Maxillary Denture Retention Guide
Maxillary Denture Retention Guide
free from http://www.eurjprosthodont.org on Thursday, January 08, 2015, IP: 123.63.187.178]  ||  Click here to download free Android application for this
journal
               ABSTRACT
               The location and preparation of the posterior palatal seal is frequently neglected procedure. This seal contributes
               significantly to the retention of a maxillary complete denture. Hundreds of dentures have failed due to the improper
               establishment of the distal limit and to an improper posterior palatal seal. Its location and preparation on the master
               cast are often done by the dentist or dental technician without reference to anatomical landmarks of the mouth. Various
               methods of achieving posterior palatal seal and reproducing it in the maxillary denture have been described in the
               literature. This article aims toward rationale and importance of posterior palatal seal, anatomical reference landmarks,
               functions, methods to record, and discusses various problems associated with recording posterior palatal seal.
KEYWORDS: Fovea palatinae, maxillary complete denture, peripheral seal, postdam, posterior palatal seal, retention
      junction of the hard and soft palates, which appears clinically            Sharry’s method (ask patient to say ‘‘ah’’ with short vigorous
      immobile during phonation. This is its orthodox position.[3]               bursts).[12] Posterior vibrating line is an imaginary line at the
                                                                                 junction of the aponeurosis of the tensor veli palatini muscle
      Anatomical Considerations for Posterior                                    and the muscular portion of the soft palate. It is elicited by
      Palatal Seal                                                               asking the patient to say ‘‘ah’’ in short bursts in a normal,
                                                                                 unexaggerated fashion posterior vibrating line marks the
      Posterior palatal seal consist of two components,                          most distal extension of denture base. Fovea palatine is a
      namely, pterygomaxillary seal area and postpalatal seal.                   clinically visible indentation in the mucosa of the midline of
      Pterygomaxillary seal extends through pterygomaxillary                     the palate formed by the coalescence of several mucous gland
      notch continuing 3-4 mm anterolaterally, approximating                     ducts, which is unique to humans. There is lot of difference
      the mucogingival junction.[4,5] It occupies entire width                   of opinion on the location of fovea palatini and anterior
      of hamular notch (loose connective tissue lying between                    vibrating line. According to Sicher, fovea palatine is located
      pterygoid hamulus of the sphenoid bone and distal                          just posterior to location of hard and soft palates. According
      portion of maxillary tuberosity). The notch is covered                     to Swenson, vibrating line is 2 mm in front of fovea palatine.
      by pterygomaxillary fold (extend from posterior aspect                     Silverman[12] concluded that posterior palatal seal can be
      of tuberosity to retromaolar pad). This fold influences                    extended 8.2 mm distal to vibrating line for retention and
      the posterior border seal if mouth is wide open during                     stability. In a study by Lye,[13] the mean position of vibrating
      final impression procedure.[6,7] The pterygomandibular                     line is 1.31 mm behind fovea, but posterior limit of denture
      ligament extends from the hamular process to the lingula                   can be extended an additional of 2 mm before soft tissue
      of the mandible. Pendleton’s[8] anatomical dissections and                 movement is sufficient to break the seal.
      histological and clinical examination have shown this area
      to vary greatly in size, form, and character. Marks[9] has                 Rationale and Importance of Posterior
      shown the tissue in this area to be variable in character.                 Palatal Seal
      The tensor palati muscle wraps around the hamular process
      and attaches to the posterior nasal spine to form the palatal              •   Often it is possible to obtain acceptable stability and
      aponeurosis [Figure 1].[10] Postpalatal seal is the area                       retention by a perfectly adapted denture base through
      between the anterior and posterior vibrating line found                        the forces of adhesion, cohesion, and interfacial surface
      medially from one tuberosity to other. It appears to be as                     tension[5]
      a cupids bow. Anterior vibrating line demarcates zone of                   •   This border seal is made possible by developing the
      transition between no movement of the tissue overlying hard                    proper width and the extension of the denture borders,
      palate and some movement of the tissues of soft palate. It                     so that they fill the spaces and make a seal against the
      serves as anterior border of posterior palatal seal. It extends                cheeks[5]
      laterally into pterygomaxillary notch. It is not a straight line           •   Posterior palatal seal will create a partial vacuum that
      due to presence of posterior nasal spine. It always occurs                     will not operate continuously, but one that will come
      in soft palate.[11] According to Sear, it is not the junction of               into play only when horizontal or tipping thrusts tend
      hard and soft palates. According to Gerald S. Wintraub, it is                  to dislodge the denture and then only long enough to
      usually located in the junction of hard and soft palates.[7] It                overcome the emergency[5]
      can be recorded by Valsalva maneuver (ask patient to blow                  •   This partial vacuum is unlikely to operate long enough
      gently through nose with nostrils closed using finger) or by                   to do any damage to the supporting or border tissues[5]
                                                                                 •   The retention of complete denture may be accomplished
                                                                                     more accurately and safely with a good appraisal of the
                                                                                     biological factors.[5]
      Size
      Hardy and Kapoor[5] claimed that on an average, the dimension
      of posterior palatal seal was 2 mm at the midpalatal region
      and hamular notch and 4 mm at the greatest curvature region
      of posterior palatal seal. But wide range of variation was also
      found. Silverman performed a study evaluating the posterior
      palatal seal clinically, radiographically, and histologically,
      and he found that the greatest mean anteroposterior width of
      posterior palatal seal is 8.0 mm (with 5-12 mm of range).[11]
                                                                                 Figure 2: Different forms of posterior palatal seal used in various dental
                                                                                 schools of United States
      Shape
      Winland and Young performed a survey to evaluate the forms
      of posterior palatal seal used in various schools of United                Displacement/compressibility
      States. They found that five different forms of posterior                  Lot of variation has been found within the posterior palatal
      palatal seal were commonly used[13] [Figure 2]:                            seal area. But low compressibility has been observed
      • Single bead scribed on the posterior vibrating line                      in midpalatal raphe and hamular notch region. High
      • Double line scribed in the anterior and posterior                        compressibility has been in the lateral part of cupids bow. Its
          vibrating line                                                         variation depends on the form of palatal vault like in class I
      • Butterfly shaped posterior palatal seal                                  palate posterior palatal seal area remains shallow, while it is
      • Butterfly shaped posterior palatal seal with notching of                 deep in class III palate.
          posterior vibrating line
      • Butterfly shaped posterior palatal seal with notching of                 Classification of soft palate
          hamular notch                                                          Before recording the posterior palatal seal, it is very
      • Variations used with different shaped soft palate based                  important to classify the type of soft palate the patient has. It
          on the classification.                                                 determines precautions needed to be taken for specific type
          Class 1: A butterfly shaped posterior palatal seal with                of soft palate. While classifying soft palate, the head position
                    3-4 mm wide                                                  should be in upright position. Palatal throat form as given by
          Class 2: Posterior palatal seal is narrow with 2-3 mm of               House[14] [Figure 3]:
                    width                                                        Class 1: Large and normal in form, with a relatively
          Class 3: A single beading made on the posterior                                  immovable band of resilient tissue 5-12 mm distal
                    vibrating line.                                                        to a line drawn across distal edge of the tuberosities
                                                                                 Class 2: Medium size and normal in form, with relatively
      Location                                                                             immovable resilient band of tissue 3-5 mm distal to
      Location of posterior palatal seal is not consistent and show                        a line drawn across the distal edge of the tuberosities
      lot of variation but on an average anterior vibrating line is              Class 3: Usually accompanies a small maxilla. The curtain
      1.31 mm distal to fovea palatini.[12]                                                of soft tissues turns down abruptly 3-5 mm anterior
                 to a line drawn across the palate at the distal edge                    and make sure denture does not cover them. T-burnisher is
                 of the tuberosities.                                                    passed along posterior angle of maxillary tuberosity until it
                                                                                         drops into pterygomaxillary notch. [Figure 4a] Extend the
      Methods of Recording Posterior Palatal                                             mark from pterygomaxillary notch 3-4 mm anterolateral
      Seal                                                                               to maxillary tuberosity approximating mucogingival
                                                                                         junction.[13] This completes marking of pterygomaxillary
      Different methods can be used for recording posterior palatal                      seal. Ask patient to say “ah” in short bursts, in unexaggerated
      seal and at different stages of complete denture construction.[13]                 fashion. Observe movement of soft palate and mark posterior
      Choice of method employed and timing depends on operator                           vibrating line, and then connect it to pterygomaxillary seal.
      preference and experience. Hardy and Kapoor[5] classified                          Advice patient, not to close mouth (to prevent smudging of
      them in to functional, semifunctional, and empirical                               markings). The resin/shellac tray is then inserted into the
      technique. Different methods of recording can be broadly                           mouth and seated firmly into tray and transfer markings
      divided in to conventional approach, functional technique,                         on master cast by placing it into cast. Later trim excess
      extended palatal technique, and arbitrary technique.[13]                           found on tray. Mark anterior vibrating line using either
                                                                                         by T-burnisher (by checking the compressibility in width
      Conventional approach (Winkler technique)                                          and depth)-usually termination of glandular tissue usually
      Ask patient to have astringent mouthwash (to remove                                coincides with anterior vibrating line or Valsalva maneuver.
      stringy saliva) and keep his head upright. Dry the posterior                       Place special tray in the mouth and get the markings on tray
      palatal area with gauge and palpate for hamular process                            which is later transferred to master cast [Figures 4b and c].
      using T-burnisher/mouth mirror. Mark them with indelible
      pencil (Dr. Thompson’s sanitary color transfer applicator)                         Master cast is scored using a Kinsley scraper. Deepest area
                                                                                         of seal is located on either side of midline (1/3rd distance
                                                                                         from posterior vibrating line). It is scrapped approximately
                                                                                         0.5-1.0 mm (due to limited compressibility) within out line
                                                                                         of cupids bow. Scrape cast to a depth of about ½ the amount
                                                                                         to which the palatal tissue in that area can be compressed.
                            a                                     b                                    c
      Figure 4: (a) Locating pterygomaxillary notch with T-burnisher, (b) Area of compressibility in posterior palatal seal, and (c) Marked posterior vibrating line
      ZOE/impression plaster (not with elastomeric impression                    Ultrasonic effects are nonionizing (do not have sufficient
      material as they are resilient, nonadherent to wax, and                    energy to displace electrons from orbital shell. High-energy
      distort wax when reseated into oral cavity). Impression                    ultrasound can cause burning of tissue (not commonly seen
      waxes used are (1) IOWA wax (white) - Dr. Earl S. Smith,                   with range of medical use). It is indicated in patients with
      (2) Korecta wax no. 4 (orange) Dr. O. C. Applegate,                        only class I, II type of palates, as type III palate prevents
      (3) K.l physiologic paste (yellow-white) - Dr. C.S. Howkins,               complete adaptation of transducer and it is contraindication
      (4) Adaptol (green) - Dr. Nathen G. Kyne. These waxes have                 in patients with neuromuscular impairments and
      specific characteristics like low-melting point to permit their            pronounced gag reflex. Miniature transducer (10 MHz
      use intraorally without discomfort or trauma, high flow rate               linear array) is used along with a real-time B-mode to
      at mouth temperature (98.6°F), low distortion and rigidity at              view image of soft tissue. Mark posterior palatal seal using
      room temperature, smooth and nongranular texture, allows                   conventional method. Place a thin rubber band on anterior
      addition of several layers without demarcation, and these                  1/3rd of transducer, which serves as an index that would
      waxes can harden readily when chilled.[2,13]                               appear in monitor. Toothpaste is used as a line couplant.
                                                                                 The transducer is taken intro oral cavity and initially
      The melted wax is painted into the impression surface (within              moved posteriorly to the left of midline to locate hard and
      the outline of the seal area). The impression is carried to the            soft palates junction. Once the rubber band is visualized
      mouth and held in place under gentle pressure for 4-6 min                  on postvibrating line, there was no display and a Polaroid
      and allow time for the material to flow. Take care for head                picture was made. Then it was moved to right side of
      position (30° to FH plane). After 4 min remove impression                  palate. The average distance of posterior vibrating from
      tray and trim excess (or) if no tissue contact is established              junction of hard and soft palate is 2-9 mm with 4-6 mm
      then add and redo the procedure.                                           wide posterior palatal seal.[15]
      Advantages of this technique include (1) physiologic                       Troubleshooting in Posterior Palatal Seal
      technique displacing tissues, (2) no over compression of                   and Clinical Implication
      tissues, (2) posterior palatal seal incorporated into trial denture
      base for added retention, and (3) no mechanical scrapping                  The most common problem associated with lack of retention
      of cast is required. But, this technique is time consuming,                of the maxillary complete denture is a faulty posterior
      cumbersome, and has difficulty in handling material and                    palatal seal.[16] A careful examination of the patient’s tissues
      additional care to be taken during boxing procedure.                       and extensions of the existing denture helps to delineate the
                                                                                 anatomical boundaries of the posterior palatal seal area, so
      Extended palatal technique (Silverman)                                     that an adequate seal can be established.
      Maxillary posterior denture border was extended on an
      average of 8.2 mm distal to the anterior vibrating line. Black             Underextention
      compound added 8-12 mm distal to the anterior vibrating line.              It is the most common cause of seal failure. It mainly occurs
      The convexities that form the distal out line of the seal areas            due to use of fovea palatine as a guideline for marking
      are formed by the depression between the tensor veli palatini              anterior and posterior vibrating line. By doing so, 4-12 mm
      and palatoglossus muscle. This technique is advantageous                   of tissue coverage loss occur leading to decreased retention.
      and most effective with class I soft palate, small, mobile, and            Tissues covering hard palate are firmly attached and the main
      displaceable residual ridges, with narrow and high-vaulted                 retention is by adhesion and cohesion, which is least during
      maxillary arches. This provides maximum tissue coverage                    function. In case of gaggers who cannot tolerate denture
      with minimum tongue irritation and pressure on residual                    base far behind in palate, they insist on reduction of denture
      ridges. Many patients may not tolerate extended trays and                  base and dentists unsure of his technique complies patients’
      produce gag reflex and pain during sneezing or coughing. It                request leading with decreased retention.[17] Other related
      is difficult to execute with various palatal forms.[12]                    causes are improper recognition of anterior and posterior
                                                                                 vibrating line, injudicious trimming of denture border by
      Arbitrary scraping                                                         technicians.
      According to Winkler, arbitrarily mark the anterior and
      posterior vibrating line and scrape about 1-1.5 mm. It is the              Overextention
      least accurate methods used to mark the posterior palatal                  It mainly occurs due to overzealous extension of denture
      seal. Its high potential for over postdamming is due to its                base for increased retention by dentist cause physiological
      nature of unphysiologic technique of recording.[11]                        violation of soft palate musculature. It mainly shows with
                                                                                 symptoms of mucosal ulcerations, painful swallowing,
      Ultrasonic technique of recording posterior palatal                        physiological violation of soft palate muscle, sharp pain
      seal given by Rajeev MN et al.                                             if pterygoid hamulus is covered. It can be managed by
      For medical applications 1-20 MHz are used and for                         selectively relieving the pressure areas and decrease the
      nondiagnostic medical application <1 MHz is used.                          distal length.[17,18]
      5.     Hardy IR, Kapoor KK. Posterior border seal-its rationale and               18. Pasam N, Hallikerimath RB, Arora A, Gilra S. Effect of different
             importance. J Prosthet Dent 1958;8:386-97.                                     curing temperatures on the distortion at the posterior peripheral
      6.     Anthony DH, Peyton FA. Dimensional accuracy of various                         seal: An in vitro study. Indian J Dent Res 2012;23:301-4.
             denture base materials. J Prosthet Dent 1962;12:67.                        19. Moghadam BK, Scandrett FR. A technique for adding the
      7.     Weintraub GS. Establishing the posterior palatal seal during                   posterior palatal seal. J Prosthet Dent 1974;32:443-7.
             the final impression procedure: A functional approach. J Am                20. Carrol EA, Shaffer FW. Redefining the posterior palatal seal
             Dent Assoc 1977;94:505-10.                                                     on a complete denture. J Prosthet Dent 1980;43:105-7.
      8.     Pendleton EC. Influence of biological factors in retention of              21. Ansari IH. A procedure for adding posterior palatal seal to an
             artificial dentures. J Am Dent Assoc 1936;23:1233-51.                          existing denture in dental office. J Prosthet Dent 1994;72:449.
      9.     Marks BI. The microanatomy of the human edentulous                         22. Sato Y. Immediate maxillary denture base extension.
             maxilla. Aust Dent J 1978;23:69-74.                                            J Prosthet Dent 2000;83:371-3.
      10.    Boucher CO, Hickey JC, Zarb GA. Prosthodontic treatment                    23. Kim Y, Michalakis KX, Hirayama H. Effect of relining method
             for edentulous patients. 7th ed. St. Louis: The CV Mosby                       on dimensional accuracy of posterior palatal seal. An in vitro
             Company; 1975. p. 118-20.                                                      study. J Prosthodont 2008;17:211-8.
      11.    Winkler S. Essentials of complete denture prosthodontics.                  24. Nimmo A. Correction of the posterior palatal seal by using
             Philadelphia, London, Toronto: WB Saunders; 1979. p. 171-92.                   a visible light-cured resin: A clinical Report. J Prosthet Dent
      12.    Silverman SI. Dimensions and displacement patterns of the                      1988;59:529-530.
             posterior palatal seal. J Prosthet Dent 1971;25:470-88.                    25. Lyan HE. Adding posterior palatal seal to a metal base
      13.    Lye TL. The significance of the fovea palatini in complete                     prosthesis. Int J Prosthodont 1989;2:283-4.
             denture prosthodontics. J Prosthet Dent 1975;33:504.                       26. Wu AY, Donovan TE. Engaging the physiological posterior
      14.    House MM. The relationship of oral examination to dental                       palatal seal with the framework of a maxillary complete
             diagnosis. J Prosthet Dent 1958;8:208-19.                                      overdenture. J Prosthet Dent 2009;101:214-5.
      15.    Rajeev MN, Applelboum BM. An investigation of the anatomic
             position of the posterior seal by ultrasound. J Prosthet Dent
             1989;61:331-6.
      16.    Ellis RW. Mucus retention cyst: A case report. Dental Update                How to cite this article: Goyal S, Goyal MK, Balkrishanan D,
             1995;22:421-2.                                                              Hegde V, Narayana AI. The posterior palatal seal: Its rationale
      17.    Lauciello FR, Conti SP. A method of correcting the posterior                and importance: An overview. Eur J Prosthodont 2014;2:41-7.
             palatal seal area of a maxillary complete denture. J Prosthet
                                                                                         Source of Support: Nil, Conflict of Interest: None declared.
             Dent 1979;42:690-2.
           The journal issue has a unique new feature for reaching to the journal’s website without typing a single letter. Each article on its first page has
           a “Quick Response Code”. Using any mobile or other hand-held device with camera and GPRS/other internet source, one can reach to the full
           text of that particular article on the journal’s website. Start a QR-code reading software (see list of free applications from http://tinyurl.com/
           yzlh2tc) and point the camera to the QR-code printed in the journal. It will automatically take you to the HTML full text of that article. One can
           also use a desktop or laptop with web camera for similar functionality. See http://tinyurl.com/2bw7fn3 or http://tinyurl.com/3ysr3me for the free
           applications.