Transformed E&M I homework

Work and Energy

(Griffiths Chapter 2)

Work & Energy

Question 1 Energy of point charge distribution

Imagine a small square (side "a") with four point charges +q, one on each corner.
Calculate the total stored energy of this system (i.e. the amount of work required to
assemble it).
Then, calculate how much work it takes to "neutralize" these charges by bringing in one
more point charge (-4q) from far away and placing it right at the center of this square.
(When studying crystal structures, it is sometimes convenient to model them as
rectangular grids of charged ions, this problem forms the starting point for such a model)

Assigned in SP08 (average score: 8.6)

Assigned in FA08
Instructor notes: This seemed to be an easy question for students.

Question 2 Energy of a continuous charge distribution

A) Find the total electrostatic energy stored in a uniformly charged sphere of radius R and
total charge Q. (Note: this is uniform throughout the whole volume; it's not a shell.) Express your
answer in terms of Q and R. There are many different ways to do this; I want you to use
two different methods so you can check yourself.
i) figure out E(r) and then use Griffiths Eq. 2.45 (being careful to integrate over all space, not just
where the charge is!)
ii) figure out V(r) and then use Griff. 2.43 (what region do you need to integrate this over?)
B) Sketch V(r) vs r and directly below your V(r) plot, sketch E(r) vs. r. Indicate clearly
the functional forms both inside and outside the sphere. Your plots of V(r) and E(r)
should line up vertically so that their relationship is clear. How are V(r) and E(r) related?
C) According to Einstein, a static electron has a rest mass energy E = mc2. It is tempting
(though wrong!) to imagine that the electron is NOT really a point charge, but instead is a
tiny sphere, with uniform charge density, whose total electrostatic energy (found above)
EQUALS this mass energy of the electron. In other words, the idea would be that the rest
energy of the electron is purely electromagnetic.
What radius would an electron have to have, for this to work out? Give formula and
numerical answer. Don't take your result too literally; a correct model must take quantum
mechanics into account.
D) Compute the electrostatic energy of an atomic nucleus with Z protons and N
neutrons, or in other words, A = N + Z nucleons. Use an approximation for the nuclear
radius of R = (1.2 1015 m) A1/3. You can assume that the nucleus is a uniformly
charged sphere. Convert your answer, which is likely in Joules, to the energy units of
MeV. (Give your result in units of MeV times Z2 /A1/3) Now use this result to estimate
the change of electrostatic energy when a uranium nucleus undergoes fission into two
roughly equal-sized nuclei. Go online and check what the experimental answer is. What
does this tell you about the source of the energy released in a nuclear explosion ? Is it
mostly electrostatic?

Assigned in SP08 (average score: ai) 8.4, aii) 7.2)

Assigned in FA08
Instructor notes: (a) There was a lot of confusion on this question.
Such as, why can't we use V(r=0)=0? Why do you stop integrating rho *V
at the edge, when there is clearly more energy "outside". Why do we
integrate over all space of (a) but just the charge density for (b)? We
had to move charge through all space in order to create the charge
distribution, so why didnt we have to integrate over the space outside
the sphere? Which V do we use V(r) or V(R)? Some wanted to use V(R)
even outside the sphere. Students are having a lot of difficulty
conceptualizing the formulas for energy physically.
Also, most students calculated V(r) by setting V(0) = 0, and just
integrating from r=0 to r=r. Firstly, they didnt recognize that this
was different from what we usually do (V=0 at infinity) or that this was
what they were implicitly assuming by doing that integral. The reason
that didnt work was because in the formula for energy, the voltage is
implicitly set to zero at infinity, but that formula is not
transparently understood.
(b) Quite a few questions about the *language* in ii What is a
"nucleon"? What is "A"? Why A^1/3? The problem as stated was just a
little confusing, they weren't quite sure how to get started or what
exactly I was asking. This problem could be reworded. Also, some
students started to use Coulombs Law (instead of Gauss) to calculate E
inside, and were still unsure how to set up Gauss Law.

Question 3 Voltage of surface of the sun

ENERGY, REAL-WORLD (Lorrain et al, p 45/46)
The surface of the sun has a voltage due to the escape of electrons from its surface. Both
the electrons and protons on the surface of the sun are hot, so they have the same kinetic
energy (T) as defined by the temperature on the surface of the sun. However, since the
electrons have a lower mass than the protons, they are more likely to escape. They
escape until electrical equilibrium is reached. All remaining electrons and protons must
have a total energy (E=U+T) below a certain threshold, Eescape, in order to remain on the
surface of the sun. If both electrons and protons that remain on the surface have an equal
likelihood of escape, then they will all have the same potential energy (U). If you
calculate that potential, you will find that the potential on the surface of the sun is about
1000 V. Use this information to estimate the net charge of the sun.
We have to decide how much information to give them to solve this problem.

Question 4 Speed of electron in hydrogen

REAL-WORLD, ESTIMATION, FORCE
Hydrogen is 1 angstrom in diameter, estimate E force on an electron using F=ma and
mv2/r. How fast is the electron going by electrical forces? Is it faster than c? (this is a
trivial problem but they have to look up these numbers).

Question 5 Compute radius of electron

REAL-WORLD (Downloaded from Reed)
One might imagine that the electrons mass is electrostatic in origin. Assume that the
electron is a uniform charged sphere; use your results from problem 11.3 (finding energy
stored in uniformly charged sphere of radius R and charge q) and the rest energy of the
electron (mc^2) to compute the classical radius r0 . You might find it convenient to
express your answer in terms of the fine structure constant and Bohr radius before
plugging in numbers:
e2

4 0

Question 6 Calculate radius of electron 2

REAL WORLD; CALCULATION (Zimmerman, have solns)
ELECTRON MASS 3
The mass of an electron is me = 9.11 x 10-31 kg. The relativistic mass energy of an
electron is mec2. Given the apparent infinite electrostatic energy associated with a point
charge, is is tempting (though wrong) to view the electron not as a point charge, but as a
sphere of uniform charge density whose electrostatic energy is equal to the mass energy
of an electron. What would the radius of such a ball of charge be? (The electrons
charge, which has the special symbol e, is -1.60x10-19 coulombs).

Question 7 Energy to hold together the electron

REAL-WORLD; CALCULATION (deGrand)
ELECTRON MASS 2
In the pre-quantum days people thought of the electron as a little charges sphere of radius
R (called the classical electron radius) and tried to set the rest mass of the electron
equal to the electrostatic binding energy. Assume for a change of pace that the
electron is a charged shell of radius R with a uniform surface charge density. Find (a) the
energy required to hold the shell together (many ways to do this) (b) the formula relating
R and and (c) a numerical value for R (it will be about 10-13 cm)

Question 8 Work to assemble chain of charges

ESTIMATION, SERIES EXPANSION (Downloaded from Reed)
Consider an infinite chain of alternating point charges q and q as shown below. Working
from Equation 2.41 in Griffiths, find the work per particle required to assemble such a
configuration. You can look up the sum or work out the Taylor series for log(1 + x) to
recognize it.
This calculation would provide a good estimate of the electrostatic energy stored
in an ionic crystal (such as NaCl). In dimensions greater than one, the calculation of these
sums (referred to as Coulomb-Madelung sums) must be carried out numerically.

Question 9 Energy of cylindrical capacitor

CALCULATION (deGrand)
Find the electrostatic energy per unit length stored in a long cylindrical capacitor (inner
radius a, outer radius b) with a potential difference between the plates equal to V, in two
ways: (a) Find C and use . (b) Use : you must find and

integrate E. In this part, finish by expressing the charge per unit length in terms of V to
show that you get the same answer in (b) that you got in (a).

Question 10 Energy of cylindrical capacitor 2

CALCULATION (Zimmerman, have solns)
A very long coaxial capacitor has an inner conducting cylinder with radius a and an outer
conducting cylinder with radius b and a potential difference V is maintained between the
conductors. You may treat these as infinite cylindrical cells. What is the energy stored
per unit length in the capacitor? Work this two ways:
(a) Find the capacitance C and use W=1/2CV2
(b) Integrate the energy density stored in the electric field

Question 11 Energy of charged sphere ; atomic radius

REAL-WORLD (From Pollack and Stump, Electromagnetism, Problem 3.28)
a. Show that the electrostatic energy of a uniformly charged solid sphere, with total
charge Q and radius R is 3Q2 /(200 R).
b. Use the result above to compute the electrostatic energy of an atomic nucleus with Z
protons and a total of A nucleons, using an approximation for the nuclear radius as R =
(1.2 1015 m) A1/3. Give your result in units of MeV times Z2 /A1/3.
c. Calculate the change of electrostatic energy when a uranium nucleus undergoes fission.
Did you know that the energy released in a nuclear explosion is primarily electrostatic ?

Question 12 Work to assemble charges on vertices of icosahedron

WORK, CALCULATION, NEW SITUATION (C. Gwinn, UC Santa Barbara)
A regular icosahedron is a solid geometrical figure with 20 triangular faces. 5 faces meet
at each of the 12 vertices. The triangles are equilateral triangles, and all the vertices are
identical. (Useful fact: The vertices of an icosahedron lie at the corners of 3 mutually
perpendicular golden rectangles. The shorter edges of the rectangles are 6 of the edges of
the icosahedron, and the longer edges are longer by a factor of = 5/2 + 1/2
 1.618.)

a) Suppose that a charge +q is placed at each of the 12 corners of a regular icosahedron,

with length of side a. Find the work required to assemble this charge distribution.
b) A negative charge Q is placed at the center of the icosahedron. Find the value of Q
for which the total work to assemble this charge configuration is 0.
For fun: Find the net potential V at r of iscosahedron plus Q.

Question 13 Energy of sodium chloride crystal

REAL-WORLD; COMPUTATION (U WASHINGTON)