Chapter 7 Job Analysis
Chapter 7 Job Analysis
7
                                                Job Analysis
                                                                Jane O'Callaghan
                                                             Sharon Suwitzer-Mclntyre
                                      Educaton                                                                                          Work
                                        Training                                                                                    Hardening
                                                                                                             Job
                                                                                                           Analysis
                                          Job
                                      Moditication                                                                                Cornditicnung
                                                                                                                                        Jce
                                                                                                                                  Modthcaten
 "Manifold  is the harvest of diseases reaped by certain                     cause of injury identified by Ramazinni
                                                                                                                          (noxious va-
 workers fron the crafts and trades that they pursue. All                    pors and very fine particles) has fallen into the realm of
 the profit that they get is njury to their health, that stems               the contemporary industrial
                                                                                                            hygienist.
 mostly, I think from two causes. The first and most potent                      The second cause (violent and
 is the harmful character of the materials that they hnandle,
                                                                                                                     irregular motions
                                                                             and unnatural postures) constitutes an area in which
 noxious vapors and very fine particles, inimical to human                   Industrial       Therapists              often function.
 beings, inducng specific diseases. As a second cause 1
                                                                                                                                               Carpal     tunnel
                                                                             syndrome (Figure 7.1, page 86), repetitive motion
 assign certain violent and irregular motions and unnatur-                   problems, cervical strains, low back pain, and degener-
 al postures of the body, by reason of which the natural                     ative disc disease                    all
 structure of the living machne is so impaired that serious
                                                                                                           are
                                                                                                                         examples of problems referred
                                                                             to by Ramazinni and treated by Industrial Therapists,
 diseases gradually develop.                                                 today, in clinical practice." lt is not enough to treat
                                          Bernardino Ramazin                 these   problems         in the clinic.
                                                De Morbis Artijicum
                                                                                                          They must also be treated
                                                                             on   the   job   site
                                                                                              there may be a mismatch between the
                                                                                                     as
                         About Diseuses of Workers, 1700                     worker's capabilities and the
                                                                                                           workplace demands.
                                                                                   During the 1990s, the United States and Canada
he need to
                                                                             passed legislation that increased the rights of workers
               analyze job demands was first recognized                      to   demand safe
n the                                                                                                      working         conditions, established the
          early eighteenth century in Furope, The first                      rights of injured workers                   to return to   work and ensured
                                                                                                                                                                85
            Part lI   Injury Prevention
     86
equitable employment for the disabled. These laws                            ments, and in response to changing legislation in the
have made job analyses a legal requirement for em-                           United States (Americans with Disabilities Act, 1992)
ployers as part of their efforts to provide safe working                     and Canada.
conditions, to return injured workers to the job and to                          Numerous lists, tables, charts, and scales which
accommodate people with disabilities (Figure 7.2).A8                         differentiate the various demands to be considered
    Industrial Therapists, using their acquired skills                       have been   developed. This chapter describes one com
and expertise in the understanding of disabilities,                          prehensive approach to understanding and analyzing
injuries, and physical demands analysis are in an ideal                      the demands of a job.
position to assist organizations in conducting Job Anal-
yses. The results of a Job Analysis are useful in many
aspects of the Worker Care Spectrum-for matching                             THE ANALYSIS CONTINUUM
workers' functional capacities with the for
                                        job;    making
hiring and job placement decisions; for identifying and                      Job Analysis (JA) is often the first step or the foundation
correcting risk exposure; for determining Work Condi-                        for most aspects of Industrial Therapy, whether it is tor
tioning or Work Hardening goals; and for designing a                         a new hire or rehabilitation
                                                                                                              purposes. The term J0o
modified job to ensure a safer return to work. It is                         Analysis refers to the total analysis continuum o
therefore   suggested         that the                                       which Job Demands Analysis (JDA), Task Analysis (TA)
approach for concise analysis of job demands.
                                              Therapist develop       an
                                                                             and Ergonomic Evaluation (EE) are subsets.
     Since the 1700s,
                              systems
                                have been developed to                           Depending on the complexity of the job to
 meet a variety of
                   objectives with respect to re-organiz-                    analyzed and the purpose for the assessment, the
 ing a workplace to improve safety and for                                   may be one or several types of analyses complete
 the physical requirements of                  predicting
                              any job. Job analysis in the                   (Figure 7.3). In all cases it is beneficial to review the jou
 past has been subjective, estimation oriented and not                       description, whether written or verbal, to gain a
 always performance related. Recently this has changed                       understanding of the purpose of the job and how it n
 due to the recognition of value in Functional
                                                  Assess-                    into the organization. The goal of the analysis must
                                                                                                         Chapter 7   Job Analyels    87
FIGURE 7.3            The Analysis Continuum.                        FIGURE 7.4         The scope and budget of a Job Analysis is
                                                                                        determined through discussion with the
                                                                                        employer.
                           Job description
                         A written or verbal
                         description of the
                         functions of the job
                           Task analysis
                     A detailed inventory of the
                  frequency, duration, and forces
                     required to meet the major
               demands of the job (mojor demands
               determine the tasks to be analyzed)
                                                                     DEFINITIONS
                       Ergonomic evaluation
                  A mathematical analysis of the
                                                                     Job Demands Analysis
                 physical aspects of the job which
                  might be considered hazardous                      A Job Demands Analysis JDA) is an objective and
                   based on the above analysis                                         to identify the demands of a
                                                                     systematic procedure
                                                                     particular job."i" The demands of a job can include;
                                                                     basic physical demands (lifting, carrying, pushing, and
Ergonomic Evaluation
Tool and job redesign issues may be identified while
performing the Job Demands Analysis and Task Analy-
sis. These components may require Ergonomic Evalua-
tion.
     Ergonomic Evaluation is a mathematical analysis
of any aspect of a job that is identified during the JDA,
as "hazardous" or of "risk" to the worker.
    Job Demands Analysis, Task Analysis and Ergo-
nomic Evaluation are all areas of the study of work
activities and do not include workers. The evaluation
of worker capability is defined as a Functional Capacity
Assessment. This measures an individual's capacity to
sustain performance in conformance with the defined
job demands analysis (see Chapter 13).
FIGURE 7.6 A, Reach; B, Lift; C, Turn; D, Carry. Job analysis involves breaking job tasks into components.
 A
                                                                                                                                         B
PURPOSES AND APPLICAIONS
                                                       i t                               A       Ole
frsts that a a p o a              at       lal
(iyue 7.7. ay 0)
      AsUmOthat   a   vinll   inaie   ni
Aids to accommodate
JobMatch - -
Training
L
(Reprinted with permission from TOC Inc., 1993.)
 FIGURE 7.8              The job is matched to the worker through Job Analysis and Job Placement Assessment.
                                                                                                                 A, Job Analysis;
                         B, Job Placement Assessment; C, Job is modified to match the worker.
                                                                                                                                    B
 A
                                                                                                   Chapter 7 Job Analysis
Job Modification
Through the job analysis process, specific aspects of a      Job and Tool           Design   and    Redesign
job that exceed the individual's work capacity, or           To    effectively redesign jobs       and tools     a   JA may be
present potential hazards can be identified. This base       performed on the new job and equipment. New pro-
line of information permits the Industrial Therapist         duction ines without thorough analysis may lead to
and other members of the team to reduce risks by
                                                             costly worker problems and additional                   equipment
modifying the hazardous aspects of the critical tasks.       changes.
Through job modification the worker can gradually,              As an example,         one   client of the authors' practice
yet progressively, return to work in their fullest capaci-   had two employees         on   the production line who com-
ty. Clear guidelines should be developed to ensure that      plained of upper extremity pain and fatigue. New
the worker returns to full capacity in a reasonable          chairs and air guns were
amount of time.
                                                                                      supplied for these employees.
                                                             Two months later the same
                                                                                         employees had complaints
                                                             of wrist and back pain. When the situation was reana-
Reasonable Accommodation                                     lyzed, it was determined that the entire production line
                                                             required redesign, and the initial fix represented un-
In order to accommodate      individual, the specific
                             an
                                                             necessary expense.
mismatches between the job demands and the abilities
of the individual need to be identified. According to the
                                                                     THE PROCESS
                                                                                                              involves      a   review of    the job
                                                                     The      Job Analysis      process
                                                                     description,         collection of all necessary            equipment and
                                                                                            of the job, completion                            of the
                                                                     documents, observation
                                                                           Demands        form, discussion with the
                                                                                   Analysis                               major
                                                                     Job                                    and written
                                                                     stakeholders, specific tasks analysis,             reports
                                                                                     Stakeholders    include all the people
                                                                     (Figure 7.10).
                                                                                          vested interest in  the  making           process     suc-
                                                                     who have         a
                                                                     cessful.
                                                                           Following is a step by step guide of how                        perform
                                                                                                                                      to
                                                                     a Job Demands Analysis and a Task Analysis.
BOX 7.1
FIGURE 7.10 The process model. FIGURE 7.11 Equipment for a Job Analysis.
Interview stakeholders
                                                                           Job Modifications
                                                                           Recommendations for accommodations or job modifi
                                                                           cations can be classified into five general types:
                                                                                                                 Chapter 7   Job Analysis
                            KEYK
                           Job Analysis
                           Phystoal Esenthit
                           DemandFunetion
                                  wORKER
                                  Reasonablo
                           AcconmmodationA
                      TasikMMaster
                                   m    en e
                                                      pete
                       eety po.
             The return-to-work transition process includes:                          days or weeks of idle time when they could be back
                                                                                      work, it creates pain and delay of recovery if they at
               1. Prepare the job and task demands analysis.                          sent back to certain tasks too soon, and it results in
                                                                                                                                                            in
               2. Determine the worker's functional capacity.                         time to the        employer,       decreased      efficiency, and
               3. Deterrnine the tasks which may be within the                        creased disability insurance costs.1
                  worker's capabilities. Compare the job de-                                                 the' information        provided    in the Jod
                                                                                                 y using
                  nands analysis with the worker's functional                         Analysis any employee, physician, Industrial Thera
                  capabilities to determine if their major limita                     pist, counselor, placement officer, or employer who
                                                                                                                                                            for
                       tions are related to strength, mobility, work                  called upon to make    decision regarding "fitness
                                                                                                                     a
                       environment, or work conditions. Then identi-                  work' will know            specifically
                                                                                                                   what that work                    involve
                       fy a task that does not require demands in                     A decision based on concrete facts will be a                     mue
                       areas of limitations, For example, if strength is              better decision than one based on guesswork.
                                                                                                           Chapter 7   Job Analysis    97
    cans with Disabilities Act, Personnel Journal, June 1992.            With Disabilities Act, Industrial Engineering 36-39, Jan
      Eastman Kodak Company: Ergonomic Design for Peojle at
                                                                         1984
      Work, vol 1, New York, 1983, VanNorstrand Reinhold.          13. Pheasant S: Ergonomics: work and health, Gaithersburg.
      Eastman Kodak Conmpany: Ergonomic Design for People at
                                                                         Md, 1991, Aspen Publishers.
    Work, vol 2, New York, 1986, VanNorstrand Reinhold.            14. Schulenberger, CC: Ergonomics In The Workplace: eval
 4. 1marinen }, Suumakki T, Nygard C, Landau K: Classif                        and     modifying jobs,       Cup   Medicine,
                                                                         uating
      cation of municipal occupations, Scand I Work Environ              7(1):105,1992.
                                                                                                                            S,
      Health 17(suppl):12, 1991                                    15. TOC      Consulting, O'Callaghan J, Switzer-Mclntyre
 5. 1sernhagen S]: Work Injury: management and prevention,               Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
      Rockville, Md, 1988, Aspen Publishers.                       16.   Wilson   JR, Corlett EN    editors: Evaluation    of Human Work:
 6.   Isernhagen S): Functional Job Descriptions, Senmin Occu-                                      Methodology, London        1990, Taylor
                                                                         A Practical   Ergonomics
      pat Med 2(1): 51,1987.                                             & Francis Ltd,.
                                                                                                                                       No.
 7. Jacobs    K,   editor:   Industrial   Rehabilitation,   WORK                   C:   Job descriptions     in   Writing: Required?
                                                                   17.   Woolsey                                           1992.
      1(1),1990.                                                       Useful? Yes, Business Insurance, 10, July
 8. Judy B: Job Accommodations and JAN, Employment                                                Board Act, Bill 162: Revised
                                                                   18. Workers' Compensation                            Printer
                                                                                                 Printed by the Queen's
      Relations Today, 121-125, Summer, 1988.                          Status of Ontario, 1990,
                                                                                                 1990.
9   KEY Functional Assessments Inc., Job Analysis Training               for Ontario,    April
    Program, vol 2, Minneapolis, 1992.
                                    Babu AJ: A Preliminary
10. Kittusamy NK, Okogbaa OG,
                                                       Envi-
    Audit For Ergonomics Design In Manufacturing
    ronments, Industrial Engineering
                                     47-53, July 1992.