Case Problem 1: Product Mix
Case Problem 1: Product Mix
NotetoInstructor:Thedifferencebetweenrelevantandsunkcostsiscritical.Thecostoftheshipmentof
nutsisasunkcost.Practiceinapplyingsensitivityanalysistoabusinessdecisionisobtained.Youmay
wanttosuggestthatsensitivityanalysesotherthantheoneswehavesuggestedbeundertaken.
1.
Costperpoundofingredients
Almonds
Brazil
Filberts
Pecans
Walnuts
$7500/6000=$1.25
$7125/7500=$.95
$6750/7500=$.90
$7200/6000=$1.20
$7875/7500=$1.05
Costofnutsinthreemixes:
2.
Regularmix:
.15($1.25)+.25($.95)+.25($90)+.10($1.20)+.25($1.05)=$1.0325
Deluxemix
.20($1.25)+.20($.95)+.20($.90)+.20($1.20)+.20($1.05)=$1.07
Holidaymix:
.25($1.25)+.15($.95)+.15($.90)+.25($1.20)+.20($1.05)=$1.10
Let
R=poundsofRegularMixproduced
D=poundsofDeluxeMixproduced
H=poundsofHolidayMixproduced
Notethatthecostofthefiveshipmentsofnutsisasunk(notarelevant)costandshouldnot
affectthedecision.However,thisinformationmaybeusefultomanagementinfuture
pricingandpurchasingdecisions.Alinearprogrammingmodelfortheoptimalproductmix
isgiven.
Thefollowinglinearprogrammingmodelcanbesolvedtomaximizeprofitcontributionfor
thenutsalreadypurchased.
Max
s.t.
1.65R
2.00D
2.25H
0.15R
0.25R
0.25R
0.10R
0.25R
R
+
+
+
+
+
0.20D
0.20D
0.20D
0.20D
0.20D
+
+
+
+
+
0.25H
0.15H
0.15H
0.25H
0.20H
D
H
6000
7500
7500
6000
7500
10000
3000
5000
Almonds
Brazil
Filberts
Pecans
Walnuts
Regular
Deluxe
Holiday
R,D,H0
MGTC74W07
Page 1 of 4
ThesolutionfoundusingTheManagementScientistisshownbelow.
ObjectiveFunctionValue=61375.000
VariableValueReducedCosts
R17500.0000.000
D10624.9990.000
H5000.0000.000
ConstraintSlack/SurplusDualPrices
10.0008.500
2250.0000.000
3250.0000.000
4875.0000.000
50.0001.500
67500.0000.000
77624.9990.000
80.0000.175
OBJECTIVECOEFFICIENTRANGES
VariableLowerLimitCurrentValueUpperLimit
R1.5001.6502.000
D1.8922.0002.200
HNoLowerLimit2.2502.425
RIGHTHANDSIDERANGES
ConstraintLowerLimitCurrentValueUpperLimit
15390.0006000.0006583.333
27250.0007500.000NoUpperLimit
37250.0007500.000NoUpperLimit
45125.0006000.000NoUpperLimit
56750.0007500.0007750.000
6NoLowerLimit10000.00017500.000
7NoLowerLimit3000.00010624.999
80.0005000.0009692.307
3.
MGTC74W07
Fromthedualpricesitcanbeseenthatadditionalalmondsareworth$8.50perpoundto
TJ.Additionalwalnutsareworth$1.50perpound.Fromtheslackvariables,weseethat
additionalBrazilnut,Filberts,andPecansareofnovaluesincetheyarealreadyinexcess
supply.
Page 2 of 4
4.
Yes,purchasethealmonds.Thedualpriceshowsthateachpoundisworth$8.50;thedual
priceisapplicableforincreasesupto583.33pounds.
Resolvingtheproblembychangingtherighthandsideofconstraint1from6000to7000
yieldsthefollowingoptimalsolution.Theoptimalsolutionhasincreasedinvalueby
$4958.34.Notethatonly583.33poundsoftheadditionalalmondswereused,butthatthe
increaseinprofitcontributionmorethanjustifiesthe$1000costoftheshipment.
ObjectiveFunctionValue=66333.336
VariableValueReducedCosts
R11666.6670.000
D17916.6680.000
H5000.0000.000
ConstraintSlack/SurplusDualPrices
1416.6670.000
2250.0000.000
3250.0000.000
40.0005.667
50.0004.333
61666.6670.000
714916.6670.000
80.0000.033
OBJECTIVECOEFFICIENTRANGES
VariableLowerLimitCurrentValueUpperLimit
R1.0001.6501.750
D1.9762.0003.300
HNoLowerLimit2.2502.283
RIGHTHANDSIDERANGES
ConstraintLowerLimitCurrentValueUpperLimit
16583.3337000.000NoUpperLimit
27250.0007500.000NoUpperLimit
37250.0007500.000NoUpperLimit
44210.0006000.0006250.000
57250.0007500.0007750.000
6NoLowerLimit10000.00011666.667
7NoLowerLimit3000.00017916.668
80.0025000.00015529.412
MGTC74W07
Page 3 of 4
5.
MGTC74W07
Fromthedualpricesitisclearthatthereisnoadvantagetonotsatisfyingtheordersforthe
RegularandDeluxemixes.However,itwouldbeadvantageoustonegotiateadecreasein
theHolidaymixrequirement.
Page 4 of 4