Debt Markets
Debt Markets
4.1 INTRODUCTION
A bond is a debt security, under which the issuer owes the holders a debt and,
depending on the terms of the bond, is obliged to pay them interest (the coupon) and/or
to repay the principal at a later date (the maturity date). Interest is usually payable at
fixed intervals (annually, semiannually, and sometimes monthly). Very often the bond
is negotiable, i.e. the ownership of the instrument can be transferred i n the secondary
market.
1
• The par value of a bond is the amount that the borrower promises to pay on or
before the maturity date of the issue.
• The coupon rate is the rate that, when multiplied by the par value of a bond,
gives the amount of interest to be paid annually by the borrower (coupon amount).
• The required return is the rate of return that investors currently require on a
bond.
1 The major advantage to munis is that the returns are free from tax.
3
than a government. The company's credit quality is very important: the higher the
quality, the lower the interest rate the investor receives.
4
1. Callable or a redeemable bond feature gives the bond issuer the right but not
the obligation to redeem their issue of bonds before the bond's maturity the
issuer, however, must pay the bond holders a premium. There are two
subcategories of these types of bonds: American callable bonds and European
callable bonds. American callable bonds can be called by the issuer any time
after the call protection period while European callable bonds can be called by
the issuer only on pre-specified dates.
2. Puttable bonds give bondholders the right but not the obligation to sell their
bond back to the issuer at a predetermined price and date. These bonds generally
protect investors from interest-rate risk. If the prevailing bond prices are lower
than the exercise par of the bond, resulting from interest rates being higher than
the bond's coupon rate, it is optimal for investors to sell their bond back to the
issuer and reinvest their money at a higher interest rate.
3. Convertible bonds give bondholders the right but not the obligation to convert
their bonds into a predetermined number of shares at predetermined dates prior
to the bond's maturity.
An embedded option that benefits the issuer will increase the yield required by bond
buyers. An embedded option that benefits the bondholder will decrease the yield
required on the bond.
The first four categories of bond ratings are considered as investment grade bonds,
which generally means that they are “safer” bonds and thus more attractive to
investors. Some regulated institutional investors are only allowed to invest in
investment grade points.
5
The following categories of bond ratings are considered as speculative grade (or junk)
bonds, which generally means that they are “risky” bonds and thus less attractiv e to
investors.
Moody’s S&P Description
Ba BB Speculative; faces ongoing uncertainties or exposure to adverse
conditions which could lead to the inability to pay interest or repay
principal
B B Vulnerable to default, but currently has the capacity to meet interest
and principal obligations
Caa CCC Currently identifiable vulnerability to default and is dependent on
favorable conditions to meet obligations
Ca CC More vulnerable to default and highly speculative
C C Extremely speculative; poor prospects for attaining any real
investment standing
D D Currently in default
The rating of a bond reflects the financial health of the issuer. The rating companies
determine the ratings based on set of the issuer’s financial ratios. There are five
financial ratios that they look at: (1) Coverage (or asset turnover) ratios; (2) Leverage
ratios; (3) Liquidity ratios; (4) Profitability ratios; and (5) Cash flow to debt ratios.
6
n
Ct Par
P0 = å n
+ n
(0.2)
t= 1 (1 + i) (1 + i )
é é 1 ùù
ê1- ê úú
ê ê(1 + i ) n úúú
ê ë ûû+ Par
P0 = C ´ ë (0.3)
i (1 + i ) n
Where P0 is the intrinsic value of a bond, C is the coupon (or interest) payment from
period t , and i is the nominal market interest rate.
A simple modification of the above formula will allow you t o adjust interest rates and
coupon payments to calculate a bond price for any payment frequency:
é é ùù
ê ê úú
ê ê 1 úú
ê1- ê úú
ê êæ i ön´ F úú
ê êç1 + ÷ úú
ê êççè F ø ÷
÷ úú
C ê êë ú
ûú Par
P0 = ´ ë û+
n´ F
(0.4)
F i æ iö
çç1 + ÷÷
F çè F ÷ø
Notice that the only modification to the original formula is the addition of “ F,” which
represents the frequency of coupon payments, or the number of times a year the
coupon is paid. Therefore, for bonds paying annual coupons, F would have a value of
1. Should a bond pay quarterly payments, F would equal 4, and, if the bond paid semi -
annual coupons, F would equal 2.
Example 1
Calculate the price of a bond with a par value of TZS 1,000 to be paid in ten years, a
coupon rate of 10%, and a required yield of 12%. In our example we'll assume that
coupon payments are made semi-annually to bond holders, and that the next coupon
payment is expected in six months. Here are the steps we have to take to calculate the
price:
1. Determine the number of coupon payments: Since two coupon payments will
be made each year for ten years, we will have a total of 20 coupon payments.
2. Determine the value of each coupon payment: Since the coupon payments are
semi-annual, divide the coupon rate in half. The coupon rate is the percentage
off the bond's par value. As a result, each semi-annual coupon payment will be
TZS 50 (TZS 1,000 X 0.05).
3. Determine the semi-annual yield: Like the coupon rate, the required yield of
12% must be divided by two because the number of periods used in the
calculation has doubled. (If we left the required yield at 12%, our bond price
7
would be very low and inaccurate.) Therefore, the required semi -annual yield
is 6% (0.12/2).
4. Plug the amounts into the formula:
é é 1 ùù
ê1-ê úú
ê ê(1 + 0.06) 20 úú
ê ë ûú
û+ 1, 000 = 50´ 1- 0.3118 + 1, 000
P0 = 50´ ë
0.06 1.0620 0.06 3.207
= 50´ 11.47 + 311.82 (0.5)
= TZS 885.32
From the above calculation, we have determined that the bond is selling at a discount:
the bond price is less than its par value because the required yield of the bond is
greater than the coupon rate. The bond must sell at a discount to attract investors, who
could find higher interest elsewhere in the prevailing rates . In other words, because
investors can make a larger return in the market, they need an extra in centive to invest
in the bonds.
Pricing Zero-Coupon Bonds
So what happens when there are no coupon payments? For the aptly-named zero-
coupon bond, there is no coupon payment until maturity. Because of this, the present
value of annuity formula is unnecessary. You simply calculate the present value of
the par value at maturity. Here's a simple example:
Example 2
Let's look at how to calculate the price of a zero -coupon bond that is maturing in five
years, has a par value of TZS 1,000, and a required yield of 6%.
1. Determine the number of periods: Unless otherwise indicated, the required
yield of most zero-coupon bonds is based on a “semi-annual coupon payment.”
Here's why: the interest on a zero-coupon bond is equal to the difference
between purchase price and maturity value, but we need a way to compare a
zero-coupon bond to a coupon bond, so the 6% required yield must be adjusted
to the equivalent of its semi-annual coupon rate. Therefore, the number of
periods for zero-coupon bonds will be doubled, so the zero coupon bond
maturing in five years would have ten periods (5 x 2).
2. Determine the yield: The required yield of 6% must also be divided by two
since the number of periods used in the calculation has doubled. The yield for
this bond is 3% (6% / 2).
3. Plug the amounts into the formula:
Par 1, 000
P0 = n
= = TZS 744.09 (0.6)
(1 + i) (1 + 0.03)10
8
You should note that zero-coupon bonds are always priced at a discount: if zero -
coupon bonds were sold at par, investors would have no way of making money from
them and therefore no incentive to buy them.
Lessons Learned from Valuing a Bond
In the previous example, we know that the characteristics of a bond (e.g. coupon rate,
term to maturity, and payment schedule) will have an impact on the intrinsic value
(i.e. fair market price) of the bond. What are some of the lessons we learned from
valuing a bond?
Lesson 1: There is an inverse relationship between the market interest rate and the
price of a bond, i.e. if the market interest rat e goes up (down), then the price of a
bond will go down (up).
Lesson 2: The price of a bond is affected by the relationship between its coupon
rate and the market interest rate.
Coupon rate > Market interest Price of bond > Par Sold at premium
Coupon rate = market interest Price of bond = Par Sold at par
Coupon rate < market interest Price of bond < Par Sold at discount
9
Example 3
If you purchased a bond with a par value of $100 for $95.92 and it paid a coupon rate
of 5%, this is how you'd calculate its current yield:
0.05´ $100
Current Yield = ´ 100% = 5.21%
$95.92
1. If a bond's current yield is less than its YTM, then the bond is selling at a discount.
2. If a bond's current yield is more than its YTM, then the bond is selling at a premium.
3. If a bond's current yield is equal to its YTM, then the bond is selling at par.
Example 4
Assume you have 15 year pays TZS 110 per year (11%) in interest and TZS 1,00 0
after 15 years in principal payment. The current price of bond is TZS 932.21. We wish
to determine YTM, or discount rate, that equates future flow with the current price.
10
1,000 - 932.21 67.79
110 + 110 +
YTM = 15 = 15 = 110 + 4.52 = 114.52 = 11.94%
0.6(932.21) + 0.4(1,000) 559.33 + 400 959.33 959.33
The answer of 11.94% is a reasonably good approximation of the exact YTM of 12%.
11
4. Yield curve risk. Changes in the shape of the yield curve mean that yields
change by different a m o u n t s for bonds with different maturities.
5. Reinvestment risk. Reinvestment risk occurs when interest r a t e s decline and
investors are forced to reinvest bond cash flows at lower yields.
Reinvestment risk is the greatest for bonds that have embedded call
options, prepayment options, or high coupon rates, and is greater for
amortizing securities t h a n for non-amortizing securities.
6. Credit risk. Credit risk comes in three forms-default risk, credit spread risk,
and downgrade risk.
7. Liquidity risk. Since investors prefer more liquidity to less, a decrease in
a security's liquidity will decrease its price, and the required yi e l d will be
higher.
8. Exchange-rate risk. This is the uncertainty about t h e value of foreign
currency cash flows to an investor in terms of his home country currency.
9. Volatility risk.This risk is present f o r fixed- income securities that have
embedded options-call options, prepayment options, or put options.
Changes in interest rate volatility affect the value of these options a n d
thus affect the value of securities with embedded o p tions.
10. Inflation risk. This is the risk of unexpected inflation, also called purchasing
power risk.
11. Event risk. Risks outside t h e risks of financial m a r k e t s (i.e., natural
dis ast ers , corporate takeovers).
12
6. The sensitivity of bond’s price to a change in its yield is inversely related to
the yield to maturity at which the bond currently is selling. 2
These six propositions confirm that maturity is a major determinant of interest rat e
risk. However, they also show that maturity alone is not sufficient to measure interest
rate sensitivity. Bonds may have same maturity, but the higher coupon bond has less
price sensitivity to interest rate change. Obviously, we need to know more than a
bond’s maturity to quantify its interest rate risk.
4.8.3 Duration
To deal with the ambiguity of the maturity of a bond making many payments, we need
a measure of the average maturity of the bond’s promised cash flows to serve as a
useful summary statistic of the effective maturity of the bond. Frederick Macaulay
termed the effective maturity concept the duration (D) of the bond.
Duration differs from maturity as a measure of interest rate sensitivity because
duration takes into account the time of arrival and the rate of reinvestment of all cash
flows during the bond’s life. Technically, duration is the weighted-average time to
maturity using the relative present values of the cash flows as the weights . Duration
is more complete measure of bond’s interest rate sensitivity than maturity because it
considers the time of arrival of all cash flows as well as the bond’s maturity.
n n n
t.CFt
å (1 + i )
t å t.CFt DFt å t.PVt
t= 1 t= 1 t= 1
D= n
= n
= n
(0.12)
CFt
å (1 + i )
t å CFt DFt å PVt
t= 1 t= 1 t= 1
Where,
t = the time period in which the coupon or principal payments occurs
CF t = the interest or principal payment that occur in period t
i = the yield to maturity on the bond
= summation sign for addition of all items from t = 1 to n.
n = last period in which cash flow is received
DF t = the discount factor using the current market interest rate.
PV t = Present value of the cash flow at the end of period t (CFt DFt )
The large the value of D that is calculated for the bond, the more sensitive is the
price of that bond to changes or shocks in interest rates.
2
A bond with a high yield to maturity will display lower price volatility than a bond
with a lower yield to maturity, but a similar coupon rate and term to maturity
13
higher the duration, the higher the bond's price risk, ceteris paribus. Formula, for
annual PMTs:
DP di
%P = =- D (0.13)
P (1 + i)
%P = Percentage change in the price of the bond (ΔP / P)
di = the change in interest rates
i = original level of interest rates
For semi-annual payments:
DP di
=- D (0.14)
P 1+ i ( 2 )
For small changes in interest rates, bond prices move in an inversely proportional
(linear) direction, according to the length of duration. The higher the duration, the
greater the price change (in %), the greater the capital loss (gain), and the gr eater the
price risk.
Example 6
Calculate the duration of a $1,000, 6% coupon bond with three years to maturity.
Assume that all market interest rates are 7%.
14
4.8.5 Bond convexity
Convexity is a measure of the sensitivity of the price of a bond to changes in interest
rates. It is related to the concept of duration. Duration is a linear measure of how the
price of a bond changes in response to interest rate changes. As interest rates change,
the price is not likely to change linearly, but instead it would change over some curved
function of interest rates. The more curved the price function of the bond is, the more
inaccurate duration is as a measure of the interest rate sensitivity.
Convexity is a measure of the curvature of how the price of a bond changes as the
interest rate changes, i.e. how the duration of a bond changes as the interest rate
changes. Specifically, duration can be formulated as the first derivative of the price
function of the bond with respect to the interest rate in question. Then the convexity
would be the second derivative of the price function with respect to the interest rate.
Price approximation using duration
Price
Actual price
Tangent line at y*
estimated price
Yield
Notice that dP/ di line is tangent to the price yield curve at a given yield as shown in
the above figure. For small changes in yields (i.e. from y * to either y1 or y 2 ), this
tangent straight line gives a good estimate of the actual price changes. In contrast, for
larger changes in yields (i.e. from y * to either y 3 or y 4 ), the straight line will estimate
the new price of the bond at less than the actual price shown by the price -yield curve.
Thus, duration allows us to estimate bond price changes for a change in interest rates.
However, the equation we are using is accurate only for very small changes in market
yield. The accuracy of the estimate of the price change deteriorates with larger
changes in yields because the modified duration calculation is a linear approximation
of a bond price change that follows a curvilinear (convex) function.
15
Determinants of Convexity
Convexity is a measure of the curvature of the price yield relationship. Because
duration is the slope of the curve at a given yield, convexity indicates changes in
duration. Mathematically, convexity is the second derivative of price with respect to
yield ( d 2 P / di 2 ) divided by price.
d 2P
Convexity = di 2 (0.15)
P
Computation of convexity:
n CF
d 2P
di 2
=
1
(1 + i )2
t
(
t =1 (1 + i )t
t2 + t ) (0.16)
Remember
Example: 3 year Bond, Face value 1000, 12% coupon rate, 9% required return
(1) (2) (3) (4) (1)x(4) (5) (4)x(5)
Year CFt PV@9% Pvt CFt PV t t +t
2
Duration: 2.70
1 =
(1 + 0.09)2 0.84168
11204.34 x 0.84168= 9430.468
Convexity = 8.764874
2 (0.19)
16