Chapter 11
Chapter 11
c c c c c
1,3 fail 3 fails 2,3 fail 1,2,3 fail 1,2,3 all hold
| {z }
f (x) is discontinuous at x = c
f (x) is continuous at x = c
In the third and fourth drawings lim f (x) doesn’t exist, so condition 2 fails,
x! c
so condition 3 also fails (by default) and f (x) is not continuous at c. Only on
the far right do all three conditions hold, so f (x) is continuous at x = c.
Intuitively, f (x) being continuous at x = c means that its graph does not
have a “break” at x = c. You can trace its graph through x = c without lifting
your pencil.
For example, the function on the y
right is discontinuous at x = °3, x = 1 2
y = f ( x)
and x = 2.5. But it is continuous at any 1
other x = c between °5 and 5. You can x
trace the graph from left to right with a °4 °3 °2 °1
°1
1 2 3 4 5
= cos(°2º) = 1.
2
Example 11.2 Find lim e x °2
.
x !1
Because e x is continuous at any number L, Theorem 11.1 guarantees that
2 lim( x2 °2) 2 1
lim e x °2
= e x!1 = e1 °2
= e°1 = .
x!1 e
µ µ ∂∂
sin(x)
Example 11.3 Find lim cos °1
ln .
x !0 x
The limit goes first inside the continuous function cos°1 and then inside the
continuous function ln.
µ µ ∂∂ µ µ ∂∂
°1 sin(x) °1 sin(x)
lim cos ln = cos lim ln
x!0 x x !0 x
µ µ ∂∂
°1 sin(x) ° ¢ º
= cos ln lim = cos°1 ln(1) = cos°1 (0) = .
x!0 x 2
Continuity on Intervals 159
That is, lim f (x) = f (c), so f is continuous on (°1, 1). Concerning the end-
x! c
points, neither lim f (x) nor lim f (x) exist because f (x) is undefined when x
x!°1 x!1
is to the left of °1 or to the right of 1. But we do have lim + f (x) = 0 = f (°1)
p x!°1
and lim° f (x) = 0 = f (1). Thus 1 ° x is continuous on [°1, 1].
2
x!1
p
Our next example is f (x) = x + 1, whose
p y
graph is the graph of y = x shifted one
p
unit left. Note that f (x) is continuous on f ( x) = x+1
its domain [°1, 1) because it is continuous x
°1
on (°1, 1), and lim + f (x) = 0 = f (°1).
x!°1
Our final example concerns the function tan(x). This function has in-
finitely many discontinuities, at º2 + kº for any integer k. But if c is not one
of these numbers, then lim tan(x) = tan(c). Thus tan(x) is continuous on each
° x! c ¢
of the intervals ° º2 + kº, º
2 + kº .
y = tan(x)
x
° 52º ° 32º ° º2 3º 5º
º
2 2 2
cos(x) + x2 p
h(x) = +5 x
sin(x)
Example 11.4 Show that the equation cos(x) = 2x has at least one solution.
This equation can’t be solved with standard algebraic techniques because x
cannot be isolated. (And writing it as cos(x) ° 2x = 0, we notice that it is
impossible to factor.) This problem is asking us just to show that there
exists a solution, not what number that solution is. To answer the question,
notice that the function f (x) = cos(x) ° 2x is continuous because it is built
from continuous functions cos(x) and x by operations listed in Theorem 11.3.
Notice that f (0) = cos(0) + 2 · 0 = 1 is positive but f (º) = cos(º) ° 2º = °1 ° 2º is
negative, so the number 0 is between f (0) and f (º). The intermediate value
theorem guarantees a number c in [0, º] for which f (c) = 0. This means
cos(c) ° 2c = 0, so c is a solution to cos(x) = 2x.
The Intermediate Value Theorem 163
16. Draw the graph of a function that meets all five of the following conditions.
1. f ( x) is continuous everywhere except at x = °1 and x = 1.
2. f (3) = 2 3. lim f ( x) = 2
x!°1
4. lim f ( x) = 1 5. lim f ( x) = °1
x!1° x!1+
17. Find the value a such that f is 18. Find the value a such that f is
continuous on (°1, 1): continuous on (°1, 1):
Ω Ω 2
3 x ° 2 if x < 2 x ° 2 if x < 3
f ( x) = f ( x) =
5 x + a if x ∏ 2 ax if x ∏ 3
19. Find the value a such that f is 20. Find the value a such that f is
continuous on (°1, 1): continuous on (°1, 1):
8
< sin(3 x ° 3)
Ω 2
x +2 if x < 3 if x 6= 1
f ( x) =
f ( x) =
ax if x ∏ 3 : a x°1 if x = 1
164 Continuity and Limits of Compositions
23. Answer these questions about the functions f and g graphed below.
(a) f (3) = y y
3 3
(b) lim g( x) = y = f ( x)
x! 2 2 2
µ ∂ y = g ( x)
1 1
(c) f lim g( x) = x x
x !2
° ¢ °4 °3 °2 °1 1 2 3 4 °4 °3 °2 °1 1 2 3 4
(d) lim f g( x) = °1 °1
x !2 °2 °2
f ( x)
(e) lim = °3 °3
x! 3 g( x ° 1)
24. Answer these questions about the functions f and g graphed below.
4 y 4 y
(a) lim f ( x) g( x) = 3 3
x !1
° ¢ y = g ( x)
(b) lim f g( x) = 2 2
x !1
° ¢ 1 1
(c) lim f g( x) = x x
x!°2
° ¢ °4 °3 °2 °1 1 2 3 4 °4 °3 °2 °1 1 2 3 4
(d) lim g f ( x) = °1 °1
x !2
° ¢ °2 y = f ( x) °2
(e) lim g f (°2 x) = °3 °3
x!°1
° ¢
(f) lim f f ( x) = °4 °4
x !2
The Intermediate Value Theorem 165
25. Answer these questions about the functions f and g graphed below.
4 y 4 y
(a) lim f ( x) g( x) = 3 3
x !1
° ¢ y = g ( x)
(b) lim f g( x) = 2 2
x !0
° ¢ 1 1
(c) lim f g( x) = x x
x !2
° ¢ °4 °3 °2 °1 1 2 3 4 °4 °3 °2 °1 1 2 3 4
(d) lim g f ( x) = °1 °1
x !2
° ¢ °2 °2
(e) lim g f ( x) = °3 °3
x!°1 y = f ( x)
° ¢
(f) lim f f ( x) = °4 °4
x !2
26. Answer these questions about the functions f and g graphed below.
y y
(a) lim g( x) = 3 3
x! 1
2 2 y = g ( x)
(b) f (3) = y = f ( x)
1 1
µ ∂
(c) f lim g( x) = x x
x !1 °4 °3 °2 °1 1 2 3 4 °4 °3 °2 °1 1 2 3 4
° ¢ °1 °1
(d) lim f g( x) = °2 °2
x !1
(e) lim f ( x) g( x) = °3 °3
x! 3
27. Show that Theorem 11.1 requires continuity: Find functions ≥ f ¥and g for which
° ¢
lim g( x)=L, f is not continuous at L, and lim f g( x) 6= f lim g( x) . Hint: you will
x! c x! c x! c
find several such examples in the exercises above.
28. Use the intermediate theorem to show that the equation x3 + x + sin( x) = 11 has a
solution.
29. Use the intermediate theorem to show that the equation e x = 7 ° x has a solution.
166 Continuity and Limits of Compositions
x+1
11. State the intervals on which the function y = is continuous.
x2 ° 4 x + 3
This is a rational function, so it will be continuous on its domain. Given that
x+1
y= , its domain is all real numbers except 1 and 3. Therefore this
( x ° 1)( x ° 3)
function is continuous on (°1, 1) [ (1, 3) [ (3, 1).
p
13. State the intervals on which the function y = x2 ° 5 is continuous.
p
By
p
Theorem 11.3, this function is continuous on its domain, which is (°1, ° 5] [
[ 5, 1).
15. Draw the graph of a function that meets all five of the following conditions.
1. f ( x) is continuous everywhere y
3
except at x = 1 and x = 2.
2
y = f ( x)
2. f (3) = 1 1
3. lim f ( x) = ° 1 °4 °3 °2 °1 1 2 3 4
x
x !1
°1
4. lim f ( x) = 1
x!2° °2
5. lim f ( x) = 2 °3
x!2+
Ω
3x ° 2 if x < 2
17. Find the value a such that f is continuous on (°1, 1): f ( x) =
5x + a if x ∏ 2
This function is a polynomial f ( x) = 3 x ° 2 on (°1, 2), so it is continuous on that
interval. The function is f ( x) = 5 x + a on (2, 1), so it is continuous on that interval.
Thus the only possible location for a discontinuity is at x = 2. In order for f to be
continuous at x = 2, we must have lim f ( x) = f (2). Now, f (2) = 5 · 2 + a = 10 + a, so
x !2
we require lim f ( x) = 10 + a. In particular, 10 + a = lim° f ( x) = lim° (3 x ° 2) = 4. This
x !2 x !2 x !2
gives a = °6.
Exercise Solutions for Chapter 11 167
Ω
x2 + 2 if x < 3
19. Find the value a such that f is continuous on (°1, 1): f ( x) =
ax if x ∏ 3
This function is a polynomial f ( x) = x2 + 2 on (°1, 3), so it is continuous on that
interval. The function is f ( x) = ax on (3, 1), so it is continuous on that interval.
Thus the only possible location for a discontinuity is at x = 3. In order for f to be
continuous at x = 3, we must have lim f ( x) = f (3). Now, f (3) = a · 3, so we require
x !3
lim f ( x) = 3a. In particular, 3a = lim° f ( x) = lim° ( x2 + 2) = 11. This gives a = 3 .
11
x !3 x !3 x !3
23. Answer these questions about the functions f and g graphed below.
(a) f (3) = 1 y y
3 3
(b) lim g( x) = 3 2 2
x! 2 y = g ( x)
µ ∂ 1 1
(c) f lim g( x) = f (3) = 1 x x
x !2
° ¢ °4 °3 °2 °1 1 2 3 4 °4 °3 °2 °1 1 2 3 4
(d) lim f g( x) = °2 °1 °1
x !2 °2 °2
f ( x) °2 y = f ( x)
(e) lim = °3 °3
x!3 g( x ° 1) 3
25. Answer these questions about the functions f and g graphed below.
4 y 4 y
(a) lim f ( x) g( x) = 0 3 3
x!1
° ¢ y = g ( x)
(b) lim f g( x) = °2 2 2
x!0
° ¢ 1 1
(c) lim f g( x) = °1 x x
x !2
° ¢ °4 °3 °2 °1 1 2 3 4 °4 °3 °2 °1 1 2 3 4
(d) lim g f ( x) = 3 °1 °1
x !2
° ¢ °2 °2
(e) lim g f ( x) = 3 °3 °3
x!°1 y = f ( x)
° ¢
(f) lim f f ( x) = 0 °4 °4
x !2
27. Show that Theorem 11.1 requires continuity: Find functions ≥ f ¥and g for which
° ¢
lim g( x)=L, f is not continuous at L, and lim f g( x) 6= f lim g( x) .
x! c x! c x! c
Answer: In Exercise 23 above, we saw functions f and g for which lim g( x)=3,
µ ∂ x !2
¢ °
f is not continuous at 3, and lim f g( x) 6= f lim g( x) .
x !2 x !2
168 Continuity and Limits of Compositions
29. Use the intermediate theorem to show that the equation e x = 7 ° x has a solution.
This amounts to showing that e x + x ° 7 = 0 has a solution. Let f ( x) = e x + x ° 7,
which is continuous on (°1, 1). We need to show that f ( x) = 0 has a solution.
Notice that f (0) = e0 + 0 ° 7 = °6 is negative but f (7) = e7 + 7 ° 7 = e7 is positive.
Since f is continuous on [0, 7] and f (0) < 0 < f (7), the intermediate value theorem
guarantees a number 0 < c < 7 for which f ( c) = 0. Therefore c is a solution for
e x + x ° 7 = 0.