[go: up one dir, main page]
Scribd
Upload
48 views1 page

G.R. No. 161188 June 13, 2008

The heirs of Purisima Nala appealed a court ruling awarding damages to Artemio Cabansag for demands to vacate a property received after Cabansag purchased it. The Court of Appeals upheld the lower court's finding that Nala and her lawyer did not intend to prejudice or injure Cabansag, as their acts aimed to protect Nala's rights over the property, which had been ordered reconveyed to her heirs in another case. While Cabansag suffered mental anguish from the demands, damages require proof of injury to legal rights, which was not shown.

Uploaded by

JuZxtin YeAhxz
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
48 views1 page

G.R. No. 161188 June 13, 2008

The heirs of Purisima Nala appealed a court ruling awarding damages to Artemio Cabansag for demands to vacate a property received after Cabansag purchased it. The Court of Appeals upheld the lower court's finding that Nala and her lawyer did not intend to prejudice or injure Cabansag, as their acts aimed to protect Nala's rights over the property, which had been ordered reconveyed to her heirs in another case. While Cabansag suffered mental anguish from the demands, damages require proof of injury to legal rights, which was not shown.

Uploaded by

JuZxtin YeAhxz
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 1

G.R. No.

161188 June 13, 2008

Heirs of PURISIMA NALA, vs.


ARTEMIO CABANSAG, respondent.

ISSUES:

Artemio Cabansag he bought a 50-square meter property from spouses Eugenio Gomez, Jr. and Felisa Duyan
Gomez on July 23, 1990. Said property is part of a 400-square meter lot registered in the name of the Gomez
spouses. In October 1991, he received a demand letter from Atty. Alexander del Prado, in behalf of Purisima Nala,
asking for the payment of rentals from 1987 to 1991 until he leaves the premises, as said property is owned by Nala,
failing which criminal and civil actions will be filed against him.

The RTC of Quezon City, Branch 93, rendered its Decision on August 10, 1994, in favor of respondent, and the
petitioner is held to pay the damages.1. P150,000.00 by way of moral damages;2. P30,000.00 by way of exemplary
damages;3. P20,000.00 as and for reasonable attorney's fees and other litigation expenses; and4. to pay the costs.

However, the RTC of dismissed the case n action for reconveyance of real property and cancellation of TCT No.
281115 with damages, filed by Nala against spouses Gomez Hence, herein petition by the heirs of Nala
(petitioners)8 with the following assignment of errors:a) Respondent Court of Appeals erred in not considering the
right of Purisima Nala to assert her rights and interest over the property.b) Respondent Court of Appeals erred in not
considering the Decision rendered by the Court of Appeals in the case for reconveyance which upheld the rights and
interest of Purisima Nala and her children over a certain parcel of land, a portion of which is subject of the present
case.c) Respondent Court of Appeals erred in awarding damages and attorney's fees without any basis.

ISSUE: Whether or not Heirs of Purisima Nala were held damages and injury

RULING: NO, respondent failed to show that Nala and Atty. Del Prado's acts were done with the sole intention of
prejudicing and injuring him. It may be true that respondent suffered mental anguish, serious anxiety and sleepless
nights when he received the demand letters; however, there is a material distinction between damages and injury.
Injury is the legal invasion of a legal right while damage is the hurt, loss or harm which results from the injury.

Nala's acts in protecting her rights over the property find further solid ground in the fact that the property has already
been ordered reconveyed to her and her heirs.

You might also like