Antenna Exam
Antenna Exam
Tentamen består av 2 delar. Del A har tryckts på färgade papper och skall lösas utan att
använda läroboken. När du har inlämnat dom färgade arken med uppgifterna för del A
och dina svar på dessa uppgifter (senast 17:00), kan du ta fram läroboken för att lösa del
B.
Tillåtna hjälpmedel:
För del A:           Valfri räknedosa
För del B:           Matematiska Tabeller inkluderad Beta
                     Valfri räknedosa
                     Kildals lärobok “Foundations of Antennas: A Unified Approach
                     for LOS and Multipath”
(Boken kan innehålla egna notater skrivna på dom inbundna sidorna. Extra ark med
notater tillåts inte.)
    1.2. In Lab 2, you have measured a standard gain horn and a microstrip slot array
         antenna; see Fig. 1.1. The measured radiation patterns are shown in Fig. 1.2 and
         Fig. 1.3.
        1.2.1. Which of the two figures show radiation patterns for standard gain horn
               and which one for microstrip slot array antenna? Explain briefly.
        1.2.2. Please sketch (redraw) the patterns and mark which curve (blue or red in
               the original graphs) is for E-plane and which one is for H-plane. Explain
               briefly.
        1.2.3. In Fig. 1.2, the radiation pattern in one plane (red curve) has much broader
               beam width than the other, why?
        1.2.4. In Fig.1.3, the radiation pattern in one plane (red curve) has lower first
               sidelobe than the other, why?
        1.2.5. What is the length of the slot in the slot array antenna in mm? The
               operating frequency for the slot array is 9.5 GHz.
        1.2.6. As you know, the slot array antenna has the maximum radiation direction
               at 30o from the broadside. What is the maximum allowed spacing between
               the slots to avoid grating lobes? If you do not remember the complete
               formula, you can give the value for the full scan case. Explain.
    1.3. In Lab 3, you could choose to realize one of several different patch antennas; see
         Fig.1.4. Explain which polarization(s) each of these patch antenna shapes radiate,
         i.e. horizontal linear, vertical linear or circular, provided the dimensions are
         properly chosen.
Figure 1.2 Measured radiation patterns on both E- and H-planes for antenna 1
     Fig. 1.3 M
              Measured raadiation paatterns on b
                                               both E- and
                                                         d H-planes for antenn
                                                                             na 2
                                                                     λg/22
                                         λg/2
 λg/2
   /
                                                                                λg/2
                                                            λg/2
                                 λg/2
λg/2 λg/2
(d) (e)
                              F
                              Figure 1.4 different patch
                                                   p     anten
                                                             nnas.
Exam
   m in the coursse Antenna Enngineering, 20011-05-28                                  -5-
Name:
  2 Radiation ppatterns:
2.2
Exam
   m in the coursse Antenna En
                             ngineering, 20
                                          011-05-28                                                -7-
Nam
  me:
2.4
  4 Radiation ppatterns:
Exam
   m in the coursse Antenna En
                             ngineering, 20
                                          011-05-28   -8-
Nam
  me:
2.6
  6 Radiation ppatterns:
2.7
  7 Radiation ppatterns:
Exam
   m in the coursse Antenna En
                             ngineering, 20
                                          011-05-28   -9-
Name:
PART B (You can use the textbook to solve this problem, but
only after PART A has been delivered)
                                               0
                                          10
           Cumulative probability (CDF)
                                           -1
                                          10
                                                     Antenna 1, isolated
                                                                                     Antenna 2, isolated
                                                                                    Selection combined
                                           -2                                       antenna 1 & 2 when
                                          10
                                                                                    they are close to
                                                                                    each other
                                           -3
                                          10
                                               -30        -25      -20     -15      -10      -5       0    5
                                                                    Normalized power level (dB)
Figure 3.1. CDF:s for the two dipole antennas measured separately without the
            other antenna present and when placed close to each other when
            selection combination is used, respectively.
    3.1 Why are the CDF curves for antennas 1 and 2 different and what does this
        difference represents?
    3.2 In the figure, sketch how the CDF curves change for the two ports (branches)
        when the antennas are placed close to each other. Explain.
    3.3 What is the gain of using the two antennas and selection combining if we compare
        with using only antenna 1? Assume a CDF level of 1%.
    3.4 What is the gain of using the two antennas and selection combining if we compare
        with using an ideal reference antenna? Assume a CDF level of 1%.
    3.5 Assume that we know that the efficiency for each branch decreases by 5 dB when
        the antennas are closely spaced with the same spacing as for the diversity
        combined curve. Determine then the absolute value of the complex correlation
        coefficient between the two branches?
    3.6 Now, we have got an offer from an antenna vendor to buy a diversity antenna
        instead of using the two dipoles. The only information we have is that the antenna
        is lossless and that it has the equivalent circuit shown in the figure below. The
        values of the impedances in the figure are;
        Z11 = Z 22 = 82.4 + j 32.1 ; Z12 = Z 21 = 76.1 − j 0.7 ohm .
        What are the effective and apparent diversity gains of this antenna if selection
        combining and a CDF-level of 1% are assumed?
I1 Z11 Z 22 I2
    3.7 If Port 1 is excited with a generator with 50 ohm internal impedance and Port 2 is
        terminated with 50 ohm, how much power is dissipated in the 50 ohm load at Port
        2 and how much power is radiated?
  2 What are the values for the phaase shifters when the maximum radiation direction
4.2                                                                           d
    (main beaam directionn) is alongg the z-axiss? Here wee assume uuniform exccitations
    (V1=V2=VV3=V4).
4.3 Write the expression for the scan n impedancce of dipolee 3 under thhe condition  n of 4.2.
    (Here you do not neeed to produ  uce any num merical valuue. It is suffficient to write
                                                                                      w     the
    expressionn and explaiin the proceedure of youur derivatioon. All the pparameters you use
    should be kknown or easy
                          e    to obtaiin from form
                                                  mulas or figgures. Explaain which formulas
                                                                                      fo
    and figuress in the com
                          mpendium you
                                     y are usingg.)
4.4
  4 Write the expressionn of the em   mbedded raddiation field function of dipole 3 when
    dipole 3 iss excited annd the rest of
                                       o the dipolees are termiinated with loads (sam
                                                                                    me as the
    source imppedances) Z0. NOTE that now V1=V2=V4=0.         = (Here you do not need to
    produce anny numericaal value. It is sufficiennt to write the
                                                              t expressiion and expplain the
    procedure of your derrivation. Alll the parameters you usse should be known orr easy to
    obtain froom formulaas or figurres. Explaiin which formulas
                                                              f          annd figures in the
    compendiuum you are using.)
4.6
  6 Now we w want to steerr the main beam
                                      b   to 30o from the z--axis. What are now thee values
    of the phasse shifters? Are there any
                                      a grating lobes
                                                l     now? If yes, in w
                                                                      which direction?
Exam
   m in the coursse Antenna En
                             ngineering, 20
                                          011-05-28                                               - 13 -
Name:
Tentamen består av 2 delar. Del A har tryckts på färgade papper och skall lösas utan att
använda läroboken. När du har inlämnat dom färgade arken med uppgifterna för del A
och dina svar på dessa uppgifter (senast 17:00), kan du ta fram läroboken för att lösa del
B.
Tillåtna hjälpmedel:
För del A:           Valfri räknedosa
För del B:           Matematiska Tabeller inkluderad Beta
                     Valfri räknedosa
                     Kildals lärobok “Foundations of Antennas: A Unified Approach
                     for LOS and Multipath”
(Boken kan innehålla egna notater skrivna på dom inbundna sidorna. Extra ark med
notater tillåts inte.)
                Solution:
                A reverberation chamber emulates the multipath environment (due to
                multiple reflections…). An anechoic chamber emulates the free-space
                environment (no refection…). (Any answers explaining the correct physics
                will get full points.)
                Solution:
                We can measure the diversity gain, efficiency, MIMO capacity, TIS,
                TRP… in a reverberation chamber. (Mentioning three quantities is
                enough.) We can radiation pattern (CO & XP), gain, … in an anechoic
                chamber. (Mentioning one quantities is enough.)
                Solution:
                For an efficiency measurement, one need to first perform a reference
                measurement with a reference antenna with unity efficiency to get the
                average power level; then do an efficiency measurement with the antenna
                under test (AUT) to get another power level. The difference of the two
                power level (in dB) is the efficiency of the AUT. (Any correct
                measurement procedure for any application, e.g. diversity, TRP…, will get
                full points.)
    1.2. In Lab 2, you have measured a standard gain horn and a microstrip slot array
         antenna; see Fig. 1.1. The measured radiation patterns are shown in Fig. 1.2 and
         Fig. 1.3.
        1.2.1. Which of the two figures show radiation patterns for standard gain horn
               and which one for microstrip slot array antenna? Explain briefly. (2p)
Solution:
                Fig.1.2 is for microstrip slot array antenna, Fig1.3 is for standard gain
                horn. Because microstrip slot array antenna has very different beamwidth
                for E- and H-planes.
        1.2.2. Please sketch (redraw) the patterns and mark which curve (blue or red in
               the original graphs) is for E-plane and which one is for H-plane. Explain
               briefly. (2p)
                Solution:
                Blue curve in Fig.1.2 is for E-plane of microstrip slot array antenna, in
                Fig1.3 is for E-plane for standard gain horn. Red curves are for H-planes.
        1.2.3. In Fig. 1.2, the radiation pattern in one plane (red curve) has much broader
               beam width than the other, why? (3p)
                Solution:
                Size in H-plane is much smaller than that in E-plane.
        1.2.4. In Fig.1.3, the radiation pattern in one plane (red curve) has lower first
               sidelobe than the other, why? (3p)
                Solution:
                Tapered field distribution in H-plane.
        1.2.5. What is the length of the slot in the slot array antenna in mm? The
               operating frequency for the slot array is 9.5 GHz. (2p)
                Solution:
                                                      
                Half wavelength in free space. l         15.8mm
                                                      2
        1.2.6. As you know, the slot array antenna has the maximum radiation direction
               at 30o from the broadside. What is the maximum allowed spacing between
               the slots to avoid grating lobes? If you do not remember the complete
               formula, you can give the value for the full scan case. Explain. (2p)
                Solution:
                        
                d                21mm
                     1  cos 
    1.3. In Lab 3, you could choose to realize one of several different patch antennas; see
         Fig.1.4. Explain which polarization(s) each of these patch antenna shapes radiate,
         i.e. horizontal linear, vertical linear or circular, provided the dimensions are
         properly chosen. (4p)
         Solution:
         (a) Linear polar: vertical;
         (b) Linear polar: horizontal;
         (c) Dual-linear polar;
         (d) Circular polar;
         (e) Circular Polar;
                                         Blue
                                                                 Red
Figure 1.2 Measured radiation patterns on both E- and H-planes for antenna 1
Blue
Red
Fig. 1.3 Measured radiation patterns on both E- and H-planes for antenna 2
                                                                         λg/2
                                       λg/2
 λg/2
                                                                                λg/2
                                                          λg/2
                               λg/2
λg/2 λg/2
(d) (e)
Note that there may exist more than one solution for the same radiation pattern
requirement.
                               E-plane                    H-plane
      Solution: (4p)
      x-directed incremental electric current, dipole.
                            E-plane                     H-plane
    Solution: (4p)
    Two crossed incremental electric dipoles located in xy-plane and excited with 90
    deg phase difference: Huygen source, eleven antenna, incremental electric current
    located 0.25 wavelengths above infinite ground plane.
                                              E-plane              H-plane
2.3 Radiation patterns:
                            E-plane                     H-plane
    Solution: (4p)
    Waveguide slot antenna (assume infinite ground plane), PIFA:
                                                 E-plane                H-plane
2.4 Radiation patterns:
                             E-plane                       H-plane
    Solution: (4p)
    Edge-fed microstrip antenna on high permittivity substrate (top view):
                                               E-plane                  H-plane
2.5 Radiation patterns:
                           E-plane                       H-plane
    Solution: (3p)
    Long pyramidal horn antenna with quadratic aperture fed by TE10 rectangular
    waveguide mode:
E-plane H-plane
E-plane H-plane
    Solution: (3p)
    x-directed incremental electric current located 0.25 wavelengths above infinite
    ground plane, Huygen source:
         z
                                   0dB
                                                                              0dB
                   y
                       x
                                   -20dB -10dB
-20dB -10dB
    a) Polarization:
    b) E-plane:
        H-plane:
                                                 -180°           0°    180°                 -180°           0°    180°
                                                         c) xz-plane                                d) yz-plane
    OR
    Long pyramidal horn antenna with quadratic aperture with soft surfaces on all
    walls, conical horn corrugated.
                          E-plane                    H-plane
    Solution: (3p)
    Long pyramidal horn antenna with quadratic aperture with hard surfaces on all
    walls. Small arrays is also a possible answer.
PART B (You can use the textbook to solve this problem, but
only after PART A has been delivered)
                                               0
                                          10
           Cumulative probability (CDF)
                                               -1
                                          10
                                                     Antenna 1, isolated
                                                                                     Antenna 2, isolated
                                                                                    Selection combined
                                               -2                                   antenna 1 & 2 when
                                          10
                                                                                    they are close to
                                                                                    each other
                                               -3
                                          10
                                               -30        -25      -20     -15      -10      -5       0    5
                                                                    Normalized power level (dB)
Figure 3.1. CDF:s for the two dipole antennas measured separately without the
            other antenna present and when placed close to each other when
            selection combination is used, respectively.
    3.1 Why are the CDF curves for antennas 1 and 2 different and what does this
        difference represents?
        Solution: (2p)
        The reason for the different CDF curves is that the two antennas have different
        efficiencies. The horizontal distance between the two curves represents the
        difference in efficiency, from the figure it can be seen to be 3 dB.
    3.2 In the figure, sketch how the CDF curves change for the two ports (branches)
        when the antennas are placed close to each other. Explain.
        Solution: (4p)
        See figure.
        - The curves for the two branches should be shifted to the left (2p)
        - The two curves should be shifted equally much (2p)
                                             0
                                        10
                                                                  Branch 2 (ant. 2)
         Cumulative probability (CDF)
                                                    Branch 1 (ant. 1)
                                             -1
                                        10
                                                   Antenna 1, isolated
                                                                                       Antenna 2, isolated
                                                                                      Selection combined
                                             -2                                       antenna 1 & 2 when
                                        10
                                                                                      they are close to
                                                                                      each other
                                             -3
                                        10
                                             -30        -25      -20      -15         -10     -5        0    5
                                                                  Normalized power level (dB)
    3.3 What is the gain of using the two antennas and selection combining if we compare
        with using only antenna 1? Assume a CDF level of 1%.
        Solution: (2p)
        From the figure the diversity gain can be seen to be approx. 7 dB.
    3.4 What is the gain of using the two antennas and selection combining if we compare
        with using an ideal reference antenna? Assume a CDF level of 1%.
        Solution: (3p)
        - From the figure the diversity gain can be seen to be approx. 4 dB (2p)
        - It should be realized that antenna 2 represents an ideal reference since it has 0
        dB efficiency (1p)
    3.5 Assume that we know that the efficiency for each branch decreases by 5 dB when
        the antennas are closely spaced with the same spacing as for the diversity
        combined curve. Determine then the absolute value of the complex correlation
        coefficient between the two branches?
        Solution: (3p)
        The apparent diversity gain is given by equation 3.12 in the book, i.e.
        Gapp  10 1   (note that it is Ok to use other, better, formulas for the apparent
                         2
        diversity gain). Since the efficiency has decreased 5 dB due to that the antennas
        are closely spaced as compared to when they are far apart the apparent diversity
        gain is 5+4=9 dB (from d). Thus, we have Gapp  109 10  10 1      0.61
                                                                          2
    3.6 Now, we have got an offer from an antenna vendor to buy a diversity antenna
        instead of using the two dipoles. The only information we have is that the antenna
        is lossless and that it has the equivalent circuit shown in the figure below. The
        values of the impedances in the figure are
        Z11  Z22  82.4  j32.1 ; Z12  Z21  76.1  j 0.7 ohm .
        What are the effective and apparent diversity gains of this antenna if selection
        combining and a CDF-level of 1% are assumed?
I1 Z11 Z22 I2
        Solution: (6p)
        The apparent diversity gain can be obtained from the knowledge of the
        correlation coefficient which in turn, since the antenna is lossless, can be
        calculated from the S-parameters as given by equation 3.10 in the book (note
        that there is an error in the book, it should be a square root in the denominator,
        it is however Ok if the expression in the book is used). Thus, the first thing we
        have to do is to determine the S-parameters. For the given problem
         Z11  Z22 and Z12  Z21 so that S11  S22 and S12  S21 .
         S11 and S21 can be determined from the following circuit;
50 I1 Z11 Z22 I2
                                 V1                                                           V2
U +
  _                                             Z12 I 2       +_                +_   Z21I1              50
                                                                                                  
                                 V 1                                                           V  2
        Since port 2 is terminated in 50 ohm V2  0 and we have the following relations;
            V1          V2
        S11  
                , S 21    
                             , V2  V2
            V1           V1
                                    U                U
        We also know that V1           V1  V1 
                                     2               2
        We can now express the S-parameters in the total voltages as;
                       2V1                  2V
        S11  S22          1 , S12  S21  2
                       U                     U
        The currents in the left and right loops can be determined as;
               U  Z12 I 2          Z 21 I1
        I1                , I2 
                Z11  50          Z 22  50
        Solving for the currents gives;
                             Z 22  50                                           Z 21
        I1  U                                        , I 2  U
                  Z11  50  Z 22  50   Z12 Z 21             Z11  50  Z 22  50   Z12 Z 21
        We can now calculate the port voltages as;
                                            Z11  Z 22  50   Z12 Z 21
        V1  Z11 I1  Z12 I 2  U
                                      Z11  50  Z 22  50   Z12 Z 21
                                          50Z 21
        V2  50 I 2  U
                             Z11  50  Z 22  50   Z12 Z 21
        The S-parameters are now given by;
                            Z11  Z 22  50   Z12 Z 21
        S11  S22  2                                               1  0.10  j 0.42
                         Z11  50  Z 22  50   Z12 Z 21
                                   100Z 21
        S12  S21                                          0.43  j 0.35
                        11
                        Z    50  Z 22  50   Z12 Z 21
        Now, when we have the S-parameters we can compute the absolute value of the
        complex correlation coefficient by using equation 3.10 in the book (or rather the
        correct version of the equation).
                                 S11* S12  S21
                                             *
                                                S22
                                                                           0.41
                          2
                  1  S11  S21
                                        2
                                                     2
                                              1  S22  S12
                                                                   2
                                                                       
        The apparent diversity gain is given by equation 3.12 in the book;
        Gapp  10 1    9.12  9.60 dB
                             2
        The effective diversity gain is defined as the apparent diversity gain multiplied
        with the radiation efficiency, equation 3.11. We have by using equation 3.7;
                           
        Geff  erad Gapp  1  S11  S21
                                            2          2
                                                           10 1     2
                                                                            4.61  6.64 dB
    3.7 If Port 1 is excited with a generator with 50 ohm internal impedance and Port 2 is
        terminated with 50 ohm, how much power is dissipated in the 50 ohm load at Port
        2 and how much power is radiated?
        Solution: (5p)
                                                                                            2
        The power terminated in the 50 ohm load at Port 2 is given by; Pterm 2  Pavail S21
        Where the available power is the power the generator can deliver in a matched
                                    2
                               U
        load, i.e. Pavail 
                               200 (where RMS-value for the voltage is assumed).
        Thus,
                                                  2
                                                                                   0.43  j 0.35
                                                                                                           2
                                            S21
                                                       From (f)  U                                          1.54  103 U
                           2            2                                      2                                                 2
        Pterm 2  Pavail S 21  U
                                            200                                           200
        Since the antenna is lossless the radiated power is given by;
                                                                           
                       Prad  Pavail  Prefl  Pterm 2  Pavail 1  S11  S 21
                                                                                      2            2
                                                                                                       
                               1  0.10  j0.42                                                2.52 10
                                2
                           U                                   2                          2                      3       2
                                                                   0.43  j 0.35                                    U
                           200
Solution (5p)
4.2 What are the values for the phase shifters when the maximum radiation direction
    (main beam direction) is along the z-axis? Here we assume uniform excitations
    (V1=V2=V3=V4).
    Solution (4p)
    Φ1= Φ2= Φ3 =Φ4=0
4.3 Write the expression for the scan impedance of dipole 3 under the condition of 4.2.
    (Here you do not need to produce any numerical value. It is sufficient to write the
    expression and explain the procedure of your derivation. All the parameters you use
    should be known or easy to obtain from formulas or figures. Explain which formulas
    and figures in the compendium you are using.)
    Solution (4p)
     We define the followings
           V1  V           I1       Z11  Z 0    Z12        Z13        Z14 
           V  V           I         Z         Z 22  Z 0    Z 23       Z 24 
     Vex   2     , I   2 , Z        21
           V3  V           I3       Z 31         Z 32    Z 33  Z 0    Z 34 
                                                                               
           V4  V          I4        Z 41         Z 42       Z 43    Z 44  Z 0 
    Where all Zij  Z ji can be found by using Fig. 10.9 in Per-Simon’s book and Vex is known.
    So we have
    Vex  ZI                  I  Z1Vex
    Now I is solved. Then,
                  V
        Z 3 scan   Z 0
                  I3
4.4 Write the expression of the embedded radiation field function of dipole 3 when
    dipole 3 is excited and the rest of the dipoles are terminated with loads (same as the
    source impedances) Z0. NOTE that now V1=V2=V4=0. (Here you do not need to
    produce any numerical value. It is sufficient to write the expression and explain the
    procedure of your derivation. All the parameters you use should be known or easy to
    obtain from formulas or figures. Explain which formulas and figures in the
    compendium you are using.)
    Solution (4p)
     We have now
          V1   0         I1        Z11  Z 0    Z12        Z13        Z14 
          V   0         I          Z         Z 22  Z 0    Z 23       Z 24 
     
    Vex   2
                      
                      , I    2
                                   , Z      21
          V3  V          I3        Z 31         Z 32    Z 33  Z 0    Z 34 
                                                                              
          V4   0        I4         Z 41         Z 42       Z 43    Z 44  Z 0 
    Where all Zij  Z ji can be found by using Fig. 10.9 in Per-Simon’s                  book and Vex is
    known. So we have
                  I  Z1Vex
    Now I is solved. Then, from (5.11) in Per-Simon’s book, we have the radiation
    function of a halfwave dipole at the origin of the coordinate system as G dx  ,   with
    a current of I0. Note that now ˆl  xˆ so (5.11) should be modified a bit. Then, the
    embedded radiation function for dipole 3 is
                                                 I1 jkr1 r                I                          I                          I
     G d 3 _ embedded  ,    G dx  ,        e         G dx  ,   2 e jkr2 r  G dx  ,   3 e jkr3 r  G dx  ,   4 e jkr4 r
                                                 I0                         I0                          I0                          I0
4.5 Write the expression for the radiation field function of the whole array.
    Solution (4p)
    Almost the same as the above expression but we should use I instead of I .
                                            I1 jkr1 r                I                           I                          I
     GWholeArray  ,    G dx  ,        e        G dx  ,   2 e jkr2 r  G dx  ,   3 e jkr3 r  G dx  ,  4 e jkr4 r
                                            I0                        I0                          I0                         I0
4.6 Now we want to steer the main beam to 30o from the z-axis. What are now the values
    of the phase shifters? Are there any grating lobes now? If yes, in which direction?
    Solution (4p)
    From (10.22), we have
                        
          cos  0  
                        kd a
    Now       0  60o , kda  1.4                   so          cos 0 kda  0.7
    So phase shifters are         0, 0.7 , 1.4 , 2.1 , respectively.
    Now there is a grating lobe, at
                                 
     1  cos 1 cos 60o             cos
                                                 1
                                                       0.5  1.43  cos 1  0.9286   158.2o
                                 da