Atieno: A Reflection on Exploitation
Atieno: A Reflection on Exploitation
RUBADIRI)
1
I attended to matters of state.
Highly delicate diplomatic duties you know,
And friend, it goes against my grain,
Causes me stomach ulcers and wind.
Ah, he continued, yawning again,
The pains we suffer in building the nation!
So the PS had ulcers too!
My ulcers I think are equally painful
Only they are caused by hunger,
No sumptuous lunches!
THEMATIC ANALYSIS.
DISILLUSIONMENT
The kind of disillusionment portrayed in the poem is that which Africans have towards their
leaders who have adopted the very tenets of the colonisers from whom they got power.
Essentially, the idea of nation building turns out to be a very complicated phenomenon where
those who are central to the process have their efforts wasted by leaders who can implement
policies.
The persona shows more disillusionment by stating that at the meeting “the menu reflected its
importance/ Cold Bell beer with small talks/ Then fried chicken with niceties/ wine…/ ice cream
2
…/coffee… (lines 6-11). This reflects the triviality of a meeting where serious issues were
supposed to be discussed.
CLASSES.
In a broader way the poem thoroughly depicts two classes in one society. There is middle class
and lower class. Both of them are supposed to mutually benefit from the national resources. Yet
the middle class that is represented by the PS exploits the lower class that more often than not
comprises those who are involved in the modes of production. For example the driver drives the
PS to the place where there is feasting (eating) while the driver does not take part in the feasting.
The role of both classes is building the nation, but the middle class has just become the parasites
who feed on the national resources at the expense of the masses. They are not building the nation
at all but building their stomachs.
AWARENESS
The poem paints a picture of awareness that those who are oppressed are now aware that those in
power are exploiting them. This is an important step as long as the liberation of the oppressed is
concerned. It is also a significant step if the nation is to realise sustainable development where
the national resources will be mutually utilized for the benefit of not only the ruling class but the
masses as well.
3
If we examine the end of the poem it seems to induce a kind of anger that should lead to
vengeance (revenge). The persona is appealing to the oppressed to rise to the occasion and deal
with the ruling class.
The fact that “two nation builders/ arrived home this evening/with terrible stomach pain/the
result of building the nation/different ways” is more like an appeal to emotions where the
persona seeks actions from the masses.
In a way, the persona calls for a reaction towards the ruling class’s hypocritical nation building
where they pretend to have welfare of the masses at heart while in real sense they just want to
capitalize on their efforts.
VULNERABILITY OF HUMANITY.
Nevertheless, the persona seems to have hopes in some facts that both the African bourgeoisie
and the proletariats have their points of vulnerability. They both suffer in one way or another
because of their own actions and lifestyles. For instance the driver becomes sick because of lack
of food while the PS becomes sick for eating too much.
So Ps has ulcers too!
My ulcers I think are equally painful
Only they are caused by hunger,
No sumptuous lunches!
MESSAGE.
* If we wish to do well in nation building we must as public servants respect everything that
belongs to the state; money, property, working hours etc.
* If the high class is not careful with nation building one day the oppressed may revolt.
RELEVANCE
4
* Hypocrisy has also become a way of life.
* Classes, exploitation and marginalization are also major issues in our society.
STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS
a. What is the poem about?
The poem is about the concept of nation building as taken by African bourgeoisie class who
came to power after colonialism. The poet shows that independence was just the change in
colour but the leaders adopted the very tenets of their predecessors.
b. Who is the persona? How do you know?
The persona is a driver who represents the low class.
In line 3 he says “I drove the permanent secretary”
c. Suggest some literary and poetic devices used in the poem.
i. Alliteration
Highly delicate diplomatic duties..
And secretly smiling…
Cold Bell beer
ii. Barbarism
Mwananchi, I too had none!
iii. Onomatopoeia
Ah, he continued yawning again.
This is the sound of yawning
iv. Satire
To an important urgent function
In fact to a luncheon at the Vic.
Lunch is called an important urgent function, this is very satirical
v. Irony.
The title of the poem ‘Building the Nation” is ironical because the guys in the poem were not
building the nation.
d. Why did the PS ask the question “Did you have any lunch friend?”
5
He asked the question just to keep himself awake throughout the journey and not because he is
concerned by the welfare of the driver.
f. The poet says in the last stanza ‘so two nation builders arrived home this evening’ were the
two people building the nation?.
Not really. The poet uses this as a satire to criticise the idea that people always claim to build the
nation but they end up building their stomachs.
6
Atieno ten years old,
Atieno yo.
7
APPRECIATION OF THE POEM
INTRODUCTION
Marjorie was born in Britain in 1928 and travelled to Kenya to work as a missionary. She met
and married Macgoye in 1960. This poem was written out of her experience in living among the
Luo – a tribe of her husband. She criticises negligence of nurturing children among African
societies. Without proper guidance, the young girl Atieno becomes pregnant which leads to her
death.
STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS
* What is the poem about?
The poem is about a young girl called Atieno who is mistreated by her own uncle. She works
without pay and ends in death due to post partum bleeding.
* What is the kind of the poem?
It is a narrative poem (telling a story) but it is a special kind of narrative poem called “a ballad”
* How many stanzas are there?
It has seven stanzas, each with six verses (lines) of unequal length and a refrain “Atieno yo”
* What is the tone of the poem?
The tone is sympathetic to the child.
* Comment on the rhyming pattern.
Every second and forth lines end with rhyme,
Chicken/kitchen
Pay/day
Kids/beads
Free/fee
Night/ right
Bad/had
All/funeral
* Who is the persona? How do you know?
The persona in the poem is Atieno’s uncle. This is revealed in the second stanza where he
comments; “since she’s my sister’s child/Atieno needs no pay.
8
* How does Atieno change over the years?
Atieno changes in behaviour in respect to her age. While she is eight she is just working at home
but as she grows fourteen, after puberty hits she stays long at the market perhaps with boys. This
eventually leads her to get impregnated.
THEMATIC ANALYSIS
CHILD LABOUR
The issue of child labour has become a burning issue that attracts the attention of most social
activists. Many children are employed informally, in the streets, homes and some workplaces.
We see them selling plastic bags, candies, washing cars, helping the military rebels etc. Atieno in
the poem is just one case in point. She represents this class. She is working as a house girl at the
age of 8 and strangely enough without pay. At this age she should have been in STD 2. Yet she is
employed in her uncle’s home.
EXPLOITATION AND OPPRESSION
9
Despite the growing awareness of the violation of human rights, the world is still facing the
problem of exploitation and oppression.
The young girl in the poem is not only exploited but also oppressed by her own uncle. Although
she works and does all the domestic chores she is not paid nor given any good care. The poetess
suggests that she even desires to have the dresses, shoes and beads of her cousins since she is not
given one. Here says the poetess.
Atieno’s sly and jealousy/Bad example to the kids/ Since she minds them like a school
girl/Wants their dresses, shoes and dresses.
Again in the second stanza she shows how Atieno’s efforts are wasted without gain.
Since she is my sister’s child/Atieno needs no pay
EARLY PREGNANCY
This is another common problem among the teenagers today. Parents are now very busy than at
any point in human history. As a result teens have been left without proper parental care. Many
girls today have failed to reach their educational goals because when they get pregnancy, they
are kicked out of schools altogether. At the age of fourteen Atieno becomes pregnant. This is
partly due to poor parental care. As the poetess says that her aunt has gone to study and uncle is
busy with the work while poor Atieno has no one to teach her what is right.
Since she is still young to handle the delivery complications she dies of excessive post partum
bleeding.
HYPOCRISY
There is hypocrisy from family level to national level when you come to think of it. Most
stepparents mistreat their stepchildren at home but in the outside they want everybody to believe
that they are taking good care of them. If you hear the tone of Atieno’s uncle you will certainly
discover some points of sympathy. But the question is; who is mistreating the young Atieno? It’s
her uncle. This is hypocrisy. On the funeral, we are told that meat and sugar more than all that
Atieno had eaten in such a narrow life were lavished in her funeral. That translates into
something like, “I loved the child” what a hypocrite!
POOR PARENTAL CARE.
While we are not told the reasons why Atieno is not living with her own biological parents, it is
evident that most parents have left the responsibility of taking care of their children to the
community like schools, churches or relatives. Because the parents are busy, they have no time
to make regular follow-ups to check the kind of upbringing their children go through.
Parenting is the most important responsibility that parents are now avoiding. Atieno goes to work
in her uncle’s home at the age of eight, and her parents are not making follow-ups. Atieno’s
uncle is also portrayed as a bad parent since he mistreats his own niece.
RELEVANCE
As we have seen child labour, hypocrisy, exploitation, oppression, poor parental care and early
pregnancies are all common phenomena in our country today. We see many children in the
streets selling things like plastic bags, washing cars; helping the military rebels etc. many girls
10
drop their studies due to early pregnancies. Every day we hear of violation and abuse of children
rights and parents are very busy today to the point that they cannot spare time to be with their
children and listen to their problems.
DEATH BE NOT PROUD (JOHN DONNE (England))
(NECTA 2009) with reference to the poem below highlight the central theme and relate it to
what is currently happening in our society.
11
people fear death terribly but in the long run death will be no more and as a result there is no
reason for fear.
He compares death with a ‘short sleep’ in which people sleep but there comes a day when they
will wake up and live eternally and death shall be the loser.
He says;
One short sleep past, we wake eternally
And death shall be no more, Death thou shalt die.
COURAGE
The poem provides us with courage of confronting death without fear. Throughout the entire
poem, the speaker grows more confident by showing that death is not the end of life. Although it
claims people’s lives now, a day is coming when death will take its own life. In such a case we
certainly have nothing to fear.
He says;
Death be not proud, though some have called thee
Might and dreadful, for though art not so.
RELIGION and FAITH
The poem seems to be centred on the subject of religion. It is only in religious spheres people
believe that after this life there comes a better life when this mortal body shall put on immortality
and death shall be defeated forever.
Even though, Donne puts a clear demarcation that this chance of rising and living eternally is not
just for everybody who simply die. He rather seems to be very meticulous by adopting a more
specific statement that only the good people (our best men) are entitled to this privilege.
He says;
And soonest our best men with thee do go,
Rest of their bones and soul’s delivery
12
THE AFTERLIFE
The poet has the hopes of the afterlife. He even shows that the afterlife is better than this life. For
him death seems to be a blessing because it is only through death that people are capable of
enjoying the afterlife.
Here says Donne;
From rest and sleep, which but thy pictures be,
Much pleasure - then from thee much more must flow,
STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS
a. What type of the poem is this?
This poem is a sonnet because it is made up of 14 lines (verses)
c. The poem has no clear/overt reference to Christianity. Aside from the title how do you know
that this is a religious poem?
It is only in the religious context people have the assurance of afterlife (life after death). It is the
bible that describes death as a short sleep and further states that death will one day be no more in
the new heaven and the new earth. (1Cor 15:26)
13
Addressing a thing/person in its/his absence. The poet addresses death but death does not
respond. Eg he says ‘poor death’ which is an embarrassing way to talk to someone who
considers himself tough.
Metaphor. The poet compares ‘rest and sleep’ as the pictures of death. Also death is compared
with a slave.
Synecdoche.
This implies using part of something to represent the whole.
In the poem he uses the “bones of the best men” to represent the whole physical body.
Rhetorical question. The speaker asks “why swell’st thou then?” it is just intended to make death
realize that he has no reasons to be proud, and not seeking for a response.
RELEVANCE
Today in our society, there are these two basic concepts about death. On one extreme there are
those who believe that death is the end of life and human history. Therefore, when they come at
the point of death they face it with fear. On the other extreme there are those especially in
religion realm who believe that death is but another door to a better life. For them, death should
not be proud because they aspire for afterlife which is better than the life we live now. They take
death as a blessing and not as a doom.
He says
I am stupid and very backward,
14
That my hair style
Makes him sick
Because I am dirty.
It is true
I cannot do my hair
As white women do.
Listen,
My father comes from Payira,
My mother is a woman of Koc!
I am a true Acoli
I am not a half-caste
I am not a slave girl;
My father was not brought home
By the spear
My mother was not exchanged
For a basket of millet.
15
At the arena
Boys surrounded me
And fought for me.
My mother taught me
Acoli hair fashions;
Which fits the kind
Of hair of the Acoli,
And the occasion.
Listen,
Ostrich plumes differ
From chicken feathers,
A monkey’s tail
Is different from that of a giraffe,
The crocodile’s skin
Is not like the guinea fowl’s,
And the hippo is naked, and hairless.
16
Is soft like silk;
It is light
And brownish like
That of a brown monkey,
And is very different from mine.
A black woman’s hair
Is thick and curly;
It is true
Ring-worm sometimes eat up
A little girl’s hair
And this is terrible;
But when hot porridge
Is put on the head
And the dance is held
Under the sausage-fruit tree
And the youths have sung
INTRODUCTION
This is a short extract from a long poem called “song of Lawino” which is almost entirely based
on the conflict between old and new ways of life. So it is based on what Lawino thinks as a
treasure for Africans as contrasted from what Ocol thinks on his side. (Although their names do
not appear anywhere throughout the poem).
17
THEMATIC ANALYSIS
Although the poem is but a small part of a long poem with several themes, still some of these
broader themes can be narrowly extracted from this poem. These include; identity and
awareness, African culture vs European culture, traditional healing, protest and the position of
women.
TRADITIONAL HEALING
Moreover, Lawino shows how Africans used to deal with different social and natural
phenomena. Although it might seem as a kind of incantation, but it helped to deal with unusual
phenomena. For example she says if a ring-worm has eaten the little girl’s hair, all they do is put
hot porridge on the head, hold a dance, sing a song, then the hair grows again. This traditional
ritual is still relevant to some societies today.
18
PROTEST
Lawino shows an open protest against European culture that is invading African culture. She
does all it takes to educate African women to love and care for what they have, believe in who
they are, and what they want to do with their lives. She protests doing her hair like white women.
She says;
It is true
I cannot do my hair
As white women do
POSITION OF WOMEN
True and strong upholder of African culture
Lawino in this poem represents a class of women who are proud of their culture and identity.
They can’t compromise their standards just to please their husbands
Care taker for children
Lawino shows that she behaves the way she does because her mother took time to teach her. It is
always believed that most of the behaviours that we have, we picked them during childhood. It is
up to parents to teach their children good manners and they will not abandon them to old age.
She says; my mother taught me/Acoli hair fashions/which fits the kind/of hair of the Acoli/and
the occasion
STUCTURAL ANALYSIS
a. What does the title of the poem “the graceful giraffe cannot become a monkey” mean?
The poet uses the symbol of the “giraffe” to represent the Acoli (Africans) and “monkey” as a
symbol for whites. As the giraffe cannot become a monkey, neither can Africans become white
people by their artificial designs.
e. Who is surer of his/her identity? Lawino or her husband? Why do you say so?
Certainly, Lawino is surer of her identity. This is due to what she expresses from the beginning
of the poem to the end. While she admits that all other women of other races are beautiful she is
not ready to compromise her identity and be like them.
20
Africans should be proud of their identity.
No matter what they do Africans will remain Africans.
RELEVANCE
The poem is relevant today in a number of aspects.
There are African women today who wish to do their hair like white women do.
There are black women who never wish to do their hair like white women. They remain natural
and proud of their identity.
There are men who pressurize their wives to do their hair like whites.
Africa my Africa
Africa of proud warriors in the ancestral savannahs
Africa of whom my grandmother sings
On the banks of the distant river
I have never known you
But your blood flows in my veins
Your beautiful black blood that irrigates the fields
The blood of your sweat
The sweat of your work
The work of your slavery
The slavery of your children
Africa tell me Africa
Is this you this back that is bent
This back that breaks under the weight of humiliation
This back trembling with red scars
21
And saying yes to the whip under the midday sun
But a grave voice answers me
Impetuous son that tree young and strong
That tree there
In splendid loneliness amidst white and faded flowers
That is Africa your Africa
That grows again patiently obstinately
And its fruit gradually acquires
The bitter taste of liberty.
INTRODUCTION
This poem is written by David Diop - A Black African who was born in France in 1927. His
father was from Senegal and his mother from Cameroon and he grew up in France and West
Africa aware of both cultures and traditions. He was deeply concerned by the question of
independence from colonial rule.
This poem is a dramatic monologue where the speaker seems to be in conversation with Africa.
The poem can be thematically divided into three parts; pre colonial Africa, colonial Africa and
post colonial Africa.
THEMATIC ANALYSIS.
EXPLOITATION
There are evidences of exploitation in the poem in the fact that the poet expresses how the sweat
of Africans was lost in vain.
The blood of your sweat
He sweat of your work
All this was done at a time when Africans were turned into slaves and worked for their masters
without any benefit.
The work of your slavery
The slavery of your children
22
OPPRESSION AND HUMILIATION
Oppression and humiliation were common practices in colonial time. They were used to force
Africans work for colonisers without objection. This has left scars to Africa that we still depend
on them even when they seem to mistreat us.
This back that breaks under the weight of humiliation
This back trembling with red scars
And saying yes to the whip under the midday sun
EFFECTS OF COLONIALISM
The poet concludes his poem by showing the effects that colonialism had on African continent.
Nevertheless, he seems to be optimistic that at least Africa is growing up again just like a young
tree.
That is Africa your Africa
That grows again patiently obstinately
a) What is the poem about?
The poem is about the effects colonialism has had on Africa. It traces the history of pre-colonial
Africa, then shows the torture that Africans underwent in colonialism and how Africa is starting
afresh like a young tree.
23
b) What does the symbol ‘that tree young and strong” suggest?
First of all the symbol refers to Africa. It suggests that after colonialism Africa began to grow up
again just as a young tree.
c) Why do the fruits acquire a bitter taste of liberty? Why does liberty taste bitter?
The fruits acquire a bitter taste because liberation of the oppressed is not a simple thing. It needs
sacrifice and determination. Some people lose their lives in the process. So in such a case liberty
is never sweet but bitter memories.
e) What is the tone of the poem? The tone changes from the beginning it is happy in the middle it
becomes sad but at the end it becomes optimistic.
f) Why does the poet say that “black blood flows in his veins”?
Black blood in this poem symbolises Africanism as there is no blood that is black in colour. So
he shows that although he grew up in France he is still aware of his African identity.
g) How have the past effects of colonialism shaped the Africa’s present?
The socio-political and economic state of Africa today was seriously affected during colonial
time. So Africa was paralysed and is just starting afresh as a young tree while the colonisers are
well off.
24
Is that you this back that is bent
Symbolism
Scars’, ‘whip’ and ‘blood’. They stand for the torture that Africans went through in colonial
time.
Black blood- symbolises African identity
Personification.
The poet addresses Africa as though it is a human being and has blood that flows, and can sweat
etc.
Alliteration- repetition of similar consonant sounds at the beginning of consecutive words
You beautiful black blood
Repetition (for emphasis)
The word Africa is repeated 7 times throughout the poem
Eg. Africa my Africa.
Under exaggeration.
Your beautiful black blood
This is under exaggeration because there is no black blood in colour.
MESSAGE
Colonialism paralysed Africa so it is up to us to make Africa’s hope alive again.
We must know our identity as Africans, where we come from, where we are and what we need to
do to get where we are going.
25
O, no! it is an ever-fixed mark,
That looks on tempests and is never shaken;
It is a star to every wandering bark,
Whose worth’s unknown, although his height be taken.
Love’s not Time’s fool, though rosy lips and cheeks
Within his bending sickle’s compass come;
Love alters not with his brief hours and weeks,
But bears it out even to the edge of doom.
If this be error, and upon me prov’d
I never writ, nor no man ever lov’d
INTRODUCTION
This is a sonnet also called sonnet 116 written by a British metaphysical poet William
Shakespeare (1564-1616) that tries to fill the vacuum of infidelity and unfaithfulness in marriage
relationships. The poet shows that at least true love based on truth and understanding can exist.
He presents two glorious lovers who come into relationship freely and are trustful to each other.
THEMATIC ANALYSIS
TRUE LOVE
The kind of love that Shakespeare brings out here is the one that stands firmly even if there
might be consequences to shake it. He says that such kind of a love does not alter/change when it
alteration finds. For him true love is like “an ever-fixed mark” which will survive any crisis. In
lines 7-8 he continues to say although we may be able to measure love to some degrees, this does
not mean we truly understand it. Love’s actual worthy cannot be known- it is a misery.
O, no! it is an ever-fixed mark,
That looks on tempests and is never shaken;
It is a star to every wandering bark,
Whose worth’s unknown, although his height be taken
This kind of love that Shakespeare expresses is the one that is unchangeable even when
challenged by some circumstances. Love is not flat but he warns that even if it means to go
through upside downs they should remain firm. It’s like a North Star that guides the ship (bark)
in deep sea.
26
On the marriage day there may really be no impediments (obstacles) but in the long run, changes
of circumstances, outward appearance and other conducts may challenge the relationship. But
lines 9-12 reaffirms that, this kind of love is unshakable throughout time and always remains so.
Love alters not with his brief hours and weeks,
But bears it out even to the edge of doom.
UNFAITHFUL LOVE
On the other hand he shows that there is another extreme of love that is not based on mutual
love. If something happens to challenge the relationship it breaks away.
…………………Love is not love
Which alters when it alteration finds,
Or bends with the remover to remove:
Lastly, in the final couplet the poet declares that if he is mistaken in his view of the unmoveable
nature of true love then he must take back all his writings on love, truth and faith. Then he says if
he judged love inappropriately no man has ever really loved in the ideal sense that the poet
professes.
If this be error, and upon me prov’d
I never writ, nor no man ever lov’d
STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS
27
Love is compared to the star
It is the star to every wandering bark
Allusion
The first two lines are a manifest of allusion to the words of the marriage service ‘if any one of
you knows cause of just impediments why these two persons should not be joined together in a
holy matrimony’
Alliteration
….compass come.
Personification
The poet uses abstract things like Time and Love as human beings to show that they can do of
feel like human beings. He even uses pronoun ‘his’ when referring to them. Eg Love alters not
with his brief hours and weeks
o What does the poet mean when he says that you can measure the height of a star but not its
worth? How can you apply this to love?
Always we can only judge outward appearance of something but inward characters are difficult
to be measured. So even in the case of love it is not what it always seems to be in the outside. It’s
worth lie deeper into the heart of someone. There is more to it than just outward appearance. No
one can read someone else’s heart.
o In Shakespeare’s day the word ‘fool’ could mean a servant. Why is love ‘not Time’s fool’?
28
Love is not Time’s servant in a sense that love is timeless. It does not last with time but it
endures forever as long as those in love have decided to remain in love no matter what
circumstance may challenge their relationship.
I remember, Countrymen,
The days of ‘Dawn Over the Land’.
Of hopes and expectations
When I truly understood
Slavery was a thing of the past –
We, the people of the land,
Had been freed.
I was there when slowly
Darkness set in.
The gradual destruction
Was there in front of me,
But I did not see it.
I continued, Countrymen, to live in the past.
And when I finally looked
It was too late, and even I
Had become a scavenger.
INTRODUCTION
This is a poem by a Malawian poetess Naomi Mnthali that tells a story of changes of power and
of hopes being raised and disappointed. The poem refers to Malawian independence that brought
hopes to the people of the land but later became only a nightmare or a daydream. Although it is
about Malawian independence it can also describe other parts of African continent in general.
THEMATIC ANALYSIS
DISILLUSIONMENT/DISAPPOINTMENT
29
Most freedom fighters did not ever imagine that the post independence life would be like this.
When they were fighting for freedom they believed that things will actually change in their
favour.
I remember, Countrymen,
The days of ‘Dawn Over the Land’
Of hopes and expectations
When I truly understood
Slavery was a thing of the past –
That is however not what it turned out to be. They are still living the life of the past and life has
even become worse since they live like scavengers.
I was there when slowly
Darkness set in.
The gradual destruction
Was there in front of me,
But I did not see it
BETRAYAL
The leaders who took power from the colonisers have betrayed the common people most of
whom took part in the struggle for freedom. The common people live the same life they lived
before independence. To them independence makes no sense.
The poet compares this situation with destruction that lay ahead but he did not notice it before.
The gradual destruction
Was there in front of me,
But I did not see it
He even shows that while some people live the modern life; he himself lives in the past. The
same kind of life they lived before independence.
I continued, countrymen, to live in the past.
And when I finally looked
It was too late, and even I
Had become a scavenger
POVERTY
30
A scavenger is an animal or a person who collects things by searching them from waste or
unwanted objects. The poet seems to come from a poor class that was betrayed by the
bourgeoisie class. This class always finds it hard to get their daily bread. They have become
scavengers in their own free countries. They eat the leftovers thrown by the privileged few.
And when I finally looked
It was too late, and even I
Had become a scavenger
This situation is almost evident in all African countries
STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS
1. The poet talks about “the days of ‘Dawn over the land’” what do you think this means?
‘Days of dawn’ means the very days when independence was attained and became like the
outbreak of a new day.
3. ‘I was there when slowly darkness set in’ what does this statement imply?
The poet confesses that he was aware as things began to change to worse.
31
Is the poem relevant to Tanzanians today?
Oh! Yes it is. Like most African countries the issue of betrayal by the bourgeoisie class is
common. So even in Tanzania most people live in the same situation described by the poet.
Epilogue
Grace Nichols (Guyana)
INTRODUCTION
This poem was written by a black woman from Guyana (Grace Nichols) who later moved to
England. It expresses important ideas about separation and a new beginning.
32
a. The poet says she has “lost her tongue” what does that mean?
It means she has adopted a new language. She no longer speaks her native language.
33
In vain; then the monsters we defy
Shall be constrained to honor us though dead.
O kinsmen! We must meet our common foe
Though far outnumbered. Let us show us brave
And for their thousand blows, deal one death blow
What though before us lies the open grave?
Like men we’ll face the murderous cowardly pack
Pressed to the wall dying but fighting back.
INTRODUCTION
Claude McKay was born in 1890 in Jamaica. He went to Kansas to study agriculture at the time
when Ku Klux Klan was highly active. He was therefore forced to move to New York in 1914.
In 1919 Washington DC newspaper gave stories of an alleged (suspected) sexual assault that was
said to be committed by an African American. The stories sparked (caused) a series of twenty
riots during the summer of 1919, beginning with white lynch mob (murderous group) that
targeted blacks in Washington. There were 28 public lynchings (killings) in the first half of the
year and the following summer and fall came to be known as “The Red Summer” of 1919. This
was the motivation behind McKay’s “If We Must Die”
He wrote the poem amid the violence and bloodshed of 1919, and in this poem he encourages his
community to take action and fight back.
STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS
34
The persona is a black American who is oppressed, humiliated and persecuted. We know this
from the history of the poet and the fact that blacks were hunted, penned (locked in small cells)
and killed like hogs (pigs) in America.
If we must die, let it not be like hogs
Hunted and penned in an inglorious spot.
While round us bark the mad and angry dogs
e) What sufferings does the person experience?
They are hunted (arrested), penned (locked in small cells) with angry and mad dog guarding
them and are sometimes killed without fair trial.
f) Is the persona afraid of death? Give reasons to justify your answer.
The persona is surely not afraid of death. The reasons for this are;
When you die fighting people will honor you. i.e. it is noble to die fighting. “let us nobly die”
Whether he fights or not, he is bound to die someday. “What though before us lies an open
grave?”
g) Comment on the figures of speech and poetic devices
i. Rhetorical question
o What though before us lies an open grave?”
ii. Metaphor
He compares the enemy/oppressors with the monsters. ‘The monsters we defy’
iii. Images
The poet paints the pictures of;
Hogs (pigs) = pigs are killed mercilessly so they should not die the same death.
Mad and angry dogs = this is the picture of the oppressor who guards the Blacks not to escape
from punishment.
iv. Symbolism
“An Open grave” this symbolizes death. Which is to say whether we fight or not death is there
waiting for us. Death is the ultimate finality of human life.
‘Blood” is a symbol for sacrifice
v. Repetition
The phrase “if we must die” is repeated for emphasis
vi. Hyperbole.
35
“For their thousand blows”
vii. Satire/Irony
The poet mocks both the enemy and himself.
“Like men we’ll face the murderous cowardly pack.” He mocks the oppressor that he is coward
like a group of wolves. But how can someone coward press you to the wall dying. He shows that
he is himself weak/inferior to the enemy. Also shows that the enemy is capable of dealing a
thousand death blows but he can deal only one.
h) The poet calls his enemy “the murderous cowardly pack” what does that mean?
A pack is a group of dogs or wolves hunting together. He compares the oppressors as a cowardly
pack because the Whites were hunting Africans in notorious mobs and not individually. This
shows that they were coward as well.
THEMATIC ANALYSIS.
SACRIFICE
In the fight against oppression, sacrifice is a valuable commodity. Few People need to sacrifice
their lives so that the majority may live in peace. In this poem the poet (McKay) calls for actions
against the enemy (foe). However, he shows that the struggle may mean death. But if they must
die, it is better to die fighting so that they may be honored later than dying while doing nothing.
He says
If we must die, o let us nobly die
So that our precious blood may not be shed
In vain! …
HUMILIATION/TORTURE/OPPRESSION
36
The poet and his fellow kinsmen go through a series of torture and mistreatment from their
enemy. They are arrested with no reason, jailed and killed like pigs. This is a situation which
affected most African American in the time of racial injustice in America and when “Jim Crow
laws” were in effect. The poet shows the experience they are going through by saying;
If we must die, let it not be like hogs
Hunted and penned in an inglorious spot.
While round us bark the mad and angry dogs
MOTALITY (DEATH)
Due to this politically charged situation death at least seems the best thing to help a person sort
out what is important in life. The speaker speaks about death in a more practical sense - he is
actually facing it. It is not the question of whether he will die or what will happen when he dies it
is about how he will meet death. To him death is an opportunity to show strength, nobility and
purpose.
If we must die, o let us nobly die
So that our precious blood may not be shed
In vain; then the monsters we defy
Shall be constrained to honor us though dead.
37