E-Payment vs Cash: Comparative Study
E-Payment vs Cash: Comparative Study
PAGE NO
ROGESS REPORT-01
Tehic DAussion
tomparaline study
on- PHyment
Cu depie u t ds againit
eplhonuheexence ls
ustamers nole tha
h
o5luom dnde
e-mymeuit
LC0sh punchase Vs dletuiled 1eseauh u
ohicshclueled ae:
4ntedudtion fdhe Tobic lgmmpany Dackgsun
Ltenaluue Reuteuw; hiectie e
study; Ratisnale
késeanch Aethadelsqyj Dala ucslleclion
study £htexhre-
Analysus i Dta "nalyss
Toels kax Dala lumitation sud
-datin; hhdihgs Zuggesluons ;
Lonclusion ; ReleuenesL
201.
dhe yea 1940 do yeo
Diuuou work
.Yausiea Khone
DalaCalletuou
Dala dnalysu aud IntexpAeataliou
2. Palak Banche
Thtodudien dhe Tohi
Ltexalune Reuieu
3 Manasui Shaumma
0bectwe e Akudy
TlelDala nalys
ahanu Padida
uCompany ackauaund
Rational_Skudy
5Khushi sdanki
Endings
uggLhans
Lrihitatien f Akudy
and Heleueuse is done by
nd bh cotclusion
03
GOLD
PAGE NIO
DATE:JO20
PROGESS EPORT-02.
Resnac Memsds
h e ludy u ExpIoalap n matwre. Thi ud
udy
psenls an 9xheumertainvesugalisn n nb-
-0tantactors inlaencaing butun _e-bayneut
Systema
Samnaling lechnique
he method skampling hu Lstudy us
HAndom Ep_data Ahsuld ba csl.etedthaug the
Ael- deugned quationnane The sizeof uueapondenf is 10
Data Lllec~onn
Quosiionaaike ulUAed Je Lollect_pruma_dala Each
ute uh the qulstionnaue has oleuelshed de addnes
spnailit cbectie
l
he analysis of_data also allatea that Zpoment Cash
be a nert-genokalion paymant tion and
l srnan asa hasie nied apeeple
2TALAk ARCAHE
3MANAsVI SHARMA
Chapter 1
Research Methodology
06. 26 2 7
Data Collection
07. 28-38
Tools for Data Analysis
08. 39
Chapter 3
HAPTER
01
OL Date
NTRODUCTION.
Ln_C-haym@nt suystem is aula nar
ansacuons et paying e nd donwi3
ggodsond
lhrsugh an elikoxic mautm, uithoulhe use
checks t Cash. Jt% ako Called an elaroi
painornt ÁYstem e Onlinebaymanl
TO ystem
lhe eleeonic afpnant ystem hos qtown inthoesingly
GuerHhe last dcodes e t he qkeroing
ophead Jternot-baselhanking And
opping es tho wsrld odvances bre uuth
technnkeqy deuolopmnt, ue Con dee he ise
elecbeonipaymntsystems And paymonpoaing
deuices s Ria _incheases,inbrauey and ppkDide
kauicle,
ran&acioninuslung Curtenu
nancial paymenl
ot morepaitiesEpaymet
tharaex betuueen wo
hou porlicular eribilty to chonge as petu tho
Customek lilstyles, þutchasingpouuor and
changing "paelerencos n E Kasearch Pape
e f i L be "couering CustDmatpAfpkan2
ousingCask paymaku vs_Epayminl
loption ol Lashles Ikarsastion has been
&ignificantl pushed by Pxime inister Ma
NHrandsaModli os darte gouenmert Aolotms
alte denpneigaluon sfih. Value Cuskoniy o
.500 _and 1odo C6L o_Cos cikculltion
The demoneigaion osulid in unorece.dentid qansth
in digtals paymernl
an
any riuato elaclo companiee oncdJndian
AnAn pproach...
easy o u e and sioree
Lashi d all porvasiue,
Ond eersgheat Convenience The challenge i n
asesing t pk0gkes o a COunby
Cosh t digitizaltibn asises om
that, gie the anonymitiy e Cash
ransacionsik s ver Aickt to establish
the ezat Vslum e Hansau0 Conductod
CoshCash And chnstqunly that_Value
ueh Bansaions
Credit Card.
chedi casd_u o bayment card imue t e
&eXA candholders) do'enahle dhe eardholder
de pay_ Mexwhant fa gosdsAnd seruices
bassd n the cardhaldlex's accuned deht
pay them
Lie pxomise te the cad issuer dto pa
h edhedmauit plus dhether agaetd chauges).
The CaKd usse sually_a bank Ckedit cárd)
union) xeatos aMevslung account and gkait
a line Hedit to dhe ucarcholden, fram_which
the con2holder ucan torrou money fer payment
te a mexchant as a cash aelvande.hete ae
tuo xedlit tand gnoups: tonume CHeditcands
CLnd huuness e d i cand Mot Lcards a e
blostus,, but usome_ane metal uads(stainles
Oddy'
Date
Oddy'
01 Date
EPayMENT Hpps.
Phonele..
honele US n ndian digital payments and n
ialtechnslogy csmpary hedguatered in
Bengaluu Kaunatuka Sndia PhonePe uas
surdledin Decenmhux 2015, b Same Migams
Rahul Chai and Buzn_bngineo The Phonee
ahbaaed on the United ymerita Jatexone_(Ue)
wwrt uine in dugust 2016 4 u swned hy
klpkat a Absioliany halmaxL.
The PhonePe aph u auadable in 1 dndian_ lungu-
-AgesUaing usex Phonep, uulrs Can sLnd and
Aeceine mohey, change mehile , DTH, dnt cacds,
mauke wiliy baymenlk,pay alT sheh3 ,nt nueAt
n daz sauing unds iouid Funds , buy unuu
-Hce muttialJunds gold, andilu n
addition_PhonePe also allouus uses do bosk dhe
Ala uids, pay o Redhus dickelh, bosk Ylighti and
hotels on aibihe thuaugh dhe Switeh plathotm
URL phonehe.com
Usexs 3 5 wHOe
Foytm
Paytm [a paial ahbuevatien le "pay dhxog
mabile) u an Andian multinatiionalJunancidl
cechmslgy ompanyseh speuializing unU digital
ument AYSTeM ,e-Lemmerce and inanial
tuansacuons and baymentsto vaisus merchai
Cund inanial inatitutisns
ds dhe
uonapany Laza) m than 2 cuGue
mexchats acuoAs hdia ue dhei QR code
AyatenaTe Ccceht payments disectls into þaymat
the
bank uoLLawitdtsgHOSS nexchandié Value in
EY2020-21 aGASall
platfoums ua u
00,000 Uoue (Us$52 billiom). In
buand value uas estimated to he 2020, Peytms
t US $G.3 billbn,
making oneGthe Tob 10 most valued
buandxun Sndia
Oddy
Date.
12
dn
ios deuice, alhet_th Jinited fundionality
aclolitiou do dhus , the Huicealse sihhi
pasKesAueh as Loubans, beauding basses, Cambus
maNeikell,
1D Cads, ca keys, euonl Hik
puhlic knsborIalioa ickels, SLoA cOxds
health AeCds ane kayalty LaMds
Partiuhalung &loe.
Un Aatomber 18,201fyocgle
0
daunched a baumanls
apb Sndia knourn as Tez,utiuzing dhe UniLed
Peuymms ntertace (UPI). n lugust 28,2ol8,
lyeoale Lehkanded Tez olyoagle Pa
Funded - Seblemhex 1,
2015, and theu
HeNeLDed n Jauay 8, 2018
Wehalte
pay.google.cem
1 Date
Aamazen hy
AmazanPay LAn online paymeili puecesing
2oot,-
seMuice unecd by olmasanLaunched un_
base
onasau Py AAKS uses t h e ugsumeH_
mang. Lm and ocuses_on gung uses
Lthe ehuon te pay wth thei dmajaM
eleuial mexphaul wehaiteA s -
Maxch 2021, he seuuice becaue auailable
un 4uStAIa Belgiuu LypAus Denmauk, kuante
enmany, Hurgaxy 9ndia Repiubluc o dnelanal
talyJapaun, Lutembouug, Nethinlcunds hrtugal
SpoinSuneclen, Suitzerlaiid United kihgd om
and the Wnited tates
ype o businesgSubsidiauy
Ounded - 200+
aytal.
mexicanmultinatuonal
aylal Holdungs , Jne. Lan
on nlune
inancial technslagu uombauny oheuating cAun=
systei un dhe majort of_
paymeli
tes that isuhpart online mony nuisfers,
elecTuonicalteumatine
a n d Auues o s can
t eadiuonalpahpaa methods such as check!
Qund maney Lclews The company aheHates_as
abayme pscessoyeu ouline uenclsrs , audion
LOmaercialLNs
site and mauy otheH
which it chaxgos a e
Estublished un1998 _as Conlinity Paufal
hugh_an 1 Po_un2002-
bacame a uholly OuLneddubsidiauy eBay
laton dhat yoan, valued at $.5 bilion Sn
2015 eBay sun Paypal de ahaneholdexs.
aune PauPal bocame an unaependeut compony
aguin he combanswA Hanked_34 th MtHhe
2h21 EouuneSoo the_laxgest UnitedStates
Cnbolfos by uLvenue
ET DANKING Apps. o o 0 o0 -
Online
Cnline taukung also knoun us internet bank-
ing web belnkingq honne banking us an
elektaonic payneltt syatema that erñables
Custemexs a bauik h e hancal
uinslittiosn to landuct a n g e inanual
Hansatllom thuough dhe ihankial ttua-
usu s webaite.1e omline bankingAYAtem
willl
u typitaly cennect_to _ be pat
the LAL haunking Aysteu sheatesd hy a
bank io pHsuide Cuslonneks akces de ankin.
suies in place o aadHosnal hranch
banking Qnihe banking Aignitantly &educes
dhe hauaka sherating kost Kby xeBucing
Heleunce on a hulncl mewokk _aue slers
gueato-Aenuenience to_Custonmes in inne
awng in coming do a buanch and the
Lenuthienue ef holhg dble Je pexsnm
banking dansaiods euen when buanches
ane losed. ntexnet banking pxewdes boxsohalL
and uepouate bankg senues fexihngealuru
Lush Laswewfh accunt baloces obtaining
sdatenaeatchésking uecet aunsariiaui,
tHanseuing mone boluueen Lacceutz ond
makingphymet.
Date
INDIA
h 1998,LLIC ICICI Bauk untradured unternet
banking to is custonmexs
AUSTRALIA
CHINA
nddu'
19 Dato
IIERATURE KEVIEW..
Jndian
by the Jndian
Lhe_choice paymentmatiod
psbulation haateoactod the atterstion o
Pound
phactitioners
hana edchelass And
lany
e grldl, masket loaders haus bean
hckeasingy bnbwngLowars making he pa
Cxfptienë asCoKvenient asOMible
CAusloek
altuclielt
De. Navpreet ingh Sinlhu (2o13)delactad bank
pekcoplian and atcepLabilty o
estomas abaut elelric banking
Mandechkau.l2o11) attempotesb unueil the poruphon
held by Cand uses and mamber eslabllshments
owandplasic oney in Jadia
Oddy
21 Date
OBTECTIVES OF
THE STUD.
The shicotae o
Atudy Jua aweptauce alecteeuMe
Dundut udore
J
Oddy
t,()(2QO0
Oddy'
'l
~ '-1
~ ~ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ __ __ 0 810- -
_ 25
=
~ :======u== = = = === =-= ==- =-= "'--= -=,- ---= =--- ===
- - -- - - - - -
--11--_-- _, - - - -- --
.. . -
. .~
'-J
- ~ ~ . a n ~-L ~
- - - -- j j~ ~ ~ . ~- ~ ~ ~~ ~1~ ~
--
•
~ ~ ~.,_ _!;.~ U . ~_!__- - - - -
~ 1-
~
• II
vyvJ/
k212)-u5be, .•
I t
-=. - -- - t r - -- - - -- - - - - - - - - - --
Oddy"
" ~
,.'
'\J -
-
-
-
'» ---~
- '
~
, f .
r,l '
'I
'
'7
I
-
~
l ~r
...
.,II
r
~ - -,JI!_
~
~u I
'
I
•<t
" ,L ... ~
I, ,L
-
.
~
.,-
• ~
~
-
, ,.-'
j
~
L
'- ,/ ~
>
•
,
- -
Oddy'
,
__!2~6
. _ _ _ _ _ ___ _ __________ Date _ _ __
Oddy"
n.-trf ■
-~
I\, _______ _____ Date_
-=
- =a:=
~ 1
~ = = , == = = ~1= = =- = ======
urn:fm_//_fUJ[[bNJ O 4 0
t -
Oddy•
?
•
t
60 ', Date _ _
t
,
ror?J1 f1<1NT
RESEARCH PROJECT
ence ways .. ...
Help us to know about your opinion towar ds payment prefer
* Required
1. Name *
2. Email ID *
3. Age *
c-) Below 18
0 Between 18-24
0 Between 24-40
0 Between 40-60
C ) Above 60
Q cash
0 E-Payments App
0 Net Banking
0 Credit/Debit Cards
:>
~
) 5. 2.Which E-Payment app you prefer?
C) Never
C ) Daily
CJ weekly
C ) Monthly
C ) Yearly
Q Agree
0 Strongly agree
~ Disagree
0 Strongly Disagree
ij,J
''\,
I\,
'\,,~ 8. 5.For what reason you generally prefer E-payments?
~· C) It saves time
C) It is convenient
"
),
\)
C) It provides cost free benefits
C) It is safe and secure
\)
9. 6.What things do you keep in mind while using E-payment?
~
Mark only one oval.
~
c=) Available Discounts
.
J
~
c=) Premium Offers
c=) cashBack
'
f 10. 7.What is your opinion regarding E-payments that using it always leads to bad
experience?
~ Strongly Disagree
(J Disagree
11. a.Do you think that rural people do not have access to E-payment due to poor
internet?
( : ) Strongly agree
C ) Agree
C) Disagree
CJ Strongly disagree
12. 9.Do you think that using E-payment will increase the chance of fraud and theft?
0 Strongly agree
C ) Agree
C) Disagree
0 Strongly Disagree
0 Not secure
0 Time consuming
C) Unsatisfied
C) Highly Unsatisfied
Forms
~
I
12.What according to you is the biggest disadvantage of cash payments?
~ Money change
Keeping track of expenses
~ With cash , you 're entirely out of luck-there's no way to get it .back if you lose it.
Availability
~ No
,y
v-
~ If the volume of transactions increase than the government would be pressurised to print more currency.
Non availabitiy of much cash with the shopkeepers make the situation uneasy to get the remaining amount.
Inconvenient
There are no records for cash payments where online payment has records
Cash handling and counting
'1-
We didn't have change on ti me
¥ Small amount of payment not available while giving change .
~ -
-L·•
Some time money problems
CARRYING CASH MAKES YOU A TARGET FOR THIEVES
When there is unavailability of cash. As everyone carries mobile. So it's an easy way. It prevents from fraud also.
It is time consuming and cash can be lost from pocket
Theft of money
Cash can be stolen and it is difficult to carry it.
L~ We cannot carry 20000-40000rs and above cash with us easily. E-payrnents made the work easier and
~ ~~~ ahv:~:~~a:~:~yo~i~:ft
~
j
~etwork issues etc
l
1
! Yes
Mostly slips from pocket
With cash , you're entirely out of luck-there's no way to get it back if you lose it.
I~ Not secure and complicated
I Ca sh replacement
I~ -
· ~ I am fine thanku
1--1)
!4)
1 • .~
,.l,1'
'\,
\) ;t is unsecure
Theft
'J To carry it
They take space in pockets and they are not easy to carry and have high risk of getting stolen.
Carrying cash
At many times , it may be unsafe & insecure.
Heandaling probably
Sometimes we lost cash due to theft.
Carrying cash is Target to thieves
Withdraw money and always keep wallet with us
Not easy to handle huge amount (risky)
Not secure
Time taking process .. Some time
Problem of change
Most accurate
No any technical issue
Always carry the cash
for anything.
Much time is consumed in it and consumer can even refuse or can make mistakes while paying
Need to carry it and there is more chances of theft
People do not pay tax pf that money and save it as a black money
Net issue
Lack of cash
Cash
Secutriy and unhonosty
Security
Cash bills take a lot of your wall et's space and makes it bulky.
To carry them all the time
No
Date _ _ -
Date
-
I
,
--
-
-
'
~
~
~
.,
,
'
)
-
-
• L
.i ,
I ·~ .,, - I
-
~"''
'
-~
-
,
~~'
ii.
-
"I
r---
\
' ~
, .....
-
I
~ l
I -
I -
L ~
. L -
,
I
11
,,L.
' ' .,__
,
l
~
,.~
~'
' J' ~
(]trlltrll~t
.... '\J
I\,
=ate::;:-~=-=-~-~ ===
'. ~====ir=_Lf:~:: ::::::::::::::::::::::::::: ::=D
___1Rll[[
l ..
~ V - - ---ll------- ---1-1--~ -
~ _rrfHlf!RillA/l] ON
1.Which payment method you prefer the most? tl:J Copy
1 00 responses
e Cash
e E-Payments App
e Net Banking
e Credit/Debit Cards
- ~ - ~=Q__=-"il-__1100 responses
-~
• Net Banking Apps
e Paytm
• Google Pay
e Phone pay
e Amazon pay
• Pay Pal
•
_:.Y:1i~___ ___ _ _ _ _ ___ ____ ____ __ o a t e - - -- -
\Q Copy
--------.1 --~3.How often do you use the following E- paymen t method?
- ~.L"-l1------ 99respons es
• Never
• Dally
• Weekly
• Monthly
e Yearly
-------<1- ---<4.E-p ayments system can be easily underst ood and readily adopted ? lb} Copy
_ _ J..{~'----ff-~100respon ses
e Agree
e Strongly agree
.. 20% 8 Disagree
e Strongly Disagree
79%
_'1!._!:l~ __________ __________ __ oate _ _ __ _
~'u- --JI--~ •
•
It saves time
It is convenient
e It provtde11 coat free benefrts
e It Is safe and secure
·- - - - - - - - - ,6.What things do you keep in mind-: ~il~ -~~ing E-payment? lbJ Copy
6
~ - -=---..,"--#--- -
99 responses
e Available Discounts
66.7%
e Premium Offers
e Cash Back
e Easy payment gateway
->
=ate---==--==--====
_~~-==--==--==--==---==---==---==---==---==-==-==--==-=D
'tS=~l(=
tx,---- 1
1----'z what is your opinion regarding E-payments that using it always leads
to bad experience?
lb) Copy
·I \~ J 100 responses
' --=c...:.___-----Jj.___
e Strongly agree
t . & \ - - -~
58% e Agree
• Strongly Disagree
e Disagree
8%
,,
e Strongly agree
e Agree
• Disagree
e Strongly disagree
,
60 'i
IDlclla:ily"
u
~
\,
- -- ---'-''"-ll----
_ '...!.___!_
i l/_
I
_ __ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ __
e Strongly agree
e Agree
• Disagree
e strongly Disagree
11 %
43%
-
, -- - - - t t - - . 10.W hat kind of obst acle s are face d while using E-pa
i,
1 ymen ts? lbl Copy
1r__ ___,=0~1t- -- 99 respo nses
e Not secure
69.7%
e Non availability of merchant
e Time consuming
e Problem due to bank server
,
__j[L_ __ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ _
_ o ate _ _ _ __
e Highly satisfied
e Satisfied
e Neutral
e Unsatisfied
e Highly Unsatisfied
54%
-7
_:lf}Q6_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ oate _ _ __
l
nJD]6J-5 o o. 0 _._,,_JJ_
•
Date
OUGGESTIONS..
Ewallkt Company dhould by atliat
o - 6o and
pesple age qkop setuak
aboue
dhould
paiiesinyøluadin Onlineaymani
in_etodo
Lse diaital dgnaliiresin ensu
ensuwre
lathontication arsaction
DuL
DuL pse internel, pesple euural akea
Cunnat haue accoss o paymenty o ,Lompany
houldscus On that alho
E-paynat leacs to
A man ims using
doing
ltauds aha hole buekik jpespla ausid
pnine kansacion
Pibternd da bigant
Prob lam_due t i Bank cloruek is
ausl by Customez,
keason bstacle
Oddy
Date
LIMITATION.
uth eash_youju utirely eut 0 Jusk
tuu's no nlay o get t back i U
Oddy
Date -
s CoMAmd ond
Huth Hi
Oddy
51 Date.
CONCLUSION...
ex all the urueyand analysis il
Can
Canbe Concludedl ancdl oid that bLth
Cash anc Anadyantagaa
andE-payrnols haue thannOwn
adksanta4e3and disaduaniagea
Cash hasbeen adloptadl om ages dD it s
ConlortoAle inpayment JAdoris oeefpda
Lho D n the athos E-baymint as msat
Conlertable genodlon