Project-II - Mohit Jain - 073
Project-II - Mohit Jain - 073
Submitted to
Asian Business School, Noida
In partial fulfillment for the award of Full time
This is to certify that the project report titled MICRO & MACRO AND CAMEL
of the requirements for the award of the Post Graduate Diploma in Management, and is an
original work by Mohit Jain (ABS/PGDM/JULY18/073). The project has been done under
my supervision & guidance and the project has not formed the basis for the award of any
SIGNATURE SIGNATURE
Internal Examiner External Examiner
2
Annexure-III
DECLARATION
I hereby declare that the project report titled MICRO & MACRO AND CAMEL ANALYSIS
OF ICICI BANK is original piece of research work carried out by me under the guidance and
supervision of Mrs. Bushra. The information has been collected from genuine & authentic
sources. The work has been submitted in partial fulfillment of Post Graduate Diploma in
Mohit Jain
Date:
3
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
First of all, I wish to express my gratitude to the almighty for giving me the strength to
present the Research Project Report on MICRO & MACRO AND CAMEL ANALYSIS OF
ICICI BANK and complete the report within the stipulated time. Many lives & destinies are
destroyed due to the lack of proper guidance, directions & opportunities. It is in this respect I
feel that I am in much better condition today due to continuous process of motivation & focus
provided by my parents & teachers in general. The process of completion of this project was
a tedious job & requires care & support at all stages. I would like to highlight the role played
Business School for her whole-hearted supervision, valuable guidance and encouragement at
I would also like to thank my lecturers, faculty members and all those persons who have
directly or indirectly helped me in providing the books and amenities which have helped in
development of this report, without such help this report would not have been possible. I am
thankful to my parents, friends and all well-wishers for blessing me for my success.
MOHIT JAIN
Batch: 2018-2020
4
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
country. Thus, economic development of a country depends upon success of banking industry
and success of banking Industry is determined to a large extent by now well then needs of its
Shortage of employable talent is a challenge faced by the Indian IT industry. There is a rising
demand for capable IT professionals but, a scarcity of this talent pool. While the number of
engineers graduating each year has grown substantially, as per a NASSCOM Report, only
about 20% of them are employable. The need of the hour is to improve supply of productive
fresh professionals. To address this growing need, Nucleus School of Banking Technology
(NSBT) was launched in the year 2010-11, with a goal to provide World Class training.
NSBT offerings are targeted at developing professionals in the area of Banking Technology
NSBT education is about laying the foundation to build long and successful career which is
Lending Business
Borrowing business
Making use of analysis for effective execution using secondary data from different journals,
5
TABLES OF CONTENTS
1 Chapter-1 Introduction
6 Bibliography
7 Appendices
10
11
7
Chapter- 1
INTRODUCTION
1.1 INTRODUCTION
world, which made grain loans to farmers and traders who carried goods between cities. This
8
began around 2000 BC in Assyria and Babylonia. Later, in ancient Greece and during
the Roman Empire, lenders based in temples made loans and added two important
sense of the word, can be traced to medieval and early Renaissance Italy, to the rich cities in
The development of banking spread from northern Italy throughout the Holy Roman Empire,
and in the 15th and 16th century to northern Europe. This was followed by a number of
important innovations that took place in Amsterdam during the Dutch Republic in the 17th
century, and in London in the 18th century. During the 20th century, developments in
telecommunications and computing caused major changes to banks' operations and let banks
many bank failures, including some of the world's largest banks, and provoked much debate
about bank regulation.
The English traders that came to India in the 17th century could not make much use of the
indigenous bankers, owing to their ignorance of the language as well the inexperience
commercial pursuit, who resigned from civil and military, organized these agency houses.
9
A type of business organization recognizable as managing agency took form in a
period from 1834 to 1847.The primary concern of these agency houses was trade, but
they branched out into banking as aside line to facilitate the operations of their main business.
The English agency houses, that began to serve as bankers to the East India Company had no
capital of their own, and depended on deposits for their funds. They Financed movements
of crops, issued paper money and established joint stock banks. Earliest of these was
in India originated in the last decades of the 18th century. The first bank in India, though
10
conservative, was established in 1786 in Calcutta by the name of bank of Bengal. Indian
Banking in India originated in the last decades of the 18th century. The first bank in India,
though conservative, was established in 1786 in Calcutta by the name of bank of Bengal.
Indian banking system, over the years has gone through various phases. For ease of study
Banking in India originated in the last decades of the 18thcentury. The first banks were The
General Bank of India, which started in 1786, and the Bank of Hindustan, both of which are
now defunct. The oldest bank in existence in India is the State Bank of India, which
originated in the Bank of Calcutta in June 1806, which almost immediately became the Bank
of Bengal. This was one of the three presidency banks, the other two being the Bank of
Bombay and the Bank of Madras, all three of which were established under charters from the
British East India Company for many years the Presidency banks acted as quasi-central
banks, as did their successors. The East India Company established Bank of Bengal, Bank of
Bombay and Bank of Madras as independent units and called it Presidency Banks. The three
banks merged in 1925 to form the Imperial Bank of India, which, upon India's independence,
became the State Bank of India. Foreign banks too started to arrive, particularly in Calcutta,
in the 1860s.
11
Bank of Bengal 1809
Bank of Bombay 1840
Bank of Madras 1863
Allahabad Bank 1865
Punjab National Bank Ltd. 1894
Canara Bank 1906
Indian Bank 1907
Bank of Baroda 1908
Central Bank of India 1911
Bank of Mysore 1913
Union Bank of India 1922
Organized banking in India is more than two centuries old. Until 1935 all, the banks were in
private sector and were set up by individuals and/or industrial houses, which collected
deposits from individuals and used them for their own purposes. In the absence of any
regulatory framework, these private owners of banks were at liberty to use the funds in any
manner, they deemed appropriate and resultantly, the bank failures were frequent. For many
years the Presidency banks acted as quasi-central banks as did their successors. Bank of
Bengal, Bank of Bombay and Bank of Madras merged in 1925 to form the Imperial Bank of
India, which, upon India’s independence, became the state Bank of India. Even though
consolidation in banking was building trust among the investors but a central regulatory,
authority was much needed. British Government in India passed many trade and commerce
The Reserve Bank of India was set up on the recommendations Royal Commission on Indian
Currency and Finance also known as the Hilton-Young Commission. The commission
12
submitted its report in the year 1926, though the bank was not set up for nine years. Reserve
Bank of India (RBI) was created with the central task of maintaining monetary stability in
India. The Government on December 20, 1934 issued a notification and on January 14, 1935,
the RBI came into existence, though it was formally inaugurated only on April 1, 1935.
3. To operate the credit and currency system of the country to its advantage
The Bank began its operations by taking over from the Government the functions so far being
performed by the Controller of Currency and from the Imperial Bank of India. Offices of the
Burma (Myanmar) seceded from the Indian Union in 1937 but the Reserve Bank continued to
act as the Central Bank for Burma until Japanese Occupation of Burma and later unto April
1947. After the partition of India, the Reserve Bank served as the central bank of Pakistan up
in India was not new or happening first time. From 1955 to 1960, State Bank of India and
other seven subsidiaries were nationalized under the SBI Act of 1955.
13
3.Dena Bank 10.Union Bank
4.Punjab National Bank 11.Allahabad Bank
5.Syndicate Bank 12.United Bank of India
6.Canara Bank 13.UCO Bank
7.Indian Bank 14.Bank of India
It was not a step taken at random or because of the whims of the leadership of the time, but
reflected process of struggle and political change which had made this an important demand
of the people. Nationalization took place in two phases, with a first round in 1969 covering
14 banks followed by another in 1980 covering seven banks. Currently there are 27
Reasons for Nationalization
1. The need for the nationalization was felt mainly because private commercial banks were
not fulfilling the social and developmental goals of banking, which are so essential for
any industrializing country. Despite the enactment of the Banking Regulation Act in 1949
and the nationalization of the largest bank, the State Bank of India, in 1955, the expansion
of commercial banking had largely excluded rural areas and small-scale borrowers.
2. The stated purpose of bank nationalization was to ensure that credit allocation occur in
3. Reduce the hold of moneylenders and make more funds available for agricultural
14
This is the phase of “New Generation” tech-savvy banks. This phase can be called as “The
Reforms Phase”. Starting of the modern and current phase of Indian Banking is marked by
Narasimhan Committee
also known as Narasimhan Committee. The Committee, headed by former Reserve Bank of
India governor M Narasimhan, was appointed by the United Front government to review the
progress in banking sector reforms. The committee submitted its recommendations to union
review the progress in the reforms in the banking sector over the past six years with and to
chart a programme on Financial Sector Reforms necessary to strengthen the India’s financial
system and make it internationally competitive taking into account the vast changes in the
15
1. A reduction, phased over five years in the Statutory Liquidity Ratio (SLR) to 25 percent,
6. Profitable and reputed banks are permitted to raise capital from the public.
7. Instituting an Assets Reconstruction Fund to which the bad and doubtful debts of banks
Assets
Cash and cash due from Central Bank; cash on deposit in postal banking accounts;
Cash held in trust: may be on the behalf of a third party or the result of a
Fed Funds Sold: Federal funds, or fed funds, are unsecured loans of reserve balances
at Federal Reserve Banks that depository institutions make to one another. Banks
keep reserve balances at the Federal Reserve Banks to meet their reserve requirements
and to clear financial transactions. Transactions in the fed funds market enable
deficiencies. Fed Funds are sold daily to various financial institutions (commercial
16
banks, thrift institutions, agencies and branches of foreign banks in the United States,
federal agencies, and government securities dealers) throughout the United States.
The most common duration or term for fed funds transaction is overnight, though
longer-term deals are arranged. The rate at which these transactions occur is called the
Most overnight loans are booked without a contract. The borrowing and lending
their experience in doing business together, and limit the size of transactions to
established credit lines in order to minimize the lender's exposure to default risk.
automatically until termination by either the lender or the borrower. This type of
agreement is used most frequently by correspondent banks that borrow overnight fed
Due From Banks: demand and time deposits with other banks (does not include
loans to banks that may be termed time deposits due from banks) and although there
Negotiable Certificates of Deposit, which should be stated at the lower of cost or net
realizable value.
Marketable Securities: U.S. Treasury and other U.S. government agencies, States
movements in these securities are dependent upon the movement in market interest
rate).
"lent" out cash and took securities at a discounted value as security, which are
recorded as receivables.
Loans or Receivables (of various maturities in excess of one year) will represent one of the
main business activities of the bank and may account for the largest percentage of total assets.
A loan is an extension of credit resulting from direct negotiations between a lender and a
borrower. Loans may be held until maturity, may be sold in whole or a portion to third
parties, and may also be obtained through purchase in whole or in portion from third parties.
term / revolving)? Construction loans (this is one of the riskiest types of loan),
loans to public authorities, consumer loans such as credit card, home equity and
Collateralized loans mean that the grantor has in its possession (or a fiduciary,
stocks and bonds). Sufficient margin on collateralized credits should also be provided
Secured loans are secured by assets that are not readily marketable and/or under the
control of the recipient of the loan (UCC filings on receivables, pledges of inventory,
inventory and real estate should be adequately insured and in the name the Grantor.
18
Loans secured by real estate are loans predicated upon a security interest in real
property. A loan predicated upon a security interest in real property is a loan secured
wholly or substantially by a lien on real property for which the lien is central to the
Shown net of Allowance of Losses (the reserve set aside that represents an amount
portfolio).
(including interest rate risk and foreign exchange risk), cash flow risk, and other risks
in operations and for trading. The accounting and reporting standards for derivative
for hedging activities are set forth in FASB Statement No. 133, "Accounting for
Mortgage Servicing Rights (MSRs): Many banks that originate primary residential
mortgages and then sell them into the secondary market retain the servicing rights of
the mortgage. This means that for a fee the bank collects the monthly payment from
the mortgagee and passes on the principal and interest components of the payment to
the trust that owns the mortgage and then also makes the insurance and real estate tax
Fixed Assets
Leasehold and freehold land and buildings (at historical cost or at revised market
19
Tangible fixed assets: fixtures, equipment, motor vehicles (depreciated or
amortized).Investments
Brady bonds (should not be carried at a value not exceeding their secondary market
value).
Investments in subsidiaries.
Other Assets
Deferred Taxes
Liabilities
Current Liabilities
Due to customers (on sight or time deposits) / Deposits: Savings accounts, regular
certificates of deposit over $100,000. They include checking interest deposits, money
market deposit accounts, time and other savings, plus demand deposits.
or through any deposit broker for deposit into one or more deposit accounts. Thus,
brokered deposits include both those in which the entire beneficial interest in a given
bank deposit account or instrument is held by a single depositor and those in which
the deposit broker sells participations in a given bank deposit account or instrument to
one or more investors. Fully insured brokered deposits are brokered deposits that are
20
issued in denominations of $100,000 or less or that are issued in denominations
greater than $100,000 and participated out by the deposit broker in shares of $100,000
or less.
United States, which rollover every 30 to 270 days and are usually not collateralized.
Short-term borrowings are usually from banks, securities dealers, the Federal Home
Loan Bank, unsecured federal funds borrowings, which generally mature daily.
Advances from a Federal Home Loan Bank are fully collateralized by loans on the
(including interest rate risk and foreign exchange risk), cash flow risk, and other risks
in operations and for trading. The accounting and reporting standards for derivative
for hedging activities are set forth in FASB Statement No. 133, "Accounting for
Long-Term Liabilities
Mortgages payable, which may have been incurred for commercial property where
Covered Bonds, which is bank debt backed by a pool of pledged, secured, qualifying
collateral, usually bank loans. However, principal amortization and interest is usually
satisfied by the cash flow of the bank, not the cash flow of the assets in the cover
21
pool. The cover pool is usually structured to allow a revolving schedule of similar
quality loans to be added to / withdrawn from the pool. The purchaser of the bond
usually also has full recourse to the financial institution if the collateral assets in the
pool are insufficient to redeem the principal and full interest of the bond (however,
any claim will rank pari passu with all other senior unsecured creditors). The covered
Contingent Core Tier 1 Capital / CoCos is debt that will automatically convert into
equity shares of the bank if the bank's core capital ratio declines below a specific
level.
Accrued/deferred taxes
Common shares (authorized and outstanding). Is there a tier system of voting shares
Why is it a poor decision for banks to buy back shares on the open market in order to increase
the market price of the common equity? Because corporate stock purchases actually reduce
capital (instead of increasing retained earnings). Why is it an even worse decision of taking
on debt to buy back shares on the open market? Because the bank is actually increasing
bank or other company which entitles its holders to some preference or priority over
the owners of common stock, usually with respect to dividends or asset distributions
in a liquidation.
Some trust related preferred securities may have equity characteristics and are treated
favourably under Tier 1 guidelines; and may have lower interest costs. The
22
instruments are deeply subordinated (just ahead of common stock) and have long
maturities although they may have call provisions. Dividend payments may have
some favourable tax treatment for the issuers. However, these securities generally
have debt-like characteristics. The bank is unlikely to defer dividend payments due to
Trust Preferred Securities / TruPS. TruPS were approved by the Federal Reserve in
1996 as Tier 1 capital (maximum 25.0% of tier 1 capital). The Trust issuer is usually a
bank. The Trust sells securities to investors and then uses the proceeds from the sale
Clarifying the value of Stockholder's Equity. Equity invested into any type of financial
institution is an accounting entry. It is not a situation where there is a separate account where
segregated cash and assets are held independently for an emergency of what is indicated on
the balance. Rather, equity is utilized to purchase / invest in assets from which the financial
institution can generate revenue. Thus, the value of Equity is only as good as the quality of
Income Statement
Income
Interest income (gross or net?): is adversely affected by falling long and short-term
interest rates.
Interest expenses
money markets, or takes in from depositors. Competition for customer funding will
increase interest expense, placing pressure on margins. Some banks and financial
services companies will also break out the average annual interest rate paid on the
Non-interest Income
(bank services, fees such service charges on deposits, trust income, mortgage
operations) that have more stable growth rates and are not tied to loan growth cycles,
Other Income
Foreign exchange: based on customer activity and volatility in the market. Sale of
investments: is it exceptional?
stock-broking
Operating income
After expenses but before provisions and taxes and extraordinary items.
24
Material events and transactions that are unusual and infrequent.
Changing market conditions where the bank operates may result in a deterioration of
loan and lease assets, which may result in actual and anticipated losses (write-down or
write-off of the asset's value). The accumulated loss may exceed the existing Loan
Reserve thus earnings may have to add to the Loan Reserve account to either increase
Taxation
Current taxation (tax payable on recognized income for the fiscal year, which was
Deferred taxation
It is an Indian global IT product and solutions company serving The Banking and Financial
Services sector for the past 27 years. It offers wide range of IT solutions and consultancy
services serving a variety of sectors of the banking industry. It is listed on The Bombay Stock
Exchange and the National Stock Exchange of India. The company has its Headquarters
started its operations in 1986 in a small office at Thyagraj Nagar, New Delhi. In 1994, the
Company went global with its entry into Singapore. In 1995, it became a public company,
when it Issued 201,000 equity shares of Rs 10 each. In 2005–06, Nucleus Software expanded
its operations In Europe with wholly owned subsidiary in Amsterdam. The Company was
awarded with Gold shield For Excellence in Financial Reporting 2010 by Institute of
(20.02% of Total Sales), for the year ending 31-Mar-2015.For the quarter ended 31-Mar-
2015, the company has reported Standalone sales of Rs. 83.18 Cr., up 22.61% from last
quarter Sales of Rs. 67.84 Cr. and up 37.47% from last year same quarter Sales of Rs. 60.51
Cr. Company has reported net profit after tax of Rs. 20.82 Cr. in latest quarter. The
Bhasin, Ms.Poonam Bhasin, Prof.Trilochan Sastry, Mr.Ashish Nanda, Mr.Janki Ballabh, Mr.
Subramaniam, Mr.Prithvi Haldea, and Mr. P Singh. Company has Deloitte Haskins & Sells as
its auditors. As on 31-Mar-2015, the company has a total of 32,383,724 shares outstanding
Nucleus Software Exports Limited operates in more than 50 countries. And has its
headquarters in Noida, Uttar Pradesh, India As of 31 March 2014, and Nucleus Software had
FinnOne Neo is an end to end loan lifecycle management solution for the global banking and
to provide risk management operational and decision making support in lending lifecycle to
FinnAxia is an integrated global transaction banking solution built on latest java technology
over Service Oriented Architecture platform. With FinnAxia banks can breakdown traditional
product silos, launch personalized products/services over multiple channels and achieve
operational excellence.
26
FinnAxia offers the capability to swiftly address corporate customer’s liquidity management
to financial supply chain management, with enhanced customer satisfaction. The solution
empowers financial institution establish and maintain a market leading presence through the
FinnOne Neo Loan Management System (LMS) is an advanced and comprehensive bank
loan management system that aims to improve the quality, turnaround time and service for
end customers, it enables banks to improve the agility, transparency and efficiency of their
the processes for achieving cost savings and enhanced customer experiences.
FinnOne Neo collections is a customer centric, web based and workflow driven solution that
allows financial institutions manage, monitor and control the delinquent loan accounts while
automating the loan collections management framework. The workflow manager governs the
entire business processes and the rule engine defines the supporting rules in line with their
policies.
MTB is Nucleus Software's mobile Transaction Banking suite for Additive (existing bank
customers) and Transformational (new bank customers) transaction banking services. This
mobile banking solutions offers a wide range of mobile banking services with out of the box
MTB provides the advantage of ready integration with the FinnAxia transaction system. It is
FinnAxia Business Internet Banking is a delivery channel for bank’s customers, offering
convenience to bank anytime and anywhere. It allows banks to provide easy access to
information from multiple back-end systems as relevant data into a single customer view. It is
27
an easy to use, robust solution that provides direct access to a comprehensive suite of
solution with 2-factor authentication using a security token, encrypted password storage,
shields against hacking as per international standards, secure communication over the Internet
using SSL (Secure Sockets Layer). Customers can personalize their user interface, dashboard
requirement rather than nice-to-have. Financial services organizations across the globe are
embracing predictive analytics at an increasing rate in order to get insights that will help them
explore new opportunities, fine-tune existing programs, minimize risk and improve
efficiencies. At Nucleus, we have more than 3000 person years’ experience in providing
components for our clients. We enable financial institutions to experience how predictive
analytics can help them in developing insights that would shape their lending business
Nucleus analyzes the historical data of the financial institution. Predictive models and
scorecards are then created and validated following which strategy maps and validated
reports are shared. The insights help the institutions take more informed decisions across the
Realize the power of Nucleus Software Products quickly, cost-effectively, transparently and
virtually risk free with our unique implementation strategy. Continuous business
improvement and transformation are critical to keep pace with the rapidly changing
competitive landscape and dynamic economic environment. To facilitate this we have taken
the knowledge and experience gained from working with the world’s leading organizations
and embedded it into our project methodology – Finn Edge. Finn Edge is designed to turn our
28
customers’ visions into reality, on time and to budget. Finn Edge is a comprehensive
incorporating industry best practices quickly, reducing the total cost of deployment and
supporting all their needs, virtually risk-free. It transforms Project Management into Solution
and Value Management, accelerating value delivery in four steps: Evaluate; define; generate;
empower.
I. The research would highlight the comparative position of a sample commercial bank
with respect to ICICI Bank - the first Indian Universal Bank, which would help the
II. The research would enumerate the financial health and risk exposure of sample
understand the relative strength and risk exposure of Indian commercial banks.
III. The research can be used as a base for Post-doctoral research work
29
Chapter- 2
LITERATURE REVIEW
30
2.1 INTRODUCTION
“Banking is a heaven for the Researchers and hell for the Practitioners” is a popular saying on
Banking. Number of research studies has been carried out in different Universities. These
studies can be grouped under classifications like PhD, studies carried by Institution like RBI,
NIBM etc. and individual scholars. The following literature have been reviewed for this study
to highlight the research work already done on the subject in India and Abroad, which proved
Al-Tamini et al (2006) have attempted to compare service quality and performance of Bank.
Comparison has been made between National and Foreign Banks in the UAE. Mann Whitney
non-parametric test has been used for comparing the financial performance.
Agarwal Pankaj K et al (2011) have compared the performance of PSBs with their Private
sector counterparts on globally accepted CAMEL model. The study discovered that PSBs
have lower Capital Adequacy than Private Sector Banks, while the Asset Quality of PSBs is
superior to Private Sector Banks which reflected in their Gross NPAs and there is no
31
Ahluwalia Montek S (01) (2002) conducted a study on “Economic Reforms in India since
1991: Has Gradualism worked?” This study deals with the impact of gradualist economic
reforms in India on the policy environment from 1991 to 2001. The researcher has gone into
depth about the process of economic reforms in India forced. By severe BOP crisis, post-
Arora et al (2005) studied the performance evaluation of PSBs in the post reforms period on
the basis of four parameters i.e. financial parameters, Operational parameters, Profitability
parameters and Productivity parameters and found the performance of PSBs quite satisfactory
Bisht et al (2002) studied the impact of Liberalisation on the Indian Banking Sector. They
established the fact that the present Banking structure is the outcome of a process of
Expansion , Re – organization and Consolidation which have been going on for many years
and passed through three important phases - Pre – nationalisation, Post nationalization and
Post Liberalization. With the advent of internet, one can distinctly perceive the arrival of
fourth phase which led to mass structural changes in Banking by replacing brick and mortar
branches with the electronic delivery channels to provide more options to the customers.
Traditional Banking has become a thing of the past; and technology has changed the rule of
the game.
Das M R(2001) made a study on performance of the PBs for the year 1999-00 vis-a- vis the
preceding year. For this purpose, data was mainly collected from the RBI Report on Trend
and Progress of Banking in India, 1999-2000. The analysis revealed that overall performance
of Private Banks during 1999-2000 looked up compared to that in the previous year. New
32
Private Bank which were equipped with latest technology was ahead of most of the old
Private Banks.
Das Uday (2002) made a study which was the critical evaluation of the Lead Bank Scheme in
the light of Banking Sector reforms. Das observed that high level of NPAs, large number of
loss making branches; lower productivity, excess manpower and old fashioned operations
Frierson, Robert DeV (2007) has made an attempt to study „Orders Issued under Section 4
of the Bank Holding Company Act‟. This study finds out that National City Corporation has
submitted an application to the U.S. Federal Reserve Board to acquire Harbor Federal
Savings Company and Appraisal Analysis Inc. and merge with Harbor Florida Bancshares
Company in Cleveland, Ohio. The Board has considered the comments and all the factors of
the proposal after the filing and publication of notice of the proposal. The application was
approved because the Companies comply with the Bank Holding Company Act.
Joshi PN (2002) have analysed the impact of Financial Sector reforms on the weaker sections
of society and observed that reforms have helped the Banks in introducing innovative
measures to improve their business prospects profitably, thus, maximizing wealth for the
shareholders.
Kaveri (2001) has made an attempt to study strategies suggested by the RBI to avoid
accretion of fresh NPAs by strictly monitoring the post sanction follow up like periodical
inspection of unit and inventory, scrutiny of books and transactions, verification of various
statements and returns, periodical interaction with borrowers etc. Such close follow up with
33
Ketkar Kusum W et al (2008) have investigated the Efficiency of Indian Banks since
systemic reforms began in 1990s using DEA technique and Bank– specific data from 1997 –
2004. The study revealed that Foreign Banks are more efficient followed by New PBs and the
efficiency/ performance of PSBs has adversely affected due to priority sector advances.
Kohli (1999) made an attempt to evaluate the effectiveness of Bank branch licensing in the
performance evaluation parameters have also changed. Earlier Performance Indicators like
Deposits, Priority Sector lending and Branch expansion, have yielded to new ones like
Kumar Sunil et al (2009) have made an attempt to study the Efficiency, Effectiveness and
Performance of 27 PSBs and concluded that in the case of PSBs, higher effectiveness is not
on account of higher efficiency but there lies a strong co- relation between effectiveness and
performance measures.
Kunjukunju, Dr. Benson (2006) conducted a study on „Reforms in Banking Sector and
their Impact in Banking Services‟. This study emphasized that strategies followed by the
Indian Banks are still far from adequate and have not obtained the expected results. The
systematic planning and introduction of customer oriented and customized products and
services by the Indian Banks will help them to compete and succeed in the contemporary
and widen the customer base, the Banks should initiate steps to better personal contacts with
34
their customers. The Banks must concentrate on enhancing quality of its personnel and try to
develop it further.
Banks across all the Banking groups, by using DEA technique. The findings revealed that
Foreign Banks outperformed other Banking Groups in terms of cost and revenue efficiencies,
though they could not generally extend their Banking services beyond metro cities.
Milind Satya (2005) carried out a study analysing the Bank ownership, particularly
Privatization, on the efficiency and performance of Banks for the period 1998-2002. The
findings categorically state that the financial performance and efficiency of partially
privatized Banks were better than wholly owned PSBs and also continue to perform better.
Nagarajan (2002) analyzed „Other Income of the Banks‟ for the period 1993-1994. He
emphasized that other income of the Banks has been receiving focused attention due to two
reasons. Firstly, Banks are being urged to increase this source of income. Secondly, there was
Pal Ved et al (2009) discussed on Productivity Analysis of Commercial Banks in India. They
focused on productivity growth of the Indian Banking Sector using panel data of 63
Commercial Banks from 1996-2005 through Data Envelopment Analysis. The study reveals
that overall productivity growth is the result of technical progress accompanied by stagnating
and negative growth rate in the other components of total factor productivity.
Prasuna (2004) has investigated the performance of 65 Commercial Banks for the period
2003 – 04 by using CAMEL model. The researcher has observed that the Bank customers
35
have tremendously benefitted from the competition among the Banks and have enjoyed
improved service quality and innovative products and services at lower cost.
PSBs. They are of the opinion that introduction of IRAC norms in the Indian Banking System
have emerged as one of the major challenges facing the PSBs. They further felt that total
elimination of NPAs is not possible in banking business due to several externalities, but their
Saha et al (2000) have made an attempt to rank 25 PSBs using DEA for the period 1991-92
to 1994-95 and observed that PSBs have improved, in general, their efficiency over the
period of study.
Sainesh G et al (2003) carried out a linkage between Service Quality and Service Climate in
the Retail Commercial Banks operating in India. Survey data was collected from the front
line employees as well as customers of 48 branches belonging to eight Public Sectors, Private
and Foreign Banks through a self-administered Questionnaire. The Researchers in the study
found that the employees‟ perception of service quality of Private and Foreign Banks is
similar. The Public Sector Banks score low on all dimensions of service quality. They further
service quality. Finally, they came to a conclusion that the existence of a linkage between
employees‟ perception of service climate and customers‟ perception of service quality does
signify the contribution of the service climate of a Bank for delivering quality service to its
customers.
36
Samal (2002) in his study has observed that NPAs cannot be totally eliminated from the
Banking System but could be minimized if appropriate pre-sanction scrutiny and post-
sanction follow up are made. It is further observed that there is a lack of political will and
Samson E Edo (2000) examined the interaction between Liquidity and Profitability in the
Banking Sector of Nigeria. An equation model is specified to explain the relationship. The
estimated results reveal that the two variables have direct and significant impact on one
another. A causality test conducted, indicated that liquidity has a stronger impact in the
Sanjeev et al (2006) examined whether there exists any co-relation between efficiency and
size of the Banks in India. The researchers have conducted the study on PSBs for the period
1997-2001 by using DEA and observed that no conclusive relationship can be established
for the year 2004-05 using CAMEL Model. The findings state that leveraging technology will
help the Indian Banks for sustainable growth with solid foundation.
Shankaraiah (1999) made an attempt to study the awareness and preferences of customers
towards the Banking services. In order to give representation to all the people in all walks of
life a sample of about 140 customers is selected on stratified random sampling method and
structured questionnaire is administered on them. The study covers only the respondents
residing in Hyderabad during the study period of 1997-1998. Researcher in this study found
that Banks are offering various deposit, credit, ancillary, diversified services to the customers
37
to meet their variety of needs. But many of these schemes are not much known to the
customers. Further, he observed that a scheme, that offers high security, return, growth,
flexibility, promptness, care, attention, simplicity, convenience, less price would attract the
customers to make use of them. In this study, he suggested that a continuous effort is required
to analyse the preferences and awareness of customers, to serve the customer better and
Sheeba Kapil et al (2003) paper’s objective was to review and analyse the Current Financial
Health of the Indian Public Sector Banks in the light of banking reforms and predict the
future and scope of the same. The viability of the 27 PSBs has been analysed on the basis of
Shrivastava Urvashi et al (2011) have studied the soundness and financial strength of Axis
Bank in terms of capital adequacy and effectiveness by using financial ratios and applying
correlation and t – test. The study reveals that the said Bank has resorted to raising of non-
equity capital as a matter of its growth strategy to meet the capital adequacy requirements.
The findings further reveal that the Bank not only could meet the minimum capital
requirement but also made provision for business growth by adequately mapping credit,
Siraj K K et al (2011) have examined the impact of global financial crisis of 2007-09 on
performance of SCBs by relying upon the relevant data for the period 1999 – 00 to 2010 – 11.
It is observed by the researcher that PSBs were comparatively more stable, While PBs and
Foreign Banks were susceptible to the financial crisis, whereas, SCBs as a whole have shown
Sooden et al (2004) have studied the performance of PSBs from profitability angle during the
pre and post reform periods by using correlation and regression analysis. The findings
38
suggest that the PSBs have gradually lost social profitability with the decline in priority
Veni (2004) studied the Capital Adequacy requirements of the Banks and the measures
adopted by them to strengthen their capital ratios. The author highlighted that the Rating
Agencies give prominence to Capital Adequacy Ratios of Banks while rating the bank’s
Certificate of Deposits, Bonds etc. They normally adopt CAMEL Model for rating Banks.
2.2 CONCLUSION
Banks. Studies conducted to analyse the performance are based on the Data Envelopment
Analysis (DEA) approach as referred to by Ozkan, Tektas, Arzu (2006), a tool to detect and
improve the sources of inefficiency by Bank Management and Supervisory Agents, which
shows that risk management issues as well as explicit considerations of Government rules
and directives drive an edge between the functioning of Public Sector and Private Sector
Banks. The analysis further revealed that there is no definite relationship between Efficiency
and Size of Banks. Technically, more efficient Banks are those which have on an average less
NPAs.
DEA method of analysis is not free from discrepancies, like results are sensitive to the
selection of inputs and outputs. So, their relative importance needs to be analysed prior to the
relationship between explanatory factors (within inputs and/or within outputs), DEA views
each company as unique and fully efficient and efficient scores are very close to 1, which
39
Another method most commonly used is “CAMELS model”. The acronym CAMELS refers
to the Bank’s five components that are evaluated: Capital adequacy, Asset quality,
Managerial adequacy, Earnings, Liquidity and Bank’s Sensitivity to market risk (added in
1997). An overall rating of 1 is best, while a rating of 5 implies a Bank being laden with
The CAMELS approach also suffers from indeterminacy, subjectivity and even
decide, whether to give an „average‟ or „below average‟ score. The good and Bad indicators
are easily available but not so the „in-betweens‟ due to the indeterminacy.
Finally, in case of Commercial Banks, DEA and CAMELS models are employed to assess
the effectiveness of performance of Banking Sector which is not secluded from discrepancies.
Therefore, it was necessary to analyse the comparative performance of the Banking Sector,
especially the Public Sector and the Private Sector Banks in India by following method other
40
Chapter- 3
RESEARCH
METHODOLOGY
41
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
The empirical data can be gathered in two ways, from primary sources and secondary
sources. Primary sources are information gathered primarily for research, primary sources
There are both advantages and disadvantages with the two different data sources. What is
favorable with the primary sources is that they are updated and gathered for the study’s
specific purpose, which makes it provide the information the study intends to investigate.
expensive to conduct. The advantage of secondary sources is that they are time and cost-
efficient. Secondary sources are used in this study. The secondary sources enabled the author
Research is based on secondary data. Secondary data was made available by official
websites of respective banks, Balance sheets of respective Banks, Magazine like Business
Today
Secondary Data:-
Secondary data is the data that have been already collected by and readily available from
other sources. Such data are cheaper and more quickly obtainable than the primary data and
also may be available when primary data cannot be obtained at all. It is used for analysis
purpose and collected through secondary sources which are extracted from annual reports,
42
The secondary data constitutes profiles of commercial banks. Slabs of rate of interest on
house loan & fixed deposit are covered to make the comparison between the interest rates
Through website
A descriptive research purpose is clearly stated and to the point. The descriptive research is
structured, the data gathering involves a structured process and follows a clear set of rules in
the execution of the research. Descriptive research could involve more than one variable, but
research can be used in both quantitative and qualitative studies. A research design provides
guidelines for conducting the study and the design should be chosen based on the fact that it
43
Chapter- 4
DATA ANALYSIS
AND PRESENTATION
44
4.1 Global Banking Outlook 2018
Ten years after the global financial crisis, the banking industry has regained its health and the
mood of bankers is more buoyant. They should enjoy it while it lasts. With 85% of banks
investment in technology to drive efficiency, manage evolving risks and benefit from growth
Our Global banking outlook survey of 221 financial institutions across 29 markets reveals
that bankers are positive about their ability to improve their financial performance in 2018
and beyond.
years ago.
The largest banks in the world have significantly improved their capital position in the
The vast majority of banks expect revenues and profitability to improve over the next
45
Cost and competitive challenges remain
Analysis of 200 banks shows that their aggregate costs have fallen by a little more than 10%
in the last five years but they are still more than 25% over their 2008 cost base.
According to the survey most banks reveals that most bankers anticipate that cost will
continue to increase over the next three years because of as the moderate savings in regulatory
change programs are reallocated to growth initiatives and cyber security spending.
On average, bankers expect a 2.1% cost increase over the next three years.
46
47
ICICI Bank is India's largest private sector bank with total consolidated assets of Rs.
11,242.81 billion (US$ 172.5 billion) at March 31, 2018 and profit after tax of Rs. 67.77
billion (US$ 1.0 billion) for the year ended March 31, 2018. ICICI Bank currently has a
History
ICICI Bank was originally promoted in 1994 by ICICI Limited, an Indian financial
institution, and was its wholly-owned subsidiary. ICICI's shareholding in ICICI Bank was
reduced to 46% through a public offering of shares in India in fiscal 1998, an equity offering
in the form of ADRs listed on the NYSE in fiscal 2000, ICICI Bank's acquisition of Bank of
Madura Limited in an all-stock amalgamation in fiscal 2001, and secondary market sales by
ICICI to institutional investors in fiscal 2001 and fiscal 2002. ICICI was formed in 1955 at
the initiative of the World Bank, the Government of India and representatives of Indian
industry. The principal objective was to create a development financial institution for
In the 1990s, ICICI transformed its business from a development financial institution offering
only project finance to a diversified financial services group offering a wide variety of
products and services, both directly and through a number of subsidiaries and affiliates like
ICICI Bank. In 1999, ICICI become the first Indian company and the first bank or financial
48
Chanda Kochhar
Lending Products
Home Loan: ICICI bank provides home loan to the customers at the rate of 8.45% P.A. For
the purpose of purchase flat, Home, etc. they also provide the loan for the construction
Car Loan: ICICI bank provides car loan to the customers at the rate of 9.75% P.A. for the
purpose of purchasing of new as well as old car with 100% ex-showroom price of the car for
new purchase.
Education Loan: Bank provide education loan to the students at the rate of 15% P.A. for India
as well as for foreign studies they also provide full coverage of fees as well as
accommodations.
Personal Loan: Bank provide personal loan to the customers on the salary basis or mortgage
Gold Loan, loan against securities, Commercial Business loans, Pradhan mantra mudra
yojana.
Introduction
49
In the 1980s, CAMEL rating system was first introduced by U.S. supervisory authorities as a
system of rating for on-site examinations of banking institutions. Under this system, each
banking institution subject to onsite examination is evaluated on the basis of five critical
dimensions relating to its operations and performance, which are referred to as the component
factors. These are Capital, Asset Quality, Management, Earnings and Liquidity used to reflect
The CAMEL rating system is based upon an evaluation of five critical elements of credit
Asset/Liability Management. This rating system is designed to take into account and reflect
all significant financial and operational factors examiners assess in their evaluation of credit
union’s performance. Credit unions are rated using combination of financial ratios and
examiner judgment.
Since the composite CAMEL rating is an indicator of the viability of a credit union, it is
important that examiners rate credit unions based on their performance in absolute terms
rather than against peer averages or predetermined benchmarks. The examiner must use
professional judgment and consider both qualitative and quantitative factors when analyzing
a credit union’s performance. Since numbers are often lagging indicators of a credit union’s
condition, the examiner must also conduct qualitative analysis of current and projected
Although the CAMEL composite rating should normally bear a close relationship to the
component ratings, the examiner should not derive the composite rating solely by computing
and arithmetic average of the component ratings. Following are general definitions and
50
The capital adequacy ratio (CAR) is a measure of a bank's capital. It is expressed as a
assets ratio (CRAR), it is used to protect depositors and promote the stability and efficiency
of financial systems around the world. Two types of capital are measured: tier one capital,
which can absorb losses without a bank being required to cease trading, and tier two capital,
which can absorb losses in the event of a winding-up and so provides a lesser degree of
protection to depositors. Tier 1 Capital consists of shareholders’ equity and retained earnings.
Tier 1 Capital is intended to measure a bank’s financial health and is used when a bank must
absorb losses without ceasing business operations. Tier 2 Capital includes revaluation
reserves, hybrid capital instruments and subordinated term debt, general loan loss reserves,
and undisclosed reserves. Tier 2 Capital is supplementary capital because it is less reliable
than Tier 1 Capital. Two types of capital are measured - tier one capital which can absorb
losses without a bank being required to cease trading, e.g. ordinary share capital, and tier two
capital which can absorb losses in the event of a winding-up and so provides a lesser degree
of protection to depositors, e.g. subordinated debt. As per the latest RBI norms, banks in
India should have a CAR of 9%. The purpose of having minimum capital adequacy ratios is
to ensure that banks can absorb a reasonable level of losses before becoming insolvent, and
51
Capital Adequacy Rati o
16.64%
15.31%
14.60%
ADVANCES TO ASSETS
This is a ratio of the Total Advances to Total Assets. This ratio indicates a bank’s
aggressiveness in lending which ultimately results in better profitability. Total advances also
include receivables.
63.90%
63.20%
60.10%
Interpretation: In comparison of the banks HDFC bank is more aggressive to given the
loans against their assets, Indusind bank is following the HDFC, ICICI is better in this with
52
GOVERNMENT SECURITIES TO TOTAL INVESTMENTS:
Government securities to total investment ratio depicts the percentage share of government
securities investment of the bank out of their total investments. This ratio shows the risk
most safe debt instrument, which, as a result, carries the lowest return. Since government
securities are risk-free, the higher the Government Securities to investment ratio, the lower
69.60%
Interpretation: In this Indusind bank is investing more in govt. securities which means
risk taking capacity is less whether HDFC is following Indusind with 81.40% in comparison
with these banks ICICI taking more risk in investments. Higher the risk higher the return.
53
4.2.2 ASSETS QUALITY:
Asset Quality determines the robustness of financial institutions against loss of value in the
assets. The deteriorating value of assets, being prime source of banking problems, directly
pour into other areas, as losses are eventually written-off against capital, which ultimately
The solvency of financial institutions typically is at risk when their assets become impaired,
to specific risks, trends in non-performing loans, and the health and profitability of bank
NPA: Non-Performing Assets – Advances are classified into performing and non-performing
advances (NPAs) as per RBI guidelines. NPAs are further classified into sub-standard,
doubtful and loss assets based on the criteria stipulated by RBI. An asset, including a leased
asset, becomes Non-performing when it ceases to generate income for the bank.
Interest and/or installment of principal remains overdue for a period of more than 90
The bills remains overdue for a period of more than 90 days in case of bills purchased
and discounted.
A loan granted for a short duration crops will be treated as an NPA if the installments
A loan granted for long duration crops will be treated as an NPA in the installments of
54
The bank classifies an account as an NPA only if the interest imposed during any quarter is
not fully repaid within 90 days from the end of the relevant quarter. This is a key to the
stability of the banking sector. There should be no hesitation in stating that Indian banks have
The ability of management to properly administer its assets, including the timely
quality
The existence of high loan concentrations that present undue risk to the credit union
The investment risk factors when compared to capital and earnings structure; and the
Gross NPA to Net Advances ratio explains the amount of bad loans that bank won’t be
receiving back from their debtors out of the total gross advances. This ratio is used to check
whether the bank’s gross NPAs are increasing quarter on quarter or year on year. If it is,
indicating that the bank is adding fresh stock of bad loans. It would mean the bank is either
not exercising enough caution when offerings loans or is too lax in terms of following up
55
where the management has not provided for loss on NPAs. The Gross NPAs are measured as
a percentage of Gross Advances. The lower the ratio, the better is the quality of advances.
9.40%
9.32%
9.16%
Interpretation: Gross NPA of all the given banks are nearly same. Less the ratio good for
the bank.
receiving back from their debtors out of the total Net advances. Net NPAs reflect the
performance of banks. A high level of NPAs suggests high probability of a large number of
credit defaults that affect the profitability and net-worth of banks and also wear down the
value of the asset. Loans and advances usually represent the largest asset of most of the
banks. It monitors the quality of the bank loan portfolio. The higher the ratio, the higher the
credits risk. It is a measure of the quality of assets in a situation where the management has
not provided for loss on NPAs. Net NPAs are Gross NPAs net of provisions on NPAs and
56
interest in suspense account. In this ratio, Net NPAs are measured as a percentage of net
advances.
3.88%
2.84%
Interpretation: Net NPA of the ICICI bank is more in comparison with HDFC and
Indusind which means asset quality of the ICICI bank is not up to the mark because it is the
57
TOTAL INVESTMENTS TO TOTAL ASSETS
Total investments to total assets indicate the extent of deployment of assets in investment as
against advances. This ratio is used as a tool to measure the percentage of total assets locked
up in investments, which, by conventional definition, does not form part of the core income
of a bank. It is arrived at by dividing total investments by total assets. A higher ratio means
that the bank has conservatively kept a high cushion of investments to guard against NPAs.
25.40%
20.00% 21.00%
investment as against advances. HDFC is investing more to cushion their NPA’s while
58
Net NPAs to Total Assets
It is a measure of the quality of assets in a situation where the management has not provided
for loss on NPAs. Here, the Net NPAs are measured as a percentage of Total Assets.
2.40%
1.73%
Interpretation: Net NPA of the ICICI bank is higher against the total assets in comparison
asset quality, earnings and profitability, liquidity and risk sensitivity ratings. In addition,
performance evaluation includes compliance with set norms, ability to plan and react to
59
Sound management is one of the most important factors behind financial institutions’
individual institutions, and cannot be easily aggregated across the sector. Furthermore, given
the qualitative nature of management, it is difficult to judge its soundness just by looking at
The ratio measures the efficiency of management in converting the deposits available with
the bank (excluding other funds like equity capital, etc.) into high earning advances. Total
deposits include demand deposits, savings deposits, term deposits and deposits of other
0.89 0.89
60
Interpretation: ICICI is converting their deposits in to the higher earning advances in
comparison with HDFC and Indusind both banks have the same ratio 0.89 while ICICI have
0.94.
This tool measures the efficiency of all the employees of a bank in generating business for the
business, we mean the sum of total deposits and total advances in a particular year.
Business per employee refers to the business that the bank is generating on each employee
being employed in it. It is a measure of how efficiently a particular bank is utilizing its
employees. Ideally, a bank wants the highest business per employee possible, as it denotes
higher productivity. In general, rising revenue per employee is a positive sign that suggests
the bank is finding ways to squeeze more sales/revenues out of each of its employee.
61
Interpretation: HDFC bank have the highest business per employee ratio in comparison
with the ICICI and Indusind. ICICI bank is following HDFC with 82841 employees where
This ratio measures the efficiency of employees at the branch level. It also gives valuable
inputs to assess the real strength of a bank’s branch network. It is arrived at by dividing the
Profit after Tax (PAT) earned by the bank by the total number of employees. The higher the
ratio, higher is the efficiency of the management. The profit per employee explains the profit
that the bank is earning per employee. This ratio shows that surplus earned per employee.
3849.57
2582.79
1132.93
Interpretation: HDFC bank is earning more profit per employee whether ICICI bank and
62
4.2.4 EARNING QUALITY:
Earnings and profitability, the prime source of increase in capital base, is examined with
regards to interest rate policies and adequacy of provisioning. In addition, it also helps to
support present and future operation of the institutions. The single best indicator used to
gauge earning is the return on assets (ROA), which is net income after taxes to total asset
ratio.
Strong earnings and profitability profile of banks reflects the ability to support present and
future operations. More specifically, this determines the capacity to absorb losses, finance its
expansion, and pay dividends to its shareholders, and build up to and adequate level of
capital.
Interest income is a basic source of revenue for banks. The interest income to total income
indicates the ability of the bank in generating income from its lending. This ratio measures
the income from lending operations as a percentage of the total income generated by the bank
in a year. Interest income includes income on advances, interest on deposits with the RBI,
and dividend income. Interest income to total income describes the interest earned by the
bank out of the total income. It compares the interest income with the total income of the
bank. Interest income is a basic source of revenue for banks. The interest income total income
indicates the ability of the bank in generating income from its lending. In other words, this
ratio measures the income from lending operations as a percentage of the total income
63
Total Income 736607624 743732155 185771625
64.60%
Interpretation: Indusind bank is earning more income from their lending operations
followed by ICICI bank, HDFC is earning less in comparison with ICICI and Indusind.
This measures the income from operations other than lending as a percentage of the total
income. A fee-based income account for a major portion of a bank’s other incomes. The bank
generates higher fee income through innovative products and adapting the technology for
sustained service levels. Non-interest income is the income earned by the banks excluding
This generates higher fee income through innovative products and adapting the technology
for sustained service levels. The higher ratio indicates increasing proportion fee-based
income. The ratio is also influenced by gains on government securities, which fluctuates
64
Income
Total Income 736607624 743732155 185771625
35.30%
26.40%
22.80%
Interpretation: Non interest income is the part of fee based income HDFC banks is
earning more by providing services to their customer in comparison with the Indusind and
ICICI Bank.
NIM, being the difference between the interest income and the interest expended as a
percentage of total assets. It is an important measure of a bank’s core income (income from
lending operations). A higher spread indicates the better earnings given the total assets.
Interest income includes dividend income and interest expended included interest paid on
deposits, loan from the RBI, and other short-term and long term loans.
0.03 0.03
0.03
Interpretation: It is the difference between interest income and interest expanded the ratio
of the banks are nearly the same it shows that these banks are retaining only 2.8 to 3%
This ratio measures return on assets employed or the efficiency in utilization of assets. It is
arrived at by dividing the net profit by average assets, which is the average of total assets in
the current year and previous year. Thus, this ratio measures the return on assets employed.
66
Net Profi t to Avg. Assets
0.04
0.02
0.01
Interpretation: ICICI bank is managing their assets in better form to earn the profit while
4.2.5 LIQUIDITY:
An adequate liquidity position refers to a situation, where institution can obtain sufficient
funds, either by increasing liabilities or by converting its assets quickly at a reasonable cost.
It is, therefore, generally assessed in terms of overall assets and liabilities management, as
mismatching gives rise to liquidity risk. Efficient fund management refers to a situation
where a spread between rate sensitive assets (RSA) and rate sensitive liabilities (RSL) is
maintained.
Liquid Assets include cash in hand, balance with the RBI, balance with other banks (both in
India and abroad), and money at call and short notice. This ratio is arrived by dividing liquid
assets by total assets. The proportion of liquid assets to total assets indicates the overall
5.12%
Government securities are the most liquid and safe investment. This ratio measures the
assets held by the bank and is arrived by dividing investment in government securities by the
total assets. This ratio measures the risk involved in the assets held by a bank.
20.60%
17.60%
14.50%
68
Interpretation: Basically banks invest in the govt. securities for meet the SLR activities,
govt. securities are safe securities for investing HDFC investing more and meet SLR in
This ratio measures the liquidity available to the depositors of a bank. Liquid assets include
cash in hand, balance with the RBI, and balance with other banks (both in India and abroad),
and money at call and short notice. Total deposits include demand deposits, savings deposits,
15.40%
14.70%
7.15%
69
Approved Securities to Total Assets
This is arrived at by dividing the total amount invested in approved securities by total assets.
Approved securities are investments made in the state-associated bodies like electricity
SECURITIES
TOTAL ASSETS 1786484138 9860426640 2761875587
RATIO 0 0 0
RANK - - -
4.3 CONCLUSION
On the whole year was a successful year for the ICICI bank which reported net profit of
₹2, 13,96,14,77,000. But the NPA of the ICICI is more in comparison of the other banks.
According to the camel analysis ICICI bank is performing well in the banking sector and
According to the analysis the business per employee and profit per employee is less in
comparison with the HDFC bank. Liquidity is maintained well, the bank has strong profits
4.5 RECOMMENDATIONS
The investment in the govt. securities must increase for the safety purpose.
70
Business per employee and profit per employee try to increase both of these to
That is all that is recommended because the bank is stable and has a well-positioned in the
market.
Chapter- 5
FINDINGS AND
LEARNING OUTCOMES
71
5.1 LEARNINGS OUTCOMES
1) Bank should give to attention to Rural Banking as banks seeks to increase their
customer base, the relatively untapped rural population in India is likely to offer
attractive opportunities.
2) Bank should give advances more to home loan because it gives more interest but
the bank must measure the credit worthiness of customer. Home loan takes more
72
3) NPA is the big problem. The bank should give more secured loan to reduce NPA
auto loan and home loan would be favorable for bank because when the borrower
make any default the bank can cover the loan by the house and auto.
4) In case of education loan till 400000 it is unsecured so the bank should be more
careful for the loan. But for loan more than 400000 the loan would be secured
5) For personal loan it gives less interest than other but tenure is less too therefore
this kind of loan should be given that customer who has less creditworthiness.
Loan in arrear is more favorable it gives more interest for same duration.
5.3 CONCLUSION
Banking is no longer a business restricted to borrowing and lending of funds. Recent years
have seen Indian commercial banks – both in the public sector and private sector diversify
into new areas to widen their business horizons. As banks started offering diversified services
ranging from insurance to mutual funds, from stock-broking to housing finance, from
metamorphosed from being business organizations having prime focus on money transactions
to a business related to information on financial transactions. Thus, with this transition, banks
73
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Books:
1) C.R. Kothari, Research Methodology: Methods and Techniques, second
revised edition, Published by New Age International (P) Ltd. (2004, 1990,
1985),Page 7,104
2) Hair, Joseph F, Arthur H. Money, Phillip Samouel, and Mike Page. Research
Web References:
1) https://www.investopedia.com/terms
2) https://www.ey.com/Publication/vwLUAssets/EY-global-banking-outlook-
2017/$FILE/EY-global-banking-outlook-2017.pdf
3) https://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/rethinking-global-economic-
system-sustainable-capitalism
4) https://www2.deloitte.com/global/en/pages/financial-services/articles/gx-banking-
industry-outlook.html
74
5) https://www.icicibank.com/managed-assets/docs/investor/annual-
reports/2016/icici-subsidiaries-ar-2015-16.pdf
6) https://www.icicibank.com/managed-assets/docs/investor/annual-
reports/2017/annual-report-fy2017.pdf
7) https://www.icicibank.com/aboutus/about-us.page?
8) http://www.kvb.co.in/global/bank_profile.html
9) http://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/camelrating.asp
10) http://www.accountingedu.org/accounting-ratios.htmlhttp://profit.ndtv.com/
11) http://business.mapsofindia.com/
12) http://www.indiamart.com/company/11349299/other-services.html
13) https://en.wikipedia.org
Journal Articles:
Empirical study of the UAE Financial Markets, The Business Review, Cambridge,
Economy: A Comparison with Private Sector Banks”, Bank Quest, Vol 82, No 4, pp
43 – 51.
3) Ahluwalia, Montek. (2002). Economic Reforms in India Since 1991: Has Gradualism
10.1257/089533002760278721.
4) Arora, Manohar & Singh, Pratap. (2005). Evaluation of temperature trends over India.
75
5) Uday Kumar Lal Das (2002). Banking Reforms and Lead Bank Scheme. ISBN
8176293822, 9788176293822
143-57.
8) Ketkar Kusum W (2008), “Performance and Profitability of Indian Banks in the post –
reform period”, The International Journal of Finance, Vol 20, No 3, pp 4910 – 4929.
Appendices:
2019 2018
CAPITAL AND LIABILITIES
Capital 1 11,651,071 11,631,656
Employees stock options outstanding 62,562 67,019
Reserves and surplus 2 987,797,070 885,657,157
Deposits 3 4,900,390,648 4,214,257,086
Borrowings 4 1,475,561,521 1,748,073,779
Other liabilities and provisions 5 342,451,588 347,264,350
Total Capital and Liabilities 7,717,914,460 7,206,951,047
ASSETS
Cash and balances with Reserve Bank of India 6 317,024,051 271,060,888
Balances with banks and money at call and short notice 7 440,106,563 327,626,531
Investments 8 1,615,065,454 1,604,117,966
Advances 9 4,642,320,842 4,352,639,419
1
Fixed assets 0 78,052,072 75,769,200
76
1
Other assets 1 625,345,478 575,737,043
Total Assets 7,717,914,460 7,206,951,047
1
Contingent liabilities 2 10,309,937,127 9,007,987,789
Bills for collection 226,231,852 216,547,286
79