Dead Images
Facing the history, ethics, and politics of
European skull collections
The exhibition
Part of the TRACES project, DEAD IMAGES is an artistic exploration
of the complex and contentious legacy of collections of human
skulls that held by public institutions in Europe. These assemblages
of the remains of the dead were created during the 19th and early
20th centuries, when scientists sought to elaborate ideas of human
difference through the comparative study of crania. Some skulls
were taken close to home, others were looted from battlefield sites
or the graves of indigenous peoples, taken without consent and in
violation of local beliefs concerning the sanctity of the dead and the
reverence for ancestors.
We live with this legacy. It resides in our cities. Often it is hidden
but it is still with us. The DEAD IMAGES exhibition, created by Tal
Adler in collaboration with a team of fellow artists, historians,
bioarchaeologists and anthropologists, brings this legacy to light
by exhibiting a life-sized 30 meter photograph of part of one such
collection, a gathering of more than 8,000 skulls which resides on
shelves along a corridor in the Natural History Museum of Vienna.
In exhibiting this photograph, this exhibition asks questions of
ourselves, our ambivalent curiosity and our own desire to see that
which is withheld. Who are we to show such a photograph and to
gaze upon the bones of others as an artistic or scientific spectacle?
We explore these questions through a series of filmed works, in
which different people speak to this history, their own beliefs and
feelings and whether or not we should display this photograph.
The choice to see the photograph, finally, rests with the visitor and
in making a choice visitors are asked to reflect upon this history,
the work of bringing this history to light, the ethics and politics of
making such a display visible and the role that descendants, curators,
scientists, artists and the public may play in reimagining a place and
purpose for these remains of once-living people.
The conference
Whether considered at an individual or population level, collections
of human remains contain multiple biographies that encompass
the biological and historical and the personal. Narratives generated
from these different biographies – by descendants, archaeologists,
anthropologists, artists, curators and historians – are often
represented as has having conflicting or opposing purposes, built on
contradictory principles and values.
Artistic engagements with these remains, such as DEAD IMAGES,
may provide the opportunity to confront, appraise and mediate these
tensions by creating unsettling spaces of encounter that transcend
the limitations of history and science. In doing so they invite the
possibility of an open and reflexive appreciation of other perspectives
on this challenging heritage.
This meeting brings together diverse reflections on encounters with
collections of human remains, to critically explore the histories,
including histories of violence and dispossession, which are disclosed
in these diasporic gatherings of bones and the problematic of their
ongoing dwelling within the public sphere.
Throughout the day of the Friday, the 29th of June, our invited
speakers will discuss these issues, presenting papers, pieces,
provocations and polemics which emerge from upon their own
engagements with the complex legacy of these collections and the
lessons that may be learned from these engagements. Time will be
given for discussion and collaborative reflection.
TRACES is a three-year project funded in 2016 by the European
Commission as part of the Horizon 2020 Research and Innovation
Programme and focusing on challenges and opportunities raised
when transmitting contentious cultural heritages in contemporary
Europe. The Project deploys innovative research practices based on
an artistic/ethnographic approach, and involves a multi-disciplinary
team that brings together established and emerging scholars,
artists, and cultural workers, in order to develop a rigorous, creative
investigation on a range of contentious cultural heritages. To
achieve this objective, TRACES has initiated a series of art-based
action researches, of which DEAD IMAGES is one, supported
and complemented by theoretical investigations with the aim
to eventually identify new directions for cultural institutions and
museums to effectively transmit contentious cultural heritage and
contribute productively to evolving European identities. For more
information see: http://www.tracesproject.eu/.
Dead Images
Exhibition Opening and Conference Programme
11.45am-12.45pm Session 3
Christine Borland: From Life 1994 to Circles of Focus 2016 – The
development of art works which reconsider the anonymous
subjects of medical and anatomical research and display
Layla Renshaw: Bones as wounds: the role of human remains in
memory campaigns
12.45-2.00pm Lunch break
Thursday, 28th of June, 2018 (exhibition opening and reception)
6.30pm Venue opens
6.45pm Welcome and introduction
7.00-7.45pm Tal Adler and Charlotte Roberts in conversation,
moderated by Sam Alberti
7.45-9.00pm Reception and viewing of DEAD IMAGES
9.30pm Venue closes
2.00-3.00pm Session 4
Konradin Kunze: Skull X – too close to the bone?
Joan Smith: The colour of skulls: rethinking the Edinburgh skull
collection
3.00-4.00pm Session 5
Anna Szöke: The absence of the gift - discussing human remains
through the politics of gift-giving
Te Herekiekie Herewini and June Jones: Respecting the ancestors
Friday, 29th of June, 2018 (Dead Images conference)
8.45am Venue opens
9.00am Welcome
9.15-10.15am Session 1
Maria Teschler-Nicola: Euphoric beginning – dysphoric present?
Collection history, experiences, and challenges with the
repatriation of human remains (temporarily) kept at the Natural
History Museum Vienna
Sabine Eggers: From the peripheries to the core: collaboration
today to heal wounds from the past?
10.15-11.15am Session 2
Elise Smith: Craniologists and cranial collections in Victorian racial
science
Rebecca Redfern: Sharing the lives of past Londoners: human
remains curated by the Museum of London
11.15-11.45am Coffee, tea and biscuits
4.00-4.30pm Coffee, tea and tray bakes
4.30-6.00pm Session 6
Paul Turnbull: The Indigenous dead in memory, history and
reconciliation
Elizabeth James-Perry: Remembering key tenets of Maushop’s
Beach
James Riding In: A simple matter of justice and human rights:
American Indian quests for repatriation and burial rights
6.00-6.15pm Final remarks and close
6.30pm Venue closes
Saturday, 30th of June, 2018
10.30-11.45am Lecture performance of “Skull X” (“Schädel X”) by
Flinn Works, in the Red Lecture Theatre, Summerhall (1 Summerhall
Place). (The audience for this performance is limited to 50, if you are
interested in attending, please speak to John Harries (j.harries@ed.ac.uk))
Dead Images
Exhibition opening and discussion
Conference abstracts
On the evening of Thursday, June the 28th, we will open the
DEAD IMAGES exhibition with a wine reception and viewing.
This will be preceded by a conversation between Tal Adler, artist
and creator of the panorama, and Charlotte Roberts, professor of
bioarchaeology at Durham University, moderated by Sam Alberti
of National Museums Scotland. The discussion will consider the
ethics and politics of our engagements with the remains of the
dead and the possibility that art-science collaborations may offer
a critical space for such considerations. Charlotte and Tal will
explore the complexities and potential contentiousness of using
human remains for a variety of purposes, including education of
people beyond academia, and the question of ownership of these
legacy collections. They will also discuss the wider collections
of human remains curated in museums across the world. In so
doing, they will consider the need to “face up” to this legacy that
humans have created, address the question of who “owns” the
dead in these collections and whether we could do better in how
human remains are ethically, sensitively and respectfully treated
in the future.
Christine Borland
From Life 1994 to Circles of Focus 2016: The development of art
works which reconsider the anonymous subjects of medical and
anatomical research and display.
In Christine Borland’s 1994 exhibition From Life the starting point
was a human skeleton purchased from a British company, which
imported and supplied real bone materials for medical training
purposes. The exhibition traced the artist’s attempts to reconstruct
an identity for the skeleton with the help of osteologists, forensic
scientists and facial reconstruction experts. The artist will discuss
this and successive works including the project Cast From Nature; a
painstaking live casting procedure and subsequent exhibition which
took as its subject an anonymous, flayed, 19th century anatomical
life cast stored in the basement of Edinburgh Medical School for
decades. Circles of Focus is a recent collaborative project with artist
Brody Condon (Berlin): it is an ambitious, performative and on-going
project (CCA Glasgow 2015 & Stroom Den Haag 2016) in which
Borland and Condon work with individuals who are signed up to, or
considering registering for, Anatomical Bequest, to interrogate the
potential of body donation for artistic as well as scientific research.
Sabine Eggers
From the peripheries to the core: Collaboration today to heal
wounds from the past?
Collections of human remains are a unique record of life and death
in the past. They contain marks of identities and ways of life, being
critical to the understanding of our biocultural (micro-) evolution.
Their way into public institutions, in contrast, sheds light on the more
recent history, on colonialism, the interactions between different
peoples, political hierarchies and (scientific) racism, resulting in
long-lasting socio-cultural wounds. Ethical concerns as to meaning,
purposes and spiritual significance of these collections are cultural
constructs intertwined with group identities and changing through
time and space and so need to be carefully addressed.
In this context, I first focus on how human remains shaped my own
trajectory. Then, I narrate my encounters with local communities,
the general public and children from the periphery of South America
and only recently in Europe regarding exposition, scientific analyses
and destiny of human remains. Next, I discuss my personal views
and wishes on how to approach ethical constraints associated with
specific parts of collections of human remains. Finally, I expose
the concerns and considerations which we, as curators of the
osteological collection at the Natural History Museum in Vienna, take
into account when dealing with requests for provenance research
and repatriation. Our work towards creating forms of “respectful
collaboration” will be open for discussion.
Te Herekiekie Herewini and June Jones
Respecting the ancestors
Māori and Moriori ancestral remains began leaving their homelands
for international destinations from the time Captain Cook’s
Endeavour arrived in Aotearoa New Zealand in 1769. Te Papa’s
research indicates over 1000 ancestral remains were collected,
traded and exported from this time. Despite the separation of
distance and time, these ancestors continue to have great cultural
connection to their homeland and their respective communities of
origin. We will present an indigenous-led approach to repatriation,
in particular highlighting the deep spiritual and cultural significance
ancestral remains continue to have for Māori and Moriori, as well as
presenting a bi-cultural approach to their care while they are housed
temporarily in Te Papa’s sacred repository (Wāhi Tapu), before they
are reunited with their communities of origin.
Institutions who hold collections of ancient human remains are in
positions of power with regard to indigenous requests for dialogue.
Colonial attitudes which led to the collection of the ancestral human
remains many years ago are often in play when institutions refuse
requests for repatriation. The vast majority of countries who hold
collections of indigenous human remains are signatories to the
United Nations Declaration of the Rights of Indigenous People (2008)
which provides for dialogue and repatriation. This presentation
will discuss why we believe there is a moral obligation to engage
in dialogue and why indigenous voices ought to play a larger role
in framing questions about how their ancestors are treated until
repatriation takes place.
Elizabeth James-Perry
Remembering key tenets of Maushop’s Beach
A central aspect of Indigenous Wampanoag belief is the importance
of caring for the elders and ancestors. As First Contact people, the
Eastern Nations of Turtle Island have experienced disruption due to
sickness, enslavement, and displacement historically, and the looting
of our burial grounds for goods, furs and bodies. This colonizing
culture of interruption and appropriation is something tribal people
have had to face for hundreds of years. The passage of NAGPRA
in the United States now allows tribes the physical reclamation
of ancestral human remains that is just one aspect of the healing
that needs to take place as we come to terms with the betrayal,
destruction, loss that were an intentional suspension of the natural
laws we hold most important.
Konradin Kunze
Skull X – Too close to the bone?
With “Skull X” (Schädel X) the Berlin based theatre company Flinn
Works turned the sensitive subject of colonial skull collections into a
lecture-performance.
Konradin Kunze will talk about his research in Germany and Tanzania,
the challenges of dealing with this subject on stage, and audience
reactions. Can a skull re-transform from a scientific object into a
human subject? How much fiction can be added to the facts? Can
one perform racist “scientific” practises on stage without reproducing
racism? Can a white actor talk about a “black” skull? Is there an ethic
difference between a real skull and an artificial one? Is it too close to
the bone?
In addition, Konradin will give an insight in his search for the skull of
chief Meli from Old Moshi, Tanzania, and how German institutions
reacted to his requests. To this day nobody was able to find Meli’s
skull, so Flinn Works offered the Old Moshi community something
else.
Rebecca Redfern
Sharing the lives of past Londoners: Human remains curated by
the Museum of London
In London everyone is different, and that means anyone can fit in.’ –
Paddington Bear
The Museum of London curates the remains of over 20,000
individuals, all of whom have been encountered through
archaeological excavation or the whim of the River Thames.
Paddington’s observation is very apt for my work as the curator for
these people, and in this talk I will share the myriad and increasingly
diverse ways in which these human remains make a significant and
unique contribution to the Museum’s activities and outputs, and also
explore the ethical and practical issues which arise from these often
contrasting situations.
Layla Renshaw
Bones as wounds: The role of human remains in memory
campaigns
This contribution is grounded in the author’s experience of postconflict and mass grave investigations, both as an archaeologist
and forensic practitioner, and as an ethnographer recording the
reflections and memories of relatives of the dead. This paper focuses
on the dead and missing from periods of war and repression, a
category that includes the imagined remains of the missing, those
still lying in mass graves, and those bodies recovered and formally
buried in war cemeteries. The multiple ways in which human remains
serve to galvanise and structure confrontations with the traumatic
past will be explored. The recovery of human remains from conflict
enable descendant communities to articulate their rights and
ownership over the past, and to challenge dominant narratives of
those conflicts.
Human remains, and the forensic techniques used to recover them,
have powerful affordances, creating new representations of the past,
and enabling the production of complex images. The role of human
remains as a focus for new forms of commemoration, inspiring and
articulating new emotional and imaginative connections to the past,
will also be addressed. These different properties of the bodies of war
dead present possible points of commonality or comparison with
the affordances of those human remains in museums and scientific
collections.
James Riding In
A simple matter of justice and human rights: American Indian
quests for repatriation and burial rights
American Indians have been struggling for decades in the national
and international arenas to stop abuses committed against their dead
in the name of science and to repatriate human remains ancestral
to them for a proper and lasting burial. To them, it is a simple matter
of justice and human rights. This conflict pitting Indigenous peoples
and their allies against archaeologists, physical anthropologists,
museum curators, lawmakers, and others is a global phenomenon.
Members of the Pawnee Nation of Oklahoma, including this
presenter, have been at the forefront of this movement.
My presentation will address major accomplishments American
Indians of the United States have made in gaining legislation that
seeks to ensure the repatriation of human remains, funerary objects,
objects of cultural patrimony, and sacred objects belonging to them
while focusing primarily on human rights matters and systemic
racism in the sciences and museums. It considers why institutions
in Europe and elsewhere must take proactive measures to end their
involvement in the mistreatment of Indian human remains and to
adopt meaningful repatriation policies and practices.
Elise Smith
Craniologists and cranial collections in Victorian racial science
In the mid-nineteenth century, craniometry—the measurement
of human skulls—emerged as the dominant expression of racial
science. Vast collections of human crania were assembled to
enable this research, and within Britain over 20,000 skulls were
gathered by museums, medical schools, and private collectors.
This paper will consider the formation of craniological collections
through the example of one large private collection, that of Joseph
Barnard Davis (later bought by the Royal College of Surgeons),
and of one University collection, acquired by Alexander Macalister
for the Anatomy Department of the University of Cambridge. It
will particularly examine the personalities of Davis and Macalister
in determining how the human remains in their collections were
organised, displayed, and interpreted as specimens. They also
reveal the singular status of human skulls as specimens for research.
As I shall argue, the politics of collection and display challenged
the supposed objectivity of racial science. Rather than defining
characteristic traits, researchers were often drawn to the life
stories of specimens—and in so doing, inadvertently emphasised
the humanity of their subjects. The material culture of craniology
therefore adds a further dimension to our understanding of Victorian
racial science.
Joan Smith
The colour of skulls: Rethinking the Edinburgh skull collection
Encountering the collection of skulls housed in a specially designed
room in the University of Edinburgh’s Medical School for the first
time can be an overwhelming experience. Organised by country of
origin, the rows of skulls surround you in the almost cubic space.
A small spiral stair allows access to the balcony level, where British
Islanders are the first to meet your gaze.
As is the case with most collections like this, many of the skulls were
gathered for what was considered to be the scientific purpose of
investigation into racial differences; however, the repetition of form
in the row upon row of skulls points more to the similarities and
connections between peoples; the subtle differences evidence the
variations from person to person rather than from race to race.
The familiar staring, grinning form of the human skull is so
ubiquitous, so familiar, so imbued with existing references, so
over-used in so many ways that it is almost impossible to find a fresh
artistic approach to the skull as a subject. This presentation describes
an art project which aims to rethink the skull collection by analysing
it using something not often associated with skulls: colour.
Anna Szöke
The absence of the gift: Discussing human remains through the
politics of gift-giving
Inventory Number 5015. The paper box with the handwritten
inventory number lies in the front row of a long glass-faced cabinet
in a hallway at the Natural History Museum Vienna. It sits in between
thousands of human skulls, which are housed at the Anthropology
Department of the museum. The box of Inv.Nr. 5015 is empty. A small
note is placed inside the box, in place of the skull of the individual
which is expected to rest there. It reads: “Im Panzerschrank” (“In the
safe”).
Who is the individual who is labelled “Inv. Nr. 5015”, how did they
become part of this collection and why are they in the safe?
This paper explores the politics of a gift that was made 113 years ago
to the emperor of Austria. It applies the logic of the gift, as discussed
by Marcel Mauss, to this case and others. By doing so, it also invites
thinking through moral and legal aspects of human remains as gifts.
Which political power structures were involved in the action of
giving? What kind of social relationships were created and how have
these relations transformed through time? Finally, it will also question
the gift-giving of human remains, emphasizing their inherent tension
of being subject and object for different sets of people at the same
time.
Maria Teschler-Nicola
Title: Euphoric beginning – dysphoric present? Collection
history, experiences, and challenges with the repatriation of
human remains (temporarily) kept at the Natural History Museum
Vienna
When Anthropology at the NHM Vienna became institutionalised it
was shaped by euphoric efforts to collect, amongst other material,
historic and modern human remains. The maxim of continued
expansion and completion of our natural history repositories and
their associated archives, be it for research or exposition, confronts
us today with an over 130-year-old legacy that poses a multitude
of questions concerning historical acquisition policy, ethical
responsibility, and appropriate handling. The collections, which
must be administered and considered with regard to their scientific
and historical relevance, documentation and value as witnesses,
or other significance, include human relics, which number about
40,000; some of them have a contentious provenience and are the
focus of critical attention and reflection. These discourses came to
the fore in the 1980s when indigenous communities began to make
representations for return of their ancestors’ remains and while
investigating the intended aims of the archivists of National Socialist
times. Thus, it is vital that an awareness of this issue composes
an integral part of today´s scientific and curatorial policy. The
contribution aims to shed light on selected aspects of the collection’s
history, based on the forMuse project, as well as to summarise some
experiences and challenges which arose from repatriation processes
of human relics and the dialog with the indigenous communities
and/or other stakeholders.
Paul Turnbull
The Indigenous dead in memory, history and reconciliation
In this presentation, I will discuss the aims, and some of the more
significant outcomes to date, of the Return, Reconcile, Renew
Project.
The repatriation of the remains of Old People to their community
of origin is an extraordinary Indigenous achievement of the past
40 years. The Return, Reconcile, Renew Project is providing new
knowledge of repatriation, its history and effects. Currently we are
actively undertaking provenance research assisting the repatriation
of the remains of Old People by the Ngarrindjeri nation of South
Australia, the peoples of the Kimberley Region of Western Australia,
and Torres Strait communities. But, importantly, the Project equally
involves community-based research on the effects of repatriation,
and its current and future roles in community development.
While speaking about the Return, Reconcile, Renew Project, I will
also offer some reflections on my encounters with the remains
of Old People in medico-scientific collections over what is now
more than twenty years, and in particular share my thoughts on
how these unexpected and sometimes disturbing experiences have
influenced my thinking about how we can best confront and effect
reconciliation with this very difficult aspect of the colonial past.
Skull X (“Schädel X”): A lecture-performance by
Flinn Works
Thousands of human skulls from all over the world are lying in the
basements of German universities and museums. Many of them stem
from the former colonies. Most of these skulls were unjustly taken
from already buried bodies or from the corpses of killed “insurgents”.
These skulls were brought to Germany as trophies. In institutes of
anthropology, scientists researched and examined the skulls in order
to substantiate theories of race. With Rudolf von Virchow and Felix
von Luschan, Berlin became the centre of the skull collectors.
100 years later, more and more demands are being made for the
respectful handling of these skulls and their restitution to their
descendants. Universities and museums are slowly starting to look
into their basements and at this dark chapter in their history. The first
restitution of skulls to the Herero and Nama people in Namibia in
2011 turned into a diplomatic disaster. Research into the origins of
the skulls is costly and complicated. Rarely can a skull be linked to a
specific individual and questions remain as to whether research on
the skulls is indeed a second debasement of these human remains.
A skull forms the centre of this lecture-performance. Two
biographical stories revolve around it. They lead from Germany to
Tanzania, across archives, consulates and battlefields, from colonial
history to the present and into the skull of each audience member.
With historical documents and sound files, they connect to a bizarre
odyssey between science, politics and theatre.
Concept, Research & Performance: Konradin Kunze; Director: Sophia
Stepf; Sound Design: Andi Otto; Video Design: Jürgen Salzmann;
Technician: Marcello Lussana; Production Management: ehrliche
arbeit - freies Kulturbüro and Helena Tsiflidis; Interviews with:
Mnyaka Sururu Mboro, Isaria Anael Meli, Upendo Moshi & Gerhard
Ziegenfuss.
A Flinn Works Production in coproduction with Sophiensæle Berlin.
Supported by Senatsverwaltung für Kultur und Europa, Fonds
Darstellende Künste e.V., Hessische Ministerium für Wissenschaft und
Kunst and Kulturamt der Stadt Kassel
See: http://flinnworks.de/en/project/sch%C3%A4del-x-skull-x
Biographies
Tal Adler (CARMAH, Humboldt University of Berlin)
Tal Adler is an artist and researcher at the Centre for Anthropological
Research on Heritage and Museums at the Humboldt University
Berlin. For the TRACES project, he developed long term Creative Coproductions between artists, researchers and institutions, for creating
meaningful and sustainable ways to disseminate contentious cultural
heritages.
For over two decades he has been developing methods of
collaborative artistic research for engaging with difficult pasts and
conflicted communities in Israel/Palestine and in Europe. Since 2011,
he has been conducting extensive artistic research on the politics
of memory and display in Austria, publishing and exhibiting artistic
work on difficult heritage at marginal and established museums,
landscapes, sites of commemoration and civil society organizations.
Sam Alberti (National Museums Scotland)
Sam Alberti is Keeper of Science & Technology at National Museums
Scotland, and Honorary Professor in the Centre for Environment,
Heritage and Policy at the University of Stirling. He trained in the
history of science and medicine; after teaching at the University of
Manchester he was Director of Museums and Archives at the Royal
College of Surgeons of England (which includes the Hunterian
Museum). He has worked on exhibitions tackling race; museum
history; anatomy models; and the First World War. His books include
Nature and Culture: Objects, Disciplines and the Manchester
Museum (2009); and (with Elizabeth Hallam) Medical Museums - Past
Present Future (2013).
Christine Borland (Department of Arts, Northumbria University)
Christine Borland is an artist whose work explores our physical
and psychological sense of self in relation to society’s institutions:
science, medicine, museology and academia. By introducing the
imaginary to these arenas, her works engender a new aesthetic
relationship with the subject matter and makes visible people and
practices, usually inaccessible to a general public. Borland was shortlisted for the Turner Prize in 1997; she is currently developing a major
commission for 14-18 NOW and Glasgow Museums (supported by
the Art Fund) reflecting on the centenary of World War I. Borland is a
Professor of Art at Northumbria University.
Sabine Eggers (Department of Anthropology, Natural History
Museum Vienna)
Born to European parents in the former Portuguese colony
Brazil, she studied human biology and received her MSc and PhD
respectively on historical demography and on psychosocial aspects
of genetic counselling from the Universities of Vienna and Sao
Paulo. This cross-cultural biography shaped her interest in cultural
influences on biological features related to health and disease, mainly
in past societies. For 20 years she was a professor at the University
of Sao Paulo teaching medical genetics and human evolution. Since
her research subject and the supervision of MSc and PhD students,
however, focused on bioarchaeology of South American groups, she
also was a curator for Brazilian prehistoric osteological collections.
As curator of the Department of Anthropology at the Natural History
Museum in Vienna since 2017 she has only recently been confronted
directly with formal issues of repatriation.
Te Herekiekie Herewini (Museum of New Zealand / Te Papa
Tongarewa)
Te Herekiekie Herewini is Head of Repatriation at the Museum of
New Zealand Te Papa Tongarewa (Te Papa). His role is to facilitate
the repatriation of Māori and Moriori ancestral remains housed in
overseas institutions. Te Herekiekie undertakes this work with his
team members, supported by the Repatriation Advisory Panel, an
expert group of Māori and Moriori elders who strategically plan,
initiate the formal request to repatriate, negotiate, and physically
uplift the return of the Māori and Moriori remains collected (stolen)
and traded from their homeland and sacred burial places. Since 2003
Te Papa through the Karanga Aotearoa Repatriation Programme
has worked in partnership with numerous international institutions,
including the University of Birmingham, to repatriate over 450 Māori
and Moriori ancestral remains.
Konradin Kunze (writer, director and actor, Berlin)
Konradin Kunze is a freelance writer, director and actor. He holds
a diploma in acting from the Hanover University of Music, Drama
and Media. He acted for several years at Theater Bremen and
Schauspielhaus Hamburg. Since 2011 he collaborates with the Berlin
based theatre and performance company Flinn Works. In the last
few years, Flinn Works has produced several projects dealing with
the German colonial history: Konradin’s solo lecture performance
“Skull X” (“Schädel X”) on human remains and the Tanzanian-German
theatre performance “Maji Maji Flava” on the Maji Maji War. Currently
he is working on “The Skull of Mangi Meli”, a video sculpture and
exhibition on the biography of the anti-colonial fighter chief Meli.
June Jones (School of Medicine, University of Birmingham)
Dr Jones is Senior Lecturer in Biomedical Ethics and Lead on
Religious and Cultural Diversity at the University of Birmingham.
She leads the repatriation programme of ancient human remains
for the University. She has collaborated on three repatriations: to
return ancestors to the Salinan Tribe of Native Americans, Aboriginal
Australian ancestors to the Australian Government’s Advisory
Committee for Indigenous Repatriation and Māori ancestors to Te
Papa Tongarewa, New Zealand. She is also Head of the University
of Birmingham Unit of the UNESCO Chair in Bioethics. Her work
centres on the moral obligation of holding institutions to work
collaboratively with indigenous groups to ensure that their claims are
treated honourably and that the desire of ancestors to return home
to their final resting place is paramount in negotiations.
Elizabeth James-Perry (Senior Cultural Resource Monitor within
the Aquinnah Tribal Historic Preservation Office)
Elizabeth James-Perry is a citizen of the Wampanoag Tribe of Gay
Head -Aquinnah, located by the richly coloured clay cliffs of Noepe
(Martha’s Vineyard). As a member of a Nation that has long lived on
and harvested the sea, Elizabeth’s is a perspective that combines
art, genealogy, Native storytelling and traditional environmental
knowledge in her ways of relating to coastal North Atlantic life.
Elizabeth’s work has received national recognition, and in 2014 she
was awarded the Traditional Arts Fellowship from the Massachusetts
Cultural Council. She has worked for the last ten years in the
Aquinnah Tribal Historic Preservation Office, serves as the federal
Tribal Co-Lead of the Northeast Regional Ocean Planning Body,
and consults on National Park Service Battlefield Grant projects.
Elizabeth holds a degree in Marine Science and resides in Dartmouth,
Massachusetts.
Rebecca Redfern (Human Osteology, Museum of London)
Dr Redfern has been curator of osteology at the Museum of London
since 2008, having previously worked at The British Museum and
Museum of London Archaeology. Rebecca has delivered several
exhibitions concerned with human remains, including ‘Skeletons:
Our Buried Bones’ with the Wellcome Collection; her current
work involves using human remains in school workshops, and
thinking about how the lives of past Londoners can be shared
in the Museum’s new venue. Rebecca’s research focuses on
bioarchaeology, and the ethics and practice of curating and
researching human remains. She has published extensively on these
topics, most recently in World Archaeology.
Layla Renshaw (Applied and Human Sciences, Kingston University
London)
Dr Layla Renshaw is an Associate Professor of Forensic Science at
Kingston University where she teaches forensic archaeology and
anthropology. She has worked as an assistant archaeologist to the
UN’s International Criminal Tribunal in Kosovo and has conducted
extensive fieldwork in Spain. She is the author of Exhuming Loss:
Memory, Materiality and Mass Graves of the Spanish Civil War. Her
research interests include the relationship between human remains
and memory, and the public perception of forensics. Her recent
work concerns the recovery of war dead from post-colonial contexts
and she is writing a book on the identification of ANZAC soldiers on
the Western Front, exploring the link between genetic testing and
memory.
James Riding In (American Indian Studies, Arizona State
University)
An activist scholar and a citizen of the Pawnee Nation, Dr Riding In
is the editor of Wicazo Sa Review. Much of his research focuses on
the role scientists have played in the desecration of American Indian
burials and the measure Indians have taken to curb those widespread
abuses. His scholarship also examines the effects of colonialism on
the sovereignty, landholdings, human rights, health, welfare, religious
freedom, and cultural integrity of Indian nations. He is the co-editor
of Native Historians Write Back: Decolonizing American Indian
History (2011) and is now working on a book about Pawnee survival
under colonization.
Charlotte Roberts (Department of Archaeology, Durham
University)
Professor Roberts is a bioarchaeologist at the Department of
Archaeology, Durham University, with a background in archaeology,
environmental archaeology, human bioarchaeology, and nursing.
She has studied and interpreted human remains from archaeological
sites for the past 35 years, and is specifically interested in exploring
the interaction of past people with their environments through
patterns of health and disease. She was elected a Fellow of the British
Academy in 2014, and is currently the President of BABAO (British
Association of Biological Anthropology and Osteoarchaeology).
She has published extensively, and alongside her academic career,
she regularly engages with the public via lectures and TV and radio
programmes.
Elise Smith (Centre for the History of Medicine, University of
Warwick)
Elise Smith is Assistant Professor in the History of Medicine at the
University of Warwick. She specialises on the history of medicine and
the life sciences in Britain and the British Empire since 1800, and has
written on the history of racial science, anthropometry, and military
medicine. She is currently revising her monograph, Skulls, Nation,
and Empire: The Rise and Fall of British Craniology, 1800-1939.
Joan Smith (Edinburgh College of Art, University of Edinburgh)
Joan Smith is an artist and is currently Head of Art at Edinburgh
College of Art where she teaches drawing, painting and anatomy.
She is part of the TRACES DEAD IMAGES project and a member of
the Bones Collective. Her research explores connections between
anatomy and art, such as the objects used to teach anatomy
to artists. Her exhibition with anthropologist Jeanne Cannizzo,
‘Smugglerius Unveiled’ at the Talbot Rice Gallery, focused on
the ecorche created by William Hunter and Agostino Carlini; a
forthcoming exhibition at Surgeons Hall Museum in Edinburgh is
inspired by archival material from the museum’s collection.
Anna Szöke (CARMAH, Humboldt University of Berlin)
Anna Szöke is an art historian, curator and researcher at the
Centre for Anthropological Research on Museums and Heritage
at the Humboldt University Berlin. She is part of the TRACES
project, analysing the Creative Co-productions engagements with
collections of difficult heritages, and their often troubling and violent
history. She is also a member of TRACES DEAD IMAGES project.
Prior to TRACES she worked at the Academy of Fine Arts, Vienna
on an arts-based research project funded by the Austrian Science
Fund, centred on human remains in institutional collections, in close
collaboration with the Natural History Museum, Vienna. Until 2013
she was a curator of contemporary art at the Essl Museum in Austria.
Maria Teschler-Nicola (Natural History Museum Vienna,
University of Vienna)
Maria Teschler-Nicola is a human biologist at the Department of
Anthropology at the Natural History Museum (NHM) Vienna and
teacher of Osteology at the University of Vienna, with an emphasis
on pathological skeletal alterations that help to explore the
interactions of past populations and their environment. In her role
as director of the Department at the NHM she was entrusted to
curate the osteological collection (1997-2015) and the pathologicalanatomical collection (2012-2015), as well as to establish several
temporary and the new permanent exhibits on hominid evolution.
She has not only extensively investigated human remains from
different periods and perspectives, her interest was also oriented
towards the history of the discipline in Austria, with a special focus on
the period between 1860–1945. She is a collaborator in the TRACES
DEAD IMAGES project. In 2014 she became an elected member of
the “Nationale Akademie der Wissenschaften Leopoldina”.
Paul Turnbull (Digital Humanities and History, Universities of
Tasmania and Queensland)
Paul Turnbull holds honorary appointments as Professor of
Digital Humanities and History at the Universities of Tasmania and
Queensland. His recent publications include Science, Museums and
Collecting the Indigenous Dead in Colonial Australia (Palgrave 2017),
which draws on the investigation of scientific archives in Europe,
Australia, and other former British settler colonies to explain how
the bodily remains of Indigenous Australians became the focus of
scientific curiosity about the nature and origins of human diversity
from the early years of colonisation in the late eighteenth century to
Australia achieving nationhood at the turn of the twentieth century.
Dead Images
Exhibition Opening and Conference venue
Project Team
The Dead Images Exhibition will be on view at ECA Studios, C6,
C7, C8, in the Main Building of the Edinburgh College of Art, 74
Lauriston Place, Edinburgh. The opening night discussion and
reception as well as the conference will take place in West Court
(room C13), just opposite the studio space, also in the Main Building
of the Edinburgh College of Art, 74 Lauriston Place, Edinburgh.
Tal Adler – Artist and researcher, Humboldt University of Berlin;
Linda Fibiger – Senior lecturer in Human Osteoarchaeology,
University of Edinburgh; John Harries – Senior teaching fellow in
Social Anthropology, University of Edinburgh; Joan Smith – Artist
and printmaker, Head of Art, Edinburgh College of Art; Anna Szöke
– Art historian, researcher, Humboldt University of Berlin; Maria
Teschler-Nicola – Human biologist and anthropologist, former
director of the Anthropological Department at the Vienna Natural
History Museum;
The lecture-performance of Skull X (“Schädel X”) by Konradin Kunze
will take place from 10.30 – 11.45 in the Red Lecture Theatre of
Summerhall, 1 Summerhall, Edinburgh, EH9 1PL.
assisted by:
ECA Main Building
Ola Wojtkiewicz – Art historian and museum outreach professional,
education research coordinator for DEAD IMAGES; Aglaja
Kempinski – Social Anthropologist, University of Edinburgh, and
ethnographer with DEAD IMAGES; Callum Fisher – ErasmusPlus
Intern at CARMAH and project assistant for TRACES; Harriet Merrow
– MA student, Institute for European Ethnology, Humboldt University
Berlin, student assistant at CARMAH; Hayley Whittingham – MA
Student, Edinburgh College of Art, Intern at Edinburgh College of Art
and project assistant for TRACES.
with input from:
Francesca Lanz – Department of Architecture and Urban Studies,
Politecnico di Milano; Jacopo Leveratto – Department of
Architecture and Urban Studies, Politecnico di Milano.
Summerhall
For more information about the “Dead Images” project, including
tours, talks and learning events see:
http://dead-images.info/
https://www.eca.ed.ac.uk/event/dead-images-facing-history-ethicsand-politics-european-skull-collections
http://www.traces.polimi.it/portfolio-posts/portfolio-04/
You can also follow “Dead Images” on Twitter @Dead_Images