c ESO 2013
Astronomy & Astrophysics manuscript no. 8680maer
June 16, 2013
Circumstellar water vapour in M-type AGB stars:
Radiative transfer models, abundances and predictions for HIFI
M. Maercker1 , F. L. Schöier1,2 , H. Olofsson1,2 , P. Bergman2,3 and S. Ramstedt1
1
2
arXiv:0801.0971v3 [astro-ph] 14 Apr 2010
3
Stockholm Observatory, AlbaNova University Center, SE-106 91 Stockholm, Sweden
e-mail: maercker@astro.su.se
Onsala Space Observatory, SE-439 92 Onsala, Sweden
European Southern Observatory, Casilla 19001, Santiago 19, Chile
received 15 September 2007; accepted 12 December 2007
ABSTRACT
Context. Surprisingly high amounts of H2 O have recently been reported in the circumstellar envelope around the M-type asymptotic
giant branch star W Hya. This has lead to the speculation that evaporation of icy cometary or planetary bodies might be an effective
ongoing mechanism in such systems. However, substantial uncertainties remain, as the required radiative transfer modelling is difficult
due to high optical depths, sub-thermal excitation and the sensitivity to the combined radiation field from the central star and dust
grains.
Aims. By performing a detailed radiative transfer analysis, we determine fractional abundances of circumstellar H2 O in the envelopes
around six M-type asymptotic giant branch stars. The models are also used to predict H2 O spectral line emission for the upcoming
Herschel/HIFI mission.
Methods. We use Infrared Space Observatory Long Wavelength Spectrometer spectra to constrain the circumstellar fractional abundance distribution of ortho-H2 O, using a non-local thermal equilibrium, and non-local, radiative transfer code based on the accelerated lambda iteration formalism. The mass-loss rates and kinetic temperature structures for the sample stars are determined through
radiative transfer modelling of CO line emission based on the Monte-Carlo method. The density and temperature profiles of the circumstellar dust grains are determined through spectral energy distribution modelling using the publicly available code Dusty.
Results. The determined ortho-H2 O abundances lie between 2 × 10−4 and 1.5 × 10−3 relative to H2 , with the exception of WX Psc,
which has a much lower estimated ortho-H2 O abundance of only 2 × 10−6 , possibly indicating H2 O adsorption onto dust grains or
recent mass-loss-rate modulations. The estimated abundances are uncertain by, at best, a factor of a few.
Conclusions. The high water abundance found for the majority of the sources suggests that either the ‘normal’ chemical processes
are very effective in producing H2 O, or else non-local thermal equilibrium atmospheric chemistry, grain surface reactions, or a release
of H2 O (e.g. from icy bodies like Kuiper belt objects) play a role. However, more detailed information on the physical structure and
the velocity field of the region where the water vapour lines are formed is required to improve abundance estimates. We provide predictions for ortho-H2 O lines in the spectral window of Herschel/HIFI. These spectrally resolved lines cover a wide range of excitation
conditions and will provide valuable additional information on the physical and chemical properties of the inner stellar wind where
H2 O is abundant.
Key words. Stars: abundances - Stars: AGB and post-AGB - Stars: evolution - Stars: mass-loss
1. Introduction
Asymptotic giant branch stars (AGB stars) are chemically
characterised according to their relative abundances of carbon
and oxygen. Carbon stars have a photospheric C/O ratio > 1,
whereas M-type (‘oxygen rich’) AGB stars have C/O < 1 (e.g.,
Russel 1934; Beck et al. 1992). It is believed that M-type AGB
stars evolve to carbon stars by the dredging up of nucleosynthesised carbon during the thermally pulsing AGB (TP-AGB) (e.g.,
Iben 1975; Boothroyd & Sackmann 1988). The evolution along
the AGB is dominated by the mass loss, starting with a low massloss rate ∼ 10−8 M⊙ yr−1 and ending in an intense wind with rates
up to 10−4 M⊙ yr−1 . The photosphere and expanding circumstellar envelope (CSE) are effective producers of a variety of molecular species and microscopic dust particles, providing up to 80%
of the dust in galaxies (Whittet 1992). When the star reaches the
end of the AGB, most of the initial mass has been lost, leaving
behind only a C/O core that ionises the surrounding material and,
Send offprint requests to: M. Maercker
for a short while, creates a planetary nebula (Habing 1996). The
lifetime on the AGB is estimated to be a few ∼ 106 yr (Marigo
& Girardi 2007).
To date, about 70 circumstellar molecular species have been
detected, most of them through transitions at radio wavelengths
(Olofsson 2007). H2 O is of special importance in the case of Mtype AGB stars, as it is possibly the dominant coolant in the inner
part of the stellar wind (where it is abundant) with a large number
of far-infrared (FIR) transitions (Truong-Bach et al. 1999). H2 O
line emission is also a potentially important probe of the physical and chemical properties of the inner regions of CSEs. H2 O is
the main reservoir of circumstellar O, and whereas CO is abundant in all AGB stars, chemical models predict H2 O to be one of
the most abundant species only in O-rich stars (e.g., Cherchneff
2006). However, H2 O has also been detected in the nearby Crich AGB star IRC+10216 (Melnick et al. 2001; Hasegawa et
al. 2006), but here the estimated abundance is comparatively low,
and the origin of H2 O uncertain.
2
M. Maercker et al.: Circumstellar water vapour in oxygen-rich AGB stars
The atmosphere of the Earth is mostly opaque at H2 O line
wavelengths and it is therefore difficult to observe H2 O from the
ground, in particular in its ground vibrational state. However,
Menten et al. (2006) managed to observe two vibrationally excited lines in the ν2 = 1 bending mode (523 − 616 at 336.2 GHz
and 661 − 752 at 293.6 GHz) towards the red supergiant VY
CMa. H2 O masers from the ground and excited vibrational states
can also be detected from the ground (Menten & Melnick 1989).
Observations from the Infrared Space Observatory (ISO) are
not hindered by the atmosphere, and the Short- and LongWavelength Spectrometer (SWS and LWS) data show a rich H2 O
spectrum in M-type AGB stars (e.g., Truong-Bach et al. 1999;
Barlow et al. 1996; Neufeld et al. 1996; Justtanont et al. 2005).
The ortho-H2 O ground state line at 557 GHz was also observed
by the SWAS (Melnick et al. 2000) and Odin satellites (Nordh et
al. 2003). In contrast to the CO radio lines, the H2 O line emission originates from closer to the star, providing information on
the warm, high-density innermost layers of the CSE (TruongBach et al. 1999). However, the high optical depths and the subthermal excitation of H2 O in CSEs make it a challenge to accurately model the observed H2 O spectral lines (e.g., Justtanont et
al. 2005).
We present here the results of radiative transfer modelling
of the ortho-H2O line emission in six M-type AGB stars with
mass-loss rates between 1 × 10−7 M⊙ yr−1 and 4 × 10−5 M⊙ yr−1 .
Detailed radiative transfer models are created using the accelerated lambda iteration (ALI) method (Rybicki & Hummer 1991,
1992). The model results are fit to LWS ISO observations between 43 and 197 µm. The mass-loss rate and kinetic temperature structure are determined through CO radio line modelling, and the dust temperature and dust density structure are
determined using Dusty (Ivezić et al. 1999). The results show
the ability of ALI to model circumstellar H2 O lines. We also
make predictions for H2 O lines in the frequency range of the
upcoming Herschel/HIFI mission. These observations will include information on the line profiles and can be used to set
firmer constraints on the physical structure of the inner CSE
and the H2 O abundance. Previous attempts to determine the water vapour content in stars included in our sample have been
made for W Hya (Barlow et al. 1996; Zubko & Elitzur 2000;
Justtanont et al. 2005) and R Cas (Truong-Bach et al. 1999).
González-Alfonso & Cernicharo (1999) used the large-velocitygradient (LVG) method to model the 183 GHz maser line in
O-rich evolved stars, to study the line intensity dependence on
source properties and physical conditions. Ryde & Eriksson
(2002) model the 2.6 −3.6 µm spectrum for R Dor observed with
the SWS on ISO, showing the dominance of water vapour in the
spectrum.
Determining the para-H2 O abundance would be a straightforward task. However, considering the uncertainty in the abundance estimates, this would not give any firm constraints on the
ortho-to-para ratio or the total H2 O abundance.
In Sect. 2 the ISO observations are briefly described.
Section 3 contains a description of the dust and CO emission
line modelling. In Sect. 4 we describe the H2 O line model, and
in Sects. 5 and 6 we present and discuss the results, respectively.
Appendix A contains a description of the accelerated lambda
technique, adopted in our radiative transfer model, in more detail
and benchmark tests are presented. All abundances mentioned
refer to the fractional abundance compared to H2 , unless stated
otherwise.
Table 1. ISO observations for the 6 M-type AGB stars.
Source
TX Cam
R Cas
R Dor
W Hya
WX Psc
IK Tau
AOT
LWS01
LWS01
LWS01
LWS01
LWS01
LWS01
Observer ID
MBARLOW
MBARLOW
KERIKSSO
MBARLOW
MBARLOW
MBARLOW
Date
1997-10-10
1997-06-06
1997-07-01
1997-08-02
1997-06-15
1997-09-02
Int time (sec)
3428
2204
1330
1778
2796
3430
2. Observations
We have used archived ISO LWS spectra (43 − 197 µm) for six
M-type AGB stars (Table 1) to identify and measure the intensity
of ortho-H2O spectral lines in the ground vibrational state. For
all observations the LWS01 AOT was used (Clegg et al. 1996).
The spectra were sampled at 1/4 of a resolution element, one element being 0.3 µm in second order (λ ≤ 93 µm) and 0.6 µm in
first order (λ ≥ 80 µm). The analysis of the data was done using the ISO Spectral Analysis Package (ISAP). The data were
cleaned from cosmic rays by excluding deviant points that were
only present in individual scans. All scans for each detector
were median averaged. In order to get a straight (continuumsubtracted) spectrum, a baseline (typically of order 2) was fit to
the data and subtracted. Finally, the ten detectors were combined
to form a complete spectrum. A section of the merged spectrum
for R Dor with labelled ortho- and para-H2 O transitions is shown
in Fig. 1. Table 2 gives the measured ortho-H2O line fluxes.
The observed fluxes are determined by fitting a Gaussian profile to the observed ortho-H2O lines using available tools within
ISAP. The error in the baseline fit dominates over the error in
the Gaussian fit, and is ∼ 30% on average (in terms of the line
intensity). The fit is more difficult in the short-wavelength part of
the spectrum due to the high noise levels. The measured values
lie within ± 20% of those of previous studies of H2 O emission
using ISO spectra in W Hya (Barlow et al. 1996) and R Cas
(Truong-Bach et al. 1999).
3. Circumstellar dust and CO line modelling
3.1. Dust emission modelling using Dusty
The dust optical depth and dust temperature profile were determined using the continuum radiative transfer code Dusty (Ivezić
et al. 1999). The observational constraints are in the form of
spectral energy distributions (SEDs) and consist of 2MASS and
IRAS fluxes. A ‘standard model’ containing amorphous silicate
dust was used, with optical constants adopted from Justtanont
& Tielens (1992). The standard model assumes the mass loss to
be spherically symmetric with a constant rate and expansion velocity, resulting in a density profile with ρ ∝ r−2 . Prompt dust
formation is assumed at the condensation temperature T c , which
is treated as a free parameter. Additionally, the dust grains are assumed to be spherical with a radius of 0.1 µm. The dust optical
depth and dust condensation temperature were adjusted in order
to find the best fit to the SED using a χ2 -statistic. A more detailed description of the modelling procedure is given in Schöier
et al. (2002).
The luminosities of the Miras are derived using a periodluminosity (PL) relationship based on bolometric magnitudes
(Feast et al. 1989). The distances are obtained from the apparent bolometric magnitude obtained in the SED modelling. For
semi-regular objects, Knapp et al. (2003) give a PL relationship
based on K-band magnitudes. Since this only uses information in
M. Maercker et al.: Circumstellar water vapour in oxygen-rich AGB stars
3
Fig. 1. The ISO LWS spectrum of R Dor between 95 and 185 µm, including the position of ortho-H2O, para-H2 O lines, and CO
lines (transitions J = 15 − 14 to J = 27 − 26) .
Table 2. Measured and modelled ISO line fluxes of ortho-H2O [in units of 10−20 W cm−2 ]. Lines without fluxes were either too weak
to detect or otherwise unusable, due to blending with other lines or unacceptable line fits. The dominant error in the observed fluxes
is due to the baseline subtraction and is ∼ 30%.
Trans
JK− K+ − JK− K+
221 − 212
212 − 101
303 − 212
330 − 321
514 − 505
423 − 414
432 − 423
734 − 643
414 − 303
221 − 110
505 − 414
616 − 505
423 − 312
321 − 212
707 − 616
330 − 221
532 − 423
523 − 414
λ
[µm]
180.49
179.53
174.63
136.50
134.94
132.41
121.72
116.78
113.54
108.07
99.49
82.03
78.74
75.38
71.95
66.44
47.97
45.11
TX Cam
F obs F mod
—
10
10
—
—
—
—
—
9
11
10
—
14
23
—
18
—
—
—
7
6
—
—
—
—
—
8
11
10
—
13
23
—
22
—
—
R Cas
F obs F mod
—
8
7
3
2
4
4
—
14
16
16
—
25
28
—
35
—
—
—
9
8
3
2
3
4
—
10
14
17
—
17
28
—
25
—
—
R Dor
F obs F mod
6
22
17
8
6
7
9
10
—
31
52
58
—
43
—
59
109
155
one point of the SED (the K-band magnitude), we instead used
the revised Hipparcos distances for W Hya and R Dor (Knapp et
al. 2003), and determined the luminosity through the SED modelling.
6
17
20
8
6
9
9
8
—
31
39
40
—
63
—
65
89
102
W Hya
F obs F mod
—
13
12
3
3
4
6
9
17
18
20
—
—
35
24
26
52
70
7
8
4
4
4
5
7
11
15
16
—
—
31
23
31
46
64
WX Psc
F obs F mod
—
—
—
1
—
2
1
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
9
—
—
—
—
—
1
—
1
1
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
12
—
—
IK Tau
F obs F mod
—
13
15
6
5
5
7
—
20
21
50
41
57
50
37
48
105
161
—
10
8
7
5
6
10
—
15
19
19
26
33
44
39
54
132
161
3.2. Modelling of CO lines
The CO line modelling is based on the Monte-Carlo method presented in detail in Schöier & Olofsson (2001) and Olofsson et al.
(2002). The radiative transfer model includes the lowest 40 rotational levels in the ground and first vibrational states. The collision rates are taken from Flower (2001) for CO-H2 , and they
4
M. Maercker et al.: Circumstellar water vapour in oxygen-rich AGB stars
are extrapolated to higher rotational temperatures as was done
in Schöier et al. (2005). The collisional rates between CO and
ortho- and para-H2 were weighted assuming an ortho- to paraH2 ratio of 3. A CO fractional abundance (CO/H2 ) of 2 × 10−4 is
adopted, a value typically used for O-rich AGB stars. The model
includes cooling terms from the adiabatic expansion of the envelope and radiative line cooling through CO and H2 . The dominant heating term is given by dust-gas collisions. The density
distribution and temperature structure of the dust grains are taken
from the dust radiative transfer modelling (see Sect. 3.1), while
the parameters for grain size, grain mass density and dust-to-gas
ratio are combined into one parameter h. The h-parameter is, in
principal, a free parameter in the CO modelling, and is chosen to
be consistent with previous models (Olofsson et al. 2002: W Hya
and R Dor; González Delgado et al. 2003: R Cas; Ramstedt et
al. 2007: TX Cam, WX Psc, and IK Tau). The outer radius is
set by the photodissociation of CO (Stanek et al. 1995, based
on results by Mamon et al. 1988). The expansion velocity and
micro-turbulent velocity (0.5 km s−1 doppler width), with local
thermal (Gaussian) line broadening, are also set in the model.
This leaves the mass-loss rate as the remaining free parameter
that affects the model line fluxes. The best fit model is then determined by fitting the model line fluxes to the observed fluxes
and minimising χ2 , where
χ2 =
X (Iobs,i − Imod,i )2
σ2i
(1)
and Iobs and Imod are the observed and modelled line fluxes, respectively, σi the uncertainty in observation i, and the sum goes
over all lines included.
The line profile is not taken into consideration, but we note
that in the case of W Hya, Justtanont et al. (2005) had to reduce
the CO photodissociation radius and increase the mass-loss rate
in order to fit the line profile. However, there is sufficient uncertainty in the underlying assumptions of the circumstellar model
that we prefer to treat all objects in the same way and avoid individual adjustments of, e.g., the CO envelope size.
The uncertainty in the mass-loss rate is estimated to be
± 50% within the adopted model (Schöier & Olofsson 2001).
Previous mass-loss-rate estimates by González Delgado et
al. (2003) and Olofsson et al. (2002) differ somewhat from the
results in Table 4. The difference is less than 10% for the lowmass-loss-rate and intermediate-mass-loss-rate objects, but more
for the high-mass-loss-rate objects WX Psc and IK Tau (± 50%).
This is due to the combination of new adopted distances, inclusion of new data, updated collisional rate coefficients and the
inclusion of thermal radiation from dust grains in our CO models. The observed CO line fluxes, used in the model fitting, are
presented in Table 3. IK Tau, WX Psc and TX Cam were modelled by Ramstedt et al. (2007). The parameters derived from the
dust and CO modelling are presented in Table 4.
4. Circumstellar H2 O line modelling (ALI)
We have developed a detailed radiative transfer code based on
the accelerated lambda iteration method, in order to accurately
model circumstellar H2 O line emission (Bergman, internal report). The Monte Carlo method is not well suited for such problems due to its slow convergence at high optical depths. The ALI
code was previously used in Justtanont et al. (2005), but a number of modifications have subsequently been made to be able to
treat the inclusion of dust emission and vibrationally excited energy levels. The accelerated lambda technique and its numerical
Table 3. Observed CO line fluxes in main beam brightness scale.
Observations were taken at Onsala Space Observatory, JCMT,
and SEST (see references for details).
Source
TX Cam
R Cas
R Dor
W Hya
WX Psc
IK Tau
a
J=1→0
[K km s−1 ]
20.1e
8.4a
5.0a
0.83a
44.4e
46.2e
J =2→1
[K km s−1 ]
60.6e
32.1b
41.6a
18.7c
80.6e
95.1e
J =3→2
[K km s−1 ]
71.1e
100.2b
70.4a
40.2d
70.1e
124.5e
J=4→3
[K km s−1 ]
148.7e
89.6b
44.6c
83.8e
129.6e
Kerschbaum & Olofsson (1999), b Delgado et al. (2003), c JCMT
archive, d Justtanont et al. (2005), e Ramstedt et al. (2007)
implementation is described in more detail in appendix A, including results of benchmarking tests against the standard problems presented in van Zadelhoff et al. (2002).
4.1. Dependence on numerical parameters
ALI calculates the mean intensity at each radial point in the CSE,
including the contribution from all other points in the envelope.
This is done by paying special attention to a proper sampling
of the central source. Typically, 50 radial points (distributed in
a logarithmic way) and 32 angular points were used. The dependence on the radial and angular sampling was tested for the
low mass-loss-rate object R Dor and intermediate mass-loss-rate
object TX Cam by increasing the two parameters by a factor of
two. The differences in the modelled line fluxes were small in
both cases, less than 2%.
After each iteration the new level populations are calculated,
using a user-defined fraction of the old level populations (here
set to 0.8) to prevent the models from diverging too easily. The
models are said to converge when the average change in the level
populations between iterations is less than a defined limit. This
limit was also tested by running models with different limits for
R Dor and IK Tau. For an average change between iterations in
the level populations of less than 10−3 the models changed by
less than 0.1% This limit was subsequently used for all models.
4.2. Modelling of H2 O lines
The radiative transfer model includes the 45 lowest levels in the
ground and first excited vibrational states (the bending mode
ν2 = 1, 6.3 µm or ≈ 2300 K above the ground state) of orthoH2 O, while excitation through the stretching modes can be neglected. For the high mass-loss-rate objects IK Tau and WX Psc,
only the ground vibrational state was included in order to improve the convergence. The effect of excluding the ν2 state on the
resulting model line fluxes was tested and found to be insignificant (≤ 4%) for these high-mass-loss-rate objects (see Sect. 5.3).
The collisional rates in the ground state are taken from the rates
of H2 O with He, corrected by a factor of 1.4 to account for collisions with H2 (Green et al. 1993). Phillips et al. (1996) suggest
that this may lead to rather different rates compared to those obtained when including H2 in the calculation. However, they only
calculate collisional rates between H2 O and H2 up to a temperature of 140 K, while typical temperatures in the CSEs of AGB
stars can be up to 1000 K. The importance of collisions within
the ν2 state and between the ground and ν2 state was also tested
(see Sect. 5.3). Rotational collision rates within the first excited
M. Maercker et al.: Circumstellar water vapour in oxygen-rich AGB stars
5
5. Results
5.1. Modelled lines and ortho-H2 O abundances
Fig. 2. Modelled ISO ortho-H2O lines for TX Cam. The dotdashed line marks the stellar vLSR , the solid line shows vLSR ±
vexp . Self-absorption and weak P-Cygni profiles are present in
the model line profiles.
state are taken to be the same as for the ground state, while collisions between the ground and excited ν2 state are based on
the ground state rotational collision rate coefficients scaled by
a factor of 0.01. The molecular data for H2 O was taken from the
Leiden Atomic and Molecular Database1 (LAMDA) (Schöier et
al. 2005).
As with the CO models, the density distribution and temperature structure of the dust grains are taken from the dust radiative
transfer modelling (see Sect. 3.1). From the CO line modelling
the mass-loss rate, expansion velocity, and kinetic temperature
profile are included (see Sect. 3.2 and Table 4). The inner radius
of the CSE is set to the inner radius of the dust envelope, i.e. the
dust condensation radius. Setting a smaller radius does not affect
the line fluxes. For all models, a Gaussian distribution of circumstellar H2 O is assumed. The maximum radius is defined by the
e-folding radius re (i.e., where the abundance has decreased to
37%) and is set to 3 × re . By varying re , the size of the circumstellar H2 O envelope is treated as a free parameter.
An estimate of re is given by the results of theoretical models
of H2 O photodissociation (Netzer & Knapp 1987), where the radius at which the abundance of OH (the photodissociation product of H2 O) is highest is given by
rNK = 5.4 × 1016
Ṁ
10−5 M⊙ yr−1
!0.7
vexp −0.4
cm.
km s−1
(2)
The remaining parameter to fit is the ortho-H2O abundance
f o−H2 O relative to H2 . The model lines are fit to the line fluxes
of the observed spectra in the same way as for the CO emission
line models. The best fit model was determined, as for the CO
modelling, by minimising χ2 as defined in Eq. 1, with re and
fo−H2 O as free parameters.
1
available at http://www.strw.leidenuniv.nl/∼moldata
For each object a grid, of models with varying ortho-H2O abundance and H2 O envelope size was calculated. The resulting χ2
maps are shown in Fig. 3. Between 4 and 16 lines are matched
for each object. The fluxes of the best-fit modelled ortho-H2O
lines are shown in Table 2, together with the observed fluxes.
For the low-mass-loss-rate objects the abundance and re can be
reasonably well determined, while setting constraints for re becomes increasingly difficult with increasing mass-loss-rate. In
the high-mass-loss-rate objects, the emitting region is excitation
limited. Consequently, the emission is not very sensitive to the
envelope size. As a result, it is difficult to constrain the size of
the of the H2 O envelope for these objects. For the low-mass-lossrate objects, the excitation can be high throughout the envelope,
thus making the emission sensitive to the envelope size, i.e. the
emission can be said to be photodissociation limited. The grids
are terminated in envelope size when an increase in re does not
lead to a significant change in line fluxes anymore, or when the
1σ contour closes. For IK Tau and WX Psc a lower limit could
not be determined, as smaller envelope sizes require a higher
abundance, for which the models could not be made to converge.
The χ2 maps are truncated at ≈ 0.1 × rNK for these objects. In
the cases where an outer radius could be determined, the radius
given by Eq. 2 lies within the 1 σ contour of the lowest χ2 model
radius. Table 4 gives the radius from the theoretical model (rNK ),
the radius of the lowest χ2 model (re ), and the corresponding
abundance estimates ( f NK and f e , respectively). From here on,
the ‘best-fit’ models refer to the results obtained using rNK from
Eq. 2.
The resulting abundances of circumstellar ortho-H2O, from
fitting the model lines to the observed ISO lines, lie between
2 × 10−6 and 1.5 × 10−3 relative to H2 (Table 4). Four of the
modelled ISO lines of TX Cam are shown in Fig. 2 as an example of an intermediate-mass-loss-rate object. Self absorption
is present in all the lines, whereas weak P-Cygni profiles are
seen in the higher-frequency lines, where the continuum emission from thermal dust grains is stronger. Since the line shapes
are not spectrally resolved in the ISO spectra, only the fluxes
were fit. HIFI will be able to resolve the line profiles, and these
can then be taken into consideration when fitting the models
(Sect. 5.5).
Figure 4 shows the kinetic temperature profile compared to
the excitation temperature for four lines for W Hya and IK Tau
(upper panels), and the tangential optical depth at line centre for
the same lines as a function of distance from the central star
(lower panels). It should be pointed out that the optical depth in
the line wings usually is considerably higher. Two of the lines
are observed by ISO, while three of the lines will be observable by HIFI. In general, the lines are subthermally excited, and
the JK− K+ − JK− K+ = 532 − 441 transition at 620.9 GHz shows
maser action. The lines are more thermalised in the high-massloss-rate object IK Tau. The tangential optical depth shows the
regions where the lines are created, and this indicates that the
ISO observations do indeed probe the inner regions of the H2 O
envelope. W Hya has a smaller envelope due to the lower massloss-rate and consequently the lines are formed closer to the star.
5.2. Constraining the H2 O abundance distribution
Several test models were calculated in order to see how the results depend on the ortho-H2 O abundance, mass-loss-rate, and
6
M. Maercker et al.: Circumstellar water vapour in oxygen-rich AGB stars
Fig. 3. χ2 maps in ortho-H2O abundance and radius of the H2 O envelope for all stars in the sample. The contours give the 1, 2 and
3σ limits. The stars mark the best model based on the theoretical radius given by Eq. 2, the dots mark the models with the lowest
χ2 values. The χ2red values in the figures refer to the best model fits.
Table 4. Results of the dust emission, and CO and H2 O line modelling (see text for details). rNK and re are the theoretical model
radius and the e-folding radius, respectively. The corresponding H2 O abundances for both radii are given under f N K and f e ,
respectively. The χ2red values refer to the best H2 O model fits using rNK . Likewise, diff gives the average difference of the modelled
H2 O line fluxes using rNK to the observations in %.
a
b
Source
Type
TX Cam
R Cas
R Dor
W Hya
WX Psc
IK Tau
M
M
SRb
SRa
M
M
La
[L⊙ ]
11900
8725
6500
5400
14600
10400
Db
[pc]
440
172
59
78
720
300
τdust
10 µm
0.4
0.05
0.03
0.07
3.0
1.2
Ṁ
[10−6 M⊙ yr−1 ]
7.0
0.9
0.2
0.1
40
10
vexp
[kms−1 ]
18.5
10.5
6.0
7.2
19.3
19.0
rNK
[1015 cm]
13.1
3.9
1.7
1.1
43.0
17.0
re
[1015 cm]
20.0
3.0
1.1
2.2
-
f NK
[10−4 ]
3.0
3.0
2.0
15.0
0.02
3.5
fe
[10−4 ]
3.0
3.5
3.0
15.0
-
χ2red
0.6
0.3
0.7
0.6
2.7
1.2
diff
%
-6.8
-4.8
-1.9
-10.4
-7.3
-8.5
From period-luminosity relation (Feast et al. 1989), except for R Dor and W Hya, where the Hipparcos distances and the dust modelling are
used.
Determined in the dust modelling using L, except for R Dor and W Hya, where the Hipparcos distances are used (Knapp et al. 2003).
size of the circumstellar envelope. This was done by varying one
of the parameters, while all other parameters were held constant.
Table 5 shows the results in the cases of R Dor and TX Cam, as
examples of low and intermediate-mass-loss-rate objects.
Increasing and decreasing the abundance by a factor of two
changes the line fluxes on average by ±20% and ±10% for the
low- and high-mass-loss-rate objects, respectively (i.e. less than
the observational error in the ISO lines). In general, the error in
the H2 O abundances is estimated to be of the order ±50% within
the adopted model.
Varying the mass-loss rate by ±50% changes the line fluxes
by ≈ ± 30%. The change in mass-loss rate affects the density distribution, and hence the efficiency of the collisional excitation,
making the lines more sensitive for changes in the mass-loss rate
than for changes in the abundance.
Increasing and decreasing re by a factor of two changes the
line fluxes by less than ±20%. The emitting region is excitation
limited, instead of limited by the size of the H2 O envelope, making it difficult to provide good constraints on re . The position of
OH masers for W Hya (0.8 − 1.4 × 1015 cm from the central star,
see Szymczak et al. (1998)) and for R Cas (1.3 − 2.6 × 1015 cm
from the central star, see Chapman et al. (1994)), indicate that
the H2 O envelope might actually be smaller than given by Eq. 2.
We conclude that the saturation of the lines, and hence the insensitivity of the integrated intensity to the abundance, is the major source of uncertainty in the determined abundances. Taking
into account the uncertainty in the mass-loss rate (Ramstedt et
al. 2007), the line fluxes, and in the model-dependent assumptions (such as the molecular distribution and velocity field), the
determined abundances are accurate to within a factor of approximately 5.
5.3. Dependences on ‘fixed’ parameters
Additional test models were calculated to examine the dependence of the line fluxes on the ‘fixed’ parameters (see Table 5).
As before, only one parameter was varied, while all other parameters were held fixed. The effect of excitation to the first
M. Maercker et al.: Circumstellar water vapour in oxygen-rich AGB stars
7
Fig. 4. Kinetic temperature profile and excitation temperatures for four modelled lines (indicated by their JK− K+ − JK− K+ quantum
numbers) in W Hya and IK Tau (upper panels), and the tangential optical depths (at line centre) for the same lines (lower panels).
The lines include a high transition line observed with ISO (523 − 414 at 45 µm), a low lying transition observed with ISO (303 − 212
at 174.6 µm), and the 557 GHz line (110 − 101 ) observed by Odin and SWAS (the latter two can also be observed by HIFI). A
line, exhibiting maser action, which can be observed by HIFI is shown (532 − 441 at 621 GHz); the dashed line indicates the region
where the level populations are inverted, and shows the absolute value of the optical depth in the lower panel. For radii larger than
3 × 1015 cm, numerical noise dominates the 532 − 441 transition in IK Tau and the model is consequently terminated at this radius.
excited vibrational state was tested for the four stars for which
models including this state converged. Excluding excitation to
this state leads to a stronger decrease of the line fluxes for the
low-mass-loss rate objects than for the intermediate and highmass-loss rate objects. Hence the error introduced by not including the first excited vibrational state for IK Tau and WX Psc is
expected to be well below the uncertainty due to the observed
line fluxes. For the low-mass-loss-rate objects, the inclusion of
vibrational excitation results in significantly lower abundances
compared to models that do not include the excited vibrational
state (Justtanont et al. 2005). The variation of the line fluxes
when excluding the dust radiation field and the central star was
also examined in test models for the low-mass-loss-rate object
R Dor and intermediate-mass-loss-rate object TX Cam (Table 5).
It must be kept in mind that the changes in line fluxes all lie
within (or close to) the observational uncertainties. This is especially true for TX Cam, where the change between different
models is at most 12% on average.
Including the rotational collision rates within the ν2 = 1 state
and between the ground state and first excited state, as described
in Sect. 4.2, does not change the fluxes significantly for any
of the stars, showing that the dust radiation field and radiation
from the central star are more important for the excitation of the
ν2 = 1 state than collisions. The role of collisions within the
vibrational ground state is tested by setting all collisional coefficients to zero, decreasing the observed line fluxes, on average,
by 17% in the case of R Dor and 58% for TX Cam. As the lines
are generally subthermally excited, the error in the collision rates
in the ground state is likely to affect the modelled line fluxes (see
Sect. 4.2).
Since the ISO H2 O emission lines probe the inner parts of
the CSE, the expansion velocity in the region where the lines are
created may not have reached its terminal value as determined
in the CO line modelling (see Sect. 3.2). [Note that changing the
expansion velocity, while keeping the mass-loss-rate constant,
effectively changes the density profile.] Decreasing the expansion velocity by 20% only changes the line fluxes by +6% for
both TX Cam and R Dor, showing that the uncertainty in the expansion velocity does not contribute significantly to the error in
the estimated abundances.
5.4. H2 O line cooling
In addition to CO and H2 cooling by line emission, H2 O could
also be an important coolant in the inner part of CSEs where it is
8
M. Maercker et al.: Circumstellar water vapour in oxygen-rich AGB stars
Table 5. Parameter dependence of the model ISO line fluxes for
the low-mass-loss-rate object R Dor and the intermediate-massloss-rate object TX Cam. Column 2 gives the change of the various parameters relative to their best-fit value (Table 4). Columns
3 and 4 give the average difference of all model line fluxes compared to the best-fit model.
param.
fe
Rmod
Ṁ
vexp
T kin
collisions
ν2
dust
star
change
+100%
–50%
+100%
–50%
+50%
–50%
–20%
±20%
excl.
excl.
excl.
excl.
R Dor
+20%
–20%
+20%
–20%
+30%
–30%
+6%
±15%
–17%
–35%
–11%
–19%
TX Cam
+10%
–10%
+20%
–20%
+30%
–30%
+6%
±15%
–58%
–4%
–12%
–3%
abundant. From the excitation analysis, the cooling (or heating)
arising from line emission can be estimated using
XX
Λ = n H2
(nl γlu − nu γul )hνul ,
(3)
l
u>l
where nu and nl are the level populations in the upper and lower
levels participating in the transition (with rest frequency νul ) and
γul and γlu are the collisional rate coefficients (van der Tak et
al. 2007). The cooling rate Λ in erg s−1 cm−3 is defined as positive for net cooling. In Fig. 5 the line cooling from o-H2 O is
compared with that from CO and H2 for the W Hya and IK Tau
models used in the present analysis. In the region where H2 O
is abundant its cooling rate will be more than an order of magnitude higher than that from CO. Due to the constraints set by
the CO-line intensity ratios, the kinetic temperature profile determined through the CO line modelling is most accurate in the
region in which the CO lines are emitted. Any major cooling
due to H2 O must therefore be partly compensated by additional
heating, by adjusting the h-parameter so that the kinetic temperature structure is consistent with the observed CO rotational line
intensities.
To include molecular cooling from water self-consistently,
the energy balance equations for CO and H2 O must be solved simultaneously. For a complete description of the energy balance,
other processes (such as a complicated heating term) would have
to be included as well, which is beyond the scope of this paper.
A crude estimate of how H2 O line cooling and other processes
might affect the modelled line intensities is done by changing the
temperature profile resulting from the CO modelling by ± 20%.
This changes the line intensities on average by less than ±15%,
without changing the line ratios.
5.5. Predictions for HIFI
HIFI (Heterodyne instrument for the far infrared) is a heterodyne receiver onboard the Herschel space telescope, scheduled
for launch in 2008. The instrument is a high-resolution (up to
107 , 0.03 − 300 km s−1) heterodyne instrument designed to provide a wide and continuous frequency coverage. The frequency
range covered includes a large amount of molecular lines (de
Graauw et al. 2005). We have modelled 19 ortho-H2O lines covering a range of excitation and optical depths within the range
557 GHz to 1885 GHz.
Fig. 5. The emissivity Λ in erg s−1 cm−3 , scaled by (r/1014cm)4 ,
of the line cooling rate from o-H2 O, CO and H2 in the circumstellar envelopes around W Hya and IK Tau. There is a net cooling (Λ > 0) throughout the envelopes for these molecules, except
very close to the star in the case of CO in W Hya (Λ < 0 indicated
by a dashed line).
The sensitivity limit of HIFI for a 5 σ line detection after 1
hour of integration at a resolution of R = 100000 is between 2.2
and 22.0 × 10−30 W cm−2 Hz−1 (de Graauw et al. 2005), depending on the frequency band. The modelled HIFI lines generally
have fluxes of 10−27 W cm−2 Hz−1 or higher, making them observable without difficulty. Typically, between 1 and 10 hours of
integration time is required to obtain a sufficient signal-to-noise
ratio, even for weaker lines in the first excited vibrational state.
Figure 7 shows a selection of the modelled lines obtained
from the best-fit models for TX Cam, W Hya and IK Tau as
given in Table 4 (based on the theoretical H2 O envelope radius
given in Eq. 2). The dot-dashed line marks the stellar vLS R and
the solid line marks ±vexp . Maser action is present in the 532 −441
and 634 −541 transitions at 621 GHz and 1158 GHz, respectively,
in all three sources.
The line profiles for models with lower mass-loss rates generally appear to suffer more from self-absorption and show significant emission outside the range vLS R ±vexp . The CSEs of these
sources are relatively small and the optical depths at the outer
parts of the CSEs are around, or larger than, unity (see Fig. 4).
This leads to effective self-absorption on the blue-shifted side,
but also to a contribution of the local line profiles to the line
wings. This is particularly pronounced in the lines where the optical depths at line centre can reach up to ∼100 (Fig. 4) for these
kinds of objects, such as 110 − 101 and 303 − 212 (Fig. 7). The
broadening of the line profiles is further enhanced by the fact
that the thermal motion, vth , is of the same order or larger when
compared with the microturbulent motion, vturb , in the emitting
region. The result is that optically thin lines can also have significant line broadening (Fig. 6). These effects are less significant in
the high-mass-loss-rate objects, as the optical depths in the outer
parts of these CSEs, which contribute most to the observed emission, are around, or below, one. Also, for the high-mass-loss-rate
objects vth << vturb in the outer parts of the envelope.
The sensitivity of the HIFI lines to changes in various parameters has also been tested. A change in abundance by ±50%
changes the HIFI line fluxes on average by ≈ ±30% compared
to the best-fit model. This compares to the 10 − 20% change
in the ISO lines, indicating that the lines in the range of HIFI
are somewhat more sensitive to the H2 O abundance (see below).
Increasing and decreasing re by a factor of two change the line
fluxes on average by less than ±16%. The line fluxes for the HIFI
lines are more sensitive for a -20% change of the expansion velocity than the ISO lines (+20% on average; however, optically
thin lines are more sensitive, see below). Resolved line profiles
M. Maercker et al.: Circumstellar water vapour in oxygen-rich AGB stars
Table 6. Model maximum intensities for 3 optically thin lines
within the range of HIFI (in units of 10−30 W cm−2 Hz−1 ).
Trans
JK− K+ − JK− K+
854 − 761
854 − 927
845 − 752
ν
[GHz]
1169
1596
1885
R Dor
TX Cam
10
3
320
4
1
40
Table 7. Parameter dependence of the model fluxes of three optically thin lines observable by HIFI for the low-mass-loss-rate
object R Dor. Column 2 gives the change of the various parameters relative to their best-fit value (Table 4). The remaining
columns give the change of the model fluxes compared to the
best-fit fluxes for the respective lines.
param.
fe
Rmod
Ṁ
vexp
T kin
change
±50%
+100%
–50%
+50%
–50%
–20%
+20%
–20%
854 − 761
±30%
+4%
–2%
+77%
–25%
+28%
+21%
+9%
854 − 927
±6%
+5%
–2%
+10%
–7%
+5%
+1%
–1%
9
Table 8. Same as Table 7, but for the intermediate-mass-loss-rate
object TX Cam.
param.
fe
Rmod
Ṁ
vexp
T kin
change
±50%
+100%
–50%
+50%
–50%
–20%
+20%
+20%
854 − 761
±30%
+20%
–14%
+70%
–44%
+48%
+13%
+13%
854 − 927
±7%
+3%
–2%
+14%
–11%
+8%
+2%
+2%
845 − 752
±30%
+6%
–6%
+71%
–53%
+40%
+22%
+22%
845 − 752
±55%
+2%
–4%
+153%
–45%
+55%
+55%
+20%
will be crucial for getting information on the dynamical structure
of the inner CSE.
Of the 19 modelled lines, 5 are optically thin throughout the
CSE. Two of these are maser lines (the 532 −441 and 634 −541 transitions at 621 GHz and 1158 GHz, respectively). The remaining
three lines are shown in Table 6 with their predicted maximum
intensities. The 5 σ line detection limit after 1 hour of integration time at R = 100000 is ≈ 2 × 10−29 W cm−2 Hz−1 , making it
difficult to detect some of these lines.
The sensitivity of these lines to the ortho-H2O abundance,
the outer radius, mass-loss rate, kinetic temperature profile, and
expansion velocity was tested for R Dor and TX Cam. The resulting change in line fluxes is presented in Tables 7 and 8 for
R Dor and TX Cam, respectively. Except for the 854 − 927 transition, the optically thin lines are much more sensitive to the
abundance, mass-loss rate and expansion velocity than the ISO
lines are. The P-Cygni profile causes the insensitivity of the integrated flux in the 854 − 927 transition. The high sensitivity to the
expansion velocity is due to the change in the density profile as
a result of keeping the mass-loss rate constant while decreasing
the expansion velocity. They are only slightly more sensitive to
a change in the kinetic temperature profile compared to the ISO
lines, and not at all sensitive to the outer radius. For R Dor, transitions 321 − 312 , 212 − 101 , and 221 − 212 at 1163 GHz, 1670 GHz,
and 1661 GHz, respectively, are more sensitive to the change of
the outer radius (with up to a 30% change in line flux), but the
emission region is essentially excitation limited.
An example of how the 845 − 752 line profile changes between the different models for R Dor (top) and TX Cam (bottom) is shown in Fig. 6. The left panels show models in which
the parameters were reduced as indicated in Tables 7 and 8, and
the right panels show the models with increased parameters. The
line profiles change mainly in intensity. However, for TX Cam
the optical depth in the 845 − 752 transition is just below one
in the best fit model. The line therefore changes from optically
thick to optically thin for the different models, and as the optical
depth decreases, the line becomes increasingly flat-topped. The
Fig. 6. Line profiles of the 845 − 752 transition for the various
models indicated in Tables 7 and 8 for R Dor (top) and TX Cam
(bottom). The left panels show the models with decreased parameters; the right panels show models with increased parameters.One parameter is varied, while the others are held fixed,
thus leading to a change in the density profile when decreasing
the expansion velocity.
detailed abundance distribution is likely to have the largest effect on the shape of the line profile. Detailed examination of the
predicted HIFI line profiles based on the spectrally resolved 557
GHz lines of R Cas, R Dor and W Hya, obtained with the Odin
satellite, will be done in a forthcoming paper (Maercker et al.,
in prep.). Since this line is excited throughout the CSE, it will
in particular help put better constraints on the size of the H2 O
emitting region.
5.6. ISO CO-lines
The ISO LWS spectrum also contains high-lying transitions of
the CO molecule (Fig. 1). These CO lines probe the same region
as the H2 O lines, while the radio lines probe the regions further out. Modelling these high excitation CO lines can be used
as a consistency check for the adopted circumstellar model used
in the ALI models. Due to weak lines and blending, in general
only between one and three lines were found in the ISO spectra. W Hya, R Dor, and R Cas show the CO J = 16 → 15 and
10
M. Maercker et al.: Circumstellar water vapour in oxygen-rich AGB stars
Fig. 7. Eight ortho-H2O lines that can be observed with Herschel/HIFI TX Cam (top two rows), W Hya (middle two rows) and for
IK Tau (bottom two rows) models based on the theoretical radius from Eq. 2. The dot-dashed line marks the stellar vLSR , the solid
line shows vLSR ± vexp . A number of line profile shapes are predicted, and the HIFI observations will help to verify or adjust the
models.
M. Maercker et al.: Circumstellar water vapour in oxygen-rich AGB stars
J = 22 → 21 lines. R Cas also shows the CO J = 17 → 16 line.
In the remaining objects only the CO J = 16 → 15 line could be
found. For all objects except W Hya, the best-fit model fits the
observations within ±20%. The modelled CO lines for W Hya
are ∼ 80% weaker than the observations, in line with the higher
mass-loss rate used by Justtanont et al. (2005) (see Sect. 3.2).
6. Discussion
6.1. Comparison with previous results
Abundance estimates for two of the sources treated here have
been made previously. For W Hya, Justtanont et al. (2005)
find an ortho-H2O abundance of 1.0 ± 0.4 ×10−3 relative to H2 .
In their paper they use an ALI code to determine the H2 O
abundance by modelling of ISO SWS and LWS lines, and the
Odin 557 GHz line. This agrees well with the abundance determined here (1.5 ± 0.75 × 10−3 ). Our higher abundance is due
to the lower mass-loss rate used (see Sect. 3.2). Barlow et al.
(1996) employ a large velocity gradient (LVG) model and determine a total H2 O/H2 of 8 × 10−4 in the inner part of the CSE
(r ≤ 6 × 1014 cm) and 3 × 10−4 in the outer part (r > 6 × 1014 cm).
Although the ortho-to-para ratio in their article is not very well
constrained, between 1 and 3, their results are consistent with the
abundances derived here. Zubko & Elitzur (2000) determine an
abundance for ortho-H2O of 5.7 × 10−5 , one order of magnitude
lower than the results presented here, and a mass-loss rate one
order of magnitude higher (2.3 × 10−6 M⊙ yr−1 ). Their results are
therefore consistent with ours, given the higher mass-loss rate.
For R Cas, Truong-Bach et al. (1999) determine an ortho-H2O
abundance of only 7.9 × 10−6 , two orders of magnitude lower
than our result, using ISO LWS spectra. The mass-loss-rate used
in their paper is somewhat lower than the one determined from
the CO modelling here, further increasing the discrepancy in the
abundance estimates. They do not model the dust emission explicitly, but instead use a power law to reproduce the far-infrared
continuum spectrum. They also estimate cooling by CO emission by adopting a three level model, compared to the more
complex scheme included here. On the other hand, they include
a dust grain drift velocity (relative to the gas) that depends on
the distance to the star. Including a velocity field in our models
would probably result in somewhat lower abundances. Although
the models are different, this is far from enough to explain the
different results.
6.2. Evaporating planetary systems?
Assuming an ortho-to-para ratio of 1 gives an estimate of the
total H2 O abundance of ∼ 6 × 10−4 in the majority of our stars.
[Justtanont et al. (2005) and Zubko & Elitzur (2000) found an
ortho-to-para H2 O ratio of 1 and 0.8 for W Hya, respectively.
Truong-Bach et al. (1999) derive a ratio of 3 for R Cas, in accordance with what is expected in LTE.] The estimated W Hya
H2 O abundance is significantly higher than this, but, as outlined
in Justtanont et al. (2005), the W Hya mass-loss rate could be
significantly higher than the value we use, and consequently the
H2 O abundance could be significantly lower. The cosmic abundance of carbon and oxygen (Anders & Grevesse 1989) limits
the abundance of H2 O relative to H2 to not more than 1 × 10−3 ,
assuming that all the carbon goes into CO, and all the remaining
O goes into H2 O. The abundance of H2 O in thermal equilibrium (TE) is approximately 1-3× 10−4 relative to H2 (Mamon et
al. 1987; Nejad & Miller 1988; Willacy & Millar 1997; Duari
et al. 1999). Taken at face value, our results indicate that the
11
abundances of H2 O observed in M-type AGB stars cannot be explained by TE chemistry. The uncertainty in our results is, however, at least a factor of a few, and therefore does not rule out a
TE abundance. NLTE chemistry can affect the H2 O abundance,
e.g., due to different densities and temperatures in shocked regions close to the star (Duari et al. 1999; Cherchneff 2006), and
photodissociation further out in the envelope will strongly affect the abundance (Mamon et al. 1987; Nejad & Miller 1988;
Willacy & Millar 1997). Other processes suggested to explain
the relatively high water abundances are the evaporation of icy
bodies (Justtanont et al. 2005) or grain surface reactions, such
as Fischer-Tropsch catalysis on the surfaces of small metallic
grains (Willacy 2004). The former process was first suggested to
explain the surprising detection of H2 O in C-rich CSEs (Melnick
et al. 2001; Hasegawa et al. 2006).
Future observations with Herschel will make it possible to
discriminate between the different formation scenarios, as suggested by e.g. González-Alfonso et al. (2007) in the case of Crich CSEs. A high abundance of H2 O in the inner regions of the
CSE will be observable through a significant amount of midexcitation H2 O transitions. These are already observed in the
ISO spectra for our objects, indicating that at least some of the
observed H2 O is formed in the inner envelope. Both FischerTropsch catalysis and the evaporation of cometary bodies result
in similar shell-like H2 O distributions. The evaporation hypothesis, however, implies the presence of HDO, the detection of
which would rule out the formation of H2 O from material ejected
by the star.
6.3. The very low abundance in WX Psc
WX Psc has an estimated abundance that is two orders of magnitude lower than for the other objects. A possible explanation
for this is depletion of H2 O on dust grains. For a sample of carbon and M-type stars, Schöier & Olofsson (2006) show that the
abundance of SiO decreases in the CSEs with increasing Ṁ/vexp
(a measure of the density), and explain this by depletion of SiO
onto the dust grains. The freezing of water ice onto dust grains is
also the explanation for the lack of H2 O lines in the spectra of a
sample of OH/IR stars (Justtanont et al. 2006). Another possible
explanation for the low abundance in WX Psc could be that the
ISO water vapour observations are probing a present day massloss rate, whereas the CO transitions probe an earlier mass-loss
epoch (Ramstedt et al. 2007). If the present day mass loss is
much lower, this would require an increase in the H2 O abundance, thereby putting WX Psc more in line with the other objects. Mass-loss-rate modulations in WX Psc with a low present
day mass-loss-rate have been suggested previously by Kemper
et al. (2003) and are further discussed by Ramstedt et al. (2007).
7. Conclusions
We have demonstrated the ability of our accelerated lambda iteration (ALI) code to model circumstellar H2 O emission lines
in M-type AGB stars at optical depths > 1000, and ortho-H2O
abundances are estimated. The models include the ground and
first excited vibrational states, collisions within the ground vibrational state, the first excited vibrational state, and between
these states, and excitation by the stellar and dust radiation fields.
The sample of stars modelled spans one order of magnitude in
mass-loss rate. The ortho-H2O abundances determined, in the
range (0.02–15)×10−4, are estimated to be accurate to within
50%, within the adopted circumstellar model, while the absolute error (including model-dependent assumptions) is within a
12
M. Maercker et al.: Circumstellar water vapour in oxygen-rich AGB stars
factor of 5. The estimated H2 O abundances are high in comparison to what can be produced by chemical models, but we explain
that the estimates are rather uncertain.
The outer radius of the H2 O envelope is better determined
for the low-mass-loss-rate objects and corresponds to within 1σ
to the radius given by the theoretical estimate in Eq. 2.
Including excitation of the ground state through the vibrationally excited state affects the low-mass-loss-rate objects, increasing the model line fluxes by ≈ 40%. This results in a lower
abundance for these objects compared to models that do not include the excited vibrational state (Justtanont et al. 2005). For
higher mass-loss-rate objects the vibrational excitation is less
important.
Several formation processes for the observed H2 O abundances are possible. LTE or NLTE models may explain the formation of H2 O in the innermost layers of the CSE, whereas
Fischer-Tropsch catalysis or the evaporation of Kuiper-belt like
objects are possible sources of H2 O in the outer parts of the envelope. Future observations with the Herschel telescope will help
to differentiate between these scenarios. The HIFI lines are generally less saturated and will therefor give a better estimate of the
circumstellar H2 O abundance. In particular, optically thin lines,
such as the 845 − 752 transition, are sensitive to the H2 O abundance, and will help constrain this parameter. The ground state
line at 557 GHz, on the other hand, is excited throughout the envelope and will help in setting constraints on the size of the H2 O
envelope.
For WX Psc, we suggest that sticking of H2 O onto
dust grains may explain the observed low amount of H2 O.
Alternatively, the present day mass-loss rate is low.
Acknowledgements. The authors would like to thank the anonymous referee for
useful comments that helped improve the quality of the manuscript. The authors
acknowledge the financial support from the Swedish Research Council and the
Swedish National Space Board.
References
Anders, E., & Grevesse, N. 1989, Geochem. Cosmochim. Acta, 53, 197
Bains, I., Cohen, R.J., Louridas, A., et al. 2003, MNRAS, 342, 8
Barlow, M.J., Nguyen-Q-Rieu, Truong-Bach, et al. 1996, A&A, 315, L241
Beck, H.K.B., Gail, H.-P., Henkel, R., & Sedlmayr, E. 1992, A&A, 265, 626
Boothroyd, A.I., & Sackmann, I.J. 1988, ApJ, 328, 671
Chapman, J.M., Sivagnanam, P., Cohen, R.J., & Le Squeren, A.M. 1994,
MNRAS, 268, 475
Cherchneff, I. 2006, A&A, 456, 1001
Clegg, P.E., Ade, P.A.R., Armand, C., et al. 1996, A&A, 315, L38
Colomer, F., Reid, M.J., Menten, K.M., & Bujarrabal, V. 2000, A&A, 355, 979
Deguchi, S. & Nguyen-Q-Rieu 1990, ApJ, 360, L27
Duari, D, Cherchneff, I., & Willacy, K. 1999, A&A, 341, L47
Feast, M.W., Glass, I.S., Whitelock, P.A., Catchpole, R.M. 1989, MNRAS, 241,
375
Flower, D.R. 2001, J. Phys. B.: At. Mol. Opt. Phys., 34, 2731
González-Alfonso, E., & Cernicharo, J. 1999, ApJ, 525, 845
González-Alfonso, E., Neufeld, D.A., & Melnick, G.J. 2007, A&A, accepted
González Delgado, D., Olofsson, H., Kerschbaum, F., et al. 2003, A&A, 411,
123
de Graauw, Th., Caux, E., Guesten, R., et al. 2005, AAS, 37, 1219
Green, S., Maluendes, S., & McLean, A.D. 1993, ApJS, 85, 181
Habing, H.J. 1996, A&A Rv, 7, 97
Hasegawa, T.I., Kwok, A., Koning, N., et al. 2006, ApJ, 637, 791
Iben, I. 1975, ApJ, 196, 525
Ivezić, Z̆, Nenkova, M. & Elitzur, M. 1999, User Manual for DUSTY, (Univ.
Kentucky Internal Rep.)
Justtanont, K., & Tielens, A.G.G.M. 1992, ApJ, 389, 400
Justtanont, K., Bergman, P., Larsson, B., et al. 2005, A&A, 439, 627
Justtanont, K., Olofsson, G., Dijkstra, C., & Meyer, W. 2006, A&A, 450, 1051
Kemper, F., Stark, R., Justtanont, K., et al. 2003, A&A, 407, 609
Kerschbaum, F. & Olofsson, H. 1999, A&A Suppl. Ser., 138, 299
Knapp, G.R., Pourbaix, D., Platais, I., & Jorissen, A. 2003, A&A, 403, 993
Lane, A.P., Johnston, K.J., Bowers, P.F., Spencer, J.H., & Diamond, P.J. 1987,
ApJ, 323, 756
Mamon, G.A., Glassgold, A.E., & Omont, A. 1987, ApJ, 323, 306
Mamon, G.A., Glassgold, A.E., & Huggins, P.J. 1988, ApJ, 328, 797
Marigo, P., & Girardi, L. 2007, A&A, 469, 239
Melnick, G.J., Stauffer, J.R., Ashby, M.L.N., et al. 2000, ApJ, 539, L77
Melnick, G.J., Neufeld, D.A., Saavik Ford, K.E., et al. 2001, Nature, 412, 160
Melnick, G.J., & Bergin, E.A. 2005, AdSpR, 36, 1027
Menten, K.M., & Melnick, G.J. 1989, ApJ, 341, L91
Menten, K.M., Philipp, S.D., Güsten, R., et al. 2006, A&A, 454, L107
Nejad, L.A.M., & Millar, T.J. 1988, MNRAS, 230, 79
Netzer, N., & Knapp, G.R. 1987, ApJ, 323, 734
Neufeld, D.A., Chen, W., Melnick, G.J., et al. 1996, A&A, 315, L237
Ng, K.C. 1974, J. Chem. Phys., 61, 2680
Nordh, H.L., von Schéle, F., Frisk, U., et al. 2003, A&A, 402, L21
Olofsson, H., González Delgado, D., Kerschbaum, F., & Schöier, F.L. 2002,
A&A, 391, 1053
Olofsson H. 2007, in ”Science with ALMA: a new era for astrophysics”, in press
Olson, G.L., Auer, L.H., & Buchler, J.R. 1986, J. Quant. Spectrosc. Radiat.
Transfer, 35, 431
Phillips, T.R., Maluendes, S., & Green, S. 1996, ApJS, 107, 467
Ramstedt, S., Schöier, F.L., Olofsson, H., & Lundgren, A.A. 2007, submitted.
Russel, H.N. 1934, ApJ, 79, 317
Ryde, N., & Eriksson, K. 2002, A&A, 386, 874
Rybicki, G.B., & Hummer, D.G. 1991, A&A, 245, 171
Rybicki, G.B., & Hummer, D.G. 1992, A&A, 262, 209
Schöier, F.L., & Olofsson, H. 2001, A&A, 368, 969
Schöier, F.L., & Olofsson, H. 2006, A&A, 454, 247
Schöier, F.L., Ryde, N., & Olofsson, H. 2002, A&A, 391, 557
Schöier, F.L., van der Tak, F.F.S., van Dishoeck, E.F., & Black, J.H. 2005, A&A,
432, 369
Stanek, K.Z., Knapp, G.R., Young, K., & Phillips, T. 1995, Ap&SS, 100, 169
Szymczak, M., Cohen, R.J., & Richards, A.M.S. 1998, MNRAS, 297, 1151
Truong-Bach, Sylvester, R.J., Barlow, M.J., et al. 1999, A&A, 345, 925
van der Tak, F.F.S., Black, J.H., Schöier, F.L., Jansen, D.J., & van Dishoeck, E.F.
2007, A&A, 468, 627
Vlemmings, W.H.T., van Langevelde, H.J., Diamond, P.J., Habing, H.J., &
Schilizzi, R.T. 2003, A&A, 407, 213
Whittet, D.C.B. 1992, Dust in the Galactic Environment, IoP Publishing, Bristol
Willacy, K., & Millar, T.J. 1997, A&A, 324, 237
Willacy, K. 2004, ApJ, 600, L87
van Zadelhoff, G.-J., Dullemond, C.P., van der Tak, F.F.S., et al. 2002, A&A ,
395, 373
Zubko, V. & Elitzur, M. 2000, ApJ, 544, L137
M. Maercker et al.: Circumstellar water vapour in oxygen-rich AGB stars
13
Appendix A: Accelerated lambda iteration (ALI)
A.1. General considerations
The radiative transfer models used in this work are created using the accelerated lambda iteration (ALI) method (Rybicki &
Hummer 1991, 1992). As for most NLTE codes, the ALI technique makes an initial guess of the level populations ni and
solves the statistical equilibrium (SE) equations (for transition
l → l′ )
X
[nl All′ − (nl′ Bl′ l − nl Bll′ ) J¯ll′ ] −
l′ <l
X
[nl′ Al′ l − (nl Bll′ − nl′ Bl′ l ) J¯ll′ ] +
l′ >l
X
(nlCll′ − nl′ Cl′ l ) = 0,
(A.1)
l′
where All′ is the Einstein A-coefficient, Bll′ and Bl′ l are the
Einstein B-coefficients for stimulated emission and absorption
respectively, and Cll′ are the collisional rates. J¯ll′ is the mean
integrated intensity
Z
Z
1
J¯ll′ =
dΩ dνφll′ (µ, ν)I(µ, ν),
(A.2)
4π
where I(µ, ν) is the specific intensity at frequencey ν along direction µ, and φll′ (µ, ν) is the normalized line shape profile (Doppler
profile) used as a weight function. In the spherically symmetric
case it is enough to solve the SE equations by determining J¯ll′
at every radial point in the circumstellar shell, considering both
the local and non-local contributions from all directions µ. This
is done by introducing the lambda operator Λµν , which relates to
the specific intensity I(µ, ν) as
I(µ, ν) = Λµν S tot (µ, ν) + Lbg ,
(A.3)
where S tot (µ, ν) is the total source function (including dust and
all overlapping lines) and Lbg is the contribution from the background to I(µ, ν). The lambda operator can be seen as a N × N
matrix with N radial points. The diagonal elements of the matrix
describe the local contribution to the specific intensity, while the
off-diagonal elements describe the contribution from all other
parts of the cloud. If τ(µ, ν) is the local optical depth in direction
µ, the diagonal elements become
Λr,r (µ, ν) = 1 − e−τ(µ,ν) .
(A.4)
For high optical depths (τ(µ, ν) ≫ 1) Λr,r → 1, whereas in the
optical thin case (τ(µ, ν) → 0) Λr,r → 0. Instead of applying the
lambda iteration directly, the accelerated lambda iteration technique uses an approximate lambda operator Λ∗µν to take care of
the high optical depths separately
†
I(µ, ν) = Λ∗µν S tot (µ, ν) + (Λµν − Λ∗µν )S tot
(µ, ν).
(A.5)
S tot † (µ, ν) is the source function from the previous iteration and
can be used, since convergence guarantees that S tot † → Stot . It is
convenient to simply choose the diagonal elements of the lambda
operator as the approximate lambda operator. This makes the
matrix inversion easily possible, and the SE equations can be
solved at every radial point individually, based on the approximate lambda operator only. Using the accelerated lambda iteration technique improves the rate of convergence compared
to normal lambda iteration, particularly in cases of high optical depths. To further improve convergence, Ng acceleration
(Ng 1974) is used, with a good description of the method given
by Olson et al. (1986).
Fig. A.1. Results from benchmarking our ALI code against the
results found in van Zadelhoff et al. (2002) for their problems 2a
and 2b, consisting of an inside-out collapsing spherical cloud.
The figure shows the radial distributions of the relative number density of HCO+ molecules in the rotational levels J = 1
and J = 4 as obtained by our ALI code after convergence. Also
shown are the deviations (in percent) of our results when compared to the mean of the results found by all other radiative transfer codes, as presented in van Zadelhoff et al. (2002).
A.2. Benchmarking
When developing a new radiative transfer code it is important to perform detailed tests as to its accuracy. A number of such test problems are available for download at
www.strw.leidenuniv.nl/∼radtrans. Our ALI code has
been benchmarked against the solutions to these problems as
found by seven different radiative transfer codes (presented in
van Zadelhoff et al. 2002). We find that our ALI code reproduces the results for all these test problems with an accuracy
that matches all the other codes included in van Zadelhoff et al.
(2002).
As an example, Fig. A.1 shows the solution obtained from
our ALI code for problems 2a and 2b of van Zadelhoff et
al. (2002). These problems consist of an inside-out collapsing
spherical cloud and contain radial gradients in most physical
parameters such as velocity, density, temperature and microturbulent velocity. The excitation analysis is performed for
HCO+ , and the final level populations (in relation to the total
number density of HCO+ molecules, ntot ) for the J = 1 and J = 4
rotational levels are shown in Fig. A.1. Also shown are the deviations of our ALI code (in percent) from the mean of the results obtained by the other radiative transfer codes presented in
van Zadelhoff et al. (2002). The spread in the results, around the
mean, between various codes in van Zadelhoff et al. (2002) is for
the J = 1 level about ± 1% and ± 2% for problems 2a and 2b, respectively. For the J = 4 level a larger spread of about ± 5% and
± 15% was obtained for problems 2a and 2b, respectively.