Comparison between manual calculation and

esteem
SLAB
FS4
Manual

Esteem

%Error

Msx

2.01 kNm/m

4.8 kNm/m

58.1

Msy

1.56 kNm/m

4.0 kNm/m

61.0

Link (x)

8H-300 (262 mm)

10T10-250 (314 mm)

16.6

10T10-250 (314 mm)

16.6

Manual

Esteem

%Error

Msx

6.93 kNm/m

10.8 kNm/m

35.8

Msy

5.94 kNm/m

8.4 kNm/m

29.3

Link (x)

8H-300 (262 mm)

28T10-225 (349 mm)

24.9

22T10-250 (314 mm)

16.6

Manual

Esteem

%Error

Msx

3.21kNm/m

6.2 kNm/m

48.22

Msy

2.5 kNm/m

3.9 kNm/m

35.89

Link (x)

H8-300 (168 mm)

12T10-250 (314 mm)

46.49

15T10-250 (314 mm)

46.49

Link (y)
FS11

Link (y)

FS8

Link (y)

FS16
Manual

Esteem

%Error

Msx

8.3 kNm/m

9.7 kNm/m

14.4

Msy

12.66 kNm/m

12.9 kNm/m

1.86

Link (x)

H10-300 (262 mm) 16T10-250 (314 mm)

16.6

Link (y)

37T10-250 (314 mm)

16.6

Manual

Esteem

%Error

Msx

2.6kNm/m

3.5 kN/m

25.7

Msy

1.97kNm/m

2.7kNm/m

27.04

Link (x)

H8-300 (168 mm)

8T10-250 (314 mm)

46.50

10T10-250 (314 mm)

46.50

FS2

Link (y)

FS3
Manual

Esteem

%Error

Msx

1.2 kNm/m

2.9 kNm/m

58.62

Msy

1.18 kNm/m

3 kNm/m

60.67

Link (x)

H8-300(168mm)

8T10-250 (314 mm)

46.50

Link (y)

H10-300(262mm)

8T10-250 (314 mm)

16.56

FS2
Manual

Esteem

%Error

Msx

2.2kNm/m

3.5 kN/m

37.14

Msy

1.86kNm/m

2.7kNm/m

31.11

Link (x)

H8-300 (262 mm)

8T10-250 (314 mm)

16.56

10T10-250 (314
mm)

16.56

Link (y)

FS8
Manual

Esteem

%Error

Msx

3.78 kNm/m

6.2 kNm/m

39.03

Msy

2.94 kNm/m

3.9 kNm/m

24.62

Link (x)

H10-300(262mm)

12T10-250 (314 mm)

16.56

Link (y)

H10-300(262mm)

15T10-250 (314 mm)

16.56

FS14
Manual

Esteem

%Error

Msx

1.86kNm/m

1.3 kNm/m

43.1

Msy

1.40kNm/m

4.7 kNm/m

70.2

Link (x)

8H-300 (168 mm)

10T10-250 (314 mm)

46.5

12T10-250 (314 mm)

46.5

Link (y)

FS15

Msx

Manual

Esteem

%Error

4.94 kNm/m

4.6 kNm/m

7.9

Msy

7.27kNm/m

7.6 kNm/m

4.3

Link (x)

H8-300 (168 mm)

14T10-250 (314 mm)

46.5

Link (y)

H8-250 (201 mm)

22T10-250 (314 mm)

36.0

SIMPLY SUPPORTED BEAM

Esteem

%Error

Moment

207.64 kNm

108.2 kNm

91.9

Shear

128.17 kN

11.6 kN

1004.9

As

4H16 (804mm)

2T12 (226mm)

255.8

As

4H25 (1960mm)

2T25 (982mm)

99.6

Link

H8-300

T10-125

Manual

Esteem

%Error

Moment

61.03 kNm

0.00 kNm

Shear

46.51 kN

37.8 kN

23.04

As

2H16 (402mm)

2T12 (226mm)

77.87

As

2H16 (402mm)

2T12 (226mm)

77.87

Link

H8-300

T10-250

Beam 2b17

Beam 2b8

Moment

Manual

Esteem

%Error

12.8kNm

13.9kNm

7.9

Shear

24 kN

13.1 kN

83.21

As

2H8 (101mm)

2T12 (226mm)

55.30

As

2H8 (101mm)

2T12(226mm)

55.30

Link

H8-300

R6-225

Manual

Esteem

%Error

Moment

31.31kNm

69.4kNm

54.88

Shear

53.51 Kn

85.6 kN

37.48

As

2H8 (101mm)

2T12 (226mm)

55.30

As

3H10 (236mm)

2T20(628mm)

62.42

Link

H8-300

t10-100

Manual

Esteem

%Error

Moment

78.30 kNm

103.2 kNm

24.1

Shear

69.90 kN

56.4 kN

24.0

As

2H08 (101 mm)

2T12 (226 mm)

55.3

As

2H20 (628 mm)

2T25 (982 mm)

36.0

Link

H8-300

T10-125

Beam 2b8

Beam 2b11

CONTINUOUS BEAM
Beam 1b12
Span
Manual

Esteem

%Error

Moment

76.77 kNm

82.3 kNm

6.7

Shear

86.43 kN

75.1 kN

15.1

As

2H8 (101 mm)

2T12 (226 mm)

55.3

As

2H20 (628 mm)

2T20 (628 mm)

Link

H8-300

T10-225

Support
Manual

Esteem

%Error

Moment

76.77 kNm

106.6 kNm

27.98

Shear

86.43 kN

128 kN

32.5

As

2H20 (628 mm)

2T25 (982 mm)

36.0

As

2H8 (101 mm)

2T20 (628 mm)

83.9

Link

H8-300

T10-225

Beam 1b2
Span
Manual

Esteem

%Error

Moment

479.87 kNm

219.1 kNm

119.01

Shear

384.75 kN

270.2 kN

42.39

As

5H20 (1570 mm)

2T12 (226 mm)

505.26

As

4H20 (1260mm)

2T205(1384 mm)

8.95

Link

H8-300

T10-125

Support
Manual

Esteem

%Error

Moment

479.87 kNm

270.4 kNm

77.46

Shear

384.75 kN

71.8 kN

435.86

As

5H20 (1570 mm)

2T20 (1610 mm)

2.48

As

4H8 (1260 mm)

2T25 (982mm)

28.30

Link

H8-300

T10-250

Beam 2b10
Span
Manual

Esteem

%Error

Moment

75.28kNm

58.8kNm

6.7

Shear

65.32 kN

30.2 kN

15.1

As

2H20(628 mm)

2T12 (226 mm)

55.3

As

2H20 (628 mm)

2T20 (628 mm)

Link

H8-300

T10-250

Support
Manual

Esteem

%Error

Moment

75.28 kNm

95.7kNm

27.98

Shear

65.32 kN

57.9 kN

32.5

As

2H20 (628 mm)

2T25 (719mm)

36.0

As

2H20(628 mm)

2T20 (88 mm)

83.9

Link

H8-300

T10-100

Beam 2b10
Span
Manual

Esteem

%Error

Moment

25.1kNm

7.2kNm

71.31

Shear

34.89 Kn

7.8kN

77.64

As

2H8(101 mm)

2T12 (226 mm)

55.3

As

2H10 (157 mm)

2T12 (226 mm)

30.53

Link

H8-300

T10-250

Support
Manual

Esteem

%Error

Moment

25.1kNm

7.1kNm

71.71

Shear

34.89 Kn

31.7kN

9.14

As

2H8(101 mm)

2T12 (226 mm)

55.3

As

2H10 (157 mm)

2T12 (226 mm)

30.53

Link

H8-300

T10-100

Beam 1b4
Span
Manual

Esteem

%Error

Moment

96.85 kNm

79.0 kNm

22.6

Shear

126.28 kN

60.7 kN

108.0

As

2H08 (101 mm)

2T12 (226 mm)

55.3

As

2H25 (982 mm)

2T20 (628 mm)

56.4

Link

H8-300

T10-225

Support
Manual

Esteem

%Error

Moment

96.85 kNm

114.7 kNm

15.6

Shear

126.28 kN

109.9 kN

14.9

As

2H25 (982 mm)

2T25 (982 mm)

0.0

As

2H8 (101 mm)

2T20 (628 mm)

83.9

Link

H8-300

T10-225

Manual

Esteem

%Error

Ned

429.5 kN

545.58 kN

21.3

Moment,z

49.02 kNm

30.27 kNm

61.9

Moment,y

4.2 kNm

48.9 kNm

91.4

As

4H16 (804 mm)

4T12 (452 mm)

77.9

Link

H6-300

T10-125

COLUMN
C14 (7,B)-ground floor-1st floor

C22 (12,F) ground floor-1st floor

Esteem

%Error

Ned

455.2 kN

1616.48 kN

71.84

Moment,z

702.93 kNm

54.34 kNm

1193.57

Moment,y

31.94 kNm

107.23 kNm

70.21

As

4H16 (804 mm)

8T12 (905 mm)

11.16

Link

H6-300

T10-125

Manual

Esteem

%Error

Ned

104. 63 kN

532.52 kN

80.46

Moment,z

25.49 kNm

44.48 kNm

42.69

Moment,y

20.56 kNm

35.35 kNm

41.83

As

4H16 (804 mm)

8T12 (905 mm)

11.16

1st floor-roof floor

Link

H6-300

T10-125

Manual

Esteem

%Error

Ned

130.18 Kn

590.24 kN

77.94

Moment,z

2.66 kNm

12.3 kNm

78.37

Moment,y

4.23 kNm

8.0 kNm

47.125

As

4H16 (804 mm)

4T12 (452 mm)

43.78

Link

H6-300

T10-125

Manual

Esteem

%Error

Ned

70.64 kN

264.19 kN

73.26

Moment,z

3.93 kNm

11.8 kNm

66.69

Moment,y

9.4 kNm

10.4 kNm

9.62

As

4H16 (804 mm)

4T12 (452 mm)

43.78

Link

H6-300

T10-125

Manual

Esteem

%Error

Ned

154.89 kN

1097.24 kN

85.88

Moment,z

3.37 kNm

4.6kNm

26.74

Moment,y

3.557kNm

8.7 kNm

60

As

5H10 (804 mm)

4T12 (452 mm)

78

C31 (,)- ground floor -1st floor

1st floor- roof floor

C14 (7,B) grounf floor-1st floor

Link

H8-300

T10-125

Manual

Esteem

%Error

Ned

236.91 kN

752.39 kN

68.5

Moment,z

35.98 kNm

47.54 kNm

24.3

Moment,y

3.78 kNm

28.04 kNm

86.5

As

5H16 (1010
mm)
H6-300

4T12 (452 mm)

123.5

T10-125

Manual

Esteem

%Error

Ned

132.72kN

348.60 kN

61.9

Moment,z

42.88 kNm

33.74 kNm

27.1

Moment,y

125.8 kNm

39.50 kNm

218.5

As

5H25 (2450
mm)
H6-300

4T12 (452 mm)

448

T10-125

C12 (5,K)- ground floor -1st floor

Link

1st floor-roof floor

Link

FOOTING
C14
Momen
t
As (x)

Manual
106.43 kNm

Esteem
132.88 kNm

%Error
19.9

10H12 (1130
mm)

12T-125(1583
mm)

28.6

As (y)

10T-100 (1492
mm)

24.3

Manual

Esteem

%Error

108.19 kNm

173.56 kNm

37.7

10H16 (2010
mm)

12T-125(1923
mm)
12T-125 (1810
mm)

4.5

Manual

Esteem

%Error

207.26 kNm

338.64 kNm

38.8

4H25 (1960
mm)

12T-100(3054
mm)
16T-175 (3217
mm)

35.8

Esteem
105.79 kNm

%Error
46.3

C12

Momen
t
As (x)
As (y)

11.0

C22

Momen
t
As (x)
As (y)

39.1

C25
Momen
t
As (x)
As (y)

Manual
56.85 kNm

4H16 (804 mm) 10T-100(1257

36.0

Manual

Esteem

%Error

19.96 kNm

40.46 kNm

50.7

39.8

C31

Momen
t
As (x)
As (y)

5H10 (393 mm) 10T-125(785

49.9
49.9