Case 4 Colgate - Palmolive Makes A Total Effort
Case 4 Colgate - Palmolive Makes A Total Effort
Case 4 Colgate - Palmolive Makes A Total Effort
In the mid- 1990s, Colgate- Palmolive developed a new tooth-paste for the U. S. market, Colgate Total,
with an antibacterial ingredient that was already being successfully sold overseas. However, the word
antibacterial was not allowed for such products by the Food and Drug Administration rules. So Colgate-
Palmolive had to come up with another way of marketing this and other features of their new toothpaste
to U. S. consumers. Market researchers told Colgate- Palmolive that consumers were weary of trying to
discern among the different advantages of various toothpaste brands and wanted simplification in their
shopping lives. In response, the name “Total” was given to the product in the United States: The one word
would convey that the toothpaste is the “total” package of various benefits.
Young & Rubicam developed several commercials illustrating Total’s benefits and tested the commercials
with focus groups. One commercial touting Total’s long- lasting benefits was particularly successful.
Meanwhile, in 1997, Colgate- Palmolive received FDA approval for Total, five years after the company had
applied for it. The product was launched in the United States in January of 1998 using commercials that
were designed from the more successful ideas of the focus group tests. Total was introduced with a $100
million advertising campaign. Ten months later, 21% of all United States households had purchased Total
for the first time. During this same time period, 43% of those who initially tried Total purchased it again. A
year after its release, Total was the number one toothpaste in the United States. Total is advertised as not
just a toothpaste but as a protective shield that protects you for a full range of oral health problems for up
to 12 hours. Total is now offered in a variety of forms, including Colgate Total Enamel Strength, Colgate
Total Advanced Whitening, Colgate Total Advanced Clean, Colgate Total Advanced Fresh, Colgate Total
Clean Mint, Colgate Total Whitening, and Colgate Total Mint Stripe. In the United States, market share for
Colgate Total toothpaste was 16.2% in the second quarter of 2008, which was its highest quarterly share
ever.
1. What probabilities are given in this case? Use these probabilities and the probability laws to determine
what percentage of U. S. households purchased Total at least twice in the first 10 months of its release.
Answer:
Two probabilities are given in this case. The first is the marginal probability or the probability that a U.S.
household had purchased Total for the first time; and
P (A) = 21% or 0.21. ; Where A represents household that had purchased Total for the first time
The second is the conditional probability or the probability that a household purchased Total (for a second
time) given that it had purchased it before:
P (B/A) = 43% or 0.43; Where B represents household that purchased Total (for a second time) given that it
had purchased it before
The percentage of U.S. household that purchased Total at least twice can be computed using multiplication
rule:
2. Is age category independent of willingness to try new products? According to the U. S. Census Bureau,
approximately 20% of all Americans are in the 45- 64 age category. Suppose 24% of the consumers who
purchased Total for the first time during the initial 10- month period were in the 45– 64 age category. Use
this information to determine whether age is independent of the initial purchase of Total during the
introductory time period. Explain your answer.
Answer:
Event C equals the probability that someone is in the 45-64 age category. Or, P(C) = 20% or 0.2.
Event D equals the probability that someone is in the 45-64 age category given their willingness to try
Total. Or P (D) = 24% or 0.24
To determine if age is independent of the of the initial purchase of Total during the introductory time
period, then the marginal probability of 45-54 age category should equal the conditional probability that
someone is in that age category given that they are willing to try Total. However, when we look at the P (A)
and P (D), the values are different which means that they are not independent.
3. Using the probabilities given in Question 2, calculate the probability that a randomly selected U. S.
consumer is either in the 45– 64 age category or purchased Total during the initial 10- month period. What
is the probability that a randomly selected person purchased Total in the first 10 months given that the
person is in the 45– 64 age category?
Answer:
4. Suppose 32% of all toothpaste consumers in the United States saw the Total commercials. Of those who
saw the commercials, 40% purchased Total at least once in the first 10 months of its introduction. Of those
who did not see the commercials, 12.06% purchased Total at least once in the first 10 months of its
introduction. Suppose a toothpaste consumer is randomly selected and it is learned that they purchased
Total during the first 10 months of its introduction. Revise the probability that this person saw the Total
commercials and the probability that the person did not see the Total commercials.
Answer: