PRELIMINARIES                         Exceptions to the rule that the place where the    Original Jurisdiction of the Sandiganbayan:
crime is committed determines jurisdiction:        1. Listed:
Jurisdiction over Person of Accused (AV)                     1. Transitory and continuing offenses           a. Provincial governors, vice-governors,
    - Arrest                                                 2. RPC Art. 2 – where criminal action                members of the sangguniang
    - Voluntary Surrender in court                              is first filed                                    panlalawigan        and     provincial
                                                             3. Human Security Act                                treasurers, assessors, engineers and
VENUE of Criminal Action                                                                                          other provincial department heads;
    In the court where the (CE)                   RPC Art. 2 – Exception to territoriality (SCINE)          b. City mayors, vice-mayors, members
           1) offense was committed                    1. Philippine airships and ships                           of the sangguniang panlungsod, city
           2) its     essential      ingredients       2. Forgery or counterfeiting of Philippine                 treasurers, assessors engineers and
               occurred                                     notes or Gov’t obligations and                        other city department heads;
    Determined by allegations in the C/I                   securities                                       c. Officials of the diplomatic service
    Vehicle = passed, departure, arrival              3. Introduction of said notes or                           occupying the position of consul and
      (PDA)                                                 obligations and security into the                     higher;
    On board a vessel = (1) FIRST point of                 Philippines                                      d. Philippine army and air force
      entry (2) any territory passed                   4. Crimes against national security and                    colonels, naval captains, and all
    Outside the PH but punishable under                    law of nations                                        officers of higher rank;
      Art. 2, RPC = where criminal action              5. Public       officers  and employees               e. Officers of the Philippine National
      FIRST filed                                           committing an offense in the exercise                 Police while occupying the position
    Continuing offenses – estafa, abduction,               of their functions                                    of provincial director and those
      malversation, libel, kidnapping, BP 22                                                                      holding the rank of senior
           o Courts of the territories where       Criminal Jurisdiction of Courts                                superintendent or higher;
               the essential ingredients of the        a) MTC (BOP 64)                                       f. City and provincial prosecutors and
               crime     took     place    have                1. Violations of BP 22                             their assistants, and officials and
               concurrent jurisdiction                         2. Violations of city/municipal                    prosecutors in the Office of the
                                                                   Ordinances                                     Ombudsman and special prosecutor;
Written Defamation (in RTC)                                    3. EOJ over damage to Property                g. Presidents, directors or trustees, or
    GR: First printed and published                               through criminal negligence                    managers of government-owned or
    Private individual – resides at time of                   4. Offenses < 6 years                              -controlled     corporations,   state
       crime                                                   5. Fine < 4,000                                    universities       or     educational
    Public officer – RTC where he held                b) RTC (MWEEDO)                                            institutions or foundations;
       office at time of crime                                 1. Money-laundering cases              2. Members of Congress and officials thereof
                                                               2. Written defamation                      classified as Grade 27 and up;
Note:                                                          3. Cases not falling within EOJ of     3. Members of the judiciary without prejudice
    If wrong venue, can file a MOTION TO                          any court, tribunal or body            to the provisions of the Constitution;
      QUASH, on the ground of no jurisdiction                  4. Violation of Omnibus Election       4. Chairmen and members of Constitutional
    Venue is jurisdictional; hence, it can be                     Code                                   Commissions, without prejudice to the
      raised at anytime, even during appeal.                   5. Dangerous Drugs Act                     provisions of the Constitution; and
                                                               6. Hold-Departure Orders
                                                                                                              Vanslembrouck CrimPro Memory Aid |1
5. All other national and local officials        Admin cases in the OMB are not appealable            2. Municipal ordinance – 2M
   classified as Grade 27 and higher             (unless GADALEJ) if:                                 3. Election law – 5Y
6. Other offenses or felonies whether simple         1. Public censure or reprimand                   4. Genocide – Never
   or complexed with other crimes committed          2. Suspension of not more than 1 month
   by the public officials and employees             3. Fine if not more than 1 month salary          Complaint / Information S2 (WPPRO)
   mentioned                                                                                             - CI shall be in writing
7. Civil and criminal cases filed pursuant to    Powers of the SOJ:                                      - In the name of People of the Phil.
   and in connection with Executive Order           1. Direct control and supervision over               - Against all persons
   Nos. 1, 2, 14 and 14RA, issued in 1986               prosecutors                                      - Who appear to be responsible
                                                    2. Act directly whenever a specific                  - For the offense.
Sandiganbayan (GR-epol)                                 function is entrusted by law or
   - At least salary grade 27                           regulation to a subordinate                   Complaint S3 (SPOPE)
   - Act was committed in relation to office        3. Direct performance of duty                        - Sworn written statement
   - Other executive officials by express           4. Approve, revise, modify acts and                  - Charging a person with an offense
       provision of law (epol)                          decisions of subordinate officials or            - Subscribed by the offended party
   - As long as one of the accused                      units                                            - Any peace officer, or other public
                                                 Representation of the people:                              officer
In Relation to Office (CWO)                         1. RTC/MTC – Fiscal or Prosecutor                    - Charged with the enforcement of the
    - office is a constitutive element of the       2. CA/SC – Office of the Solicitor General              law violated
        offense
    - Without the office the crime would not                        RULE 110                          Information S4 (APOP-C)
        have been committed.                                  Prosecution of Offenses                     - An accusation in writing
                                                                                                          - Charging a person with an offense
OMB Jurisdiction:                                How are Criminal Actions Instituted                      - Subscribed by the prosecutor
  1. Any malfeasance/misfeasance/omission                          MM/Chartered    OMM / Outside          - And filed with the court
                                                                   Cities          Chartered Cities
      by a public officer (even not related to
                                                                   Office of the   Office of the
      official duties)                              With PI
                                                                   Prosecutor      Prosecutor         Who Must Prosecute Criminal Action S5 (CC-
  2. Primary       jurisdiction  over    cases      NO PI          OP              OP/MTC             PDP)
      cognizable by the SB (may take over at        Summary
                                                                   OP              OP/MTC
                                                                                                         - All criminal actions
      any stage)                                    Procedure                                            - Either commenced by C/I
  3. Jurisdiction over cases cognizable by                                                               - Shall be prosecuted
      regular courts                             Prescription of offenses (interrupted by any            - Under the direction and control
                                                 proceeding, including executive):                       - Of a public prosecutor
Reviewing actions by the OMB:                    1. Act 3326 (SPL):
   1. Admin case – CA Rule 43                            a. Fine and imprisonment up to 1M –          Note: Matters of presentation of witnesses by
   2. Criminal case with GADALEJ – SC Rule                   1Y                                       the prosecution and the determination of which
       65                                                b. If more than 1M, less than 2Y – 4Y        evidence to present rests upon the prosecution.
                                                         c. If 2Y or more, less than 6Y – 8Y
                                                         d. If 6Y or more, except treason – 12Y
                                                                                                             Vanslembrouck CrimPro Memory Aid |2
Duties of a public prosecutor:                  But note that as a general rule, A complaint for   Note:
   1. Conduct PI                                purpose of PI can be filed by ANY competent           - If he fails to object before plea/trial, he
   2. Prosecute a case                          person (unless cannot be prosecuted de oficio).          is deemed to have waived such.
   3. Conduct Inquest proceedings
                                                Requisites of A Complaint/Information: S6          Amendment of C/I
Private Crimes – need complaint filed by an     (NDA-NDP)                                             Amendment – adding/ striking out /
OFFENDED party. (MTQ if by prosecutor)             - Name of the accused                                correcting an ALLEGATION or NAME of
                                                   - Designation of the offense given by                party (ASCAN)
Private Crimes: (CA SAL D)                              statute (or section)                          Formal – not prejudicial to accused
    1. Concubinage                                           Qualifying circumstance                 Substantial – prejudicial
    2. Adultery                                              Aggravating circumstance
    3. Seduction                                   - Acts and omissions complained of              Test WON Formal/ Substantial Amendment
    4. Abduction                                   - Name of offended party                            - WON DEFENSE / EVIDENCE under
    5. Acts of Lasciviousness                      - Approximate date of the commission of                original would be equally available
    6. Defamation which consists of the                 the offense                                       after?
        imputation of any of the above             - Place where the offense was committed                    o Yes = formal; No =substantial
        offenses.                                       (within court’s jurisdiction)                  - WON changed the designation of the
                                                                                                          nature of the crime?
Note:                                           Remedy for Insufficiency of Information:
   - Minor, Parents, grandparents, and             - Bill of particulars                           Rules Regarding Amendments
      guardians if minor for SAL.                  - Motion to Quash information                       - Before plea = formal / substantial
   - No prosecution if expressly pardoned                                                                  WITHOUT leave of court
      by any                                    Name of Party: Full, appellation/nickname,                XPN: (DEMOL)
   - Minor Dies/ incapacitated = State          described under fictitious name.                               o Downgrades the offense
                                                                                                               o Excludes any of the accused
Prosecution of Adultery and Concubinage         Offended Party - the person against whom or                    o Made only by:
(BCPC)                                          against whose property the offense was                                  motion by prosecutor,
-the offended party cannot institute criminal   committed (S12)                                                         notice offended party
action if:                                                                                                              with leave of court
    1. Without including BOTH guilty parties    Offenses Against Property (UPO)                        - After plea = formal ONLY, never
         (if alive)                                 - Name unknown, property must be                       substantial
    2. Offended party has consented or                 described with                                          o WITH leave of court
         pardoned the offenders                     - Such particularity as to properly identify               o Not prejudice rights of accused
    3. Without the complaint filed by the              the offense charged
         offended spouse                                                                           Note: In exclusion of an accused (which is done
                                                A complaint or information must charge only        before arraignment) double jeopardy will NOT
Offended spouse: ALWAYS the HUSBAND of the      one offense, except when the law: S13 (SV)         attach, (e.g. WPP) but in DISCHARGE of a
adulterous woman                                   - Prescribes a single punishment                witness as state witness, it will, as he has to
                                                   - For various offenses                          plead and it is technically an acquittal.
                                                                                                           Vanslembrouck CrimPro Memory Aid |3
                                                                 Private lawyer prosecute a criminal case?             New PI needed if: (SSPPCC)
Substitution of Complaint / Information                              - Authorized in writing (CRC)                        1. Substitution of information (unless
    Substitution – dismissal by the court of                                o Chief of Prosecution Office                    merely mode of commission)
        the ORIGINAL CI upon the filing of a                                 o Regional State Prosecutor                  2. Substantial      amendment      to    the
        new one charging the proper offense                                  o Approval of court                              information
        provided the accused would NOT be                            - If Civil action instituted with the                3. Provisional dismissal when the original
        placed in double jeopardy.                                       criminal action (S15) (But still with the            witness recanted or died or is no longer
    WHEN: Anytime before judgment                                       control of public prosecutor)                        available or when new witnesses
    WHY: If it appears that                                                                                                  appear
            1. Mistake in charging the proper                    Requisites for double jeopardy: (CJA-ACMW-               4. Other persons are charged under a new
                offense                                          IFI)                                                         complaint for the same offense or
            2. Accused cannot be convicted of                         1. First jeopardy must have attached:                   complaint
                the offense charged / offense                            (CJA)                                            5. Under a new complaint, original charge
                included therein                                              a. Upon              a           valid          is upgraded
    May be done before and after plea                                            complaint/indictment                    6. Under a new complaint, criminal
                                                                              b. Before a court with competent                participation is upgraded
                                                                                  jurisdiction
        AMENDMENT                      SUBSTITUTION                           c. After arraignment                                    RULE 111
Formal       /    substantial    Substantial change                   2. First jeopardy terminated: (ACMW)                    Prosecution of Civil Action
changes                                                                       a. Acquittal
Before plea can be made          ALWAYS with leave of court                                                            Rule on Implied Institution of the Civil Action
without leave of court
                                                                              b. Final conviction
If formal amendment                                                           c. Dismissal on its merits               With the Criminal Action
- NO need for another PI         -NEED for new PI                             d. Dismissal     without       express       - civil action for recovery of civil liability
- No need for new plea           -NEED for new Plea                               consent of accused                          arising from the offense (carclao) shall
An amended information           A substitution                       3. Second jeopardy must be for the same                 be deemed instituted with the criminal
- Refers         to    SAME      - New            information
                                                                         offense as that in the first: (IFI)                  action UNLESS: (WPR!)
      offense as charged in           involves a DIFFERENT
      the             original        offense                                 a. One offense is identical to the                   1. Waiver of civil action
      information OR             - Does not include or is                         another (unless a set of acts                    2. Institutes it prior to the criminal
- An offense which                    not          necessarily                    constitute two or more                               action
      necessarily includes or         included in the original                                                                     3. Reserves the right to institute it
                                                                                  offenses, termination of one
      is included in the              charge
      original charge                                                             does not bar prosecution under                       separately (except BP22)
                                 Hence, CANNOT         invoke                     the other)
Hence,             substantial   double jeopardy.                             b. One is an attempt or frustration      Reservation (ECRO)
amendments CANNOT be                                                              of another                              - made BEFORE prosecution starts
made over the accused’s
                                                                              c. One necessarily includes or is               presenting its evidence
objection, for if the original
information withdrawn, the                                                        necessarily included in the             - under circumstances affording the
accused     could      invoke                                                     other                                       offended      party     a   reasonable
double jeopardy.                                                                                                              opportunity to make a reservation
                                                                                                                               Vanslembrouck CrimPro Memory Aid |4
Effects of the Commencement of the Criminal           Instances of Independent Civil Action:               Elements of a Prejudicial Question (PID)
Action upon the Separate Civil Action                     1) Art. 32 - Interference by public officers        1) Previously instituted civil action
(DeSuCoT)                                                     or employees / private individuals with         2) Civil action involves an issue similar or
     1) Deferment – separate civil action can’t               civil rights and liberties                          intimately related (sir) to the issue
         be instituted until final judgment               2) Art. 33 – Defamation, Fraud, Physical                raised in the subsequent criminal action
     2) Suspension – crim action after civil;                 Injuries                                        3) The resolution of such issue determines
         until final judgment                             3) Art. 34 – failure to aid by police                   WON the criminal action may proceed
     3) Consolidation (MIB)                               4) Art. 2176 – Whoever by act or omission
              Motion of the offended party                   causes damage to another, there being        Note: Suspends criminal action. Filed in Office
              In court trying criminal action                fault or negligence, is obliged to pay for   of the Prosecutor/Court before prosecution
              Before judgment on civil action                the damage done.                             rests.
              Evidence               automatically
                  reproduced, can still cross-        Note: No counterclaim, cross-claim or third                      RULE 112
                  examine and present additional      party complaint by accused in criminal case, but        PRELIMINARY INVESTIGATION
                  evidence                            any cause of action which could have been the
     4) Tolling of Prescriptive Period                subject thereof may be litigated in a separate       Preliminary Investigation (ISB-CGH)
              Of civil action which cannot be        civil action.                                            - An inquiry to determine
                  instituted / suspended                                                                       - Whether there is sufficient ground
Civil Action If Accused ACQUITTED (ROC-DI)            Note: Judgment in civil action not a bar for             - To engender a well-founded belief
     - If based on reasonable doubt – civil           criminal action.                                         - That a crime has been committed
         action may still be instituted                                                                        - And the respondent is guilty thereof
     - If based on ground that he did not             Rules on death of accused:                               - And should be held for trial
         commit offense – no more civil action            1. Death after arraignment and during                - 4 Y, 2M, 1 Day
           XPN: (DI)                                         pendency of criminal action:
             o Civil action based on obligation                  a. Criminal liability extinguished        Probable Cause – existence of such facts and
                  not from the delict (LCQQ)                     b. Civil liability arising from the       circumstances as would lead a reasonable
             o Law grants the right to institute                     delict extinguished (XPN: LCQQ)       person to believe that the persons charged
                  independent civil action                       c. Independent         Civil   action     committed the crime
     - Court declares that liability of the                          continues against the estate or
         accused is only CIVIL – civil liability                     legal representative of the           Persons Authorized to Conduct Preliminary
                                                                     accused                               Investigation (PCA NaRel)
Independent Civil Action (IPR-DS)                         2. Death before arraignment                          1) Provincial or City Prosecutors and their
     When        carclao     may      proceed               a. Case dismissed                                     Assistants
       independently (side by side with crim a)              b. No prejudice to any civil action that          2) National and Regional State Prosecutors
                                                                 may be filed                                  3) Other officers as may be authorized by
     Preponderance of evidence
                                                                                                                   law
     No reservation needed
     No double recovery
                                                                                                           Note: MTQ if Resolution not approved by City
     Not suspended
                                                                                                           Prosecutor.
                                                                                                                  Vanslembrouck CrimPro Memory Aid |5
Filing of preliminary investigation – all 10 day      Effect of Appeal to the DOJ                          Summary Procedure (e.g. BP 22 cases) (ACS)
periods:                                                  - Will NOT hold the filing of the                   1. Submission of Judicial Affidavits
     1. File complaint (subscribed before                     information                                     2. Subject to cross – examination
         prosecutor or government official)               - If the information already filed, the             3. No NEED to issue warrant of arrest, only
             a. Except – if not prosecutor or                 appeal to the DOJ will defer                       summons
                 official available                           arraignment for 60 days (motion to              4. However, repeated failure to appear,
     2. Investigating officer dismisses or issues             defer)                                             can then issue WOA
         subpoena to respondent                           - Arraigned AFTER appeal: DOJ can still
     3. Respondent submits counter-affidavit                  act (but it really is useless, since court   Records of Preliminary Investigation
             a. If none – officer decides based               already has jurisdiction)                    - GR: Do NOT form part of the records of the
                 on complaint                             - Arraigned BEFORE appeal: petition not             case
             b. If there is – officer can call a              given due course.                            - XPN: Court’s initiative / OR on motion of
                 clarificatory hearing                                                                        any party, may order when: (CORE)
     4. Officer’s resolution (filing information      If DOJ decision is adverse:                                      1) Necessary in the resolution of
         or dismissal)                                    1. Review via Rule 43 to CA                                      case
                                                          2. If GADALEJ – Rule 65 to CA                                2) To be introduced as evidence
Review of the resolution of investigating                 3. Office of the President if punishable by                      by the requesting party
prosecutor:                                                   RP or higher                                 - Note: Unless there is an appropriate COURT
1. Resolution forwarded to city (or provincial                                                                ORDER, the mere fact that the said records
    or state) prosecutor or OMB                       Information filed in court – RTC judge options:         have been physically attached does not
         a. If recommendation is for dismissal,       (DIE) within 10 days                                    mean that it is already part of the record.
             but it is disapproved, boss can:             1. Dismiss the case for absence of
                   i. File info himself; or                   probable cause                               Inquest (nSFW)
                  ii. Direct another prosecutor           2. Issue a warrant of arrest (or                     - summary and Formal investigation by
                       to file without need for new           commitment order) within 10 days,                    an inquest prosecutor in cases of
                       PI                                     after personally determining probable                warrantless arrest
         b. If recommendation is for filing –                 cause                                            - Purpose: Determine WON warrantless
             needs approval by boss                       3. In case of doubt of the existence of                  arrest valid.
2. Resolution may be appealed to the office of                probable cause, may order the                    - will decide WON:
    the SOJ within 15 days via verified petition              prosecutor to present additional                         o To detain you (subsequently
    for review                                                EVIDENCE                                                      charged in court)
3. Parties can file a petition with SOJ to                                                                             o Release for further PI (go
    reverse or modify the resolution, SOJ can:        Warrant of Arrest Unnecessary (SFC)                                   through Sec. 3, affidavit of
         a.      Ask prosecutor to file info             1) Accused is already under custody by                             arresting officer)
                 without need of new PI or                  virtue of a warrantless arrest                     - A C/I may still be validly filed, even if
         b.      Ask prosecutor to dismiss the           2) Offense is penalized by a fine only                    there is need for PI if there has already
                 info                                    3) If it is covered by the Rule on Summary                been an inquest
                                                            Procedure (may be arrested though if
                                                            fails to appear)
                                                                                                                   Vanslembrouck CrimPro Memory Aid |6
Requisites for inquest proceeding:                  Investigatory Procedure for Cases NOT                                 RULE 113
   1. Warrantless arrest                            requiring PI                                                          ARREST
   2. Offense requires PI                               a) Complaint Filed with Prosecutor (FED) –
                                                            Sec. 3(a) R112 only                          Arrest (CBCO)
Options when lawfully arrested w/o warrant                  -act on it within 10 days from filling (no       - Taking of person into custody
and brought to police station: (IBP-125)                    counter-affidavits/subpoena)                     - in order that he may be bound
   1. Inquest proceedings                                        1) May dismiss the case for want            - to answer for the commission of an
   2. Apply for bail                                                 of probable cause                           offense
   3. If detained and before complaint or info                   2) He may file the corresponding
       is filed, you can go for PI, but you waive                    information upon existence of       An Arrest Is Made By:
       Rule 125                                                      probable cause                         1) Actual restraint
   4. If info already filed without PI – you can                 3) Require additional evidence.            2) Submission to the custody of the
       ask for PI                                       b) Complaint Filed with the MTC                         person making the Arrest
                                                            -judge shall act within 10 days
Note:                                                            1) May dismiss the case for want        When May A Warrantless Arrest Be Lawfully
   - In the absence or unavailability of the                         of probable cause                   Made? (JPE)
      inquest prosecutor, fled directly with                     2) Require additional evidence          - a peace officer or a private person may,
      the court on basis of affidavit of:                            and within 10 days from notice,     without a warrant, arrest a person (JPE)
          o Offended party                                           determine WON there is                  1) When in his presence, the person to be
          o Arresting officer / Person                               probable cause.                            arrested has committed, is actually
   - Also filed in MTC if warrantless arrest                     3) Issue a warrant of arrest /                 committing, or is attempting to commit
      but needs no PI (may apply for bail)                           commitment order– if there is              an offense (haa)
                                                                     probable cause                          2) When an offense has just been
                                                                 4) May issue summons instead of                committed and he has probable cause
                                                                     warrant of arrest                          to believe based on personal knowledge
                                                                                                                of facts and circumstances that the
                                                                                                                person to be arrested has committed it
                                                                                                                (jpp)
                                                                                                             3) When the person to be arrested is an
                                                                                                                escaped prisoner.
                                                                                                             4) Arrest by judicial bondsmen
                                                                                                             5) Accused on bail attempts to depart the
                                                                                                                country
                                                                                                         Note: Personal knowledge not necessarily of the
                                                                                                         CRIME but of facts and circumstances indicating
                                                                                                         that the person to be arrested has committed
                                                                                                         the crime.
                                                                                                                Vanslembrouck CrimPro Memory Aid |7
2 requirements for in flagrante delicto: (OIPV)      Conditions of bail: (FAWE)                            Bail Should Be Denied
    1. Overt act indicating that the has                1. Undertaking shall remain in force until             a) Before RTC, offense DRL, evidence of
        committed, is actually committing, or                the promulgation of judgment                          guilt is strong
        has just committed                              2. Accused shall appear in court when                  b) After RTC, offense punishable by DRL
    2. Committed in the presence or within                   he/she is ordered to do so                        c) After RTC, and penalty imposed is
        the view of the arresting officer               3. Failure to appear in court without                      imprisonment greater than 6 years
                                                             justification will be a waiver of his right           upon the following bail-negating
Duty of arresting officer if arrest is made                  to be present thereat – trial in absentia             circumstances: (REP FC)
without a warrant:                                           will proceed                                               1) Recidivist – Accused is a
    1. State his authority to arrest; and               4. Bondsman will surrender the accused to                            recidivist,      quasi-recidivist,
    2. Cause of the arrest                                   the court for execution                                         habitual     delinquent,       or
                                                                                                                             committed        the       crime
Duty of private person if arrest is made             No Release / Transfer unless: (OB)                                      aggravated by reiteration
without a warrant:                                      - order of court                                                2) Escaped – escaped from legal
    1. State cause of the arrest; and                   - admitted to bail                                                   confinement, evaded sentence,
    2. Intention to arrest him                                                                                               or violated the conditions of
                                                     If inquest NO BAIL yet, prosecutor will still look                      bail without valid justification
This double duty (above) is disposed if:             at the arrest report and the affidavit of the                           (eve)
    1. Engaged in the commission of the              arresting officer and if he finds absence of                       3) Probation – committed the
        offense                                      evidence, can be released.                                              offense while under probation,
    2. Pursuit      immediately      after     its                                                                           parole, conditional pardon (prc)
        commission                                   The accused can waive his appearance if                            4) Flight Risk
    3. Escapes, flees, or forcibly resists before    stipulated in the conditions of the bail.                          5) Crime Risk – undue risk that
        officer could do so                                                                                                  accused may commit another
    4. Giving of such will imperil the arrest        Bail As A Matter of Right                                               crime during pendency of the
                                                         1) Before/After conviction by MTC                                   appeal
                  RULE 114                               2) Before RTC offense NOT punishable by               d) Judgment of conviction has become
                    BAIL                                     death, RP, life imprisonment                          final, UNLESS before finality accused
                                                                                                                   applies for probation
Bail (SRC-FAC)                                       Bail is Discretionary                                     e) After accused has commenced to serve
    - security given                                     1) Before RTC, offense punishable by                      sentence
    - for the release of a person in custody of               death, RP, life imprisonment (check
        law,                                                  WON guilt is strong=NO bail)                 Where to apply for bail:
    - furnished by him or a bondsman,                    2) After RTC, offense NOT punishable by             - If appealed and before transmission of
    - to guarantee his appearance before any                  death, RP, life imprisonment                        records to appellate court – RTC
        court                                                                                                - If appealed and RTC conviction changed
                                                                                                                  from non-bailable to bailable offense –
Note: As long as there is deprivation of liberty.                                                                 appellate court
                                                                                                                   Vanslembrouck CrimPro Memory Aid |8
Procedure in A Bail Hearing (Summary                  Guidelines in Fixing the Amount of Bail (FNPC   Where is Bail Filed (Sec. 17)
Procedure)       but     MANDATORY          (WON      HAW PPFF) Excessive Bail NOT required             1) Court where case is pending
right/discretion) (NRWW-SCOO)                            1) Financial ability of accused                          Arrested in said area
    1) Judge notifies prosecutor of hearing /            2) Nature and circumstance of the offense                Unavailability of judge – any
         require     him       to    submit    his       3) Penalty for offense charged                                court in said area
         recommendation                                  4) Character and reputation of the                       No arrest; voluntary surrender
    2) Prosecution shall present its witnesses                accused                                             If the grant of bail is
         with option of (1) examining them or            5) Age and health of the accused                              discretionary,       or     for
         (2) adopting their affidavits.                  6) Weight of evidence against the accused                     recognizance
    3) Accused may submit affidavits of his              7) Probability of the accused appearing at     2) RTC of place where accused is arrested
         witnesses to prove his innocence                     trial                                               If place is other than where the
    4) Court shall examine affidavits and                8) Forfeiture of other bail                                   case is pending
         testimonies to see if evidence of guilt is      9) Fact that accused was a fugitive from                 If no RTC judge, the MTC judge
         strong.                                              justice when arrested                               Forward such bail and order of
    5) Cross-examination from both sides of              10) Pendency of other cases where accused                     release to where case is
         witnesses                                            is on bail.                                              pending (which may require a
    6) Oral arguments of parties on WON the                                                                            different one to be filed).
         evidence of guilt is strong                  Cash bond must be deposited with:                 3) Any court in the province, city,
    7) 48 hours after hearing, court issues an           1. Nearest BIR collector                            municipality where he is held
         order with brief summary of evidence,           2. Provincial, city or municipal treasurer      If there is an arrest but no case pending
         as to WON evidence of guilt is strong                                                               (warrantless)
                                                      Corporate surety:
Note:                                                    1. Accredited by SC                          Bail is Not Required (SMS – LO62)
   - The evidence in bail hearing considered             2. Accused pays premium which he                 1) Those under Summary Procedure
      automatically reproduced at trial.                     doesn’t get back if acquitted                2) Person has been in custody for a period
   - A judge must conduct a hearing of the                                                                     equal to or more than the possible
      application for bail regardless of WON          Property bond:                                           maximum imprisonment prescribed by
      the prosecution refuses to present                 1. Accused need not be owner                          the offense – shall be released
      evidence to show that guilt of accused             2. Owner must be resident of the                      immediately.
      is strong                                              Philippines                                  3) Judge is satisfied no need for custody
   - Motion to reduce bail is possible, but              3. Annotate the title within 10 days from             (in cases in the MTC less than 4 years, 2
      then will be asked to file a CASH BOND.                approval of the bond                              months, 1 day), just summons
   - Court cannot require arraignment                                                                     4) Violation of ordinance, light felony, or a
      before posting bail                             Recognizance:                                            criminal offense punishable by a
                                                      -undertaking that the accused shall appear in            penalty not exceeding 6 Months
                                                      court and comply with its orders                         imprisonment, and/fine of P2,000
                                                          1. Accused himself                                   where person unable to post the bond
                                                          2. Responsible member of the community
                                                                                                              Vanslembrouck CrimPro Memory Aid |9
Note: A person may be released on a REDUCED       An application for bail shall not bar the
bail or on his own recognizance when he is in     accused from: (PAW)
custody for a period equal to or more than the        1. Assailing the regularity or questioning
minimum of the principal penalty prescribed for          the absence of PI
the offense charged (without ISL or modifying         2. Challenging the validity of his arrest
circ.)                                                3. The legality of the warrant
Q: Once the accused is admitted to bail, may      Note: Provided he raises them BEFORE plea.
the court INCREASE or REDUCE its amount?
     Yes, upon good cause. When increased,       Random Notes:
       the accused may be committed to               - If accused is denied bail, Rule 65 to CA
       custody if he does not give bail in the          within 60 days - GADALEJ
       increased amount within a reasonable          - Denial of MTQ = proceed to TRIAL
       period.                                          without prejudice to reiterating the
                                                        special defenses
When may the court render a judgment of              - Denial of MTD = certiorari under Rule
forfeiture?                                             65, GADALEJ
     If the accused fails to appear in person       - MTQ granted = dismissed case, but the
        = forfeited                                     criminal information can be re-filed
     Bondsmen given 30 days to produce              - Generally, you do not appeal an
        their principal and show cause why no           acquittal. May be challenged in a
        judgment should be rendered against             Petition for Certiorari under Rule 65 –
        them for the amount of their bail (PS).         must prove GADALEJ and coupled with
        Within the said period, the bondsmen            consent of the OSG.
        must (PE)
            o Produce their principal or give     Some Crimes Punishable by reclusion perpetua
                 reason for non-production        to death, and life imprisonment
            o Explain why he did not appear           - Parricide
                 when first required to do so.        - Murder
                                                      - Drug-trafficking
Cancellation of bail: (ADE-SD)                        - Robbery with homicide
   1. Automatic when                                  - Rape with homicide
            a. Accused acquitted;                     - Syndicated or large-scale estafa / illegal
            b. Dismissal of case; or                      recruitment
            c. Execution of judgment of
                conviction
   2. Upon application of bondsmen when:
            a. Surrender of accused
            b. Proof of his death
                                                                                                     Vanslembrouck CrimPro Memory Aid |10