All Hallows' Eve
By Paul F. McNamara
When one thinks of Halloween, the majority of the responses would be ghouls,
vampires, scary movies, trick (or trunk) and treat for kids, and lots of candy. However,
the celebration is deeply rooted in ancient religious themes. The term, Halloween
means All Hallows' Eve. The etymology of the word ‘hallow’ reveals that it comes from
the Proto-Germanic *hailagon , Old Saxon helagon, Middle Dutch heligen, Old Norse
helga, and from Proto-Indo-European language root *kailo- meaning "whole, uninjured,
of good omen”. As an example, the Lord’s Prayer from the Christian tradition, states
“hallowed by thy name”. Halloween or All Hallows' Eve is the eve (October 31st) of the
celebration of all those hallowed. Accordingly, Roman Catholics celebrate All (Hallowed)
Saints day on November 1st of every year. A lesser-known commemoration is All Souls’
Day, which would follow on November 2nd.
The Celts, from Ireland and nearby areas, as early as 500 BCE, first celebrated
Samhain. This is a pagan religious festival. The word Samhain is rooted in the Irish
Gaelic word samhuinn) and from Old Irish word samain, which literally means
“summer's end”. Notably, from Old Irish sam "summer" and fuin "end." The macabre
environs that are associated with Halloween, such as ghosts, the dead entering our
world, and communing with spirits, can be traced to Samhain. With the influx of
Christianity in many western cultures, one might have expected the eradication of this
scary celebration, but instead Christian societies embraced the holiday.1
1
Mullally, Erin. “SAMHAIN REVIVAL.” Archaeology, 34
Author: Paul F. McNamara
Roane State Community College
All Hallows' Eve
By Paul F. McNamara
Two opposing groups have given much attention to Halloween in modern times.
One in a positive manner and other in a negative way. These groups are the new-age
adherents and the religious right. New-age adherents have stressed the beneficial
qualities of Halloween. Specifically, how the celebration is helping people access the
realms of legend and imagination and reconcile with their fears of change and death.
The Christian evangelists, in contrast, have condemned its glorification of evil. Some
have even claimed that Halloween is where witches meet to worship the devil. They
have even advised school boards to ban Halloween celebrations because of the day’s
blatantly un-Christian implications. These people do not grasp the erudition of
Halloween.
We can dismiss the thought that the Samhain celebration is “satanic” and
certainly, that Halloween is a “satanic ritual”. Although a few pre-Christian religions
depicted a dualistic struggle between the God of Light and the God of Darkness,
Satanism is essentially a Christian creation, a travesty of Christian forms centered on
the fallen rebel angel (star), Lucifer. In fact, the standard doctrine of the early Christian
church left little room for Satan. The term sâtan is Hebrew: ָּׂשטָּׂ ןfor accuser. He made
his first appearance in the Book of Job, whereas from the academic perspective, Satan
worked for God and was on his high court. The book of Job looks at the problem of
theodicy. Satan took orders from God in the book of Job. He was not an opponent of
Gods in the Hebrew bible. Satan first appeared as an opponent in the New Testament,
and came to the forefront in the writings of St. Augustine. Satanism was in discord with
the polytheism of the ancient Celtic religion. Indeed, the belief in the satanic flourished
in the late medieval era when it was formed as part of the persecutory discourse against
Author: Paul F. McNamara
Roane State Community College
All Hallows' Eve
By Paul F. McNamara
heretics and witches. All of this happened long after the demise of the ancient Celtic
Samhain festival. Satanism, and how it understood in modern times, has no root in
Halloween.2
One might consider that in the modern era, Halloween is the “last stand” of the
goblins, witches, vampires, and ghosts. This is because the next day (Nov 1st All-Saints
Day), sainthood and holiness are recognized and commemorated. In reality, the
archetypal ‘monsters’ of Halloween are tame and benevolent. Halloween has become a
harmless gala with good fun for kids and adults alike.
In Irish mythology, the Samhain festival is considered to be the division of the
year between the lighter half (summer) and the darker half (winter). This period of time
views the division between the corporeal world and the metaphysical world as
attenuated, therefore the portal between the two worlds is vulnerable to allow spirits to
pass through. Each year, during the latter part of October, is when the natural world is
perceived as dying. The harvest is complete, plants, grass and trees have appeared to
have died but actually have gone dormant and livestock have been slaughtered for the
winter. Many animals, like bears, bats, and groundhogs to name a few, hibernate.
Combining these factors together with the disappearing sun, the ancient Celts felt that
the Samhain period was this phase of each year in which the world of the living beings
and the spiritual realm were closest. People would wear costumes and masks to
disguise themselves as harmful spirits to avoid mistreatment.3
2
3
Rogers, Nicholas. Halloween : From Pagan Ritual to Party Night. 24-26
Gilroy, John. “Samhain (Samain) - The Celtic Roots of Halloween
Author: Paul F. McNamara
Roane State Community College
All Hallows' Eve
By Paul F. McNamara
The Hill of Ward in County Meath, Ireland existed as one of the foremost spiritual
sites for the ancient Celts, and the Samhain festival. This festival was first celebrated
millennia ago. The Samhain festival took place each year from sunset on October 31 to
sunset on November 1, which marks the beginning of winter and the transition to a new
year. The ancient Celts believed that this night marked a critical spiritual transition,
when the spirits of all who had died since the previous Oiche Shamhna ("Night of
Samhain") moved on to the next life. Tradition has it that the ancient Celts assembled
on Hill of Ward on October 31 and built a sacred fire on which sacrifices were offered to
thank their pagan gods for a successful harvest. Considering that, the Irish climate is
typically cool and rainy and add to the fact that the darkness was prominent during
wintertime as the sun was near its lowest point, it is, therefore, logical to assume that
there was a huge concern among the ancient Celts regarding the lack of sunlight and
warmth. These factors likely further precipitated this Celtic myth and the need for the
Samhain Festival.4
Many have misinterpreted Samhain to be the Celtic god of death. This is one of
the most resolute errors associated with Halloween. Research from scholars have
discovered that Halloween had its origins among the ancient Celts and is based on the
Samhain Festival. However, a writer in the 18th century incorrectly specified that
Samhain is named after the famous Celtic "god of the dead."
4
Mullally, Erin. “SAMHAIN REVIVAL.” Archaeology, 35
Author: Paul F. McNamara
Roane State Community College
All Hallows' Eve
By Paul F. McNamara
There was no such deity ever recognized or celebrated. Many religious
conservatives who are opposed to Halloween heeded this ‘hearsay’ and believed such
to be valid without checking the accuracy. However, this idea is erroneous. Within the
last two decades, many secular newspapers, television and radio programs had
misconstrued this ‘hearsay’ and propagated it widely. Universally, many people now
accept this information as valid, particularly those that claim to be conservative
Protestants. 5
Halloween has evolved from the Samhain festival as the common colors are
black and orange; as black represents the end of summer and orange represents new
season of autumn. Many ancient Celtics would dress up disguised as ghosts to get
food and treats left for the wandering spirits. Regarding the tricks aspect of Halloween,
some speculate that it started back in Scotland, as the celebrants would go from door to
door on "All Souls day" saying prayers for the dead and their souls. The celebrants
would receive food in return.6
5
6
Rogers, Nicholas. Halloween : From Pagan Ritual to Party Night, 33
Oraby, Mahmoud. “Et Scares: Famous Halloween Traditions”
Author: Paul F. McNamara
Roane State Community College
All Hallows' Eve
By Paul F. McNamara
In the Celtic tradition, the significance of the Hill of Ward begins in ancient Celtic
mythology with the story of the druidess Tlachtga, the daughter of a sun god named
Mug Ruith. The legend tells us that Tlachtga was attacked and raped by the three sons
of her father’s mentor, a powerful wizard named Simon Magus. This is where Celtic
mythology crosses over to Christian Gnosticism (gnostic Ancient Greek: γνῶσις gnōsis,
knowledge. Later construed to mean ‘secret knowledge’). In this Gnostic tradition,
Simon Magus was a magician and Sorcerer. He is also mentioned in the orthodox
biblical texts. Some scholars even suggest he was the founder of one version of
Gnosticism (Note: There are many versions). Tlachtga was given the title ‘Goddess of
the Sun’ and gave birth to three sons, one from each of three fathers, at the site of the
Author: Paul F. McNamara
Roane State Community College
All Hallows' Eve
By Paul F. McNamara
Hill of Ward. According to legend, Tlachtga died there during childbirth. In her honor and
because of the Samhain fire ceremonies that took place on the hill, the Hill of Ward was
named Tlachtga. This ceremony was an attempt to proliferate light and warmth against
the growing darkness of winter.7
Until recently, much of Ireland’s archaeologically prosperous Boyne Valley had
been ignored. However, archaeological and historical research had begun in the
summer of 2014 at the Hill of Ward. Archaeologists were hoping to ascertain more
details and understand how its usage and significance evolved over the centuries. Not
discarding, of course, the customary rites and festivities that eventually led to the
modern holiday of Halloween. Archaeological research in the area have determined that
the Hill of Ward was built in three separate stages over many centuries. The first period
was during the Bronze Age (1200-800 BCE), while the last period was during the late
Iron Age (400 and 800 CE). This was near the era of Ireland’s conversion to Christianity
(400-520 CE). The physical center of the memorial was built in multiple stages and is
enigmatic. Much of the excavation work completed to date at the Hill of Ward has
concentrated on the middle segment, which is providing enticing clues into the
ceremonial and ritual activities that may have occurred for many centuries. 8
7
8
Mullally, Erin. “SAMHAIN REVIVAL.” Archaeology, 34
Mullally, Erin. “SAMHAIN REVIVAL.” Archaeology, 35
Author: Paul F. McNamara
Roane State Community College
All Hallows' Eve
By Paul F. McNamara
The pumpkin, also referred to a Jack O’ Lantern, has become an integral part of
the Halloween celebration. The name, Jack O’ Lantern, comes from an Irish folktale
about a man named Stingy Jack. The legend says that Stingy Jack invited the Devil for
an alcoholic beverage, except Stingy Jack did not want to pay for his drink. Using his
slyness, Jack convinced the Devil to change himself into a coin. Jack was supposed to
use this coin to pay for the drinks. However, Jack decided to keep the money and put
the coin next to a silver cross. This prevented the Devil from changing back to his
original self. Jack finally did free the Devil under the arrangement that the Devil would
not bother Jack for a year and should Jack die, the Devil would not take his soul. That
next year, Jack, again with his sly ability, tricked the Devil into climbing a tree to pick an
Author: Paul F. McNamara
Roane State Community College
All Hallows' Eve
By Paul F. McNamara
apple. During this time, Jack carved a cross in the tree, which trapped the Devil. The
Devil agreed not to bother Jack for ten more years if he would free him from the tree.
Jack agreed. Jack finally died. God would not permit such an unscrupulous person as
Jack into heaven. The Devil, distraught by Jack’s tricks, and keeping his promise, would
not allow Jack into hades. Jack wandered into the dark night with only a burning coal he
put into a pumpkin to light his way and has been roaming the Earth ever since. The Irish
refer to this ghastly figure as “Jack of the Lantern,” and later, simply “Jack O’ Lantern”.9
Some historical and religious scholars suggest that the Hindu Diwali festival and
Halloween have a mutual core in antiquity. The Diwali festival was first celebrated
around 500 CE (which is similar to the first Samhain celebration), when King Rama
returned to his hometown of Ayodhya after being erroneously expelled to a harsh life in
the forest for 14 years. The Diwali Festival of Lights occurs about the same time each
year as the Samhain celebration.10
9
History.com Editors. “History of the Jack O’ Lantern.” HISTORY
Gilroy, John. “Samhain (Samain) - The Celtic Roots of Halloween.”
10
Author: Paul F. McNamara
Roane State Community College
All Hallows' Eve
By Paul F. McNamara
Works Cited
Gilroy, John. “Samhain (Samain) - The Celtic Roots of Halloween.” Newgrange.Com,
2019, www.newgrange.com/samhain.htm.
History.com Editors. “History of the Jack O’ Lantern.” HISTORY, 7 June 2019,
www.history.com/topics/halloween/jack-olantern-history.
Mullally, Erin. “SAMHAIN REVIVAL.” Archaeology, vol. 69, no. 6, 2016, pp. 34–37.
Oraby, Mahmoud. “Et Scares: Famous Halloween Traditions.” EgyptToday, 2019,
www.egypttoday.com/Article/6/29043/et-Scares-Famous-Halloween-Traditions.
Rogers, Nicholas. Halloween : From Pagan Ritual to Party Night. Oxford, Oxford
University Press, 2003.
Author: Paul F. McNamara
Roane State Community College