Study

Journal of Avian Biology Supplementary material JAV-00396 Schweiger, A., Fünfstück, H.-J. and Beierkuhnlein, C. 2014. Availability of optimal-sized prey affects global distribution patterns of the golden eagle Aquila chrysaetos. – J. Avian Biol. doi: 10.1111/jav.00396 Appendix 1 Table A1 Diet breadth and distance to species distribution boundary of nesting Golden Eagle populations based on international literature accounts from the Palearctic and Nearctic region. n: number of examined prey individuals, Nests: number of observed nests; B: diet breadth as a measure for foraging generalism; distance: minimum distance to eagles distribution boundary. Region Source n Nests B distance (-) (km) Palearctic (52 studies) Norway (Fimark fjord) Johnsen et al. (2007) 144 12 3.64 40 Norway (Finmark inland) Johnsen et al. (2007) 325 25 2.77 272 Finland (north) Sulkava et al. (1984) 3766 500 3.3 133 Finland (south) Sulkava et al. (1984) 1796 50 2.7 33 Finland (south) Sulkava et al. (1999) 1595 ? 2.8 46 Finland (south) Sulkava et al. (1999) 3387 ? 4.2 130 Finland (central) Sulkava et al. (1999) 1049 ? 3.5 336 Finland (north) Sulkava et al. (1999) 873 ? 4.0 336 Sweden (Gotland) Högström and Wiss (1992) 645 3 3.7 27 Sweden Tjernberg (1981) 2792 105 2.9 288 Sweden Nytröm et al. (2006) 410 23 1.9 230 Estonia Zastrow (1946) 133 4 6.2 153 Belarus Ivanosky (1990) 749 10 3.4 123 Scotland (south) Marquiss et al. (1985) 302 4 3.69 21 Scotland (north-west) Watson et al. (1992) 345 ? 3.2 31 1 Scotland (Inner Hebrides N) Watson (2010) 85 23 4.7 9 Scotland (Inner Hebrides S) Watson (2010) 143 29 3.5 15 Scotland (Highlands N) Watson (2010) 274 29 7.2 54 Scotland (Highlands NW) Watson (2010) 148 38 5.9 43 Scotland (Highlands W-Centr) Watson (2010) 17 25 7.3 17 Scotland (Highlands SW) Watson (2010) 47 16 5.4 21 Scotland (Highlands E) Watson (2010) 161 28 2.4 92 Scotland (SW Agryll) Watson (2010) 109 3 7.4 19 Switzerland Stemmler (1955) 298 65 3.8 77 Switzerland (Graubünden) Haller (1996) 249 4 3.0 131 Switzerland (Bern/Pre-Alps) Haller (1988) 126 2 4.7 46 Austria (Kalkalpen) Steiner (2006) 21 1 8.3 38 Germany (Allgäuer Hochalpen) present study 82 10 6.9 68 Germany (Werdenfels) present study 384 28 7.1 52 Germany (Berchtesgaden) present study 411 39 8.2 49 France (Pyrenees) Clouet (1981) 114 10 11.2 1 France (Pyrenees) Nebel et al. (1996) 28 ? 5.9 1 France (Alps) Huboux (1987) 424 17 2.1 83 France (Alps) Huboux (1987) 198 6 5.1 18 France (Alps) Mathieu and Choisy (1982) 109 7 3.2 24 France (Massif Central) Austruy and Cugnasse (1981) 83 5 6.2 43 Italy (Apennines) Magrini et al. (1987) 149 7 4.7 5 Italy (Sicily) Seminara et al. (1987) 74 10 4.9 4 Italy (Apennines) Noveletto and Petretti (1980) 160 5 3.4 5 Italy (Alps) Pedrini and Sergio (2001) 195 27 5.8 16 Spain (north-east) Fernandez (1987) 104 30 2.1 99 2 Spain (north-west) Delibes et al. (1975) 247 3 3.9 105 Spain (central) Delibes et al. (1975) 229 2 3.1 64 Spain (south-west) Delibes et al. (1975) 167 3 2.0 46 Spain (south-east) Sánchez-Zapata et al. (2010) 99 3 3.6 41 Macedonia Grubac (1987) 85 19 3.2 30 Hungary (Zemplen-Mts.) Janos (1998) 58 4 8.8 32 Russia (Perm-Region) Shepel (1992) 382 9 2.59 1542 Russia (Altai-Sayan) Karyakin et al. (2010) 372 ? 7.8 566 Kazakhstan (Aral-Caspian) Karyakin et al. (2011) 420 115 5.6 1312 Turkmenia Varshavski (1986) 188 5 3.2 296 Mongolia Ellis et al. (1999) 63 1 3.6 96 Alaska Hatler (1974) 53 1 2.8 125 Alaska Murie (1944) 690 ? 1.4 367 Alaska Ritchie and Curatolo (1982) 66 17 2.3 232 Alberta Boag (1977) 200 2 1.4 782 Oregon Thompson et al. (1982) 34 7 4.5 495 Montana McGahan (1968) 980 38 2.0 631 Idaho Kochert (1972) 1297 28 1.8 437 Idaho Collopy (1983) 456 8 1.9 437 Washington Knight and Erickson (1978) 311 74 4.4 348 Arizona Eakle and Grubb (1986) 47 2 4.5 375 Nevada Bloom and Hawks (1982) 1154 119 1.4 268 California Carnie (1954) 503 17 5.3 12 Nearctic (15 studies) 3 California (Santa Rosa island) Collins and Latta (2009) 242 4 5.7 7 California (Santa Cruz island) Collins and Latta (2009) 181 6 2.1 5 New Mexico 993 41 2.1 300 Mollhagen et al. (1972) 4 Study site description for the Bavarian Golden Eagles In our study on the feeding behaviour of breeding Golden Eagles in the Bavarian Alps (Southern Germany), we examined three subpopulations located in the very eastern parts (Berchtesgaden), the central parts (Werdenfels) and the western-most parts (Allgäuer Hochalpen) of Bavaria over a 10year period (1998-2008). All three study sites, each covering an area of about 1400 km², are dominated by calcareous parent material. Altitude varies between 600 and 2900 m a.s.l. On mountain slopes, forests are characterized by coniferous trees (mainly Norway spruce, Picea abies). The tree line ranges between 1700 and 1900 m a.s.l. Above the tree line, the vegetation is dominated by alpine meadows. Mean annual temperature varies between 5 to 7°C in the valleys and 0 to -2°C in the summit regions. Annual precipitation ranges from 1500 up to 2600 mm (Bay. StMLU 2001, Bay. StMUGV 2007, LfU 2007). Prey collection and analyses for the Bavarian Golden Eagles The diets of nesting eagles were determined for the three Bavarian populations by analysing food remains and pellets from N = 77 nests and their close vicinity, with 10 nests in the Allgäuer Hochalpen, 28 nests in Werdenfels and 39 nests in Berchtesgaden. Nests with recorded breeding activity were sampled after fledglings left the nests (mainly between August and October 19982008) or breeding was abandoned. In order to get a complete picture of the foraged prey, the uppermost layer was removed from the nests and checked for small prey remains such as claws or skin from small mammals or birds (cf. Ellis et al. 1999). Prey remains were determined to the lowest possible taxonomic level by considering the age and sex of prey items by using reference collections and literature (e.g. Boye 1981, März 1987). For each prey species, the minimum number of foraged individuals was determined by considering side of the body, degree of ossification and grade of bone weathering (cf. Sulkava et al. 1999). Based on this information, a total of 877 preyed 5 individuals from 68 species could be determined for the study period of 10 years (1998-2008, see Tab. A.2). However, these records for foraged individuals have to be seen as minimum numbers. The number of prey remains within the observed nests might be biased by different intensities of prey removal by scavengers or by different degree of cleanliness observed by the adult eagles. Biomass was estimated for each foraged individual from the literature (e.g. Bauer et al. 2005, Niethammer and Krapp 1968, 1978, 1990). As the living biomass especially of large prey, such as ungulates is not fully usable for the eagles (e.g. bones), biomass values from the literature were corrected to prevent overestimating the prey weight (cf. Högström and Wiss 1992). Table A2: Prey species of Bavarian Golden Eagles during the nestling period between 1998 and 2008 within the three study sites Allgäuer Hochalpen (AH, 10 nests), Werdenfels (WF, 28 nests) and Berchtesgaden (BG, 39 nests). Depicted is the number of identified prey individuals per study site (* = determined individuals were almost unexceptional juveniles > 1 year). Prey species AH WF BG Total 13 90 86 189 1 1 3 2 6 Chamois* Rupicapra rupicapra Ibex Capra ibex Domestic sheep Ovis ammon f. domestica Red deer Cervus elaphus 2 1 3 Roe deer Capreolus capreolus 3 18 21 Red fox Vulpes vulpes 27 29 60 Badger Meles meles 1 1 Beech marten Martes foina 2 2 4 Pine marten Martes martes 1 3 4 Marten sp. Martes sp. 3 4 9 1 4 2 6 Stoat Mustela erminea 2 Domestic cat Felis sylvestris f. catus Mountian hare Lepus timidus European hare Lepus europaeus Hare sp. Lepus sp. Domestic hare Leporidae sp. 1 1 Hedgehog Erinaceus europaeus 1 1 European mole Talpa europaea Shrew sp. Soricidae sp. Yellow-necked mouse Apodemus flavicollis Long-tailed mouse sp. Muridae sp. 2 Common vole Microtus arvensis 3 1 4 Brown vole Microtus agrestis 2 1 3 Vole sp. Microtus sp. 3 3 Alpine marmot Marmota marmota 16 10 18 44 Red squirrel Sciurus vulgaris 4 25 12 41 Edible dormouse Glis glis 1 1 Mallard Anas platyrhynchos 2 2 Common buzzard Buteo buteo 4 10 Goshawk Accipites gentilis 1 1 Sparrow hawk Accipiter nisus 1 1 Kestrel Falco tinnunculus 12 22 Peregrine Falco peregrinus 2 2 Woodcock Scolopax rusticola 1 6 Yellow-legged gull Larus michahellis 1 1 Eurasian jay Garrulus glandarius 4 5 6 2 3 5 1 1 38 21 65 4 4 8 14 23 39 1 1 2 1 3 5 7 5 1 3 5 1 1 2 7 Eurasian nutcracker Nucifraga caryocatactes 2 2 Balck-billed magpie Pica pica 1 1 Alpine chough Pyrrhocorax pyrrhocorax 1 1 3 5 Carrion crow Corvus corone 1 1 7 9 Common raven Corus corax 1 4 12 17 Common cuckoo Cuculus canorus 1 1 Tawny owl Strix aluco 4 4 Boreal owl Aegolius funereus 2 2 Pygmy owl Glaucidium passerinum Owl sp. Strigidae sp. 1 1 Black woodpecker Dendrocopus martius 1 1 Great spotted woodpecker Dendrocopus major 3 1 4 Common wood pigeon Columba palumbus 1 1 2 Feral pigeon Columba livia f. domestica 1 2 Pigeon sp. Columba sp. 5 4 9 Capercaillie Tetrao urogallus 1 14 15 30 Black grouse Tetrao tetrix 11 47 52 110 Rock ptarmigan Lagopus muta 4 4 9 17 Hazel grouse Tetrastes bonasia 8 1 9 Grouse sp. Tetraoninae sp. 3 2 5 Gamefowl Galliformes sp. 3 3 Barn fowl Gallus gallus f. domesticus Sky lark Alauda arvensis Blackbird Turdus merula Ring ouzel Turdus torquatus Song thrush Turdus philomelos 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 7 2 9 4 3 8 8 Mistel thrush Turdus viscivorus Thrush sp. Turdus sp. Black redstart Phoenicurus ochruros 1 1 Snowfinch Montifringilla nivalis 1 1 Chaffinch Fringilla coeleps Red crossbill Loxia curvirostra 1 1 Citril finch Serinus citrinella 2 2 Dunnock Prunella modularis 1 1 Lizard sp. Lacerta sp. Slowworm Anguis agillis 2 Common frog Rana temporaria 1 Sterlet Acipenser ruthenus Dung beetle sp. Geotrupidae sp. Weevil sp. Curcurlionidae sp. Beetle sp. Coleoptera sp. Total 14 4 18 2 2 1 1 2 2 1 2 1 2 1 1 1 2 2 2 3 3 4 10 82 384 411 877 9 Additional references Austruy, J. and Cugnasse, J. 1981. L'Aigle Royal Aquila chrysaetos dans le Massif Central. – Nos Oiseaux 36: 133–142. Bauer, H. G., Bezzel, E. and Fiedler, W. (eds.) 2005. Das Kompendium der Vögel Mitteleuropas. Vol. 1 and 2. – Aula. Bayerisches Staatsministerium für Landesentwicklung und Umweltfragen (BayStMLU) 2001. Nationalparkplan Berchtesgaden. – Bay. StMLU. Bayerisches Staatsministerium für Umwelt, Gesundheit und Verbraucherschutz (Bay. StMUGV) 2007. ABSP-Band, Arten-und Biotopschutzprogramm. Landkreis GarmischPartenkirchen. Vol. 2. – Landesamt für Umwelt. Bloom, P. H. and Hawks, S. J. 1982. Food habits of nesting Golden Eagles in northeast California and northwest Nevada. – Raptor Research 16: 110–115. Boag, D. A. 1977. Summer food habits of Golden Eagles in southwestern Alberta. – Canadian Field Naturalist 91: 296–298. Boye, P. 1981. Heimische Säugetiere. – Deutscher Jugendbund für Naturbeobachtungen. Carnie, S. K. 1954. Food habits of Golden Eagles in the coast ranges of California. – Condor 56: 3–12. Clouet, M. 1981. L'Aigle Royal Aquila chrysaetos dans les Pyrénées Francaises. Resultats de 5 ans d'observations. – L'Oiseau et R.O.F 51: 89–100. Collopy, M. W. 1983. A comparison of direct observations and collections of prey remains in determining the diet of Golden Eagle. – Journal of Wildlife Management 47: 360–368. Eakle, W. L. and Grubb, T. G. 1986. Prey remains from Golden Eagles Nests in Central Arizona. – Western Birds 17: 87–89. Fernandez, C. 1987. Seasonal variation in the feeding habits of a pair of golden eagles in Navarra. – In: Michel, S. (ed), L'Aigle Royal en Europe. Actes du Premier Colloque International, pp. 107–117. Hatler, D. F. 1974. Foods at a Golden Eagle nest in central Alaska. – Condor 76: 356–357. Huboux, R. 1987. Contribtion a une meilleure connaissance du – In: Michel, S. (ed), L'Aigle Royal en Europe. Actes du Premier Colloque International. pp. 118–123. Ivanosky, V. V. 1990. Birds of prey and ornithological monitoring (in Russian). – Communication of the Baltic Commission for Study of Bird Migration 22: 92–101. Janos, B. 1998. On the occurrence and foraging of the Golden Eagle (Aquila chrysatos) in the Zemplén-Mountains. – Ornis Hungarica 8: 211–214. Johnsen, T. V., Systad, G. H., Jacobsen, K. O., Nygård, T. and Bustness, J. O. 2007. The occurrence of reindeer claves in the diet of nesting Golden Eagles in FInmark, northern Norway. – Ornis Fennica 84: 112–118. Karyakin, I. V., Nikolenko, E. G., Barashkova, A. N., Smelansky, I. E., Konovalov, L. I., Grabovskiy, M. A., Vazhov, S. V., Bekmansurov, R. H. 2010. Golden Eagle in the Altai-Sayan Region, Russia. – Raptors Conservation 18: 82–152. Karyakin, I. V., Kovalenco, A. V., Levin, A. S. and Pazhenkov, A. S. 2011. Eagles of the Aral-Caspian Region, Kazakhstan. – Raptors Conservation 22: 92–152. Knight, R. L. and Erickson, A. W. 1978. Marmots as a food source of Golden Eagles along the Columbia River. – Murrelet 59: 28–30. Kochert, M. N. 1972. Population status and chemical contamination in Golden Eagles in southwestern Idaho. – University of Idaho, M.Sc thesis. Landesamt für Umwelt (LfU) 2007. Standard-Datenbogen 8528-401, Naturschutzgebiet „Allgäuer Hochalpen. – LfU. Magrini, M., Ragni, B. and Amertano, L. 1987. L'Aigle Royal dans la partie centrale des Appennins. – In: Michel, S. (ed), L'Aigle Royal en Europe. Actes du Premier Colloque International. pp. 29–32. Marquiss, M., Ratcliffe, D. A. and Roxburgh, R. 1985. The Numbers, Breeding Success and Diet of Golden Eagles in Southern Scotland in Relation to Changes in Land Use. – Biological Conservation 34: 121–140. März, R. 1987. Gewöll- und Rupfungskunde. 3., neu von Konrad Banz bearbeitete Auflage. – Akademie-Verlag. McGahan, J. 1968. Ecology of the Golden Eagle. – Auk 85: 1–12. Mollhagen, T. R., Wiley, R. W. and Packard, R. L. 1972. Prey remains in Golden Eagle nests: Texas and New Mexico. – Journal of Wildlife Management 36: 784–792. Murie, A. 1944. The Wolves of Mt. McKinley. (Golden Eagle-Chapter 8). – US Fauna series No 5. Nebel, D., Duquesne, A. and Geoffroy, J. 1996. L’Aigle royal Aquila chrysaetos dans la Réserve Domaniale du Mont Vallier (Ariège) 1987-1995. – Alauda 64: 179–186. Niethammer, J. and Krapp, F. (eds) 1968. Handbuch der Säugetiere Europas; Band 2/II: Paarhufer-Artiodactyla (Suidae, Cervidae, Bovidae). – Aula. Niethammer, J. and Krapp, F. (eds) 1978. Handbuch der Säugetiere Europas; Band 1: Rodentia I (Sciuridae, Castoridae, Gliridae, Muridae). – Akademische Verlagsgesellschaft. Niethammer, J. and Krapp, F. (eds) 1990. Handbuch der Säugetiere Europas; Band 3/I: Insektenfresser – Insectivora, Herrentiere – Primates. – Aula. Noveletto, A. and Petretti, F. 1980. Ecologia dell' Aquila Reale negli Appennini. – Rivista Italiana di Ornitolgia 50: 127–142. Ritchie, R. J. and Curatolo, J. A. 1982. Notes on Golden Eagle productivity and nest site characterisation, Porcupine River, Alaska, 1979-1982. – Raptor Research 16: 13–127. Sánchez-Zapata, J. A., Eguía, S., Blázquez, M., Moleón, M. and Botella, F. 2010. Unexpected role of ungulate carcasses in the diet of Golden Eagles Aquila chrysaetos in Mediterrenean Mountains. – Bird Study 57: 352–360. Seminara, S., Giarratana, S. and Favara, R. 1987. L'Aigle Royal en Sicile. . – In: Michel, S. (ed), L'Aigle Royal en Europe. Actes du Premier Colloque International. pp. 33–36. Shepel, A.I. 1992. Raptors and owls of Perm region. – Izd-vo Irkut, un-ta. Stemmler, C. 1955. Der Steinadler in den Schweizer Alpen. – Selbstverlag. Thompson, P. S., Johnstone, R. S. and Littlefield, C. D. 1982. Nesting history of Golden Eagles in Malheur Lakes Basin, southeastern Oregon. – Raptor Research 16: 116–122. Tjernberg, M. 1981. Diet of the Golden Eagle Aquila chrysaetos during the breeding season in Sweden. – Holarctic Ecology 4: 12–19. Varshavski, B. S. 1986. Feeding of Aquila chrysaetos in southwestern Ust-urt (in Russian) – Ornitotlogija 9: 146–149. Watson, J., Leitch, A. F. and Broad, R. A. 1992. The diet of the Sea Eagle Haliaeetus albicilla and the Golden Eagle Aquila chrysaetos in western Scotland. – Ibis 134: 27– 31. Zastrow, M. 1946. Om Kungsörnens Aquila chrysaetos ut bredning och biologi i Estland. – Vår Fågelvärld 5: 64–80.