[go: up one dir, main page]
Scribd
Upload
588 views2 pages

(Kindly Check If The Claim Is Plausible or Not) (Kindly Check If The Claim Is Plausible or Not)

The three versions of the Cavite Mutiny provide different perspectives on the events. The Spanish version claims it was a rebellion orchestrated by disgruntled native soldiers and laborers to overthrow Spanish rule. The Filipino version views it as a minor mutiny in response to harsh new policies, which was exaggerated by Spanish officials to justify cracking down on Filipino independence efforts. The governor's official report blamed native clergy for instigating the mutiny by promising victory and rewards, though the goals of establishing a monarchy or republic were unclear since Filipino had no direct translation for those terms.

Uploaded by

Risha Mhie Matila
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
588 views2 pages

(Kindly Check If The Claim Is Plausible or Not) (Kindly Check If The Claim Is Plausible or Not)

The three versions of the Cavite Mutiny provide different perspectives on the events. The Spanish version claims it was a rebellion orchestrated by disgruntled native soldiers and laborers to overthrow Spanish rule. The Filipino version views it as a minor mutiny in response to harsh new policies, which was exaggerated by Spanish officials to justify cracking down on Filipino independence efforts. The governor's official report blamed native clergy for instigating the mutiny by promising victory and rewards, though the goals of establishing a monarchy or republic were unclear since Filipino had no direct translation for those terms.

Uploaded by

Risha Mhie Matila
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 2

Subject being compared: The three versions of Cavite Mutiny

Reasons for comparison: To know the different sides of the story because each story has different
claims.
 

Spaniards’ Version of the Cavite Filipinos’ Version of the Cavite Official Report of Gov. Izquierdo
Mutiny Mutiny  on the Cavite Mutiny

In his report he blamed the native clergy,


scholars, and some residents of Manila
The Spansih version of the Cavity Mutiny and neighboring provinces as instigator of
was narrated by Jose Montero y Vidal he In the Filipino version as written by Cavite Mutiny. According to Gov.
states that on the 20th of January 1872 Trinidad H. Pardo de Tavera the mutiny is Izquierdo, Native clergy attracted
afateful event happens due to the a mere incident of mutiny orchestrated by supporters by giving them charismatic
concerted effort of disgruntled native native soldiers and laborers who reacted assurance that their fight would not fail
soldiers and laborers of Cavite arsenal to the harsh policy of the new governor because they had God`s support aside
who willfully revolted to overthrow the general Rafae de Izquierdo, who from promises of lofty reward such as
Spanish rule, and thus, guilty of rebellion terminated the old time privileges such as employment, wealth, ranks in the army.
and sedition. And by such acts, the exempting them from paying the annual
execution of prominent critics of the tribute and from rendering forced labor. It It has not been clearly determined if they
Spaniards and Friars by the Spanish is clear that the mutiny is blown-up by the planned to establish a monarchy or
officials are justified. Spanish officials and friars into a revolt as republic, because the indios have no word
a way for Filipinos to gain independence in their language to describe this form of
from Spanish monarchy. government. Whose head in the Filipino
would be called hari; but it turns out that
they would place at the head of the
(Kindly check if the claim is plausible government a priest, that the head selected
or not) would be D.Jose Burgos or D. Jacinto
Plausible _______         Not (Kindly check if the claim is plausible Zamora
Plausible____ or not)
Plausible _______         Not
Plausible____
(Kindly check if the claim is plausible
or not)
Plausible _______         Not
Plausible____

You might also like