ECE 4353
Chemical Process Safety
Source Models
(Lecture 5)
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
Explain the government-industry’s responsibility for
health and safety
Evaluate the nature of hazards posed by materials
which are flammable, toxic and reactive
Identify and quantify common industrial methods to
control hazards.
Last Updated:17 October 2015 © LMS SEGi education group 2
Lecture 5
5.1 Source Model
5.2 Flow of Liquid through Hole
5.3 Flow of Liquid through Hole in a Tank
5.4 Gases or Vapors through Hole
5.5 Choked Flow
Last Updated:17 October 2015 © LMS SEGi education group 3
Last Upd
Upda
ate
ted
d:17 Octo
tob
ber 2015 © LMS SEGi education group 4
5.1 Release mechanisms
1. Wide aperture release
Example : Overpressuring and explosion of tank
2. Limited aperture release
Last Upd
Upda
ate
ted
Upstream pressure / conditions remain
d:17 Octo
tob
ber 2015 © LMS SEGi education group 5
Release mechanisms: Physical state of material
affects release mechanism
Last Upd
Upda
ate
ted
d:17 Octo
tob
ber 2015 © LMS SEGi education group 6
5.2 Source Model
Source model describe how materials
are discharged from the process
Rate of discharge
Quantity discharged
State of the discharged (solid/vapor/liquid)
Last Upd
Upda
ate
ted
d:17 Octo
tob
ber 2015 © LMS SEGi education group 7
5.2 Source Model (Derivations)
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
1010
5.2 Source Model
A. Flow of LIQUID through HOLE
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
1111
5.2 Source Model
A. Flow of LIQUID through HOLE
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
1414
5.2 Source Model – Flow of Liquid through Hole
A. Flow of LIQUID through HOLE
Mechanical Energy balance
For incompressible liquids, density is constant
External pressure is atmospheric, del P = Pg
Velocity within process u1 = 0
Change in elevation, del z = 0
Alfa = velocity profile correction factor = 0.5 (laminar)
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
1515
Source Model – LIQUID THROUGH HOLE
Frictional losses represented by discharge coefficient
A new discharge coefficient C0
Velocity of fluid exiting a leak
Mass flowrate from hole of area A
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
1616
Source Model – LIQUID THROUGH HOLE
C o Coefficient of Discharge
Coefficient of discharge is the ratio of the
true flow to the theoretical flow
It is applied to the theoretical flow equation to obtain
the correct flow rate.
C o = 0.61 for sharp edge and Re > 30000
C o = 1 for well rounded nozzle
C o = 0.81 for short sections of pipe (L/D >3)
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
1717
Source Model – LIQUID THROUGH HOLE
Last Updated:17 October 2015 © LMS SEGi education group 19
Force, weight and mass
1. F = ma /gc : W = mg /gc
kg.m/s2 g.cm/s2 Ibm.ft/s2
2. gc = 1 --------- = 1 --------- = 32.174 -----------
N dyne Ibf
3. g = 9.8066 m/s2 ===> g/gc = 9.8066 N/kg
g = 980.66 cm/s2 ===> g/gc = 980.66 dyne/g
g = 32.174 ft/s2 ===> g/gc = 1 Ibf/Ibm
4. Example: Water has a density of 62.4 Ibm/ft3. How
much does 2.000 ft3 of water weigh?
Source Model – LIQUID THROUGH HOLE
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
2121
5.3 Source Model – FLOW OF LIQUID THROUGH
HOLE IN A TANK
B. Flow of LIQUID through HOLE in a
TANK
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
2222
Source Model – LIQUID THROUGH HOLE IN A TANK
B. Flow of LIQUID through HOLE in a
TANK
Mass flowrate at any time
Initial mass discharge flowrate Qm @ hL = hL°
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
2323
Source Model – LIQUID THROUGH HOLE IN A TANK
B. Flow of LIQUID through HOLE in a
TANK
Time te for vessel to empty to the level of leak
If vessel at atmospheric pressure, Pg = 0
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
2424
Source Model – LIQUID THROUGH HOLE IN A TANK
A cylindrical tank 20ft high and 8 ft in diameter is used to
store benzene. The tank is padded with nitrogen to a
constant regulated pressure of 1 atmg. The liquid level
within the tank is presently at 17ft. A 1-in puncture
occurs in the tank 5 ft off the ground.
Estimate:
(a) The gallons of benzene spilled
(b) The time required for the benzene to leak out
(c) The maximum mass flowrate of benzene through the
leak.
Given Sg benzene = 0.8794
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
2525
Source Model – LIQUID THROUGH HOLE IN A TANK
(a)Benzene spilled = volume of benzene above the leak
V = A th L °
Area of tank At = (πd2)
4
= (3.142)(8 ft)2/ 4
= 50.2 ft2
V = (50.2 ft2)(17ft - 5ft)(7.48 gal/ft3 ) = 4506 gal
(b)Time required for benzene to leak out = te for vessel to empty to the level of
leak
t e = 56.4 min
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
2626
Source Model – LIQUID THROUGH HOLE IN A TANK
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
2727
Source Model – LIQUID THROUGH HOLE IN A TANK
(c) Maximum mass flowrate happens at t = 0 and hL = hL°
Qm = 10.4 lbm/s
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
2828
Source Model – GASES or VAPORS THROUGH HOLE
C. Flow of GASES/VAPOR through HOLE
Free expansion is an adiabatic
process in which no work is done on or
by the system.
Q = W = 0J
Real gases experience a temperature
change during free expansion.
For ideal gases, the temperature doesn't change, and
the conditions before and after adiabatic free expansion
satisfy P1*V1 = P2*V2
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
2929
5.4 Source Model – FLOW OF GASES or VAPORS
THROUGH HOLE
C. Flow of GASES/VAPOR through HOLE
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
3030
Source Model – GASES or VAPORS THROUGH HOLE
A. Flow of GASES/VAPOR through HOLE
Mechanical Energy balance
Initial Pressure within process = P0, External pressure = P
Velocity within process u0 = 0, Velocity at throat = u (<sonic velocity)
Change in elevation, del z = 0
Ws = 0
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
3131
Source Model – GASES or VAPORS THROUGH HOLE
For ideal gas with isentropic expansion,
The entropy of a given mass does not change during a
process that is internally reversible and adiabatic.
A process during which entropy remains constant is called an
isentropic process.
Some isentropic thermodynamic devices include: pumps, gas
compressors, turbines, nozzles, and diffusers.
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
3232
Source Model – GASES or VAPORS THROUGH HOLE
For ideal gas with isentropic expansion,
Eqn *
Mass flowrate at
any point
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
3333
Source Model – GASES or VAPORS THROUGH HOLE
C. Flow of GASES/VAPOR through HOLE
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
3434
5.5 Source Model – CHOKED FLOW OF GASES or
VAPORS THROUGH HOLE
D. Choked Flow of GAS through HOLE
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
3535
Choked Flow
What is choked flow?
When does choke flow happen?
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
3636
Choked Flow
Flow restri ctions in gas systems (e.g.
restriction orifices, control valves) will result in a
pressure drop.
If the pressure differential across them is large,
CCChoked FLOW will result.
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
3737
Choked Flow
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
3838
Choked Flow
Gas flowing along a pipe in which there is an orifice plate.
This results in a pressure drop.
Pressure upstream of the orifice plate (P1) is constant.
Pressure downstream (P2) is gradually reduced
This results in a greater pressure difference across the
orifice plate, increasing both the gas velocity and the gas
flow through the restriction.
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
3939
Choked Flow
Eventually, as the downstream pressure is dropped
further, the flow through the orifice plate becomes sonic.
Choked flow happens when velocities across a
restriction in the flow path becomes sonic.
Q (flow) is a function of
• Velocity
• Density
• Orifice Area
Any further drop in the downstream pressure will not
result in an increase in gas flow. Once the flow
becomes choked, it is independent of conditions
downstream of the restriction.
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
4040
Choked Flow
The pressure ratio (Upstream Pressure / Downstream
Pressure) at which choked flow occurs is known as the
Critical Pressure Ratio.
Rule of thumb: Critical Pressure Ratio is approx. 2 for a range of gases.
Example:
Air leak to atmosphere. P choked = 14.7 psia.
Flow will be choked
if upstream pressure is >14.7 / 0.528 = 27.8 psia = 13.1 psig.
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
4141
Choked Flow
Mass flowrate at
choked flow condition
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
4242
Heat
Capacity
Ratios for
selected
gases
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
4343
Choked Flow
Velocity and mass flow rate is independent of the
downstream pressure
Q (flow) is a function of
• Velocity
• Density
• Orifice Area
Choked flow is a limiting condition where the mass flow
will not increase with a further decrease in the
downstream pressure environment while upstream
pressure is fixed.
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
4444
Source Model – GASES or VAPORS THROUGH HOLE
D. Choked Flow of GAS through HOLE
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
4545
Choked Flow
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
4646
APPLICATIONS OF CHOKE FLOW
Engineers can design equipment to
make use of choked flow in gases.
One example is in high temperature
steam cracking reactors.
Maintaining equal flow through
parallel reactor tubes is essential to
ensure even residence time in the
cracking reactor. Installing a
restriction orifice (RO) at the
entrance of each reactor tube
achieves choked flow. Provided
that choked flow is maintained,
flowrates are not affected by any
variation in reactor tube pressure
drop.
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
4747
CHOKED FLOW OF GASES THROUGH
RESTRICTION ORIFICE)
RO (restriction orifice) to restrict gas blow-by
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
5050
CHOKED FLOW OF GASES THROUGH HOLE
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
5151
CHOKED FLOW OF GASES THROUGH HOLE
RO (restriction orifice) to restrict gas blow-by
RO is installed here
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
5050
CHOKED FLOW OF GASES THROUGH HOLE
RO to control pressurization
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
5252
CHOKED FLOW OF GASES THROUGH HOLE
RO downstream of blowdown valves
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
5353
CHOKED FLOW OF GASES THROUGH HOLE
Choked Flow of GAS through HOLE
Example 1:
A 0.1 in hole forms in a tank containing nitrogen at
200psig and 80°F. Determine the mass flowrate through
this leak.
For N2, Ɣ= 1.41
= 0.527
P choked = 0.527(200 + 14.7)psia = 113.1 psia
(An external pressure <113.1 psia will cause choke flow)
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
5454
CHOKED FLOW OF GASES THROUGH HOLE
Pressure is atms choke flow
A = πd2/4 = (3.14)(0.1 in)2(1 ft2/144in2) =5.45 X 10-5 ft2
4
Assume discharge coefficient C0 = 1.0
P0 = 200 + 14.7 = 214.7 psia
T0 = 80 + 460 = 540R
Qm choked = 3.86 X 10-2 lbm/s
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
5555
CHOKED FLOW OF GASES THROUGH HOLE
Example 2:
The vapor space above liquid ethylene oxide (EO) in
storage tanks must be padded with nitrogen to prevent
explosion. Nitrogen is supplied from a 200 psig source.
It is regulated to 81 psig and supplied to the storage
vessel. In the event of a failure of the regulator, the
vessel will be exposed to the full 200-psig pressure
which exceeds the pressure rating of the storage vessel.
To prevent rupture, the storage vessel is equipped with
a relief device to vent the nitrogen.
(a) Determine the mass flow rate of nitrogen through the
relief valve assuming an orifice size of 1.049 in?
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
5656
CHOKED FLOW OF GASES THROUGH HOLE
Po = 200 + 14.7 psia, A = πd2/4 = 0.864 in2
For N2, Ɣ= 1.41
P choked = (0.528)(214.7 psia) = 113.4 psia
Assume Co = 1.0
Choked flow can be expected because the system vents to atmospheric
conditions.
Qm = 4.16 lbm/s
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
5757
CHOKED FLOW OF GASES THROUGH HOLE
(b) Suppose the relief device is capable of relieving only
0.5 lbm/s. Suggest an Inherently safer design method
you may use to prevent an incident.
(c) Calculate the orifice diameter required to reduce the
flow from the nitrogen line to 0.5 lbm/s.
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
5858
CHOKED FLOW OF GASES THROUGH HOLE
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
5959
CHOKED FLOW OF GASES THROUGH HOLE
LLaasst UpdUpdaatetedd::1177 OOcctotobbeer 22001155 © LMS SEGi education group
6060
