Answers Segfgjkllm v1
Answers Segfgjkllm v1
Cancer
Guest Expert:
Thomas Rutherford, MD
Associate Professor of Gynecologic
Oncology
www.wnpr.org
www.yalecancercenter.org
I am Bruce Barber and this is Yale Cancer Center Answers with Drs. Ed Chu and Ken
Miller. Dr. Chu is Deputy Director and Chief of Medical Oncology at Yale Caner Center
and an internationally known expert on colorectal cancer. Dr. Miller is a Medical
Oncologist and the Director of the Connecticut Challenge Survivorship Clinic. He also
specializes in pain and palliative care. If you like to submit a question about cancer,
please e-mail us at canceranswers@yale.edu or call 1-888-234-4YCC. If you would like
to hear past editions of Yale Cancer Center Answers, each segment is posted on the Yale
Cancer Center website at yalecancercenter.org. This evening, Dr. Chu and Dr. Miller
will be talking about ovarian cancer with Dr. Thomas Rutherford who is Associate
Professor of Obstetrics and Gynecology at the Yale School of Medicine and Head of the
Section of Gynecologic Oncology.
Miller Thomas, let's start out the program by talking about what ovarian cancer is.
Rutherford Ovarian cancer is a tumor of the ovary. The layer of the ovary that it comes from
depends upon what point the patient is in their life. Early in life, the patient would
have what is called a germ cell tumor. Germ cell tumors are usually seen up to
the age of 35. These tumors grow very fast and are very responsive to
chemotherapy. Back in the 1970s, women who had germ cell tumors would die
three to four months after diagnosis. Currently, once detected, with the new
chemotherapy the patient would undergo surgery and chemotherapy with cure
rates approaching 95%.
Miller Would this be a young girl, a teenager or someone in their early 20s?
Rutherford The earliest documented patient is 12. In general when we think about an ovarian
cancer we think about the Gilda Radner tumor. These are epithelial tumors and
are generally seen after the age of 45 with a peak incidence around 65. These
tumors, unfortunately, are diagnosed late and that is what makes it so deadly a
tumor. They are very difficult to diagnose early, but if they are diagnosed early
our cure rate approaches 95%. There is another tumor that is an epithelial tumor,
called a borderline ovarian tumor. It is still a cancer; however it is a surgically
treated tumor. It does not respond to chemotherapy as other epithelial tumors. It's
considered borderline because once you take it out that should take care of it.
Unfortunately, these can recur 10 to 15 years later in life.
Miller In your experience, because you treat women of all different ages, which of those
three are the most common and which are the least common?
Rutherford The least common are the germ cell tumors in the younger women. The most
common, unfortunately, are the epithelial tumors.
Chu Tom, where does ovarian cancer rank relative to other women’s tumors like breast
cancer, uterine cancer, or cervical cancer?
Chu What are some of the risk factors, especially for, as you said, the Gilda Radner
type of ovarian cancer?
Rutherford The bottom line is that we do not know. Family history definitely plays a
significant role. Instead of risk factors, we know that if you have multiple
children, if you are on birth control pills specifically for more than 5 years, if you
have a prophylactic oophorectomy or if you have a tubal ligation prior to the age
of 35, you can decrease the incidence of ovarian cancer.
Rutherford When someone ovulates they have proliferation of cells, and those cells are
ruptured and spread through the abdominal cavity during normal ovulation, birth
control pills would decrease that incidence of rupture so you have less spread and
less damage to repair. Tubal ligation has no effect at all on that. No one really
knows how it works but we do know that if someone has a higher propensity due
to family history, if we put her on the birth control pill and tubal ligation, it will
decrease her incidence, but we do not understand the mechanism.
Miller We have an e-mail from a woman in Stamford. She said, "I have had numerous
ovarian cysts over the years. Sometimes I have discomfort because of them and
this makes me nervous. Am I at a higher risk of developing ovarian cancer
because of these cysts?"
Miller Okay.
Chu There is an interesting relationship between breast cancer and ovarian cancer. Can
you elaborate for our listeners out there?
Chu Is there a genetic mutation that is common to both breast and ovarian cancer?
Rutherford The mutation that we know of today is the BRCA 1 and 2 gene. BRCA 2 seems to
have a higher incidence of ovarian cancers than tubal carcinomas.
Rutherford With our patients that have breast cancer we look at their family history. If the
history is significant, we would get genetic counseling. However, if you see that
family of tumors together, then definitely there is benefit to testing the entire
family.
Miller If we look at a woman who, for example, has a family history that includes a
mother that had breast cancer, or there were other types of these cancers in the
family, what kind of screening would be done for ovarian cancer as the woman
approaches middle age and beyond?
Rutherford Unfortunately, there is no standard of care for screening for ovarian cancer at the
current time. What we have done at Yale is come up with a serum blood test that
looks at six different markers for early detection for ovarian cancer. This is
currently going to a national trial to see the validity of the testing. What we have
recognized ourselves is that it does have some validity, not only in detecting early
stage tumors, but also in screening people for recurrent disease. The other thing
that people will do is use an ultrasound. Patients who currently have family risk
for ovarian cancer will follow-up with the CA-125 as well as ultrasounds. The
problem with this CA-125 test is 40% to 60% of patients with early stage ovarian
cancer have a normal CA-125. When the CA-125 is elevated, that tells us we
have advanced disease. The other problem with the CA-125 is that you can have
an elevation in that number due to fibroids, menstrual cycle, pregnancy or
endometriosis. Because of this it is a very poor screen for a cancer.
Miller In prostate cancer the PSA is a very good screening. There are some issues with
it, but you are saying that with ovarian cancer we are not there yet?
Miller That is unfortunate. Where do you predict things will go in terms of screening?
Do you see any major breakthroughs, for example, with your blood test?
Rutherford Yes, I think so. We are fortunate to be finding tumors early. Some of the patients
have been operated on and underwent prophylactic bilateral salpingo-
oophorectomies which found a very early tumor based upon screening and family
history.
Chu One thing to emphasize for our listeners out there is that the screen you have
talked about comes from laboratory efforts.
Rutherford Correct. It was developed predominantly through the efforts of Dr. Gilmore, and
currently the test can be obtained through LabCorp. We have an outreach
program so that blood can be drawn at a local office and sent to Yale for
evaluation.
Chu This is also part of your Discovery to Cure efforts, right? Can you elaborate a
little bit more and tell our listeners what that is all about and how they can support
this effort?
Rutherford The Discovery to Cure is looking for early detection methods. Out of that
program we developed this screening technology. The technology also looks at
people who have cancer and how we can treat them. There are a lot of research
efforts looking at once you have cancer. We obtain a piece of tumor at the time of
a surgery, we send it out for testing for specific chemotherapy, or more
importantly to find out what not to treat you with.
Miller In terms of treatment, if a woman is found to have, lets say, early stage ovarian
cancer, she goes to a doctor, they feel something on the ovary, how is treatment
then approached with those women?
Rutherford If you have a woman with a complex ovarian or adnexal mass, by complex we
mean it has either solid or cystic components together, normally the first thing we
do is obtain a pelvic ultrasound. We use an entity on the ultrasound called
Doppler flow. It measures blood flow to that ovary. If it looks like it has
tendencies towards being malignant, we would recommend that they undergo a
surgical exploration to look at that ovary. We would do either a conservative
management or a complete surgical staging based upon what we find. It also
depends upon her age. Somebody who is thinking about having children and has
an ovarian mass, this does not necessarily mean you lose your ability to have
fertility, so the patient needs to be evaluated. If an ovarian cancer is found early,
generally what needs to be done is to take out that ovary and/or the uterus and
Miller There are some women who undergo this surgery and really do not need anything
else.
Miller What are some of the criteria that you look for in women that you operate on that
would make you follow-up with chemotherapy or some other treatment?
Rutherford If the tumor is a well-differentiated tumor and totally encapsulated within the
ovary and is located on just one ovary, that woman would not need chemotherapy.
When you look at what the tumor looks like, if it is a poor histology, meaning it
looks like it has more chance for distant spread, those patients would need
chemotherapy. If you have an ovary that is stuck to other pelvic organs, stage II
disease, those patients will need chemotherapy.
Chu Is there ever any role for radiation therapy after surgery has been performed?
Rutherford Years ago radiation therapy was sort of the standard of care, mainly before
chemotherapy came along, but the answer is still yes. We do use some
chemotherapy. It depends upon if the disease is within the pelvis. If the entire
disease is in the pelvis, radiation will give us a relatively good cure rate; however,
the effects of radiation are permanent and can cause some damage or changes to
the bowel and bladder that never totally heal. With chemotherapy we do not have
those effects. It is really a judgment call based on where that tumor is located.
Miller We would like to remind you to e-mail your questions to us, and Dr. Thomas
Rutherford, to canceranswers@yale.edu. We are going to take a short break for a
medical minute. Please stay tuned to learn more about ovarian cancer with Dr.
Rutherford from the Yale Cancer Center.
Medical Minute
This year over 170,000 Americans will be diagnosed with lung cancer. More
than 85% of lung cancer diagnoses are related to smoking, and quitting, even
after decades of use, can significantly reduce your risk of developing lung cancer.
Each day, patients with lung cancer are surviving. Thanks to increased access to
advanced therapies, specialized care and new treatment options, lung cancer
survivors have new hope. Clinical trials are currently underway at federally
designated comprehensive cancer centers like the one at Yale, to test innovative
Miller Welcome back to Yale Cancer Center Answers. This is Dr. Ken Miller, and I am
here with my co-host, Dr. Ed Chu, and our guest Dr. Tom Rutherford, discussing
the latest treatment options for women with ovarian cancer. Tom, one of the
concepts that has come up in treating other cancers is using chemotherapy early
before surgery, is that being done with ovarian cancer, and what are some of your
observations about that approach?
Rutherford Actually what we call it is neoadjuvant chemotherapy. This was initiated here at
Yale under Dr. Peter Schwartz. When I first came here in 1993, I met a patient
with advanced ovarian cancer and Dr. Schwartz asked how I was going to treat
the patient. At that time it was standard care to take her to the OR but he said that
was wrong because it should be treated with chemotherapy. I looked at him and
said "Wow, okay." We treated her with chemotherapy and then took her to the
OR. This patient had marked reduction in tumor disease. She had a much easier
postoperative course and did not go to the intensive care unit. She stayed in the
hospital for maybe 3 days. She had a marked decrease in blood transfusions, 0
units versus 5-6 units. More importantly, what happens with neoadjuvant
chemotherapy, especially in ovarian cancer since they present with bloating and
fluid in the abdomen, is that all that resolves as the nutritional status is improved
and you are healed much quicker and better.
Miller Potentially, surgery is actually safer when you do operate. Are the outcomes
better?
Rutherford Currently there is a trial in Europe which is starting to show that there is benefit to
treating a patient with neoadjuvant chemotherapy. In the past we were taking the
worst of the worst patients and putting them on neoadjuvant chemotherapy.
Those patients did not do worse as compared to the other group; however, the
group where you started was much worse as a starting point. As time goes on and
the group gets larger in population so that more and more patients with stage 3
and 4 tumors are being treated upfront with chemotherapy, you will see patients
with survival improvement. We see that trend here at Yale.
Chu If a woman undergoes this neoadjuvant chemotherapy, then goes to surgery and
has a successful operation, will she then receive additional chemotherapy
afterwards?
Chu It is very similar to the disease that I know very well, colorectal cancer. In
patients who have an advanced liver disease, we give them chemotherapy, take
them to the OR, then if there is no evidence of disease usually there is nothing to
do, but we give them additional chemotherapy. This sounds very similar.
Chu If a woman has either early stage or a bit more advanced cancer, getting
chemotherapy after surgery is the usual recommendation for follow-up. How
often should they come back and be evaluated by you and your team?
Rutherford We follow-up with patients every three months with a physical exam and with the
CA-125 if it is a marker for them, and in 80% of the patients that blood test is a
marker. What we hope to do is obviously not find anything that has recurred;
however, many times we start seeing the CA-125 slightly increased and
somewhere between 3 to 6 months that number continues to rise. Most of the
time, the CA-125 will rise somewhere between 3 and 6 months before you see
any CT scan evidence of any lesions.
Miller We had an e-mail from Sarah who lives in Norwich. She says, "I am 56 years old
and I have been treated for ovarian cancer which recurred. What is new in terms
of new therapies for ovarian cancer, and are there any other vaccines or more
targeted therapies?"
Rutherford Targeted therapies are becoming the thing that everybody is trying to do. So the
answer to that is, yes, things are becoming much more targeted and we are
starting to understand the biology of the tumor. On recurrent patients, we have
the ability to take a piece of tumor, send it off and do chemo sensitivity testing.
Some of the testing that we are looking at is actually using the Fas/Fas ligand
system, look in to cap says three activity and tumor sensitivity.
Rutherford All cells are programmed to die and Fas/Fas ligand is a marker for cell death.
What we can do is treat the tumor with chemotherapy and see if that will become
activated. Within that system we have drugs that are trying to manipulate that
pathway such that if a tumor is resistant to cell death, called apoptosis, then we
can use that drug. Currently we are looking at a drug called phenoxodiol that will
Miller So does the chemotherapy cause it to grow, or does it just not prevent it?
Rutherford Very scary. Instead of doing what is good for the patient as we want too, we are
actually causing them problems because the gold standard for ovarian cancer is
carboplatin with Taxol. By treating a patient who is MyD88-positive, we may be
doing harm. We currently have a trial looking at that. The next question is what
to do with those patients who are MyD88. The story gets a little harder because it
has to do with immunotherapies and how to manipulate it. We are looking at a
CD-44 cell, which is part of the immunotherapies. We have some ideas about
how to go about reversing this; specifically, reversing what is called an
NF-kappaB inhibitor is one of the ways. We have another gentleman, Dr.
Alexander Santane, who will be joining us later this fall. He is bringing with him
Dendritic therapy. This is becoming a very specific immunotherapy towards
these tumor cells.
Chu One point to emphasize is that all of this work really comes from the laboratories
here at Yale within the GYN Oncology Group and is part of this whole Discovery
to Cure Program.
Rutherford Correct.
Rutherford Very unique. On our accreditation they were surprised at how many trials from
the laboratory to the patient bed care we have been able to do.
Chu As a cancer center, this is a high priority to be able to take innovative ideas from
the laboratory and bring them to the clinic, as you are doing, and then bring ideas
and observations from the clinic back to the laboratory. It really is a very cyclical
process.
Rutherford Correct. We have been lucky that we have been helped quite a bit by many
people.
Rutherford Phenoxodiol was actually started six or seven years ago. Early on we were
looking at estrogen receptors and ovarian cancer and what we found is that as the
tumor becomes metastatic, it loses one of the estrogen receptors called the beta.
We have compounds that are estrogen like, and phenoxodiol is an estrogen like
compound. We treated some cell cultures with this compound and the cultures
died. So, initially we thought that we had contaminated the cultures. However,
we repeated it many times and found that we could definitely take cells and kill,
or at least stabilize them, with the phenoxodiol. In that phase 1 trial, we
accumulated forty patients and within six months we found that 40% to 50% of
the patients had at least stable disease and one had regression of the tumor with
that drug alone. It acts as a biologic modifier. At the same time, in the
laboratory, we were using phenoxodiol with chemotherapy and found that we
needed one one thousandth the chemotherapy to affect the same response of cell
death with the phenoxodiol. Based on that data we did the phase 2 trial looking at
phenoxodiol with chemotherapy and the response rate was 56%, which is pretty
good when you look at recurrent disease, especially when somebody is down fifth
and sixth line, your normal responses is somewhere between 7% to 12%.
Chu If anyone wants to learn more, or gain access to your clinical trials, how can they
do so?
Miller They can also call the Yale Cancer Center. Tom, I want to thank you for joining
us and sharing some very interesting information about ovarian cancer. It was
new to me and hopefully to our listening audience. Thanks for joining us.
Chu Thanks for joining us. We look forward to hearing more about Discovery to Cure
from you and your colleagues in the future.
Until next week, this is Dr. Ed Chu and Dr. Ken Miller from the Yale Cancer
Center wishing you a safe and healthy week.