[go: up one dir, main page]

100% found this document useful (1 vote)
977 views28 pages

Signal Integrity Handbook

Uploaded by

darkcrosserxii
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
100% found this document useful (1 vote)
977 views28 pages

Signal Integrity Handbook

Uploaded by

darkcrosserxii
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 28

SIGNAL INTEGRITY

HANDBOOK

Reference for the Selection of High-Performance Interconnects


for Signal Integrity Optimized System Design
SIGNAL INTEGRITY
FOR HIGH-PERFORMANCE SYSTEM DESIGN

The 5G /6G Network, High-Performance Computing, Artificial Intelligence and Auto "2.0" industries are driving
new architectures that demand previously unimaginable transmission speeds, bandwidths, frequencies and
densities – all while balancing scalability, power and thermal management concerns, and of course, cost.

5G/6G NETWORK HPC AI / ML AUTO 2.0

NEXT GENERATION SYSTEM SI CHALLENGES

Interconnect solutions that support bleeding edge speeds are a necessary component of next generation
high-performance systems. Those
capabilities, however, can be rendered
ineffective unless they are part of a
well-designed and optimized system.
A holistic approach to system design –
particularly as speeds, bandwidths and
densities increase – is a necessity.

FULL SYSTEM OPTIMIZATION... FROM SILICON-TO-SILICON™

The purpose of this handbook is to provide a reference for those with little or no signal integrity (SI) experience
who are tasked with selecting a high-speed interconnect. The information included has been carefully developed
by Samtec's industry-leading Signal Integrity Engineers to help facilitate informed decisions when specifying
components that will affect a system’s signal integrity.

For additional assistance with complex system design challenges, Samtec provides high-level design and
engineering support both at the component level and system level - from bare die, to IC package, to PCB, to
connectors and cables, and back again. To discuss your specific application, please contact sig@samtec.com or
learn more about Samtec's signal integrity capabilities at samtec.com/s2s.
Table of Contents
I. SIGNAL INTEGRITY FUNDAMENTALS | 4-5 VI. CHANNEL PERFORMANCE METRIC | 13

i. What is Signal Integrity?


VII. MODEL CONSIDERATIONS | 14-15
ii. Single-Ended Signals

iii. Differential Signals i. Simulation Tools

ii. Boundaries
II. SIGNALING TERMS | 6
iii. Validation
i. NRZ & PAM4 iv. Encrypted 3D Components

III. FREQUENCY DOMAIN & S-PARAMETERS | 7-9 VIII. SYSTEM ANALYSIS | 16-17
i. Insertion Loss i. Eye Diagram
ii. Return Loss ii. Channel Operating Margin (COM)
iii. Crosstalk
IX. SELECTING A CONNECTOR | 18-19
iv. Mode Conversion
i. Contact Spacing
v. Electromagnetic Interference
ii. Pin Mapping
vi. Voltage Standing Wave Ratio (VSWR)

X. BREAKOUT REGION DESIGN | 20


IV. TIME DOMAIN | 10-12
i. Constraints
i. Impedance
ii. Outside the BOR
ii. Propagation Delay and Skew

iii. Rise Time and Dispersion XI. SIGNAL INTEGRITY IN RF SYSTEMS | 21

iv. Apparent Impedance

22 | Signal Integrity Tools & Support


V. SINGLE VALUE METRICS | 13
24 | Reference Materials & Further Reading
i. Effective Return Loss (ERL) 26 | Acronyms & Abbreviations
ii. Integrated Crosstalk Noise / Return Loss 27 | Copyright, Trademarks & Patents

Samtec Signal Integrity Handbook 3


I Signal Integrity Fundamentals
Anytime an electrical signal is transmitted, signal integrity (SI) is a concern. Water circuits are subject to limited flow along the
water path. In a analogous manner, electrical circuits are subject to attenuation along the signal path (see Figure 1). At its most
basic level, SI ensures that a signal is transmitted from “Point A” to “Point B” with sufficient quality (or integrity) to allow effective
communication. As a term, SI typically applies to baseband signals that are transmitted using an interconnect, such as a cable,
printed circuit board (PCB) trace, or transmission line, and it also applies to broadband applications, such as those operating at
RF or microwave and millimeter wave frequencies (see "Signal Integrity in RF Systems" p. 21).

i. What is Signal Integrity?


SI needs to be considered throughout the entire system and component design process. Unlike in the past, interconnects can
no longer be treated as an afterthought. As rise times get shorter and clock frequencies increase, connectors and cables once
considered electrically transparent can have a significant effect on the quality of a system’s transmitted signal. Factors such as
crosstalk, return loss, insertion loss, and electromagnetic interference (EMI) can all play significant roles in determining what
interconnect solution is optimal for a given application. Digital interfaces use one of two types of signaling: single-ended or
differential signaling, and each has its own effects on SI.

Figure 1. As water circuits are subject to reduced flow along the water path. electrical circuits
are subject to attenuation along the signal path.

4 Samtec Signal Integrity Handbook


ii. Single-Ended Signals
Typically used in low-speed protocol designs, a single-ended signal is transmitted down a transmission line as a pulse
referenced between a signal conductor and a return path. The return path is often referred to as “ground,” but at higher
frequencies, the return path should be considered a critical part of the transmission line. The return path in a single-ended
system might be a ground plane under a microstrip trace, an adjacent signal pin in a connector, or the outer tape shield of
a cable. It is very challenging to achieve high data rates using single-ended signaling. Typically, data rates for single-ended
signals range from approximately DC (e.g., reset signals, LED lights) up to 8.4 Gbps (e.g., DDR memory, UCIe™).

iii. Differential Signals


A differential signal consists of two wires, each carrying two separate pulses that switch in opposite directions. For example,
one pulse is switching from logic level 1 to 0 while the other pulse is switching from logic level 0 to 1. If a differential signal
is perfectly symmetrical or balanced, it will propagate effectively on two identical conductors, 180 degrees out of phase and
canceling the effects of symmetrically applied noise (see Figure 2).

In order to reduce interference and extend the capabilities of high-speed circuits, many interfaces have adopted a differential
signaling architecture rather than single-ended signaling. Differential signals in PCB designs are more resilient against coupling
with nearby magnetic fields (crosstalk), allowing for longer lengths and higher speeds in dense designs.

Figure 2. In differential
signaling, because the
two signals propagate
180 degrees out of
phase, they are resistant
to the influence of noise,
and the signal at the
receiver matches the one
from the sender.

Samtec Signal Integrity Handbook 5


II Signaling Terms
All interconnect products and signaling standards are defined by data rate or bandwidth capabilities, communicating the
number of bits transferred. The definitions related to these specifications are:

Bandwidth and Data Rate within an interconnect and not just the capability of a single lane.
For example, 800 Gb Ethernet may describe eight lanes operating
Data rate references the number of bits transferred per second.
at 100 Gbps. Use caution and context to verify data rate statements.
Bandwidth refers to the frequency spectrum required to transmit
those bits.
Unit Interval

Baud Rate The length of a single bit transition.


Number of signal units per second or data rate divided by number
Unit Interval =
of bits per baud (e.g. 56 Gbps PAM4 signaling has a baud rate of Nyquist
28 Gbps i.e. 56 Gbps / log2(4) = 28 GBaud).
*Computed the same way for NRZ or PAM4.
Nyquist Frequency
Bit Error Ratio (BER)
Fastest switching speed of an interface or baud rate, divided by 2:
– Nyquist Frequency for 28 Gbps NRZ is 14 GHz A measure of errors occurring on a complete link. It may be a
measured or simulated value. BER = # errors/# of bits transmitted.
– Nyquist Frequency for 56 PAM4 is 14 GHz
Signaling standards provide minimum limits most often 1e-12
or 1e-15. However, in some cases, detector error ratio (DER) is
Aggregate Data Rate
specified, which details the error tolerance prior to error correction
Describes the summation of the data rates of all the individual lanes encoding. Examples of DER targets are 1e-4 and 1e-6.

i. NRZ & PAM4


For the last few decades, high-speed
links in the data center and compute
environment have used two voltage levels
in signaling, with low voltage representing
binary 0, and high voltage representing
binary 1. This scheme is also known
as non-return to zero (NRZ) or pulse
amplitude modulation 2-level (PAM2).

As Nyquist frequency increases to a higher


data rate, loss and reflection become a
challenge. A shift to four-level signaling
(pulse amplitude modulation 4-level;
PAM4) encodes data in the amplitude and
Figure 3. Eye diagrams for NRZ (top) versus PAM4 (bottom) show the increased
doubles the data rate for signals operating
complexity of signal analysis and illustrate the sensitivity of PAM4 signals to crosstalk.
at the same Nyquist frequency as PAM2.

Each of the four voltage levels corresponds


to one of four bit-sequences (00, 01, 10, 11), providing two bits on the space previously occupied by one, yet not increasing
operating frequency.

Unfortunately, PAM4 signaling is more sensitive to noise sources such as reflection and crosstalk (see Figure 3). This is due to the
reduced signal amplitude (1/3 of NRZ), effectively reducing the signal-to-noise ratio. The highest speed standards operating at
NRZ/PAM2 are 28 and 32 Gbps. Above this data rate, PAM4 is typically used, beginning at 56 and 64 Gbps and beyond.

6 Samtec Signal Integrity Handbook


III Frequency Domain & S-Parameters
S-parameters, also known as scattering parameters, are a
unified set of frequency-domain performance characteristics
that can be used to completely define the properties of an
electrical device.

S-parameters can be generated from a simulation, or they


can be measured with a vector network analyzer (VNA).
S-parameters are treated like a black box between input and
outputs: the performance through is described; however, the
contents are hidden. This makes S-parameters an ideal way to
share characteristics while protecting intellectual property.

The total number of available S-parameters for characterizing a


specific electrical device is determined by its number of ports.
Figure 4: S-parameter measurements give an indication of the
S-parameter models may be used to make performance
electrical device’s performance, in terms of insertion loss, return
charts or can be used directly in full channel simulations. loss, and crosstalk. This figure identifies three relationships of
From S-parameters, numerous SI characteristics can be interest in a six-port device under test.
extracted including insertion loss, return loss, and crosstalk
(see Figure 4).

Characterizations in the frequency domain are not specific to a particular data rate. Interpretation depending on frequencies of
interest is left to the reader. The following sections provide a guide.

i. Insertion Loss
In the frequency domain, the transferred signal
through a medium is characterized as insertion loss
(IL). In a two-port device under test (DUT), insertion
loss is the magnitude of S21 in an S-parameter matrix
and expressed in dB, where the nomenclature "21"
(expressed as "two-one") refers to the signal observed
at port 2 when stimulated at port 1.

Insertion loss is expressed as a negative number for


attenuation and as a positive number for gain. It is
expressed in dB as the ratio of output to input.

In some cases, industry specifications for insertion loss Figure 5: Example of connector performance where insertion loss
must be satisfied for components or complete channels. performance target is highlighted in green.

Often component bandwidth is defined as the point where insertion loss crosses -3 dB. However, for high-speed applications,
this rule is less applicable. It is not uncommon to require -1 to -2 dB insertion loss from a small component (like a connector) at
Nyquist frequency (see Figure 5).

For larger components, like cables or even packages, insertion loss is significant and a wholistic assessment, channel insertion
loss must be evaluated against interface requirements.

Samtec Signal Integrity Handbook 7


III Frequency Domain & S-Parameters (continued)

ii. Return Loss Crosstalk power sum is the combination of multiple crosstalk
responses in an effort to describe the total crosstalk noise in a
Return loss (RL) is a measurement of reflected noise in a system (see Figure 9). It may be separated as NEXT and FEXT
single port due to impedance mismatch against a reference power sums.
value (see Figure 6). As device impedance becomes further
mismatched to the reference impedance, return loss increases iv. Mode Conversion
in the positive direction. Reference impedances are most often
50 Ω, 46.25 Ω or 42.5 Ω, depending on the application. Mixed modes are undesirable energy lost from or added to
the differential signal. They can be measured at the system
iii. Crosstalk or component level. SDC, or differential-to-common mode
conversion, is the amount of transmitted differential signal that
Crosstalk is unwanted coupled noise that a signal lane remains when the positive and negative signals of the pair are
experiences from other nearby lanes or sources. Every part subtracted. Similarly, SCD is common-to-differential mode and
of the interconnect, from chip to chip, is a potential source of represents noise sources added to the differential signal that
crosstalk. Most applications desire crosstalk levels of -40 dB remain after subtraction.
through Nyquist frequency (see Figure 7).
For a perfectly balanced differential pair, SCD & SDC are zero.
There are two types of crosstalk of concern in high-speed Imbalances and skew within the pair lead to mixed modes
systems, near-end crosstalk (NEXT) and far-end crosstalk (FEXT) that can be observed as through, reflected, or coupled noise.
(see Figure 8). NEXT is the measure of crosstalk coupling from Sometimes specifications provide limits for mixed modes.
transmitting (Tx) lanes onto nearby receiving (Rx) lanes. NEXT
is most critical when coupling sources (vias, connectors, etc.) v. Electromagnetic Interference
occur near the transmitting source (where Tx signal levels are
the highest and the Rx signal levels are the smallest). Electromagnetic interference (EMI) refers to the electrical
noise that is emitted to other electrical devices that are
FEXT relates to signals traveling in the same direction. For operating nearby.
example, FEXT is the noise that a transmitting lane experiences
from other transmitting lanes. It is generally viewed in the Because of the serious nature of electromagnetic
context of the length and loss of the channel. With FEXT, both compatibility (EMC) issues, many governments require EMI
the crosstalk levels and signal levels are attenuating together compliance testing of active electronic systems. In the US,
before reaching the receiver. regulations are administered by the Federal Communications

Figure 6: As a rule of thumb, RL values of less than -15 dB in the Figure 7: Crosstalk is measured in dB as the ratio of sent to
frequency band of interest are desirable, and a value of -15 dB is received noise; smaller (negative) numbers represent less
typically sufficient. crosstalk (which is desirable).

8 Samtec Signal Integrity Handbook


Commission (FCC). Military applications may require more VSWR is a term commonly used in RF and microwave
stringent testing. environments. It is often specified as a “one number
rating,” especially for coaxial connectors. In such cases, the
Techniques to mitigate EMI include routing PCBs internally impedance mismatches within the terminated connector
as stripline and grounded caging/ shielding around external system will be the dominant electrical characteristic limiting
connectors. its performance in a high-frequency system. Performance
data for a coaxial connector might simply be provided as
vi. Voltage Standing Wave Ratio “VSWR 1.20.” This is shorthand for an implied maximum
VSWR of 1:1.20 of the connector when used in a system with
Another way of characterizing the effects of impedance
an appropriate impedance, and across the frequency band
mismatch in the frequency domain is voltage standing
of interest.
wave ratio (VSWR; pronounced “viz-wer”). Impedance
discontinuities within a terminated cable connector and/or Since VSWR and return loss are both related to impedance,
terminated PCB connector (terminated connector system) will VSWR can provide quick insight into the amount of voltage
cause partial reflections of a traveling wave. These reflections that is reflected into a transmitter from a terminated
will either interfere constructively (add to the magnitude interconnect system. Return loss (measured in dB) provides
when in phase) or interfere negatively (out of phase) with the similar insight into the ratio of the transmitted power to the
original traveling wave. The resultant wave is called a standing reflected power and thus the eventual level of a signal that is
wave as it does not actually travel along the transmission transmitted through the same interconnect system.
line. VSWR describes the ratio between these maximum and
minimum voltages measured at a given point before the
terminated connector system within the transmission line.

Figure 8: FEXT and NEXT result from


different signal paths. In applications,
designers seek to isolate transmit
and receive lanes from each other to
minimize NEXT and FEXT.

Figure 9: Power sums are often used


for industry specifications to restrict the
total allowable noise. In this case, the
desired total FEXT is below -40 dB.

Samtec Signal Integrity Handbook 9


IV Time Domain
Analysis in the time domain reveals the pertinent behavior of an interconnect and is specific to a given data rate. The
advantage of time domain analysis is that it provides spatial resolution and can inform us about behavior at every location
throughout the topology.

i. Impedance point in the transmission path where there is a change in


impedance the signal “sees.” These types of reflections are
Impedance (Ω) is a measure of the behavior of the also called inter-symbol interference (ISI).
interconnect. It is influenced by signal conductor and reference
Time domain reflectometry (TDR) is a common diagnostic
conductor surface area, the gap between them, and the
used to review impedance throughout a structure; it can be
dielectric property of whatever is between them (air, plastic,
measured or simulated. A step response is provided at an
etc). Impedance is a function of inductance and capacitance,
input, reflected voltage is observed, and the ratio of reflected
and is highly influenced by conductor surface area. The
voltage to input voltage (reflection coefficient) is converted to
impedance value affects return loss.
characteristic impedance. In fact, the TDR plot identifies the
For high-speed interfaces, impedance is measured as an physical location of impedance discontinuities known by their
instantaneous (2D) value, called characteristic impedance. delay. A desirable TDR plot is smooth and depicts a gradual
Systems are generally designed to meet an impedance target. change in impedance (see Figure 10). Note: TDR results are
Often these system impedance targets apply to the individual subject to the rise time used. The rise time used should be
components or the PCB traces in an attempt to better match appropriate for the signaling standard.
the system impedance.
Connectors are generally not characterized at a specific
In practice, the difficult to control pieces of the interconnect, impedance; in fact, it is expected that impedance could vary
such as vias, surface mount (SMT) pads, and ball grid array as much as 20%, depending on the data rate and application.
balls, are lower in impedance. This can require a lower For connectors, then, overall impedance is characterized by
impedance design of components and routing in order to return loss performance. Since return loss is referenced to a
yield better signal integrity in the system. Some typical system specific value (100 Ω, 92.5 Ω, or 85 Ω), it captures the overall
impedances are shown in Table 1. severity of the discontinuities in the component.

It is common practice to renormalize a measurement


Impedance Requirements for Common High-Speed Signals or simulation from 100 to 92.5/85 ohms, thereby better
Interface Impedance (Ω) Mode representing the performance for the intended application.
Give care to reading TDR and return loss plots by verifying the
PCI Express® 85 Differential
reference impedance that was used.
SATA 85 Differential
Clocks 85, 100 Differential All measurements for products such as RF connectors,
adaptors, and cables are precision tuned to 50 ohms and
Ethernet 100 Differential
interoperate with little impedance discontinuity. For this
DDR, DQ, DQS 40, 50 Single-Ended
reason, measurements and models are most often referenced
Miscellaneous Signals 50, 55 Single-Ended to 50 ohms, 75 ohms single-ended, or 100 ohms differentially.
USB 85 Differential Components that are not designed for 100 ohms may then
Table 1
appear poor, showing a mismatch against the equipment
output or reference.
While PCB routing is generally uniform, vertical components
(such as connectors, vias, and sockets) have a variable
impedance because of their complex geometry. Mismatches
in impedance throughout an interconnect create reflections
and degrade performance. This discontinuity occurs at every

10 Samtec Signal Integrity Handbook


Figure 10: This figure shows an example of two TDR responses from a PCIe® system: one model with the PCB trace at
85 Ω and the other at 100 Ω. Note the physical locations on the bottom of the graph and their subsequent effect on
the system’s characteristic impedance. This graph shows larger discontinuities at 100 Ω.

ii. Propagation Delay & Skew


Propagation delay is defined as the amount of time it takes for a signal to propagate through an interconnect path. Knowing
the propagation delay of the various signal paths can be critical for system timing analysis for some interfaces.

Skew is defined as the difference in propagation delay between multiple wires. For a single-ended bus, skew between data
and a clock may be important. In a differential pair, skew between the two wires composing the pair is critical. Between
differential pairs, skew may be less stringent, and requirements vary by interface.

Within a differential pair, skew leads to increased insertion loss, impedance mismatch, crosstalk, and EMI. Sources of skew may
include bends in PCB routing, PCB routing parallel to glass bundles called “fiber weave skew,” right-angle connectors, and
cable assemblies physical length mismatch.

iii. Rise Time & Dispersion


Rise time is the rate at which a signal changes from low to high. It is usually defined between 10 and 90% (or 20 and 80%) of
the total voltage range. For high-speed interfaces, rise time is related to data rate.

As a rule of thumb, rise time is 25% of the unit interval. So, a 10 Gbps signal contains the same signal content as a 25 ps rise
time: 0.25 * ( 1 / 10E 9 ). The rise time is the same for 28 Gbps NRZ and 56 Gbps PAM4 signals as they share the same Nyquist
frequency and unit intervals (~36 ps). For this case, rise time = 9 ps, unit interval = 36 ps, and Nyquist frequency is 14 GHz.

Time domain characterizations require a rise time input, most commonly TDR. Rise time used for TDR should be related to
the data rate of interest. It is important to note that rise time degrades as a signal passes through the interconnect due to
dispersion. Dispersion is the spread of signal due to changes in propagation delay across frequencies in PCB dielectrics.
Receiver equalization is designed to compensate for dispersion.

Samtec Signal Integrity Handbook 11


IV Time Domain (continued)

iv. Apparent Impedance


Apparent impedance is the effective impedance of a component when measured or used at a specific signal rise time or frequency,
in a specific impedance environment. As rise times get slower and the frequency bandwidth goes lower, the effective, or apparent,
impedance of a component moves closer to the impedance level of the circuit in which the component is being used.

At slow rise times, the device will appear to have an impedance value close to the reference or system impedance. But as rise times
decrease (in other words, as edge rates get faster), the measured impedance values begin to move toward the true characteristic
impedance of the component. At an infinitely short rise time, we would measure the true characteristic impedance of a device.

This effect is important when seeking an interconnect solution for a system with an impedance other than the reference impedance
used in the characterization process. In those instances, the impedance values at the fastest rise times on the TDR impedance
profile should be used as an approximation of the interconnect’s “true” characteristic impedance (see Figure 11).

Figure 11: Measured TDR Differential Impedance for a Samtec NovaRay® 7 mm stack height from high-speed
characterization reports with three apparent impedances at 30, 50 and 100 ps rise times.

12 Samtec Signal Integrity Handbook


V Single Value Metrics

i. Effective Return Loss (ERL) ii. Integrated Crosstalk Noise &


Effective return loss (ERL) is a figure of merit representing
Integrated Return Loss (ICN & IRL)
measured RL and is a single value. ERL is the amount of Integrated crosstalk noise (ICN) and integrated return loss
digital signal returned which is statistically reduced to (IRL) are single numbers used to characterize the total noise
an effective value at the test point. It may address both in a system or component. To achieve this, a weighting
compensable and un-compensable ISI and is computed from filter is configured to the data rate of interest, focusing only
RL (see description of return loss, page 8). on applicable frequencies. Once filtered, the response is
integrated into a single number expressed in mV. Many
The concept of ERL was introduced during the specification
standards use ICN calculated from the crosstalk power sum
development of the IEEE 802.3 50 Gbps Ethernet Standard.
for compliance, including IEEE, OIF, PCIe®, and USB. For
The intent of this metric is to control variations in system
reflections, IRL is used for USB cable compliance.
performance due to excessive reflections that occur when
pieces of the system are designed and budgeted separately
but later expected to work together in high volume.
ADDITIONAL RESOURCES
As the name implies, ERL is related to the return loss of a
device, channel, or component in that energy is injected
into a port and the return signal is analyzed; this is like echo
pinging into the scattering parameter. The injected signal is
a unit pulse that represents a single symbol. The histogram
of this return signature is then combined with a histogram
of a collection of random symbols to create a single value
property. Often this combination is done with the cumulative
gEEk® spEEk Webinar: Samtec White Paper:
distribution of the stochastic nature of symbol reflections. "What is ERL & How is it "Characterizing High-Speed
The value is reported in dB and as a necessity requires a data Computed?" Digital Interfaces: Reflecting
rate and symbol error rate. on Reflections"

VI Samtec Channel Performance Metric


Recognizing that it is important to consider an interconnect
as part of the system, Samtec offers a Channel Performance ADDITIONAL RESOURCES
Metric (CPM) for its products that provides a recommended
maximum data rate based on system complexity. This chart
is displayed in the catalog and product’s web page.

Samtec CPM is calculated using full end-to-end channel


simulation including PCB, packages, reflections, and
crosstalk. Maximum data rate is determined when a
minimum BER threshold is reached.
Samtec Blog Article: Samtec Blog Article:
"High-Speed Connector Rating "New Protocol Capabilities for
Accounts for Entire System" High-Performance Interconnects"

Samtec Signal Integrity Handbook 13


VII Model Considerations
i. Simulation Tools
There are many modeling tools to enable electrical behavior characterization. These include 2D, 2.5D, 3D, and hybrid field-solving
tools that focus on the multiphysics of larger structures broken down to simpler nodal coarse static or dynamic mesh solutions.

There are also system-level characterization analysis tools based on building schematics and libraries, including scripted
programmed functionalities that allow engineers to bring models from concept to realization (see Figure 12).

Figure 12: Various simulation


tools enable electrical model
characterization, including 2.5D
wave EM solvers (top left), 3D
field solvers (top right), and
system analysis tools (bottom).

ii. Boundaries
Understanding a model’s boundary is important when interpreting frequency or time domain reports. Models can vary in terms
of the impedance and duration of PCB routing that is included. For example, if the pads or vertical transitions of the PCB or
breakout region (BOR) are not included, performance may further degrade when they are added. Comparing products with
different extents of the interconnect included may lead to incorrect conclusions. Clear documentation should indicate the
physical location of model ports.

In some instances, connector models do not include PCB breakout areas. This enables modeling of application specific stack-
up and breakout needs separately. Simulation tools provide functions to cascade S-parameters, combining separate connector
and PCB models (see Figure 13).

iii. Validation
Several criteria are often checked to determine model or measurement quality for use in system analysis, including passivity,
causality, and reciprocity. Definitions of these terms are provided in the IEEE 370-2020 standard. Software to evaluate these
limits is provided by IEEE 370-2020 and is also being implemented in several commercial tools.

Model bandwidth, or maximum frequency available for a given model, needs to meet or exceed the spectrum for which energy
exists for a given data rate. Therefore, a minimum range of 1.5x to 3x Nyquist frequency is recommended to account for the
higher frequency harmonics contained in the signal energy.

14 Samtec Signal Integrity Handbook


Figure 13: This diagram shows connector models (red and blue) that can be combined with PCB, Tx and Rx models
(green) within a simulation tool to capture a unique stack up design. Samtec ExaMAX® (EBTM /EBCF Series) and
AcceleRate® (ARC / ARF6 Series) are shown.

iv. Encrypted 3D Components


Encrypted 3D components within 3D field solver tools allow for a better collaboration space between component-level and
assembly-level designs while protecting the intellectual property of the component manufacturer. As data rates increase, it
becomes more important to have accurate system-level
models of the entire signal channel from package die to
package die with the precise plane of reference match. ADDITIONAL RESOURCES

Samtec’s encrypted 3D components, for instance, have all of


the specifications with corresponding material properties,
physical structure attributes, points of contact, wipe distance,
and deflections incorporated in the model.

Designers can use encrypted models in their workspace,


directly on their board designs, with their own parameters
and launches. Video: Video:
How to Encrypt ANSYS® ANSYS® 3D SI Models for
3D Components Samtec Interconnects

Samtec Signal Integrity Handbook 15


VIII System Analysis
During a system’s design phase, obtaining an assessment of SI performance of the complete channel design may be required
before moving on to the development of a physical prototype. To support this system-level assessment, a design team needs
electrical simulation models, usually in the form of S-parameters, and a particular physical protocol and topology expectation to
execute channel simulation.

Simulation of an entire link can be done in a number of available tools. Many standards offer simulation tools preloaded with
transmitter and receiver configurations. This includes the free, open-source tool Seasim for PCI Express® channels and the
channel operating margin (COM) algorithm for IEEE and OIF. If specific silicon is known, IBIS-AMI models (which can be used
in commercial tools such as ADS) may be obtained to represent the actual noise levels, which may be better than specification
limits. Channel simulation can require product eye diagrams, COM results, or BER.

i. Eye Diagram
Slew Rate = tan(𝛼)
An eye diagram is a characterization of system level
performance. Eye patterns are generated by sending Rise
continuous streams of data from a transmitter to a receiver EH
Edge
and overlaying the received bits upon one another. Over
time, the received data builds to resemble an eye.

Negative SI effects in the transmission path can cause the


signal to distort, which over time, will cause the eye to
EW
"close." Specifications may define a minimum eye mask
template, which can be placed on the amount of open area 1 UI
as an aid to determine compliance (see Figure 14). Eye
diagram specifications are used for the entire interconnect Figure 14: Sample eye diagram. The red diamond is the eye mask, and
path, or subsets of the path, but are not used for smaller the blue lines show the received bits. (EH: Eye Height, EW: Eye Width,
components like connectors or cables. UI: Unit Interval)

ii. Channel Operating Margin (COM)

During the development of 25 Gbps Ethernet


signaling in IEEE 802.3, a need arose to help ADDITIONAL RESOURCES
unify the budgeting capability of transmitter,
receiver, and channel specifications. The
previously recommended frequency domain
masks were abandoned in favor of time domain
specification of the system. This time domain-
based specification is known as COM.

COM is a figure of merit for a channel


derived from a measurement of its scattering Free Software: gEEk® spEEk Webinar: gEEk® spEEk Webinar:
parameters. It is related to the ratio of a Request a Copy of "IEEE COM for "Mechanics of Running
calculated signal amplitude to a calculated Samtec's COM Code Channel Analysis" COM"

noise amplitude at a receiver input.

16 Samtec Signal Integrity Handbook


Transmitters (represented by "n") are used to transfer
data between physical layers (PHYs). There are "n"
near-end crosstalk paths, and "n-1" far-end crosstalk
paths going into a victim receiver, as illustrated in
Figure 15. The specific number of paths depend on
the number supported lanes.

COM is computed using defined path calculations and


a specified procedure. In addition to S-parameters,
COM accepts parameter values such as signaling
rate, frequency (min, max and step), and the device
package model to use in the computation (see Figure
16). For convenience, and to ensure consistency in
computational results, the COM procedure has been
implemented in a MATLAB® script. An accompanying
spreadsheet referred to as "COM configuration file" is
used to load the parameter values into the MATLAB Figure 15: COM is related to the ratio of a calculated signal
procedure script. amplitude to a calculated noise amplitude at a receiver input, and it
depends on the number of transmitters. This image shows NEXT and
As opposed to an eye diagram, COM operates as a FEXT paths in a sample system.
budget for insertion loss, insertion loss deviation (ILD),
crosstalk, and SerDes parameters.

Figure 16: COM voltage injection and voltage measurement points. COM is computed from a voltage injection point
(VIP) to voltage measurement point (VMP) from provided measured S-parameters TP0 to TP5.

Samtec Signal Integrity Handbook 17


IX Selecting a Connector
Connector solutions generally fall into two categories: open-pin-field and assigned signals. Open-pin-field offers the best
flexibility to place signals, grounds, or power in any location. Selections with assigned signals usually have superior SI
performance due to specially designed ground structures. Cabled connectors may also have assigned positions to properly
connect the twinax ground shield.

Many parameters critical to high-speed connector performance will vary significantly depending upon the pin assignment and
form factor. An open-pin-field connector will have improved crosstalk performance when two grounds are placed between
signals (SSGGSS) as compared to a single ground (SSGSS). A design with a smaller pitch may favor system placement because
of its greater density; however, performance could be reduced as higher crosstalk is incurred due to proximity. This is not
always true due to innovative designs, so it is critical to refer to SI characterization reports to make the best decisions.

i. Contact Spacing
As the distance between contacts increases, inductive and capacitive coupling decrease. This effect can be observed in an
electromagnetic field plot by noting the reduced number and density of field lines connecting the two conductors. For example, a
connector with terminals spaced on a 0.80 mm pitch will typically have better crosstalk performance than one with a 0.50 mm pitch.
In differential pair systems, increasing the distance between adjacent pairs minimizes coupling and, in some cases, eliminates the
need for interstitial grounds, so total signal density can be increased (see Figure 17).

ERX8 Series, 30 Position ERX5 Series, 30 Position

Separate with Greater Pitch Spacing Separate with Interstitial Spacing

Figure 17: Recommended PCB Layout footprint for Samtec Edge Rate® (ERX8 and ERX5 Series)
with 0.80 mm pitch and 0.50 mm pitch, greater pitch spacing, and interstitial spacing.

18 Samtec Signal Integrity Handbook


ii. Pin Mapping
By assigning pins between signals as return paths (grounds), unwanted coupling between signal pins can be minimized. A 1:1
signal-to-ground ratio is typically used in the industry. So, pin mapping for single-ended applications would then be SGSG, while
differential pair applications would use DP-G-DP-G. These pin assignments generally provide a good performance vs. density
trade-off.

To increase isolation, more return paths could be added between signals. For example, optimal solution mappings could have
a 1:2 signal-to-ground ratio. Differential solutions would then use DP-G-G-DP while single-ended applications would use SGGS.
These can be directed either vertically or horizontally depending on the connector solution. This approach, however, will reduce
the signal density of the interconnect (see Figure 18).

Figure 18: Single-ended 1:1 pattern (above) and differential pair 1:2 optimal horizontal pattern
(below) from Samtec’s SEARAY™ high-speed characterization report.

Samtec Signal Integrity Handbook 19


X Connector Breakout Region Design
High-speed performance of PCB-mount connectors must be considered in the context of the application in a real-world
environment. “Connector-only” data can be useful for comparing the relative performance between two similar connectors, but it
may be very far removed from the performance practically obtainable in an actual application. This is mainly because of the PCB
traces and ground planes in the vicinity of the connector. This region is often referred to as the breakout region (BOR), because, in
this area, traces are “broken out” from an optimized, consistent transmission line environment and routed as required to attach to
the connector terminals. If not done correctly, system performance can suffer. BOR/launch must be carefully designed to allow for
the best possible high-frequency performance.

i. Constraints ii. Outside the BOR


When designing a BOR, it is important to first consider the Once the BOR has been finalized, it is time to consider
limitations of the design and then improve the performance factors for routing across larger areas of the PCB:
around these limitations:
• A number of techniques can help minimize skew within a
• What is the intended routing direction? Right-angle differential pair due to differences in dielectric property
connectors, for example, typically only allow routing in of glass and resin in the PCB:
the direction opposite to the cable. What makes the most – Board routing should have a trace pitch that is the
sense for the use case? same as the fiber weave in the board.

• Does this connector have a single ground (GND) or – Routing at non-orthogonal angles can reduce fiber
double GND positions between signals in a row? This will weave skew. The design should avoid using angles
affect crosstalk performance and routing that must travel within +/- 10 degrees of the orthogonal directions
through rows of vias. If routing through a row of vias, it is on the panel because of manufacturing variations
critical to design around the routing path early. between the orthogonal directions of the fiberglass
and those of the copper trace etch (see Figure 19).
• How much space do I have left to add GND vias for
• Length matching the traces within a signal pair is critical.
shielding, and where can I place them to shield crosstalk
It is best to do this by having an equal number of left
most effectively?
and right turns as a trace routes across the board.
Length matching structures like ‘serpentine’ traces are
• Large open areas should be avoided in the BOR because
acceptable but should be avoided if the signal can be
they can resonate. GND vias can be placed to break up
balanced by matching left and right turns.
and limit the size of dielectric cavities. Larger cavities
resonate at lower frequencies, so the importance of this is • Thieving or copper balancing is placed throughout the
bandwidth dependent. board to keep the dielectric thickness consistent through
a uniform copper density.
• After the overall layout of the vias and routing has been
established, the signal vias can be impedance optimized • Routing length across the board should be kept as short
by changing the distance between the edges of the GND as possible within reason. Longer traces increase signal
planes and the sides of the signal vias. The cut outs in the loss and reduce the signal bandwidth.
GND planes that allow signal vias to transition through
layers are known as anti-pads, and the anti-pad diameters
are tuned to optimize via impedance.

Figure 19: An example of routing style to avoid fiber weave effect.

20 Samtec Signal Integrity Handbook


XI Signal Integrity in RF Systems
While digital and RF/microwave cables and connectors tend to be application specific, there are a number of similar concerns
for designers of high-speed digital and high-frequency systems. High-speed digital designers, therefore, may find some value in
the analysis of RF techniques.

Additionally, it is possible to use cables and connectors designed for RF/microwave applications for high-speed digital
applications, so some comparison of similar terms might be useful. While a full discussion of RF is beyond the scope of this
document, below is a brief listing of some RF terms and how they are analogous to SI ones.

As mentioned above, VSWR is one characteristic that is commonly used to specify RF cables and is related to return loss. Others
include cable propagation velocity (which is related to time delay in a digital application), RF phase matching (which is analogous
to skew), attenuation (which is analogous to insertion loss), and RF cable shielding (which is analogous to isolation and crosstalk).

There is much to consider when selecting a high-speed interconnect. For additional assistance, see the resources suggested
and/or contact sig@samtec.com.

Samtec Signal Integrity Handbook 21


SIGNAL INTEGRITY TOOLS & SUPPORT

Samtec Signal Integrity Engineers address next generation system design challenges with industry-leading expertise in high-
performance interconnect systems, along with testing and validation services, system optimization support, and easy-to-use
design and development tools. Contact sig@samtec.com to discuss your specific application.

SIGNAL INTEGRITY SERVICES & SUPPORT

Frontline Engineering Services Technical Application Support Industry Standards Support

• High Data Rate Simulations • Signal/Power Integrity Expertise • Member/Participant of 30+ Industry,
Corporate & De Facto Standards
• Channel Analysis • Testing, Validation & Analysis
• Compatible/compliant products
• Signal Integrity Models • Full Channel SI Analysis/Optimization include: VITA, PICMG®, PCIe®, CXL,
IEEE, OIF, SFF-SIG, PC/104™, PISMO™,
• PCB & Breakout Region (BOR) Designs • PCB Layout & Routing Assistance SATA, USB and more

• Connector Selection • Full System Design Support • Visit samtec.com/standards

ONLINE DESIGN & DEVELOPMENT TOOLS

• Innovative product search, connector • Large Technical Library offers free 3D • Semiconductor & T+M partnerships
builder and simulation tools that help models, prints, footprints, test reports, demonstrate next gen 112/224 Gbps
streamline the design process white papers, application notes, etc. PAM4 interconnect solutions

TESTING & VALIDATION CAPABILITIES

Design Qualification Testing (DQT) Severe Environment Testing (SET) Signal Integrity Screening

Standard testing undergone by all Additional testing evaluates whether VNA-based test system screens for
Samtec products to verify the product select products are suitable for rugged manufacturing process anomalies that
design meets our intent. and/or harsh environments and other could lead to SI degradation in higher
extreme applications. samtec.com/SET data rate products.
Extended Life Product™ (E.L.P.™)

Rigorous testing that evaluates contact Leakage Testing


resistance including 10 year Mixed Platform developed for applications
Flowing Gas (MFG) and High Mating with higher voltage levels & extremely
Cycles (250 to 2,500). samtec.com/ELP sensitive current leakage specifications.

22 samtec.com/signalintegrity
Samtec-designed Evaluation & Development Kits simplify the design process and reduce time to market. Kits are available
for many of our high-performance connector sets, high-speed cable assemblies and optical solutions. Custom kits are also
available. Visit samtec.com/kits or contact kitsandboards@samtec.com for a full list of availability.

FPGA DEVELOPMENT BOARDS

VITA 57.4 FMC+ VITA 57.4 FMC+ Extender Card VITA 57.4 FMC+ FMC+ HSPC Loopback Card
HSPC Loopback Card 25/28 Gbps FireFly™ Module Supporting Xilinx® Virtex®
UltraScale™+ VCU118 Kit

SIGNAL INTEGRITY EVALUATION KITS

ExaMAX® High-Speed Backplane Generate™ High-Speed Generate™ Differential Pair AcceleRate® HD High-Density
System (EBTF/EBTM) Edge Card Socket (HSEC6-DV) Edge Card Socket (HSEC8-DP) Arrays (ADM6/ADF6)

ExaMAX® Backplane AcceleRate® Flyover® NovaRay® Flyover® Extreme Flyover® QSFP Bulls Eye® 70 GHz
Cable System Slim Direct Attach Cable Density & Performance Cable Double Density Cable System High-Performance
(EBCM/EBTF-RA) System (ARC6/ARF6) System (NVAC/NVAM-C) (FQSFP-DD to NVAC/ARC6) Test System (BE70A)

samtec.com/kits 23
REFERENCE & FURTHER READING

Articles / Papers:
Boesing, D., New High-Speed Connector Rating that Accounts for Entire System, Samtec Blog (2016)

Burns, M., Samtec Releases New Protocol Capabilities for High-Performance Interconnect, Samtec Blog (2018)

Channel Design,"2014 IEEE International Symposium on Electromagnetic Compatibility (EMC)," Raleigh, NC,
2014, pp. 648-653

Edwards, A., 3D Components and Service Strategy, Signal Integrity Journal, August 31, 2021

Gore, B., IEEE Channel Operating Margin (COM) For Channel Analysis, Samtec gEEk® spEEk (2020)

Gore, B. and R. Mellitz, "An Exercise in Applying Channel Operating Margin (COM) for 10GBASE-KR Channel
Design," 2014 IEEE International Symposium on Electromagnetic Compatibility (EMC), 2014

Gore, B., "25 Gbps Ethernet Channel Design in Context: Channel Operating Margin (COM)," SI Symposium,
Penn State Harrisburg, 2016

Krooswyk, S., Component Crosstalk Characterization by ICN, Samtec gEEk® spEEk (2020)

Krooswyk, S. and M. Rengarajan, "Don’t Judge a Bit Just By Its Fourier: 112G PAM4 Component Optimization
and Selection," DesignCon 2019

Love, J., High Bandwidth Connectors: Sorting Out What Matters, Signal Integrity Journal, April 19 2022

McMorrow, S., Practical Use of ERL to Optimize Interconnect/BOR Design, Samtec gEEk® spEEk (2020)

Mellitz, R., Mechanics of Running COM, Samtec gEEk® spEEk (2021)

Mellitz, R., Effective Return Loss and How it is Computed, Samtec gEEk® spEEk (2020)

Mellitz, R., A. Ran, M. Li and V. Ragavassamy, "Channel Operating Margin (COM): Evolution of Channel
Specifications for 25 Gbps and Beyond," DesignCon 2013

Mellitz, R. and E. Sayre, "Effective Return Loss for 112G and 56G PAM 4," DesignCon 2018

Niehoff, B., What is PAM4? Understanding NRZ and PAM4 Signaling, Samtec Blog (2020)

Simonovich, B., "A Guide for Single-Ended to Mixed-Mode S-parameter Conversions," Signal Integrity Journal,
July 31, 2020

Trobough, N., "RF to Digital: Extreme Coaxial Cable Requirements," Signal Integrity Journal, April 7, 2022

24 Samtec Signal Integrity Handbook


Books:
Bogatin, E., Signal and Power Integrity – Simplified (Signal Integrity Library, 3rd edition) (2017)

Bogatin, E., Bogatin’s Practical Guide to Transmission Line Design and Characterization for Signal Integrity
Applications (2020)

Hall, S.H. and H. L. Heck, Advanced Signal Integrity for High-Speed Digital Designs, IEEE Press, 2009

Huray, P., The Foundations of Signal Integrity (2009)

Pupalaikis, P., S-Parameters for Signal Integrity (2020)

Zhang, H., S. Krooswyk and J. Ou, High Speed Digital Design: Design of High Speed Interconnects and
Signaling (2015)

Samtec Signal Integrity Handbook 25


ACRONYMS & ABBREVIATIONS

—B— —N—
BER bit error ratio NEXT near-end crosstalk
BOR breakout region NRZ non-return to zero

—C— —O—
COM channel operating margin OIF Optical Internetworking Forum

— D— —P—
DDR double-data rate (refers to memory) PAM2 pulse amplitude modulation 2-level
DUT device under test PAM4 pulse amplitude modulation 4-level
PCB printed circuit board
—E— PHY physical layer
EMC electromagnetic compatibility
EMI electromagnetic interference —R—
ERL effective return loss RL return loss
Rx receive
—F—
FCC Federal Communications Commission (USA) —S—
FEXT far-end crosstalk SI signal integrity
SMT surface mount
—G—
GND ground —T—
TDR time domain reflectometer/reflectometry
—I— Tx transmit
ICN integrated crosstalk noise
IEEE Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers —U—
IL insertion loss UCIe™ Universal Chiplet Interconnect Express
ILD insertion loss deviation
IRL integrated return loss —V—
ISI inter-symbol interference VNA vector network analyzer
VSWR voltage standing wave ratio
—L—
LED light-emitting diode

26 Samtec Signal Integrity Handbook


COPYRIGHTS, TRADEMARKS & PATENTS

Product names used herein are trademarks of their respective owners. All information and material in this publication are
property of Samtec, Inc. All related rights are reserved. Samtec, Inc. does not authorize customers to make copies of the
content for any use.

Terms of Use
Use of this publication is limited to viewing the pages for evaluation or purchase. No permission is granted to the user to
copy, print, distribute, transmit, display in public, or modify the contents of this document in any way.

Disclaimer
The information in this publication may change without notice. All materials published here are “As Is” and without implied
or express warranties. Samtec, Inc. does not warrant that this publication will be without error, or that defects will be
corrected. Samtec, Inc. makes every effort to present our customers an excellent and useful publication, but we do not
warrant or represent the use of the materials here in terms of its accuracy, reliability or otherwise. Therefore, you agree that
all access and use of this publication’s content is at your own risk.

Patents
Multiple patents are issued and pending.

Updated Documentation
Please contact sig@samtec.com to get access to the latest Signal Integrity documentation, and to ensure that you have the
latest version of this document.

NEITHER SAMTEC, INC. NOR ANY PARTY INVOLVED IN CREATING, PRODUCING, OR DELIVERING THIS
PUBLICATION SHALL BE LIABLE FOR ANY DIRECT, INCIDENTAL, CONSEQUENTIAL, INDIRECT, OR PUNITIVE
DAMAGES ARISING OUT OF YOUR ACCESS, USE OR INABILITY TO ACCESS OR USE THIS PUBLICATION, OR
ANY ERRORS OR OMISSIONS IN ITS CONTENT.

PCI-SIG®, PCI Express® and the PCIe® design marks are registered trademarks and/or service marks of PCI-SIG.
ExaMAX® is a registered trademark of AFCI.

SIGNAL INTEGRITY HANDBOOK


© January 2023, Samtec, Inc. All rights reserved.

Samtec Signal Integrity Handbook 27


SUDDEN SERVICE®

UNITED STATES • NORTHERN CALIFORNIA • SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA • SOUTH AMERICA • UNITED KINGDOM
GERMANY • FRANCE • ITALY • NORDIC/BALTIC • BENELUX • ISRAEL • INDIA • AUSTRALIA / NEW ZEALAND
SINGAPORE • JAPAN • CHINA • TAIWAN • HONG KONG • KOREA

© JANUARY 2023, SAMTEC, INC.

You might also like