Introduction
Definitional techniques are fundamental tools for achieving precision and clarity in language.
They aid in conveying the meaning of concepts or terms, ensuring that communication is
effective. These techniques fall into two broad categories: extensional (denotative) definitions
and intensional (connotative) definitions.
Source: ([Solved] 2.4 10. Practice With Definitional Techniques Definitional. . . | CliffsNotes,
2023)
Extensional (Denotative) Definition
An Extensional (Denotative) Definition: It is the one that assigns a meaning to. a term by
indicating the members of the class that the definiendum denotes. They are chiefly. used for
producing lexical and stipulative definitions.
Three kinds of definition:-
1. Demonstrative (ostensive):- Demonstrative language, specifically ostensive
demonstration, involves using physical gestures or actions to direct attention to a
specific object or set of objects. This type of communication is often employed when
trying to convey the meaning of a word or concept. Let's elaborate on the example you
provided:
Example: "Board"
Imagine you are in a classroom, and there are several boards present. To convey the
meaning of the word "board" through ostensive demonstration, you would point to one
or more specific boards while saying, "Board" to indicate that the term refers to the
object(s) you are pointing at.
1. Pointing to one board: You point to a single board and say, "Board," making it clear
that the word refers to that particular item.
2. Pointing to all boards: Alternatively, if you want to convey that the term "board"
encompasses all similar objects in the room, you may gesture towards all the boards
present while saying, "Board," indicating that the word applies to each of them.
2. Enumerative definitions
assign meaning to a term by listing or naming specific members or instances of the class that the
term represents. This type of definition provides clarity by offering concrete examples, making it
easier for individuals to understand the scope and characteristics of the term. Let's elaborate
further with an example:
**Example: "Fruit"**
In an enumerative definition, the term "fruit" could be defined by listing specific examples of
fruits. For instance:
"**Fruit** means a botanical product that develops from the ovary of a flowering plant and
typically contains seeds. Examples include:
1. **Apple**
2. **Banana**
3. **Orange**
4. **Grapes**
5. **Watermelon**
In this definition, the term "fruit" is explained by naming specific members of the class—apple,
banana, orange, grapes, and watermelon. Each of these examples helps to convey the idea that
fruits are botanical products derived from flowering plants, and they commonly contain seeds.
This approach is useful when dealing with terms that have identifiable and specific instances
within a well-defined class. Enumerative definitions are beneficial for introductory purposes,
especially when the audience needs concrete examples to understand the concept being defined.
However, it's important to note that enumerative definitions may not cover all possible members
of the class and might not be exhaustive.
3. Definition by subclass,
also known as division or subclassification, assigns meaning to a term by specifying its various
subclasses or subcategories. This type of definition breaks down the broader category into more
specific components, providing a more detailed understanding of the term. Let's elaborate on the
example you provided:
**Example: "Philosophy"**
In a definition by subclass, the term "philosophy" is explained by naming several subcategories
or branches of philosophy:
"**Philosophy** means a systematic study that includes various branches, such as:
1. **Metaphysics**
2. **Epistemology**
3. **Logic**
4. **Ethics**
5. **Aesthetics**
In this definition, the term "philosophy" is defined by enumerating its main subclasses. Each of
these subclasses represents a distinct area of study within the broader field of philosophy.
- **Metaphysics** deals with the fundamental nature of reality.
- **Epistemology** explores the nature and scope of knowledge.
- **Logic** focuses on reasoning and valid argumentation.
- **Ethics** examines moral principles and values.
- **Aesthetics** concerns the study of beauty and artistic principles.
This approach is effective in conveying the diversity within the broader category, helping
individuals understand the specific areas or aspects covered by the term. Definition by subclass
is useful when a term encompasses a range of related but distinct subcategories, and breaking
them down clarifies the overall meaning.
Intentional (Connotative) Definitions
Intentional (connotative) Definitions : It is one that assigns meaning to a word by indicating the qualities
or attributes that the word connotes.
Four kinds of Definition:-
1.Synonymous definition
A synonymous definition is one in which the term being defined (definiendum) is equated with
another term (definiens) that carries the same or nearly identical meaning. This type of
definition is straightforward and aims to provide a clear and direct understanding of the term.
Let's elaborate on the example you provided:
**Example: "Physician"**
In a synonymous definition, the term "physician" is defined by using the term "doctor" as its
equivalent:
"**Physician** means **doctor**."
In this case, the definiens ("doctor") is a single word that conveys the same attributes or
characteristics as the term being defined ("physician"). The terms "physician" and "doctor" are
considered synonymous in this context, as they refer to the same professional role in the field
of medicine.
Synonymous definitions are commonly used when the terms being equated are widely
accepted as interchangeable and convey an identical or nearly identical meaning. They simplify
the understanding of a term by providing a readily recognizable synonym, making the definition
concise and accessible.
2. Etymological Definition
An etymological definition reveals the historical roots and development of a word, explaining its
origin in both its own language and other languages. It involves breaking down a word into its
components and exploring the meanings of those components in various languages. Here's a
simple example:
**Example: "Quarantine"**
The term "quarantine" has an interesting etymology. It comes from the Italian word
"quarantina," meaning forty days. The Italian term, in turn, traces its roots back to the Latin
word "quadraginta," also meaning forty.
In the 14th century, during the Black Death, ships arriving at the port of Venice were required
to anchor for 40 days before landing to prevent the spread of the plague. This practice was
known as "trentino" or "quarantine." The term later evolved into the English word
"quarantine."
So, in an etymological definition:
"**Quarantine** is derived from the Italian 'quarantina,' which means forty days, and
ultimately from the Latin 'quadraginta,' also meaning forty. The term originated from the
practice of isolating ships for 40 days during the Black Death in Venice."
This etymological explanation not only defines the word but also provides a historical context
for its usage and sheds light on its linguistic evolution.
3. Operational definition
An operational definition assigns meaning to a word by detailing the specific experimental
procedures or observable criteria that determine whether the word is applicable to a particular
thing or concept. This type of definition is particularly common in scientific and research
contexts, where clarity and precision are crucial. Let's break down this concept with an
example:
**Example: "Intelligence"**
Suppose you want to provide an operational definition for the term "intelligence" within the
context of a psychological study. Instead of offering a vague or abstract definition, you might
specify observable criteria or procedures to measure intelligence:
"**Intelligence** is operationally defined as the score obtained on the 'XYZ Intelligence Test,'
which assesses problem-solving abilities, memory, and logical reasoning. Individuals scoring
above a certain threshold on this test are considered to have a high level of intelligence."
In this example:
1. The term "intelligence" is defined in operational terms by referring to a specific test (XYZ
Intelligence Test).
2. The experimental procedure involves the administration of this test.
3. The observable criteria for determining intelligence are the scores on the test, with a certain
threshold indicating a high level of intelligence.
This operational definition makes the concept of intelligence measurable and replicable,
allowing researchers to apply consistent criteria in different situations. It emphasizes the
importance of concrete procedures and observable outcomes, aligning with the principles of
scientific rigor and precision.
4. Definition by Genus and Difference
Definition by genus and difference is a method of assigning meaning to a term by identifying a
broader category (genus) and one or more specific characteristics that distinguish the term
from other members of that category (difference). Your example, "Ice means frozen water,"
illustrates this concept:
- **Genus:** "Water"
- **Difference:** "Frozen"
In this definition:
- **Genus (Water):** Specifies the broader category to which the term belongs.
- **Difference (Frozen):** Identifies the specific characteristic that distinguishes "ice" from
other forms of water.
So, the complete definition can be expressed as:
"Ice is a form of water that is in a frozen state."
This method helps clarify the meaning of a term by placing it within a broader category (genus)
and highlighting the specific features that set it apart (difference). It is commonly used to
provide precise and systematic definitions, especially in philosophical and logical contexts.