NORTH-WESTERN JOURNAL OF ZOOLOGY 8 (1): 164-171
Article No.: 121111
©NwjZ, Oradea, Romania, 2012
www.herp-or.uv.ro/nwjz
First record of Stagnicola montenegrinus Glöer & Pešić, 2009
(Mollusca: Gastropoda: Lymnaeidae) in Bulgaria
and its taxonomic relationship to other European lymnaeids
based on molecular analysis
Katrin SCHNIEBS1,*, Peter GLÖER2, Dilian GEORGIEV3 and Anna K. HUNDSDOERFER1
1. Senckenberg Natural History Collections Dresden, Museum of Zoology, Königsbrücker Landstraße 159,
D-1109 Dresden, Germany, E-mails: katrin.schniebs@senckenberg.de, anna.hundsdoerfer@senckenberg.de
2. Biodiversity Research Laboratory, Schulstraße 3, D-25491 Hetlingen, Germany, E-mail: gloeer@malaco.de
3. Department of Ecology and Environmental Conservation, University of Plovdiv,
Tzar Assen Str. 24, BG-4000 Plovdiv, Bulgaria, E-mail: diliangeorgiev@abv.bg
* Corresponding author, K. Schniebs, E-mail: katrin.schniebs@senckenberg.de
Received: 24. October 2011 / Accepted: 19. February 2012 / Available online: 21. February 2012 / Printed: June 2012
Abstract. Stagnicola montenegrinus was found in the floodplain of the river Maritza in Plovdiv. By comparison
of the cyt-b sequences (fragment of 329 bp) of one of the specimens with other European Stagnicola
specimens, this specimen fell in a cluster together with two sequences of S. montenegrinus from Skadar Lake,
confirming the morphological determination and the first record of this species for Bulgaria. S. montenegrinus
is a species closely related to S. corvus. The species' occurrence is evidently not limited to the Skadar Lake
region from where S. montenegrinus was originally described.
Key words: Stagnicola montenegrinus, Bulgaria, Lymnaeidae, molecular genetics.
Introduction
For the freshwater snail fauna of Bulgaria currently, three species of the genus Stagnicola Jeffreys, 1830 are known: S. palustris (O. F. Müller,
1774), S. corvus (Gmelin, 1791), and S. turricula
(Held, 1836) (Angelov 2000, Hubenov 2007).
When S. montenegrinus was described as a new
species of this genus, it was only known from
three localities in Montenegro: the Skadar Lake,
the Crnojevica River and the Humsko Blato near
Vitoja (Glöer & Pešić 2009). Up to now no other records became known.
In June 2010 three specimens of genus Stagnicola were collected in the floodplain of the river
Maritza in Plovdiv (Bulgaria) and sent to the
Senckenberg Natural History Collections Dresden,
Museum of Zoology (SNSD) for determination
and molecular genetics analyses. Anatomical examinations by Peter Glöer determined that these
three specimens belong to S. montenegrinus. The
aim of the study is to prove the determination
based on shell and genital characters by molecular
techniques.
Material and methods
The specimens of S. montenegrinus were found in shallow
floods and pools on the north bank of Maritza River in
Plovdiv city (Upper Thracian Lowland) near the VHVP-
bridge (Fig. 1), N42° 09' 13.5'' E24° 43' 34.8'', leg. Dilian
Georgiev, 09.06.2010.
Figure 1. Habitat of S. montenegrinus on the northern
banks of Maritza River in Plovdiv city (photo by
Stanislava Vassileva).
Dissections and measurements of genital organs and
shells were carried out using stereo microscopes (ZEISS
and OLYMPUS). Photographs were taken with a digital
camera system (OLYMPUS DP10).
For the taxonomy we followed the current European
checklists (Falkner et al. 2001, Bank 2011).
For outgroup comparison in the molecular genetic
analyses we used Palaearctic specimens of the species
Planorbarius corneus (Linnaeus 1758), Aplexa hypnorum
(Linnaeus, 1758). Lymnaea stagnalis (Linnaeus, 1758), Galba
truncatula (O. F. Müller, 1774), Omphiscola glabra (O. F.
Müller, 1774), Radix auricularia (Linnaeus, 1758), R.
balthica (Linnaeus, 1758), R. labiata (Rossmässler, 1835),
Stagnicola montenegrinus in Bulgaria
165
Stagnicola palustris, S. fuscus (C. Pfeiffer, 1821), and S. corvus were used as ingroup. The snails were fixed in 70-80%
ethanol. All specimens used in the study are listed in Ta-
ble 1. They are stored in the Molluscan collection of the
Senckenberg Natural History Collections Dresden, Museum of Zoology (SNSD).
Table 1. Material used in the molecular genetic studies. ENA=European Nucleotide Archive.
Code
Collection
Locality
No. SNSD
Planorbarius corneus (Linnaeus, 1758)
Planorbarius corneus 1
Moll 52556
Planorbarius corneus 2
Moll 52557
Aplexa hypnorum (Linnaeus 1758)
Aplexa hypnorum 1
Moll S348
Aplexa hypnorum 2
Moll S350
Galba truncatula (O. F. Müller 1774)
Galba truncatula 1
Moll 52545
Galba truncatula 2
Moll 52546
Galba truncatula 3
Moll S1130
Galba truncatula 4
Moll S1131
Omphiscola glabra (O. F. Müller 1774)
Omphiscola glabra 1
Moll S303
Omphiscola glabra 2
Moll S304
Omphiscola glabra 3
Moll S305
Lymnaea stagnalis (Linnaeus, 1758)
Lymnaea stagnalis 1
Moll 53093
Lymnaea stagnalis 2
Moll 53094
ENA No.
cyt-b
ITS-2
Germany, Saxony, Linz, pond Goldgrubenteich, FR797880 FR797830
13°43'09"E 51°19'45"N
FR797881 FR797831
Germany, Mecklenburg-Vorpommern, lake, Ne- FR797882 FR797832
bel, 12°42'02"E 53°15'32"N
FR797883 FR797833
Germany, Saxony, Oelsnitz/Erzgebirge, former FR797892 FR797847
pond, 12°42'04"E 50°43'02"N
FR797893 FR797848
Bulgaria, Osogovo Mountains, Smolichane
FR797890 FR797845
Village, karst spring, 22°48'25.2"E 42°07'58.1"N FR797891 FR797846
Germany, Hamburg, Kollau, Mühlenau,
09°55'33"E 53°36'34"N
Germany, Baden-Württemberg, lake Bodensee,
peninsula Mettnau, north side, 09°00'04"E
47°43'52"N
Lymnaea stagnalis 3
Moll 53108 Germany, Baden-Württemberg, Konstanz-Egg,
Lymnaea stagnalis 4
Moll 53109 ditch Hockgraben, 9°11'34.2"E 47°40'57.3"N
Stagnicola palustris (O. F. Müller 1774)
Stagnicola palustris 1
Moll 48716 Germany, Saxony, wetland west of Burghausen,
12°14'44"E 51°21'33"N
Stagnicola palustris 2
Moll 53095 Germany, Baden-Württemberg, lake Bodensee,
Stagnicola palustris 3
Moll 53096 peninsula Mettnau, north side, 09°00'04"E
47°43'52"N
Stagnicola palustris 4
Moll S1345 Germany, Mecklenburg-Vorpommern, lake
Grosser Plaetschsee, south bank, 12°19'18"E
53°26'25"N
Stagnicola fuscus (C. Pfeiffer 1821)
Stagnicola fuscus 1
Moll 48550 Germany, Saxony, reservoir Lobstädt, north
bank, 12°27'27"E 51°07'58"N
Stagnicola fuscus 2
Moll 51794 Germany, Saxony, marsh wood near Raden,
13°29'57"E 51°22'23"N
Stagnicola fuscus 3
Moll S2082 Germany, Saxony, nature reserve Alte See Grethen, marsh wood, 12°40'18"E 51°13'42"N
Stagnicola fuscus 4
Moll S2199 Germany, Baden-Württemberg, nature reserve
Erlich, marsh wood, R 3462394 H 5449072
Stagnicola fuscus 5
Moll S2946 Germany, Thuringia, alder marsh near Appenrode, 10°43'07"E 51°34'27"N
Stagnicola corvus (Gmelin 1791)
Stagnicola corvus 1
Moll 49821 Germany, Saxony, Niederspree, pond Großer
Tiefzug, 14°53'38"E 51°24'20"N
Stagnicola corvus 2
Moll 49872 Germany, Saxony, pond Vierteich near Freitelsdorf, 13°41'57"E 51°15'43"N
Stagnicola corvus 3
Moll 52830 Germany, Saxony, Grethen, ditch on the west
Stagnicola corvus 4
Moll 52831 side of the pond Kleiner Kirchenteich,
Stagnicola corvus 5
Moll 52832 12°39'22"E 51°14'29"N
Stagnicola montenegrinus Glöer & Pešić 2009
Stagnicola montenegrinus 1
Moll 51854 Montenergo: Skutari See, Vranjina 9°07'32.52"E
Stagnicola montenegrinus 2
Moll 51855 42°16'37.37"N
FR797887 FR797853
FR797888 FR797854
FR797889 FR797855
FR797896 FR797836
FR797897 FR797837
FR797894 FR797834
FR797895 FR797835
FR797899 FR797841
HE577651 HE577631
HE577652 HE577632
HE577653 FR797838
HE577654 HE577633
HE577655 HE577634
HE577656 HE577635
HE577657 HE577636
HE577658 HE577637
HE577659 HE577638
HE577660 HE577639
HE577661 HE577640
HE577662 HE577641
HE577663 HE577642
HE577664 HE577643
HE577665 HE577644
Schniebs, K. et al.
166
Table 1. (continued)
Code
Stagnicola montenegrinus 3
Radix auricularia (Linnaeus 1758)
Radix auricularia 1
Radix auricularia 2
Radix auricularia 3
Radix auricularia 4
Radix labiata (Rossmässler 1835)
Radix labiata 1
Radix labiata 2
Radix labiata 3
Radix labiata 4
Radix balthica (Linnaeus 1758)
Radix balthica 1
Radix balthica 2
Radix balthica 3
Radix balthica 4
Collection
Locality
No. SNSD
Moll S2313 Bulgaria: floodplain of the Maritza river in
Plovdiv, 24° 43' 34.8''E 42° 09' 13.5''N
Moll 53070
Moll 53071
Moll 52857
Moll 52859
Germany, Bavaria, Weichering, pond in riverside forest, 11°19'23.6"E 48°43'34.1"N
Moll 51275
Moll 51276
Moll 51696
Moll 51697
Germany, Saxony, pond near Langenberg,
12°51'21"E 50°33'09"N
Moll 51281
Moll 51283
Moll 53111
Moll 53112
Switzerland, canton Basel-Landschaft, Liestal,
Orishof, 07°43'03"E 47°28'22"N
Russia, Novosibirsk Region, Novosibirsk
Reservoir near Kirza River 81° 39.63114"E 54°
14.244”N
Germany, Brandenburg, small lake near Wachow, 12°43'05"E 52°32'05"N
Germany, Baden-Württemberg, Konstanz-Egg,
pond near University, 09°11'29"E 47°41'09" N
Molecular techniques
Tissue samples were taken under a microscope from the
feet of the snails and fixed in 100% ethanol. The samples
were registered in the tissue collection of the SNSD with a
new collection number and the collection number of the
specimen in the molluscan collection of SNSD and stored
at -80°C.
For molecular genetic analyses we obtained sequence
data of the complete nuclear ITS-2 marker (280 bp in A.
hypnorum up to 491 bp in L. stagnalis) and a 329 bp fragment of the cyt-b gene as mitochondrial marker.
DNA was extracted using DTAB (dodecyl trimethyl
ammonium bromide) buffer (Gustincich et al. 1991). The
tissue samples were washed with 100 µl TE buffer and
subsequently incubated with 500 µl preheated DTAB for
30 min at 65°C. The incubation was continued after adding 10 µl Proteinase K (50 mg/ml) for 20-24 hours, followed by a short incubation with 10 µl RNase (10 mg/ml)
for 30 min at 37°C. Remaining tissue fragments disintegrated after vortexing. For cleaning 550 µl chloroform/isoamyl alcohol (24/1) was used. The samples were
vortexed for 20 sec and the phases subsequently separated again at 12 000 g for 3 min. With the upper aqueous
phase the procedure was repeated. 100 µl 4M LiCl and
400 µl isopropanol were added to the aqueous phase for
precipitation. The samples were cooled at -20°C for 30
min and subsequently the DNA was pelleted by centrifugation at 11 200 g for 20 min at 4°C. The liquid was disposed of and the pellets were dried by inverting the tubes
on a paper towel. The pellets were cleaned twice with 200
µl ice-cold 70% ethanol. The DNA pellets were dried 10
min at 50°C and subsequently redissolved in 50 µl of TE
buffer.
The PCRs were carried out in a final volume of 20 µl
with quantities of DNA from 0.5 to 5.0 µl depending on
the concentration estimated by gel electrophoresis, 2 µl
10x PCR buffer (Bioron, incomplete), 1 µl MgCl2 (Bioron,
ENA No.
cyt-b
ITS-2
HE577666 HE577645
FR797902
FR797903
HE577667
HE577668
FR797842
FR797843
HE577647
HE577646
HE573106
HE573107
HE577669
HE573108
HE573068
HE573069
HE577648
HE573070
HE577670
HE573133
HE573116
HE573117
HE577650
HE573082
HE573078
HE577649
0.055 µS/cm), 1 µl of each primer (10 pmol/µl), 0.5 µl
dNTP (10 mM), 0.2 µl Taq DNA polymerase (DFS-Taq
Bioron) and the corresponding volume of sterile H2O.
From the cyt-b gene a region of circa 370 bp was amplified with the primers UCytb151F and UCytb270R (Merritt
et al. 1998) and a temperature profile of 94°C for 4 min, 40
cycles of 94°C for 40 s, 48°C for 40 s, 72°C for 1.15 min,
followed by an extension at 72°C for 6 min and hold at
8°C, was used. The primers used for ITS-2 were LT1 (Bargues et al. 2001) and ITS2-Rixo (Almeyda-Artigas et al.
2000). The temperature profile used was the following:
94°C for 4 min, 40 cycles of 94°C for 30 s, 50°C for 30 s,
72°C for 1 min, followed by 7 min at 72°C and 8°C hold.
PCR products were purified with 0.1 µl Exo Sap-It
plus 4 µl ddH2O and incubated for 30 min at 37°C, followed by deactivation for 15 min at 80°C.
The primers used for the cycle sequencing were
UCytb151F for cyt-b and LT1 for ITS-2. The quantity of
PCR product used for cycle-sequencing ranged from 0.5
to 5.0 µl depending on the concentration estimated by gel
electrophoresis. 0.5 µl BigDye T-Mix (ABI, Applied Biosystems), 2.25 µl BigDye buffer (5x), 0.5 µl primer
(10pmol), and sterile H2O were added to a total volume of
10 µl. The following temperature profile was used: 25 cycles of 96°C for 10 s, 50°C for 5 s, 60°C for 4 min and 8°C
hold. The products were purified by adding 1 µl 3M
NaAc (pH 4.6) and 25 µl EtOH (100%), centrifuging at
13 000 g for 15 min, inverting the tubes on a paper towel
and washing with 200 µl 70% EtOH. After removing the
EtOH the pellets were dried for 10 min at 50°C. Samples
were sequenced on an ABI 3130 xl (Applied Biosystems).
1
Data analysis
For maximum-likelihood analyses, including bootstrap
support, we used raxmlGUI 0.9 beta 2 (RAxML) (Silvestro
& Michalak 2010, Stamatakis et al. 2005). The settings
were “ML+thorough bootstrap” with 100 (replicate) runs
and 1000 (bootstrap) repetitions.
Stagnicola montenegrinus in Bulgaria
167
Maximum-parsimony (MP) trees were reconstructed
using PAUP (version 4.0b10; Swofford 2002; settings:
gapmode=NewState, addseq=closest). For presentation of
MP results, one of the best trees was chosen to be able to
illustrate branch lengths (one showing the same overall
topology as the majority rule consensus tree was chosen).
Genetic distances of the cyt-b were calculated using
MEGA version 4 (Tamura et al. 2007).
Results
Habitat and associated freshwater molluscs
S. montenegrinus occurs in pools on the northern
banks of Maritza River in Plovdiv city fed by high
waters of the main river and a small tributary
coming from north. The substrate is sand and
mud, water is running very slow or standing depending on the water levels of the river Maritza.
Bank vegetation is dominated by Salix spp., Typha
spp., Phragmites australis (Cavanilles, 1799) Trinius
ex Steudel, 1840, and water plants by Ceratophyllum demersum Linnaeus, 1753 and Elodea canadensis
Michaux, 1803. Other molluscs found in the locality are: Unio pictorum (Linnaeus, 1758), Planorbis
planorbis (Linnaeus, 1758), Physella acuta (Draparnaud, 1805), Radix auricularia (Linnaeus, 1758),
Valvata piscinalis (O. F. Müller, 1774), Lymnaea
stagnalis (Linnaeus, 1758), Planorbarius corneus
(Linnaeus, 1758), Galba truncatula (O. F. Müller,
1774) and Anisus vortex (Linnaeus, 1758).
Molecular genetics
Distance analyses. Genetic distances (p-distance)
from pair-wise comparisons of cyt-b sequences
(fragment of 329 bp) are shown in Table 2. Distances between species of different families
(Planorbidae, Physidae and Lymnaeidae) (outgroup comparison) ranged between 31.2% and
25.5%. Differences between different genera
within the family Lymnaeidae ranged from 26.4%
to 15.1%. Among the four Stagnicola species analysed, the values are between 19.4% and 14.7%.
The highest difference between S. montenegrinus
and the other three Stagnicola species is the difference to S. palustris (19.1%). The difference to S. corvus and S. fuscus are 17.5% and 14.7% respectively.
The values of the three analysed Radix species
ranged between 17.5% and 13.0%.
Molecular phylogeny. The maximum-parsimony
(MP) tree of the cyt-b sequences is illustrated in
Fig. 2 (tree length = 532, consistency index =
0.5602, retention index = 0.8769).
It shows low or very low support on basal
branches. Omphiscola glabra is paraphyletic with
respect to the other genera of Lymnaeidae analysed in this paper. Galba truncatula is paraphyletic
with respect to Radix auricularia, R. labiata, and R.
balthica. In contrast the clades of the species have
full bootstrap support. Within analysed representatives of the genus Stagnicola, S. montenegrinus
groups sister to S. fuscus with low support (66%)
whereas S. palustris groups sister to S. corvus
(bootstrap support 71%).
The RAxML tree of the cyt-b sequences (not
shown) shows similar results. The basal branches
have low or very low support. This poor support
is underlined by two polytomies: one between the
S. fuscus
0.175
0.177
0.160
0.211
0.224
0.237
0.230
0.147
0.191
0.219
0.242
0.238
0.263
0.194
0.187
0.247
0.216
0.240
0.227
0.264 0.226
0.261 0.220 0.130
0.273 0.249 0.175 0.149
R. auricularia
S.
montenegrinus
0.214
0.237
0.214
0.258
0.218
0.192
0.207
0.209
R. balthiac
S. corvus
0.202
0.230
0.241
0.232
0.259
0.224
0.151
0.158
0.161
R. labiata
O. glabra
0.263
0.255
0.278
0.298
0.292
0.328
0.278
0.259
0.255
0.259
L. stagnalis
G. truncatula
0.312
0.294
0.275
0.306
0.308
0.305
0.315
0.284
0.284
0.308
0.298
S. palustris
A. hypnorum
Planorbarius corneus
Aplexa hypnorum
Galba truncatula
Omphiscola glabra
Stagnicola corvus
Stagnicola montenegrinus
Stagnicola fuscus
Stagnicola palustris
Lymnaea stagnalis
Radix labiata
Radix balthica
Radix auricularia
P. corneus
Table 2. Evolutionary distances (p-distance) of the cyt-b gene fragment (329 bp)
calculated using MEGA version 4 (Tamura et al. 2007).
168
Figure 2. Hypothesis of the phylogenetic relationships of
S. montenegrinus based on one of the 71 best maximumparsimony trees of the sequenced fragment of the mitochondrial marker cyt-b (329 bp; tree length = 532, consistency index = 0.5602, retention index = 0.8769).
Branch lengths are proportional to the number of substitutions and the overall topology corresponds to that
of the strict consensus tree. Bootstrap support values
above 50% are reported below nodes.
Radix-Galba cluster and the other genera of Lymnaeidae analysed, and the other within the RadixGalba group. S. montenegrinus groups sister to S.
fuscus with low support (67%) too. S. palustris is
the sister group to S. corvus (71%). The clades of all
species have high bootstrap support.
The maximum-parsimony (MP) tree of the nuclear marker ITS-2 (tree length = 1767, consistency
index = 0.8087, retention index = 0.9650) (Fig. 3) is
well-supported within the Lymnaeidae. Most of
the basal branches have full bootstrap support.
The tree shows the analysed representatives of the
genus Radix as sister group to the other studied
genera of Lymnaeidae. Within the latter G. truncatula groups sister to O. glabra, L. stagnalis and the
Schniebs, K. et al.
Figure 3. Hypothesis of the phylogenetic relationships of
S. montenegrinus based on one of the 9 best maximumparsimony trees of the nuclear marker ITS-2 (tree length
= 1767, consistency index = 0.8087, retention index =
0.9650). Branch lengths are proportional to the number
of substitutions and the overall topology corresponds to
that of the strict consensus tree. Bootstrap support values above 50% are reported below nodes.
Stagnicola species analysed. S. palustris groups sister to S. fuscus, S. corvus and S. montenegrinus. On
the other hand, although not well supported
(59%), S. fuscus groups as the sister group to a
cluster consisting of S. corvus and S. montenegrinus
that has full bootstrap support.
The RAxML tree of the nuclear marker ITS-2 (not
shown) shows G. truncatula as sister group to the
other Lymnaeidae analysed. The three Radix
Stagnicola montenegrinus in Bulgaria
169
species group sister to the genera Stagnicola, Omphiscola, and Lymnaea. In contrast to the MP tree
there is no resolution within the genera Stagnicola,
Omphiscola, and Lymnaea. S. montenegrinus forms a
cluster together with S. corvus with bootstrap support of 95%. S. palustris groups sister to S. fuscus
with bootstrap support of 66%.
Morphology
Two of the three specimens from the Maritza
River floodplain have higher and wider shells
(Table 3) than the specimens from Skadar Lake
(shell height 10.6-21.5 mm, shell width 4.4-9 mm)
(Glöer & Pešić 2009). The aperture is also a little
higher than the spire, as defined as a differential
characteristic between S. montenegrinus and S. corvus (Glöer & Pešić 2009). The mantle pigmentation
is bluish black and lacks white spots as shown in
Glöer & Pešić (2009, p. 55, Fig.2) for S. montenegrinus from Skadar Lake. The anatomy is very similar
to that of the specimens from Montenegro. The
prostate contains 3 folds and the bursa duct is also
thickened at the distal end by entering the vagina
(Fig. 4).
Table 3. Shell measurements of S. montenegrinus from Maritza River in Plovdiv city.
Shell height
Shell width
Aperture height
SNSD Moll S2313
26.7 mm
10.3 mm
14.3 mm
SNSD Moll S2314
25.0 mm
10.3 mm
14.1 mm
SNSD Moll S2315
21.0 mm
9.6 mm
11.9 mm
Figure 4. Stagnicola montenegrinus from Maritza River floodplain (Bulgaria). –
1: shell of SNSD Moll S2313; 2: shell of SNSD Moll S2314; 3: mantle pigmentation of SNSD Moll S2315; 4: cross-section through prostate gland SNSD
Moll S2313; 5: male copulatory organ SNSD Moll S2313; 6: female sex tract.
bc = bursa copulatrix, bd = bursa duct, cp = corpus pyriforme, pht = phallotheca, pr = prostate, = prp = praeputium, pvd = provaginal duct, vd = vas
deferens.
170
Discussion
The molecular distances of 17.5% between S. montenegrinus and S. corvus, 14.7% between S. montenegrinus and S. fuscus, and 19.1% between S. montenegrinus and S. palustris in the cyt-b fragment
(about 329 bp) (Table 2) show similar values like
the distances between S. palustris and S. fuscus as
well as S. corvus and S. fuscus (19.4% and 17.7% respectively). The lowest value of 14.7% between S.
montenegrinus and S. fuscus is even higher than the
distance between the Radix species R. balthica and
R. labiata (13.5%) as well as the distances between
R. balthica and R. lagotis (Schrank, 1803) (9.0%), between R. ampla (Hartmann, 1821) and R. lagotis
(9.2%) (Schniebs et al. 2011) or between Aenigmomphiscola europaea Kruglov and Starobogatov,
1981 and Ae. kazakhstanica Kruglov and Starobogatov, 1981 (9.0%) (Vinarski et al. 2011). Similar to
other authors (e.g. Abramson 2009), we interpret
the existing differences between the values of the
molecular distances between species clearly distinguishable by morphological characteristics, as a
consequence of different evolutionary speeds for
the cyt-b gene.
The results of our molecular genetic analyses
of the nuclear marker ITS-2 and the mitochondrial
marker, the cyt-b fragment (329 bp) (Figs 2,3), are
inconsistent and not congruent like in studies of
Unionidae using the nuclear ribosomal internal
transcribed spacer region in comparison to the mitochondrial genes 16S and COI (Källersjö et al.
2005). Whereas there is a significant difference in
gene distances in the cyt-b fragment (about 329
bp) between all Stagnicola species analysed (Table
2) and S. montenegrinus groups sister to S. fuscus
and S. corvus groups sister to S. palustris using this
gene (both with only medium support of 66% and
71% respectively), the nuclear marker ITS-2 shows
no sequence differences between the three specimens of S. corvus from Germany (collection No.
SNSD Moll 49821, 49872 and 49872) and the
specimens of S. montenegrinus from Skadar Lake
and Bulgaria (Fig. 3). The result is the same if sequences of S. turricula from GenBank as well as
own sequences from other Palaearctic Stagnicola
species are included in the calculation (unpublished data).
Although there is no difference between S.
corvus and S. montenegrinus in nuclear marker ITS2 sequences we think that the parsimony tree (Fig.
3) reflects the most realistic relationships between
the genera Omphiscola, Lymnaea, and Stagnicola, be-
Schniebs, K. et al.
cause own studies of the 18S rRNA gene (Vinarski
et al. 2011) and analyses of Bargues & Mas-Coma
(1997) as well as studies based on 16S, ITS-1 and
ITS-2 spacers of other authors (Correa et al. 2010)
have shown that these three genera are very
closely related. Of the Stagnicola species analysed
from Bulgaria, S. palustris is the only one with one
prostate fold and it groups sister to the species
with two and more folds in the ITS-2 parsimony
tree. S. fuscus with two prostate folds groups sister
to S. montenegrinus and S. corvus with three and
more folds. So the ITS-2 tree (Fig. 3) appears also
to reflect meaningful relations between the analysed species of Stagnicola. Anyway the clusters of
the ITS-2 (Fig. 3) appear to reflect the subdivision
into genera we used following the current European checklists (Falkner et al. 2001, Bank 2011).
We thus have more confidence in this phylogenetic hypothesis based on the nuclear marker,
than in the one based on the mitochondrial marker
cyt-b.
From anatomical differences important for differentiation of European Stagnicola species, as
number of prostate folds and diameter of the
bursa duct at the distal part, as well as from our
molecular genetic analyses we conclude that S.
montenegrinus is a species closely related to S. corvus. Its occurrence is not limited to the Skadar
Lake region and needs further investigation.
Acknowledgements. We would like to express our
thanks to Prof. Dr. Uwe Fritz (SNSD) for financing the
greatest part of the molecular analyses, Anke Müller
(SNSD) for some sequences and the instruction of K.S. in
lab work, as well as Prof. Dr. Vladimir Pešic (University
of Montenegro), Michael Korn (University of Konstanz,
Limnological Institute), R. Diercking (Hamburg), Dr.
André Reimann (SNSD), Maxim V. Vinarski and Alfried
V. Karimov (Omsk State Pedagogical University),
Christoph Oberer (Natural History Museum Basel),
Robert Haldemann (Strausberg), Dr. Nicole SchröderRogalla (Munich), Susanne Thiel (Munich), Andrea Pohl
(Dresden), Gudrun Rutsch (Dresden) and Christa
Schniebs (Oelsnitz) for the material collected and
provided. We also thank the biologist Stanislava
Vassileva (University of Plovdiv) who took the picture of
the habitat. Last but not least we also thank the reviewers
for improvements to the manuscript: Dr. Vitaliy
Anistratenko (Institute of Zoology NAS of Ukraine, Kiev)
and Dr. Barna Páll-Gergely (Department of General and
Applied Ecology, University of Pécs, Hungary).
Stagnicola montenegrinus in Bulgaria
References
Abramson, N.I. (2009): Molecular markers, phylogeography and
search for the criteria for delimiting species. Proceedings of the
Zoological Institute of the Russian Academy of Sciences
313(Supplement 1): 185-198. [In Russian]
Almeyda-Artigas, R.J., Bargues, M.D., Mas-Coma, S. (2000): ITS-2
rDNA sequencing of Gnathostoma species (Nematoda) and
elucidation of the species causing human gnathostomiasis in the
Americas. Journal of Parasitology 86(3): 537-544.
Angelov, A.M. (2000): Mollusca (Gastropoda et Bivalvia) aquae
dulcis. Catalogus Faunae Bulgaricae 4. Pensoft & Backhuys
Publishers, Sofia, Leiden.
Bank, R. (2011): Fauna Europaea project. Systematical and
distributional checklist of species-group taxa of continental
Mollusca of Europe. <www.faunaeur.org. Last update 27
January 2011, version 2.4.>
Bargues, M.D., Mas-Coma, S. (1997): Phylogenetic analyses of
Lymnaeid snails based on 18S rDNA sequences. Molecular
Biology and Evolution 14(5): 569-577.
Bargues, M.D., Vigo, M., Horak, P. Dvorak, J., Patzner, R.A.,
Pointier, J.P., Jackiewicz, M., Meier-Brook, C., Mas-Coma, S.
(2001): European Lymnaeidae (Mollusca: Gastropoda),
intermediate hosts of trematodiases, based on nuclear ribosomal
DNA ITS-2 sequences. Infection, Genetics and Evolution 1(2):
85-107.
Correa, A.C., Escobar, J.S., Durand, P., Renaud, F., David, P., Jarne,
P., Pointier, J.P., Hurtrez-Boussès, S. (2010): Bridging gaps in the
molecular phylogeny of the Lymnaeidae (Gastropoda:
Pulmonata), vectors of Fascioliasis. BMC Evolutionary Biology
10: 381.
Falkner, G., Bank, R.A., Proschwitz, T. von (2001): Check-list of the
non-marine molluscan species-group taxa of the states of
Northern, Atlantic and Central Europe (CLECOM I). Heldia 4:
1-76.
Glöer, P., Pešić, V. (2009): Stagnicola montenegrinus n. sp., a new
species of Montenegro (Gastropoda: Lymnaeidae). Mollusca
27(1): 53-56.
Gustincich, S., Manfioletti, G., del Sal, G., Schneider, C., Carninci, P.
(1991): A fast method for high-quality genomic DNA extraction
from whole human blood. Biotechniques 11(3): 298-302.
171
Hubenov, Z. (2007): Fauna and Zoogeography of Marine,
Freshwater, and Terrestrial Mollusks (Mollusca) in Bulgaria. In:
Fet, V., Popov, A. (eds), Biogeography and Ecology of Bulgaria.
Monographiae Biologicae 82: 141-198.
Källersjö, M., von Proschwitz, T., Lundberg, S., Eldenäs, P., Erséus,
C. (2005): Evaluation of ITS rDNA as a complement to
mitochondrial gene sequences for phylogenetic studies in
freshwater mussels: an example using Unionidae from northwestern Europe. Zoologica Scripta 34(4): 415-424.
Merritt, T.J.S., Shi, L., Chase, M.C., Rex, M.A., Etter, R.J., Quattro,
J.M. (1998): Universal cytochrome b primers facilitate
intraspecific studies in molluscan taxa. Molecular Marine
Biology and Biotechnology 7(1): 7-11.
Schniebs, K, Glöer, P., Vinarski, M.V., Hundsdoerfer, A.K. (2011):
Intraspecific morphological an genetic variability in Radix
balthica (Linnaeus, 1758) (Gastropoda: Basommatophora:
Lymnaeidae) with morphological comparison to other European
Radix species. Journal of Conchology 40(6): 657-678.
Silvestro, D., Michalak, I. (2010): RAXMLGUI: a graphical front-end
for RAxML. <http://sourceforge.net/projects/raxmlgui/>
Stamatakis, A., Ludwig, T., Meier, H. (2005): RAxML-III: a fast
program for maximum likelihood-based inference of large
phylogenetic trees. Bioinformatics 21(4): 456-463.
Swofford, D.L. (2002): PAUP* - Phylogenetic analysis using
parsimony (*and other methods). Ver. 4. Sinauer Associates Inc.
Publishers, Sunderland.
Tamura, K., Dudley, J., Nei, M., Kumar, S. (2007): MEGA4:
Molecular Evolutionary Genetics Analysis (MEGA) software
version 4.0. Molecular Biology and Evolution 24: 1596-1599.
Vinarski, M.V., Schniebs, K., Glöer, P., Hundsdoerfer, A.K. (2011):
The taxonomic status and phylogenetic relationships of the
genus Aenigmomphiscola Kruglov and Starobogatov, 1981
(Gastropoda: Pulmonata: Lymnaeidae). Journal of Natural
History 45(33-34): 2049-2068.