9084 Learner Guide
9084 Learner Guide
9084 Learner Guide
Learner Guide
9 revise, by providing revision tips and an interactive revision checklist (Section 6).
Following a Cambridge International AS & A level programme will help you to develop abilities that universities value highly,
including a deep understanding of your subject; higher order thinking skills (analysis, critical thinking, problem solving);
presenting ordered and coherent arguments and independent learning and research.
Studying Cambridge International AS & A Level Law will help you to develop a set of transferable skills, including the ability
to use relevant knowledge and understanding, to analyse and learn to apply legal concepts, principles and rules to a range
of situations and to communicate an argument through problem-solving and evaluative writing. In particular, studying
Cambridge International AS & A Level Law will help you to be:
confident, using statutes, cases, legal principles, and examples, analysing and applying relevant law, and communicating
logical and evaluative legal arguments
responsible, considering the application of law within the English legal system and working towards a better understanding
of a range of issues which impact on its operation and effectiveness
reflective, considering laws, legal rules, principles and concepts and the ways in which legal issues and problems may be
resolved
innovative, approaching learning and tasks with flexible and substantiated thinking
engaged, developing an interest in broader legal issues and exploring the law changing in response to a range of challenges.
4
Learner Guide
1.1 Principles and sources of English Law 1.1.1 English legal system and its context
1.1.2 Parliamentary law making
1.1.3 Delegated legislation
1.1.4 Statutory interpretation
1.1.5 Judicial precedent
1.2 Machinery of justice 1.2.1 Civil courts and civil process
1.2.2 Alternative methods of dispute resolution
1.2.3 Criminal courts and criminal process
1.2.4 Police powers
1.3 Legal personnel 1.3.1 The judiciary – superior and inferior judges
1.3.2 Legal professionals
1.3.3 Lay personnel
5
Learner Guide
Prior knowledge
No prior knowledge is assumed.
Key concepts
Key concepts are essential ideas that help you to develop a deep understanding of your subject and make links between
different aspects of the course. The key concepts for Cambridge International AS & A Level Law are:
• Rights, duties and responsibilities, and freedoms
This is about how the law safeguards rights and freedoms, and imposes obligations on how citizens behave.
• Liability
This is the notion of legal responsibility for actions or omissions.
• Justice, fairness and morality
This is a broad notion of the purpose of law to bring about a state of fairness. This includes how and why laws are enacted
and enforced, and how far the civil and criminal law achieve justice through the use of remedies and sentences. This also
relates to how morality and the law interlink and whether changing morality within society is reflected in the law.
• Power and its limits
This is about who has power within society and how this power is regulated. This also relates to power within the legal
system.
• Effectiveness and certainty
This is about the aims of law and whether systems and provisions can meet these aims. This also relates to how citizens
are aware of their rights and responsibilities to each other and to the state, and what distinguishes certainty in law.
6
Learner Guide
Time and
Component Questions Weighting
marks
Section A: you will need to answer five compulsory questions.
Paper 1: 1 hour 30 There are four short answer questions and one extended answer
50% of AS Level
minutes question.
English Legal
25% of A Level
System 75 marks Section B: you will need to write two essays from a choice of
three. There are two parts to each essay.
Section A: you will need to answer one compulsory scenario-
based problem question using source material. There are three
1 hour 30
Paper 2: parts to the question. 50% of AS Level
minutes
Criminal Law Section B: you will need to answer one question from a choice 25% of A Level
60 marks
of two. There are two parts to the question: one short answer
question and one essay.
Section A: you will need to answer one scenario-based problem
1 hour 30
Paper 3: question from a choice of two.
minutes 25% of A Level
Law of Contract Section B: you will need to write two essays from a choice of
75 marks
three.
Section A: you will need to answer one scenario-based problem
1 hour 30
Paper 4: question from a choice of two.
minutes 25% of A Level
Law of Tort Section B: you will need to write two essays from a choice of
75 marks
three.
7
Learner Guide
8
Learner Guide
4. Command words
The table below includes command words used in the assessment for this syllabus. The use of the command word will relate
to the subject context.
Analyse examine in detail to show meaning, identify elements and the relationship between them
9
Learner Guide
All information and advice in this section is specific to the example question and response
being demonstrated. It should give you an idea of how your responses might be viewed by an
examiner but it is not a list of what to do in all questions. In your own examination, you will
need to pay careful attention to what each question is asking you to do.
Question
Command words have been highlighted and their
meaning explained. This will help you to understand
clearly what is required. For more information go to www.
cambridgeinternational.org/exam-administration/what-to-
expect-on-exams-day/command-words
Common mistakes
We have highlighted some typical errors which candidates
may make when attempting this question
General advice
These tips will help you to answer questions in general.
10
Learner Guide
Question
This is the question for Paper 2 Section A Question 1 (a–c)
Section A
Answer Question 1(a), (b) and (c) using only the source material provided.
1 (a) Anwar is in a lot of debt and he asks his wealthy employer, Karinna, for a loan but
she refuses to help him. That night, when Karinna has left the office where she and
Anwar work he sees a diamond ring on her desk. He steals the ring and takes it to
a shop where it is valued at £120 000. Anwar sells the ring and clears his debts.
The ring was all Karinna had to remind her of her mother, who died when she was
a child. Anwar is convicted of theft.
Explain how the Sentencing Council Guidelines will apply to Anwar. [10]
(b) Femi is targeted by a local street gang and told to pay them £500 or he will be
beaten up. Femi is scared and as he is walking home he sees Sam on his mobile
phone. Femi runs up to Sam and steals his mobile phone. Femi sells the phone
but it is only worth £200. Sam needed to use his phone for important business
calls and he now feels scared when walking in open spaces.
Explain how the Sentencing Council Guidelines will apply to Femi. [10]
(c) Carly is part of a group who decide to steal a prize winning dog. The dog belongs
to Paul, who lives alone since his wife died a year ago. They make a plan that
Carly will invite Paul round to her house for tea whilst others in the group steal the
dog from Paul’s house. The plan succeeds and the dog is sold for £1500. Paul is
so upset that he has to have a week off work as the dog was a birthday gift from
his wife. Carly and the others in the group are all convicted of theft.
Explain how the Sentencing Council Guidelines will apply to Carly. [10]
11
Learner Guide
12
Learner Guide
A limited conclusion.
13
Learner Guide
Here is application of
three factors relating to harm:
inconvenience, loss to Sam's business
and fear.
Here is a specific link to loss
of confidence using the facts of the
scenario.
Clear identification of Category
4 and application by linking it to the
value of the mobile phone.
A clear link to the potential level
of sentence.
A clear conclusion that Femi is
guilty.
14
Learner Guide
A limited conclusion.
Examiner comments
Part (a) – the candidate identifies and uses the levels of culpability to apply the law to Anwar by saying that there is little
evidence of planning in his actions. Some application is credited as they say that the ring is of substantial value and they
make the point that this is based on more than monetary worth. There is more application where they specifically link to the
financial value of the ring.
Part (b) – there is clear identification of the correct level of culpability and this choice is explained by application of the fact
that Femi had been intimidated by the gang into stealing the phone. There is also identification and application of harm
related to the inconvenience, financial harm and fear Sam suffers. Identification of a Category 4 offence is valid as it is clearly
linked to the value of the phone. A clear conclusion is reached as to the likely level of sentencing.
Part (c) – there is clear identification of an appropriate level of culpability and this is explained by application of the fact that
Carly is playing a significant role in the theft of Paul’s dog. There is also application in the reference to the fact that Carly has
been involved in planning the theft. There is identification and application of the harm criteria as there is reference to the fact
that Paul suffers emotional distress. There is correct identification of a Category 3 offence but this is linked to an inappropriate
sentencing range.
15
Learner Guide
Part (c) – this is a Level 2 response for AO1 and Level 3 for AO2. It would have been helpful to have clearer application for the
Category 3 offence and accurate linking to the likely sentencing range. With reference to the level of culpability there could
have been application that there was a breach of trust as Carly made friends with Paul and the offence would not have been
possible without her.
Common mistakes
The most common mistakes learners make are:
• Rewriting the question – this takes time and does not attract any marks.
• Writing out the source material – this takes time and it is usually enough to reference the element of the source material
being used. Sometimes it might be helpful to include a few key words or a phrase from the source but the marks come
from accurate and relevant identification of law which is then applied.
• Being vague in references to the source material – as the learner has the source material in the examination, references
made should be accurate; for example if the source is an Act it is best to give the appropriate section and any subsections
that are relevant so it is clear to the examiner that the learner has made a precise and accurate selection which they then
apply.
• Not having a conclusion or having one which is vague. A learner who has accurately selected and applied relevant law
should be able to reach a definitive conclusion. It is better to use a phrase such as, ‘Fred will be guilty because…’ rather
than ‘Fred might be guilty because...’
General advice
In order to answer this type of question well:
• Always read all parts of the question carefully, noticing the command words and key instructions. You may want to
underline or highlight them to help you remember to refer back to them.
• Once you have read the question it is helpful to pause and to think about which aspects of the source material are
relevant. Make a note of them and be aware that it is very unlikely you will be using the same part of the source material
over and over again. If you can see you are doing that stop and check before you write your answer.
• Use the law in the source material to help you resolve the situation in the scenario. This means selecting the most
appropriate part of the source material and applying it. It is important to refer to the relevant law, however there is no
need to write it out in your answer.
• Spread your time equally across all three parts of the question as each part is worth the same number of marks.
• Remember that most of the marks are for your skill in applying the relevant law to the facts. Also remember to reach
a conclusion based on the source material, especially if this is what the question asks you to do. Be confident in your
conclusion; rather than saying, ‘the defendant may be guilty’ say, ‘the law as given in the source material states the
defendant will or will not be guilty’. In some questions the source material will include information about sentencing and if
this is the case use that as an element of your application.
• If you have had a good attempt at a question and still not managed to finish it, it is best to move on to another question
and come back to it later.
• Try to keep a few minutes at the end of the examination to check your work so your answers are your very best work.
16
Learner Guide
6. Revision
This advice will help you revise and prepare for the examinations. It is divided into general advice and specific advice for each
of the papers.
Use the tick boxes to keep a record of what you have done, what you plan to do or what you understand.
General advice
Before the examination
Plan ahead by finding out when the examinations are and make a revision timetable so you have plenty of time to revise
and consolidate each topic, as well as keeping some time to do other things you enjoy.
Be honest in terms of how long you can work for and make a revision timetable you can keep to. Revise small sections of
the syllabus at a time and test yourself before you move on.
Start making your revision notes early, ideally as you get to the end of each topic. You can reduce them further as you get
closer to the examinations but they will give you a basis to start from. Beginning this process early also gives you chance
to refine the type of revision that works for you.
As the examinations get closer make sure you know how long each examination is and how many questions you have to
answer.
Check that you understand the meaning of the command words used in questions and think about how you would
respond to each of them. You can find these on page 27 in the syllabus.
Once you have consolidated your factual knowledge get someone to test you – a revision buddy or a family member
can be really helpful. Explain what you know to help you put information and ideas into your own words. Then practise
putting what you know down on paper. Build your confidence by practising questions on each of the topics.
Look at specimen assessment material and past paper questions so you become familiar with the format of each
examination paper.
Use these questions to practise your writing skills and complete them under timed conditions so you get used to the
length of an examination and how to allocate your rime between questions.
Look at mark schemes to help you to understand how the marks are awarded for each question and the assessment
objectives relevant to the question. Detail on what the assessment objectives mean are in the syllabus. Ask your teacher if
you can see the reports published by the examiners which can provide helpful information.
Revise steadily and methodically and do not leave everything to the last minute.
17
Learner Guide
Try to keep a few minutes at the end of the examination to check through your work. Read through what you have written
slowly and silently so you know what you have actually written rather than what you think you have said.
If you run short of time use bullet points in the last five minutes.
Make your writing as neat as possible so the examiner can read what you have written easily.
18
Learner Guide
Revision checklists
In the next part of this guide we have provided some revision checklists. These include information from the syllabus that you should revise. They don’t contain all the detailed knowledge
you need to know, just an overview. For more detail see the syllabus and talk to your teacher.
The table headings are explained below:
19
Learner Guide
Describe and explain the rules of language, intrinsic and extrinsic aids.
Describe and explain ratio decidendi, obiter dicta and law reporting.
Describe and explain the hierarchy of the courts and their role.
20
Learner Guide
Machinery of Justice Describe and explain the role and jurisdiction of civil courts.
Evaluate ADR.
Describe and explain the role and jurisdiction of criminal trial courts.
Describe and explain bail from the court – Bail Act 1976.
Evaluate bail.
Describe and explain police powers of stop and search – PACE 1984, Misuse of
Drugs Act 1971, Terrorism Act 2000, Code A.
Describe and explain police powers of arrest – PACE 1984, SOCPA 2005, Code G.
21
Learner Guide
Legal personnel Describe and explain the qualifications, selection and appointment, role,
training, retirement and removal for superior and inferior judges.
Describe and explain the independence of the judiciary.
Describe and explain the qualification, training, role and regulation of barristers.
Describe and explain the qualification, training, role and regulation of solicitors.
Describe and explain the qualification, training, role and regulation of legal
executives.
Evaluate the legal professions.
Describe and explain the qualifications, selection and appointment, training and
role of lay magistrates in civil and criminal cases.
Describe and explain the qualifications, vetting, challenges and role of jurors in
criminal trials and alternatives to juries.
Evaluate lay people in the law.
22
Learner Guide
Offences against property Describe and explain theft – s1 – s7 Theft Act 1968.
Describe and explain handling stolen goods – s22 Theft Act 1968.
Describe and explain making off without payment – s3 Theft Act 1978.
Describe and explain obtaining services dishonestly – s11 Fraud Act 2006.
23
Learner Guide
Contents of a contract Describe and explain the distinction between representations and express terms
and their importance.
Describe and explain written terms – incorporation by signature and the parole
evidence rule.
Describe and explain terms implied into a consumer contract by the CRA 2015 –
s9, s10, s11, s20, s22, s23, s24, s49, s52, s55, s56.
24
Learner Guide
Discharge of a contract Describe and explain the entire or strict performance rule.
Describe and explain the effect of frustration at common law and under the Law
Reform (Frustrated Contracts) Act 1943, s1(2) and s1(3).
Evaluate each aspect of discharging a contract.
Remedies for breach of a Describe and explain the remedy of damages at common law.
contract
Evaluation of the use of damages as a remedy.
Describe and explain the purpose and nature of equitable remedies and the
limitations on their award in contract law.
Evaluation of the use of equitable remedies.
25
Learner Guide
Describe and explain factual and legal causation, multiple causes and intervening
acts.
Describe and explain the test for remoteness of damage.
Describe and explain novel duty situations – pure economic loss, negligent
misstatement and nervous shock.
Evaluate negligence.
Torts affecting land Describe and explain liability to lawful visitors in OLA 1957.
26
Learner Guide
27
Learner Guide
7. Useful websites
The websites listed below are useful resources to help you study for your Cambridge International AS and A Level Law.
Cambridge Assessment International Education is not responsible for the accuracy or content of information contained in
these sites. The inclusion of a link to an external website should not be understood to be an endorsement of that website or
the site's owners (or their products/services).
The website pages referenced in this guide of work were selected when the guide was produced. Other aspects of the sites
were not checked and only the particular resources are recommended.
www.bbc.co.uk
www.guardian.co.uk
These websites contain general news and articles about law and legal issues.
www.judiciary.uk/about-the-judiciary/the-justice-system/jurisdictions/civil-jurisdiction/
www.gov.uk/courts
These websites contain information about civil and criminal courts.
www.judiciary.uk/
www.lawsociety.org.uk/
www.barcouncil.org.uk/
www.cilex.org.uk/
These websites contain information about judges and legal professionals.
www.magistrates-association.org.uk/about-magistrates
www.cps.gov.uk/legal-guidance/juror-misconduct-offences
These websites contain information about lay people in the law.
www.sentencingcouncil.org.uk/
www.ybtj.justice.gov.uk/
www.judiciary.uk/you-and-the-judiciary/sentencing/
These websites contain information about sentencing.
28
Cambridge Assessment International Education
The Triangle Building, Shaftesbury Road, Cambridge, CB2 8EA, United Kingdom
t: +44 1223 553554
e: info@cambridgeinternational.org www.cambridgeinternational.org