Workup for Failed Back Syndrome
• Orthopeadic Chief Resident at Thomas
Jefferson University Hospital and the
Rothman Institute
• Administrative and Academic Chief
Resident 2010-2011
• Interest:
• Spine Surgery
• Medical Illustrations
• Medical education
• Medical Leadership – Emergent Leader Physician
Chadi Tannoury, MD • Enjoys Arts, Music, Martial Arts, Travel,
Social Networking
• Contact: chadi.tannoury@gmail.com
Failed Back Surgery Syndrome:
The Workup
Chadi Tannoury, M.D.
Thomas Jefferson University Hospital
& The Rothman Institute
S.P.I.N.E. Meeting – Lebanon June 2010
Disclosure
*Disclosure of Financial Interest
The author have not received nothing of value from or does not own stock (or stock
options) in a commercial company or institution related directly or indirectly to the subject
of this topic.
!!Failed Surgery!!
Patient: Surgeon:
Anxiety Anxiety
Repeat Surgery Hit to the Ego
Pain Revision Sx
Debilitation Technical diff
Poor Outcome Grief !!!!
Failure… what failure?
FBSS:
Unresolved symptoms
New Symptoms
What caused the “Perfect”
surgery to Fail?
Bad Patient selection
Incorrect Diagnosis
Inappropriate surgery
Technical errors
Nonunion of the fusion
Imbalance
Missed pathology
Arachnoiditis
Progression of disease
Poor Pt Selection
Intrinsic Pathological x
MMPI: Psych disturb
Hysteria, hypochodriasis
Depression, Anxiety
Workman’s compensat’
Non-compliance
Incorrect/Incomplete Diagnosis
Failure to address:
Foramin/lat recess
stenosis
Unnecess Rx: Asymp
Radiog findings
Misdiagnosis: conj NR
– Far lat HNP
Wrong Surgical Procedure
Wrong Level
Poor Technique:
Battered NR syndrome
Iatrogenic Instability
Inappropriate hardware
placement
Progressive Disease
Recurrent Sx:
Ongoing DDD
Recurrent HNP (5-15%)
Scar formation – NR
tethering
Adjacent DD (35%)
Workup
Careful Thorough Evaluation
Results of Revision Surgery:
Poorer than index surgery
Etiologies:
R/o Non-spinal causes
Psychological Sources
Spinal workup
History
Symptoms relation to index surgery
Review of Med Records / OR Reports /
Imagings:
Wrong level surgery vs. Incorrect initial diagnosis
ROS – Social hx:
Identify co-morbidities: Somatizat’ – Addictions –
Depression – Personality disorders
Constitutional Sx: Malig vs. Infections
Physical Examination
Non-Organic Physical Findings (Waddell signs):
Superficial or non-anatomic distribution of symptoms
Over-reaction to stimuli
Pain out of proportion – to non painful stimuli
• > 2 above Strongly predicts Poor Outcome
Waddell Spine 1980
Standard Tests: Posture, Gait, Tenderness, ROM, NR
tension signs, NeuroExam, Hips/knee
Imaging
Biplanar Standing Rad:
Site of Surgery
Balance
Progressive Degeneration
Flex/ext Rad (post Fusion):
Instability
Hardware Loosening/ subsidence
SI joints eval – Hip/Knee eval
ICBG site: r/o pelvic frx
Standing 36” Radiog
Imaging – Cont’d
MRI: w-w/out Gad
Enhancement (scar) vs.
Nonenhancement (recurr HNP)
Post op infection?!
Imaging Cont’d
CT Myelo: if MRI is contraindicated
Assess fusion vs. Pseudarthrosis
Hardware placement – Loosening
/Subsidence
Electrodiagnostic Studies
EMG, NCV
Rarely Indicated
Evaluate extra-spinal etiologies:
Peripheral neural compression
Peripheral Neuropathy
Laboratory Tests
ESR, CRP:
Nonspecific
Eval for Occult Infx in Pts w diffrt quality LBP
CRP returns to Nl in 14 days postop, ESR later
Good Indicators: response to treatment
Psychological Assessment
Psychological distress measurement:
MMPI: high scores Poor outcome
(Minnesota Multi-phasic Personality Inventory) Wiltse’75, Spengler’80
Pts w h/o Chronic pain: Referral to a
Psychologist/Psychiatrist can be helpful
Pts with Depression + Sleep disturbances:
should be treated before and after surgery
Diagnostic Blocks
Selective Nerve Root Blocks:
Help Confirm culprit level
~ Predict outcomes of surgery
Provocative diskography:
Controversial use
Help localize Adjacent segment disease
Diagnostic Facet Blocks:
Used to Identify painful transitional motion segments
Expectations
For some diagnosis:
Recurr HNP – Pseudarth – Adjacent SD
Revision Surgery GRATIFYING
Arachnoiditis – epid/perin Fibrosis Spinal cord
Stimulation SUCCESSFUL
Chronic Pain: Preop screening by a Psychologist
Help avoid additional Surg in pts high risk for
unfavorable outcomes!
Best Management = Prevention
Pre-surgical thorough Assessment:
Good Indications
PE: Red Flags (Waddell sings – Pain Behavior, etc..)
At Surgery: Correct Level
After decompression: adequate Foraminal decomp
After fusion: Inspect Hardware for misplacement
If Complications happen: Rx Promptly + Aggressively – Do
Not Delay!!!