The kinetics of reaction between trifluoroacetic acid as an acid of medium strength and the carotenoids beta-carotene, zeaxanthin, canthaxanthin, and astaxanthin has been examined in detail including the effects of dioxygen, acid concentration, and carotenoid structure. Reaction between acid and carotenoid leads to species absorbing in the red and near-infrared (NIR) spectral regions, intermediates that subsequently disappear. ESR experiments clearly show that these species are not carotenoid radicals, although their NIR absorption is similar to the absorption of carotenoid radical cations. Under most reaction conditions, the disappearance of carotenoids follows pseudo-zero-order kinetics, whereas the reaction order is >1 with respect to acid, and the long-lived (hours) intermediates are suggested to be mono- (700 nm) and diprotonated carotenoid ( approximately 950 nm). Acid induces cis/trans-isomerization via the protonated intermediates, which also decay to nonradical species with shorter conjugated systems-most probably carotenoid esters. Slow protonization of the methine carbon is the primary step in the degradation, but dioxygen increases the rate as a result of formation of a charge-transfer complex with the carotenoids as indicated by a red-shift of the NIR absorption bands. Carotenoids with carbonyl groups (astaxanthin and canthaxanthin) have slower rates of degradation than beta-carotene and zeaxanthin, indicating preferential nondegradative protonation of the carbonyl groups.