Volume2 No.2 Art2 - Alfonso PDF
Volume2 No.2 Art2 - Alfonso PDF
ABSTRACT
Governments ensure the welfare of the people, and this was the
concern of Jose P. Laurel when he was chosen by the Japanese to
lead the Second Philippine Republic. As president, Laurel was able
to protect a number of persons from captivity, execution, and
military conscription. He ordered the planting of food crops in
available lands and distributed food among the hungry masses.
Though branded as a "collaborator," his actions were vindicated
when the people's trust in him manifested through the 1949
senatorial elections, where he gained the highest number of votes.
This paper delves into how Laurel steered the Second Philippine
Republic to promote the interest of the Filipinos through his
policies. An examination of primary and secondary documents, in
light of the Stewardship Theory, was made to assess Laurel's
actions in securing the welfare of the people. Thus, a provided
analysis would present a meaningful narrative supplying the
historical methodology that links the situation of the country, the
measures employed by Laurel, and the consequences of these
responses.
INTRODUCTION
1 The author is a full-time instructor of history in the Institute of Arts and Sciences of Mabalacat
City College, Pampanga, Philippines. He finished his Master of Arts in History in the University of
Santo Tomas, Philippines, and is currently finishing his Doctorate in Philosohy, major in History
from the same University.
ALFONSO 28
and was one of the most perilous times in their history. The citizens experienced
firsthand what it was like to have their country transformed into a battlefield
between two industrial and military powers––an experience starkly different
from their previous colonizers. Thus, to be the president of the Philippines
during this time meant facing an extraordinary predicament in order to ensure
the nation's survival. A political scenario that Laurel faced head-on as the
President of the Second Republic, a topic that shall be the main focus of this
paper.
The Japanese forces were at the doorsteps of the Philippines as their advance
toward Manila was unstoppable, and its capture was inevitable. General
Douglas MacArthur, Commander of the United States Armed Forces in the Far
East or USAFFE, evacuated Manila and proclaimed it an open city to save it
from destruction. He then fortified Bataan and Corregidor to make it his last
line of defense against the Japanese invaders. Now, with the increasing risk of
capture, General MacArthur instructed Manuel L. Quezon to leave for
Corregidor. Reluctant at first, Quezon eventually heeded the General's advice
and left for Corregidor along with some of his cabinet members. Before
departing on December 24, 1941, Quezon instructed those who remained to
minimize civilian casualties and trust the Unites States.2 He initially asked
Laurel to go with him, but later changed his mind and decided that Laurel
should stay in Manila and deal with the Japanese.3
After the capture of Manila, the Japanese gathered all remaining officials to
facilitate the restoration of peace and order in the country. After a series of
meetings, the officials established the Executive Commission in response to the
Japanese' demands, which the latter approved. However, the Commission had
little to no leeway in actualizing its measures due to the constraints of the
ridiculous number of Japanese "advisors" who were, in truth, spies during the
Commission's meetings.4
As early as January 21, 1942, Japanese Premier Tojo Hideki started hinting
on the grant of independence to the Filipinos as long as there are evident signs
2 Teodoro A. Agoncillo, The Burden of Proof (Quezon City: University of the Philippines Press,
1984), 1, 10-13.
3 Jose P. Laurel, War Memoirs (Manila: Jose P. Laurel Memorial Foundation, 1962), 54.
4 Agoncillo, The Burden of Proof, 20-34.
Laurel expressed his political philosophy in several works such as the 1943
Constitution, his Inaugural Speeches, and the Forces that Make a Nation Great.
Here, he espoused that the Executive branch should be given a broader range of
powers to better work for the sake of the people, especially during times of war
and emergency. However, granting more authority to this branch meant
running a higher risk of exploitation and the abuse of power. Therefore, in order
to avoid corruption, Laurel argued that the Executive should exemplify and
practice the essential virtues of leadership.6
The Executive, being the steward, is therefore responsible for directing the
nation towards its goal of cultivating and securing public safety and welfare,
ensuring equitable growth among the citizenry. However, in order to achieve
this feat, a broad range of powers should be granted upon the authority for him
to function in practices and activities that were formerly out of governmental
affairs.8 This setup is valid due to the nature of the steward's capacity in
determining the best means of fulfilling given duties and instructions. With this,
the steward is therefore held accountable to his master for whatever decisions
he takes in following the latter’s orders.
Political Theory Of Republican Progressive Statesmanship And The Foundation Of The Modern
Presidency. Doctoral Dissertation, The Claremont Graduate School, 1997, retrieved January 18,
2013, from http://www.dtic.mil/cgi-bin/GetTRDoc?AD=ADA324102, 38
8 Robinson, The Stewardship, 6-7.
It was only in the formation of the Second Republic was the task of being the
"steward" of the people was officially conferred on Laurel by the Japanese.
Likewise, one must recall that President Manuel L. Quezon directed Laurel to
take care of national concerns and deal with the Japanese. For Quezon, Laurel
was a nationalist who could ensure the survival of the Republic. With the
welfare of the population in mind, Laurel would now set the direction of the
newly founded Republic and perform his duties as the Chief Executive of the
country.
9 Claro M. Recto, Letter to General Wachi in Mauro Garcia, Documents on the Japanese
Occupation of the Philippines, (Manila: The Philippine Historical Association, 1965), 109-124.
10 Claro M. Recto, Three Years of Enemy Occupation: The issue of political collaboration in the
Further, Article II, Section 10 stated that the President has the authority to
appoint the provincial governors, city and municipal mayors whose
appointments were not provided by law and who were also members of the
National Assembly by virtue of Article III, Section 2.15 With this provision, not
only could the President swiftly replace inefficient officials, but he could also
virtually influence the law-making body of the government. Because of the
nature of the situation, then, according to Laurel, a quasi-dictatorial Chief
Executive was needed to swiftly and decisively address the national crisis
engulfing the country.16
11 Jose P. Laurel, “Together We Shall Work,” in His Excellency Jose P. Laurel President of the
Second Philippine Republic: Speeches, Messages & Statements October 14, 1943, to December
19, 1944, (Manila: Lyceum of the Philippines, 1997).
12 Philippine Constitution of 1943, art. III, sec. 13.
13 Rose L. Avancena, Days of Courage: The Legacy of Dr. Jose P. Laurel, (Philippines, 1980),
124.
14 Philippine Constitution of 1943, art. III, sec. 14.
15 Philippine Constitution of 1943, art. II, sec. 10 & art. III, sec. 2.
16 Avancena, Days of Courage, 98.
with the demands of the situation ending with the normalization of conditions
in the country.17
Laurel’s inaugural address contained his vision of a republic that was suited
for the Filipinos, one that would transcend the Japanese occupation and would
still be ideal for the Philippines today. Before it looked to the future, it had to
deal with the immediate problems of its time, namely, the securing of peace and
order in the country and the procuring of basic necessities for the people. These
were the conditions that the Republic had to face, and working as a government
official during that time was not a sought-after vocation, but someone had to do
it.
LAUREL’S POLICIES
One of the first policies of Laurel right after the inauguration of the Republic
was to grant amnesty to Filipinos who had committed political crimes and
offenses. Through Proclamation No. 2, guerillas and those guilty of sedition and
17 Teodoro A. Agoncillo, The Fateful Years, Vol. 1 (Quezon City: R. P. Garcia Publishing Company,
1965), 380-383.
18 Laurel, “Together.”
illicit association could have freely received amnesty with nothing but an oath
in return. This amnesty could be availed within sixty days from the date of its
promulgation, from November 25, 1943, up to January 25, 1944. For those in
the Visayas, Mindanao, and Sulu areas, the amnesty period was to start on the
date when the respective authorities received copies of the proclamation. The
proclamation also included Filipinos who have already been captured and
detained, which granted their freedom back.19 In line with this proclamation was
Administrative Order No. 3, which created an Amnesty Board, the purpose of
which was to talk with guerilla units and encouraged them to avail of the
amnesty program of the government. The members of the Board included Gen.
Juan Cailles, Gen. Mateo Capinpin, and Gen. Jose de los Reyes, who acted as the
chairman.20 As the end of the Amnesty period approached, Laurel appealed to
the people––both public officials and private citizens––to consolidate their
efforts in making the campaign successful. Through Proclamation no. 11, Laurel
called on the people to exert energetic efforts from January 19 to 25 to foster
peace and order through the campaign. The Amnesty Week, however, was not
observed in the Visayas, Mindanao, and Sulu areas due to the incoherence
between the reception of the Amnesty program in the mentioned areas with the
promulgation date in Luzon.21 Since the reception of official order will take
considerable time in the areas as mentioned earlier, it was emphasized in the
statute that the Amnesty Week will not apply to those places in order to avoid
further confusion in regards to the dates involved during the campaign.
As early as the first quarter of 1944, the Allied Forces commenced their
campaigns in the Pacific arena of the war. Despite the much-anticipated
fulfillment of MacArthur’s promise of return, the Filipinos were still at risk by
the devastation of possible air raids by the Allies. Hence, in order to protect the
Filipinos and prepare them for the possibility of bombings, Laurel enacted
19 Proclamation no. 2, Official Gazette of the Philippines during the Japanese Occupation,
October 1943.
20 Administrative Order no. 3, Official Gazette of the Philippines during the Japanese
January 1944.
22 Avancena, Days of Courage, 186
Executive Order No. 36, which created a Civilian Protection Service that drew
plans and procedures to ensure the readiness of the people on occasions of air
raids and their possible consequences, and to coordinate all activities related to
such incidents.23
Even before the inauguration of the Republic, Laurel was already instructed
by the Japanese to declare war against the U.S. and Britain. In their trip to
Tokyo in September of 1943, he was asked by Premier Tojo himself to make the
declaration. Laurel, however, declined to this demand.24 By September 21, 1944,
the USAFFE started its air raids on Manila. Laurel knew that further
postponement of a declaration of war against the Allied Forces, which the
Japanese had wanted since the birth of the Republic, would be a mistake. Thus,
on September 22, 1944, Laurel issued Proclamation No. 30, Proclaiming the
Existence of a State of War in the Philippines. This proclamation of Laurel was
non-aggressive in the sense that it did not connote the Filipinos' waging of war
against the Allies, but merely confirmed the fact that hostile conditions were
present in the Philippines. Further, the proclamation had no provision for the
conscription of Filipinos into the Japanese Army. All Laurel asked from the
people was their loyalty and support to the government that they may secure
the survival of the Philippines.25
Laurel expressed his stand against the conscription of Filipinos even before
his Proclamation of a State of War. On September 13, 1944, he announced that
the Republic would not allow the conscription of Filipinos into the Japanese
army.26 In a letter to General Yuzuru Iimura, the Chief of Staff of the Imperial
Japanese Army in the Philippines, Laurel once again declared his stand against
the conscription of the Filipinos. He stated:
23 Executive Order no. 36, Official Gazette of the Philippines during the Japanese Occupation,
February 1944.
24 Agoncillo, The Burden of Proof, 55.
25 Avancena, Days of Courage, 141-142.
26 Avancena, Days of Courage, 138.
In another speech, the President reiterated his desire to prevent the enlisting
of the Filipinos and even remarked on how the behavior of the Japanese affected
the cooperation of the people. Laurel said (Laurel, 1944f):
28 Jose P. Laurel, “The Grim Spectres,” (Radio Speech delivered by remote control from
Malacañang over Station PIAM, Manila), in His Excellency.
This was later reinforced by Ordinance No. 2 that provided for the cultivation
of all available lands for the production of food crops. This ordinance
redistributed idle lands, including private lands, to the citizens––preferably to
those unemployed––especially when the landowner refused or is unable to
cultivate the land suitable for farming. The resulting crops were to belong to
those who cultivated the land after setting aside at most 10% for the
government. State farms were also established in appropriate places to be
maintained by the Bureau of Plant Industry and cultivated by the unemployed
members of the population. This policy was conceptualized so that the people
may use the land to grow short-term crops to address the problem of food
shortages, while, at the same time, relieving the problem of unemployment.32
29 Jose P. Laurel, “Their Salvation Lies in Their Own Hands,” (Remarks at a press conference in
Malacañang, Manila), in His Excellency.
30 Ordinance no. 1, Official Gazette of the Philippines during the Japanese Occupation,
November 1943.
31 Executive Order no. 49, Official Gazette of the Philippines during the Japanese Occupation,
April 1944.
32 Ordinance no. 2, Official Gazette of the Philippines during the Japanese Occupation,
November 1943.
entities that were in charge of them. Harvested crops from this endeavor were
to be given to hospitals, prisons, or similar public institutions for the use of its
internees. If they were sold instead, the proceeds were to be given to charity. If
the office or entity was unable to cultivate the land, they may allow private
persons to do so in their place, in which case the latter gains ownership of the
crops that they may harvest.33
Now, with the policy set in place, the President appealed to the people to
contribute to making the program a success. Through Proclamation No. 10,
Laurel reached out to the various civic and religious organizations to set aside
at least one day in their schedules for planting food crops. The President also
appealed to the educational institutions to formulate and conduct agricultural
activities––making sure that these would not compromise the students’
academic activities––to encourage and expose students to farming and arouse
their interests in the said activity.34 Moreover, through Executive Order No. 37,
the President ordered the recruitment of able-bodied Filipinos, aged 16-60 to
render emergency service for food production. If called upon, they would have
to render service for at most one day a week for 8 hours a day. Citizens who had
a stable and productive occupation could choose not to render the said service
by paying five pesos per day or by securing substitutes to work in their place.
Those who were not engaged in gainful occupation may be required to render
service for a longer period.35 Whether through forced or voluntary cooperation,
the people responded to Laurel’s call for food production such that the scenery
of Manila has changed.36
In addition to human labor, the security of animal labor was also provided by
Laurel through Ordinance No. 5, which prohibited the killing of carabaos. A
permit had to be secured if the carabao was to be slaughtered.37 Fruit-bearing
trees were also protected with the enactment of Ordinance No. 15 that
33 Administrative Order no. 9, Official Gazette of the Philippines during the Japanese
Occupation, December 1943.
34 Proclamation no. 10, Official Gazette of the Philippines during the Japanese Occupation,
January 1944.
35 Executive Order no. 37, Official Gazette of the Philippines during the Japanese Occupation,
February 1944.
36 Juan Labrador, O.P., A Diary of the Japanese Occupation December 7, 1941-May 7, 1945,
1944.
prohibited its logging in order to increase the food supply of the country.38 The
government deemed these factors as necessary for the food production
campaign.
Laurel designed his policies to cater to the needs of the people. He made use
of the instrumentations of the government to secure the welfare of the citizens.
Since he wanted to ensure that all Filipinos have sufficient means to procure
their necessities, the circumstances limited his options of utilizing whatever was
available. His policies were structured such that available resources were much
considered. Laurel's directives needed to be realistic concerning the situation-
at-hand, thus, limiting his orders to granting amnesties, cultivating available
lands, and the redistribution of excess rice to the needy members of the society.
Laurel approached the situation as best as he could––that, at the time, these
were arguably the best measures that one could have executed.
38Ordinance no. 15, Official Gazette of the Philippines during the Japanese Occupation, April
1944.
39 Executive Order no. 55, Official Gazette of the Philippines during the Japanese Occupation,
May 1944.
40 Pedro Sabido, “Report on the Progress of the Confiscation and Distribution of Rice,”
(Memorandum to Jose P. Laurel, October 21, 1944, Laurel War Documents from the Jose P. Laurel
Memorial Foundation, Series 3, Box 7).
As the trials pushed through, more and more people had come to realize the
motives of the actions of Laurel as the President of the Second Republic. As the
truths behind the actions of Laurel were exposed through the developments of
the trials, the comprehension of the people became apparent. They realized that
Laurel was not a traitor, as the anti-collaborators claimed. He was cushioning
the impacts of the Japanese Occupation and was steering the nation towards
41 Teofilo del Castillo & Jose del Castillo, The Saga of Jose P. Laurel, (Manila: Associated
better times. As time passed, the people’s concerns moved away from the trial
to the more pressing issue of reconstruction and rehabilitation. Amnesty,
therefore, has been a frequent mention in some of the newspapers from the sides
of both the pro-collaborators and the anti-collaborators.43
With the passing of time, much light has been shed on the collaboration issue
and the truth behind the actions of Laurel. Hamamoto Masakatsu, the Japanese
interpreter between the top officials of the Republic and the Japanese officials,
stated in his post-war interviews that there was no one among the high
government officials who were pro-Japanese.44 In terms of the aims of the
Japanese, Hamamoto said that their choice of Laurel as president was a mistake,
that they misinterpreted his qualities and thought that he would aid the
Japanese, when in fact, he did not.45
Laurel assumed the presidency of the Second Republic that he may become a
shield to protect the people and soften the shock of the Japanese Occupation. He
may not have fought directly against the Japanese like some of the guerillas, but
he struggled against the Japanese on a different battlefield. His was a battle of
trying to outwit the enemy’s policies on political warfare. In the words of former
senator Pedro Sabido:
43 De Viana, Kulaboretor!.
44 Hamamoto Masakatsu, quoted in Satoshi Nakano, Appeasement and Coercion, in The
Philippines under Japan: occupation policy and reaction, eds. Ikehata Setsuho and Ricardo T. Jose
(Quezon City: Ateneo de Manila University Press, 1999).
45 Hamamoto Masakatsu, quoted in Agoncillo, Burden of Proof, 1984, 70.
46 Remigio E. Agpalo, Jose P. Laurel: National Leader and Political Philosopher, (Manila: Jose P.
SUMMARY
It fell upon Laurel as president of the Second Philippine Republic to steer the
nation through turbulent waters towards its preservation. He did so by
brilliantly maneuvering the reins of authority vested in him by the Japanese,
who assumed that they could easily manipulate the leader.
Laurel structured the constitution and the government in such a way that it
would be helpful in his endeavor to minimalize casualties and uphold the welfare
of the people. With the centralization of the administration headed by the
executive, Laurel smoothened and hastened the manner of governmental
functions that were needed during the period of turmoil. He knew the demands
of the time and chose the type of government that could best respond to the
situation-at-hand while enabling the attainment of their goals. He removed
some aspects of the previous democratic set-up and installed a semi-dictatorial
government, one that can quickly act and react to the circumstances of the time.
Laurel, by way of his policies, sought to unify and direct the actions of the
nation for the sake of the people. He believed that during their period of crisis,
the only way the Filipinos could endure the hardships of war is by being united
in achieving the goal of national survival. Laurel called upon all people––young
and old, those in the mountains, and all of those who are capable––to work
together for the survival of the nation. Through his speeches and messages, he
47 Pedro Sabido, “Laurel, the friend, the patriot, the man,” in Memorial Series vol. 1 Dr. Jose P
Laurel: tributes, recollections, appraisals of close friends, associates, admirers, and the press,
(Manila: Jose P. Laurel Memorial Foundation, 1962), 94-96.
reminded the people of the value and importance of cooperation between the
people and the government. As the steward of the people, he knew his role as
the caretaker of the people. As their leader, he performed to the utmost of his
capabilities and tried to keep the people intact in actualizing the goals he has set
in the interest of the nation.
Thus, Laurel's actions have brought security to the majority of the people. In
response to the third question of the study, he managed to prevent the wide-
scale massacre of the Filipino people by the Japanese. Through his direction, he
guided the people toward the production of food crops and the redistribution of
rice. Undeniably, there were Filipinos who were victims of the brutalities of the
conquerors and the harshness of the circumstances. There were factors that
were beyond the control of the Republic. Nevertheless, Laurel and his
administration still managed to stave off the extinction of the bulk of the
Filipino nation. Through his guidance, the Republic's goal of national survival
has been attained.
REFEENCES:
Books
Agoncillo, Teodoro A. The Burden of Proof. Quezon City: University of the
Philippines Press, 1984.
__________________. The Fateful Years, Vol. 1. Quezon City: R. P. Garcia
Publishing Company, 1965.
Agpalo, Reigio E. Jose P. Laurel: National Leader and Political Philosopher.
Manila: Jose P. Laurel Memorial Corporation, 1992.
Avancena, Rose L. Days of Courage: The Legacy of Dr. Jose P. Laurel. Philippines,
1980.
De Viana, Augusto V. Kulaboretor!: The Issue Of Political Collaboration During
World War II. Manila: UST Publishing House, 2003.
Del Castillo, Teofilo & Jose del Castillo. The Saga of Jose P. Laurel. Manila:
Associated Authors, 1949.
Labrador, Juan, O.P. A Diary of the Japanese Occupation December 7, 1941 – May
7, 1945. Manila: University of Santo Tomas Press, 1989.
Laurel, Jose P. Letter to General Yuzuru Iimura. in His Excellency Jose P. Laurel
President of the Second Philippine Republic: Speeches, Messages & Statements
October 14, 1943 to December 19, 1944. Manila: Lyceum of the Philippines,
1997, 226-227.
___________. “The Grim Spectres.” Radio Speech delivered by remote control
from Malacañang over Station PIAM, Manila. In His Excellency Jose P. Laurel
President of the Second Philippine Republic: Speeches, Messages & Statements
October 14, 1943 to December 19, 1944. Manila: Lyceum of the Philippines,
1997.
___________. “Their Salvation Lies in Their Own Hands.” Remarks at a press
conference in Malacañang, Manila. In His Excellency Jose P. Laurel President
of the Second Philippine Republic: Speeches, Messages & Statements October 14,
1943 to December 19, 1944. Manila: Lyceum of the Philippines, 1997.
___________. “Together We Shall Work.” Inaugural Address delivered at the
Legislative Building, Manila. In His Excellency Jose P. Laurel President of the
Second Philippine Republic: Speeches, Messages & Statements October 14, 1943 to
December 19, 1944. Manila: Lyceum of the Philippines, 1997.
___________. War Memoirs. Manila: Jose P. Laurel Memorial Foundation, 1962.
Dissertation
Robinson, Randall L. The Stewardship Theory Of The Presidency: Theodore
Roosevelt’s Political Theory Of Republican Progressive Statesmanship And The
Foundation Of The Modern Presidency. Doctoral Dissertation, The Claremont
Graduate School, 1997. Retrieved January 18, 2013, from
http://www.dtic.mil/cgi-bin/GetTRDoc?AD=ADA324102
Official Documents
The 1943 Constitution of the Philippines.
The Official Gazette of the Philippines During the Japanese Occupation. Vol. 1,
(1-9), 1943.