6 Who Works More
6 Who Works More
THERMODYNAMICS
WHO WORKS MORE?
NEET BOARDS
Isothermal Expansion or Compression
ΔU = CV ΔT
Where,
CV = Heat capacity at constant volume
ΔT = Change in temperature
Or
qV = CV ΔT
ΔH = CP ΔT
Where,
ΔH = Change in enthalpy
CP = Heat capacity at constant pressure
For an isothermal process, the change in temperature, ΔT = 0
Therefore, for a isothermal reversible or an irreversible expansion or compression of an ideal gas,
the value of ΔU and ΔH is zero.
∴ ΔU = ΔH = 0
According to the first law of thermodynamics,
ΔU = q + W
Since for an isothermal process ΔU = 0, we get,
q = −W
The magnitudes of q and W depend on the manner in which the process of expansion or
compression is carried out, i.e., whether it is carried reversibly or irreversibly.
NEET BOARDS
Adiabatic Expansion or Compression
For a small change, the first law of thermodynamics can be written as,
dU = dq + dW ... (1)
In an adiabatic process, no heat is allowed to enter or leave the system.
Hence, dq = 0
C = n × Cm ... (3)
Where, ‘n’ is the number of moles.
For constant volume, equation (3) can be written as,
CV = n × CV, m ... (4)
Substituting the value of CV from equation (4) in equation (2), we get,
dW = nCV, mdT ... (5)
We know, dW = −PextdV ... (6)
From equations (5) and (6), we get,
PVγ = Constant
γ−1
TV = Constant
γ γ
P1 − T = Constant
Let's consider an irreversible adiabatic process, −Pext(V2 − V1) = nCV, m(T2 − T1)
where, the external pressure is constant, i.e., P (V − V ) = nC (T − T ) … (4)
ext 1 2 V, m 2 1
Pext = Constant.
From the ideal gas equation, PV = nRT,
According to the first law of thermodynamics,
ΔU = q + W nRT
V=
P
In an adiabatic process, no heat is allowed to
enter or leave the system. Thus, q = 0 nRT1 nRT2
= V1 = , V2
W = ΔU = nC ΔT … (1) P1 P2
V, m
Note
Once the adiabatic process is complete the value of final pressure or P2 in the above equation will
be equal to external pressure.
T P −T P
C V, m ( T2 − T1 ) =
PextR 1 2 2 1
P1 P2
In an adiabatic process, no heat is allowed to enter or leave the system. Thus, q = 0.
According to the first law of thermodynamics,
ΔU = q + W ⇒ ΔU = Wadi
Note
q=0 ΔU = W W = ΔU ⇒ +ve T↑
q=0 ΔU = W W = ΔU ⇒ −ve T↓
dP P
= −
dV V
Where,
dP Pγ
== Slope
− of the pressure (P)-volume (V) curve.
dV V
In the case of an isothermal reversible process,
dP P
Slope of the curve == − ... (1)
dV V
PVγ = Constant
dP Pγ
d(PVγ) = d(constant) = −
dV V
Pd(Vγ) + Vγ(dP) = 0
We know, Where,
d n dP Pγ
x = nx n − 1 == Slope
− of the pressure (P)-volume (V) curve.
dx dV V
P (γ Vγ − 1 dV) + Vγ dP = 0 In the case of an adiabatic reversible process,
P (γ V γ −1
dV) = − V dP γ
P
dP P γ V
−1 γ
Slope of the curve = − γ … (2)
= γ
V
dV −V
dP From equations (1) and (2), we get,
= − P γ ( V − 1 .V − )
γ γ
Note
Adiabatic Isothermal
On differentiating, On differentiating,
P × γ Vγ − 1 dV + Vγ dP = 0 PdV + VdP = 0
dP P dP P
= −γ = −
dV V dV V
P-V Plot
A C
Adiabatic curve
In the Fig. 5, the P-V curve for adiabatic and isothermal
processes are shown. The steeper curve (in red
colour) represents the adiabatic process and the
Pressure
Expansion
Isothermal
increasing. Therefore, this is expansion. The area
under the P-V curve represents the work done in that
particular process. So, the area under the curve in the
case of isothermal expansion is more than the area Adiabatic
under the curve in the case of an adiabatic expansion
for the same change in volume.
Compression
The red curve signifies the adiabatic curve and the green
curve signifies the isothermal curve. As the pressure is
increasing, the volume of the gas is decreasing, so it is
Pressure
compression. The area under the P-V curve represents
the work done in that particular process. So, the area under Adiabatic
the curve in the case of an adiabatic compression is more
than the area under the curve in the case of an isothermal
compression for the same change in volume. Isothermal
(a) A, C Pressure
(b) B, D B C
(c) A, D
D
(d) B, C
Volume Volume
Solution
The slope of the adiabatic P-V curve is steeper than the slope of the isothermal P-V curve. In plot 1,
curve B has a steeper slope than curve A. So, the thermodynamic process ‘B’ is adiabatic. In plot 2,
curve C has a steeper slope than curve D. So, the thermodynamic process ‘C’ is adiabatic. Therefore,
B and C are the adiabatic processes.
The correct answer is option (d).
Quick
recap
Isothermal process
Adiabatic process
For the same expansion (from same initial to final volume) and same initial pressure, more
pressure needs to be applied in an isothermal process as compared to an adiabatic process.
Isothermal process
Adiabatic process
Type of process ΔU ΔH
Isothermal 0 0
Free expansion 0 0
S. No Formula Process
γ(1 − γ ) γ 1− γ
V1 T1 P1
1. = = Adiabatic reversible process
V2 T2 P2
2. ΔU = W = 0 Free expansion
γ γ
3. P1V1 = P2V2 Reversible adiabatic process