Div 7 Newsletter June 2018
Div 7 Newsletter June 2018
Div 7 Newsletter June 2018
This
fire was one of the more heart wrenching events in living memory. It
led to the New York City Fire Department (FDNY) changing its
protective gear. Firefighters would begin being outfitted for “Bunker
Gear” starting May 16, 1994. The fire will forever be known in the
annals of the FDNY as the “Watts Street Fire”.
The Size-Up…”COAL WAS WEALTH”
Most wood lath and plaster had been removed and replaced with dry wall
in the building. The ceilings had been dropped from the original height of 9 feet 3
inches to 8 feet 4 inches. The fire apartment had energy efficient replacement
windows which also had screens and steel bars.
The second floor originally had two entrance doors to the apartment.
Renovations to the second floor eliminated the rear apartment door. The area of
the hallway on each of the three floors was reduced due to renovations. The only
entrance door was in the front of the stairway. It was a 36 inch wide steel buck
metal door. The second floor apartment door had
three locks. In the hallway of the second floor,
there was a box spring and a mattress near the
front apartment entrance door leaning against the
bannister. This storage of a mattress and a box
spring would prove to be a factor in the incident.
There was also a table in the hallway near the
stairway leading to the third floor.
The third floor apartment had two entrances off the hallway.
A AREA: Each apartment occupied the entire floor, minus the stairs and
hallway. Each apartment had a floor area of approximately 900 square feet.
L LIFE: The building was an occupied multiple dwelling. The top three floor
apartments were accessed by an open interior wooden stairway. There was a
basement apartment which was accessed via an exterior door. An occupant was
removed from the basement apartment early in the fire.
All floors from the fire floor to the top floor had
wooden plank floors. The wooden floors within the
building had been re-finished two days prior to the fire.
L LOCATION: The location of the fire was the first floor apartment of 62
Watts Street. The fire did not spread to any of the exposures.
T TIME OF DAY: The time of day impacted the order of response of fire
companies. It was the height of rush hour. It was also shortly after the start of
the night tour in the FDNY. This would have an impact due to the rotation of
personnel between Ladder 5 and Ladder 8.
H HEIGHT OF BUILDING: The building was 3 stories tall, and was 32 feet
6 inches in height. This was well within reach of aerial ladders and all floors could
be reached via portable ladders.
At 1936 hours, Manhattan Fire Alarm Dispatchers transmitted Box 308 for a
telephone alarm for a reported smoke condition on the top floor of 60 Watts
Street. Engines 24, 55, and 7, Ladders 5, and 8, and Battalion 2 were dispatched
to the scene. At 1938 hours, a second source reported a smoke condition in 64
Watts Street (erroneously reported as 52 Watts Street).
The OV from Ladder 8 took the front windows with a hook. After about 5
seconds, a ball of fire
erupted from the front
windows which lasted about
10-15 seconds. Fr. Kevin
Erdman, Engine 55’s
Nozzleman who was on his
knees, was driven to the
floor by heavy fire coming
out, under pressure, from
the apartment door. He fell
backwards and saw “orange
all around him.” A tremendous amount of fire now had possession of the
apartment doorway and the first floor hallway. Engine 55’s Control Firefighter,
Scott Koennecke, had made it to the entrance hallway on the first floor where he
was donning his mask facepiece. The amount of heat and energy coming out of
the first floor apartment banked downward and drove him to the front entrance
door and stairway. The fire came out of the first floor apartment with a loud roar.
Firefighter Erdman, Engine 55’s Nozzleman,
operated the hose line from his back to try
to cool the area above where he was and in
the hallway. He was able to recover and
start operating his hose line
through the apartment door.
Deputy Chief Bruce Hassett of Division 1 arrived at the fire. Battalion Chief
Ardisson briefed him of what had transpired, including the “Urgent” transmission
that was heard but were unable to get a clarification of the message.
Before going above the fire, make face to face contact with the Engine
Officer or Truck Officer or Engine Control Firefighter on the fire floor.
For those who
have been contacted
about firefighters going
above the fire, never
lose control of the fire
apartment door. If
water is lost or
delayed, the hose line
should be backed out
of the fire apartment
and this fire apartment
door should be closed.
The fire apartment door should remain closed in this situation until the
firefighters operating above the fire are out of the hallway.
If water is lost
or delayed and
firefighters are going
above the fire, call
them over the radio
and advise them of
the water supply
difficulties.
In this age of
energy efficient
windows (EEW),
horizontal ventilation
should be delayed until a hose line is in place and operating in the fire area. EEWs
should be considered the norm and not the exception. EEWs can allow a
tremendous buildup of heat without failing.
If going above the
fire, consider the building
construction in your size-
up. The most dangerous
type of construction to go
above the fire is wood
frame construction. The
second most dangerous is
brick and wood joist
(ordinary) construction.
Before going
above the fire, be
clear what your
objectives are.
Upon arrival at
the floor above, the first act that must be
completed is to force entry into an “area of refuge”.
This area of refuge is usually on the other side of the
hallway than the apartment directly above the fire.
Photos courtesy of FDNY Photo Unit, Fire Marshals investigative reports and video
Resources: New York Times, FDNY Safety Bulletin 69, “Modeling a Backdraft
Incident, The 62 Watts St (NY) Fire” by Richard W. Bukowski P.E.; “Fire
Department of City of New York Investigative Report for Manhattan Box 2-2-308”,
FDNY Safety and Inspection Services Command, Public Employee Safety and
Health Bureau (PESH) Report, Report by Battalion Chief Richard Ardisson to
Assistant Chief Donald J. Burns, WNYF Magazine 1st Issue 2013, “Fire at 62 Watts
Street” by Battalion Chief Edward McDonald (Ret.) and Battalion Chief Daniel
Melia. “Safety and Survival on the Fireground” 2nd Ed., by Vincent Dunn, Fire
Engineering; “Random Thoughts” by Tom Brennan, Fire Engineering.