Background: Following decades of fire exclusion, many open pine and oak forests across the central and eastern US are shifting to closed-canopy forests that are increasingly dominated by shade-tolerant, fire-sensitive species (i.e., mesophytes). As mesophytes encroach into historically pyrophytic landscapes, changes in crown traits and understory microclimate may interact with fine fuel traits to influence fuel moisture retention, and ultimately, fire behavior. To better understand potential interactions among overstory trees and underlying fine fuels that occur during mesophyte encroachment, we measured in situ drying rates of leaf litter and 10-h woody debris of three functional groups (pyrophytic pine, pyrophytic oak, and mesophytic oak) in gaps and beneath overstory trees of each functional group within a longleaf pine-mixed oak woodland along with crown (area, volume, cover), leaf litter (curling, thickness, specific leaf area, volume), and woody debris (density) traits of each functional group and understory microclimate (vapor pressure deficit (VPD)).

Results: We found that leaf litter from pyrophytic and mesophytic oaks had higher initial moisture content than pyrophytic pines, but pyrophytic pine and pyrophytic oak leaf litter dried 1.5 times faster than that of mesophytic oaks, likely due to their greater leaf curl, thickness, and volume. Initial moisture content of mesophytic oak woody fuels was lower than that of pyrophytic pine and pyrophytic oak, potentially because of higher wood density, but there were no differences in fuel drying rates. Regardless of fuel functional type, leaf litter and woody fuels dried 1.5 times faster in gaps and underneath pyrophytic pine compared to mesophytic oaks, likely due to the more open conditions in these areas. Notably overstory functional group and time of the day interacted to influence VPD, with VPD increasing throughout the day for all groups, but more so for gaps and beneath pyrophytic pines than either oak functional group.

Conclusions: Thus, fuel and crown traits differentially impacted understory microclimate and leaf litter and 10-h woody debris drying rates, leading to slower drying of fuels of encroaching mesophytes compared to pyrophytic pines and oaks, which could lead to reduced forest flammability, and consequently, the continued encroachment of mesophytic species into fire-dependent pine and oak forests.