Visualization of Industrial Production Processes U
Visualization of Industrial Production Processes U
Abstract
This paper explores the use of 3D simulation software for visualizing industrial production processes and its potential to
enhance decision-making for improved production efficiency, quality, and profitability. Industrial production processes are
complex and involve many variables and factors that can interact in unpredictable ways. Visualization helps to simplify these
complex interactions, identify patterns and relationships, and enable more informed decision-making.
The research question that guides this paper is: How can the use of 3D simulation software for visualization of industrial
production processes improve decision-making and optimize production efficiency, quality, and profitability? This paper will
investigate the benefits and challenges of using 3D simulation software for visualizing industrial production processes,
including the ability to identify bottlenecks, and optimize the production process. Further, the paper examines the role of
visualization in enabling more informed decision-making, including the ability to analyze production data and make data-
driven decisions. To illustrate this, an industrial automation case study consisting of a manufacturing industry modelled in a
3D simulation software has been presented.
The results of this 3D-simulation model provide insights into the advantages and disadvantages of utilizing 3D simulation
software to visualize industrial manufacturing processes. The article further presents the significance of these findings for
production managers, engineers, and decision-makers. Thus, the purpose of this study is to help readers understand how using
3D simulation software for visualization of industrial production processes can improve decision-making and optimize
production efficiency, quality, and profitability.
Keywords: Industrial production processes, 3D simulation software, visualization, decision-making, production efficiency,
industrial automation, data-driven decisions, manufacturing industry, optimization.
and analyze. Furthermore, visualization is used to        research articles was conducted to gain insights into
identify patterns and relationships that may not be       visualization techniques, simulation software, and
apparent from raw data. For example, by plotting          decision-making methodologies. The review
machine performance over time, it may be possible         included a range of sources including scholarly
to identify recurring issues that are impacting           articles, research papers, and industry reports to
machine production efficiency (Atmakuri et al.,           understand the current state of research in the field.
1993). By presenting this information graphically, it     Data collection for this study involved gathering
is easier to identify patterns and make informed          relevant information from various sources.
decisions about how to address the issues.                Keywords related to industrial production processes,
                                                          visualization, and decision-making were used to
Through displaying information in a way that is           identify peer-reviewed articles that contributed to
clear and accessible, visualization also aids in          the research area. These articles were carefully
enabling more informed decision-making (Atmakuri          selected and analysed to extract valuable insights.
et al., 1993). This can assist stakeholders in making
more informed decisions by helping them
understand the effects of various actions on
production efficiency, quality, and profitability
(Yang et al., 2021). Therefore, the topic of
visualization of industrial production processes
using 3D simulation software for enhanced decision-
making is important because it enables                                Figure 1: Research Method
manufacturers to optimize their production
processes, leading to better production efficiency,       The software Visual Components® has been utilized
quality, and profitability. By visualizing production     by the author to develop the 3D simulation model.
processes in 3D simulation software, manufacturers        The model represents an industrial production
can identify bottlenecks, test different scenarios, and   process consisting of injection moulding machines,
make data-driven decisions before implementing            series of conveyor belts, robots and a warehouse for
changes in the physical world. This can lead to           storage. The model was developed based on the
reduced costs, improved quality, and increased            specific requirements and specifications of the case
competitiveness, all of which are critical factors for    study and a dynamic representation of components
success in the manufacturing industry. Hence, the         flow has been visualized. The experiment design
research question has been formulated as follows:         phase involved defining the simulation resources
                                                          and parameters. Key variables, such as production
How can the use of 3D simulation software for             volumes, cycle times, and system constraints, were
visualization of industrial production processes          determined to create a realistic simulation
improve decision-making and optimize production           environment. The experimental design aimed to
efficiency?                                               capture the complexities and dynamics of the
                                                          industrial production process under study. The
    2.   Methodology                                      simulation model was executed to replicate the
                                                          production operations. During the simulation run,
The problem addressed in this study is the need for       process states, utilization rates, and performance
enhanced decision-making in industrial production         metrics were recorded. This data provided valuable
processes. Traditional methods of decision-making         insights into the functioning of the production
may lack comprehensive insights into the complex          system and allowed for a detailed analysis of the
dynamics of production systems. Therefore, there is       simulation results.
a growing interest in utilizing 3D simulation
software to visualize industrial processes and            The collected data was analysed to answer the
improve decision-making capabilities.                     research question posed in the study. The analysis
                                                          focused on evaluating the effectiveness of the
The purpose of this study is to explore the potential     visualization of industrial production processes
benefits of using 3D simulation software for              using the 3D simulation software. Performance
visualizing industrial production processes and           metrics, such as throughput, cycle times, and
examine its impact on decision-making. By                 resource utilization, were examined to assess the
investigating this area, the study aims to provide        impact of visualization on decision-making. The
valuable insights and practical recommendations for       results were interpreted to draw conclusions and
improving decision-making in industrial settings.         provide practical recommendations. Based on the
Figure 1 illustrates the research methodology             analysis of the simulation results, conclusions were
involved in the development of the simulation             drawn regarding the effectiveness of using 3D
model. A comprehensive review of scholarly and            simulation software for visualizing industrial
SIMS 64                                                      Västerås, Sweden, September 26-27, 2023
production processes and enhancing decision-             information and enabling real-time interaction
making. The study provides insights into the benefits    (Molenda et al., 2019). By visualizing the processes
and limitations of visualization techniques and          in a virtual environment, decision-makers can better
offers recommendations for further improvements in       grasp the flow of materials, detect inefficiencies or
decision-making practices within industrial settings.    bottlenecks, and make data-driven decisions to
                                                         optimize the system.
     2.1. Simulation of Industrial Production
          Processes                                          2.2. Building 3D Simulation Model
Industrial production processes are fundamental in
the manufacturing industry, encompassing a series        The use of a 3D manufacturing simulation model
of stages and steps that convert raw materials or        provides a valuable tool for simulating and
components into finished products (Molenda et al.,       analyzing basic manufacturing procedures within a
2019). These processes involve crucial operations        virtual environment. This technology leverages 3D
such as material handling, assembly, packing, and        visualization, which utilizes computer technology to
quality control (Chawla & Banerjee, 2001), which         depict real-world objects in a virtual space,
have been recognized as essential for simulating         surpassing the limitations of two-dimensional (2D)
manufacturing processes. However, the complexity         images in representing complex spatial information
of these processes, often involving multiple             (Xu et al., 2021). By incorporating real-time
interconnected systems and subsystems, presents          interaction capabilities, the 3D visualization
challenges in comprehending and optimizing them          enhances the immersive experience and enables
effectively (Atmakuri et al., 1993).                     users to engage with the simulated environment
                                                         effectively. The implementation and integration of a
Optimizing industrial production processes holds         3D simulation model involve several important
immense value as it has the potential to improve         steps. Key considerations during this process
various aspects, including production efficiency,        include defining resource parameters, selecting
product quality, and overall profitability (Yang et      appropriate equipment, establishing fundamental
al., 2021). By identifying and addressing                simulation logic, and incorporating relevant
bottlenecks, minimizing waste, and maximizing            production data (Xu et al., 2021). These elements
throughput, optimization efforts can lead to             are crucial for creating an accurate and realistic
significant cost savings, enhanced customer              representation of the manufacturing system within
satisfaction, and increased competitiveness in the       the simulation model.
marketplace. However, achieving optimization in
                                                         The resource parameters encompass various factors
industrial production processes is not without its
                                                         such as material properties, production capacities,
obstacles. Challenges such as demand variability,
                                                         and operating constraints. These parameters define
equipment breakdowns, and workforce availability
                                                         the characteristics and capabilities of the resources
can impede the optimization journey, necessitating
                                                         involved in the manufacturing process, enabling the
the adoption of advanced technologies to overcome
                                                         simulation model to accurately reflect their behavior
these hurdles (Chawla & Banerjee, 2001; Yang et
                                                         and interactions (Chawla & Banerjee, 2001). The
al., 2021). In this context, the utilization of 3D
                                                         selection of equipment involves identifying and
simulation software and visualization techniques
                                                         configuring the machinery, tools, and systems that
emerges as a powerful solution. These technologies
                                                         are integral to the manufacturing process. By
enable a deeper understanding and effective
                                                         modelling these equipment components within the
management of industrial production processes by
                                                         simulation, their functionalities and interactions can
providing insights into complex interactions and
                                                         be evaluated and optimized (Wang et al., 2015).
facilitating   informed     decision-making.       3D
                                                         Fundamental simulation logic refers to the
simulation software allows for the creation of virtual
                                                         underlying principles and algorithms that govern the
environments where manufacturing procedures can
                                                         behavior and dynamics of the simulated
be simulated, analyzed, and optimized (Chawla &
                                                         manufacturing process.
Banerjee, 2001). By replicating real-world
scenarios, these simulations enable manufacturers to     Creating a 3D simulation of an industrial production
test different scenarios, evaluate the impact of         procedure entails multiple processes (Figure 2).
process changes, and identify potential areas for        First, describe the simulation's scope and objectives,
improvement.                                             outlining the precise goals to be attained. Next,
                                                         collect relevant data about the manufacturing
Visualization techniques, particularly in 3D, offer a    process and identify the components and processes
more intuitive and comprehensive representation of       that must be modelled. Choose a 3D simulation
the production processes. They surpass the               program that matches the project's criteria. Create
limitations of traditional two-dimensional (2D)          the simulation model by combining the acquired
images by providing a richer visualization of spatial    data and modelling the manufacturing line's
SIMS 64                                                       Västerås, Sweden, September 26-27, 2023
components and procedures. This includes                  process that cannot be seen in depth on the 3D
developing 3D models, setting material flow rules,        simulation of the production site (Xu et al., 2021).
and determining timing and sequencing. Validate
                                                              2.4. Decision Making from simulation model.
and improve the simulation model by comparing it
to real-world data and making necessary
                                                          Effective decision-making is crucial in industrial
modifications. Analyze the simulation findings to
                                                          production processes as the decisions made during
find areas for improvement and to enhance decision-
                                                          production can significantly impact efficiency,
making.
                                                          quality, and profitability (Yang et al., 2021). It is
                                                          essential to have a clear understanding of the
                                                          production processes and the consequences of
                                                          different decisions on the outcomes. This is where
                                                          the utilization of 3D simulation software and
                                                          visualization techniques proves valuable (Xu et al.,
                                                          2021). These tools enable manufacturers to create
                                                          virtual representations of their production systems,
                                                          visualizing the flow of materials, machines, and
                                                          resources. Through simulation and visualization,
                                                          decision-makers can assess different scenarios,
    Figure 2: Building a 3D simulation model.             identify potential issues, and make informed
                                                          decisions before implementing changes in the
    2.3. Visualization Techniques for Simulation          physical world (Yang et al., 2021).
The use of virtual reality (VR), augmented reality        Figure 3 presents a conceptual model for decision
(AR), and visual simulation technology allows to          making which has been designed to capture an
create a simulation model that can replicate real         expert's knowledge using simple and understandable
                                                          elements, without relying on complex artificial
production scenarios in a safe environment (Xu et
                                                          intelligence or process representation (Garcia-
al., 2021). By inputting actual production data into
the model, it is possible mimic on-site production in     Crespo et al., 2010). Instead, real-life situations
real-time. This technology helps us convert complex       have been focused, which occur during the
                                                          execution of a manufacturing process, which
problems into more understandable ones (Xu et al.,
                                                          consider facts (data), action (resources) and
2021). Furthermore, the simulation model provides         verification (checking the results from action are
a visual representation of production or                  valid) through the process of making a decision.
manufacturing processes using terminal equipment
(Abidi et al., 2020). They have further presented
that by analysing and optimizing data, refining the
mathematical model; and a closed-loop control and
monitoring system can be created. This means that it
enables to continuously monitor and adjust the
production process based on the information
provided by the simulation model.
A new strategy to generalizing the manipulation of
                                                            Figure 3: Decision Making Conceptual Model
industrial process simulation is explored (Abidi et
                                                                    (Garcia-Crespo et al., 2010)
al., 2020), where it is possible to visualize and
engage with an industrial simulation model. It also       The aspect of decision making becomes important
enables industrial actors to visualize the operation of   once there is an access to the real-time data through
their factories which is based on virtual reality         the created simulation model. Furthermore, Garcia-
technology and behavioural programming of the             Crespo et al., (2010) in their research have
production flow.                                          presented this ontology for describing the
                                                          automation of decision-making processes in the
Xu et al., (2021) in their research describe the
                                                          manufacturing process setting. In that, they have
frame of visualization application, where they show
                                                          highlighted the importance of having a semantic
the entire process starting from Cyber Physical
                                                          representation of different manufacturing processes
System (CPS) to formulating the visualization
                                                          which further enable data representation strategy
platform. Within this VR and AR have been utilized
                                                          based on with the process of decision making is
for visualizing the created simulation model for the
                                                          enabled.
purpose of scheduling optimization and real-time
monitoring. This results in a 3D recreation of
industrial processes that depicts the production
SIMS 64                                                      Västerås, Sweden, September 26-27, 2023
from the conveyor belt line to ensure product              optimization, and overall improvement of industrial
quality. Moving on to Zone 2, this area is dedicated       manufacturing processes.
to the packaging system, which is constructed along
the conveyor system. The packaging process begins              3.2. Decision Making
with an automated machine that prepares folded             Creating a 3D simulation model for visualizing and
boxes. These prepared empty boxes are then                 optimizing     industrial   production     processes
transported on the conveyor belt and stop near the         necessitates a number of crucial decision-making
robot. With the box in place, the robot organizes the      elements. The creation of discrete zones on the
baskets by picking and placing them in an organized        production shopfloor gives an organized structure
sequential order within the box. Once the box is           for analysing and improving each phase of the
filled, it is transported to another automated             production line. The structure and arrangement of
machine, where it is sealed before being moved to          the production shopfloor is the first key decision-
the next conveyor belt.                                    making component. The shopfloor is divided into
Zone 3 represents the palletization process which          particular zones, such as Zone 1, Zone 2, Zone 3, and
involves a conveyor system. In this zone, the boxes        Zone 4, allowing for a systematic approach to
filled with baskets are placed on pallets with the         understanding and optimizing the many functional
assistance of a robot. Once the pallets are filled with    procedures involved. Choosing the best combination
the boxes, the conveyor system transports them to an       of resources, machinery, and equipment for each
automated plastic wrapping station. At this station,       zone is a critical choice that affects the overall
the pallets undergo a plastic wrapping process,            efficiency and productivity of the production line.
ensuring their stability and protection during             Decisions about the arrangement of injection
transportation and storage. After the plastic              moulding machines, the overhead robot, and the
wrapping is complete, the pallets are transferred          conveyor transport system were made within Zone
through the conveyor line to an automated pallet           1. To ensure seamless operation and efficient
stacking machine. This machine lifts the pallets and       material flow, factors such as machine capacity,
stacks them on top of one another, optimizing space        cycle times, and coordination between machines and
utilization and facilitating efficient storage. Finally,   robots were taken into consideration. Moving on to
Zone 4 is dedicated to the storage of the pallets in       Zone 2, the decision-making process constituted of
the warehouse. An automated stacker crane system           creating an efficient packaging system along the
is employed in this zone to hoist the pallets and          conveyor system. Choosing the right automated
arrange them in an organized manner. The design of         machine for folding boxes, deciding the positioning
the stacker crane system ensures that the warehouse        and sequencing of baskets by the robot, and ensuring
storage racks are within the crane's reach, enabling       effective box sealing are all important factors that
seamless storage operations.                               affect the overall packing process. Decisions in Zone
As a result, the simulation model described here           3 revolve around the palletization process. The
provides a comprehensive picture of an industrial          selection and location of the robot for palletizing the
automation case in the manufacturing industry. The         boxes, optimizing the conveyor system for efficient
simulation model provides a full portrayal of the          box transfer, and constructing the plastic wrapping
industrial production processes involved in making         station to ensure secure and stable pallets for transit
plastic injection-moulded baskets by dividing the          and storage are all important considerations. Finally,
production shopfloor into discrete zones and adding        in Zone 4, the decision-making process revolves
various components and processes. The 3D                   around pallet storage in the warehouse. Choosing the
simulation software's representation of the                right automated stacker crane system, customizing
production shopfloor allows for a clear knowledge          the crane's reach and movement, and correctly
of the interconnection and operation of each zone.         organizing the storage racks are all critical decisions
This visualization helps in the identification of          in order to maximize space utilization and
potential bottlenecks, areas for improvement, and          streamline storage operations.
the overall optimization of production efficiency,         It is essential to examine elements such as system
quality, and profitability. The simulation model           throughput, resource usage, material flow
demonstrates the importance of visualization and           optimization, and overall production efficiency
simulation approaches in improving decision-               throughout the decision-making process. Simulation
making in industrial manufacturing processes.              modelling provides for the testing of numerous
Decision-makers can analyze the impact of many             scenarios, the evaluation of the impact of various
aspects on the production line, such as throughput,        choice alternatives, and the identification of
resource usage, and system performance, by                 potential bottlenecks or areas for improvement.
modeling the different zones. This enables educated
decision-making, which leads to better planning,
SIMS 64                                                      Västerås, Sweden, September 26-27, 2023
Acknowledgment
References
Abidi, M.-A., Chevaillier, P., Lyonnet, B., Kechiche, M., Baert,
P., & Toscano, R. (2020). How to Create a New Generation of
Industrial Processes Simulation by Coupling Simulation Tools
with VR Platforms.
Atmakuri, S., Upadhya, G., Wang, C. M., Chandra, U., & Paul,
A. J. (1993). The role of visualization in process simulation. JOM,
45(10), 21–24. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03222455
Molenda, P., Jugenheimer, A., Haefner, C., Oechsle, O., & Karat,
R. (2019). Methodology for the visualization, analysis and
assessment of information processes in manufacturing
companies.          Procedia        CIRP,      84,        5–10.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.procir.2019.04.291
Wang, J., Phillips, L., Wu, B., Moreland, J., & Zhou, C. (2015).
Simulation and Visualization of Industrial Processes in Unity.
Xu, T., Song, G., Yang, Y., Ge, P., & Tang, L. (2021).
Visualization and simulation of steel metallurgy processes.
International Journal of Minerals, Metallurgy and Materials,
28(8), 1387–1396. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12613-021-2283-5
Yang, T., Yi, X., Lu, S., Johansson, K. H., & Chai, T. (2021).
Intelligent Manufacturing for the Process Industry Driven by
Industrial Artificial Intelligence. Engineering, 7(9), 1224–1230.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eng.2021.04.023