Chapter 2
Chapter 2
Chapter 2
A Thesis presented to
The Faculty
NURSING AND HEALTH SCIENCES DEPARTMNET
NAGA COLLEGE FOUNDATION
City of Naga
In Partial Fulfillment
Of the Requirements for the Degree
Bachelor of Science in Nursing
ABIAS, ALYSSA M.
ANDAL, ALANNES O.
BIGORNIA, JANRICK N.
BONAGUA, CHRISTIAN B.
LAURETA, ARJEL R.
LUNA, MARK JEFFERSON C.
2023
Introduction
of general education and professional courses. It teaches students the knowledge and
skills to render care to other people. The nursing program comprises three components,
which are knowledge, skills, and attitude (KSA). Knowledge, or a theoretical aspect, is
book-based information given by the clinical instructors (CIs), and it is said to be ideal.
It is the foundation for all the students and even Cis to perform the skills. Skill, or
practice turning, is the application of theory into practice. Its goal is to sharpen the
expertise and attributes of nursing students in different aspects and areas of the nursing
profession. Attitude is how the students behave, and constructive criticism. It consists of
Theory-Practice Gap (TPG) has long been highlighted one of the biggest problems
hindering the advancement of nursing sciences and nursing students from achieving
their learning outcon (Bouchlaghem & Mansouri, 2018). Salahetal (2018) noted that
while the problem of TPG is growing, it is not receiving the attention, that reflects its
significance, and despite the documentation and researches on it, the improvement on
professional practice has been at “snail pace.” Because of TPG, new generations of
nurses are being produced unable to cope with the demands of caring (Lindsay, 2019).
between what students learn in the classroom and what they experience in clinical
settings. This problem causes the students to struggle and perform poorly. There are
several factors affecting the performance of the students. These include the different
checklists and equipment of the institution, a lack of interpersonal skills, and the ideal
versus the practical. The ideal is best explained in a return demonstration because in
school the findings are normal, whereas in practice the findings vary from patient to
We observed the gaps in theory and practice experienced by the 2nd-year nursing
We chose this study for the sake of all 2nd-year nursing students. This study will
prepare them for the dynamic changes that arise over time. Further, it will help them
adjust and adapt in clinical settings. And most importantly, it will improve their
This study will focus on the THEORY – PRACTICE GAP: Challenges of 2nd year
a. age
b. gender
c. marital status
d. family status
e. monthly income
2. What are the challenges of 2 nd year nursing student on transition from theory to
a. different procedure
b. RLE protocol
c. interpersonal skills
3. What are the effects of THEORY – PRACTICE GAP: Challenges of 2nd Year
a. psychosocial effects
b. emotional effects
c. physical effects
theory to practice.
5. What is the intervention program that can be proposed to bridge the gap
Assumption
2. This study will show the challenges of Theory – Practice Gap among 2 nd year
Nursing Students.
4. The feasible intervention program that can be proposed in bridging the gap
between theory and practice.
Hypothesis
This study will premise the hypothesis that challenges and effects of THEORY–
PRACTICE GAP: Challenges of 2nd Year Nursing Students on Transition from theory to
This study will determine on the theory-practice gap: Challenges of 2nd year
Naga College Foundation nursing students, school year 2023-2024; Out of the total 316
regular nursing students, 177 respondents were determined using Slovin’s Formula, 22
students per section will be selected as the respondents. Other year level such as 1 st
year, 3rd year, 4th year, and students from Manila group are not included in the study.
Nursing Students. This study will help them to be prepared in a real-world clinical
setting which will enhances the quality of care they provide to the patient and improve
patient outcome.
Clinical Instructors. The result of this study may help them to determine the
challenges of students between theory and practice. Through this, they will realize the
Dean of Health and Sciences Department. The result of this can study can be used
for the implementation of training programs to enhance nursing student’s practical skills.
School Administrator. This study will be useful for them to develop effective method
Future Researchers. This study can be used as a reference which will broaden their
Definition of Terms
Common terms used in this study were defined operationally for clarity.
Theory Practice Gap. It is what students learn in the classroom and what they
Nursing Student. 2nd year students officially enrolled during the school year
Definition of Terms
Common terms used in this study were defined operationally and conceptually.
Theory Practice Gap. In this study it refers on what students learn in the classroom
a. Physical. This may have a negative impact on students' physical health by impeding
practical skills could result from this gap, compromising patient care and safety. To
guarantee that nursing students are suitably equipped to handle physical health issues
b. Emotional. Students may experience emotional effects from this gap, such as
emotional health. Closing this gap will help nursing students feel more competent and
emotionally resilient, which will make them better able to handle the emotional demands
of patient care.
students to develop their psychosocial competence and improve their general well-being,
2nd year Nursing Student. 2nd year regular students officially enrolled during the
practical skills, students may struggle with mastering physical procedures, such as
b. RLE protocol. Students may struggle to follow established protocols during clinical
patients, families, and healthcare teams. This gap can impact the quality of patient
Theory to Practice. Connection between practice and theory that demonstrates the
NOTES
Ugwu, S.N., Ogbonnaya, N.P., Chijioke, V.C., & Esevio, J.N (2023). Causes and effects of
18(1). https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/17482631.2023.2164949
Saifan, A., AbuRuz M.E., & Masa’deh, R. (2015). Theory Practice Gaps in Nursing
https://scholar.google.com/scholar?
hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C5&q=Theory+Practice+Gaps+in+Nursing+Education
%3A+A+Qualitative+
+Perspective&btnG&fbclid=IwAR3UMSEIjA2D6vDa_GNUHdtj3z8QaHCzcUFvoVNWuTlf52
HRNq1G4KI-DeU#d=gs_qabs&t=1699795670869&u=%23p%3DATkknEOc_xQJ
https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1224150.pdf?
fbclid=IwAR0186VDEKiB3ETGKtjAYT8U3XBfnycKioNFIgGa6_CiOtTYE7dUjOIaQRo
CHAPTER 2
This chapter presents the related literature and studies after the in-depth research
of the researchers including the local, national, and foreign journals and articles which
decade-long competency crisis that still affects the nursing profession until today
(Gamblin, 2019). Bouchlaghem and Mansouri (2018), added that TPG has been
identified as one of the primary obstacles hindering the progress of nursing students and
According to Abusalah and Salama (2018), the gap between nursing theory and
practice can be defined as the inconsistency between what student nurses acquire
through theoretical classroom lectures and what they experience in the clinical setting.
Many studies have shown that the growing disparity between nursing theory and
specifically to the nursing students who are affected by the gap which threatens their
future profession. In addition, Wasini, et al. (2019) also declared that the TPG arise
when the classroom knowledge is not being transferred into practice at the same time
Mahmoud (2014), confirmed the TPG will serve as a hindrance to the nursing student’s
The study conducted by Foley, et. al (2017) stated that the effects of TPG have a
consequence which has confirmed as an outcome portraying to the concept that occur in
Rodgers Model of concept analysis. According to the model, it proposes that TPG has an
impact on nurses and nursing students which results to disparity between academics
and clinical staffs. It is acknowledged generally that TPG have negative effects on the
learning process and interfere to the clinical practice of the nursing students. Also, the
discrepancies of TPG have caused much concern to instructors, professors, educators
In the study published by Ugwu, et.al (2022) it reveals the different causes of TPG
during clinical practice are resource constraints, environmental system challenges, and
unhealthy human attitudinal and behavioral factors. It was confirmed in the studies of
Salifu, et al. (2018) and Wasini, et al. (2019) that the main contributor to TPG was the
alternative are not well designed for the procedure which resulted in delayed care,
prevented the provision of appropriate care, and causes confusion to the nursing
students since they were not able to experience the correct standard procedure being
carried out using ideal instrument. In connection with this, unconducive classroom
session was also one of the predisposing factors to TPG in which students stand at the
back and outside the classroom while receiving the lectures and some are forced to go
out when they cannot learn in that type of environment. Furthermore, student’s
behavior and attitude were identified as predisposing factor of TPG which includes
skipping classes and browsing the internet during lectures that causes distraction
thereby contributing to poor theoretical and practical knowledge. Also, poor dedication,
being late, unwillingness to do the practice, and uninterested in the assigned duty lead
more to the widening of the gap. In addition, lecturers are also an additional factor
contributing to TPG due to poor preparation of lectures and teaching, not adhering to
teaching time table, rushing lectures, and not providing materials for the students to
read.
According to Cabalsa (2018), the knowledge gained from the classes should be well
interpreted in the clinical learning environment in which the instructor teaching in the
classroom and in clinical area should be carefully chosen and qualified to train the
nursing students. Nursing students receive guidance from the clinical instructor during
each clinical session, giving them the chance to put their classroom knowledge into
practice. Through exposing them students will develop skills and confidence in handling
The gap between theory and practice in nursing education is a complex subject that
is influenced by a variety of factors. Both Kertu (2019) and Odetola (2018) emphasize
the challenges that nursing students experience when incorporating theory into practice,
nations that are developing (Odetola, 2018). Mahmoud (2014) and Saifan (2015)
highlight the importance of clinical preceptors and instructors in bridging this disparity,
with a specific emphasis on the need for improved supervision, preparation, and
nursing students' perspectives of the gap between theory and practice. Students cited a
One of the main aspects that aids nursing students' awareness of their practice in a
demonstrate the expertise and skills required to bridge the theory-practice gap. The
purpose of this study was to investigate nursing students' perceptions of their practical
was employed in this study to explore and explain nursing students' perceptions of their
practical learning and theory-practice gap. This study included a convenient sample of
61 nursing students.
guidance, an inadequately designed simulation laboratory (100%), and only 50.8% had
the chance to hone their skills during simulation sessions. The majority of respondents
(67.2%) indicated that summative evaluation was completed at the end of the course,
although they were not prepared for the examination (57.4%). The participants saw a
gap between theoretical knowledge and real clinical procedures in the wards (54.1%).
Conducting ongoing education in teaching and learning principles for faculty to improve
education. The proportion is greater in theory classrooms than in clinical settings. It was
thought that handling a lesser number of students would eliminate disparities in nursing
education. One of the pupils observed that the large number of students in the class had
demonstrated that dealing with a large number of pupils has an impact on the amount
of time allotted to each student. This may limit the nursing teacher's capacity to lead a
theoretical practice, which has been caused by structure, pedagogical and Relational
communication barriers in clinical settings are exacerbated by these gaps (Kertu, 2019).
laboratories, and a dearth of opportunities for skill practice (Mahmoud, 2014). These
results highlight the need for nursing education to be realigned in order to better
prepare students for the difficulties they will encounter in clinical settings.
Rhikhotso, Williams, and De Wet (2014) suggest that in order to reinforce theory
integration in the clinical placements, the maximum amount of time should be spent as
accompaniment with the student. According to Siganga and Jeggels (2014), this
accompaniment will help nursing students get ready for a variety of obstacles they may
particularly for second-year students who are just beginning to gain clinical experience.
The theory-practice gap refers to the discrepancy between the knowledge and skills
learned in the classroom and the actual application of those skills in real-world clinical
settings (Saifan et al., 2021). This gap can be attributed to various factors like
structured and controlled, while the clinical environment is dynamic and unpredictable.
This can lead to students feeling overwhelmed and unprepared to apply their knowledge
students may have limited opportunities to practice their skills in the clinical setting,
making it difficult to bridge the gap between theory and practice. High patient acuity
and workload: Clinical settings often have high patient acuity and a heavy workload,
which can make it. Moreover, the quality of supervision and mentorship can vary
significantly between clinical placements, which can affect students' learning outcomes.
differed from what they had learned in the classroom. This mismatch caused
participants to feel uncertain about executing nursing tasks on actual subjects and
raised concerns about potential harm. In a study conducted by Kim et al., findings
experiences and classroom teachings. The procedures and standards for nursing skills
applied in the clinical setting deviated from the theoretical knowledge they had acquired.
Engaging in clinical practice enables students to put into practice the theoretical
concepts they've acquired in academic settings. This involves the active integration and
and expectations. Accordingly, in the context of nursing, many students may experience
nervousness due to the unfamiliar hospital setting during clinical practice, highlighting
the contrast between theoretical content learned in school and the practical realities of
clinical situations.
the contemporary challenges faced by new graduate nurses. Amanda et al., (2022).
Asserted that it is imperative for recent graduates to conclude their university education
as advanced beginners to mitigate the impact of transition shock and align with the
theoretical framework facilitates a profound grasp of the diverse stages and processes
Gill and Shanta. (2019), Claimed that nurses undergo a period of transition when
they move from their existing roles to pursue new career paths or explore different
areas within clinical practice. Experienced nurses, appreciated for their essential skills,
clinical judgment, and knowledge, play a crucial role in meeting the demand for highly
skilled professionals in specialized settings like radiology. Despite their value, the process
of transitioning can instill feelings of uncertainty, fear, and distress among nurses who
marked by a level of shock that aligns with the acknowledged theory-practice gap. Due
to their restricted exposure to clinical settings and experiences, these nurses face the
Additionally, there is a tendency to prioritize time management and task completion over
patient safety and care. The impact of transition shock directs the attention of new
graduate registered nurses towards prioritizing time management and completing tasks
rather than emphasizing patient safety and holistic care. To cultivate a safety culture
among these nurses, there is a crucial need for encouragement and support that
The cited review of related literature and studies provide information with regards
students. The researchers found out that all materials were significantly relevant for the
research study.
The studies of Abusalah and Salama (2018), Wasini et al. (2019), Mahmoud (2014),
Foley et. al. (2017), Ugwu et. Al (2022), Salifu et. al (2018), Wasini et. al (2019), and
Cabalsa (2018) have been found to be relevant with this study in connection to Theory-
Practice Gap. Their study declared that TPG arise when the knowledge taught inside the
The current studies objectives, which focus on identifying the factors influencing
nursing students' theory-practice gaps, are essentially identical to those of the previous
analysis. However, the consequences of the theory-practice gap on Naga College
Foundation, Inc. second-year nursing students were the primary focus of this study. In
this study, challenges such as different procedures, RLE protocol, and Interpersonal skills
were evaluated by the researcher to further assess the factors that affect students in
Theoretical Framework
The theory-practice gap is a problem seen between what students learn in the
classroom and what they experience in clinical settings. In this study, the different
theories we discussed will demonstrate where the study will revolve. John Watson’s
provides the idea that all behaviors are learned through interaction with the
automatic response.
c. Conditioned stimulus is the stimulus that is repeatedly paired with the
experiment.
the nursing competencies that a student nurse should possess. It can be a factor that
can help bridge the gap between theory and practice. Behaviorism affects how students
react and behave in the classroom under the influence of the teacher. It also refers to an
individual’s ability to perform core skills and be evaluated by performing those skills.
However, it does not only apply in the classroom but also in life. The way people behave
is the way they dictate their lives. Therefore, behavior can be a guide to a better life.
Applying the Theory of Behaviorism in this study shows the harmonious relationship
between students and teachers in the classroom. Good behavior is effective in learning
by listening, participating, and asking actively and politely throughout the discussion.
Avoiding unnecessary activity and improving skills can greatly help improve people’s
abilities. Classical conditioning provides positive reinforcement, like rewards for good
performance, and discourages negative consequences for undesirable actions. These will
increase the motivation and engagement of the students in the learning process. Over
time, it will create a positive environment and improve students’ overall performance.
Intelligences. This refers to a theory describing the different ways students learn and
acquire information. These multiple intelligences range from the use of words, numbers,
E. Musical intelligence – being able to produce and analyze pitch, rhythm and
sound.
H. Naturalist intelligence – being able to recognize and classify the different plant
I. Essential intelligence – being able to ask deep and critical questions about the
This theory of multiple intelligences is included because it shows how diverse the
intelligence of a human is. Students should be aware of what type of multiple they
belong to and utilize it in the right way. Using it in the wrong way can lead to poor
performance in class, thus leading to a gap between theory and practice. This theory
can bridge the gap between theory and practice in nursing. Since intelligence is the
Relating this theory to our study could address some procedures existing in the
classroom. This can help teachers adjust their learning style so that they can cater to
and pay attention to the students who are having a hard time learning. Students learn
effectively with the right methods and strategies that are appropriate to them, which
can give them a chance to succeed at learning. No one is ignorant since everyone has
an intelligence that is fit for them. People should just identify and cultivate it.
This study is anchored on Robert Katz’s skill theory. Katz (1955:34) defines skills as
what leaders can accomplish, while traits are what leaders are. He argued that effective
B. Interpersonal skills – are often referred to as people skills, social skills or social
intelligence.
C. Conceptual skills – are the abilities that allow an individual to better understand
This theory helps the researchers understand the basic personal skills that a
student nurse should possess. This was used to perform the specific skills needed for a
knowledge into action. Skills should be evidence-based to prevent harm to other people.
and use equipment correctly. The basic procedure includes taking vital signs and
administering medications. Interpersonal skills are crucial as the nurse builds rapport
and improve care outcomes. Conceptual skills are vital as nurses analyze situations and
make informed decisions. It makes them think critically and develop effective solutions
Classical conditioning
Operant conditioning
To make the present study congruent to the foregoing theories, the researchers
Input includes the demographic profile of the respondents, challenges of 2nd year
Challenges of 2nd year Nursing student on transition from theory to practice, association
between the challenges and effects of THEORY – PRACTICE GAP: Challenges of 2nd
Year Nursing Students on Transition from theory to practice, and intervention program
that can be proposed to bridge the gap between theory and practice.
through questionnaire.
Output comprises preparing 2nd year Nursing Student for the dynamic changes
that will occur over time, help individuals adjust and adapt in therapeutic situations, and