BDD V5 PDF
BDD V5 PDF
BDD V5 PDF
Antonela Corban, Assoc. Prof., PhD, ”Al. Ioan Cuza” University of Iași
Abstract: The artistic representation of the zodiac in the space of the church is similar in both the
Western and the Eastern areas, the only difference being that concerning the technique used: stained
glass, mosaic and relief sculpture, on the one hand, and mural painting, on the other (with numerous
examples from France, Italy, Romania, Greece, Macedonia). The representation of time and of the
zodiac in the Romanian churches followed two well-known paths: the linear representation and the
circular representation, each with their own meaning. The linear representation of time, start from the
principle according to which the world has a beginning and an end. In the compositions containing
signs of the zodiac is the recurrent use of the circle, especially of concentric circles (the circle is
considered the symbol of the original unity and of the canopy). The presence of the signs of the zodiac
in the very space of the Western cathedrals was permitted because they were correlated with a
calendar of agricultural works and the types of activities specific of each season and month.
Keywords: zodiacal signs, artistic representation of the zodiac, linear time, cyclic time.
The artistic representation of time has always been a major challenge for painters.
While the space has been mastered using shapes, colour and light, so that they convey the
impression of volume, of distance, of what is commonly known as perspective, in order to
represent time it was necessary to resort to allegories and symbols. It implies using something
that would convey the idea of passage, of lapse. It is true that perspective, too, was referred to
as a “symbolic form” (Erwin Panofski’s theory can be mentioned here).
The representation of time in the Romanian churches followed two well-known paths:
the linear representation and the circular representation, each with their own meaning. Many
of the painters of the monasteries in Moldavia opted for the linear representation of time,
starting from the principle according to which the world has a beginning and an end. Thus, in
Voroneţ and Suceviţa, Moldoviţa, Probota and Saint Dimitry (Suceava), time is represented as
a horizontal band, a large rotullus (or a volumen, more precisely) held at both ends by angels;
this plays the role of the empyrean where the planets and stars are placed, the sun, the moon,
as well as the zodiac signs. All these murals centre round an image of the Ancient of Days.
The Bible provides information about the Ancient of Days: “9I beheld till the thrones
were cast down, and the Ancient of days did sit, whose garment was white as snow, and the
hair of his head like the pure wool: his throne was like the fiery flame, and his wheels as
burning fire. 10 A fiery stream issued and came forth from before him: thousand thousands
ministered unto him, and ten thousand times ten thousand stood before him: the judgment was
set, and the books were opened.” [Daniel, 7.9-10]
The opinions regarding this excerpt from Daniel are divided. Some interpreters
consider that the Ancient of Days is God the Father. However, a similar description can be
found in the Apocalypse, describing the Son: “His head and hair were white like wool, as
white as snow” (Revelation, 1.14). For this reason, the interpetations of the theologians
provide the explanation according to which the two natures of Christ are both equally
contained in this image: His human nature (the Son of Man) and His divine nature (the
Ancient of Days).
40
1
Voroneţ Monastery was built in 1488, during the reign of Stephen the Great, but the outer murals was not
completed until 1547, during the reign of Petru Rareş and of metropolitan archbishop Grigore Roşca.
41
Probota Monastery
Unfortunately, along the time the painting was deteriorated due to fires, negligence or
ignorance. Across the sky painted in the manner described above, on either side of God the
father are placed the Sun, Sagittarius, Cancer, Aries, Pisces, Libra, Leo (to the left) and the
Moon, Taurus, Virgo, Scorpio, Capricorn, Gemini, Aquarius (to the right).
Similar to the paintings at Voroneţ, in terms of the manner of representation of the
zodiac signs, here are certain particularities: Capricorn is painted like a unicorn, more similar
to a horse than a goat. Aries is presented in a manner that makes it resemble a he-goat, while
Leo looks very much like a feline (on closer inspection, with facial features very similar to a
human face, one could say).
Moldoviţa Monastery2. While at Voroneţ and Probota the space allowed the unfolding
of the composition along one wall (or on the domed ceiling) and the visualization of the
whole is possible at one glance, at Moldoviţa Monastery the limited space in the open porch
forced the painters to compress images and to use optimally each inch of the wall; the
continuity is interrupted by arches, doors and windows.
2
The church was painted in 1537 by Moldavian painters of the time, trained by the famous Toma from Suceava.
He was the official artist at the court of Prince Petru Rareş, the founder of the monastery. Specialists assume the
that the painters’ names remained unknown becuase they refrained from signing their work for reasons of
Christian humility (Cf. Constantin Severin, Imperiul Sacru. Mănăstiri și biserici din nordul Moldovei, Editura
Paralela 45, București, 2003); this is a common feature for icon painters as well.
42
left (the left of the image), behind a stanchion and an arch, there are Aquarius, Pisces and
Taurus. Continuing these images, behind other stanchions and arches, there are the Sun,
Sagittarius and Libra(to the left), and, on the other side Scorpio, Virgo, Capricorn and the
Moon(to the right). It is interesting to note that some of the images – persons and animals –
are placed into what appears to be small boats, to suggest the almost liquid flow of the time
(as there is definitely no connection with the water signs); there are also representations that
follow the pattern of the Western iconography, where the body of the Taurus, Capricorn,
Aries and Leo end in a fish-like kind of tail. Such images are common in the compositions of
all the churches analysed in this paper (Voroneţ, Suceviţa, Sf. Dumitru, Probota).
St. Dimitry Church of Suceava was built in about same period as the Monastery of
Moldoviţa. As there are many similarities between the two in terms of architecture, the
hypothesis has been put forward that they were erected by the same team. The painting was
done between 1537 and 1538 and the inside murals are original. In the porch, however, the
images in the painting were damaged and were restored in 1997; although the restoration
work was done carefully, the overall result does no longer bear the mark of 16 th century
painting. The representation of the zodiac is similar to that in Voroneţ or Probota (on the
ceiling of the exonarthex): it is linear, flowing, without abrupt breaks caused by architectural
features. The order of the signs is different, however. A change can be traced in the
inscription: Latin characters are used when the name of Savaot, the Lord of the Hosts, is spellt
to indicate God the Father.
Suceviţa3. At the Monastery of Suceviţa the sign of the zodiac are also placed in the
porch, which is closed in this case; the signs are painted on two arches, delimiting the Last
Judgment on both sides. The choice was determined by the lack of more room. Six signs of
the zodiac are placed to the right, next to the Sun, while the other six are placed to the left,
together with the Moon. The scroll (volumen) is divided into two images, with each fragment
of the scroll folded by two angels and with representations of the Sun, Leo, Cancer, Gemini,
Taurus, Capricorn and Pisces on one side, and the Moon, Virgo, Libra, Sagittarius, Aries,
Scorpio and Aquarius on the other.
It is interesting to note that at Suceviţa Monastery, the zodiac can also be found in the
Pronaos. The common element of the iconography of all the monasteries in Northern
Moldavia is generally acknowledged: the images are arranged in such a manner as to form
narratives. The remarkable aspect here is that the painter chose to indicate the temporal
dimension of the scene depicted by means of a medallion in yellow ochre where a sign of the
zodiac is painted. All the important feasts and holidays in the calendar of a month are placed
horizontally and somewhere between these images the temporal clue is given. What could
have been the source of such a representation? The answer could be found in the fact that the
two painters of the monastery, the two brothers Sofronie and Ion, were well acquainted with
both Italian and Russian architecture and painting. It is well known that painted or sculpted
circular zodiac emblems were frequently used in Italian art under the influence of ancient
mosaics or cameos).
Monastery of Sveti Gavril Lesnovski4, Macedonia. In this church, the zodiac is placed
on the ceilinig of the narthex; its elements are on either side of the circular image of Jesus
Christ Pantocrator5. Unlike the paintings in other churches, here a large group of angels (not
organized according to the hierarchies) surround Jesus. Although a part of the fresco was
preserved and the colours are still fresh and clear, the rest has disappeared due to the damage
3
The founders of Suceviţa Monastery are the Movilă family and the painting of the church was completed in
1595, which is much later than the murals of the other monasteries.
4
The monastery in the village of Lesnovo, built in 1341 by the feudal lord Tyrant Oliver.
5
The fresoe at Lesnovo monastery was painted by four painters in two stages: between 1341 and 1346, and
between 1347 and 1349
43
of the wall. An angel riding a fantastic creature holds the Sun in both hands. Aries, Taurus,
Leo, Cancer and Gemini, as well as winged creatures hold in their hands or claws or paws a
kind of spiral-ending clubs or sticks. I initially hypothesized that they were angels; on closer
inspection, however, I remarked that they are no clad – a very strange detail indeed. Only the
Moon, Libra and Pisces can be still seen from the right side of the composition.
6
Hans Biedermann, Dicţionar de simboluri, Saeculum I.O., Bucureşti, 2002, p. 89
7
Chevalier J., Gheerbrant A., Dicţionar de simboluri, Editura Artemis, pp.176-178
8
The founder of this church was Prince Matei Basarab; the building was initiated in 1654 but it was completed
later by a High steward.
44
9
Much of the painting was altered in the 18th and 19th century.
Constantin Cihodaru, Gh. Platon, Istoria orașului Iași, vol. I, Editura Junimea, Iași, 1980, p. 349
10
45
the signs of the zodiac together with the Sun and the Moon. Many of the figures in the circle
are fantastic representations of the actual animals or persons (Leo, Sagittarius, Capricorn,
Aquarius, Aries, Taurus) and end in a spiralled tail.
46
Byzantine style specific of Moldavian church painting, rather he resorted to the Art Nouveau
manner (according to the fashion of the day). One other aspect that the artsits who restored the
church ignored was that the zodiac was placed next to the Creation of the world theme and
not together with the traditional Last Judgment / Apocalypse.
3. The zodiac and the works and activities associated to each month
What should be mentioned from the very beginning regarding the representations of
the Western zodiac (irrespective of the techniques used) is the presence of a number of
simple, popular elements; some of the forms even have grotesque or monstrous or inaccurate
shapes (most likely in the shapes imagined by those who painted them). Even if most of them
appear in Gothic cathedrals, it has to be stated that influences of Roman art can still be traced
in these drawings, with all its very popular representations of strange beasts and their didactic
and moralizing purpose.
The presence of the signs of the zodiac in the very space of the church was permitted
because they were correlated with a calendar of agricultural works and the types of activities
specific of each season and month. The Gothic style in architecture favoured large windows
decorated with stained glass; this is in fact the place where the most famous images related to
the zodiac appear (Chartres, Notre Dame de Paris, Angers). Along with such representations
on the inside of the church, reliefs of various degrees of complexity appear on the outer walls,
on tympanums, archs, archvolts (Chartres, Amiens,Autun, Issoire, Vezelay-Franţa, San
Isidoro-Spania, Domul din Lucca-Italia). In such stained glass windows, the signs of the
zodiac as a manner of marking a period of time by records of man’s agricultural works are
surveyed by a Christ Chronocrator from above ( as in Chartres or Soissons) or by Virgin
Mary and Her Son from the centre (as in Notre Dame of Paris). The cathedrals are also the
places where the zodiac appears in the technique of the mosaic (Pantaleone – Otranto, St.
Gudule – Bruxelles, Canterbury).
The graphic of the signs of the zodiac, of the months of the year and of the works
associated with them (either painted or sculpted) has many similar and also many different
elements in various geographical areas. They will be mentioned here.
January. The image presents either a man seated at table, feasting, with two cups in
front; it may well present the two-faced god Janus (one face directed towards the year that has
passed and one towards the year that is just beginning), the god of doors and gates, of the
11
Hans Biedermann, Dicţionar de simboluri, Editura Saeculum I.O., 2002, p. 415
47
feasts of passage and transitions (as in Notre Dame of Paris). Interestingly, in Chartres,
January has three faces: one directed towards the past, one towards the present and one
towards the past.
48
49
Bibliography:
Battistini Matilde, Astrology, Magic, and Alchemy in Art, Getty Publications, Los
Angeles, 2007
Biedermann Hans, Dicţionar de simboluri, Editura Saeculum I.O., Bucureşti, 2002
Chevalier J., Gheerbrant A., Dicţionar de simboluri, Editura Artemis, Bucureşti, 1993
Constantin Cihodaru, Gh. Platon, Istoria orașului Iași, vol. I, Editura Junimea, Iași,
1980
Cohen Simona, Transformations of Time and Temporality in Medieval and
Renaissance Art, Brill Academic Pub, 2014
Dionisie Pseudo-Areopagitul, Ierarhia cerească, Ierarhia bisericească, Editura
Institutul European, Iaşi, 1994
Henisch Bridget Ann, The Medieval Calendar Year, Pennsylvania State University
Press, 1999
Hourihane, Colum (ed.), Time in the Medieval World: Occupations of the Months and
Signs of the Zodiac in the Index of Christian Art, Pennsylvania State University Press, 2007
Severin Constantin, Imperiul Sacru. Mănăstiri și biserici din nordul Moldovei, Editura
Paralela 45, București, 2003
50