[go: up one dir, main page]

Academia.eduAcademia.edu
What do hyperlocals do? Abstract The value of news is often viewed through a prism of its relationship to democracy. Key to this is the idea that democracy enables good government most effectively if citizens’ decisions are based on reliable and independent information. Numerous studies have found the crisis in the mainstream UK news industry is endangering the local-ness, quality and independence of local news. One of the things we wanted to test was whether, and how, this new community news could (at least partly) replace the services offered by the declining commercial newspaper market. Our content analysis of hyperlocal news sought to measure the social, political, and cultural value of this emergent form of community news. Method This content analysis of hyperlocal news in the UK pays particular attention to: sources (who gets to define hyperlocal news and in what ways); topics (what news is covered?); the “local-ness” of this news; the civic value of the news (in relation to coverage of politics, but also the role of this developing cultural form in fostering (or not) different forms of “citizenship” in communities). Our sample consisted of posts published on the sites of members of the UK’s “Openly Local” hyperlocal news directory during 11 days at the beginning of May 2012. We analysed 1941 blog posts. Results and Conclusions Hyperlocal news is very focussed on giving communities information about politics, specifically local politics. It also gives the general public more of a voice in public debate than mainstream newspapers. However, while some of our findings seem to suggest a rosy picture in terms of hyperlocal news’ ability to foster citizenship, democracy, and local community cohesion, others were less positive. One of the ways professional journalists transparently provide us with a plurality of perspectives on local life is to speak to numerous news sources to gather the raw materials of news, many of whom they go on to quote in their stories. Hyperlocal journalists quote relatively few news sources, and when used they rarely provide conflicting or oppositional viewpoints. This does not bode well for this news’ ability to foster and inform real debate around contentious local issues. We see hyperlocal news as a valuable form of creative citizenship in itself, but whilst they provide information about local community life, these blogs rarely encourage others to participate actively in their communities. This includes encouraging readers to produce, or collaborate on, community news itself. What gets covered: Story subject Each story across the 1,941 stories was identified as being on a certain subject. These were the top five subjects that occurred. Community Politics/ Government Sport Crimes Business 13% 12% 12% 7% 7% Who gets to speak: Sources Directly and indirectly quoted sources were coded by category throughout the stories, 1,871 quotes across the 1,941 stories. These were the top five occuring source types. Politics (local) Business/ Commercial 16% 14% Member Community Group of Public 12% Police 7% 6% Who gets linked to: Hyperlinks Each hyperlink that appeared in a story was coded and categorised: 3,170 links across the sample of 1,941 stories. These are the top five categories, with ‘Own Content’ referring to the hyperlocal linking to their own pages. Own content Business 29% 14% Local Government Community 10% Arts 8% 7% Fostering citizenship: Calls to action Where a call to a citizenship activity was identified, it was coded and categorised, with multiple calls possible in a story. 533 such calls were coded across the 1,941 stories. These are the top four categories. Non-Political Community Reporting to authorities Acts of journalism Formal political 11% 6% 5% 3%