Belvoir
Belvoir
Belvoir
Prepared for
The Garden Club of Virginia
Prepared by
Cheryl L. Miller
2014 Rudy J. Favretti Fellow
Belvoir
Cheryl L. Miller
2014 Rudy J. Favretti Fellow
Belvoir Formal Boxwood Garden, 1927. Mary Moore Personal Collection.
ii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
With great appreciation, I thank the Garden Club of Virginia for the opportunity to serve as the 2014 Rudy J.
Favretti Fellow, and for the GCVs ongoing commitment to the documentation of Virginias landscape heritage
through this unique fellowship program.
I extend many thanks to Will Rieley, Karen Kennedy, Roxanne Brouse, Kim Nash, Marty Moore, Emily Wolf,
Phyllis Andersen, and the Garden Club of Virginia Restoration and Fellowship Committee members for their
assistance and support throughout the fellowship. Your expert guidance and enthusiasm elevated the work and
made the experience a truly memorable one.
My gratitude goes out to the many local individuals, especially Jay Adams and Wayne Eastham, who shared their
knowledge of all things related to Belvoirs story. In particular, I would like to thank Robert Gaskins, Belvoir
gardener since 1962, for his time and wealth of information. To Polly Rowley and the ladies of the Fauquier and
Loudon Garden Club, I thank you for welcoming me to the neighborhood with true Southern hospitality.
Mary Moore deserves special mention and my utmost gratitude for her willingness and efforts to share Harrison
family historic photos, manuscripts, and oral history. I am so thankful that Kim Nash found you.
I wish to thank the descendants of Arthur F. Paul and Oglesby Paul for their interest in my research as it relates to
their grandfathers, and for their efforts to help uncover the story of these largely forgotten landscape architects. It is
my sincere hope that their stories will eventually be told, and their contributions to the practice of professional
landscape architecture better understood and acknowledged.
I would also like to acknowledge the archivists and staff of the Virginia Historical Society, Archives of American
Gardens at the Smithsonian Institute, University of Virginia Library Special Collections, College of William and
Mary Library Special Collections, Middleburg Reality, Athenaeum of Philadelphia, Pennsylvania Horticultural
iii
Society, Fauquier County Public Library, Fauquier Heritage and Preservation Foundation, Hershey Archives, The
Cultural Landscape Foundation, Garden Club of America, and Garden Club of Virginia.
Lastly, I would like to thank my daughters and husband for their patience with, and support of, my academic
pursuitsonce again. Your love and enthusiasm mean everything to me. I promise that this really is the last
academic degree.
iv
I wish to dedicate this report to the memory of Hetty Cary Harrison, truly one of Virginias most brilliant
daughters.
I would also like to dedicate this report to Robert Gaskins, Belvoir gardener since 1962. Like those unnamed
gardeners who have skillfully tended Belvoir before him, Roberts expertise and dedication have sustained Belvoirs
gardens over the years, allowing them to age with grace and dignity.
vi
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Introduction ..
Page 1
Site Maps..
Page 11
Page 17
Page 23
Page 63
Page 75
Page 81
Concluding Remarks
Page 101
Appendices
Page 105
vii
viii
INTRODUCTION
BELVOIR FARM I THE PLAINS, VA
in the early 20th century. A lawyer by training, Fairfax spent nearly his entire professional life working for the
Southern Railway Co., and the last 24 years as President. Under his skillful leadership, the Southern Railway Co.
weathered both World War I and the Great Depression, and experienced unprecedented expansion and
profitability during the heyday of the railroads.2,3 Fairfax was also a scholar of Virginia history and genealogy, and
authored a number of books and manuscripts on these topics.4 Hetty was an authority on gardening, landscape
history, and landscape design.5 She was a pioneering force within the Garden Club of Virginia, and also held
numerous leadership positions within the Garden Club of America and the American Horticultural Society. Hetty
was very involved with the Mount Vernon Ladies Association, the Colonial Dames, and the Mary Washington
Monument Association. A highly educated woman herself, schools and education were also among her great
interests. 6
Figure
1-
4:
Aerial
Photo
of
Belvoir
Formal
Grounds
and
House.
Approximate
Date
Late
1930s.
(Undated
Photo,
Mary
Moore
Personal
Collection)
A wealthy businessman who had made a fortune selling planes to China during WW II, William Pawley had
returned to the U.S. in 1944 to pursue political interests in Washington D.C. William and Edna Pawley owned
multiple homes, with Belvoir serving as a part-time country retreat. At Belvoir Farm, they could indulge Pawleys
interests in hunting and fishing, and host events and parties for their political friends such as President
5
grounds surrounding the Belvoir mansion, from the beginning of the Harrison era through today. This project has
also attempted to bring to light a greater appreciation for both the people who created Belvoir and Belvoir Farm,
and for those who have stewarded the property into the 21st century. My investigation has relied on analysis of
existing conditions and oral histories, as well as detailed study of historical manuscripts, photographs, newspapers,
and architectural drawings. What emerges from this three-month long study is a partial understanding of the
Harrisons Colonial Revival vision for Belvoir, what remains of that vision from the Harrison era, and a better
appreciation of the extent to which each of the four owners has shaped the landscape of Belvoir Farm. It is my
hope that the findings presented in this report will inspire future research on the gardens and grounds at Belvoir, as
well as the people who have stewarded Belvoir Farm over time.
1Morello,
Carol, and Ted Mellnik. 2012. Seven of Nations 10 Most Affluent Counties are in Washington Region. The Washington Post, September 20.
Accessed September 30, 2014. http://www.washingtonpost.com/local/seven-of-nations-10-most-affluent-counties-are-in-washingtonregion/2012/09/19/f580bf30-028b-11e2-8102-ebee9c66e190_story.html
2 Unknown. 1938. Fairfax Harrison. The Richmond News Leader, February 3, editorial. Accession number 1843, Fairfax Harrison Papers 1911-1943, Special
Collections, University of Virginia Library, Charlottesville, VA.
3 Harrison, Fairfax. October 21, 1937. Letter to all officers of the Southern Railway System announcing President Harrisons intention to retire. Accession
number 1843, Fairfax Harrison Papers 1911-1943, Special Collections, University of Virginia Library, Charlottesville, VA.
4 Unknown. Fairfax Harrison. Wikipedia. Accessed on November 3, 2014 at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fairfax_Harrison
5 Hetty Harrisons personal library contained a large collection of both historic and contemporary books on horticulture, botany, and landscape design. Many
of her books were donated to William and Mary, and are located at the Swem Library.
6 Baird, Ursula. April 22, 1970. Letter from Ursula Baird to Mrs. Martin at the Garden Club of Virginia regarding Hetty Harrison. Garden Club of Virginia
Archives, Kent Valentine House, Richmond, VA.
7 Virginia Historic Landmarks Commission. 1979. Survey Form, Belvoir. File no. 30-80.
8 Harrison, Fairfax. June 11, 1906. Letter to H.B.S. at the Southern Railway Co. proposing that Fairfax Harrison would pay to have side track and a
passenger shelter installed near Belvoir. Fairfax Harrison Papers 1736-1945. Special Collections, Swem Library, College of William and Mary.
9 Fauquier County Circuit Court Archives, Deed Book Grantees H to L 1759-1914, page 35.
10 Harrison, Fairfax. 1906-1907. Correspondence with Harris Bros. General Contractors, and Wyeth and Cresson Architects. Fairfax Harrison Papers 17361945, Special Collections, Swem Library, College of William and Mary.
11 Hetty Harrisons personal library contained a large collection of both historic and contemporary books on horticulture, botany, and landscape design. Many
of her books were donated to William and Mary, and are located at the Swem Library.
12 Harrison, Fairfax. 1906-1907. Correspondence with Harris Bros. General Contractors, and Wyeth and Cresson Architects. Fairfax Harrison Papers 17361945. Special Collections, Swem Library, College of William and Mary.
13 Fauquier County Circuit Court Archives, Deed Book 106, page 134.
14 Fauquier County Circuit Court Archives, Deed Book 128, page 121.
Harrison, Fairfax. May 16, 1910. Memorandum of grass mixture used on Belvoir Farm, Fauquier County, Virginia. Fairfax Harrison Papers 1736-1945.
Special Collections, Swem Library, College of William and Mary.
16 Harrison, Hetty. April 12, 1941. Belvoir lease agreement between Hetty Harrison and Hamilton Robinson. Fairfax Harrison Papers 1886-1973, Mss1
H2463 q 538-555, Virginia Historical Society Archives.
17 Ryland, S.P. 1943-1944. Correspondence between First and Merchants National Bank of Richmond, and Mrs. Charles Baird and Mrs. G.H. Dieke
concerning the estate of Hetty Harrison. Fairfax Harrison Papers 1886-1973, Mss1 H2463 q 594-609, Virginia Historical Society Archives.
18 Unknown. 1944. China Swashbuckler buys Showplace at Warrenton. The Washington Post, April 22, page 3.
19 Carrozza, Anthony R. 2012. William D. Pawley: The Extraordinary Life of the Adventurer, Entrepreneur, and Diplomat Who Cofounded the Flying Tigers. Washington
D.C.: Potomac Books, 183, 189, and 193.
20 Pattee, Dorothea. 1953. Fauquier Folk Live High and Handsome. The Washington Post, April 12, page S3.
21 Greely, Rose. 1952-1953. Pawley, Mrs. William, Belvoir The Plains, Virginia. Rose Greely Papers. MSS 10772. Special Collections, University of
Virginia.
22 Unknown. 1960. Belvoir Estate Bought by E. DeLong Bowman. The Fauquier Democrat, December 1, page 1.
23 Middleburg Real Estate. 1960. Belvoir Farm Brochure. Middleburg Real Estate Archives.
15
10
11
Google Earth I mage of B elvoir Farm. Property Line Delineated in Dashed Outline.
12
13
14
15
16
A Belvoir Farm Building in the Distance as Seen From Harrison Road, 2014.
17
Belvoir Farm is located in the town of The Plains in the northeast portion of present day Fauquier County.
Fauquier County is situated in the Upper Piedmont region of Northern Virginia, between the Piedmont and the
Blue Ridge Mountains. In the late 17th century the land now known as Fauquier County was listed as part of the
land grant known as the Northern Neck Propriety, initially under the ownership of Lord Culpeper and later under
Lord Fairfax. 1 The area remained largely unsettled by colonists until Governor Spotswood negotiated the 1722
Treaty of Albany with the Iroquois tribe, and secured the area for settlement. In 1759 Fauquier County was
established from a section of land previously considered Prince William County. The County was named in honor
of Francis Fauquier, the Lieutenant Governor of the Colony of Virginia at the time. Considered to be one of the
most popular of the Royal Governors, Francis Fauquier was sympathetic towards the American colonies, and
remained friendly with men such as Thomas Jefferson until his death in 1768.2
Early settlers were drawn to Fauquier County for its fertile soils, plentiful timber, and abundant waterways.3
During the mid-18th century tobacco was the main cash crop, with various other crops grown on a subsistence basis.
By the late 18th century, wheat had replaced tobacco as the primary export crop in Fauquier County.4
Improvements in farming methods and techniques brought greater prosperity to Fauquier County farmers in the
first half of the 19th century, as did new transportation routes and methods that helped to link Fauquier farms with
distant markets in Alexandria, Georgetown, and D.C.5
Following the Civil War, Fauquier County farmers faced a war-devastated economy and the demise of their labor
system. Eventually, agricultural reforms and reorganized railroads played a large part in the economic recovery of
the area, allowing for expedited transport of larger crops to more distant urban centers, and giving rise to
associated local industries. By the late 19th century, both the Orange & Alexandria and the Manassas Gap
18
railroads were part of the Southern Railway system, which had become the primary transporter of goods in this
area.6 In a letter to the agricultural journal The Southern Planter, Southern Railway Co. President Fairfax Harrison
outlined the many ways his company was advancing agriculture in the South. The Southern Railway Co.
had on staff agricultural agents and market agents that advised farmers on best farming practices, and connected
local farmers with potential buyers and markets. Fairfax Harrison wrote:
It is the agents business to bring Southern producers into touch with buyers and to advise buyers where the products
which they want may be obtained along the lines of the Southern Railway systemthe Company is able to be helpful to
farmers along its lines in all stages of their operations to the final sale of their products.7
19
Throughout the early 20th century, Fauquier County remained a predominantly rural area, dotted with small
crossroad communities serving as commercial centers. The unbroken, open countryside of Fauquier County lent
itself to fox hunting, drawing wealthy equestrians to the area, and bringing an element of gentrification to Fauquier
County at the turn of the century. Prominent families bought up large properties so they could spend the hunting
season in the area, eventually building impressive country places for extended stays and entertaining. The Orange
County Hunt, a prestigious hunt club for wealthy New Yorkers, travelled to Fauquier in private railroad cars. The
Orange County Hunt was so enamored with the location that it eventually relocated the clubhouse from Orange
County, New York, to the town of The Plains in Fauquier County.9 By 1917, The Plains and other picturesque
destinations within the Piedmont Region were advertised by the Southern Railway Company in travel brochures
that showcased impressive area estates, hunt clubs, and other area amenities.10
Figure
2-
2:
Comparative
Analysis
of
Belvoir
Site
Context
Using
Aerial
Photographs.
A)
1937
Aerial
Photograph
(Fauquier
County
GIS
Department
Archives).
B)
1965
Aerial
Photograph
(Fauquier
County
GIS
Department
Archives).
C)
Aerial
Photograph
of
Current
Belvoir
Site
Context
(Google
Earth
Image).
Study
Area
of
Belvoir
House
a nd
Formal
Grounds
Outlined
in
Red
Box.
20
At present, Fauquier County remains a predominantly rural area characterized by large and small farms, historic
roadways, and a cohesive picturesque landscape at the foothills of the Blue Ridge Mountains. Despite the
proximity to D.C. and other large centers in northern Virginia, Fauquier County remains true to its agricultural
and equestrian heritage, and is often considered the heart of Virginias horse country. Consequently, Belvoir
Farms site context today remains largely reflective of its early 20th century setting, with large farms and dispersed
homesteads surrounding the property, and unobstructed views of the foothills (figures 2-2, 2-3).
21
Fauquier Historical Society. Colonial Times in Fauquier County. What You Should Know About Fauquier History. Accessed October 27, 2014 from
http://www.fauquierhistory.com/index.cfm?pagesID=3
2 Fauquier County, Virginia. About Fauquier County. Accessed October 27, 2014 from http://www.visitfauquier.com/aboutfauquier.html
3 Carr, Lois Green. 1987. Adaptation and Settlement in the Colonial Chesapeake. St. Marys City Research Series No. 6. St. Marys City, Maryland.
4 Poland, Charles Preston Jr. 1976. From Frontier to Suburbia. Missouri: Walsworth Publishing Company. Pages 27-28.
5 Ibid, pages 116-117.
6 Southern Railway Historical Association. Southern Railway History. Accessed November 12, 2014 from
http://www.srha.net/public/History/history.htm
7 Harrison, Fairfax. 1915. Letter to the editor. The Southern Planter, 76th Year. July. Pages 431-432.
8 Town of the Plains. A Brief History of The Plains, Virginia. About Us Our History. Accessed October 27, 2014 from
http://www.theplainsvirginia.org/about-us
9 Khalifa, Daisy Ridgway. 2012. A Day in the Country. Virginia Living. February. Accessed October 29, 2014 from
http://www.virginialiving.com/exploring/a-day-in-the-country/
10 Town of the Plains. A Brief History of The Plains, Virginia. About Us Our History. Accessed October 27, 2014 from
http://www.theplainsvirginia.org/about-us
11 Virginia Historic Landmarks Commission. 1979. Survey Form, Belvoir. File no. 30-80.
12 Fauquier County Circuit Court Archives, Deed Book 98, page 213.
13 Richards, Paul C. 1906. Letter to Mr. Harrison regarding including adjacent landowners to the plat of Belvoir. Fairfax Harrison Papers 1736-1945.
Special Collections, Swem Library, College of William and Mary.
14 Fauquier County Circuit Court Archives, Deed Book 106, page 134.
15 Fauquier County Circuit Court Archives, Deed Book 128, page 121.
16 Middleburg Real Estate. 1960. Belvoir Farm Brochure. Middleburg Real Estate Archives.
17 Fauquier County, Virginia. GIS parcel mapper tool, accessed October 30, 2014 at http://maps.fauquiercounty.gov/
1
22
Belvoir Formal Boxwood Garden as Seen From Second Floor of House, 2014.
23
The eldest son of Constance Cary and Burton Norvell Harrison, Fairfax
Harrison was born in New York on March 13, 1869. He attended Yale
College and later attended both the Law School and School of Political
Science at Columbia University.1 Fairfax was admitted to the New York
Bar in 1892 and spent five years in the New York office of Bangs, Stetson,
Tracy and MacVeagh.2 In May 1896 he relocated to Washington D.C. to
become Solicitor of the Southern Railway Company. He held several
positions within the Southern Railway Company, ultimately serving as
President for 24 years before his retirement (figure 3-1).3 Fairfax spent his
entire young life in and around New York, with summer holidays at Lenox,
Massachusetts and Bar Harbor, Maine. The one exception was the
summer of 1889 spent in Knoxville, Tennessee and Middlesborough,
Kentucky where he met Hetty Cary.4
Hetty Cary was born in Richmond, Virginia on August 6, 1871, the eldest
daughter of Frances Daniel and John Brune Cary (figure 3-2). Hetty was
raised in Baltimore County, Maryland and was educated by her
grandmother at the Southern Home School in Baltimore.5 She lived for
several years in Knoxville and Middlesborough while her father was
engaged in business there. Hetty summered in Bar Harbor for several
seasons, and spent the entirety of 1891 abroad in Italy.6
24
On June 6, 1894 Fairfax and Hetty were married at St. Marks Church in Baltimore County, Maryland.7 Their
early married life was spent living in Staten Island, New York until they relocated to Washington D.C. in 1896,
Figure 3- 2: Dated and Undated Photographs from Mary Moore Personal Collection
where they remained in full time residence until 1906.8 The Harrisons had four children over the course of
eighteen years: Constance Cary Harrison, born on March 30, 1895; Ursula Fairfax Harrison, born on December
14, 1897; Richard Harrison, born on August 14, 1906; and Sally Cary Fairfax Harrison, born on February 7,
1913.9
25
When the Harrisons relocated to Fauquier County in 1906, they were making a deliberate choice to raise their
children away from the vagaries they associated with modern city life. Fairfax clearly stated their concerns with
raising their children in town in the following excerpt from an unsent letter to Mr. Finley, then the President of the
Southern Railway Co.
... I am sure that you will understand the effort I am making to educate my children away from the current habit of
domestic publicity. The daily newspapers, the cheap monthly magazines, and other widely distributed publications, are
filled with the names and pictures of unimportant people men, women and even children their houses, their
automobiles, their horses, their dogs, their sports, which are of no intrinsic interest and serve only to tickle an appetite for
prominence and display of what money can bring. We know that these things are solicited and that they are usually paid
advertisements, so that every such publication of a chapter of the life of a private person is infected with a suspicion that it
springs from personal vanity.
Because it is difficult in town to resist the malady of which this is a symptom, my wife and I have elected to bring
up our children in the country, in the endeavor to secure for them that simplicity of mind which is still characteristic of the
Virginia country people, as it always was of their ancestors, and seems to me to be the best guaranty of a contented life in a
restless age. 10
Employment with the Southern Railway Co. required that Fairfax be away from home much of the time,
particularly when he was based in Chicago between 1906-1913. During this time, Fairfax and Hetty corresponded
frequently by letter and telegram, a subset of which have been preserved and archived.11 These surviving
correspondences, primarily written by Fairfax to Hetty, provide valuable insight into the domestic life of the
Harrisons at Belvoir, as well as insight into Fairfaxs personality and prevailing attitudes. Despite being absent for
extended periods of time, he appears to have been deeply committed to his family and their life in the country at
Belvoir, as the following correspondence excerpts indicate.
Every time I go home, I long with renewed enthusiasm that my fortune permitted my organizing my life in the country,
but the problems of the great world are worth fighting for. My only regret is that 20 years of service under our conditions
do not seem any longer to bring the reward of leisure to invite ones soul.12
26
Your budget of home news this morning may have been prosaic as you say but it was very welcome and more so than all
the poetry on earth. Nothing makes home as dear as a record of peace and cheerful developments and I have been with you
recently enough and long enough to enable me to conjure every word of your news into vivid reality.13
I spent last night taking a bath of poetry, which is a useful bit of mental hygiene to be practiced occasionally. In Shelley,
I came on the verses I am sending you, which voice my feeling about Belvoir, blessed resort of high principle and sweet
living. When I think of the joy of staying there, I remember Tennysons Odysseus read it. It all applies to me except
the old wife. Mine will never grow old or at least seem so to me.
Shelleys Epipsychidion
And I have fitted up some chambers there
Looking towards the golden Eastern air
And level with the living winds, which flow
Like waves above the waving corn below
I have sent books and music there and all
Those instruments with which high spirits call
The future from its cradle, and the past
Out of its grave, and make the present last
In thoughts and joys which sleep, but cannot die,
Folded within their own eternity. 14
Consistent with the unsent letter to Mr. Finley, the Harrison manuscripts also reveal how intensely private Fairfax
was, and how much he deplored any form of publicity. Belvoir was the Harrisons private sanctuary and they went
to great lengths to protect that privacy. Throughout his adult life, Fairfax consistently rejected all requests to
photograph himself, his home, or family, and clearly articulated his position on the topic of publicity in the
following letter.
27
While Belvoir was their primary residence, the Harrisons also maintained a leased townhouse in D.C. as the
Southern Railway Co. was headquartered in Washington D.C., requiring Fairfax to spend a significant amount of
time in town. 17 In an ongoing effort to maintain his privacy and that of his family, Fairfax Harrison systematically
requested that his personal address and phone number be eliminated from several Washington, D.C. directories.18
His position on the topic of privacy did not soften with age, as we see in this 1929 rejection of a request from Time
Magazine for a personal interview.
Madam:
Thank you for your pleasant note of June 11th. As I suffer from an acute phobia of personal publicity, I must respectfully
decline to respond to your polite inquisition.
Believe me, with respect,
Yours faithfully19
28
The Harrison correspondences further suggest that, like many Americans at the end of the 19th and early 20th
centuries, the Harrisons were seeking an antidote in the Virginia countryside to what they saw as unsettled times,
characterized by concerns regarding industrial and urban growth, increased immigration, and a sense of
widespread moral deterioration. The Colonial Revival movement represented such an antidote, by offering
Americans a romanticized and comforting backward look at the nations founding and its successful struggle for
freedom. And Americans like the Harrisons, whose pedigrees could be traced to colonial families, were often
among the most ardent proponents of the Colonial Revival movement. As Theobald suggests,
Unsettled times often encourage people to turn to the past. Americans of the late 19th century had only to look back one
hundred years to see an era that by comparison looked idyllic: a Golden Age of American values, when heroic pioneers
sustained their families through honest labor and patriotic farmers fought for freedom beside selfless Founding Fathers.
The vision was not so much inaccurate as it was incomplete and romanticized.20
Reviving the architecture, home furnishings, gardens, and other material manifestations of the American Colonial
period became an approach many believed would lead to the renewed cultivation of patriotism and other noble
colonial virtues. By surrounding themselves with such material references to a more family-oriented period of
American history, Colonial Revivalists were attempting to counteract the perceived sense of widespread moral
deterioration.21 According to Marling, much of the architectural interest in the colonial past was devoted to the regeneration of
American virtue through the restoration of the American home.22 The Harrisons were deeply patriotic Americans,
particularly interested in Virginia history and proud of their collective Virginia heritage. It is no surprise that they
took such an interest in Colonial Revival material references to that heritage in their plans for Belvoir.
Coincident with the rise of interest in American history and the birth of the historic preservation movement in
America, Colonial Revival architecture had become the most fashionable and affordable style by the late 19th and
early 20th centuries, particularly along the east coast.23 Living in Washington D.C. during this period, the
Harrisons would have been exposed to many examples of high style interpretations of Colonial Revival architecture,
and been familiar with the prominent Colonial Revival architects practicing in Virginia at the time. When the
29
Harrisons embarked on relocating to Fauquier County in the spring of 1906, it is likely they had a fairly well
developed Colonial Revival vision in mind for their future home at Belvoir.
Transforming Fair Fountains into Belvoir
On June 2, 1906 the deed for the 372-acre property heretofore known as Fair Fountains and hereafter to be
known as Belvoir was officially conveyed to Fairfax Harrison from Annie Lee Peyton.24 Before the property had
transferred, the Harrisons had already hired the D.C. based architectural firm of Wyeth & Cresson to design their
new Colonial Revival home at Belvoir. By1906, Nathan Wyeth had established significant professional credentials,
having trained at the Ecole Des Beaux Arts (1892-1899), apprenticed in the office of Carrere and Hastings (18991900), and worked in the U.S. Capitol in the office of the Supervising Architect of the Treasury Department (19001903), and as the Chief Designer in the office of the Architect of the Capitol (1904-1905).25 William Cresson, the
junior partner in the firm, only practiced architecture for a few years before moving on to other careers.26 The
short-lived Wyeth & Cresson partnership (1906-1907) focused primarily on embassies and high-end residential
work within D.C. and the surrounding areas.27
The first set of blue prints and specifications for the house at Belvoir were delivered to the Harrisons on June 5 of
1906, just days after closing on the property, yet the correspondence indicates that some amount of editing of the
plans continued through at least February of 1907.28,29 An excerpt from one such correspondence from Wyeth &
Cresson revealed their intention to incorporate the existing Fair Fountains brick dwelling into the new house design.
In our conversation of yesterday you gave us to understand that while you are satisfied with the way in which we have
carried out the alterations to your property at Plains VA, you feel that a larger house could be built by removing the present
structure and building an entirely new house...
We feel however that you under-estimate the advantages of having brick walls to a part of your house at least, and leaving
questions of sentiment aside, the finish in the rooms now existing is quite worth some sacrifice to preserving. 30
30
31
crosses the railroad at a point where there is a post office known as The Swamp. There is a mail crane in use at this point,
which will identify it. Would it be possible to put in, say, 300 of side track on the right of way at this road crossing and
erect a passenger shelter, which could be made a flag stop for passenger trains. If such a shelter is established, I would also
ask that you consider calling it by the name of my place, Belvoir.32
Surely the close proximity of railroad service would have been highly desirable and convenient for the Harrisons.
Fairfax paid for the installation of sidetrack and the construction of a passenger shelter for the area residents to use,
and was successful in having Swamp and the nearby area of Swampoodle renamed Belvoir (figures 1-1, 2-1, 3-4).33
Belvoir Expansion
32
Figure
3-
8:
Undated Photograph of the Formal Boxwood Garden, Taken on Axis with the Recently Expanded House. This Photograph Reveals a Young
Formal Garden, where Paths and Beds Have Been Laid Out, but Many of the Later Signature Elements Such as the Monopteros, Wire Forms Around the
Monopteros, and Mature Boxwoods are Missing. The Large Wooden Structure to the Left was Later Replaced by the Stone Guest Cottage Designed by
Waddy B. Wood. (Photograph from Mary Moore Personal Collection)
34
many of the later Harrison garden features are missing such as the monopteros, the central wire frames for the
boxwood and roses, statuary, sheared hedges, and perimeter retaining walls. These photos were likely taken shortly
after the house expansion.
To date, no garden plans or other primary documentation have been found to shed light on the timing and
developmental details of the Belvoir gardens during the Harrison era. However, one secondary reference suggests
a date for when work began on the formal garden. That reference comes from a write up of Mrs. Fairfax
Harrisons garden in the 1921 List of Gardens of the Members of the Garden Club of America Open to Visit by Members:
Mrs. Fairfax Harrison, Belvoir, Fauquier co., Va.
Type Formal, with mixed borders and flowering shurbs
Best Bloom 1st week in May 2nd week in June
Owners Remarks Trains leave Union Station, Washington at 9 a.m. and 3:55 p.m.; returning leave Belvoir at 9:10
a.m. and 7:10 p.m. There is only one morning and one afternoon train each way. Owner will meet visitors and provide
entertainment upon special arrangement by letter, a reasonable time in advance. This garden is only ten years old, but has
some old box and many flowering shrubs and perennial borders.40
Thus it appears the Harrisons began creating the formal gardens in 1911, presumably near the time that the
Belvoir House expansion took place.
Given Hettys knowledge of horticulture and landscape design, one can assume she took an active role in the design
and implementation of the formal grounds and gardens during her tenure at Belvoir. However, the full extent to
which Hetty received professional guidance from a landscape architect remains unclear. A local newspaper article
in 1960 claimed, The beautiful formal boxwood gardens were designed by the late A.H. Paul of Philadelphia and later developed
under Mrs. Harrisons guidance.41 This refers in all likelihood to Arthur F. Paul of Philadelphia, a well-known
landscape architect, horticulturalist, and nurseryman who practiced during the first half of the 20th century.42, 43
35
Until Oglesbys death in 1915 when he was just 39 years old, the office was known
simply as that of Oglesby Paul, Landscape Architect, a common convention at
the time despite having several professional associates employed in the firm.56 After
36
VA, and thus began a new, and much more public, chapter in Hettys
life. Hetty was a member of the Warrenton Garden Club until she
resigned in 1915, at which time she organized the Fauquier and
38
39
on the occasion of Ursula Harrisons wedding (figures 3-12, 313). While both photos offer limited glimpses of the formal
garden, it is clear that by 1920 the formal boxwood garden had
evolved significantly from the earlier photos (figures 3-7, 3-8),
with the addition of multiple garden structures and mature
plantings. In figure 3-12, the monopteros and associated tall,
sculpted boxwoods can be seen behind Mrs. Harrison,
indicating these signature features of the garden were installed
by 1920. In figure 3-13, one can make out certain elements of
the formal boxwood garden beyond the gathering on the rear
terrace. Lombardy poplars can be seen in the distance, which
largely disappear from the garden by the late 1930s. From this
image the profile of the garden temple at the left rear corner of
the garden can be discerned, indicating this structure was in
place by 1920. A mature privet hedge that encloses the garden
space can also be seen in figure 3-13. This hedge reflects an
40
progress while remaining true to the original geometric plan. Figure 3-16, taken from the second floor of the house,
provides a sense of how the formal boxwood garden plantings had matured by 1927. The image reveals new
garden features such as the circular planting located within the turf, a stone fountain, and a new run of stone wall
attached to a stone archway leading into the cutting garden. The highly manicured state of the formal gardens
strongly suggests a gardening staff existed at Belvoir, and Sally Harrison caught at least two of these gardeners on
film (Figures 3-17, 3-18). The first dated glimpse of the change in grade at the back of the house, and the
introduction of a stone retaining wall and steps at the transition into the boxwood garden, appear in a photo from
1928 (figure 3-19). Additional photos from 1928 highlight newer garden features, such as the stone fountain of a
42
boy riding a turtle in the boxwood garden (figure 3-20), and one of the two stone fountains located within the
cutting garden (figure 3-21).
In addition to the historic photographs from the Harrison family archives, the gardens at Belvoir were
photographed as a result of Hettys affiliation with the GCA, one of the first proponents of early garden
photography in America. In 1919 the GCA formed the Slide Committee to document gardens belonging to
members, as well as those associated with historic sites.69 Ultimately, the GCA amassed over 2000 glass lantern
slides between 1920 and 1935.70 In 1927, The Fauquier and Loudoun Garden Club sent a set of slides of member
gardens to the GCA, which included of Belvoirs formal gardens.71,72 These slides provide richly detailed
close ups of various features within the Harrisons highly manicured boxwood garden, and include one image of the
rock garden that was located on the lower east lawn (figures 3-22 through 3-27).73 From these images, it is clear
that the regrading behind the house, and associated introduction of stone retaining wall and steps at the transition
into the boxwood garden, were in place as early as 1927 (figure 3-22). Hettys extensive collection of irises was
43
showcased in these late spring slides, as was the highly manicured state of the boxwood hedges and specimen
plantings. The inclusion of the decidedly less formal rock garden on the lower east lawn within the slide collection
provides an interesting contrast to the formal boxwood garden, and likely reflects the intense interest in rock
gardens amongst garden club members at the time (figure 3-27).74
Frances Benjamin Johnston (1864-1952), one of the first prominent female photographers in America, also
photographed Belvoir in the early 1930s (figures 3-28-3-33).75 Later in her career she moved away from portrait
and photojournalism work to specialize in photographing architecture and gardens. 76 Johnston traveled
extensively to research and lecture on the gardens she had photographed, and images of Belvoir were used in her
Garden and Historic House Lecture Series.77 Johnstons summer photographs at Belvoir reveal a mature garden
characterized by exuberant perennial flower displays, architectural evergreens, and a variety of interesting
structures and features. Figures 3-30 and 3-31 provide a rare look at the architectural detail of the garden temple,
44
an open-air pavilion that anchored the southeast corner of the formal boxwood garden. Figure 3-31 was featured
on the front cover of the February 1934 issue of The Garden Gossip.78 Johnstons photographs also provide important
documentation of the former cutting gardens (figures 3-32, 3-33), revealing the extensive rose arbor that once
existed, and the multitude of planting beds filled with irises, roses, and peonies.
As the Johnston photographs indicate, the gardens at Belvoir were well developed by the early 1930s, characterized
by mature plantings, structures, and other features for entertainment and visual pleasure. Yet the gardens and
grounds continued to be edited and enhanced by the Harrisons during this time. In late 1933, architect Waddy B.
Wood designed a sophisticated stone guest cottage for the Harrisons to replace an earlier wooden building located
within the formal boxwood garden (figures 3-6, 3-8). An undated historic photo from the Harrison family archives
reveals the stone guest cottage under construction, suggesting this image was captured in the early 1930s after the
design was finalized (figure 3-34). This aerial photograph provides a wonderful overview of the formal grounds
surrounding the house at Belvoir, highlighting how they have matured after several decades of editing and growth.
45
The last historic image of Belvoir from the Harrison family is another undated aerial photograph suggestive of
ongoing editing of the grounds and gardens (figure 3-35). While undated, several details indicate the photograph
was taken after that in figure 3-34, possibly late 1930s to early 1940s: the stone cottage has been completed, fewer
46
Figure
3-35: Aerial Photo of Belvoir House and a Portion of the Formal Grounds and
Gardens. Approximate date late 1930s to early 1940s based on the Introduction of
Newer Landscape Features. (Undated Aerial Photograph, Mary Moore Personal
Collection).
members of the Orange County Hunt Club, the Harrisons made portions of their property available for
foxhunting.85 They contributed generously to a number of civic improvement projects, and Fairfax was one of the
original founders of the Fauquier County Fair.86 The Harrisons were largely responsible for the gentrification and
transformation of the former crossroad of Swampoodle into the hamlet of Belvoir. Fairfaxs pride in this
transformation can be detected in the following description he proposed for a directory of Fauquier County in
1916:
Dear Miss Evans:
In response to your note of March 14th to Mrs. Harrison, I suggest
the following paragraph as a notice of Belvoir for the proposed
Directory of Fauquier County, VA:
48
Such a tour of the grounds and gardens at Belvoir in 1921 would have given Hetty exposure and credibility in
terms of the design and implementation of a complex landscape, during a very early stage in the evolution of the
GCV. By the time the GCV was prepared to undertake historic garden restoration work several years later, Hetty
would have been well known within the organization in terms of her personal experience with, and knowledge of,
Colonial Revival garden design. Through her various organizational affiliations, Hetty eventually became involved
in an impressive number of garden restoration projects that included: the Mary Washington Monument, Kenmore,
Mount Vernon, Monticello, Stratford Hall, Bruton Parish Churchyard, and the Woodrow Wilson Birthplace in
Staunton.90, 91
49
Harrison family correspondences from the 1920s into the 1930s suggest they enjoyed a happy albeit busy domestic
life at Belvoir during this time. Their second eldest daughter Ursula was married at Belvoir in 1920, and the
Harrisons experienced the joy of grandchildren from that union.92 Fairfax continued to be away from home on
business often, prompting him to write Hetty and the children frequently. His surviving letters described his work
life away from home, but often included references to the flowers, trees, pets, and horses of Belvoir.93 It would
seem Belvoir and all it represented were never far from his thoughts. The Harrisons were active equestrians, and
Fairfax was known to be an excellent horseman who was greatly interested in polo, fox hunting, and other
equestrian sports.94 The letters suggest a happy and content lifestyle at Belvoir, one anchored in the country but
connected to the larger world through D.C. and New York society, the best private boarding schools for the
younger children, and travel abroad.95,96,97
While Hetty was immersed in her volunteer commitments, she found time to pursue her personal horticultural
interests. She continued editing and expanding the gardens at Belvoir, while fine-tuning her horticultural skills.
Her extensive cutting gardens of roses, peonies, phlox, and irises served her well, as she was a highly successful
flower show competitor who often took home blue ribbons.98 Hetty appears to have become something of an
authority on flower show competitions, and was judging for such events as early as 1935.99
Similarly, Fairfax managed to find time to pursue his personal interest in Virginia history. He was known as a man
of broad culture, and an acute and restless intellect.100 He served as a Vice President of the Virginia Historical
Society for years, and was a frequent contributor to the Societys magazine.101 Fairfax authored a number of books
on different aspects of Virginia history that were privately printed to share with friends and academics. Among
these are: Landmarks of Old Prince William County, The Proprietors of the Northern Neck, The Virginia Land Grants, The
Virginia Carys, The Devon Carys, Roman Farm Management, and several articles and books on the history of turf in
Virginia.102
50
A Retirement Thwarted
Despite the immense professional success Fairfax enjoyed while employed with the Southern Railway Company,
his announcement to retire on October 21, 1937 spoke of his desires to spend more time with his family and to
pursue his other research and scholarly interests.
To all Officers,
After having devoted forty-one years, all my mature life, to the Southern and having had the honour and privilege of the
chief command for twenty-four years, I have taken a back seat. My purpose is to have more time to be with my family
and to pursue studies of other things than railroading which have also always interested me.
My first thought in taking this step is gratitude to you, one and all, for the support and steady confidence you have given
me during the years we have worked together. It has been a great and happy adventure, through all the vicissitudes of our
fortunes, during our periods of success as well as during the recent grueling depression. I have been fortified in the will to
protect the interests of the numerous and constantly changing company of investors we have represented, by a sense of the
solidarity and permanence of our official managing organization: and now when I look back I realize more than ever that
our greatest achievement has been the friendship and mutual respect which have grown with our association and have held
us together. It is with that friendship and that respect that I now salute you again, as I have so often in the past.
I am glad that it is not yet necessary to say goodbye. The Board of Directors of the Southern Railway Company have
asked me to be Chairman of their Finance Committee, and in that relation I shall have opportunity to know what you are
doing and, I hope, from time to time to shake your hands and look you in the eye.103
Unfortunately, Fairfax did not realize his desires to spend more time with family and his research, nor his dream of
organizing my life in the country.104 He died of heart failure on February 2, 1938 following several months of illness
and hospitalization in the Union Memorial Hospital of Baltimore, MD. Less than four months after submitting his
resignation to the Southern Railway Company, Fairfax Harrison was buried beside his parents at Ivy Hill
Cemetery in Alexandria, Virginia.105
51
It would appear that those who knew him well were aware of Fairfaxs fond devotion to Belvoir, as well as to his
scholarly pursuits. After his death, the Officers of the Southern Railway Company commissioned a posthumous
portrait from Eugen Weisz to honor the late Fairfax Harrison. The painting, presented to Mrs. Fairfax Harrison in
1939, portrays Fairfax seated at his desk at the Southern Railway Company, surrounded by references to treasured
possessions (figure 3-38). The painting hanging on the wall behind him is clearly a partial aerial view of Belvoir,
capturing the house and formal boxwood garden. A full bookcase to his right makes reference to his vast library,
his love for books, and the associated scholarship and research.
Figure
3-38:
Portrait
Presented
to
Mrs.
Fairfax
Harrison
from
the
Southern
Railway
Co.
in
Honor
of
Fairfax
Harrison.
Inscription
on
Back
of
Portrait
Includes
Artists
Signature.
(Portrait Located at the Virginia Historical Society Museum Collections, http://www.vahistorical.org)
52
An undated memo from Fairfax to Hetty, containing an epitaph, speaks volumes about what had been important
to Mr. Harrison in life:
There are no known sources that illuminate the extent to which Fairfaxs untimely death impacted Hetty, but it
can be assumed it was a tremendous, unexpected loss for her. At the time of his death, Hetty was entrenched in
her volunteer efforts with a number of organizations, where she held several key leadership positions in parallel. By
this point in her life, she had clearly established herself as an effective organizer and leader, who was also well
versed in matters of horticulture, historic preservation and restoration, and beautification. Throughout Virginia,
Hetty was widely known:
Mrs. Harrison is one of the most prominent persons in gardening activities in this part of the country. Her home, Belvoir,
at The Plains, Va., is one of the showplaces of the State.107
For the GCV, she had already successfully overseen the garden restorations at Stratford Hall and had moved on to
serve as the Chairman of the GCV Restoration Committee (1938-1943), and as a Director-at-Large (19361939).108,109 Hetty had become a Vice President with the American Horticultural Society (AHS) in 1936, a position
she held until becoming an AHS Director in 1941.110 During this time she also continued to serve as the President
of the National Mary Washington Memorial Association, the Vice Regent of Virginia for the Mount Vernon
Ladies Association, and President of her District Society for the Colonial Dames of America.111,112, 113
53
Hetty remained in residence at Belvoir with her eldest daughter and son for several years after her husbands death.
Nothing is known of the financial circumstances in which she found herself, but it is likely that maintaining the
large house in addition to the gardens, along with the responsibility of managing the large working farm, were
simply too much for Hetty, financially or otherwise. In April of 1941, she leased the house and formal grounds of
Belvoir to Hamilton Robinson.114 The details of the lease agreement highlight Hettys intentions and the state of
Belvoir at the time of lease: Hetty would continue to be responsible for the care of her beloved grounds and
gardens, even if she were not in residence; the tennis court was in existence by 1941; and she was looking to
ultimately sell Belvoir Farm. The following excerpt from that lease agreement make these points clear:
THE LESSOR is to maintain the grounds at her own expense including maintaining the lawn, planting and
maintaining the flower garden and vegetable garden except that the lessor will put the tennis court in good order at the
beginning of this lease and mark it off for the lessee and thereafter the lessee will maintain and mark off the tennis court,
the necessary tools being made available by the lessor. It is understood and agreed between the lessor and the lessee that in
the event of the sale of Belvoir at any time after the first six months of this lease the lessee will vacate and give
possession to the lessor within ninety days from the beginning of the lease month beginning after written notice from the
lessor or her agent.
It is understood and agreed, however, that the lessee is to have the refusal to purchase the property at any price that may be
acceptable to the lessor.115
After leasing Belvoir to Hamilton Robinson, Hetty and her two children removed to a much smaller house on the
property known as Edenburn, the Harrisons name for the house and 198-acre parcel they added to Belvoir Farm
in 1925.116 Despite health complications, and restrictions on travel during the lean war years of 1942-1943, Hetty
continued to work diligently on behalf of her volunteer commitments.117 On May 14, 1943 the Garden Club of
Virginia Massie Medal Award Committee chose to recognize Mrs. Fairfax Harrison for her many contributions to
that organization over the years.
54
The Massie Medal is awarded this year to Mrs. Fairfax Harrison, Belvoir House, Belvoir, Virginia, member of the
Fauquier and Loudoun Garden Club, for her untiring and outstanding work as chairman of the Stratford Restoration
Committee, and for her loyal support and active work on the Restoration Committee of the Garden Club of Virginia, of
which she has been chairman since 1938.118
The citation on the medal reads:
To Hetty Cary Harrison,
Whose Inheritance and Ideals
Inspired Fruitful Research
Into the History of Virginia
Gardens and Shrines
In a letter to a fellow Director of the GCV, Hetty shared her reaction to having received the medal:
My dear Anne,
The medal has come and I am quite speechless, your having chosen me for this honor, the most coveted of all and the wonderful inscription,
fills my cup of happiness to overflowing.119
The letter also indicated that Hettys health had been in decline, explaining her inability to attend the GCV Board
of Directors meeting. While it is unknown what exactly ailed her, it was clearly serious; on June 23 of 1943, Hetty
died in Doctors Hospital, Washington D.C. after having been hospitalized for two weeks prior.120 Her death was
widely and publicly mourned. An editorial in Richmonds The News Leader paid one such tribute to Mrs. Fairfax
Harrison:
When Mrs. Fairfax Harrison died in Washington, Virginia lost one of her most brilliant daughters. All that
her husband was among men, she was among women. They had the same background and the same inheritance of great
names and high traditions. Had Hetty Cary Harrison lived in Richmond during the period of the Confederacy, she would
have been as renowned as either the famous Hetty or Constance Cary of that era. One could imagine her in fact, as being
55
the heroine of many of the stories told in her mother-in-laws memoirs, Recollections Grave and Gay. All that was
Virginian appealed to Mrs. Harrison. Gardens and shrines and fanes and folkways were as wine to her imagination.
Wherever she went, she gave grace to the occasion and beauty to the setting.121
Mrs. William R. Massie, Honorary President of the GCV, wrote a touching tribute to Hetty on behalf of the GCV,
which summarized many of her contributions to that organization:
The Garden Club of Virginia bows its head in sorrow at the passing of its beloved and distinguished member,
Mrs. Fairfax Harrison. Her death leaves her wide circle of friends with a sense of irretrievable loss and grief. A member
of this Club since its foundation, she did much to form its policy and to make the successful organization which it has
grown to be.
Her accurate knowledge of the early history of Virginia, its homes and its people, has been an invaluable asset in
the restoration work to which the Club is pledged, and to this work she gave unstintingly of her time and her talents.
The Stratford gardens especially enthralled her and their restoration was carried out under her leadership. She was
connected with the reclamation of every old garden undertaken by The Garden Club of Virginia. She later became
Chairman of Restoration, which office she held at the time of her death.
It was decided two years ago that the next project of the Garden Club would be the restoration of the Colonial
churchyards. She, as Chairman of Restoration, at once began research into the histories and all data available concerning
these ancient burial yards and she felt that many interesting historical facts would be revealed as the work progressed. In
the summary of the years work, as reported to the Board of Directors on May 20, 1943, she stated that up to that time
only one of these restorations had actually been undertaken, and while she was much encouraged and gratified at the
progress made, she reported that the work was not yet completed.
The efficiency and dignity with which Mrs. Harrison fulfilled every undertaking made her deeply respected and
admired. Her loyalty and graciousness made for deep friendships, and many mourn her irreplaceable loss today.
We owe her much, for she gave much
We shall not look upon her like again.
S.W.M.122
56
In honor of Hetty Cary Harrison, and the Cary family legacy at the College
of William and Mary, the GCV placed a portrait of her at the College
together with a compilation of garden books (figure 3-39). 123 Her
gardening, horticulture, and landscape design books formed the core of the
collection to which the GCV supplemented, ultimately creating a repository
of books on gardening and gardens that was regarded as one of the most
outstanding in the country.124
Given that Hetty was attempting to sell Belvoir Farm prior to her death
suggests that her children were not interested, or could not afford, to take
on its ownership. Correspondences between the Harrisons two youngest
daughters, Ursula and Sally, and First and Merchants National Bank, the
executor and trustee of Mrs. Hetty Fairfax Harrison estate,125 highlight the
challenges that were faced in selling such a property during World War
II.126 There were limited numbers of buyers who could afford such a large
estate in the country at this time, and fuel rationing made travel difficult for
would-be urban buyers to even evaluate the prospect. The correspondences
also suggest that many updates and repairs were needed at Belvoir, which
might have been daunting to prospective buyers.127 Finally in April of 1944,
William D. Pawley paid $110,000.00 for Belvoir Farm, the contract
covering the real estate and buildings, all farming equipment, supplies,
cattle, horses and other animals belonging to the Estate, and the half
interest in other animals owned jointly with Mr. Adams. It did not cover
the furniture or other personal effects in either house.128
Unknown. Entries in the handwriting of Fairfax Harrison from the Belvoir Book. Accession number 1843, Fairfax Harrison Papers 1911-1943, Special
Collections, University of Virginia Library.
2 Ibid.
3 Ibid.
4 Ibid.
1
57
Ibid.
Ibid.
7 Ibid.
8 Ibid.
9 Ibid.
10 Harrison, Fairfax. June 3, 1912. Unsent letter to Mr. Finley. From the Fairfax Harrison Papers 1736-1945, Special Collections, Swem Library College of
William and Mary.
11 Harrison, Fairfax and Hetty Harrison. Letters and telegrams contained within the Fairfax Harrison Papers 1736-1945, Special Collections, Swem Library
College of William and Mary; and the Fairfax Harrison Papers 1911-1943, Special Collections, University of Virginia Library.
12 Harrison, Fairfax. May, 1912. Letter to H.H. Accession number 1843, Fairfax Harrison Papers 1911-1943, Special Collections, University of Virginia
Library.
13 Harrison, Fairfax. July 19, 1912. Letter to H.H. Accession number 1843, Fairfax Harrison Papers 1911-1943, Special Collections, University of Virginia
Library.
14 Harrison, Fairfax. April, 1913. Letter to H.H. Accession number 1843, Fairfax Harrison Papers 1911-1943, Special Collections, University of Virginia
Library.
15 Harrison, Fairfax. March 8, 1916. Letter to Raphael S. Payne. From the Fairfax Harrison Papers 1736-1945, Special Collections, Swem Library College of
William and Mary.
16 Harrison, Fairfax. May 30, 1912. Letter to H.H. Accession number 1843, Fairfax Harrison Papers 1911-1943, Special Collections, University of Virginia
Library.
17 Harrison, Fairfax. January 3, 1914. Letter to Arthur D. Addison, Esq. regarding lease of 1824 Massachusetts Avenue, Washington D.C. From the Fairfax
Harrison Papers 1736-1945, Special Collections, Swem Library, College of William and Mary.
18 Harrison, Fairfax. February 24, 1921. Letter to the Chesapeake & Potomac Telephone Co. From the Fairfax Harrison Papers 1736-1945, Special
Collections, Swem Library, College of William and Mary.
19 Harrison, Fairfax. June 12, 1929. Letter to The Editor of Time Magazine. Accession number 1843, Fairfax Harrison Papers 1911-1943, Special Collections,
University of Virginia Library.
20 Theobald, Mary Miley. 2002. The Colonial Revival: The Past That Never Dies. Colonial Williamsburg Journal. Accessed October 8, 2014 from
http://www.history.org/foundation/journal/summer02/revival.cfm
21 Lears, T.J. Jackson. 1981. No Place of Grace: Antimodernism and the Transformation of American Culture, 1880-1920. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
22 Marling, Karal Ann. 1988. George Washington Slept Here: Colonial Revivals and American Culture 1876-1986. Cambridge MA and London: Harvard University
Press.
23 Theobald, Mary Miley. 2002. The Colonial Revival: The Past That Never Dies. Colonial Williamsburg Journal. Accessed October 8, 2014 from
http://www.history.org/foundation/journal/summer02/revival.cfm
24 Fauquier County Circuit Court Archives, Deed Book 98, page 213.
25 Gabbett, Harry. August 31, 1963. Nathan C. Wyeth, Architect for D.C., is Dead here at 93. The Washington Post. Page B3.
26 Cresson, William Penn (1864-1932). American Architects and Buildings Project. Accessed on November 17, 2014 from
http://www.americanbuildings.org/pab/app/ar_display.cfm/51289
27 Ibid.
28 Wyeth & Cresson. June 5, 1906. Letter to Fairfax Harrison regarding Belvoir House blue prints. From the Fairfax Harrison Papers 1736-1945, Special
Collections, Swem Library, College of William and Mary.
5
6
58
Wyeth & Cresson. February 4, 1907. Letter to Fairfax Harrison regarding stairway and rear porch change orders at Belvoir House. From the Fairfax
Harrison Papers 1736-1945, Special Collections, Swem Library, College of William and Mary.
30 Wyeth & Cresson. September 1, 1906. Letter to Fairfax Harrison regarding the merits of constructing Belvoir House around the existing brick dwelling.
From the Fairfax Harrison Papers 1736-1945, Special Collections, Swem Library, College of William and Mary.
31 Personal correspondence with Wayne Eastham, Property Manager for Belvoir Farm. June, 2014.
32 Harrison, Fairfax. 1906. Correspondence with the Southern Railway Company regarding Belvoir passenger and freight stop. From the Fairfax Harrison
Papers 1736-1945, Special Collections, Swem Library, College of William and Mary.
33 Ibid.
34 Fauquier County Circuit Court Archives, Deed Book 128, page 121.
35 Wyeth & Cresson. September 1, 1906. Letter to Fairfax Harrison regarding the merits of constructing Belvoir House around the existing brick dwelling.
From the Fairfax Harrison Papers 1736-1945, Special Collections, Swem Library, College of William and Mary.
36 Unknown. April 12, 1962. Noted for its Classical Gardens. The Fauquier Democrat. Page B1.
37 Fauquier County Circuit Court Archives, Deed Book 128, page 121.
38 Mary Moore personal collection of Belvoir and Harrison family photographs and manuscripts.
39 Ibid.
40 The Garden Club of America. 1921. List of Gardens of the Members of the Garden Club of America Open to Visit by Members. Page 18.
41 Unknown. December 1, 1960. Belvoir Estate Bought by E. DeLong Bowman. The Fauquier Democrat. Page 1.
42 Unknown. November 30, 1952. Arthur F. Paul Dies at Age of 74. The Philadelphia Inquirer.
43 Griswold, Mac and Eleanor Weller. 1991. The Golden Age of American Gardens: Proud Owners, Private Estates 1890-1940. New York: Harry N. Abrams, Inc.
Page 148.
44 Harvard University. 1903. Secretarys First Report, Harvard College: Class of 1902. Cambridge: Harvard University Press. Page 184.
45 Harvard University. 1899. Harvard University Catalog, The Bussey Institution. Cambridge: Harvard University Press. Page 169.
46 Pray, James Sturgis. January 1911. The Department of Landscape Architecture in Harvard University. Landscape Architecture. Vol. 1, No. 2. New York:
N.Y. Pages 56-57.
47 The Cultural Landscape Foundation. Jacques-Henri-Auguste Grber. Accessed March 10, 2015 at http://tclf.org/pioneer/jacques-gr%C3%A9ber
48 The Cultural Landscape Foundation. Thomas W. Sears. Accessed March 10, 2015 at http://tclf.org/pioneer/thomas-w-sears
49 Paul, Oglesby. January 6, 1906. The Ideal Country Home. Horticulture. Pages 16-17.
50 Unknown. August 18, 1905. Flower Men Adjourn: Last Days Session Full of Business and Pleasure. The Washington Post. Page 2.
51 Philadelphia Architects and Buildings. Oglesby Paul, Landscape Architect (d.1915). Accessed on March 9, 2015 at
http://www.philadelphiabuildings.org/pab/app/ar_display.cfm/22324
52 Unknown. 1902. Organizations and Individuals Municipal Engineering. Vol. 23, page 479.
53 Personal communication with Tammy Hamilton at Hershey Community Archives. Oglesby Paul Landscape Architect was hired to landscape the entire
community of Hershey, PA as well as High Point, the Hershey familys private residence. Invoices and plans suggest Oglesby Pauls firm worked with
Hershey at least between 1908-1914.
54 Alpha Associates Website. 1991- High Gate Mansion, Fairmont, WV. Accessed on March 9, 2015 at
http://www.alphaaec.com/holiday/detail.php?id=13
55 Bemis, Margaret Page. 2009. Historic Virginia Gardens: Preservation Work of the Garden Club of Virginia, 1975-2007. Charlottesville: University of Virginia Press.
Page 133.
29
59
All letterhead, paid advertisements, and plans from the firm that have been examined credited the work to Oglesby Paul, Landscape Architect without any
mention of partners or associates, despite the fact that at least Arthur F. Paul had been working with Oglesby Paul since 1903.
57 American Architects and Buildings Project. Paul, Arthur F. Landscape Architect. Biography. Accessed November 22, 2014 from
http://www.washingtonpost.com/local/seven-of-nations-10-most-affluent-counties-are-in-washington-region/2012/09/19/f580bf30-028b-11e28102-ebee9c66e190_story.html
58 Unknown. November 30, 1952. Arthur F. Paul Dies at Age of 74. The Philadelphia Inquirer. Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.
59 Unknown. April 18, 1937. Gardening Program Inaugurated by KBST; Authority Presents Letters each Tuesday and Thursday Morning. Abilene ReporterNews. Abilene, Texas. Page 5.
60 National Register Listing in Maryland for Tyrconnell. Accessed December 2, 2014 from
http://mht.maryland.gov/nr/NRDetail.aspx?HDID=857&FROM=NRMapBA.html
61 Library of Congress. Montpelier Marion du Pont Scott house, 11395 Constitution Highway, Montpelier, Orange County, Virginia. Willow Gate.
Accessed November 23, 2014 from http://www.loc.gov/pictures/item/2008680015/
62 Oglesby Paul. February 28, 1911. Key List for Planting Plan for Evergreen Walk for the Garden of Mrs. Fairfax Harrison, Belvoir, VA. Mary Moore
Personal Collection of Belvoir and Harrison family photographs and manuscripts.
63 Unknown. December 1, 1960. Belvoir Estate Bought by E. DeLong Bowman. The Fauquier Democrat. Page 1.
64 Ibid.
65 Martin, Mrs. James Bland, editor. 1970. Follow the Green Arrow: The History of the Garden Club of Virginia, 1920-1970. Richmond: The Dietz Press, Inc. Pages
1-4.
66 Hetty Harrison served in various positions within the Garden Club of America, which include: Vice President, Director, Chairman of the Nominating
Committee, and Vice Chair of the National Capitol Committee, and Chair of the Committee on Education and Fellowship. Information provided by
Anne R. Myers from the Garden Club of America Archives.
67 Martin, Mrs. James Bland, editor. 1970. Follow the Green Arrow: The History of the Garden Club of Virginia, 1920-1970. Richmond: The Dietz Press, Inc. Page 6.
68 Garden Club of Virginia Archives, Kent Valentine House.
69 The Garden Club of America. The GCA Internship in Garden History and Design. Accessed on December 2, 2014 from
https://www.gcamerica.org/index.cfm/scholarships/details/id/14
70 Ibid.
71 Brown, Elizabeth. 1956. Mrs. Fairfax Harrison President.
Forty Years On: A Brief History of the Fauquier and Loudoun Garden Club 1915-1955. Pages 10-11.
Provided by Anne R. Myers from the Garden Club of America Archives.
72 Smithsonian Institution, Archives of American Gardens, Belvoir House Created by the Fauquier and Loudoun Garden Club, Garden Club of America
Collection.
73 Ibid.
74 Numerous articles on rock gardens and rock gardening appeared in early issues of the Garden Gossip, the Garden Club of Virginias magazine. A number of
the early Garden Gossip cover photos are of rock gardens. Garden Club of Virginia archives, Kent-Valentine House.
75 The Library of Congress. Frances Benjamin Johnston Biographical Overview and Chronology. Prints and Photographs Reading Room. Information
accessed on December 2, 2014 at http://www.loc.gov/rr/print/coll/fbjchron.html
76 Ibid.
77 Belvoir, Fairfax Harrison house, Star Route 709, The Plains, Fauquier County Virginia. Temple. Information on how slides were used found in the Notes
section accessed on December 2, 2014 from http://www.loc.gov/pictures/collection/fbj/item/2008679239/
56
60
Garden Club of Virginia Archives. February, 1934. Cover photo of fringe tree at Belvoir with caption Notable Virginia Trees: Fringe Tree at Belvoir,
Estate of Mr. and Mrs. Fairfax Harrison. The Garden Gossip. Kent-Valentine House.
79 Unknown. April 27, 1944. Belvoir Estate of 685 Acres Bought W.D. Pawley. The Fauquier Democrat. Page 1.
80 Unknown. April 8, 1942. Judges Chosen for Flower Mart. The Washington Post.
81 Unknown. August 13, 1930. Gymkhana at Belvoir Saturday Afternoon. The Fauquier Democrat.
82 Unknown. June 11, 1938. Miss Sally Harrison becomes Bride of Gerhard Dieke. The Fauquier Democrat. Page 1.
83 Harrison, Fairfax. September 12, 1917. Letter to E. Albert Smith, Esq, Superintendant of Schools, Warrenton, VA, regarding experimental summer school
the Harrisons started at Belvoir for local children who had not previously attended school. From the Fairfax Harrison Papers 1736-1945, Special
Collections, Swem Library, College of William and Mary.
84 Unknown. August 16, 1931. Foxcroft Teacher Weds Chicago Man. The Washington Post.
85 Orange County Hunt Club. November 11, 1927. Letter to Mr. Fairfax Harrison thanking him for the generous subscription. Accession number 1843,
Fairfax Harrison Papers 1911-1943, Special Collections, University of Virginia Library.
86 Unknown. February 5, 1938. Fairfax Harrison, 69, Retired President of Southern Railway Company, Dies in Baltimore Hospital of Heart Disease. The
Fauquier Democrat. Page 1.
87 Fairfax Harrison. March 21, 1916. Letter to Miss M. Louise Evans, c/o the Fauquier Democrat, Warrenton Va. Accession number 1843, Fairfax Harrison
Papers 1911-1943, Special Collections, University of Virginia Library.
88 Unknown. December 1, 1960. Belvoir Estate Bought by E. DeLong Bowman. The Fauquier Democrat. Page 1.
89 Brown, Elizabeth. 1956. 1921, Mrs. Fairfax Harrison President.
Forty Years On: A Brief History of the Fauquier and Loudoun Garden Club 1915-1955. Page 8.
Provided by Anne R. Myers from the Garden Club of America Archives.
90 Rieley & Associates Landscape Architects. November, 2004. The Garden Club of Virginia, Chairmen of the Restoration Committee from 1920-1995.
Excerpts from Follow the Green Arrow, Volumes 1 and 2.
91 Personal communication with Mary Moore based on documents and landscape plans concerning Mount Vernon found within Harrison family archives.
92 Unknown. October 23, 1920. Harrison Baird. The Fauquier Democrat. Page 1.
93 Harrison, Fairfax. Letters and telegrams from Fairfax Harrison to members of his family. Accession number 1843, Fairfax Harrison Papers 1911-1943,
Special Collections, University of Virginia Library.
94 Unknown. February 5, 1938. Fairfax Harrison, 69, Retired President of Southern Railway Company, Dies in Baltimore Hospital of Heart Disease. The
Fauquier Democrat. Page 1.
95 Unknown. November 29, 1931. Concert Patronesses. The Washington Post. Page S3.
96 Unknown. Entries in the handwriting of Fairfax Harrison from the Belvoir Book. Accession number 1843, Fairfax Harrison Papers 1911-1943, Special
Collections, University of Virginia Library.
97 Harrison, Fairfax. Various letters regarding travel with the children to Europe. Accession number 1843, Fairfax Harrison Papers 1911-1943, Special
Collections, University of Virginia Library.
98 Unknown. July 24, 1927. Rare Blooms Lauded at Big Garden Display. The Washington Post.
99 Unknown. May 16, 1935. U.S. Iris Medal Awaits Takoma Show Winner. National Society to Award Silver Honor; Judges are Listed. The Washington Post.
100 Unknown. February 3, 1938. Fairfax Harrison. Editorial. Richmond News Leader.
101 Unknown. February 4, 1938. Ex-President of Southern Ry. Heart Victim. New York Times. Page 1.
102 Ibid.
103 Harrison, Fairfax. October 21, 1937. Memo to officers of the Southern Railway System announcing Fairfax Harrisons decision to retire. Accession
number 1843, Fairfax Harrison Papers 1911-1943, Special Collections, University of Virginia Library.
78
61
Harrison, Fairfax. May, 1912. Letter to H.H. Accession number 1843, Fairfax Harrison Papers 1911-1943, Special Collections, University of Virginia
Library.
105 Unknown. Entries in the handwriting of Fairfax Harrison from the Belvoir Book. Accession number 1843, Fairfax Harrison Papers 1911-1943, Special
Collections, University of Virginia Library.
106 Harrison, Fairfax. Epitaph. Accession number 1843, Fairfax Harrison Papers 1911-1943, Special Collections, University of Virginia Library.
107 Unknown. April 8, 1942. Judges Chosen for Flower Mart. The Washington Post.
108 Rieley & Associates Landscape Architects. November, 2004. The Garden Club of Virginia, Chairmen of the Restoration Committee from 1920-1995.
Excerpts from Follow the Green Arrow, Volumes 1 and 2.
109 Massie Medal Award Committee, The Garden Club of Virginia. May 14, 1943. Report of Massie Medal Award Committee. The Garden Club of
Virginia Archives, Kent-Valentine House.
110 Unknown. April 20, 1941. Horticulture Group Elects. The Washington Post.
111 Unknown. August 27, 1939. Tribute Paid to Mary Washington. The Washington Post.
112 Personal communication with Mary Moore based on documents found within the Harrison family archives.
113 Unknown. March 7, 1939. Colonial Dames to Give Tea for National President. The Washington Post.
114 Harrison, Hetty. April 12, 1941. Belvoir lease agreement between Hetty Harrison and Hamilton Robinson. Fairfax Harrison Papers 1886-1973, Mss1
H2463 q 538-555, Virginia Historical Society Archives.
115 Ibid.
116 Fauquier County Circuit Court Archives, Deed Book 106, page 134.
117 Harrison, Hetty Fairfax. December 13, 1941. Letter to Mrs. Sands. Garden Club of Virginia Archives, Kent-Valentine House.
118 Massie Medal Award Committee, The Garden Club of Virginia. May 14, 1943. Report of Massie Medal Award Committee. The Garden Club of
Virginia Archives, Kent-Valentine House.
119 Harrison, Hetty. May 24, 1943. Letter expressing appreciation for having received the Massie Medal. The Garden Club of Virginia Archives, KentValentine House.
120 Unknown. June 24, 1943. Mrs. Harrison, Widow of Former Railroad Head, Dies on June 23. The Fauquier Democrat. Page 1.
121 Unknown. Tribute to Mrs. Fairfax Harrison. Editorial in The News Leader, Richmond, VA. Located in The Garden Club of Virginia Archives, KentValentine House.
122 Massie, Susan. June, 1943. Mrs. Fairfax Harrison. The Garden Club of Virginia Archives, Kent-Valentine House.
123 Martin, Mrs. James Bland, editor. 1970. Follow the Green Arrow: The History of the Garden Club of Virginia, 1920-1970. Richmond: The Dietz Press, Inc. Page
83.
124 Ibid.
125 After Fairfax Harrison died in 1938, Hetty appears to have adopted Mrs. Hetty Fairfax Harrison as her official name.
126 Letters between First and Merchants National Bank and Mrs. Charles Baird Jr. Fairfax Harrison Papers 1886-1973, Mss1 H2463 q 538-555, Virginia
Historical Society Archives.
127 Ibid.
128 Ryland, S.P. April 12, 1944. Letter to Mrs. Charles Baird, Jr. Fairfax Harrison Papers 1886-1973, Mss1 H2463 q 538-555, Virginia Historical Society
Archives.
104
62
63
William D. Pawley was born in Florence, South Carolina, but spent most of his childhood in Cuba and grew up
speaking Spanish fluently.1 Despite a lack of formal education, he became a successful self-made businessman, first
in Florida real estate speculation and later with aviation ventures in Florida, Cuba, and Asia.2 Acting as CurtissWright Corporations sales representative in China in the 1930s, Pawley positioned himself as the exclusive source
of American military aircraft sold to the Chinese government. He reportedly sold 30 million dollars worth of
planes and services to China, earning him the nickname the China Swashbuckler for his role in airplane
manufacturing negotiations there.3 He went on to build an airplane factory in India to support the Allies in Asia
during World War II, and was involved in establishing the Flying Tigers, a group of American volunteer pilots who
flew for the Chinese Air Force.4 Having made a fortune from his ventures in Asia, Pawley returned to the U.S. in
1944 to pursue an interest in politics and diplomacy, and to establish residency near Washington D.C.
Pawleys fluency in Spanish was an asset, and his diplomatic aspirations were quickly realized when President
Harry Truman appointed Pawley as the Ambassador to Peru in 1945, and then as Ambassador to Brazil from 1946
through 1948.5 Pawley eventually switched political parties, and campaigned for his friend Dwight Eisenhower
during his bid for the presidency in 1952. President Eisenhower later assigned Pawley to the State Department,
where he handled sensitive national security matters, and dealt with world leaders as a Special Advisor.6 He was a
frequent guest at the White House during the Eisenhower administration, and remained a close personal friend and
supporter of the President.
At the time William and Edna Pawley purchased Belvoir in 1944, they owned a 20-room home in Miami Beach as
well as a residence in Washington D.C.7,8 Pawley was an avid sportsman, and was likely drawn to purchase this
large farm for its hunting and fishing opportunities, while remaining close to the political scene of D.C. He also
dabbled in raising racehorses at Belvoir, an effort that was met with some amount of success.9,10 Belvoir was more
of a country retreat and entertainment venue for the Pawleys than merely another residence. Within just a few
years of purchasing Belvoir Farm, Pawley had a 10-acre lake dug on the property and stocked with bass.11 He also
64
raised pheasants, chukar partridge, and quail at the farm, dedicating more than 100-acres to growing feed for the
game birds, and worked with Virginia authorities to have Belvoir declared a game preserve. 12,13 The Pawleys
frequently entertained friends and guests for fishing and hunting, and used Belvoir to host events and rallies for
political purposes.14,15 Ike and Mamie Eisenhower were frequent visitors to Belvoir, as Eisenhower and Pawley
had become close friends who shared like-minded political views. 16 There, the Eisenhowers could relax and enjoy
being pampered by the wealthy Pawleys. In a letter to Pawley, Eisenhower wrote of Belvoir:
I cannot tell you
what both of us
wouldnt give this
minute to be able to
sit leisurely there a
week or two, on the
back porch of your
home, with no
thought of going
farther astray than
the bass lake to see if
the big ones are
rising to fly.17
Figure
4-1:
1953 General Design Plan by Rose Greely for Mrs. William Pawley Belvoir The Plains,
Virginia. (Rose Greely Papers, MSS 10772, Special Collections, University of Virginia)
The Pawleys
also introduced
changes and
additions to the
formal gardens and
grounds. While it is
not known for certain,
it is likely that the
Pawleys installed the
greenhouses at
Belvoir. They do not
appear on any of the
historic aerials that
date to the Harrison
era (figures 2-2, 3-34,
3-35), and oral
history suggested
Edna used the
greenhouses to
provide fresh cut
flowers year-round.20
18,19
Figure
4-2: 1953 Planting Plan for the Perennial Garden by Rose Greely for Mrs. William Pawley Belvoir The Plains,
Virginia. (Rose Greely Papers, MSS 10772, Special Collections, University of Virginia)
Edna Pawley, William D. Pawleys second wife, has been another elusive historical figure, and to date very little
information has been uncovered about her for this study. A brief mention of her describes: Mrs. Pawley, an
Oklahoma gal, is a most satisfactory blonde.21 There is no known evidence that she engaged in local Fauquier County
society events or organizations. Press coverage of Edna appears to be limited to society page entries that tracked
Ambassador Pawley and wife on a more national, rather than local, level.22 However, based on surviving plans, we
do know that between 1951 and 1953 she hired landscape architect Rose Greely from Washington D.C. to update
the formal grounds and gardens at Belvoir.23
66
Rose Ishbel Greely (1887-1969), trained in a number of artistic disciplines, was also certified in both architecture
and landscape architecture.24 After graduation, she worked as a draftsman for Fletcher Steele before returning to
her hometown of Washington D.C. to work with Horace Peaslee.25 By 1925 Greely had become Washingtons first
female licensed architect, and had established her own successful architectural firm which went on to handle a wide
variety of both architectural and landscape commissions.26 Greely was a frequent contributor to House Beautiful,
authoring articles on a range of horticultural and design topics. By the time Greely began working with the
Pawleys on updates for Belvoirs formal grounds and gardens, she was winding down a very productive, forty year
long career.27
Figure
4-3: 1952 Bulb Plan for the Perennial Garden by Rose Greely for Mrs. William Pawley Belvoir The Plains,
Virginia. (Rose Greely Papers, MSS 10772, Special Collections, University of Virginia)
67
68
69
The most substantial updates to Belvoirs formal grounds were suggested for hardscape elements, which included
redoing the rear and front terraces, steps, and walls; introducing a new flagstone terrace at the bottom of the
southwest porch; creating a new terrace next to the tennis court; and expanding the entrance court (figures 4-1, 4-5,
and 4-6). With the exception of the proposed flagstone terrace at the base of the southwest porch, physical
evidence confirms that all proposed hardscape elements were installed (figures 4-7 through 4-16). There is no
evidence that proposed plantings to accompany these hardscape elements were ever realized, as they do not exist in
the landscape today (Figure 4-1). Greely demanded that her projects were implemented to a very high standard,
resulting in projects that were extremely well built, and many of her hardscape installations have endured the test of
time.30 Today, all the Greely designed hardscape features for Belvoir are extant, except for the tennis court terrace
which was intentionally removed by the current owners.
Figure 4-6: Rose Greely Designed South Porch Stone Steps, 2014.
Figure
4-7: Photograph From Porch Looking Down Rose Greely Designed
South Porch Steps, 2014.
70
71
72
During the 1950s, Pawley invested heavily in business ventures in Cuba that included a public transportation
system and a sugar plantation.31 Quite familiar with the inner workings in Cuba, he was vocal with the U.S. State
Department and Administration about his concerns regarding the political state of affairs in Cuba, warning of a
communist takeover if Fidel Castro ever came to power.32 Pawley and the State Department did not agree on an
interpretation of the threat Castro represented at that time. After Castro seized power, Pawley went on to spend
years and much of his personal fortune attempting to support an overthrow of Castro.33 It is unclear exactly why
the Pawleys chose to sell Belvoir Farm during these tumultuous times, but it is possible that Pawley felt he needed to
relocate to Florida to be closer to the situation in Cuba. In December of 1960, Belvoir Farm was sold to E.
DeLong Bowman of Sunset Hills, Fairfax County Virginia.34
Thayer, Mary Van Rensselaer. August 14, 1947. Flying Tiger Diplomat is U.S. Host at Rio. The Washington Post. Page B3.
Ibid.
3 Unknown. April 27, 1944. Belvoir Estate of 685 Acres Bought by W.D. Pawley. The Fauquier Democrat. Page 1.
4 Carrozza, Anthony R. 2012. William D. Pawley: The Extraordinary Life of the Adventurer, Entrepreneur, and Diplomat Who Cofounded the Flying Tigers. Washington D.C.:
Potomac Books.
5 Thayer, Mary Van Rensselaer. August 14, 1947. Flying Tiger Diplomat is U.S. Host at Rio. The Washington Post. Page B3.
6 Carrozza, Anthony R. 2012. William D. Pawley: The Extraordinary Life of the Adventurer, Entrepreneur, and Diplomat Who Cofounded the Flying Tigers. Washington D.C.:
Potomac Books. Page 196.
7 Unknown. April 22, 1944. China Swashbuckler Buys Showplace at Warrenton. The Washington Post. Page 3.
8 Personal communication from Robert Gaskins regarding the Pawleys having a residence in Washington D.C. August, 2014.
9 Unknown. September 30, 1947. Travancore Wins Gansett Feature. The Washington Post. Page 14.
10 Unknown. February 14, 1951. Baltimorean Brings Meet Total to 17. The Washington Post. Page 23.
11 Pattee, Dorothea. April 12, 1953. Fauquier Folk Live High and Handsome. The Washington Post. Page S3.
12 Carrozza, Anthony R. 2012. William D. Pawley: The Extraordinary Life of the Adventurer, Entrepreneur, and Diplomat Who Cofounded the Flying Tigers. Washington D.C.:
Potomac Books. Page 189.
13 Ibid.
14 Carrozza, Anthony R. 2012. William D. Pawley: The Extraordinary Life of the Adventurer, Entrepreneur, and Diplomat Who Cofounded the Flying Tigers. Washington D.C.:
Potomac Books. Page 183.
15 Sampson, Paul. October 15, 1956. Humphrey Tells GOP Objectives. The Washington Post and Times Herald. Page 18.
16 Carrozza, Anthony R. 2012. William D. Pawley: The Extraordinary Life of the Adventurer, Entrepreneur, and Diplomat Who Cofounded the Flying Tigers. Washington D.C.:
Potomac Books. Page 183.
17 Ibid.
18 Unknown. April 12, 1962. Noted for its Classical Gardens. The Fauquier Democrat. Page 1.
19 Thayer, Mary Van Rensselaer. August 14, 1947. Flying Tiger Diplomat is U.S. Host at Rio. The Washington Post. Page B3.
20 Personal communication from Robert Gaskins regarding the greenhouses being in existence at Belvoir when the Bowmans assumed ownership. August, 2014.
1
2
73
Thayer, Mary Van Rensselaer. August 14, 1947. Flying Tiger Diplomat is U.S. Host at Rio. The Washington Post. Page B3.
Unknown. July 19, 1948. In New York. The Washington Post. Page B3.
23 Greely, Rose. 1952-1953. Pawley, Mrs. William, Belvoir The Plains, Virginia. Rose Greely Papers. MSS 10772. Special Collections, University of
Virginia.
24 The Cultural Landscape Foundation. Rose Ishbel Greely. Accessed on December 23, 2014 from http://tclf.org/pioneer/rose-greely
25 Ibid.
26 Ibid.
27 Ibid.
28 Unknown. May 1, 1940. Miss Rose Greely Judges Flower Mart. The Washington Post. Page 17.
29 Greely, Rose. 1952-1953. Pawley, Mrs. William, Belvoir The Plains, Virginia. Rose Greely Papers. MSS 10772. Special Collections, University of
Virginia.
30 30 The Cultural Landscape Foundation. Rose Ishbel Greely. Accessed on December 23, 2014 from http://tclf.org/pioneer/rose-greely
31 Carrozza, Anthony R. 2012. William D. Pawley: The Extraordinary Life of the Adventurer, Entrepreneur, and Diplomat Who Cofounded the Flying Tigers. Washington D.C.:
Potomac Books. Page 213.
32 Ibid, page 214.
33 Ibid, pages 225-236.
34 Unknown. December 1, 1960. Belvoir Estate Bought by E. DeLong Bowman. The Fauquier Democrat. Page 1.
21
22
74
75
76
78
Barnes, Bart. October 20, 1989. E.D. Bowman Dies at 78; Headed Virginia Distillery. The Washington Post. Page D4.
Ibid.
3 Ibid.
4 Ibid.
5 Unknown. December 1, 1960. Belvoir Estate Bought by E. DeLong Bowman. The Fauquier Democrat. Page 1.
6 Unknown. February 5, 1977. Recent Fauquier Property Sales. The Washington Post. Page D30.
7 Slater, Kitty. October 4, 1963. The Horse Country The Washington Post. Page D4.
8 Unknown. July 9, 1964. Belvoir Horse Center Approved. The Fauquier Democrat.
9 Middleburg Real Estate. 1960. Belvoir Farm Brochure. Middleburg Real Estate Archives.
10 Unknown. April 12, 1962. Noted for Its Classical Gardens. The Fauquier Democrat. Page 1.
11 Personal communication from Belvoir gardener Robert Gaskins, July 2014.
12 Unknown. April 12, 1962. Noted for Its Classical Gardens. The Fauquier Democrat. Page 1.
13 Unknown. February 5, 1977. Recent Fauquier Property Sales. The Washington Post. Page D30.
14 Trumbo, Trudy. December 30, 1976. Belvoir Sold to Brazilian. The Fauquier Democrat. Page 1.
15 Ibid.
1
2
79
80
81
Figure 6-1: Plan of Belvoir House Formal Grounds and Key to Former Garden Features.
82
During the Harrison era, Belvoir Farm was nearly a constant work in
83
progress. While the subsequent three owners have all left their mark, those
changes have left much of the original Harrison era property intact: the
larger farm landscape Fairfax Harrison assembled remains largely
unchanged and continues to be used for agricultural purposes, and the
formal residence, gardens, and grounds continue to largely reflect design
intent and spatial organization dating to the Harrisons.
The Approach
84
85
Circulation
Belvoirs entrance and interior roads appear to have the same layout as
they did during the Harrisons tenure (figures 1-7, 3-35, 6-1). Large
maple trees still frame the entrance drive, albeit in smaller numbers than
were seen on historic aerial images (figures 1-7). Due to the loss of trees,
the house can be partially seen from the moment one turns into the
drive, which is unlikely to have been the case when the alles were intact
(figures 1-7, 6-3). The drive itself has been resurfaced in asphalt and pea
stone, possibly reflecting an earlier gravel treatment. Through the tree
trunks are long views of the southwest and southeast lawn areas (figures
6-4, 6-5). As can be seen in figure 6-1, the entrance drive gently curves
to the right as it approaches the house (figure 6-6). Belvoir house sits on
the highest elevation within the formal grounds, approximately 8 feet
above the entrance drive grade. The front entrance is reached via the
Greely-designed landing, steps, and walkway installed in the 1950s. The
Greely-designed entrance court provides limited parking and valuable
pull out space, as the entrance drive is only wide enough for a single
vehicle (figure 6-7).
The inner drive continues forward past the house, smoke house, and
farm office building before turning sharply to the left near the garages,
all buildings that date to the Harrisons (figures 6-8, 6-9). Farm related
buildings and structures, once hidden behind a screen of trees (figure 17), are visible in the distance across fenced pastures (figure 6-8). Just past
the garages and on the right is the Harrison barn dating to 1907
86
87
Perimeter Plantings
Dense perimeter plantings of evergreen and deciduous trees, used by
the Harrisons to define and spatially separate the formal residence from
the larger working agricultural landscape, have thinned with time
(figures 1-7, 6-2). This has been largely due to the loss of aging trees,
significant storm events, and inevitable change in plant form such as
with the Eastern white pines located at the southwest corner of the lawn
(figure 6-16).
Lawns
Extensive areas of lawn have characterized this landscape since the
beginning of the 20th century, as can be seen from the historic aerial
photographs (figures 1-7, 3-35). Today, large open areas of lawn
continue to dominate the south grounds on either side of the entrance
drive (figures 6-4, 6-5). Despite the infill of maturing trees near the
side-covered porch, the open southwest lawn allows important views
from the house to the Blue Ridge Mountains in the distance to be
preserved (figure 6-17). During the Harrison era, the east lawn was
densely planted with a mixture of deciduous and evergreen trees (figure
1-7). Many of those trees are now gone, expanding the degree of open
lawn in this area of the grounds (figures 6-18, 6-19). The remnants of
Hettys rock garden are still visible near the fence line in the southeast
portion of the east lawn (figures 3-27, 6-20).
section of the east lawn, but was removed and replaced with lawn by
the current owner due to deterioration (figures 6-1, 6-21). In the 1950s,
Greely had designed a terrace for the Pawleys that was placed next to
Figure
6-22:
Rose
Greely
Steps
to
Tennis
Terrace,
2014.
88
89
the tennis court, as well as elegant curving steps leading down to the
tennis terrace from the driveway (figures 4-5, 6-22, 6-23). The
staircase remains intact and is still in use, whereas the flagstone
terrace was largely dismantled. All that remains are a few partially
buried pavers and the garden bench to mark the spot under the
white pines.
converted to lawn include the kitchen garden and the cutting garden
(figure 6-1). All that remains from the kitchen garden are two low
stone retaining walls that create shallow terraces, and two stone piers
that likely mark the former entrance gate into the previously fenced
in garden (figures 3-35, 6-24, 6-25, 6-26). Directly across from the
former kitchen garden stone piers are two symmetrically placed
stone piers marking the entrance gate into the former cutting garden,
located behind the tall stone wall along the inner drive (figures 3-35,
6-27). The extensive rose arbor and multitude of planting beds are
gone from the cutting garden and have been replaced with lower
maintenance lawn (figure 6-28). All that remains from the Harrison
cutting garden are the square and round stone fountains, a low
stonewall near the round fountain, and a number of white pines and
boxwood along the west perimeter stone wall. A few persistent
yuccas, daylilies, and irises poking through the turf are likely
holdovers from the former cutting beds.
Adjacent to the former cutting garden is the former work yard, which eventually became the site of the
greenhouses, presumably installed during the Pawleys tenure (figures 6-29). A concrete slab next to the existing
90
91
92
93
Figure 6-37: View Along Central Axis from Rear Terrace, 2014.
94
95
Figure
6-49:
Curved
Steps
at
Figure
6-50:
Rear
Terrace
Stone
Retaining
Wall,
2014.
Southwest
Corner
of
Formal
Garden,
2014.
96
97
98
Just beyond the outer privet hedge along the south edge
of the formal boxwood garden is the lengthy boxwood
hedge installed by the Bowmans in the 1960s (figures 61, 6-62). Running parallel to the entire length of the
privet hedge, the boxwood hedge terminates near the
pool, also installed by the Bowmans (figure 6-1, 6-62, 663).
Personal communications from Robert Gaskins 6/2014, Belvoir gardener since 1962, and current property owner on 7/17/2014.
99
100
Harrison Era Weeping Cherry Trees as Seen From Second Story of Southeast Porch, 2014.
101
CONCLUDING REMARKS
Belvoir is a significant surviving example of Colonial Revival estate design, as practiced in Virginia during the late
19th and early 20th centuries. However, the significance of this Colonial Revival showplace extends beyond the
impressive buildings and grounds, as Belvoirs history represents a microcosm of Virginias history from the turn of
the 19th century to the present. The history of Belvoirs evolution includes the story of the people who created,
shaped, and later stewarded the property into the 21st century, each in the cultural context of their day. The house
and gardens created by Fairfax and Hetty Harrison at Belvoir were an expression of their wealth, education, values,
expertise, and collective Virginia heritage, manifested at a point in American history when the Colonial Revival
movement held many perceived answers to the problems of the day. The Harrisons Belvoir was a constant work
in progress during their tenure, impacted at various points by leading professionals of the day such as landscape
architects Oglesby Paul & Associates, and Colonial Revival architects Wyeth & Cresson and Waddy B. Wood. The
work of Hetty Harrison at Belvoir is also integrally linked to the birth of the Garden Club of Virginia, and the
development of that organization into a major force in historic landscape preservation that it is today.
Each of Belvoirs subsequent owners have left their mark on this property, contributing their own fascinating
chapter to an ongoing story. Belvoir Farm has changed little since the time of the Harrisons, and has been
continuously maintained as a working farm. The house and associated gardens and grounds of Belvoir continue to
serve as a private residence, albeit on a much more part-time basis than was the case for the Harrisons. The
Pawleys, Bowmans, and Fischers have all introduced changes to the house and formal grounds to some extent, yet
the framework of the underlying Harrison-era designs remain largely intact. In the formal grounds and gardens,
this is largely due to extant hardscape features such as walls, terraces, pathways, statuary, and other garden
structures and buildings. The more ephemeral plant material that date to the Harrisons no longer exists, yet there
are still a fair number of boxwood, evergreen, and deciduous trees that remain despite the thinning of the plantings
due to the ravages of time.
Remarkably conservative instincts on the part of the Pawleys, Bowmans, and Fischers have helped to preserve the
framework of the Harrison era landscape at Belvoir, despite access to very little historic documentation to inform
102
those efforts. However, time has taken its toll on remaining hardscape, statuary, and surviving plant material, and
the grounds and gardens are fast approaching a pivotal point in which the rate of loss of historic fabric will
accelerate as all of these materials enter their next century. It is my hope that with the findings presented in this
report, a case can be made for putting in place an active stewardship plan for the Belvoir grounds and gardens so as
to ensure the stabilization and preservation of this historic landscape for the benefit of future generations.
103
104
105
APPENDIX
106
PLANT LIST
TREES
AA
AH
AC
AP
AR
AS
CB
CF
CO
CV
DV
FA
FG
GB
IC
IO
LI
LT
MX
MG
MS
PA
PC
PE
PP
PS
PU
PV
QF
QP
107
Ailanthus altissima
Aesculus hippocastanum
Acer saccharum
Acer palmatum
Acer rubrum
Acer saccharinum
Catalpa bignonioides
Cornus florida
Celtis occidentalis
Chionanthus virginicus
Diospyros virginiana
Fraxinus americana
Fagus grandiflora
Ginko biloba
Ilex cornuta
Ilex opaca
Lagerstroemia indica
Liriodendron tulipifera
Malus x
Magnolia grandiflora
Magnolia soulangiana
Picea abies
Pyrus communis
Prunus serrulata
Prunus persica
Pinus strobus
Prunus subhirtella pendula
Prunus avium
Quercus falcata
Quercus palustris
Tree of Heaven
Horsechestnut
Sugar Maple
Japanese Maple
Red Maple
Silver Maple
Southern Catalpa
Flowering Dogwood
Hackberry
White Fringe Tree
Common Persimmon
White Ash
American Beech
Ginko
Chinese Holly
American Holly
Crapemyrtle
Tulip Poplar
Ornamental Crabapple
Southern Magnolia
Saucer Magnolia
Norway Spruce
Common Pear
Ornamental Cherry
Common Peach
White Pine
Weeping Higan Cherry
Sweet Cherry
Southern Red Oak
Pin Oak
QR
QV
RP
SJ
TA
TC
TD
UA
VN
Quercus rubra
Quercus velutina
Robinia pseudoacacia
Styrax japonica
Tsuga caroliniana
Tilia cordata
Taxodium distichum
Ulmus Americana
Vitex negundo
Red Oak
Black Oak
Black Locust
Japanese Snowbell
Carolina Hemlock
Little Leaf Linden
Bald Cypress
American Elm
Chaste Tree
SHRUBS
Ag
Az
Bs
Ic
Jn
Lk
Lv
Pc
Pl
Rh
Sv
Tb
To
Wf
Abelia grandiflora
Rhododendron x
Buxus sempervirens
Ilex cornuta
Jasminum nudiflorum
Lonicera karolkowii
Ligustrum vulgare
Philadelphus coronarius
Prunus laurocerasus
Rhododendron catawbiense
Syringa vulgaris
Taxus baccata
Thuja occidentalis
Wisteria floribunda
Glossy Abelia
Azalea
Common Boxwood
Chinese Holly
Winter Jasmine
Blue Leaf Honeysuckle
Common Privet
Sweet Mock Orange
Common Cherry Laurel
Catawba Rhododendron
Common Lilac
English Yew
Arborvitae
Japanese Wisteria
108