Muslim Law Notes
Muslim Law Notes
Muslim law in India, also known as Islamic law or Sharia law, is a significant part of the
country's legal system, particularly in the context of personal laws. The scope of Muslim law
in India covers several aspects of the lives of Muslims, including marriage, divorce,
inheritance, and other family-related matters. Here's an overview of the key areas:
1. Personal Law
   -Marriage (Nikah): Muslim marriage is considered a contract rather than a sacrament. The
laws governing marriage, including the conditions for a valid marriage, dower (Mehr), and the
rights and duties of spouses, are derived from Islamic texts and customs.
   - Divorce (Talaq): Divorce can occur through different methods under Muslim law, includ ing
Talaq (unilateral divorce by the husband), Khula (divorce initiated by the wife), and Mubarat
(mutual consent). The Supreme Court of India has also ruled against instant triple talaq, making
it illegal.
  - Maintenance (Nafaqa): Muslim women are entitled to maintenance during the marriage and
after divorce. The extent of this maintenance can vary and is often subject to interpretatio n
based on various factors.
  - Inheritance: Muslim inheritance laws are based on specific principles outlined in the Quran.
The property is divided among heirs according to fixed shares, with male heirs typically
receiving a larger share than female heirs.
2. Criminal Law
  - Muslim law does not have a separate criminal code in India. Muslims in India are subject
to the same criminal laws as other citizens, governed by the Indian Penal Code (IPC) and the
Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC).
The scope of Muslim law in India is thus quite broad, encompassing various aspects of personal
life while interacting with the broader legal framework of the country. It is a dynamic area of
law that continues to evolve through legislative changes and judicial interpretation.
    - Shia Islam has its own jurisprudential school called Ja'fari or Imami, which has its unique
interpretations and sources of law.
Islamic law is a complex and multifaceted system that influences the lives of Muslims across
the world, both in their personal and public lives. It is a dynamic legal tradition that has evolved
over centuries and continues to adapt to changing circumstances while maintaining its core
religious foundations.
The traditional Islamic law or Islam's legal system is well known as Sharia, it is an Arabic word
which in the literal sense is referred to as the way. Sharia is originated from Allah and that is
the reason that Muslims consider it as holy. Muslims considered it a word of god' which
regulate and evaluate human conduct. The Sharia is also derived from Prophet Mohammed's
principles and by some of the Muslim legal scholars who interpreted his teachings. It is said
that Islamic jurisprudence is also something that goes back to the lifetime of Mohammed. For
Muslims, the Quran' is the only disclosed book of Allah.
In the case of Narantakath v. Prakkal (1922) ILR 45 Mad 986, it was stated that there are two
basic beliefs of Muslims, first, the existence and oneness of God, and second was the belief in
the truth of Prophet Mohammed's mission.
Primary Sources:
Quran
The word Quran is derived from the Arabic word Qurra which means to read. Every word of
Quran is the word of god, communicated to the Prophet Mohammed through angel Gabriel for
the benefit of mankind, at different times, places, and situations during the period from 609 to
632 A.D (23 years).
The whole body of the Quran was given to the world in small incomplete parts during the
lifetime of the Prophet. The Quran was never compiled or arranged in a proper form. In the
starting, it was written down on palm leaves, skin or parchment, so it was available in this form
only.
The Quran was structured in Arabic and it consists of 114 chapters, which are known as suras.
The suras contain 6666 verses which are called Ayats and the total number of 77, 934 words.
Out of these verses, 200 dealt with legal principles such as marriage, maintenance, transfer of
property, inheritance, etc. The Quran was disclosed over two periods which are:
Meccan and Medina
The words of the Quran is divine in nature, it cannot be amended, revised, or modified by any
institution or human agency. The sacred book has been translated into a number of langua ges
as well.
Aga Mohammad Jaffer v. Koolsom Beebee and others,
It was a judgment delivered by the Privy Council on 7th April 1897.
It was observed that where a passage of the Quran was interpreted in both Hedaya (a work of
Sunni Law), and in the Imamia (a work of the Shia Law) it was not open to a judge to construe
it in a different manner.
The courts should not compare any traditional settled law with Quran.
The Sunnat
Sunnat is also known as Hadis or Sunna, it is the traditions of the Prophet Mohammed. The
term Sunnat means a procedure, the trodden path or a way of action. Quran consists of the
words of Allah but on the other hand, Sunnat indicates some precedents, acts, language, and
the practice of the Prophet. Whatever the actions of the Prophet were or the Prophet said or did
was considered as a tradition. According to Islamic law, there are two types of revelations i.e.
manifest (Zahir) and internal (Batin).
Ijma
Ijma is a consensus within Muslim jurists on a particular legal issue. In simpler words when
Quran and other traditions were not able to provide any rule of law for a particular problem,
the jurists unanimously gave their decision and this was referred to as Ijma.
Those people who had much knowledge and learning about the law were known as Mujtahids
(jurists). The Ijma derives its power and authority from both the Quran and the Sunnat due to
which it can never be contradictory to anyone of them.
There are two types of Ijma or consensus:
Ijma-al-ummah (community consensus)
Ijma-al-aimmah (religious authorities consensus)
Qiyas
Qiyas is the fourth primary source of Islamic law, it means analogical reasoning. The term in
the literal sense is known measuring or ascertaining the length, quality, and weight of
something. There are no clear authorities of Qiyas in the Quran. However, many legal jurists
   have provided several proofs from the Quran and Sunnat and also from the practices done by
   the companions as indirect evidence to support the authority of Qiyas.
   The Hanafi school of thought very strongly supports Qiyas. As Abu Hanifa quoted - The
   knowledge of ours is an opinion; it is the best we have been able to achieve. He who can arrive
   at different conclusions is entitled to his own opinion as we are entitled to our own.
   Secondary Sources
   Judicial Decisions
   Our Indian judiciary at several instances interpreted Muslim law in several cases. All these
   interpretations is generally relied upon primary sources. Legislation, opinion of jurists and
   courts have settled many important legal anomalies using judicial interpretations.
   Customs
   Customs are basically practices that people follow continuously for a long period of time. In
   fact, it is followed for so long that it obtains the status of law in some cases. In Muslim law
   there are various customs which regulate the practices of people.
   Legislation
   Muslim law in India is not codified, but the parliament has made some laws to regulate Islamic
   practices. For ex. The Muslim personal law (Shariat) Application Act, 1939.This act deals with
   the marriage, succession, inheritance and charities among Muslims.
   Who is a Muslim?
   The term Muslim means submission. A Muslim is a person who follows Islam. Muslim law
   applies to a born Muslim or a person who is a convert Muslim.
1. Muslims by Birth or Origin: A child whose both parents are Muslim is a Muslim and even if
   one of the parents is a Muslim the child will be Muslim.
2. By Religion or Conversion: A convert is a person who renounces his faith and adopts another
   religion but the conversion should be bonafide and not with any ulterior motive or intention.
   In the case of Sarla Mudgal v. Union of India (1995 AIR 1531) The husband was already
   married under Hindu law and he embraced Islam and solemnized a second marriage under
   Muslim Law. The court held that the second marriage of a Hindu husband after conversion to
   Islam without having his first marriage dissolved under Hindu law would be invalid.
   In Lily Thomas v. Union of India (AIR 2000 SC 1650) the Supreme court held that one
   personal law cannot be used to defeat the spirit or purpose of another personal law. The
   Supreme Court held that the husband is guilty of the offence of bigamy under section 494 of
   IPC.
   In Azima Bibi v. Munshi Samalanand, (1912) 17 CWN 121, it was observed that a child born
   out of a Muslim couple would be Muslim, even if he by choice goes to a Hindu temple. The
   person would be a Muslim, till the time he does not renounce his religion and converts to
   another religion.
In Bhaiya Sher Babadur v. Bhaiya Ganga Baksh Singh, (1914) 41 IA 1, it was held that
   if a Muslim woman has a child from a Hindu man but the child from the time he was born was
   brought up as a Hindu, then, in this case, he would be called
   Under Muslim law, if a married man renounces his religion then in that case his marriage ends
   immediately but this is not the case for Muslim women who convert, her marriage would not
   come to an end if her marriage was done according to the rituals of Muslim law. Unless and
   until she was a convert Muslim and again re-embraces her faith.
   The Five Commandments of Islam are the basis of the Islamic faith. They are the core beliefs
   and practices that Muslims must follow
   The Holy Qur’an, Tradition and Ijtihad are the three main sources of Islamic law which govern
   and regulate all aspects of a Muslim’s public and private life. These laws relate to religio us
   worship, prohibitions, and all contracts and obligations that arise in social life such as
   inheritance, marriage, divorce, punishments, conduct of war and the administration of the state.
   The science of these religious laws is called Fiqah and the expert in this field such as a jurist
   is called a faqih (plural: fuqaha).
   We read that Ijtihad, or the exercise of judgement, is a valid source of Islamic laws in areas
   where the Holy Qur’an and the Traditions are not explicit. But the exercise of this independent
   judgement can only be left in the hands of proper scholars of the Holy Qur’an and the Traditio n.
   The vast majority of Muslims give this right of independent reasoning to only four ancient
   Muslim theologians and jurists who lived in the first three centuries of Islam. These four fuqaha
   are:
   Although a number of other jurists also became popular during their times, only the above four
   are now recognised by the vast majority of Sunni Muslims. These four great jurists and
   theologians tried to systemise the Islamic law into a comprehensive rational system which
   covered all possible legal situations. The four prominent schools of Islamic law are named after
their founders and are called the Hanafiyya, the Malikiyya, the Shafiyya, and the Hanbaliyya
schools of religious law.
Most Muslims regard these four schools as equally valid interpretations of the religious law of
Islam. These schools are in good agreement on all essential aspects of the religion of Islam.
They all acknowledge the authority of the Holy Qur’an and the Traditions as the ultimate source
of the Islamic law. Only in areas and situations where these two sources are silent, do the four
schools use their independent reasoning in which they may differ with each other.
The earliest school formed was by Imam Abu Hanifa (699-767 A.D.) of Kufa. It generally
reflects the views of the jurists of Iraq. Abu Hanifa did not compose or write any books on law
himself, but his numerous discussions and opinions as recorded by his disciples, form the basis
of this school.
As a theologian and a religious lawyer, Abu Hanifa exercised considerable influence in his
time. His legal thought is very consistent, uses high degree of reasoning, avoids extremes, and
lays great emphasis on the ideas of the Muslim community. The Ahmadi Muslims generally
follow the Hanafiyya school of law.
Other areas in which this school has a following include Turkey, the countries of the Fertile
Crescent, Lower Egypt and India.
The next school of law in order of time was the one founded by Imam Malik bin Anas (d. 795
A.D.) of Medinah and reflects the views and practises associated with that city. Imam Malik
served as a judge in Medinah and compiled all his decisions in a book form called al-Muwatta
(the Levelled Path).
Like the jurists of Iraq, Imam Malik preferred to depend more on the Traditions associated with
the Companions of the Holy Prophet.
This school was founded by Imam Ahmad bin Hanbal (d. 855 A.D.) of Baghdad. Imam Hanbal
did not establish a separate school himself; this was rather done by his disciples and followers.
The Hanbaliyya was the most conservative of the four schools. Its rigidity and intolera nce
eventually caused its decline over the years. In the eighteenth century, however, this school
was revived with the rise of Wahhabism and the growing influence of the House of Sa’ud.
Today, Hanbaliyya school is followed only in Saudi Arabia.
The Hanbalis insist on the literal injunctions of the Holy Qur’an and the Hadith and are very
strict in the observance of religious duties.
Although the Muslims generally apply the Islamic law according to the principles and details
laid down by the four ancient jurists, legal situations keep arising from time to time for which
there are no clear answers in these early schools of law. To cope with this changing aspect of
Islamic society, particularly in the light of new facts, specialists in the field of Islamic law are
asked to give their decisions using the traditional tools of legal science. Such a decision is
called aIntroduction
    ▪   At the time of the death of the Prophet, there was a quarrel between the two groups for
        imamate (the temporal leadership of the religion).
    ▪   One group advocated the principle of the election in choosing the ‘Imam’, this group
        is   known       as ‘Sunni’. The        adherents   to   the    ‘Sunni’     doctrine    are
        called ‘Sunni Muslims’.
    ▪   While, the other group opposed the principle of the election in choosing the ‘Imam’ and
        proclaimed that ‘Ali’ is the successor of the ‘Prophet’.
           o    They firmly believe that imamat must be devolved upon the successors of the
                prophet, i.e.
o Sunni school
o Shia school
Sunni Schools
In Sunni sect, there are four major schools of Muslim law which are as follows:
▪ ‘Hanafi School’ is the first and the most popular schools in Muslim law.
           o    Before being named ‘Hanafi’, this school was known as ‘Kufa School’ which
                was based on the name of the city of Koofa in Iraq.
           o    Later, this school was renamed ‘Hanafi School’ based on the name of its
                founder ‘Abu Hanafi’.
   ▪   The founder of this school was ‘Imam Abu Hanifa’. He had two most important
       disciples:
o Abu Yusuf
           o    Imam Muhammad.
   ▪   In India, most of the Muslims follow ‘Hanafi school’. This school was followed in
       China, Pakistan, Afghanistan, Turkey as well. Among the entire Muslim population
       around the world, the followers of this school are one third.
          o   They followed a simple methodology and were amongst the most popular and
              prevalent schools.
   ▪   They did not rely much on the prophet’s hadiths until they were proved to be true
       beyond a reasonable doubt. They relied very much on Qiyas. They even
       extended ‘Ijma’ and gave preference to ‘Isthiasan’.
o This school was believed to be stricter than other schools in lifting traditions.
          o   Also, in the application of the law, Abu Hanifa believed that it is important to
              rely on usages and local authorities.
   ▪   ‘Imam Malik’ was the founder of this school. This school gets its name from Malik-
       bin-Anas. He was the ‘Mufti of Madina’.
   ▪   People of ‘Madina’ also followed a certain way of ‘Islam’, this way was also followed
       by the ‘Maliki School’ and accepted the practices of the people of ‘Medina’ and the
       sayings of the companions of the prophet.
   ▪   They followed ‘Qiyas’ only when the ‘Quran’ or ‘Sunnat’ were silent on that
       particular matter. They also followed the ‘Public Interest’ –Al-masalih, al- mursalah.
o The pupils of ‘Iman Malik’ were ‘Imam Muhan’ and ‘Imam Shafi’.
   ▪   This school was popularly followed in North Africa, Morocco, Spain, Algeria,
       Tanzania, etc.
          o    Then he started working with the disciples of ‘Imam Abu Haneefa’ and went
               to ‘Kufa’.
   ▪   He concluded the ideas and the theories of ‘Hanafi School’ and ‘Maliki School’ in a
       friendly manner.
          o    The ‘Imam Shafi’ was considered as one of the greatest jurists of Islam. He
               created the classical theory of the Shafi’s Islamic Jurisprudence.
   ▪   The followers followed all four sources and rejected the public interest methodology
       followed by the ‘Maliki school’ and were also not in favor of ‘Isthiasan’.
   ▪   Their teachings were popular in Lebanon, Syria, Egypt, and some parts of Iraq,
       Pakistan, Iran, Yaman, and India as well.
   ▪   ‘Ahmad bin Hanbal’ was the founder of the ‘Hanbali School’ of Islamic
       Jurisprudence.
   ▪   They were strict regarding the traditions of the ‘Prophet’ and strictly confirmed to
       the principle of Hadiths.
   ▪   They followed ‘Qiyas’ only when they believed it to be necessary. They were dominant
       in Saudi Arabia mostly.
Shia Schools
   ▪   Shia Sect is considered as the minority in the ‘Muslim’ world. They enjoy the politica l
       power only in Iran though they don’t have the majority in that state also. As per Shia
       Sect, there are three schools of law:
1. Ithna-Ashari:
   ▪   These schools are based on the followings of ‘Ithna-Ashari’ laws. The followers of
       these schools are mostly found in Iraq and Iran.
   ▪   In India too, the majority of ‘Shia Muslim’ follow the principles of the Ithna-
       Ashari School.
             o   They are considered political quietists. This school is considered as the most
                 dominant school of the ‘Shia Muslims’.
   ▪   The Ja’fari Fiqh of the ‘Shias’ in most cases is indistinguishable from one or more of
       the four Sunni madhahib, except mutah is considered as a lawful marriage.
   ▪   The people who follow the ‘Ithna Asharis’ school believe that the last of the Imams
       disappeared and will be returning as Mehdi (Messiah).
2.The Ismailis:
   ▪   The school of ‘Ismailis’ accepted only seven ‘Imams’ and were hence known as
       the ‘Seveners’. Their origin could be traced to Egypt. There are two groups of them
       namely:
3. Zaidya:
   ▪   The followers of this school believed that ‘Imam’ should be based on election, so the
       succession in this school is through the election. They believed ‘Imam’ to be above all
       and considered him as a ‘right guide’.
    ▪   The followers of this school are not found in India but are maximum in number in South
        Arabia. This sect of the ‘Shia school’ is the most dominant among all in ‘Yemen’.
    ▪   The followers of these schools are considered political activists. They often reject
        the ‘Twelver Shia’ school philosophies.
fatwa and the religious scholar who gives this decision is called a mufti.
            o   Sound mind
            o   Age of Puberty (it is not mandatory that his guardians agree to fulfill the
                conditions of mahr).
            o   Can marry in a different religion:
                   i.   A women cannot marry any other religion man under Muslim Law.
                  ii.   A Sunni mohammedan man can marry a non Muslim women if she is
                        kitabia.
                 iii.   A Shia mohammedan man cannot marry a non Muslim women even if
                        she is kitabia.
            o   If the other religion person converts to Islam before marriage then there is no
                bar.
    •   There should be a proposal (ijab) and also there should be acceptance (qubul) of the
        proposal which should be expressed in one meeting means at the same time when the
        proposal needs to be accepted in front of;
   •   Fasid nikah is known as an irregular or a voidable marriage which becomes valid after
       removing                                  the                             obstacles.
           o   Prompt Dower (muajjal): Under this type of Dower, the wife has the right to
               demand it at any time after or before marriage either fully or partially.
           o   Deferred Dower (postponed): Under this type of Dower wife is liable to receive
               at the time of talaq fully in case of marriage consummate or half in case of if
               not consummate. It is also claimed by the wife in case of husband death or
               claimed by the wife's heirs in case of wife death within the period of three years.
           o   Unspecified (Mahr-i-misel): It is also known as Proper Dower or Customary
               Dower. The amount or value of Dower is unspecified at the time of marriage
               and is called unspecified Dower. The amount depends upon the basis of
               certain grounds as follows;
             o   Divorce by husband: There are four types of divorce claim by husband against
                 his wife;
             o   Talaq-ul- Sunnat: 'Sunnat' means 'word of God'. This is known as a pure form
                 of talaq in Muslims. It is further divided into two types as follows;
             o   Talaq-e-Ahsan: Under this there are three conditions needed to perform;
      •   Talaq-ul-biddat: It is also known as triple talaq or instant talaq. Biddat came from
          biddah, which means innovation which did not previously exist; it was devised later.
          In India only recognized by Sunni's.
   •   Zihar: It is a form of inchoate divorce in which if the husband compares his wife to
       any woman to whom the marriage is prohibited the wife can claim for divorce on the
       above ground.
Divorce by wife: There are two types of talaq claim by wife as follows
   •   Talaq-e-Tafweez: Under this husband delegated the power of talaq in the hand of his
       wife or any other third person because of the specific reason. It may be absolute or
       temporary.
   •   Lian: Under this type of talaq a wife can claim when a husband makes false charges of
       Adultery (out of aggregation).
   •   Divorce by mutual consent of both husband and wife: There are two types of talaq
       based         on          mutual          consent          as          follows;
          o   Khula: Under this wife offer talaq on the condition of repay of dower and also
              pay the compensation to breach of contract marriage and at the same time
              husband must agree on the same. They must observe Iddat period.
          o   Mubara'at: Under this type of talaq both husband and wife mutually agreed on
              the matter of talaq.
          o   Faskh: talaq declared by Qazi with the assistance of both husband and wife.
   •   Judicial Divorce: There are 9 grounds of divorce is mentioned under section 2 of the
       Dissolution       of       Marriage        Act,       1939        as        follows;
What is tuhr?
According to Muslim Law tuhr is a period between two menstruation cycles is called one
successive tuhr. It is also known as the purity period of women.
   •   Iddat period for dissolution of marriage by death of the husband: According to the
       Muslim Law Iddat period fixed under this head which is 4 months and 10 days it must
       be observe by his wife from the death of his husband. In this case, no matter whether
       the marriage is consummate or not, the wife must observe the Iddat period mentio ned
       above.
   •   Iddat period for a pregnant woman: According to the Muslim Law there are two
       periods mentioned;
What is Will/Wasiyat?
   •   Will/Wasiyat is a document in which a person mentions all details about his desire to
       transfer his property in the hands of one or more persons after his death.
   •   According to Muslim Law there is some provisions given regarding the Will as such as
       follows;
           o   A person only makes a will against property which is under his ownership,
           o   Only ⅓ parts of the property can transfer through will to the person other than
               the part of their heirs. It simply means Will must be made within the limits of
               his testamentary power mentioned in the Muslim Law. These limits may be
               increased with the consent of their heirs,
           o   A person who makes a will is known as 'testator', to whom in favor of will made
               is known as 'legatee' and the document is known as Wasiyatnama,
           o   Testator must be a competent person,
           o   Will in case in favor of unborn child only valid if child born within the period
               of six months,
           o   It    comes     into     effect    after    the     death    of   the      testator,
   •   Revocation of Will/Wasiyat;
           o   Expressed: It may be oral or written.
           o   Implied: It must be implied by the conduct of the person.
What is Gift/Hiba?
According to the Muslim Law any property self acquired or ancestral, movable or
immovable, corporal or incorporal and conditional or unconditional can be gifted. There are
three main conditions for a valid gift such as follows;
   •   Doner's declaration with real bonafide intention,
   •   Donee's acceptance expressed or implied by himself or someone else on his behalf,
   •   Delivery of the subject matter of a gift , actual or constructive,
   •   Doner must be competent means Muslim as a religion, major and sound mind,
   •   Actionable claims can be gifted,
   •   Conditional     gifts    are    valid     except     for    corpus    conditions      only.
Topic 2:
Marriage, as a social institution, has evolved significantly over time, with new concepts, trends,
and formalities emerging across different cultures and societies. The right to marry is
recognized as a fundamental human right, and the understanding of marriage has expanded to
include diverse forms of unions beyond traditional notions. Below, we'll explore the modern
concept of marriage, trends, requisite formalities, and the right to marry.
2. Trends in Marriage
  - Destination Weddings: Couples are opting for weddings in exotic or meaningful locations,
often involving smaller, more intimate ceremonies. Destination weddings have become a
popular trend, emphasizing personal experience over traditional large gatherings.
  - Customizable Ceremonies: Modern couples are moving away from rigid, traditiona l
wedding ceremonies, instead opting for personalized celebrations that reflect their values,
beliefs, and personalities.
  - Digital Influence: The internet and social media have greatly influenced marriage, from
online dating platforms to virtual weddings, and the sharing of wedding experiences online.
Digital tools have also made planning weddings more accessible.
   - Interfaith and Intercultural Marriages: There is a growing trend of interfaith and
intercultural marriages, where individuals from different religious or cultural backgrounds
come together. This has led to more inclusive and diverse wedding practices.
  - Legal Innovations: In some countries, legal frameworks have been updated to refle ct
modern realities, such as recognizing civil unions, cohabitation rights, and offering alternatives
to traditional marriage.
4. Right to Marry
  - Human Rights Perspective: The right to marry is recognized as a fundamental human right
in various international treaties and declarations, such as the Universal Declaration of Human
Rights (Article 16) and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (Article 23).
These instruments emphasize that adults have the right to marry and found a family, without
discrimination based on race, nationality, or religion.
  - Equality in Marriage: The right to marry includes the right to choose one’s partner freely,
without coercion, and to have the marriage recognized legally. This right has been central to
the global movement for marriage equality, ensuring that all individuals, regardless of sexual
orientation, have the right to marry.
  - Protection Against Forced Marriage: The right to marry also includes protection against
forced or child marriages, which are considered human rights violations. Many countries have
laws prohibiting forced marriage and providing support to those at risk.
  - Recognition of Diverse Marriages: The right to marry is increasingly interpreted to include
diverse forms of marriage, such as same-sex marriage, and to ensure that legal systems
accommodate and respect these unions.
Conclusion
Marriage in the modern world is a dynamic and evolving institution that reflects broader
societal changes. The trends, formalities, and the right to marry are shaped by legal, cultura l,
religious, and social factors, making marriage a deeply personal yet universally signific a nt
experience. The increasing emphasis on choice, equality, and individual rights continues to
transform the landscape of marriage globally.
Topic 2:
The concept of NRI (Non-Resident Indian) marriage refers to the marriages involving Indian
citizens who reside outside India, either temporarily or permanently. NRI marriages often
encompass unique challenges and considerations due to the cross-border nature of the union.
These marriages can involve Indian citizens living abroad marrying either fellow NRIs, foreign
nationals, or residents of India. Here’s an exploration of the concept, including key aspects and
trends:
Conclusion
NRI marriages represent a unique intersection of cultural, legal, and emotional factors,
requiring careful navigation to ensure a successful union. With the globalized nature of modern
relationships, NRI marriages continue to evolve, reflecting broader trends in internatio na l
marriages while maintaining ties to Indian cultural and legal traditions.
Topic 2: Point 8
Discussion on the Concept of Marriage
Marriage is a fundamental social institution that has evolved over time, reflecting changes in
societal values, cultural practices, legal frameworks, and individual choices. Traditiona lly,
marriage has been seen as a union between a man and a woman, often tied to religious, cultura l,
and familial expectations. However, in the modern world, the concept of marriage has
expanded to accommodate diverse forms of relationships, recognizing the evolving needs and
rights of individuals.
2. Evolution of Marriage
-Marriage as Partnership: In recent times, marriage has increasingly been viewed as a
partnership based on love, mutual respect, and shared responsibilities. This shift reflects
broader societal changes, including the recognition of gender equality and individ ua l
autonomy.
-Legal Recognition of Diverse Marriages: The legal recognition of same-sex marriages, civil
unions, and cohabitation reflects the growing acceptance of diverse forms of relationships.
Many countries have reformed their marriage laws to ensure equality and protect the rights of
all individuals, regardless of their sexual orientation or gender identity.
-Delayed Marriage and Singlehood: There has been a trend towards delaying marriage as
individuals prioritize education, career, and personal development. Additionally, the
acceptance of singlehood and alternative family structures, such as cohabitation or single
parenthood, has increased.
3. Contemporary Trends
- Online Matchmaking: The rise of digital technology has transformed the way people meet
and marry. Online dating platforms and matrimonial websites have made it easier for
individuals to find compatible partners, often transcending geographical and cultura l
boundaries.
- Destination and Hybrid Weddings: Modern couples are opting for personalized and non-
traditional wedding ceremonies, often blending elements from different cultures or opting for
destination weddings in unique locations.
-Intercultural and Interfaith Marriages: With increased globalization, intercultural and
interfaith marriages have become more common, leading to the blending of different traditions
and customs within a single union.
Topic 4:
In Islamic law, marriage is referred to as Nikah, a fundamental institution that is both a social
contract and a religious duty. The concept of Nikah is central to Muslim personal law, and it
governs the rights and obligations of spouses within a marriage. Here, we'll explore the concept
of Nikah, its essential elements, and the different types of marriages recognized under Muslim
law.
3. Witnesses:
  - In Sunni law, at least two adult male witnesses, or one male and two female witnesses, are
required to validate the marriage.
  - Shia law, however, does not require witnesses for the validity of the marriage, although the
practice may vary.
4. Mahr (Dower):
  - Mahr is a mandatory gift or consideration paid or promised to the wife by the husband as a
mark of respect. It is an essential element of a Muslim marriage and can be prompt (paid
immediately) or deferred (to be paid later).
 - The amount and terms of Mahr are agreed upon at the time of Nikah.
5. Free Consent:
  - The consent of both the bride and groom is essential for a valid Nikah. If either party is
coerced, the marriage may be considered void or voidable.
2. Nikah-e-Misyar
  - Definition: Nikah-e-Misyar is a type of marriage where the couple agrees to waive some of
the rights and obligations typically associated with marriage, such as living together or the
wife’s right to financial support. This arrangement is common in some Arab countries.
  - Purpose: This form of marriage is often contracted by individuals who wish to mainta in
their independence while still being in a lawful marital relationship.
3. Nikah-e-Halala
   - Context: Nikah-e-Halala refers to a marriage that is contracted to make a woman lawful for
her first husband after she has been divorced by him through the pronouncement of three Talaqs
(triple divorce). Under Islamic law, after triple Talaq, the woman cannot remarry her first
husband unless she marries another man, consummates that marriage, and is subsequently
divorced.
  - Controversy: The practice of Nikah-e-Halala is highly controversial and criticized,
particularly because it can be exploited and may lead to significant social and moral issues.
   ▪   The above-mentioned list is not exhaustive hence some other kinds of marriages might
       be void as considered by rules of a certain school of Muslim law.
   ▪   In Munshi v. Mst. Alam Bibii (1912), the court observed that permanent or perpetual
       prohibition from marriage due to non-adherence of a condition makes such marriage
       void.
Effect of a Void Marriage
   ▪   A void marriage is of no legal effect either before or after consummation.
   ▪   It does not create any rights or obligations between the parties.
   ▪   The wife is not entitled to maintenance.
   ▪   One cannot inherit from the other, but the woman is entitled to dower if the void
       marriage has been consummated.
   ▪   The offspring of a void marriage is illegitimate.
   ▪   The parties can separate from each other at any time without divorce and may
       contract another marriage lawfully.
Fasid Nikah (Irregular Marriage)
   ▪   A marriage contracted by parties suffering from relative prohibition or directory
       incapacity is irregular.
   ▪   Some grounds which make the marriage irregular (fasid) are:
          o   Marriages contracted without witnesses (Sunni Muslims),
          o   Marriage with a fifth wife (Sunni Muslims),
          o   Marriage with a woman undergoing Iddat,
          o   Marriage with non-scriptural woman (i.e., idolatress or fire worshipper),
          o   Marriage contrary to the rules of unlawful conjunction.
The term literally means “pleasure marriage”. Muta marriage is a temporary agreement for a
limited time period, upon which both the parties agreed. There is no prescribed minimum or
maximum time limit, it can be for a day, a month or year(s). The marriage dissolves itself after
the expiration of the decided period, however if no such time limit was expressed or written,
the marriage will be presumed permanent. This type of marriage is seen as prostitution by the
Sunni Muslims and thus, is not approved by Sunnis.
However, it is considered legitimate by the Twelver Shia sect, which is predominant in Iran
and constitutes 90% of India’s Shia population. In Iran, the word mut’ah is only from time to
time utilized and this practice is called ‘sigah’. The rules for sigah are fixed for eg- the contract
for temporary marriage can be attracted for one hour to 99 years; it can’t be for an indetermina te
period. This provision distinguishes mut’a from nikah or lasting marriage, which has no time
limit. However, just like in nikah, in sigah too, the bride must get some monetary benefit.
No witnesses are required for mut’ah. And just like in any other contract, the woman being a
party can lay down conditions for her sexual union throughout this time limit, this can also
include her daily maintenance. Her temporary husband must respect these conditions. The
marriage automatically dissolves at the end of the stated period. No matter how short the
duration was, the woman has to practice abstinence lasting up to two menstrual cycles.
Interesting part is that, the temporary husband and wife can renew the contract but the husband
must regardless of this pay the amount to the bride. Husband has a unilateral right to revoke
the marriage-mark of his superior position in the relationship. But the woman can refuse to be
intimate with him or even leave him, but in such case, she must return back the amount she
received from him.
India is a country that has partially approved live-in relationships; However, it will still be quite
difficult for the Supreme Court to constitutionally invalidate this form of marriage. In modern
day era, where feminists all across the globe see this arrangement equivalent to prostitutio n.
There are many advocates of Nikah mut’ah who believe that being a contract, this arrangeme nt
is superior to the live- in relationships.
Dissolution of Marriage
There are 2 categories of divorce under Muslim law:
   •   Judicial
   •   Extra-Judicial
The Extra-judicial mode of Divorce can further be divided into 3 subdivisions:
   1. By husband- talaaq, ila, and zihar.
   2. By wife- talaaq-i-tafweez, lian
   3. By mutual agreement- khula and mubarat
A divorce falls into 2 categories:
Talaaq-i-sunnat
It can further be divided into two categories:
i) Talaaq-i-ahsan
A single pronouncement of divorce is made during the period of tuhr (the period of purity
between two menstrual cycles), followed by abstinence from sexual intercourse during the
period of iddat. Here, the divorce can be revoked at any time before the completion of iddat,
thus preventing hasty and unreasonable divorces.
ii) Talaaq-i-hasan
A husband is required to pronounce a formula of Talaaq three times, during three successive
tuhrs. It is important that pronouncements are made when no intercourse takes place during
any period of tuhr. The marriage is dissolved irrevocably, regardless to the period of iddat.
Talaaq-i-Biddat
It is a form of Islamic divorce which is instant in nature. It allows any Muslim man to legally
divorce his wife by stating the word “Talaaq” three times in oral, written, or more recently,
electronic form. This is prevalent among the Muslims in India, especially among the adherents
Hanafi school of Islam. This is also known as “Triple Talaaq” and has been a subject to debate
and controversy.
In Shayara Bano V. Union of India and Ors. It was submitted that:
“This practice of talaq-e-biddat (unilateral triple-talaq) which practically treats women like
chattel is neither harmonious with modern principles of human rights and gender equality, nor
an integral part of Islamic faith, according to various noted scholars. Muslim women are
subjected to such to such gross practices which treats them as chattel, thereby violating their
fundamental rights enshrined in Articles 14, 15, 21 and 25 of the Constitution. The practice
also wreaks havoc to the lives of many divorced women and their children, especially those
belonging to the weaker economic sections of the society.”
There have been many cases in High courts and the supreme court, where the court invalida ted
the instant triple talaaq. In Shamim Ara V. State of U.P, the court observed that:
The correct law of Talaaq as ordained in Holy Quran is that:
   1. There must be a reasonable cause for the divorce.
   2. The declaration of divorce must be preceded by attempts of reconciliation between
      husband and wife by 2 arbitrators. If the attempts fail, then only the divorce will come
      into effect.
Supreme court in August 2017 declared Triple Talaaq as “unconstitutional”. The Modi
Government introduced a bill called The Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Marriage)
Bill, 2017 and presented it in the Parliament which was passed on 28 December 2017 by the
Lok Sabha. The bill makes moment triple (talaq-e-biddat) in any structure spoken, recorded as
a hard copy or by electronic methods, for example, email, SMS and WhatsApp unlawful and
void, with as long as three years of imprisonment for the husband.
However, one of the principle conflicts against the proposed enactment has consistently been
its acknowledgment of a common offense as a cognisable and non-bailable offence.
Conclusion
The notions of Muta marriage can be evidently seen in our country. In India, temporary
marriage is not recognized, although there exists few who contract Muta marriage but such
marriages are not enforceable in court. Hyderabad is considered to be the epicentre of the
practice where marriage can be instituted for time span as short as one or two days. In a
Hyderabad case it was held that there is no difference between muta for an unspecified period
and a muta for life; a permanent nikah marriage for life can be contracted by the use of word
muta also; specification of the period for which a muta marriage is contracted alone makes a
marriage a temporary marriage for the period specified.
The practice of Temporary “Muta” marriage is widespread in the modern times and often
arranged by Imams and other Islamic leaders in Europe, America (Shia parts of Dearborn,
Michigan), and in the Middle east. It is commonly the destitute widows and orphaned girls that
are within the clutches of temporary marriage who are often sold to old men. For the women,
there is no desire or pleasure that drives them into such misery; it is the extreme means to pay
the rent and feed themselves and their children. As a result, this arrangement has received
widespread criticism by various countries as it impliedly encouraging legalization of
prostitution.
The conflicts over the rights of minority women are best dealt with by creating new
representative bodies which have special provisions to ensure that women are sufficie ntly
represented. In the Shah Bano case, this would have meant creating a new mechanism to
administer Muslim personal law instead of simply recognizing the Muslim Personal Law Board
as the legitimate representative of the Muslim community. Creating a new mechanism is more
sensitive to the political reality of Muslims in India, which is that they consist of widely
dispersed groups characterized by significant differences. It would also make some provision
to ensure that Muslim women have some access to the institutions which make the rules which
govern their lives.
Topic 5:
Parsi marriage and divorce are governed by the **Parsi Marriage and Divorce Act, 1936**, a
specific legal framework in India that applies exclusively to the Parsi community. This act
outlines the legal requirements for marriage, the grounds for divorce, and other related matters
specific to Parsis, who are followers of the Zoroastrian religion.
1. Parsi Marriage
B. Registration of Marriage
   -Mandatory Registration: After the marriage ceremony, the marriage must be registered
under the Parsi Marriage and Divorce Act. Failure to register the marriage does not invalida te
it but is punishable with a fine.
2. Parsi Divorce
Divorce among Parsis is also governed by the Parsi Marriage and Divorce Act, 1936. The
process and grounds for divorce under this Act are unique to the Parsi community.
A. Grounds for Divorce
 - Adultery: If a spouse has committed adultery, the other spouse can file for divorce.
  - Cruelty: Mental or physical cruelty by one spouse towards the other can be a ground for
divorce.
  - Desertion: If a spouse has deserted the other for a continuous period of at least two years, it
can be grounds for divorce.
  - Unsoundness of Mind: If a spouse has been incurably of unsound mind for at least two years
preceding the filing of the petition, the other spouse can seek divorce.
  - Imprisonment: If a spouse has been imprisoned for seven years or more, it can be grounds
for divorce.
  - Conversion to Another Religion: If one spouse converts to another religion and ceases to
be a Zoroastrian, the other spouse can seek a divorce.
  -Leprosy: If a spouse has been suffering from leprosy for two years or more, it can be grounds
for divorce.
  - Venereal Disease: If a spouse has been suffering from a virulent and incurable venereal
disease for two years or more, the other spouse can seek a divorce.
  - Failure to Return after Presumption of Death: If a spouse has not been heard from for seven
years and is presumed dead, the other spouse can file for divorce.
  - Mutual Consent: The Act also allows for divorce by mutual consent if both spouses agree
to end the marriage amicably.
Conclusion
The Parsi Marriage and Divorce Act, 1936, provides a distinct legal framework for the Parsi
community in India, balancing traditional Zoroastrian values with modern legal principles. The
Act ensures that Parsi marriages are solemnized according to the community's religio us
customs and offers specific grounds and procedures for divorce that reflect the community's
unique cultural heritage.
This specialized legal approach allows the Parsi community to manage marital relationships in
a way that aligns with their religious beliefs while providing necessary legal protections.
Through this framework, the Parsi community can navigate marriage and divorce with respect
for both their cultural identity and the rule of law.
The Christian Marriage and Divorce Act refers to the legal framework governing the marriage
and divorce of Christians in India. The key legislation that applies to Christians in India is the
**Indian Christian Marriage Act, 1872, and the Indian Divorce Act, 1869. These laws regulate
the solemnization of marriages and the legal process for divorce among Christians.
1. The Indian Christian Marriage Act, 1872
The Indian Christian Marriage Act, 1872, outlines the legal requirements for the solemniza tio n
of Christian marriages in India. This Act applies to the marriages of Christians, defined as
people professing the Christian religion.
A. Key Provisions of the Indian Christian Marriage Act, 1872
- Eligibility for Marriage:
 - Age Requirement: The Act requires that the minimum age for marriage is 21 years for men
and 18 years for women.
 - Consent: The free and voluntary consent of both parties is essential for a valid marriage. If
either party is a minor, the consent of a parent or guardian is required.
- Prohibited Degrees of Relationship:
 - The Act prohibits marriages between individuals who are within prohibited degrees of
consanguinity or affinity unless authorized by a special license.
- Solemnization of Marriage:
  - Authorized Ministers and Marriage Registrars. Christian marriages must be solemnized by
licensed ministers of religion or marriage registrars appointed by the government.
  - Ceremonial Requirements: The marriage ceremony must include a public declaration by
both parties in the presence of at least two witnesses and an officiating minister or registrar,
stating that they take each other as husband and wife.
  - Publication of Banns: The Act provides for the publication of banns (announcements of the
intended marriage) in a church or public place for three consecutive Sundays before the
marriage, to allow for objections to the marriage.
  - Marriage Certificate: After the marriage ceremony, a marriage certificate must be signed by
the officiating minister or registrar, the couple, and the witnesses, and it must be entered into
the official marriage register.
- Registration of Marriage:
  - Mandatory Registration: Christian marriages must be registered under the Act. The
registration ensures legal recognition of the marriage and provides evidence of the marriage in
legal proceedings.
- Judicial Separation:
 - The Act allows for judicial separation, where the spouses live separately but remain legally
married. Judicial separation can be granted on similar grounds as divorce.
- Annulment of Marriage:
 - The Act provides for the annulment of marriages that are void or voidable. A marriage is
void if it contravenes the essential conditions of marriage, such as prohibited degrees of
relationship or lack of valid consent. A voidable marriage can be annulled on grounds such as
impotency, fraud, or coercion.
- Custody of Children:
 - The Act also provides for the custody of children in divorce cases, with the primary
consideration being the welfare of the children.
3. Jurisdiction of Courts
- Family Courts: Family Courts or District Courts have jurisdiction to hear cases under the
Indian Christian Marriage Act and the Indian Divorce Act. Appeals from these courts can be
made to the High Court.
- Civil Courts: In areas without Family Courts, civil courts with appropriate jurisdiction handle
matrimonial matters under these Acts.
- Gender Equality: The Indian Divorce Act, 1869, originally required that a wife seeking
divorce on grounds of adultery had to prove additional grounds like cruelty or desertion, unlike
the husband. However, this provision was amended in 2001 to allow both spouses to seek
divorce on the ground of adultery alone, promoting gender equality in divorce proceedings.
- Religious Sensitivity: The Indian Christian Marriage and Divorce Acts respect the religio us
practices and customs of Christians while providing a legal framework for marriage and
divorce. The Acts ensure that Christians can solemnize their marriages according to their
religious beliefs while having the legal backing of Indian law.
5. Conclusion
The Indian Christian Marriage Act, 1872, and the Indian Divorce Act, 1869 form the legal
foundation for marriage and divorce among Christians in India. These Acts provide a
comprehensive legal framework that respects Christian religious practices while ensuring that
marriages are legally recognized and that individuals have access to legal remedies in cases of
marital breakdown.
The Acts have evolved over time, with amendments addressing issues of gender equality, the
inclusion of divorce by mutual consent, and provisions for alimony, maintenance, and child
custody. The legal framework thus balances the protection of individual rights with the
preservation of religious and cultural values, making it a vital aspect of Christian personal law
in India.