC. 2 persons
representing 6.45% of the total Respondents had completed M.COM. 1 person of
the total Respondents had completed ITI DIPLOMA.
24
TOTAL 31 100%
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
Ques1:- NAME
Made with Xodo PDF Reader and Editor
34
Ques2:- DEPARTMENT
Made with Xodo PDF Reader and Editor
35
36
37
Made with Xodo PDF Reader and Editor
38
Made with Xodo PDF Reader and Editor
39
Made with Xodo PDF Reader and Editor
40
41
Made with Xodo PDF Reader and Editor
42
Made with Xodo PDF Reader and Editor
43
44
45
RATING QUESTIONS:-
46
47
48
49
QUES.5- I received a proper training in order to perform
my job effectively…
Made with Xodo PDF Reader and Editor
50
QUES.6- All problems and complaints were resolved in a
prompt and fair manner...
Made with Xodo PDF Reader and Editor
51
52
QUES.8- I felt comfortable sharing questions and
concerns with my manager...
Made with Xodo PDF Reader and Editor
53
54
55
QUES.1- Medical
Made with Xodo PDF Reader and Editor
56
QUES.2- Dental
Made with Xodo PDF Reader and Editor
57
QUES.3- Vision
Made with Xodo PDF Reader and Editor
58
QUES.4- Paid time off
Made with Xodo PDF Reader and Editor
59
60
61
QUES.7- How long do you spend productively working
on the tasks assigned to you?
Made with Xodo PDF Reader and Editor
62
QUES.8- I always Perform beyond my expectation to
make my Management Happy...
Made with Xodo PDF Reader and Editor
63
64
65
COLLECTED PRIMARY DATA :-
Table.6 Questionnaire Analysis
2 My Supervisor 8 20 2 0
told me when I
was doing a good
job.
3 I felt free to 12 15 4 0
suggest changes
to my
department.
5 I received the 10 19 1 1
proper training in
order to perform
my job
effectively.
66
prompt and fair
manner.
7 I felt 11 17 2 1
comfortable
sharing questions
and concerns
with my
supervisor.
8 I felt comfortable 14 15 0 2
sharing questions
and concerns
with my
manager.
10 I felt secure in 9 16 2 4
my job.
67
a big project, Do you receive
any recognition?
68
10.38.7% of the respondents last time they accomplished a big project, in which
they doesn't receive any recognition.
11.38.7% of the respondents are leaving their company because of a personal
reason, 16.1% of the respondents are leaving their company because of work
environment, 12.9% of the respondents are leaving their company because
of medical reason.
12.If I were to implement their suggestions then 80.6%/ of the respondents are
ready to consider working in company again.
13.48.4% of the respondents felt free or agree,12.9% of the respondents felt
Disagree, and 38.7% of the respondents are strongly Agree to suggest
changes in their department.
14.Overall 53.3% of the respondents are Good in their work Performance.
15.54.8% of the respondents are felt agree to sharing questions and concerns
with their supervisor, 35.5% of the respondents are strongly agree and 6.5%
of the respondents are strongly Disagree to sharing questions and concerns
with the supervisor.
16.61.3% of the respondents are agree and 32.3% of the respondents are
strongly agree to received a proper training in order to perform their job
effectively.
17.48.4% of the respondents are garee,45.2% of the respondents are strongly
agree and 6.5% of the respondents are disagree to sharing questions and
concerns with their manager.
18.58.1% of the respondents are agree and 38.7% of the respondents are
strongly agree about companies policies and procedures are kept well or
not.
19.51.6% of the respondents are agree, 29% of the respondents are strongly
agree, 12.9% of the respondents are disagree and 6.5% of the respondents
are strongly disagree to felt secure in their job.
20.20.7% of the respondents are thinking that they need additional benefits that
company should offer.
Made with Xodo PDF Reader and Editor
69
21.58.1% of the respondents are agree, 32.3% of the respondents are strongly
agree and 9.7% of the respondents are disagree that all problems and
complaints were resolved in a prompt and fair manner.
TCS is a subsidiary of Tata Sons Group. It was found in 1868 by Jamshedji Tata. It
generates 70% revenues of Tata Sons i.e. about US$103.5 billion. In 2015, TCS is
ranked 64th overall in the Forbes World's Most Innovative Companies. It employs
660,000 people. The performance appraisal for these employees is done as
follows:Even TCS has been in the process of transforming from Forced
Distribution model to continuous feedback. In forced distribution, every appraisee
is provided with a goal sheet which contains 15 to 20 goals (based on his/her
experience and profile) which are rated out of 5 by appraiser and attendance of
project as well as technical trainings. Average score of these ratings is done for
aggregate rating.According to the aggregate rating obtained, employee is put into
A, B, C or D categories. For suppose, 20 members in a group for a project are to be
evaluated, the project leader or project manager rates them and put 2 in A, 6 in B, 8
in C and 4 in D categories based on the rating scores. While rating appraisee, it is
also observed for them meeting with Subject Matter Experts. The pay hike starts
from 0% for D to 12 -14% for A. The hike is based on Gross Pay. This forced
ranking model is done twice in a year and pay is increased once in a year by rating
and categorization basis. Appraiser for entry level employees is team leader or
project manager.Continuous feedback has more transparency when compared to
the above model implemented. Appraiser would be willing to share the feedback
and appraisee can ask to know the lacking KPAs in the appraisal sheet. Here, the
feedback is provided for each quarter of financial year. Feedback here is givenby
Made with Xodo PDF Reader and Editor
70
considering individual ability and not compared with any other which has a better
scope for self improvement of skills and lacking areas of performance.
INFOSYS
71
72
some of the major drivers contributing to the increased visibility of
performance management system (PMS). Faced with fast moving and
competitive environments, companies ae constantly searching for unique
ways in which to differentiate themselves from their competition and are
increasingly looking to their "human resources" to provide this
differentiation.
Primary data
PART.1 :- Questionnaire
On Employees job satisfaction survey and Exit interview
feedback form.
Secondary data :
PART.2- BOOKS-
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY BOOK
73
PUBLISHER:- NEW AGE INTERNATIONAL (P) LIMITED,
PUBLISHERS
Through this book, I have read how primary and secondary data are
collected.
74
https://academic.microsoft.com/search?q=EMPLOYEES%20PERFOR
MANCE%20MANAGEMENT%20SYSTEM&f=&orderBy=0&skip=0
&take=10
LINK-
https://academic.microsoft.com/
75
be measured in cognitive (evaluative), affective (or emotional), and behavioral
components.
Researchers have also noted that job satisfaction measures vary in the extent to
which they measures feeling about the job (affective job satisfaction). Or
cognitions about the job (Cognitive job satisfaction).
76
C.WEBSITE VISITED-
1. https://journals.sagepub.com/
2. https://drive.google.com/file/d/12fMKNPNhRteCdOdEa5ZWybbo
eO_M9-53/view
3. https://www.researchgate.net/search/publication?q=STUDY%20O
F%20EMPLOYEES%20PERFORMANCE%20IN%20MANAGE
MENT%20SYSTEM
4. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tata_Consultancy_Services
5. https://www.slideshare.net/Tomangers123/performance-appraisal-i
n-infosys
6. "Larsen & Toubro - Wikipedia"
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Larsen_%26_Toubro
Made with Xodo PDF Reader and Editor
77
PRIMARY DATA
DATA COLLECTION :-
The required information needed for the thesis was collected through the use of
questionnaires. The Questionnaire were administered to Total 31 Employees.
N=31, A Sample size of 31 was used out of 50. The Questionnaire considered of
Seven sections- Section-A, Section-B, Section-C, Section-D, Section-E, Section-F,
and Section-G. Section-A is main heading, Section-B was designed to collect
General profile of Respondents. Section-C was Employees exit interview feedback
form. Section-D was designed to collect personal details. In Section-E was Rating
questions, Section-F was designed to collect the benefits which the Respondents
received from their company, And the last is Section-G that was was designed to
collect rating for other benefits.
THROUGH QUESTIONNAIRE:-
https://www.questionpro.com/blog/employee-satisfaction-survey-questio
ns/amp/
https://www.questionpro.com/blog/conduct-exit-interview-questions/am
p/
Made with Xodo PDF Reader and Editor
78
SECONDARY DATA
● http://www.srjis.com/pages/pdfFiles/146771381814.D.%20B.%20
Bagul.pdf
● https://books.google.co.in/books/about/Performance_Management
_System.html?id=QlTYAdvri8kC
● http://euroasiapub.org
These are already published online reports who helped me very much to complete
my research report on time. From these reports, i get to know about that how to
make a good research report.
79
VARIABLES
● Promotion
● Clarity of roles
● Feedback
The research has formulated following null and alternate statements for this
hypothesis.
80
ALTERNATIVE HYPOTHESIS (H1): PerformanceAppraisal cause Feeling
Unvalued.
In the questionnaire, a question has been asked to understand the opinions of the
respondents about psychological barriers in the performance management process
especially on the ‘Feeling unvalued ’in the organisation.
1 YES 27 87.1%
2 NO 4 12.9%
TOTAL 31 100%
Analysis table
1. MALE 12 1 13
2. FEMALE 15 3 18
TOTAL 27 4 31
Made with Xodo PDF Reader and Editor
81
Total 31 0.52
E = R × C/N
Where R = Sum of row total
C = Sum of column total
N= Sample size
CALCULATED VALUES
Observed Frequency = 31
Expected Frequency = 31
Made with Xodo PDF Reader and Editor
82
( O-E )² /E = 0.52
X² = Σ ( O - E )² / E
= 0.52
CRITICAL VALUE:- The table value of CHI SQUARE at 5% and for 1 degree of
freedom is ( 0.05, 3.841 )
INTERPRETATION
Since Calculated value of test Statistics chi square = 0.52 is less than the Critical
Value = 3.841.
RESULT
Made with Xodo PDF Reader and Editor
83
In the above results suggest that the Value of Chi square (0.52) is less than the
Critical Value (0.05,1) = 3.841, So the null hypothesis (Ho) is accepted and the
Alternative hypothesis (H1) is Rejected.
CONCLUSION
The data collected from the questionnaires will be thoroughly analysed and
compared to the data collected from previous studies. Analysis and interpretation
of various statements give a skilled and experienced for a better understanding and
Performance of the firm.
If the respondents feel excellent that improvement in work area. 21% of the
respondents feel very good were improvement required quality and housekeeping
area. 6% of the respondents were good, 2% of the respondents feel improvement
required, 2% of respondents feel unsatisfactory. Hence the maximum numbers of
employees are suggestion and implementation to improvement in work area.
84
sent to the Employees by social Media (WhatsApp) at the levels and Responses
were collected. More than 50 Questionnaires were sent out of which 31 responses
were collected.
SAMPLE AREA:-
There are a lots of employees who have given the responses of the Questionnaire,
they all work in different organizations, so I have not taken any particular company
as well as an area to Complete my project. The Part of Questionnaire is completely
finished by the help of Social media (through whatsapp only).
ASSUMPTIONS :-
The study assumes that all respondents will be very knowledgeable about
Performance management and are intelligent enough to understand the questions.
No training shall be given about performance management principles. Respondents
answer the questionnaires with integrity and honesty.
Made with Xodo PDF Reader and Editor
85
86
87
9:- CONCLUSION:-
This study concludes that the applied performance management system is very
effective and suitable for every level of the organization. It helps in analysing the
strengths and weaknesses of the employees as well as the organization and is also
helpful for framing the future policies of performance management system.This
study has also highlighted the satisfaction level of employees towards the current
performance management system and it was felt that it should be continued in the
coming years.
Made with Xodo PDF Reader and Editor
88
Made with Xodo PDF Reader and Editor
89
10. ANNEXURES :-
1:-
By this chart I've got the Critical Value that was 3.841 of 1 degree of freedom,
that's helped me to complete the hypothesis Test by Chi square method.
Made with Xodo PDF Reader and Editor
90
https://youtu.be/f53nXHoMXx4
This Video also helped me a lot. From this video the CHI SQUARE Method's
concept has become much clearer to me.
Made with Xodo PDF Reader and Editor
91
11:- REFERENCES :
BOOKS:
WEBSITES:
92
"Data Collection: Definition, Methods, Example and Design | QuestionPro"
https://www.questionpro.com/blog/data-collection/amp/
I've used these websites for just an idea only, I've Nothing copied
anything from this.