FSCA Investment Guide 2023
FSCA Investment Guide 2023
za
The FSCA acknowledges the input provided by the individuals and organisations listed below into the development,
review and preparation of the FSCA Investment Guide.
Note: Financial service providers (FSPs) quoted in this guide by no means indicate that the FSCA views them as
preferred FSPs or that the FSCA endorses their organisation or entity.
The FSCA Investment Guide (2022) was developed by Helen Ueckermann, an independent writing professional,
on behalf of the Financial Sector Conduct Authority (FSCA) and in consultation with stakeholders and experts in
the financial services industry.
The FSCA Investment Guide (2022) replaces and updates the previous investment series published in 2016 by the
former Financial Services Board (FSB), now known as the Financial Sector Conduct Authority, namely: Prepare
to Invest: An Introduction to Investing, Grow Your Money: Intermediate Investing and Create Personal Wealth:
Advanced Investing in one concise, informative guide.
The FSCA believes that educated and informed financial customers can make better financial decisions about
which financial products and services are best suited to their needs and budget. Informed and educated customers
are also more aware of their rights and responsibilities and can confidently engage with the sector on more equal
terms.
Therefore, this resource wants to build on the previous series by bringing home a deeper understanding of the topic
of investing, the benefits thereof, and the fact that anyone can do it. This is important to motivate consumers to take
the first steps towards seeing their money grow.
It aims to address gaps of financial education in the target audience, improve financial self-confidence, counter the
misbelief that you need large amounts of money to invest and bust the myth of “our lives will not improve”. It also
updates any relevant legislation that you, as financial customers and investors, should be aware of.
If this is achieved, South Africans may gain financial wellness as individuals, families and as a nation.
To get the most out of this guide, you have to apply the knowledge to your day-to-day behaviour. Therefore, we
endeavoured to provide rule-of-thumb information that is easy to apply, practical and doable. The aim is to present
the knowledge in a way that is simple to understand and relevant to South African culture.
Thus, beginner investors make use of investment vehicles such as passive funds (a fund that simply tracks an
index) and other lower-risk collective investment schemes (unit trusts), to start saving. These vehicles enable
the beginner investor to minimise risk by keeping investments diversified with the assistance of an authorised
financial advisor.
Beginner investors should focus on how to beat the increasing cost of living and ensure that invested funds
are growing at a rate higher than inflation. Financial education and learning should be a core focus, as this
will help beginner investors understand investing and which investment vehicles are aligned with their goals.
Intermediate investors have some experience in the market and may want to become more active participants
in investment decisions but are still open to seeking the assistance of an expert such as a financial advisor
and an authorised user of exchange platforms (broker). In addition to lower risk to moderate investments, they
may move on to a more active form of investing, for instance playing a bigger role in choosing the assets they
want to invest in.
They may progress to investing directly in shares on the stock exchange and using fundamental analysis,
including asset allocation and stock picking. Intermediate investors are confident that researching and
analysing assets based on performance metrics can help them to make good decisions. Intermediate investors
look at growing funds at a higher rate by researching investment opportunities.
Their focus is on following the news and market reports to find new assets that will help them to grow their
money. However, they are typically long-term investors looking to buy and hold onto assets for longer periods
of time.
Advanced investors invest for the long-term as well as trade in the short-term, in order to take advantage
of short-term market moves. They are more confident in their ability to find opportunities in the market. They
are often prepared to take higher risks over and above the important considerations such as age and lifestyle.
In other words, within the advanced investors group one would often find that there are investors that would
be prepared to take on more risk for higher potential returns, keeping in mind factors such as the total mix
of their age, current life experience and investment portfolio. Advanced investors focus on where the next
opportunity lies, using either fundamental or technical market analysis. They are savvy enough to invest
directly without making use of a financial advisor.
1. Introduction 132
2. Types of scams 133
3. What to look out for 138
4. What to do when you find yourself investing in a scam 139
5. Knowledge is protection 140
6. Conclusion 140
7. Self-assessment 141
1. Introduction 143
2. Your rights as a financial customer 145
3. Your responsibility as a consumer 147
4. The FSCA 149
4.1 The role of the FSCA 149
4.2 What the FSCA does not do 149
4.3 How are investors in South Africa’s financial markets protected? 150
4.4 How and when to submit a complaint to the FSCA 151
4.5 What information is required? 151
4.6 How will I know what the outcome of the investigation is? 152
5. What are my rights if I have a complaint against an unregistered
financial institution? 152
6. Conclusion 152
7. Self-assessment 153
1. Introduction
When working with money, especially your money, it is essential to make good choices today, so that you do not
have future regrets. Our choices not only affect our own lives and future financial well-being but also have an
impact on the lives of others, specifically those close to us that we need to care for. We are not alone in our choices,
but we form part of a bigger financial picture.
As a beginner, intermediate or advanced investor, you all have one goal which is to make your money work for you
and for those you love. Make no mistake; investing is not only for the rich. Anybody who is interested, willing to
learn and prepared to make a few sacrifices can do it. There are some investments, such as collective investment
schemes, that accept a reasonable small amount of investment contributions monthly.
But have you ever thought about how to make your money work for you? How to grow your money without
labour? Investing can do that for you over the longer term. Investing entails a different way of thinking about
making money. Most people think of an income as something they earn by going to work every day and
getting paid. The problem is that there are only so many hours in a day to make money in that way.
Investing is an efficient pathway to financial wellbeing and covering future expenses such as your children’s
education or to provide an income after retirement. When you invest your money, you buy something that you
believe will increase in value over time, for instance, putting your money in the stock market by buying stocks
(equity shares) or bonds, or in a business or property. Sometimes these options are called investment vehicles,
which simply means “a place to invest”.
Invest/Investing
Placing money into a financial vehicle (venture) or business such as
shares, stocks, collective investment schemes or similar.
Investment
When you have placed money in an investment product to make a profit, you
have made an investment. .
R
Investor
R
R
R
R R R
A person who invests, e.g., buys (invests) in shares, bonds, etc. in order to
R
make a profit or return.
Income
R Your earnings. For example, your salary, grant, maintenance, allowance,
overtime pay, etc. Also, the income that you can earn from savings and
INCOME
certain investments.
BILL
Expenses
R
The money that you spend on everything you have to pay, like bills. This
also includes money that you spend on things like birthday presents.
PAY NOW
Business
An enterprise that organises resources such as knowledge, raw materials,
land, labour and capital in order to accumulate money (profit).
Portfolio
Your collection of shares and other investments makes up your investment
portfolio. You can have just a few shares in a portfolio, but you can also
theoretically own an infinite number of shares.
• Investing allows you to grow your money so that you can meet long-term financial goals, especially
retirement. The amount of risk you can take varies a lot.
• Saving is a short to medium-term strategy where you set aside a certain amount of money to help you
accomplish short or medium-term goals and keep some cash available. Saving usually carries less risk, but the
returns are also quite limited. A good example is a normal bank savings account.
Conditions
Legally binding requirements to be followed when entering into a contract with an FSP or authorised financial
advisor or investment provider. The conditions set out the obligations of the parties that enter into a contract. Or
the terms and provisos of an investment product when you buy it.
Interest
A payment made in return for the use of borrowed money. This relates to debt instruments (also interest-
bearing instruments). For example, if you lend money to a bank or the government, they are indebted to you.
Risk appetite
Risk appetite refers to the amount of risk you are prepared to take and live with to reach your financial goals.
It is the level of risk you are prepared to accept before you adjust your investment strategy to lessen your risk.
Determining your appetite for risk helps you decide how much risk you are prepared to live with, and importantly,
when it becomes necessary to take action to reduce your risk, perhaps related to your stage of life.
Interest rate
The rate of interest paid on money borrowed, calculated as an annual percentage.
Profit
When income exceeds expenses, you have made a profit or when you get more money back than you put into
the investment.
Savings Investments
Period Short-term: Ready to go Long-term: Achieve major goals
• Saving is for shorter-term goals • Investing can help you reach bigger long-term goals,
like going on holiday or having like starting your own business, preparing for retirement
money for an emergency. or providing for a child’s future education.
• Savings are goal-orientated and • People invest to build wealth over a longer time, usually
are typically for smaller financial at least 5 years or more.
goals you want to achieve in 1-3 • Investing often carries a higher risk than saving of
years. capital loss – see ‘Risk’ below.
• A suitable savings product should • Investing always carries the risk of losing some or all
preserve the capital amount (the the money you invest (noting that it is unlikely that
initial amount saved), meaning you will lose the whole capital amount if invested in a
that there is minimal risk of loss. regulatedproduct with a regulated provider). This risk
However, this low risk of loss varies according to the type of investment you choose.
means lower interest earned on An authorised financial advisor will help you to identify
the amount (see below). investment products that are aligned with the risk
you are prepared to take (your risk appetite) and to
minimise the possibility of losses. Remember that, in
the long run, wise investing will probably give you better
returns than savings. This is essential to beat inflation
and not erode the value of your wealth over time.
• With savings, the only returns • Investments have the potential for higher returns than a
you earn is the interest on the regular savings product, although the value of your
money you put into your savings investments may fluctuate in value over time.
product. The interest rate is • Selling shares or collective investment scheme
usually quite low. participatory interests (PI’s) at a higher price than what
you bought them for, will make you a profit.
• Investment accounts return higher interest than savings
accounts, especially over a 5 to 10-year period.
It is often wise to put the money that you want quick access to into a quick-access financial product like a savings
account, and your other money into a spread of investment types, depending on your risk appetite.
Examples of interest-bearing savings instruments/products include banking products such as savings accounts,
tax-free savings accounts, call accounts, fixed-term deposit accounts and notice deposits. These products are
available at all banks. Life insurance companies and collective investment schemes also offer tax-free accounts.
Insurance risk and savings policies are not considered investment vehicles as such, because no dividends or
interest are paid i.e. these policies do not generate a return on the investment, although there are often investment
components as well. Examples of these include:
• Permanent life insurance (whole life and universal life): Covers you against the risk of death while a portion
of the premium is usually directed to a saving or investment account which does build up some cash value over
time, usually less than the money you put in.
• Endowment plan: An investment/savings plan with a minimum term of five years where you can nominate a
beneficiary to receive the money or take ownership of the investment if you pass away.
Example:
You invest R10 000 and in year one, you earn a 10% return. That would be R1 000 in growth, increasing
your overall portfolio value to R11 000.
Then, in year two, you earn another 10%. However, now you are earning 10% on R11 000 instead of the
initial R10 000. So, you’d actually earn R1 100 in interest in year two, bringing your account value to
R12 100.
• It works the same way with your debt – if you do not pay your debt regularly, the amount you owe will grow
bigger and bigger, with interest calculated on the interest. i.e., you will end up paying much more than
originally owed.
The famous mathematician and physicist Albert Einstein reputedly said compound interest was the greatest
invention of mankind and the 8th wonder of the world. “He who understands it, earns it; he who doesn’t,
pays it,” he said.
Example 1
Tim is 24 years old and for the next six years, until he is 30, he puts R250
in a bank account every month. That is a total of R18 000.
If Tim simply leaves those savings in his account that pays an average of 9%
interest per year (per year is also referred to as per annum), by the age of
65, the value of those savings would be about R480 000.
This means, in this case, compound interest earned Tim an extra R462 000
without you having to lift a finger.
If Tim, decides to continue depositing R250 per month into his bank account
after he has turned 30, he would have more than a million rand by age 65.
To be specific, he would have a whopping R1 152 864.
Example 2
John decides to start saving R250 per month for 30 years, but he only starts
saving at age 35 – 10 years later than Tim. He earns the same interest as does
Tim, but after 30 years he only has R425 528.
This shows the importance of time: The more time you allow your savings to
compound, the better! Make an early start and reap the fruit of your efforts.
It beats inflation
While putting money in a bank savings account does not beat inflation after deducting the costs, investment returns should
always be compared to the inflation rate. To do this properly, one needs to understand what inflation really means.
Inflation is the sustained increase in the general price level of goods and services in an economy over a period. If your money
is growing at a rate lower than the general increase in the cost of goods and services, it essentially means that your savings are
losing value year after year.
Inflation can have a negative effect on consumers as it reduces their purchasing power. Therefore, it is necessary, as a saver
and an investor, to take steps to protect your wealth against the damaging effect of inflation.
Example:
For every R4 000 you need per month after retirement, you will need to save R1 000 000. This should ensure that
you do not run out of money and will be able to give yourself an increase every year to protect your income against
increases in living expenses. If you want R20 000 per month, you will have to save R5 000 000.
– Ronald King, Director Financial Intermediaries Association of Southern Africa and Head: Public Policy &
Regulatory Affairs, PSG Konsult
In recent years, a great many new and cheaper ways of saving and investing have emerged. One can invest
smaller amounts in numerous investment funds that are accessible online, even on one’s smartphone.
The cost of investing has also dropped considerably. While lower, all investments have costs that lower your
returns. In South Africa fees average 2.75% of the larger spectrum of investments, plus VAT. The fees may, for
example, consist of 0.075% for advice fees; 0.5% for administration; 1.5% for investment fees. You may also be
paying performance fees. It is important to pay attention to what you pay and why; always question whether the
cost is justified. The money you pay to invest can have a big effect on what you have left in your pocket.
Investing, if done correctly, will help you protect your family from financial distress and will ensure that you have a
good amount of money to keep you going after retirement. The 2019 10X Retirement Reality Report states that
out of 15 million economically active South Africans, 67% have no retirement plan.
Almost a third (30%) of South Africans in general have no formal retirement savings at all (often because of
unemployment and having no choice but to depend on grants to survive) and may become reliant on family or face
poverty when they are forced to stop working and earning. Can you see why investing your money is necessary?
A large amount of the money that people save or invest in investment products is used to buy shares and company
bonds. When investors buy company shares, the companies use that money to grow their business, which means
more productivity and more jobs, which in turn means more disposable income for workers who will then be able
to spend more money in retail stores. So, by investing in a company you help make it stronger and to employ more
people who will be able to feed their families. As the company grows, so will the value of your shares and bonds.
Share Shareholder
One of the equal parts that the ownership of a company is divided into, A person who owns shares in a
which can be bought by members of the public as shareholders. company.
Investing is a long-term undertaking and building an investment portfolio requires discipline and consistency.
Markets go through cycles, and your investment portfolio needs time to work through these cycles to benefit from
the long-term upward trends. These upward trends are difficult to notice when looking at your portfolio with a short-
term view.
Sticking to a few golden rules for investing will make all the difference to your success.
• Stick to your long-term plan – do not focus on the short-term fluctuations in your portfolio. Give your investment
a chance to grow. Time is your friend as the value of your portfolio will go up and down all the time, but in the long
term, it will most likely show an increase in value.
• Make sure to have and maintain an emergency fund for unexpected events, to ensure that you do not have
to dip into your investment portfolio at short notice. Unexpected events may come at a time when markets are
down and can cause a capital loss in your portfolio, or it may not be easy to access your invested money in a
short space of time when you need it most.
• The products in your portfolio must be aligned with your objectives (goals), not with your emotions. Do
not be influenced by your emotions. Fear and/or greed, including the fear of missing out (FOMO), can lead to
mistakes that can cripple a portfolio. Your financial advisor can help you to stay on track here. Diversify your
portfolio by investing in different financial products and/or industries. This will offer some protection when events
influence the markets, as not all industries react the same to external influences.
• Make informed decisions. You are entitled to ask as many questions as you need before you make an
investment decision – there are no stupid questions! Informing yourself will also help you steer clear of scams
and fraudsters.
• Knowledge is power. By educating yourself about investing and the shares you want to invest in, you improve
your chances of success. In this way, you will have the money to build wealth not only for your future but also for
future generations.
6. Conclusion
Starting a successful investment journey requires that you at least know the basics of investing, so you can enjoy
the benefits of managing your own money. Investing is a bit like going to the gym: you do not get a six-pack after
only one exercise session.
You become investment-fit by getting used to allocating funds to your portfolio, learning how the financial markets
work, and getting comfortable with all the investment terminology. Initially, your financial advisor should provide you
with investment options to choose from – and even more savvy investors still rely on the guidance of experienced
professionals rather than be solely responsible for managing their risk.
1. Introduction
By developing good financial habits, you can manage your money better. This requires educating yourself about
the world of money, how it works and how you can benefit from it.
Financial customers/investors learn about financial products, concepts and risks through information, instruction
and/or objective advice. Through education, you can develop the skills and confidence to become more aware
of financial risks and opportunities, make informed choices, know where to go for help and take other actions to
improve your financial wellbeing.
Financial education is a process of building financial capability, which means having the knowledge and skills to
understand your financial circumstances and – through that knowledge - the ability to take action to improve your
life.
Financial risk
Actions that can lead to a change in the value of your investment and possible financial loss or gain.
Financial literacy
Financial literacy is a big one because one of the many consequences of poverty is not understanding things
like budgeting or making sound financial choices. Financial literacy is a learnt art. You can only achieve
financial wellness or wellbeing and stability by implementing what you know. Financial well-being is how you
behave around money issues and consistently implement financial education or literacy elements.
43% of us borrow money to get through the rest of the month after we run out. Of these:
- 9% turn to banks to help them make it through the month
- 20% use their credit cards
- 59% resort to borrowing money from family and friends
Budget/budgeting
A budget is a list of your income (how much you earn/money entering your bank account)
and your expenses (how much you spend/money leaving your bank account). It helps with
managing your money by, for instance, showing where you can save more or spend less.
This shows that we have some work to do if we want to get serious about managing our money and our lives –
whether it is freeing up or generating more money to invest, educating ourselves and/or improving the way we
manage our money. The good news is that each of these stumbling blocks can be overcome.
The way forward is to arm yourself with knowledge. Reading this investment
guide is a first step and an indication that you are willing to learn. Financial
education, specifically investor education, is crucial to achieving success in
investing.
Investing can be complex and very daunting, but not taking the time to
educate yourself can lead to:
Investing is not a gambling game but one of analysis with a reasonable expectation of profit. Gambling entails
putting your money at risk in the hope that something good will come of it, like acting on a “hot tip” you heard
somewhere.
While there is always a risk and no guarantees, real investing is much more than hoping that luck is on your side.
It requires work on your part and knowledge serves to protect you in your quest.
Example:
You can start with the simple act of initially putting away R25 a week. That may not seem
like a lot, and you may not think it will make much of a difference to your life, but before
you know it, after one month, you have R100 in your savings account and R600 in 6
months. In a year, you will have R1 200, and this is without interest earned.
The idea is to eventually save or invest 10-15% of your income. The real amount depends
on what you earn and your unique circumstances. The message is to start with small
amounts of money and then to increase the amount as you become more comfortable with
the process and start making saving a habit.
Put your savings in an account that is separate from your other accounts. When your savings is large enough, you
can take some of this money out and move it into an actual investment vehicle of your choice. In this way, you will
grow your money and attain a measure of financial freedom.
• Budgeting is boring
Initially, budgeting may feel like a tedious burden, but that will soon change into excitement when you start to
understand where your money is coming from, where it is going, and how the changes you can make will open
the door to saving and investing. It soon becomes an empowering exercise and a lifelong skill that you practise
monthly until it becomes a habit.
IMPORTANT: By now you have seen the words “authorised financial advisor” quite a few times already, and
not without reason. Choosing the right advisor is one of the most important investment decisions you can
make.
Please take note that everything you need to know about seeking advice and choosing a financial advisor
is discussed in chapter 3, under heading 7: Seeking advice: financial advisors,
with more information in chapter 7.
If you only pay the minimum due on your credit card, you will remain indebted for decades. For example,
if you owe R20 000 on your credit card, with an interest rate of 20% and only pay the minimum amount of
3%, it will take almost 25 years to pay it off. Only paying the minimum on your credit card is just not a good
financial choice.
A 2021 survey by global financial services giant BlackRock shows that 57% of people are not investing. Yet the
survey found that when people do take a step to invest, they create a greater sense of wellbeing.
Unfortunately, not changing your attitude to money management or investing will cost you dearly in future in lost
time and lost profits. Suppose you want to start building wealth and want to become financially free, in that case,
you need to stop relying on your cheque or savings accounts or hoping you will win the Lotto. To obtain something
greater, you must do something different today.
Even though all investors want to make a profit, you come from diverse backgrounds and have different needs.
People have different personalities and expectations. Knowing who you are will make it easier to choose
investment methods that are suitable for you.
Your choices affect how your life unfolds, with good choices yielding positive results and poor choices leading to
problems and regrets. Let’s look at an example. You want to buy a car and you can just afford the monthly payment.
You can go ahead and buy the car, or stop and ask yourself a few questions first:
After answering these questions, do you still feel that you can afford the car? What will your life look like in 10 or 20
years if you make this choice today?
Remember that the road to investing begins with saving. Here are four
practical tips to start saving:
Live within your means
This means you should have a realistic budget, and you should stick to it. Plan for
R
events such as car services, school fees, stationery, uniforms and holidays, as
well as your regular monthly expenses.
Most people cannot pay cash for a house or a car. However other personal
loans, credit cards and revolving credit could be avoided.
This is crucial! You should keep between 3-6 months’ salary/income saved in an account. You should have
immediate access to this money when needed – but not in your cheque account, where it is too easy to spend
and earns no interest. Make sure that you do not cause unnecessary emergencies through lack of planning
(see the first point in this table about living within your means).
Think of retirement as an example – your goal setting will determine if you can retire well i.e., enough money
to retire comfortably.
5. Conclusion
In this chapter, we looked at what it takes to better manage your money by exploring hurdles that may keep you out
of the investment landscape, and how you can change your approach and mindset for success.
If there is one lesson that 2020/2021 has delivered – the year the Covid-19 pandemic changed our lives – it is
that the future will surprise us and that predicting what will happen is almost impossible. This does not mean
that inaction is the most appropriate response. Even in times of uncertainty, planning for the future remains
important. The next chapter will deal with financial planning.
Which beliefs do you have that may hinder your progress as an investor?
1. Introduction
Do not be a payday millionaire! Fun for a few days and hardship for the rest of the month never made a real
millionaire and neither did living from payday to payday. What can open the door to financial wellbeing, however, is
financial planning and setting up your own financial strategy. A personalised financial strategy will help you create
that ideal of having money throughout the month. A personalised financial strategy will bring you to the point of
getting through the month with cash to spare, which you can then use toward investing.
Developing a solid financial strategy or plan will help you save money, afford the things you really want, and achieve
long-term goals like investing for education and retirement. A financial strategy starts with your income. We are
looking for the best way to move from mere saving to investing and meeting your financial goals. Consider the
following points:
Why do I need an action plan? This will help me to set smaller, more manageable
goals on the road towards achieving some of my
bigger goals. Taking small, easy steps and achieving
minor goals helps me to keep focused and motivates
me to continue.
What is the next step? Once you have determined your goals and your plan
of action, create a budget that will allow you to start
investing.
• setting goals
• your life experiences and your money
• budgeting
• having an emergency fund
• understanding investment timeframes
• seeking professional financial advice.
Note: Towards the end of this chapter, there is a section for intermediate and advanced investors.
Financial advisors will tell you that your financial plan is the link between your goals and your investments, and the
investment returns you require to achieve those goals. Your financial plan also helps:
• to understand the risk of your investment choices, and
• ensures that you know about and are comfortable with the possibility of not achieving your goals, should those
risks become a reality.
Direction: Setting goals gives you a target to work towards. With a clear understanding of what
you are aiming for, you are more likely to stay focussed, stick to your budget and continue to work
towards your goals.
Motivation: When you invest, you need to be prepared to work continuously toward your goals. By
setting goals that are important to you, you give yourself the tools that provide you with purpose and
the energy to remain disciplined in your efforts.
Accomplishment: Goals are a great motivator, but if you only work towards the end result, it
becomes difficult to continue on your path. Set small attainable goals that you can celebrate as you
work towards your final goal. It is these small victories that will help keep you motivated to reach
your final goal.
Accountability: It is easy to convince yourself to skip an investment payment unless you hold
yourself accountable or try and be accountable to a significant other. If you have a set goal you are
working towards, you can honestly judge what is important and what is not.
Finding and setting investment goals that work for you can be a fairly simple process. When deciding on your
investment goals, make sure to include your investment time horizon, how accessible your money should be
(liquidity needs), and how much risk you are willing to take (risk tolerance).
Step 1
Step 2
Set your boundaries and define your steps by using the SMART goal
framework:
• Specific: Make each goal clear and specific
• Measurable: Frame each goal in a way that is easy to measure
• Achievable: Set goals that are achievable
• Realistic: Set realistic and relevant goals
• Time-based: Attach a timeframe to your goals so that you can
track your progress
Short-term goals are set for targets you want to reach quickly.
Examples include:
• going on a holiday that requires travel long-term
• paying off debt (e.g., a furniture account)
• building an emergency fund to cover your
expenses in case of an emergency (a good
rule is to save enough to cover three months
of expenses when you are young and single
and six months when you have greater
financial responsibilities like being
married with dependants).
Examples include:
• saving for a deposit on a car
• saving for a deposit on a home
• paying off a study loan
Long-term goals generally focus on retirement planning and other investments so that you have enough to live
on when you get to the point where you are too old to work. Generally, targets that you set beyond five years are
considered long-term goals.
Step 3
To establish how important your various goals are to you, complete the
worksheet below. If you have a spouse or partner, ask them to complete
their own worksheet. In this way, you can see to what extent the two of
you agree on your financial priorities.
Control spending 1 2 3 4 5
Understanding my investments 1 2 3 4 5
Looking for ways to make the most of tax advantages and benefits offered 1 2 3 4 5
Create an action list as a guide that can be reviewed and updated as you work towards your goal.
Let’s have a look at how Linda and Paul did it. Linda and Paul were struggling to get through the month
despite both having permanent jobs and living with Paul’s parents. Linda is a shop assistant at a large
department store and earns R5 500 per month. Paul is a security guard at a shopping centre and earns R7
000 per month. Together they earn R12 500 per month. They decided to take a serious look at their money
management and worked out the following action list to reduce their spending.
To their amazement, Linda and Paul found that they had a lot of unnecessary
expenses. Linda could save R1 000 per month or R12 000 per year, and Paul R1
150 per month or R13 800 per year. Together they would have R25 800 per year
available for investment or saving. Excited about their new knowledge, they decided
on the following actions:
• Each to save 5% of their earnings before deductions such as tax and unemployment
insurance for a personal dream they want to come true.
• The rest of the newly available money would go to a retirement savings plan.
By saving small amounts every month for their own use, after a year Linda had R6 600 in her savings account
and Paul R8 400. By keeping their minds firmly on their long-term goal of a comfortable retirement, they were
able to put R18 900 per year in a retirement fund.
Step 5
The more you focus on your goals, the more you subconsciously create pathways to success. Regularly
reviewing your goals helps you to gauge your progress. If you set smaller targets on the road to your big
goal, you will get a sense of progress that will motivate you to keep moving forward.
Example:
After working hard for a year or two, Linda and Paul are promoted
and receive an increase each. They set a new goal: To move out of
Paul’s parents’ house and buy their own home. They want to save for a
deposit of R100 000, which seems like an impossible amount.
Instead of looking at the total amount they break it down into small-
er chunks. They work out that they can afford to save R20 000
per year, which is R1 666.66 per month. Now it looks much less
daunting!
They now know that it will take them five years to save for their
deposit, or even less if they can get a favourable interest rate and
save any extras, like an annual bonus, as well.
By paying yourself first, you are putting away some cash for yourself, whether that’s into a savings or
retirement account. Make sure you set aside a portion of your income to save. Thinking of personal
savings as the first bill you must pay each month can help you build tremendous wealth over time.
Investopedia.com
Keep in mind that your goals will be unique to you. Everybody’s financial goals will be different, depending on
their life experiences.
Your last year of high school is exciting but also a bit scary. You are on the verge of a new phase – your life as
a grownup. What will be next? Where to from here? There are important questions to ask and to answer by the
time you get your grade 12 certificate, such as:
• Once you have completed your studies at a college or university, you again
need to make some important decisions. What do you want in life? How are
you going to achieve that?
• Where will I apply for jobs or do I want to work for myself?
• What bank account am I going to put my salary or business income into?
• What bills and expenses will I need to pay for? (For example, rent, student
loan, food, clothes, entertainment, transport, etc.)
• Does the money I make cover all my expenses? Insurance
• If I do not make enough money to pay all my bills, what will I do to get more A way to protect yourself
money every month? against losses like
• Am I planning any big purchases soon, e.g., buying a car? death, theft, accidents
• Are there any insurance policies that I should have? and so on.
• When should I start saving for retirement?
Career changes: You may want to change your career for new challenges or to earn a better
income. You may want to start your own business or move into a different industry. This is
a major life change. You should equip yourself with as much information as possible before
making drastic financial decisions.
Losing a job and becoming unemployed: Job loss is frequently unexpected and extremely
upsetting. Unemployment can lead to huge financial, physical and emotional stress. You may
find yourself unable to pay your bills, or you may even have to consider going into debt review.
These financial issues must be dealt with head-on rather than ignored.
Getting married: From a financial point of view, getting married allows us to share costs and
plans, but there are also financial challenges and risks. By planning your finances together,
you can make sure that both your needs are met. The key is sharing decision-making and
being completely honest about your finances prior the marriage.
Live-in partner (co-habitation): Moving in with a partner or getting a place together is a huge
step in any relationship. When you have decided to move in together, the relationship now
moves from a “lovey-dovey” perspective to a “business” perspective when it comes to making
financial decisions.
Starting a family: Whether you are having a baby, adopting a child, or dealing with an
unplanned pregnancy, you are starting a family. While nothing can quite prepare you for the
changes about to happen, one area that you can get a handle on is your finances.
Blended families: Financial planning when preparing for a new marriage or relationship (with
or without children from previous relationships) is always a challenge, but it can be even
harder when you are trying to blend the budgets of two families.
Divorce: Parting ways is never easy. From a financial point of view, costs have been shared,
but after a divorce - they will still have to be carried individually.
Buying a car: Once you’ve passed your driving test, you’ll want to get your own set of wheels.
But do not be too hasty. If you want to finance your car, you will be subjected to an affordability
test to ensure that you do not over-extend yourself. Financing a car is a long-term commitment.
Apart from the insurance premium that needs to be added to the monthly car payments, you
will also need to budget for fuel, car services and unexpected repairs.
Buying a house: Buying your first home is a milestone. It is a major decision that takes
planning, research and careful budgeting.
Retiring: As you get closer to retirement, you will need to make some big adjustments. As with
all major lifestyle changes, your income will probably also change. You must start saving for a
comfortable retirement as soon as possible.
The death of a family member: The sudden death of a family member is traumatic and
painful. It brings a lot of financial decision-making, particularly if the deceased did not make
many plans for his or her dependents.
Planning for your funeral: Funerals form an important part of our cultural life. In many cases,
families spend far more than they can afford to bury their loved ones, resulting in situations
that may land them in debt. Often, over-spending happens to keep up social appearances.
Planning for funerals should not be driven by emotions or family pressure but by sound deci-
sions that will not end in debt.
Whatever life experiences come your way, you must be prepared by thinking about what would need to be
doing and how you would go about it. The assistance of an authorised financial advisor is strongly
recommended, especially once you are employed or earn an income in any form or at different periods i.e.,
monthly, yearly, bi-monthly, weekly etc.
4. Budgeting
Do not spend more than you earn. Easier said than done,
right? Well, it is not all that difficult if you learn one
important life skill early and that’s how to budget.
It will take a bit of your time, but your
decision to do it will be worth your while.
A budget is an estimate of what you expect to earn and spend over a period of time.
A monthly budget allows you to understand how much you spend and what you typically spend your money on.
Anyone can budget, even if you do not earn a salary. Just list whatever money comes in and what your regular and
irregular expenses look like.
Budgeting does not need to be complicated or tedious. In fact, it gives you a better understanding of yourself and
allows you to make more informed choices. It helps you to manage your money better and thus live a better, more
fulfilling life. It is, therefore, well worth the effort.
Irregular expenses
South Africans are among the hardest workers in the world, spending on average almost 43 hours at work per
week. If you are going to spend so much time earning an income, you need to make sure that your money is going
towards the things that are important to you.
If your total expenses are more than your income, you need to make some changes. This means that you spend
more than you earn. See where you can cut your costs (start with the “wants”) so that your income is more than
your expenses. If at the end of your pay-check month you are short of money, then it is clear you are spending
more than you earn.
take a lunch box to work or school drive a cheaper car? But make sure
instead of buying lunch? it is reliable
cancel your gym contract if you have spend less on luxury clothing and
not been there lately? technology?
If your total expenses are less than your income, you also have decisions to make. How are you going to pay off
debt, save or invest that extra money? Paying off your debt is most often the best immediate investment.
Take your receipts out of the box at the end of every week to sort them into categories such as groceries, vehicle
expenses, entertainment, etc. You can also take photos of your receipts and keep an electronic log of your receipts.
By tracking your income and expenses, you gain insight into your financial situation. You can now make informed
decisions about where to make changes that can pave the way to your financial security.
Example of a budget
January January February February
Budgeted amount: What you plan to spend Budgeted Actual Budgeted Actual amount
Actual amount: Your real spend amount amount amount
INCOME (YOUR EARNINGS)
Salary
Child support/grant
Other income
SUB-TOTAL INCOME (I)
EXPENSES (EVERYTHING YOU HAVE TO PAY)
Fixed costs (Costs that do not change from month to
month)
Rent/Home loan/bond
Vehicle finance
Short-term insurance (e.g., vehicle cover)
Medical aid/Hospital plan
School/Crèche (day-care) fees
Retail store accounts (e.g., furniture account)
Cell phone contract
Internet contract
Magazine/Newspaper subscriptions
DSTV
Personal savings/Emergency fund/Investments
Gym
SUB-TOTAL FIXED COSTS (F)
VARIABLE COSTS (COSTS THAT CHANGE FROM MONTH
TO MONTH)
Transport, e.g., petrol and taxi fare
Utilities (water, sewerage and electricity)
Groceries
Clothing accounts
Entertainment (eating out, takeaways, movies)
Medication
Cell phone airtime/data (PayAsYouGo or TopUp)
SUB-TOTAL VARIABLE COST (V)
Other expenses
Contribution to events (e.g., gifts, funeral)
Vehicle repairs
Haircut/Salon/Beauty treatment
Stationery
TV licence fee (annual or monthly)
Vehicle licence renewal (annual)
SUB-TOTAL OTHER EXPENSES (O)
TOTAL INCOME (I)
Total Expenses (F + V + O)
SURPLUS OR DEFICIT (TOTAL INCOME – TOTAL
EXPENSES)
When you spend more than you earn you will have a deficit (negative balance/shortfall).
Pay on time:
Make sure you pay all your bills on time or before time. Ensure that you have enough money in your bank
account for your debit orders. You do not want your debit orders to bounce – because with this also comes
additional charges from your bank and your creditor who is debiting your account. This can also
affect your credit score negatively, which means that banks may be reluctant to lend money to
you, if at all, or you will pay a higher interest on debt as you will be a high-risk borrower.
Budgeting as a family:
Families can set goals, too. Creating a budget gives family members something to work towards,
together. They will feel less resentful about making sacrifices over the short term if they know the
outcome will be favourable over the long term.
Temptation can be expensive, especially if you go into debt to satisfy your immediate desires. But it will cost
you a lot more if instant gratification distracts your long-term savings goals. -
It taught us that having an emergency fund is vital to any individual’s financial strategy. Apart from losing your job or
main source of income, unforeseen expenses such as medical bills, vehicle and household repairs, funeral costs
or even a child’s sports tour can place any household budget under pressure if there is nothing left after paying
regular expenses.
“When you are in your 20s, start this fund as soon as possible, even if you start small. This is the bedrock
of every good financial plan or budget. Your first step is to have R10 000 and over time build up to at least
three months of expenses. This is what stops you from getting into debt when a crisis like retrenchment, an
unexpected medical bill, etc. hits. Even if you do not face a crisis, it will remove financial stress and anxiety.”
How much you need to save in your emergency fund differs from person to person. Most financial
advisors agree that 3 to 6 months’ living expenses is the ideal amount to protect you against a sudden loss of
income or surprise expenses. While life is expensive, and budgets are under pressure you must start somewhere,
irrespective of how much you initially contribute to your emergency fund every month.
To save means you have decided to use your money at a later stage for specific purposes. Ideally, you would like
to reward yourself for showing discipline and self-control by saving in an account that earns you the best interest
on the money you save.
Instant access: The money you Stability: Invest your money in Inflation: If you plan to use your
save needs to be easily available an account or financial product savings in an emergency in the
when you need it. that offers stable returns, as you future, your money’s purchasing
might need to use this money power must stay the same. If
during less stable economic you allow inflation to lessen your
times. buying power, it defeats the
purpose of saving. Make sure
that you put your money where
you can earn an inflation-beating
return, for example in a money
market account.
Timeframes, or time horizons, refer to how long you can invest. For example, when a young man
invests to make provision for his retirement, his investment time horizon is several decades, presuming he starts
saving at age 25, retires at 65 and lives to 80. But if you are saving for a deposit for a house, your investment time
horizon may only be two or three years.
As a rule of thumb, the more time you have to invest, the more risk you can take. The value of shares increases
and decreases all the time but generally shows an upward line over a longer timeframe. When you want to invest
for less than five years, the volatility of share prices may put you at a disadvantage.
Financial advisors give out general and specific financial advice for a fee (which may consist of the commission
an advisor earns on a product they sell you) and may manage client assets and his or her investment portfolio
construction. They are your link between financial service providers (FSPs) and the investment (vehicles) products
that help you achieve your goals.
An authorised financial advisor has the expertise and experience to help you navigate the complex
investment environment and teach you the principles that will help you achieve your financial dreams and make
sound investment decisions.
For example, calculations around life expectancy, replacement ratios and declines in investments or funds are
often complicated, and as a consumer, you might not be aware of all the financial products on offer. This is where
the help of a professional can be invaluable.
Assets
Things you own that have value, for example, a house, a car,
furniture, an investment portfolio, etc.
Underlying assets
These are the assets owned by a portfolio.
IMPORTANT:
An unauthorised financial advisor may give you information that is not rooted in a deep-seated,
academically qualified background. It may lead to incorrect advice and big financial losses. Investing on your
own, for instance online, via robo-advice or on tips from your friends and family may also be risky. Always
work with an experienced, authorised financial advisor.
As an investor, it is important to have a trusted partner to walk this path with you. There are various areas in your
investment journey where an authorised financial advisor can assist and add value:
• Legal: There are so many different laws that can apply to your investment portfolio. Your advisor will be able
to assist with ensuring that you comply with all legal requirements. Take note that financial advisors must be
registered as tax practitioners to be able to provide tax advice. If that is not the case, a separate tax advisor is
required.
• Products: Once you start looking around to invest, you will realise there are countless investment products
available – each looking more attractive than the other! Your financial advisor can help you make the best
choice to ensure the products in your portfolio are suited to your individual needs and objectives.
• Goals and objectives: Your investment goals and objectives are not always clear. Your financial advisor can
help you to identify these, ensure that they are realistic, and compile a plan to help you reach your goals in the
long term. Regular meetings with your financial advisor will help you to stay on track with your goals and make
changes when required.
• Emotions and decision-making: It is easy to underestimate the degree to which emotion influences our
decisions – but it is so important! Making investment decisions based on emotion can be extremely costly in the
long term, and this is where your financial advisor will step in and help guide you to make the logical decisions,
even if this is not the easy option.
• set your financial goals to make sure they are realistic and achievable
• stay on track with your finances
• make your money work for you
avoid expensive mistakes
• protect the things that you own
• make the financial environment easier to understand
• secure your standard of living
• protect your income.
7.2 How does your financial advisor create your financial plan?
A good financial advisor is interested in you as a person and not just in your goals and finances. By following the
internationally recognised six-step process, they will create a financial plan that is unique to your financial situation
and goals.
Unless there is a life-changing event that requires you to immediately review your financial plan, it is important that
you meet your financial advisor at least once a year to review your portfolio.
Choosing the right authorised financial advisor is vital as the aim is to build up a long-term relationship with
someone you can trust. As with any relationship, you should expect your financial advisor to be honest, competent,
act with integrity, and be committed to acting in your best interests.
Although many of us follow the recommendations of family members, friends and colleagues when choosing a
financial advisor, it is best to make sure that your financial advisor is accredited and authorised by the Financial
Sector Conduct Authority (FSCA). Ask the following questions:
One of the key responsibilities of the FSCA is to protect financial customers and ensure that they are treated
fairly. The FSCA, together with the Financial Advisory and Intermediary Services Act (FAIS), therefore, requires
that every FSP be registered with the FSCA before they may legally conduct business. The FSCA is an important
resource if you need to check whether the financial advisor you are considering is authorised to offer financial ad-
vice and/or sell you a particular financial product.
What can you expect from a good financial advisor? They should be able to:
• perform a needs analysis to ascertain your financial needs and risk profile
• put together a portfolio that is aligned with your needs, income and life stage
• be a good sounding board and dissuade you from making moves based on fear or greed
• work with you over time and understand your changing circumstances and requirements
• review your portfolio at least once a year and advise you of any decisions that need to be taken
• identify gaps or shortcomings in your portfolio, recommend the necessary changes
IMPORTANT: Many financial advisors are members of the industry’s professional association, the Financial
Intermediaries Association of South Africa (FIA) and the Financial Planning Institute of Southern Africa (FPI) an
independent representative body of professional financial planners in South Africa. It is helpful if your financial
advisor has a professional qualification from an approved institution, is a member of a professional body such
as the FPI, a professional body recognised by SAQA and the only institution in South Africa to offer the CFP®
certification. FPI has also been approved by SARS as a recognised controlling body. Financial advisors’
membership of these organisations helps protect you as a financial customer.
You can read more about how you are protected as a financial customer, including Treat Customers
Fairly (TCF), the FAIS Act and the Consumer Protection Act (CPA), in chapter 7.
What do you charge, and what will you provide for this fee?
It is important to understand how your financial advisor earns an income. Find out how this
will affect and benefit you. Make sure that you are going to get value for money. Some
financial advisors build in their advice fee into a financial product that you may buy from them.
It is important that you, as the investor, ask the right questions, compare the financial
advice given and understand the impact of actions that will be implemented on your
behalf with your hard-earned money. Yes, you can shop around for the right financial
advisor just like to shop for any other service or product.
There are still instances where clients of financial advisors do not really understand
what they are told, or where a husband tells his wife to sign a contract without really
understanding the contents thereof. This is illegal. Any investor has the right to know
and should feel empowered to ask any question and get the answers they seek.
IMPORTANT: There are no dumb questions when you are about to sign away a portion of your income to
be invested on your behalf. You have the right to fully understand what is being offered to you. Take note of
the fact that you are by no means the only person who does not always understand or who feels silly asking
yet another question.
Financial advisors typically charge a fee for their services or work on commission (the maximum commission they
can charge is prescribed by law). It is important to discuss this with them upfront so that you understand how they
charge and know what you are paying for. Some might charge a monthly retainer, a fixed amount, or a percentage
of your investment. Perhaps more important is the value they provide for what they charge and whether your in-
vestment portfolio yields decent returns. If your financial advisor cannot demonstrate the value they have added in
return for their fee, you may want to work with another individual or company.
Besides reading as many brochures and informational articles as you can, there are other sources of financial
advice you may consider.
Online: There is a lot of information online that can help you with questions about your finances. Always verify the
source and information before you make a decision.
FSCA and other regulators: In South Africa, the FSCA and other regulators participate in work-based employee
assistance programmes. These encourage employees to save for rainy days and retirement and include topics like
planning, budgeting, saving, rights and responsibilities and recourse.
Seminars and workshops: Financial advisors very often offer workshops and free seminars that give general
advice. If you want advice that takes your personal situation into account, you need personal financial advice, which
will mean talking to an authorised financial service provider, one-on-one.
8. Conclusion
This chapter, where we discussed setting goals, life experiences,
budgeting, emergency funds, investment timeframes and the role of
financial advisors, has covered a lot of ground in terms of financial
planning and the importance of financial advice. In chapter 4, we will
look at choosing the appropriate financial products for your unique
needs but before we come to that, we will investigate financial planning
for intermediate investors.
What is the point of setting goals, and what would your first three goals be?
What are life experiences, and what do they have to do with your financial plan?
1. Introduction
After having been exposed to basic investing tools, you may want to start investing directly in specific asset classes
like shares or property or decide to diversify your portfolio over different asset classes. You might be interested
in investments like commodities, which include gold, silver and crude oil. You might think of investing in specific
shares. You may be considering which collective investment scheme portfolios best suit you, by underlying asset
class or by investment strategy – see chapter 4, part 2, section 2.4 for more detail. Whatever the case, it takes
time and many hours of studying the markets and investment vehicles before you will be able to manage your
own portfolio. You must take personal responsibility for your financial affairs before you can expect to succeed in
investing.
Learn all you can about following the financial markets on a day-to-day basis. Recent developments in
software programming have made this much easier for private investors. It is also much easier to stay
informed about what is happening in the share market than in the past. Financial news websites such as
Moneyweb, Fin24, Business Day, Financial Mail, Sharenet and others publish market information and share market
movements daily. The following three points will put you on the right track.
• Keep up to date with news about the local economy as well as the global economy. Set aside a certain amount
of time each day to stay on top of things. Time is money – the more you invest in understanding your field, the
more likely it is that you will make better informed financial choices.
• Apart from having a good general idea of the financial landscape, follow a number of shares and get to understand
their movements. This is a good academic exercise to help you understand how the market works and how
individual shares perform within it.
3. Conclusion
To move beyond basic investing, you need to educate yourself thoroughly. Learn everything there is to know so you
can enjoy a successful investment journey in the years to come.
If you are an advanced investor, you’ve mastered the basics, taken a step forward to intermediate investing, and
are now ready to gain a deeper understanding of the more advanced aspects of investing. You devote at least a few
hours a week to researching investments and gaining a basic understanding of financial statements. You probably
have a circle of friends that you can discuss investments with, and you understand the finer points of financial
statements.
As per the listing requirements of the Johannesburg Stock Exchange (JSE), a listed company has to publish its
financial results twice a year: interim results at mid-year and final results at financial year-end. The listed company
has to distribute results and its annual financial statements to all holders of securities within three months after the
end of each financial year and at least fifteen business days before the date of the annual general meeting.
The financial results will include the listed company’s income statement, cash flow statement and balance sheet.
It will also include profit (or loss) statements, dividend announcements and commentary on how the company is
doing as well as how it views the future.
Company financial statements provide in-depth information about a company’s revenue, expenses, profitability,
debt load, and ability to meet its short-term and long-term financial obligations.
Balance sheets
Financial statements are, in effect, written records of the company’s activities over a certain period of time.
Financial statements must be audited to make sure they reflect an accurate picture of the company in terms of its
activities and also for tax, financing, or investing purposes.
cash-flow statement
balance sheet income statement measures how well a
gives an overview focuses on a company’s company generates
of assets, liabilities, revenues and expenses, cash to pay its debt
and stockholders’ as well as net income obligations and fund its
equity or loss operating expenses and
investments
The results must be published using the International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS). This ensures
consistency across results and companies.
R
(profits).
Equities
Company shares that can be bought and sold.
Stocks
Stocks refer to the holding of corporate equities, or
corporate equity securities traded on a stock exchange
in general, whereas shares may refer only to shares,
whether listed or not, for a particular company.
According to Investopedia.com, a company’s earnings are, quite simply, its profits. While the details of real
accounting are much more complicated, earnings always refer to how much money a company makes minus costs.
The terms profit, net income, bottom line, and earnings all refer to the same thing.
Earnings are often expressed in terms of earnings per share (EPS), which is the most important indicator of a
company’s financial health. EPS is a company’s net income (or earnings) divided by the number of common shares
held by all its shareholders. It shows how much a company earns for each share. A higher EPS indicates the com-
pany’s stock has a higher value when compared to others in its industry. This is how you can compare companies’
financial health.
Investors should take earnings seriously because they ultimately drive stock prices. Strong earnings generally
result in the stock price moving up, weak earnings or losses drives the stock down. While there are no guarantees,
earnings and EPS are an excellent indicator of a company’s performance and whether an investor should consider
buying a company’s shares or not.
3. Conclusion
• As an investor, you should be able to read, understand and interpret a company’s financial results.
• The investor with a good knowledge of a company and who can read, understand and interpret financ statements
will have a lead over others who cannot.
1. Introduction
How do you know which financial products are right for you? Earlier on, we discussed getting to know yourself.
Individual preferences are important; for instance, some people believe property is a great investment, while others
think it is too risky.
• risk appetite – the amount of risk you are prepared to live with to reach your financial goals. In
investments, risk is often related to how much the value of your investment goes up or down and how frequently
it happens. The more the value changes, the higher the risk that you may make a loss on a day that you need
your funds; the more constant the value, the lower the risk. Usually, products with a higher risk will grow faster,
but there is no guarantee.
• risk capacity – the ability to take risks without jeopardising financial goals.
• risk tolerance – the emotional or psychological willingness to take risk.
Markets and shares fluctuate, and decisions that make sense today may not make sense in the near or distant
future. Sometimes you need to act on this, but sometimes you need to ride out market movements regardless. To
make the right choices, it helps to understand the different asset classes and what investing in them entails. There
are pros and cons to different investment strategies and educating yourself is critical.
Everyone has a different investing personality – some people simply cannot tolerate risk, while others thrive on
taking chances for greater rewards. Working with a financial advisor can help you to better understand your risk
appetite and make informed decisions when it comes to growing your money.
Investopedia.com uses the following example of how contradictions play out in the markets:
Sally believes that the key to investing is to buy small companies that are
poised to grow at extremely high rates. Sally is, therefore, always watching
for the newest, most cutting-edge technology and typically invests in
technology and biotech firms, which sometimes aren’t even making a profit.
Sally does not mind because these companies have huge potential in the
longer term.
Shareholder
A person who owns shares in a company.
How can digital apps (budgeting/saving/investing) help you when you start to invest?
Time is such a scarce commodity. These apps will help you save time. Not only will your budget be at your
fingertips whenever you need to check your financial status, but you also have to spend time capturing all
your expenses. You can use these aids to identify your spending patterns and habits, which can help you
make the required changes to enable you to become an investor.
- Hester van der Merwe, Financial Planning Institute’s 2020 Financial Planner of the Year
4. Conclusion
We have seen that there are many different investing styles and strategies and that two opposite approaches can
both result in success. What is important is that you put together a diversified portfolio in accordance with your risk
appetite and that you protect your investment against loss.
Bonds are sold by government institutions or listed companies (government bonds and corporate bonds) in order
to raise money to improve the infrastructure of the country (by building roads, hospitals, and so on).
2. Variable-interest investments
These are investments on which the interest earned varies or differs from time to time. The interest rate can go up
or down but generally increases over time.
Shares give you part ownership of a company. Shares are also referred to as equities and stocks, which is why we
talk about stock markets, stock exchanges and stockbrokers (now called authorised users of exchange platforms).
Companies usually offer shares through a stock exchange to raise initial funds for operations or as a way to fund
growth objectives or specific projects. The level of ownership depends on the number of shares you own.
Case study
1 000 ÷ 100 = 10
Or, in other words, his 100 shares mean he owns 10% of the
equity or stock in the company.
Most companies will need money to fund the start-up of its operations or more money than they generate from their
business activities to fund a new project or to develop a new product line. Issuing shares and selling them to the
public is an affordable way for private-sector enterprises to raise capital for such activities. As an investor, you can
buy shares at a certain price today in the hope of selling them in the future for more than you paid for them.
As a shareholder (someone who owns shares), you are entitled to a share of any declared dividends (profits). If
the company does not perform well, its share value decreases, and your shares may be worth less than when you
bought them (until the company recovers). If a company’s performance does not improve, or the company ceases
operations, you will lose some or all of your investment.
While shares are most often associated with a stock exchange, there are small unlisted businesses that also want
to expand and grow their business. They often find investors through private marketing or even among family and
friends or simply a group of private individuals willing to buy shares in the business.
Investing in real estate can be a safe and reliable investment in times of uncertainty and can deliver a good return
on investment.
• Buy-to-let: This is the bread and butter of property investment where you buy a property to rent out. Your
tenant will help you pay off the mortgage (bond) and other expenses like maintenance costs, after which
the after-tax rental money will go straight into your pocket. The potential rental yield can serve you well in
retirement or help pay for your children’s education.
• Buy to renovate and sell: If you are creative and can do the renovations yourself, it may prove a shrewd
investment. Kitchen renovations are the most effective in boosting the value of a property, followed by
bathrooms.
• ROI: Your return on investment is decided by how much profit you make when you sell the property. A good
profit means a positive ROI while selling at a loss will mean a negative ROI. (Further on in this chapter you will
learn how to calculate ROI).
• Buying the wrong property: You must stay abreast of trends in the property market to make the right decisions.
Choosing the correct location is very important to retain or increase value.
• Greed: Property investment is a long game, slow and steady. Do not invest in property if you want to get rich
quick.
• Natural disasters: Make sure your properties are insured against damage.
• Unreliable tenants: Tenants that do not pay rent or damage your property can ruin your investment journey.
• Have all tenants been properly screened and are you keeping the relationship professional? You are investing,
not making friends.
• Real estate crash: Yes, prices can drop. However, real estate is a long-term game, and when prices drop, you
can still rent the property out and sell when the market recovers.
• Political instability: This may lower the selling price of your house, but on the other hand, it may open
opportunities for buying another property at a lower price. Also look at possible land claims on a property before
buying a specific property.
Collective investment schemes (CISs), also known as unit trusts in South Africa, are popular investment vehicles as
they are easy to understand and are well regulated. In fact, they are the biggest retail investment vehicle in South
Africa. The majority of ETFs listed on the JSE are also CISs.
• Whatever your investment goal, they provide you with an effortless way to grow your wealth and offer all the
advantages of a savings account with the benefits of long-term exposure to the financial markets (the longer
the investment term, the better your protection against market movements and volatility).
• Your portfolio will be managed by a registered CIS Manager who will in turn appoint a professional investment
manager, who will pool investors’ funds in the portfolio selected by the investor. Different portfolios are registered
with the FSCA according to its own investment policy, which is determined by different asset classes and
industry sectors, including local and global equities, bonds, property, money-market instruments and more.
The aim is to create a diverse, investment portfolio that will allow investors with different risk appetites to
participate in the stock market.
• Typically, trustees or custodians like the big banks will hold the assets of your portfolio on your behalf and
in the name of the portfolio, and you get to share the risks and benefits of the investment according to your
participatory interest (PI) in the CIS – this means the percentage of your share in the pooled funds. The value
of your investment can be calculated by multiplying the price of a PI by the number of participatory interests
you own.
Sector
Shares in the same industry belong in the same sector. For example,
the technology sector includes companies like Apple and Microsoft.
Some authorised users of exchanges prefer to trade in one sector
because they know the industry well and can better predict the per-
formance of the shares.
Investment manager
An individual or company that has been registered in terms of the
Financial Advisory and Intermediary Services Act (FAIS Act), to
manage the assets in a portfolio on behalf of investors (individual or
institutional investors).
• Securities: A security is any financial instrument with monetary value that can be bought, exchanged or sold,
and includes shares, bonds, debentures, notes, interest-bearing instruments and participatory interest in other
CISs or ETFs.
• Property: Investors can pool their funds to invest directly in property in any jurisdiction anywhere in the world,
and includes a mix of property types, like residential or retail property, factories or warehouses.
• Participation mortgage bonds: A mortgage bond is registered on a property, and investors’ funds are lent to
developers who will improve the value of the property through developing it. In the event that the developers
cannot repay the loan, the scheme will take ownership of the developed property and sell it to recoup the funds.
The portfolio invests in the mortgage bonds.
• Hedge funds: In April 2015, regulation of hedge funds was introduced as collective investment schemes
governed by the Collective Investment Schemes Control Act 45 of 2002. Before this, hedge funds sometimes
charged exorbitant fees and frequently failed to deliver as promised.
One finds two different types of hedge funds in South Africa; the Qualified Investor Hedge Fund (CIHF) and the
Retail Investor Hedge Fund (RIHF). The QHIF’s are only available to investors with a considerable amount of
money to invest and who have specialised investment knowledge to evaluate the specialised risk of these funds.
The RIHF’s however are available for anyone to invest in. RIHF’s in South Africa mostly focus on hedging the fund
against possible losses. Therefore, it may be ideal for many retail investors who are hoping to make a profit above
normal interest rates but do not want to take the higher risks of losses of the normal CIS funds that in invest in
shares (equity). However, an investor must be careful to make sure that the portfolio they want to buy is one that
hedges against losses and not one that follows a riskier strategy to chase profits.
Diversified portfolio
A diversified portfolio contains a mix of distinct asset
types and investment vehicles in an attempt at
limiting exposure to any single asset class or risk.
Diversification
A risk management strategy that mixes a wide variety
of investments within a portfolio.
Balanced portfolio
May be ideal for a first-time investor who is looking
for a long-term investment with average risk. These
funds are one of the different types of CIS’s in
securities that invest in a flexible combination of
shares and interest-bearing instruments or bonds
and may include some foreign exposure and property
exposure. This strategy allows you the growth in
some investments even when others don’t perform,
thereby mitigating downturns. Balanced portfolios
mainly follow the limits of permitted investment
determined by the Pension Funds Act and are
thus ideally positioned for long term retirement
investment. However, different funds have different
levels of exposure to asset classes, and the investor
needs to be aware of the limits permitted for a fund in
the public documents provided.
Money market funds are collective investment schemes/unit trusts (other jurisdictions Money market fund
use the term ‘mutual funds’), which means that your money is pooled with that of A type of investment
other investors, and an investment professional will try to negotiate the best possible that provides monthly
interest rate. There is a minimum investment amount that you have to invest, and income through
you can top up your investment at any time. Remember to ask your investment interest.
professional about their fees or commission.
Your service provider will be able to tell you what the minimum investment amount
is. You need to put down an initial lump sum, but you can arrange for a monthly debit
order if you would like to deposit more money into the fund each month.
An ETF is essentially a basket of shares. You buy the basket and get exposure to anywhere from 10 to perhaps 600
different shares in that basket, depending on the index that the ETF tracks, which reduces the impact of downward
share price movements of companies in the ETF basket and reduces your risk of losses if a company in the basket
goes bankrupt.
An ETF and other collective investment schemes are essentially the same, but ETF’s are listed on an exchange
and other collective investment schemes are purchased directly from the CIS manager, online or through other
financial intermediaries.
A great starting place for many individual investors who are looking to build a share portfolio is the ETFs. ETFs
are short for Exchange-Traded Funds and they are products that are listed on the JSE and can be bought or
sold just like any share. ETFs allow you to track the performance of a basket of shares or indices such as the
FTSE/JSE Top 40 Index, or even single commodities.
- Adele Hattingh, JSE Business Development & Exchange Traded Products Manager – Capital Markets
Dividends
A sum of money a company pays to its
shareholders out of its net profits and/or
reserves.
According to Adele Hattingh, JSE Business Development & Exchange Traded Products Manager – Capital Markets,
the greatest benefit of ETFs to first-time investors is that they provide a diverse exposure to shares without having
to buy all the underlying stocks directly. Having just one ETF share exposes you to the underlying index which may
be made up of as many as 40 shares.
(An ETF share is not a company equity share, but actually a participatory interest. Worldwide it is accepted that
ETF’s participatory interests are also named shares because the fund is listed). They are also liquid instruments
and are relatively low in cost.
ETFs open the door for anyone to invest in the financial market and do not require extensive research into each
and every underlying company. By buying ETFs you can achieve a diversified portfolio even as a beginner investor.
If a share within an ETF declares a dividend you will be entitled to it just as a shareholder would be. Some ETFs
automatically re-invest these dividends back into the fund which means the effects of compounding are put to work
for you, whereas other ETFs pay out the dividends to investors.
The following are some examples of Equity ETFs that are available for trade by investors:
An investor is faced with a decision whether he or she should invest in an unlisted CIS or an ETF. This choice will
be informed by the investor’s personal preferences as the one is not necessarily better than the other, as well as
the main differences between unlisted CISs and ETFs.
These are:
• ETFs are traded on a secondary market (the stock exchange) and CISs are purchased directly from the CIS
manager, online or through other financial intermediaries and redeemed the same way;
• Market makers or agents are appointed in the case of ETFs to ensure provision of liquidity, whereas the liquidity
in the CIS fund will purely depend on the ability to sell off the assets in the portfolio;
• In the case of ETFs, the stock exchange’s SENS announcements are used for disclosures in addition to the reg-
ulated disclosures required for a CIS;
• An ETF is generally more transparent than CIS in the shorter term, as intra-day pricing is possible, either through
full disclosure of underlying holdings or provision of iNAV;
• ETFs are currently passively managed by simply referencing to an index; there are also some passively managed
CIS Funds, but they are far in the minority and usually relate to funds that invest in resources shares – otherwise
CIS’s are mainly actively managed by professional investment managers.
This is a measure of the intraday net asset value (NAV) of an investment. iNav is reported approximately every 15
seconds and gives investors a measure of the value of the investment throughout the day.
Each investment option has its own advantages and disadvantages and it is important to take into consideration
the costs and the risks associated with each.
Let us look at the differences between passive and active funds below:
Passive funds
• It references or tracks the performance of an index that is specifically chosen and disclosed to the investor.
• The performance is limited to the up and down movement of the chosen index and the investor cannot
expect outperformance.
• Because the fund only needs to choose assets to track an index, the fees are often less.
• The investment policy is easier to understand if the index is known and understood.
Active funds
• It buys and sells different financial instruments or assets on an going basis in order to out-perform specifically
chosen and publicly disclosed benchmark. This benchmark can also be an index or a composition of indices.
• It can deliver better performance than the index over time if the fund management strategy is successful (but
as the stock market is a zero-sum game, it may also under-perform the benchmark over time).
• Higher fees may apply because much more work needs to go into the selection of the assets, especially
research and analyses of the shares.
• The investment policy may sometimes be quite complex to understand, and the investor does not know over
the short term how the assets are changed around in the portfolio.
3. Conclusion
In Part 2 of this chapter, we had a closer look at how to choose appropriate financial products for your unique
circumstances and needs. Some of these products will be discussed in more detail in Parts 3 and 4 of this chapter.
Why can two totally different investment strategies achieve the same success?
What is the difference between a growth investor and a value investor? Which one are you, and why?
Think of your portfolio as a pie chart where each portion represents a certain part of the total investment. The mix
is chosen according to what you want to achieve, the strategy you follow, the risk you are willing to take, and the
expected return.
• Aggressive investment strategies shoot for the highest possible return and are best suited for investors who
have a high-risk tolerance and a longer time horizon. Aggressive portfolios generally have a higher investment
in equities especially the smaller capitalised shares.
• Conservative investment strategies make safety a high priority and are best suited to investors who are
cautious and risk-averse and who have a shorter time horizon. A conservative portfolio generally consists of
mainly cash and cash equivalents or high-quality fixed-income instruments but could include some of the low
volatility top 40 shares, depending on risk appetite of the investor.
• Passive investing strategy: The aim of passive investing is to get market returns through researching, buying
and holding the investments. It is an approach by which investors try to replicate the performance of a specific
market benchmark, typically through the purchase of index funds. Passive investors usually hold shares for
years or decades. In taking a hands-off approach to managing their portfolios, passive investors miss profits
from rising stocks that aren’t included in the index they track – and opportunities to buy at a bargain after-market
correction, but they do take less risk than the active trading investor that is trying to time the financial markets.
2. Asset allocation
The process of investing your money across different asset
classes in order to meet your investment objectives is
known as asset allocation. It simply means that you decide
how you are going to:
• spread your money across different asset classes, such
as equities, bonds, property or the money market.
• select a mix of asset classes that reflects your investment
objectives, time frame and attitude towards risk.
Every investor has different goals. These examples from Vanguard, one of the world’s largest investment
management companies, highlight how different types of investors may choose to structure their investment mix.
An investor in her 30s is saving for retirement, and you might expect her to meet
her goal by investing primarily in equity-based funds. But she’s wary of the stock
market, an inexperienced investor, and sees that equities have suffered recent
declines. She finds that she’s most comfortable with a portfolio that includes 20%
equities and 80% bonds.
A newly retired couple in their 60s first considered a portfolio of 30% equities and
70% bonds. However, they believe their retirement benefits are ample for their
income needs, and they want to build a larger estate to benefit their grandchildren.
They decide on a more aggressive asset allocation consisting of 50% equities and
50% bonds. Here, the additional risk is expected to generate higher long-term
returns.
Note: The Collective Investment Schemes Control Act, Act No. 45 of 2002 regulates the administration,
management, and sale of collective investments.
3.1 Why should I invest in a CIS? 3.2 When will I receive an income?
• It allows me exposure to shares and markets Income is distributed to investors every month,
I might not be able to access otherwise due quarterly, six-monthly or annually depending on the
to the high prices for good shares and money specific type of funds, but investors are taxed on it as
market instruments. it is treated as interest earned or dividends, depending
• Depending on my investment strategy, I on the underlying asset types.
can be in vested anywhere in the world and
benefit from the differential in exchange rates According to SARS investors are taxed on the
and foreign markets’ performances. Note that profits they make (capital gains) when they sell their
some portfolios do not invest offshore at all. participatory interest at a marginal rate which may vary
• A professional investment company manages between 18% (but effectively 0% of your tax rebates
my fund and I can choose from any of the are taken into account) and 45%, depending on the
many diverse CIS funds to tailor my portfolio level of your taxable income (2021).
according to my needs and investment time
horizons. Individual taxpayers enjoy
• I can invest a lump sum, or make a monthly an annual exemption on
contribution, knowing that I have the flexibility to all South African interest
put in as much as I like and access the funds income they earn, set by
when I need them by cashing in a portion or all SARS every year.
of the CIS investment.
• I can check how my investment is performing For the interest income for
daily or in the longer term by examining people under 65, SARS
newspapers, market reviews, relevant websites allows an exemption of
/ apps, annual or semi-annual reports. R23 800 and R34 500 for
• Detailed information on each portfolio is people 65 years and older
updated quarterly and easily available to (2021), at a rate of 18%.
anyone.
Note 1: South Africa uses a “twin peaks” model of regulation of the financial services sector. Monitoring the financial
soundness and health of investment companies is the responsibility of the South African Reserve Bank as the
prudential authority (PA). The Financial Sector Conduct Authority (FSCA) regulates the market conduct of all
financial institutions, including the managers of collective investment schemes.
Note 2: The Financial Intelligence Centre (FIC) administers anti-money laundering requirements of the Financial
Intelligence Centre Act of 2001. The FSCA shares the responsibility by supervising the FIC Act requirements as
delegated to it by the FIC.
• Government bonds or gilts: Government-issued bonds are promises of repayment for money you have lent
to the government or large corporates; government bonds are usually used to invest in infrastructure projects
such as roads, power stations and hospitals. Government bonds tend to be of lower risk as most governments
are regarded as the least risky entity in a country, but they pay a lower interest rate.
• Semi-government stock or bonds: Parastatals like Telkom, Eskom and Transnet also issue bonds to raise
funds for capital projects. They are also deemed to have a lower risk of default and together with government
bonds are the cornerstone of a diversified portfolio. As with bonds, interest and capital are guaranteed by
government in most cases. However, all bonds issued or backed by government are sensitive to interest rate
changes.
• Municipal bonds: Local government entities issue these debt securities to consumers, so they have enough
income to fund public works and build or repair roads, bridges, schools, parks and so on. The issuer of the bond
guarantees to pay interest (coupons) at set periods and to repay the principal debt on a specified date. The
interest paid on the bond is tax deductible.
• Zero-coupon bonds: These bonds are debt securities that are sold at a discount on the understanding that the
investor will receive a profit when they mature and are paid out. They do not pay interest, and their future worth
is greater than their present value.
• Corporate bonds: Companies sometimes issue bonds to raise money for ongoing operations or to expand
their business. These tend to be longer-term debt instruments, and interest is typically paid out twice a year.
The face value of the bond is paid out upon maturity.
REITs can be risky as you are exposed to the property market and economic risk but can render higher profits than
you would get from putting your money in a savings account, for example, to compensate you for that risk.
• Prices are publicly listed and driven by supply and demand, which means a high degree of price transparency.
• You will need to pay a brokerage and administration fee, but the properties you are invested in are managed on
your behalf.
REITs do not attract capital gains tax (CGT) for the disposal of their properties, shares in another REIT, or shares
in a controlled property company. However, CGT must be paid when shares in the REIT are sold by the investor. If
the investor is a trader, the profit would be regarded as income and attract income tax. South African investors do
not pay dividend withholding taxes (DWT) when it is distributed by a REIT. Instead, as a South African investor you
pay normal income tax on all the dividends you receive taxed at your marginal tax rate (on a sliding scale up to a
maximum of 45%). Non-residents are subject to a 20% dividend withholdings tax.
6. Offshore investing
Offshore investing aims to capitalise on advantages offered outside of an investor’s home country.
Offshore investors are interested in investing and spreading their risk in different economies and geographic
regions. A broader selection of companies may want to go this route to earn returns under different conditions.
An offshore investment in your own name in the foreign country can also be a great financial plan for possible future
migration or overseas studies.
South Africans older than 18 are allowed to invest up to R10 million every year in offshore investments. To use this
allowance, investors need a tax clearance certificate from SARS. The SARS certificate is only valid for 12 months,
after which time you will have to apply for a new one.
If you wish to invest more than R10 million per year, you must be able to prove that you legally exported other funds,
including:
• income generated on funds previously retained abroad
• income earned abroad from a foreign employer after 1 July 1997
• inheritances retained abroad
• inheritances paid out abroad but remitted to South Africa
• foreign inheritances
• own foreign capital introduced to South Africa after 1 July 1997.
• funds on which amnesty was granted in terms of the Exchange Control Amnesty and Amendment
• of Taxation Laws Act, 2003 (Act No. 12 of 2003)
• any funds for which specific approval was granted by the SARB
7. Crypto Assets
Crypto assets, commonly but mistakenly called cryptocurrencies as they are not recognised as legal tender, are
becoming hugely popular, but it is an enormously volatile instrument and risky to invest in.
Cypto assets are digital representations of value that are not issued by a central bank, and so are not currency,
not legal tender and not guaranteed by the South African Reserve Bank (SARB). Some well-known crypto assets
include Bitcoin (BTC) and Ethereum (ETH) as well as Litcoin, Namecoin and PPCoin.
They have been used for payments, investments and capital raising. In October 2022, the FSCA declared crypto
assets as a financial product under the FAIS Act. This is because of the wide-scale abuse and fraud that is being
observed in this market, particularly in the area of crypto-derivatives, with many people losing their life savings to
unscrupulous scammers.
Cryptocurrencies are traded, transferred and stored electronically through a decentralised technology called
blockchain. Blockchain records peer-to-peer transactions on a digita ledger. No third party, i.e., a bank, is involved
in the transaction.
Mirror Trading International (MTI) was named the biggest crypto scam of 2020, with R8,6
billion of investors’ bitcoin stolen.
• They have an organic nature. Members of the virtual community agree to accept crypto asset units as a
representation of value in the same way that physical currency is accepted.
• Digital currencies generally exposes end-users to risks, particularly the potential to incur sizeable financial
losses due to wild demand and supply (and therefore price) fluctuations.
• They could be vulnerable to operational risks. A cyber-attack could potentially wipe out the total value of a
digital currency.
• Crypto asset prices are highly volatile and not a suitable investment if needing steady and reliable returns.
Crypto assets can be difficult to sell, meaning that you may not have access to your savings as quickly as you
need.
• Bitcoin’s commitment to a limited production (of 21 million bitcoins) is fundamental to its objective of retaining
value. Although it must be noted that this commitment is not contractual, and there is no clear recourse indicated
should the token be devalued (or more bitcoins mined).
• Crypto assets are not immune to the threat of hacking. In Bitcoin’s short history, the company has been subject
to over 40 thefts, including a few that exceeded a billion dollars in value.
Bitcoin can be bought and sold in South Africa through a Bitcoin exchange that can be accessed through your
personal computer or smartphone using the relevant mobile app. Once you have signed up for an account and it is
verified, you need to obtain a Bitcoin wallet which you use for your Bitcoin transactions.
It is possible to transfer funds from any of the major financial institutions in South Africa to a Bitcoin
exchange, and you can start trading as soon as the funds are cleared. You have the choice of keeping your bitcoins
in the exchange or transferring them to your personal Bitcoin wallet.
Crypto-asset tax implications: SARS will apply general tax principles and tax the income or capital gains
that are received or accrued to the taxpayer. SARS has started auditing cryptocurrency investors and
expects investors to provide proof of transactions from the various crypto investment platforms.
Compliance requirements or exchange control regulations: As an individual, you may purchase crypto assets
from abroad using your single discretionary allowance of up to R1 million and/or your individual foreign investment
allowance of up to R10 million with a tax compliance status PIN (a personal identification number) per calendar
year. You will need to apply for a foreign tax clearance certificate from SARS, which will be valid for 12 months.
IMPORTANT: Marketing of crypto assets is often misleading and focuses on how much you can gain,
without explaining how much you can lose. Make sure providers explain the risks fully and completely, and
disclose fees, Ts&Cs and any conflicts of interest. Know all the facts before you invest.
Investing in property typically has a high barrier Pooled funds are used to pay for a large property,
to entry. However, real estate crowdfunding can like an apartment building, or invest in REITs – in
give you exposure to the property market with little both cases, investors do not have to worry about
capital outlay. Real estate crowdfunding platforms the day-to-day management of properties or
often invest in REITs which, as we have seen, tenant headaches. As these investment vehicles
frequently offer dividends; however, they can also turn a profit, investors will receive proportional
give investors access to private market real estate pay-outs according to how much revenue the
investments. property generates.
A class of shares owned by people that gives them the These are a special series/class of company shares.
right to receive part of the company’s profits. They also Unlike ordinary shares, they have a fixed dividend.
have voting rights. Preference dividends are paid out to shareholders
before ordinary share dividends are paid. Holders
If you own ordinary shares, you can earn an income by of preferred shares do not have voting rights, unlike
selling your shares at a profit when the share price goes ordinary shareholders.
up, or a company meets its profit targets. Companies
can choose to pay out dividends (a share of their profits) If you own preference shares, you have the peace of
to shareholders if they perform well. mind of knowing that, if the company goes bankrupt, you
can recoup some (if not all) of your investment before
As a shareholder, you own a little piece of the company, other shareholders. That said, you have no voting rights
and you have voting rights at its annual general meeting at the company’s annual general meeting (AGM). An
(AGM). However, if a company goes out of business, AGM is a yearly meeting of shareholders of a company
you will be paid last, after the South African Revenue or organisation, convened for holding elections, voting
Service (SARS), employees, holders of preferred on issues and reporting on the year’s events.
shares and creditors.
You can open different accounts with a full-service authorised user of an exchange platform, for instance:
Primary markets: New shares or other securities are issued in primary markets – for example, when a
company sells its shares to the public for the first time, in an initial public offering (IPO).
Secondary markets: Share or other securities that were previously issued are bought and sold (traded) in
secondary markets, such as on stock exchanges.
As a shareowner or shareholder, you must know and understand that you are entitled to information about
the company you hold shares in, which can be obtained via mail, electronic communication or telephone.
Companies listed on stock exchanges are obliged to publish an annual report setting out their audited
financials for the previous year. Both current and future shareholders, as well as the FSCA, must be allowed to
have sight of these.
• Reduced risk: Licensed stock exchanges are highly regulated, and listed companies must comply with
strict requirements before they can list and trade their shares. The result is transparency and fairness,
allowing investors to trade in an efficient investment environment. It gives one peace of mind to know
one is investing in real companies, with supply, demand and easily verifiable company performance
determining market prices. You can also create a diverse portfolio by investing in different companies and
sectors since stock exchanges provide a central marketplace for publicly listed companies to raise capital from
investors.
• Simplicity: Technology has made it easy for investors to access information about shares and
companies, as well as to buy and sell shares. It is also easy to disinvest (cash out your investment) if you need
money. Increasingly, people are showing an interest in the stock exchange because they are not intimidated
by the investment process.
• Build wealth: Investing in equities is one of the easiest ways to grow one’s wealth in the long term.
Although share prices rise and fall all the time, a diversified portfolio can deliver solid results over time, providing
shareholders with dividends or profits earned from the sale of shares when their value increases.
R
spread of equities rather than in the stocks of one or
two companies. This helps because it spreads out
your risk so that when one share is not performing
well, there are others that do. However, risk tolerance
is very specific to each investor. Some may choose
to have a balanced portfolio with a mix of stocks and
bonds to spread their risk, while others may opt for a
high-risk focused portfolio.
There are different types of investors who are interested in funding private companies:
• Angel investors: Funding from friends or family members on very favourable terms to start a business.
• Venture capital investors: These investors get involved after the start-up phase and usually consist of a group
of more savvy investors offering growth capital, managerial know-how and other operational assistance. At this
stage, a firm is seen to have at least some long-term potential.
• Mezzanine investors: These investors invest in private companies to raise funds for specific projects or help
with the acquisition through a hybrid of debt and equity financing. This type of financing can provide more
generous returns compared to typical corporate debt. Mezzanine loans are most commonly used to expand
established companies.
ROI measures and evaluates the performance or potential return from a business or investment. When you invest
in a private business, your return on investment is decided by how well the business does. If it makes a good profit,
you will have a good ROI. If it makes a loss, so will you.
To calculate ROI, the benefit (or return) of an investment is divided by the cost of the investment multiplied by 100.
The result is expressed as a percentage or, sometimes, a ratio.
One disadvantage of ROI is that it does not consider how long you have had an investment and so makes it difficult
to compare two investments over time.
11. Conclusion
As you can see from Part 3 of this chapter, intermediate investors are more informed and work with more complex
investment opportunities.
We have discussed a variety of investment vehicles, some of which were built on what we learnt in the previous
chapter, and some of which were newly introduced, namely asset allocation, how to invest in CISs, bonds, shares,
and investing in a business.
1. Introduction
By now you have learned quite a few basics about investing and you might want to start your own personal journey
in buying shares. Do not wait too long, because only practise makes perfect. Direct investing in shares is an on-
going, evolving and learning journey with no final destination to reach before you can start.
There are two things you need to know to put together a diversified portfolio:
Take note: Getting to know the company you want to invest in is a cornerstone to success.
Useful sources:
• The company’s official website
• Your authorised user of exchanges (formerly known as a stockbroker)
• Financial/business newspapers.
According to Ralph Speirs, JSE CSI Officer, Marketing and Corporate Affairs, your research should tell you that
the company you are interested in is growing and financially sound, and that it is operating in a strong and growing
industry, offering services and products that consumers want.
Due diligence
An investigation, audit, or review performed to confirm facts or details of a matter or company under
consideration. In the financial world, a due diligence requires an examination of financial records before
entering into a proposed transaction with another party.
Fundamental analysis
The process of getting to know a company through analysing its financial statements and operations.
The hard truth is that if you want to do your due diligence and want to be able to read between the lines of financial
statements or annual reports, you will need a basic understanding of accounting principles to take a closer look
at the company’s financial statements. Fundamental analysis is a tried and tested method of identifying a good
company, and therefore, a good share.
While this is easy for an accountant, reading and understanding financial statements can be daunting for the rest
of us. Let’s look at a few necessary concepts to get you started.
A company’s balance sheet (Statement of Financial Position) gives you a financial summary of their net worth at
the end of a period. It measures the company’s assets less liabilities or what they have minus what they owe.
Net worth is also known as equity or net asset value (NAV). The balance sheet is an important document
used to make sure that a company is in a strong financial position.
The income statement (Statement of Comprehensive Income) is the profit and loss account statement that
records how much money or profit the business has generated over a period of time.
Financial Ratios
Financial ratios are tools to identify relationships between two or more figures found in the financial statements.
Earnings per share (EPS) is the single most important ratio in determining a share’s price. It measures the
portion of the business’s profits that are allocated to each ordinary share that is outstanding and is a means
to calculate the return on your investment.
EPS is the price you are willing to pay for the future stream of earnings. It is also a major component used
to calculate the price-to-earnings valuation ratio.
You cannot begin to consider share prices and their value without understanding and including the
Price to Earnings ratio (P/E). You may sometimes also hear it referred to as the earnings multiple and is the
most widely used barometer of a company’s value.
Now that we know what the important parts of financial statements are called and what they are for, the
question is what are you supposed to keep an eye out for?
You need to focus on the sales, income, debt numbers and liquidity (cash) in the financial statements to
guide you, so let us look at those.
• A signal of a growing company is one that is making more money in the current year than it did in the
preceding year. Take a look and compare this year’s net income to last year’s net income.
Net Income is simply a company’s earnings or profit earned after tax. This number is found on a
company’s income statement and is an important measure of how profitable the company has been over a
period of time.
• If a company offers desirable products and services and is competitive in its industry, it is
reasonable to expect its sales to increase.
Sales or revenue (income) refers to the money that a company receives when customers buy goods and
services from them. It is also reflected on the income statement.
Make sure that these figures reflect growth; some suggest that at least a 5% to 10% rise from the
previous year’s number is necessary to justify a company as growing.
• In recent years debt has been a growing problem for many firms and those that carry too much are at
risk of bankruptcy. A potentially bankrupt business obviously holds out little hope for a wealthier you,
so it is prudent to note whether the company has low or easily repayable debt on their books.
Debt
A company’s balance sheet will tell whether debt is a growing item or whether it is at least under control.
The debt-to-equity ratio will tell you how dependent the company is on debt or how much the company owes
and owns.
A debt-to-equity ratio below 1 is desirable, while a ratio higher than 2 is cause for concern because it tells
you that for each rand a company owns in assets there is twice as much debt.
Another financial ratio that will help you decide what to buy is the return-on-equity ratio (ROE). A ROE of 15
or more is often seen as a viable investment opportunity.
5. Conclusion
Part 4 of this chapter focused on the advanced investor who wants to try his or her hand at direct investing. We
looked at where to find more information about a company or share, the importance of getting to know a com-
pany before you decide to invest, the importance of research and what your research should tell you. Lastly, we
learned more about financial statements and what to look out for.
Next, you can test your newly acquired knowledge on these themes.
Name 4 things that you want your research to tell you about a company
In what way do dividends show you whether a company is in good financial health?
1. Introduction
A stock exchange has two main functions, namely
In other words, they help to bring a company to market and then help the company to trade its shares.
As an investor, it is beneficial to have at least an elementary understanding of how a stock exchange works.
So, let’s have a look at some of the inner workings of a stock exchange. We will use the JSE as an example
1. Do not borrow money to invest, and do not invest money that you cannot afford to lose.
2. Superior returns (high rewards) are not risk-free.
In the old days, traders on the market would shout out the prices at which they wanted to buy or sell shares. This
happened on a trading floor and was called the open outcry system.
The open outcry system has since been replaced by a new system called the central order book trading system.
Today, instead of shouting out the prices at which they want to buy or sell stocks, modern traders enter the prices
into the central order book trading system electronically. The central order book trading system then keeps an
anonymous list of the prices at which the traders want to buy or sell. The system finds and matches buyers and
sellers that entered the same price into the system. The moment a buyer and seller are matched, the system does
an automatic trade.
As an investor, you can still instruct your authorised user of trading platforms (your stockbroker) to buy or sell your
stocks on a current trading price available on the order book.
Diversification
A risk management strategy that mixes a wide variety of investments within a portfolio.
A financial market index often serves as a benchmark to show you how well your investment performed. Indices
point to the benchmarks for the performance of a group of assets, e.g., a class of assets or an industry’s shares.
Indices also give you a look at how share prices change continually. This means that you can see how your shares
(or a whole industry or segment or even the entire market) performed and what they are worth at a given time.
The two most common indices on the JSE (2021) are the FTSE/JSE Africa All Share Index (ALSI) and the Top
40 Index. The ALSI represents 99% of the full market capitalisation (market value) of all eligible equities listed on
the Main Board of the JSE, while the Top 40 Index tracks the average moves or price of the 40 most investable
companies in the ALSI.
4. Conclusion
After reading Part 1 of chapter 5, we now know a little
more about trading platforms, how exchanges help to
bring companies to the market; and then help to trade their
shares, as well as about indices. We also looked at the
central order book trading system of the JSE
1. Introduction
As an intermediate investor, you want to find new investment opportunities to grow your money. You know that
following the news, reading market reports and keeping an eye on indices will help you find those new investment
opportunities.
In this section, we will discuss the different indices on the JSE, understanding financial news reporting,
online trading and derivatives.
• The vast number of indices that are available allow you to track and benchmark almost any focus you have
within the JSE.
• The small-cap index and mid-cap index focus on size. The small-cap represents the top 96%-99% of the
full market cap value of all ordinary securities listed on the main board of the JSE which qualify as eligible for
index inclusion. The mid cap represents the middle 85% - 96% and the large cap represents 85% of the full
market capital value.
• The Resource 10 Index and Industrial 25 Index are two of the sector focused indices.
• Prices can also be benchmarked by following the Preference Share or the Dividend Plus indices. Specialised
indices such as the Preference Share Index do not necessarily have much bearing on an investor’s specific
portfolio holding, because it is unlikely that an investor would include each of the preference shares in his
portfolio and in the same weighting as the index.
• FTSE/JSE Africa Index Series: Designed to represent the performance of listed South African companies,
providing investors with a comprehensive and complementary set of indices, based on a joint venture between
the JSE and FTSE Russell (FTSE), which measure the performance of the major capital and industry segments
of the African market.
Good financial journalists are, unfortunately, a rare breed. This is because few have the skill to analyse the story
behind the numbers. You will not necessarily learn much if you read every available article and opinion since
information can be sensationalised or simply incorrect. It is important to be discerning when it comes to your
sources – there is no point in digesting dozens of media releases that spin the facts, present incorrect figures, or
take company spokespeople at face value.
Credible newspapers, magazines and websites will educate you rather than feed you rehashed press releases.
South African options to consider include Financial Mail, Finweek, Business Day, Fin24, Sake24, Moneyweb and
business programmes on television. Keeping abreast with financial and company news will further broaden your
understanding of the investment environment.
• Is the article based on data or opinion, i.e., how factual is the information?
• Is it descriptive of past conditions or predictive of the future? Most articles look to the past while very few give
a perspective on what might still come.
• Is the theory set out in the article verifiable?
• Understand the consensus: Find what is generally agreed upon. Once you’ve done the groundwork on a
specific investment opportunity, you need to see through the generally accepted beliefs in order to follow it or
bet against it. Jot down what you read to help organise your thoughts.
• Find opposing opinions: You need to understand the other side of the trade. This means reading opinions
that differ from yours.
• Question what you read: Reporters are under intense deadline pressure and often frame issues in a way that
is confusing or distorted. The information may be incomplete, misleading, or simply wrong.
• Respect the data: Charts, tables, and numbers are good places to start for corporate results and economic
data. Make sure to check the primary source when possible.
• Avoid partisan interpretation: Turn off your political bias when you read and interpret the news but be wary
of commentators who have political agendas.
• Develop your own framework: Before you read the news, you must have your own framework in place for
decision-making. Otherwise, you’ll end up unduly influenced by what you read.
• Investing takes a long-term approach to the markets, for instance when you invest to supplement your retire-
ment income.
• Trading involves short-term buy and sell strategies to maximise your returns daily, monthly, or quarterly.
• Investors are more likely to ride out short-term losses, while traders will attempt to make transactions that can
help them profit quickly from fluctuating markets.
• Both attempt to make a profit in the financial markets, but they differ substantially, especially in risk.
• Trading software usually consists of a charting package that helps traders make buy and sell decisions.
• For a trader who trades frequently, this can be a vital part of achieving success as charting helps to evaluate
patterns in the trading data.
• Most online stockbrokers will offer some online trading software, and that should be sufficient for someone just
starting out.
A word of warning: Some trading software companies try to sell trading software and educational packages for
traders at high prices. They cold-call you and make online trading sound easy, which is not the case. Education is
freely available on the internet. However, if you do decide to buy a top trading software package, compare prices
first.
Online trading can be risky. While online trading gives you total control over your collection of shares (portfolio), you
would also need to research companies by yourself. If you do not have experience and background knowledge,
that may be difficult to do.
However, you will remember from chapter 4 that you can open different accounts with a full-service authorised
user of an exchange platform, namely a discretionary or a non-discretionary investment account. Opening a non-
discretionary investment account would give you the opportunity to decide on what trades to make after receiving
advice from an authorised user who has reviewed your financial position and investment targets. This opens an
opportunity to gain investment experience together with your authorised user.
As digital or online trading has become easier and more popular, the danger of overextending yourself or being
scammed has grown as well, especially among unsophisticated investors. Online trading may seem a safe option,
but scams abound on digital platforms, and you could easily fall victim to one of them.
• Scams: Fraudsters take advantage of economic downturns or crises, and investors should be increasingly on
their guard. Unfortunately, it is not always easy to tell a scam from a genuine investment opportunity. When
in doubt, ask an authorised user of exchange platforms or consult with the FSCA, as he or she has a good
understanding of the investment landscape.
• Speed: Although digital trading platforms are easy to access, and one can execute rapid trades, there is a risk
of ‘gambling’ with your money, overinvesting or making poor choices in a hurry. Most platforms limit how much
you can invest and what you can buy, which can prevent you from jeopardising your financial security.
• To hedge a position: The investor hedges their investment in stocks by purchasing derivatives that will protect
against a price decline such as put options, short fences, etc.
• To increase leverage: The purpose of leverage is to enhance the magnitude of returns. The client only pays
a fraction of the exposure (i.e., margin). The risk is that the investor can lose more than their initial investment.
• To speculate on an asset’s movement: This involves trying to make a profit from a security’s price change.
The main purpose is to profit from betting on or against the direction you think the price of an asset will move.
• Call overwriting: A client sells a call option on a stock that the investor currently owns. Strike price of the call
is typically higher than current stock price. This is a yield enhancement strategy for buy only funds. The option
premium adds to the stock returns of the fund’s portfolio.
There are three main types of derivatives, although any contract written that promises returns based on an
underlying referenced asset, is a derivative:
• options
• futures/forward contracts
• swaps
OPTIONS STRATEGIES
Long call: You believe a security’s price will increase and buy the right (long) to own (call) it. If the security’s
price exceeds the exercise price by more than the premium paid for the call, you have made a profit.
Long put: You believe a security’s price will decrease and buy the right (long) to sell (put) the security. If the
security’s price is below the exercise price by more than the premium paid for the put, you have made a profit.
Short call: You believe a security’s price will decrease and sell (write) a call. If you sell a call, the counterparty
(the holder of a long call) has control over whether or not the option will be exercised. For you, as the writer of
the call, the payoff is equal to the premium received by the buyer of the call if the security’s price declines. You
will lose money if the security rises more than the exercise price plus the premium.
Short put: You believe the security’s price will increase and sell (write) a put. As the writer of the put, the payoff
is equal to the premium received by the buyer of the put if the security’s price rises, but if the security’s price
falls below the exercise price minus the premium, you lose money.
By separating the price from the physical delivery of goods, futures markets remove the uncertainty
associated with the price (because the price is determined in advance). An agreement is made between
you and a buyer or seller that an asset will be bought or sold in the future for a specified price. These
contracts are usually written using the spot or the most current price. The purchaser’s profit or loss is
calculated by the difference between the spot price at the time of delivery and the forward or future price. Profits or
losses are cash settled. If you want to lower your risk, futures may be a good choice.
Futures are standardised contracts that trade on exchanges, while forwards are non-standard contracts that are
traded over the counter (OTC). Forwards are inherently riskier products in terms of exposure to counterparty credit
risk, much less liquidity due to their customisable nature, and no price transparency to value the positions, which is
one of the benefits of exchange trading.
A swap is a derivative contract through which two parties exchange the cash flows or liabilities from two different
financial instruments. Most of these swaps involve cash flows based on a notional principal amount (a predeter-
mined amount) such as a loan or bond or any other instrument.
• Interest rate swaps: Parties exchange a fixed-rate loan for one with a floating rate or the opposite. If one
party has a fixed-rate loan but has floating rate liabilities, they may enter into a swap with another party and
exchange a fixed rate for a floating rate to match liabilities. Interest rate swaps can also be entered through
option strategies, while a swaption gives the owner the right but not the obligation to enter into the swap.
• Currency swaps: One party exchanges loan payments and principal in one currency for payments and prin-
cipal in another currency.
• Commodity swaps: A contract where a party and counterparty agree to exchange cash flows, which are de-
pendent on the price of an underlying commodity.
6. Conclusion
Now that you have a better idea of indices, how to interpret financial news reporting, online trading and derivatives,
it is time for self-assessment.
Define derivatives
What is a swap?
Costs add up. You do not just lose the tiny amount of fees you pay but also all the growth that money might have had
for years into the future. Saving even a small portion of your fees can make a big difference to your end investment.
Example: Imagine you have R100 000 invested. If the account earned 6% a year for the next 25 years and had no
costs or fees, you’d end up with about R430 000. If you paid 2% a year in costs for the investment, after 25 years,
you’d only have about R260 000. You can see the damage: The 2% you paid every year would wipe out almost
40% of your final account value. That 2% is not as small as it seemed, right?
A 2013 National Treasury report noted that if you reduced your annual investment fees from 2.5% to 0.5%, you
would receive a benefit of 60% greater at retirement after 40 years. That means retiring with R1.6 million instead
of R1 million.
Every transaction in shares is subject to trading fees. Some can be attributed to the mandatory costs incurred,
Securities Transfer Tax(STT), Investor Protection Levy (IPL) such as VAT and STRATE (South Africa’s central
securities depository) fees, while others include the charges incurred by brokers. These fees and expenses erode
your investment returns, especially if excessive buying and selling strategies are employed.
Clearly, it is important to pay attention to different fee structures when you decide on how you want to transact
within the share markets and when you choose an FSP.
1.3 Tax
Your growing portfolio may also be subject to tax payable to the government.
It is important to understand that unless it is a tax-free investment or tax-deductible portion, your investment is
subject to tax on your income earned or capital gains. These taxes come at different rates, so it is important to
know the difference.
• Dividend income is paid out of the profits of a corporation to the stockholders. If you receive an income out of
dividends, you may be expected to pay dividends tax. Normally the amount due is withheld from your dividend
payment and paid over to SARS by a withholding agent.
• Capital gains are profits made when an investment is sold at a higher price than the original purchase price.
The difference between the original purchase price and the higher price you sold your investment for, is subject
to CGT.
Inflation is a rise in the price level of an economy, which erodes the purchasing power of the currency
operating in that economy. In short, inflation changes the value of your money over time. If you look back to
the past, it is obvious that everything was much cheaper. However, if you think about how much your
money will be worth in 20 years’ time, you may realise that everything will be far more expensive than it is now!
Keeping up with inflation is the very least your money should be doing. You can try to beat inflation by
aiming for growth in both capital returns and dividend yields to avoid a loss of purchasing power.
Your real return on any investment can only be calculated when inflation is considered. If you earn a return of 10%,
but inflation is at 6%, your real return will only be 4%.
• Take note: When considering dividend-paying shares, make sure that you are taking inflation into account.
For example, if a company consistently pays a 5% dividend over five years, but inflation has risen from 5% to
10%, then the dividend is disappointing. One advantage of dividends, however, is that they generate cash for
reinvestment, so they offer some protection against inflation.
• Inflation hedges are investments that aim to protect you against inflation. Including inflation hedges in your
portfolio may help you eliminate this risk of inflation. Gold is deemed by some to be a good example of such
an inflation hedging investment. Over the years, many investors have recognised that gold is one of the most
reliable hedges (or protections) against inflation – therefore, they include gold mining company shares in their
investment portfolio.
MAJOR DIFFERENCES
Technical analysis Fundamental analysis
Study of price action Study of factors affecting supply and demand
Studies the effect of market moves Studies the cause of market moves
Source: JSE, Grow My Wealth
2.4 What is charting?
Technical analysts make use of a variety of price charts in their attempts to predict price movement. Charts are
the working tools of the technical analyst. They are like a map showing you where a stock has been and where it
“might” be going.
The two primary variables for technical analysis are the time frames considered and the particular technical
indicators that a trader chooses to use.
The technical analysis time frames shown on charts range from one minute to monthly, or even yearly, time spans.
Of course, no technical indicator is perfect, and none of them gives signals that are 100% accurate all the time.
Smart traders are always on the lookout for warning signs that signals from their chosen indicators may be
misleading. Technical analysis, done well, can improve your profitability as a trader.
3. Conclusion
Always keep an eye on the costs of your investments at all times. The money you lose to costs rises exponentially
over time. Because investments with higher costs have to overcome these expenses, their performance tends to
suffer compared to lower-cost investments.
Successful investors are not afraid of research and more research. The more you know and understand what you
are investing in, the safer your investments are. Technical analysis and charting are two types of tools you can use
to keep abreast of what is happening in the financial markets.
Complete the following sentence: A savvy investor knows their goals continuously
Many are being swindled out of their hard-earned cash by fraudsters who promise them a good return on their
investments. Whenever the supposed ‘greatest investment of all time’ presents itself, speak to your authorised
financial advisor to find out how it really works and if it is legitimate or not. It is important to ensure that any
financial advisor, platform, and investment product is fully licensed. As an investor, you have a right and a duty to
ask all the necessary questions.
Unsolicited investment opportunities that come to you via cold-calls, social media or unsolicited emails can
often be scams. The fraudsters may even pretend to represent an established wealth manager but will ask that you
only contact them on a personal email address or number. In addition, the fraudster could say the offer is available
for a short period of time only as it is greatly in demand. The fraudster may send you official-looking documentation
and ask for a copy of your ID or proof of address, but this is simply to gain your trust – and quick access to your
funds.
If an investment offers you very high returns, you need to start asking questions about the legality thereof, as well
as the associated risk. The old saying “If something looks too good to be true, it probably is” still holds true. Be wary
of promises of excessive returns, and always get a second opinion if you feel uncomfortable or are unsure of the
terms and conditions.
Be vigilant. It is best to take your time and make sure an investment opportunity is valid before making a financial
decision. Remember, scammers do not care about you – they only want your money.
A pyramid scheme is a scheme that requires you to make an initial entry payment after which you would be
required to recruit other members before earning a return on the original ‘investment’. The more recruits, the
greater the return.
Ponzi scheme
Ponzi schemes are based on fraudulent investment management services. Members contribute money to
the ‘portfolio manager’ who promises them a high return. When those members want their money back,
they are paid out with the incoming funds contributed by participants who join at a later stage. The person
organising this type of fraud manages the entire operation. They merely transfer funds from one client to
another. There is no real investment product, or the investment product does not provide the returns for the
high pay-outs to “investors”.
2. Types of scams
2.1 Pyramid schemes
These continue to be popular, and unfortunately, a large number of people still fall for them, lured by the prom-
ise of impressive returns. These schemes are illegal, so if you become aware of one, report it to SARB and the
South African Police Services. There are also a number of scam awareness websites where consumers post their
experiences and warnings to others.
Pyramid schemes recruit members, promising to pay them or provide them with goods and services in
exchange for enrolling other members in the scheme. Money for this ‘investment’ comes in when new members are
recruited. Although this seems harmless enough and not all that different from crowdfunding strategies, there is no
underlying business or investment opportunity and no legitimate products and services to be enjoyed.
A pyramid scheme gets its name from the fact that there are a few people at the top of the pyramid receiving a ‘return’
on their money, and large numbers of people at the base who cannot recruit additional members and who therefore
simply lose the money they have put in (the sliding scale of returns benefits the founders and early adopters the
most). When they report the pyramid scheme to the authorities, the founders will likely have disappeared with the
cash.
Ponzi schemes appear to be similar to pyramid schemes, but a Ponzi scheme sees initial investors handing their
money over to a portfolio manager who has no real investment products (or investment product with returns
too low to fund the high pay-outs) but who pays out funds to investors with money coming in from additional
investors. The scheme was named after Charles Ponzi, who told investors that he could make a profit of 50% for
them in a mere three months. The 1920s swindler was able to maintain the illusion that he was running a legitimate
business for as long as new investors were contributing funds and not demanding repayment of their capital.
R
Stokvel
Stokvels have a long history in South Africa, and most are trusted savings vehicles. Unfortunately, fraudsters
have found a way to turn some stokvels into pyramid schemes, using a WhatsApp chat group to reach members.
Members have to pay a joining fee of R200 and are promised a return of around R1 000 for recruiting two or more
people to the group. This is not how traditional stokvel work, which sees a group of likeminded people coming
together to save for particular goals. Each stokvel member puts money into a kitty each month (say R100), and
every member has a turn to receive the pooled funds (R100 from 10 members if R1 000).
Stokvels should be registered with the National Stokvel Association of South Africa (NASASA). If in doubt, ask
the stokvel for the NASASA registration number and check with NASASA to make sure. Do not join an illegitimate
stokvel as it may be a scam.
The following fraudulent schemes have seen many South Africans robbed of millions of rands:
• WhatsApp stokvels
• Pipcoin, a cryptocurrency scheme
• SAcoin, a rare coin investment scam
• Copy Profit Success (CPS) Global
• BTC Global, a cryptocurrency trading
platform
• Mavrodi Mundial Moneybox
(MMM)
• Invest200, an invest-money-for-profit
scheme
• Kubus scheme, which involved the
cultivation of milk yeast cultures to
make a beauty product
Case study
Some schemes may go as far as to pay you to invest, encouraging you to make a similar outlay.
Sandra was very excited about the money-making advice she received.
A friend told her that if she invested R1 000 she would get R200 back after a month. “That is a return of
20%,” the friend said excitedly. Sandra felt optimistic about future profits. She would never get that kind of
return at a bank!
She decided to invest R1 000 every month, but before she could do so her father told her that he had spoken
to his authorised financial advisor.
The financial advisor saw the “investment opportunity” in quite a different light.
“Beware”, he said, warning that Sandra was most likely “investing” in a fraudulent scheme. “Remember that
all you see at the end of the month is the R200 “return” you get from the scheme. Where is the rest of your
R1 000? It is still with the scammer who has made R800 – R600 more than you.
“If you invest R1 000 and get R200 back after a month (a 20% return), you may feel optimistic about future
returns and put in a further R1 000. However, the R200 “return” came from the R1 000 you put in, and the
scammers now have R1 800 while all you have is R200!
Before investing, approach a licensed advisor to do a risk assessment and suitability analysis.
Keep up to date with warnings issued by the FSCA about fraudulent forex schemes by visiting;
https://www.fsca.co.za/Pages/Media-Releases.aspx
Other online trading scams include those trading in stocks, crypto-asset, precious metals, commodities and binary
options.
Many Forex fraudsters and scam artists use social media to find their next victims. Don’t be
Quick lured or fooled by images of fancy lifestyles. Do your due diligence before parting with your
Tip! hard-earned cash!
If you have found an opportunity via a website, check for red flags that may indicate it is fraudulent:
If the answer to any of these is ‘no’, it may be a scam webpage. Another indicator of a fake website may be
spelling mistakes in the URL or content, or poor language use.
Fake investment websites steal a well-known person’s identity and use it to extract money from you by posing as
well-known financial institutions. They create the impression that this famous person has benefited greatly from the
scheme, and so could you.
These websites are often hard to distinguish from genuine ones, display one type of product promising a high
return, and ask you to leave your contact details to receive an investment brochure.
Here, a fraudster will deliberately buy the shares of a very low-priced stock of a small company of which the shares
are not often traded. False information is then spread about the company. This increases the interest in the stock,
which increases the stock price. Investors start buying the stock as they believe that they are getting good value for
money, pushing the price of the stock up even more. At this point, the fraudster dumps his or her shares at a high
price and disappears, leaving many people caught with worthless shares of stock.
Source phone numbers yourself: Do not call back on a number you have been given by the person you are
speaking to, either by email or by phone. Only call back on a trusted number you can look up yourself.
Watch out for brand impersonation: Brand impersonation fraud is increasingly common. If you have been
contacted by email, pay attention to the sender’s address. Is it the real address of the institution that pretends to
contact you?
When is it too good to be true: True investment opportunities will usually be accessible for longer than a few
hours or days. If you are being pressured to invest now because the opportunity will not be available for long, tell
the person you are speaking to that you do not mind missing the opportunity if that is what it takes to make sure
the investment offered is real.
Take your time: Do not rush into anything. Do not disregard fraud warnings when making payments, and always
make sure you are 100% certain it is not a scam before making an investment.
Guarantees: Be suspicious of anyone who guarantees you a return. The investment will always carry a degree of
risk.
Unauthorised financial advisors: Many scams involve unauthorised financial advisors selling unregistered
investments, including shares, bonds, hedge funds and other fictitious instruments.
Overly consistent returns: Investments that go up month after month or that provide remarkably steady returns
irrespective of the market conditions are likely to be scams.
Complex strategies: Avoid anyone who credits their success with a highly complex investing technique. If they
cannot explain it clearly, walk away.
Missing documentation: If someone tries to sell you an investment without a prospectus or an offering circular,
he or she may be selling an unregistered investment.
• The FSCA will be able to tell you if the company is authorised to conduct business in South Africa.
Fraudsters have been known to steal the registration number of an approved financial services provider, so
you may need to dig a little deeper.
• Pyramid schemes hold seminars or household meetings to attract new members or send unsolicited messages
via email, post or social media. They can also ‘cold call’ you. Few people like to be rude, which is something
they are counting on – and they also rely on the fact that you may keep such a meeting from your spouse,
children or neighbours. It is best to discuss possible opportunities with people you know as you are in a good
position to warn others about a potential scam. Fraudsters often use members to attest to their good reputation
at meetings, but this does not mean they are above reproach – do your homework.
• Some legitimate businesses also contact you through various methods, so make sure you know the
difference between a fraudulent and a genuine organisation.
Important questions to ask a person or company that wants you to invest with them
6. Conclusion
Impatience and greed, as well as economically challenging times, and the uncertainty they bring, are breeding
grounds for fraudsters. Do not become the hard-working investor who gets swindled out of their hard-earned cash
by empty promises of good returns.
Be vigilant and take your time before you make any financial decisions.
List as many questions as you can remember to ask a company or person who wants you to invest with
them?
The Financial Sector Regulation Act (Act 9 of 2017) establishes the FSCA as a market conduct regulator,
responsible for ensuring that financial institutions treat their customers fairly, in all interactions and that the
financial markets are fair and efficient for investors. To achieve this, the FSCA monitors financial institutions to
promote their compliance with laws that govern their conduct, Treating customers fairly outcomes below:
Financial Customers
People who buy financial products and services, also referred to as consumers.
TCF Outcome 1
Customers must feel confident that they are dealing with an institution where TCF is at the core of their culture.
TCF Outcome 2
Financial products and services in the retail market which are sold and marketed are designed according to the
needs of the customers identified and targeted accordingly.
TCF Outcome 3
Customers are provided with clear information and kept appropriately informed before, during and after point of
sale.
TCF Outcome 4
Advice is suitable and according to the customer’s circumstances.
TCF Outcome 5
Service is of an acceptable standard and products perform as customers have been led to expect.
TCF Outcome 6
Customers do not face unreasonable post-sale barriers when they want to change a product, switch providers,
submit a claim or make a complaint.
In terms of FAIS Act, who can give advice and render intermediary services (financial services)?
• Any person who gives advice or renders an intermediary service or both in respect of a financial product must
be authorised as an FSP or must be appointed as a representative of an authorised FSP.
• FSPs are authorised by the FSCA, and representatives are appointed by the FSP.
• It is the responsibility of the FSP to ensure that its representatives are fit and proper. This, among others,
entails that the FSP must check that its representatives are persons who are honest and have integrity, are
competent to render financial services.
As a consumer you should always check that your financial services provider (financial
Quick institution) is properly licensed and authorised by the FSCA. To confirm, visit www.fsca.
Tip! co.za, email enquiries@fsca.co.za or call 0800 20 3277
• Collective Investment Schemes Control Act (CISCA), which governs financial institutions that provide and
manage CIS portfolios.
• Pension Fund Act, which governs all the different types of retirement funds, including those provided by insurers
and occupational funds provided by employers, as well as the boards of funds and fund administrators.
• Insurance Act, which governs insurers and related persons.
• Banks Act: governs banks and any person or entity that accepts deposits.
• Financial Markets Act: governs the financial markets, financial market participants and financial
instruments.
• A written quotation
• Purchase document within 30 days of signing the application
• Information on how to submit a claim
• The total cost of the financial product per month e.g. insurance
• Commission paid to any intermediary and how this is calculated
• Fees for services rendered in relation to a financial product
• Inclusions and exclusions of the policy i.e. what does the policy cover and not cover
• Physical address and telephone number of the financial services provider
• Who to complain to if you are unhappy with the financial product or service you have received (the dispute
resolution process).
If, for instance, you are the owner of a policy, the grace period must be clearly set out in the policy document. It
usually means that you are allowed to skip (not pay) your premium for one month, and your policy will remain valid.
You will have to catch up with your skipped payment in the following month.
You have 30 days to change your mind after you signed a purchase contract. This is called a “cooling off” period.
You can always complain or raise a dispute with your financial institution if you feel you have not been treated fairly;
if the financial product or service does not meet your expectations; or if you have received poor service.
You also have access to alternative dispute resolution channels if you are not satisfied with how the financial
institution has handled your complaint as listed below.
An empowered consumer is someone who is able to make informed financial decisions and can hold
his or her financial institution to account for poor service received or broken commitments. If you believe
that a financial institution has provided you with poor or sub-standard service and has not lived up to its
contracted commitments or has treated you unfairly, you have the right to complain and be heard.
Herewith the general dispute resolution process to follow when engaging with the financial services industry:
Step 1: Write a formal letter of complaint against the relevant company/person or entity whose conduct/
product/service you want to complain about and give them the opportunity to respond in writing.
Step 2: If you are unhappy with their response you may refer your complaint to the relevant Ombudsman.
Step 3: If you are still not satisfied with their response, you may contact the FSCA. Read more about the
role of the FSCA in section 4 below specifically with regards to investment complaints.
See Parts 1 and 3 for the FSCA’s and the Financial Sector Ombudsmen’s contact information respectively,
in the USEFUL CONTACTS section.
There are currently five different Ombud schemes in the financial sector, each providing an impartial dispute
resolution platform that is free to consumers and external to financial institutions. Your contract must provide you
with the contact details of the various ombudsmen. Refer to Part 3 for a list of the Financial Sector Ombudsmen’s
in the USEFUL CONTACTS section towards the end of this guide.
• Contravening or failing to comply with any instruction given by the investor or any agreement or
mandate entered into with the client.
• Acting dishonestly, negligently or recklessly.
• Treating the investor unreasonably or unfairly.
In a 2012 article titled South Africa: Know Your Rights and Your Responsibilities, corporate and commercial law firm
Werksmans Attorneys pointed out the following consumer responsibilities.
• Read. Read agreements, including the terms and conditions, before signing. If you are unsure about
anything, ask questions so nothing is unclear.
• React. If you receive any kind of legal documents, such as a summons or notice of motion, react as quickly as
possible because you are given a limited number of days to respond. The amount of time you have will be in
the document.
• Record. Write down as much as you can – from simple details such as the name of the person that you
spoke to at a consumer complaints desk, to more important details such as discussions and resulting
arrangements. If you ever have a legal problem at a later stage, it will be far easier to prove the facts if you
have them in writing.
• Review. Check quotations and prices before accepting them. According to the Consumer Protection Act (CPA),
you are entitled to a written quotation for any repair or maintenance services over R1 in value.
• Reconsider. The CPA allows you to reconsider a purchase made as a result of direct marketing. But it is your
responsibility to reconsider and inform the supplier of your decision in writing, within five business days from
the date on which the transaction was concluded or the goods were delivered to you.
• Rely. Consumers have the right to complain to the relevant Ombudsman of certain service industries
(e.g., banking, credit, motor, press, short-term and life insurance), who will try to mediate between you and
the supplier to solve the issue. However, it is your responsibility to choose respectable suppliers that are
governed by these bodies if you wish to rely on this option.
• Resolve. It is your responsibility to try to resolve your consumer rights issue with the supplier directly.
Certain resources will only be accessible once you have done so.
• Resist. Think about the consequences of overspending and resist the temptation. Be aware of the impact of
your consumer behaviour on your own pocket and the community around you.
• Relay. Tell others what you learn about consumer rights and responsibilities. The National Consumer forum
highlights the following consumer responsibility: “organise together as consumers to develop the strength
and influence and to promote and protect our interests”. The CPA allows for recognised consumer protection
groups to act and protect the interests of consumers individually or collectively.
The FSCA is mandated to educate and protect consumers and investors. It does this through supervising
compliance of financial institutions with financial sector laws, and by educating and empowering financial
consumers.
It is important to recognise that the FSCA does not resolve individual customer complaints or
contractual disputes between the customer and his or her financial institution. However, the FSCA
may investigate complaints where there is an alleged transgression of law, or where there is a
concern that the conduct and practices of a financial institution may pose a risk for investors at large, rather than
a single investor.
The Financial Markets Act (FMA) makes provision for an exchange, a central securities depository, and an
independent clearinghouse. The FMA makes provisions for exchange platforms to use the self-regulatory
organisations (SRO) model to supervise and regulate their respective members. An SRO, like a stock exchange, is
allowed to set and enforce regulations and standards for its members.
As SROs, exchanges have to abide by the Financial Services Ombud Schemes (FSOS) Act, which adds an extra
layer of protection for investors. This legislation allows for the Financial Services Providers Ombudsman to act as
an impartial party in disputes between FSPs and clients.
Exchanges: JSE Limited (Johannesburg Stock Exchange), Cape Town Stock Exchange (previously known
as 4AX), Equity Express Securities Exchange, A2X Markets
Kindly take note that the FSCA does not issue monetary relief to complainants/consumers, issuing of such
relief falls within the jurisdiction of the relevant ombud schemes.
The FSCA investigates matters relating to the conduct of financial service providers and at the conclusion of the
investigation determines whether or not to take further action.
The FSCA will advise you in writing of the outcome of the investigation and the reasons for reaching their conclusion.
Where you have interacted with an unlicensed entity, you can report this to the FSCA, as conducting certain
activities without a license is illegal.
6. Conclusion
Today, no consumer needs to be a victim of unfair treatment. Know your rights, and do not hesitate to lodge a
complaint if you feel that you have been wronged or you are unsatisfied with the service or financial product that
has been sold to you.
Can a consumer complain about their financial institution? How should they do so?
The deeper understanding you have gained about money management and investing will motivate you to:
Lastly, remember that financial capability opens doors to better financial decisions, which may lead to a higher
quality of life.
Herewith the general dispute resolution process to follow when engaging with the financial services
industry:
Call centre: 086 066 3247 Call centre: 0860 726 890
Telephone: 012 762 5000 Telephone: 011 726 8900
Fax: 012 348 3447 Fax: 011 726 5501
Email: info@faisombud.co.za Email: info@osti.co.za
Postal address: P.O. Box 74751, Lynwood Ridge, Postal address: P.O. Box 32334, Braamfontein 2017
0040 Physical address: 1 Sturdee Avenue,
Physical address: 125 Dallas Avenue, Menlyn, 1st Floor, Block A, Rosebank,
Waterkloof Glen, Pretoria, Johannesburg, 2196
0010 Website: www.osti.co.za
Website: www.faisombud.co.za
NOT SURE IF YOU SHOULD CONTACT THE LONG-
CREDIT OMBUD OR SHORT-TERM INSURANCE OMBUDSMAN?
The Credit Ombud resolves complaints from consumers
and businesses that are negatively affected by credit Here is the central contact point for insurance related
bureau information or when a consumer has a dispute complaints
with a credit provider. For information on the credit
industry or to lodge a complaint against credit bureaux Sharecall: 0860 103 236/0860 726 890
or creditor providers, contact the Credit Ombud. Fax: 086 589 0696
Email: info@insuranceombudsman.co.za
Website: www.insuranceombudsman.co.za
DISCLAIMER
The information contained in this information guide has been provided by the Financial Sector Conduct Authority (FSCA) for
information purposes only. This information does not constitute legal, professional, or financial advice. While every care has been
taken to ensure that the content is useful and accurate, the FSCA give no guarantees, undertakings or warranties in this regard
and does not accept any legal liability or responsibility for the content or the accuracy of the information so provided, or, for any
loss or damage caused arising directly or indirectly in connection with reliance on the use of such information. Except where
otherwise stated, the copyright of all the information is owned by the FSCA. No part of this information guide may be reproduced
or transmitted or reused or made available in any manner or any media unless the prior written consent has been obtained from
the Financial Sector Conduct Authority’s Office of General Counsel.